Individualized assessment and treatment program for alcohol dependence: Results of an initial study to train coping skills

Department of Behavioral Sciences and Community Health, University of Connecticut Health Center, Farmington, CT 06030, USA.
Addiction (Impact Factor: 4.74). 09/2009; 104(11):1837-8. DOI: 10.1111/j.1360-0443.2009.02693.x
Source: PubMed


Cognitive-behavioral treatments (CBT) are among the most popular interventions offered for alcohol and other substance use disorders, but it is not clear how they achieve their effects. CBT is purported to exert its beneficial effects by altering coping skills, but data supporting coping changes as the mechanism of action are mixed. The purpose of this pilot study was to test a treatment in which coping skills were trained in a highly individualized way, allowing us to determine if such training would result in an effective treatment.
Participants were assigned randomly to a comprehensive packaged CBT program (PCBT), or to an individualized assessment and treatment program (IATP). The IATP program employed experience sampling via cellphone to assess coping skills prior to treatment, and provided therapists with a detailed understanding of patients' coping strengths and deficits.
Out-patient treatment.
A total of 110 alcohol-dependent men and women.
Participants in both conditions completed experience sampling of situations, drinking and coping efforts prior to, and following, 12 weeks of treatment. Time-line follow-back procedures were also used to record drinking at baseline and post-treatment.
IATP yielded higher proportion of days abstinent (PDA) at post-treatment (P < 0.05) than did PCBT, and equivalent heavy drinking days. IATP also elicited more momentary coping responses and less drinking in high-risk situations, as recorded by experience sampling at post-treatment. Post-treatment coping response rates were associated with decreases in drinking.
The IATP approach was more successful than PCBT at training adaptive coping responses for use in situations presenting a high risk for drinking. The highly individualized IATP approach may prove to be an effective treatment strategy for alcohol-dependent patients.

  • Source
    • "The main finding of this study is relevant to the understanding of establishment of alcohol drinking levels or patterns in social circumstances, as well as the effect that a social influence can have on changing alcohol intake. There is considerable literature examining peer influences on alcohol drinking in humans, including both social influences that increase drinking as well as those that are protective against high drinking or relapse (e.g., Andrews et al., 2002; Henry et al., 2009; Homish and Leonard, 2008; Litt et al., 2009), but the literature in animal models is relatively sparse. However, there are several studies showing effects of a social influence, or social learning, on alcohol intake levels. "
    [Show abstract] [Hide abstract]
    ABSTRACT: Peer interactions can have important effects on alcohol-drinking levels, in some cases increasing use, and in other cases preventing it. In a previous study, we have established the prairie vole as a model animal for the effects of social relationships on alcohol intake and have observed a correlation of alcohol intake between individual voles housed together as pairs. Here, we investigated this correlated drinking behavior, hypothesizing that 1 animal alters its alcohol intake to match the drinking of its partner. Adult prairie voles were tested for baseline drinking levels with continuous access to 10% alcohol and water for 4 days. In Experiment 1, high alcohol drinkers (>9 g/kg/d) were paired with low alcohol drinkers (<5 g/kg/d) of the same sex on either side of a mesh divider for 4 days with continuous access to the same 2-bottle choice test. In Experiment 2, high drinkers were paired with high drinkers and low drinkers paired with low drinkers. In both experiments, animals were again separated following pairing, and drinking was retested in isolation. In Experiment 3, alcohol-naïve animals were tested for saccharin consumption (0.05%) first in isolation and then in high saccharin drinkers paired with low saccharin drinkers, and then in another isolation period. In Experiment 1, high drinkers paired with low drinkers significantly decreased their alcohol intake and preference from baseline drinking in isolation, and drinking levels remained significantly lower during isolation following pairing. Interestingly, there was variability between pairs in whether the high drinker decreased or the low drinker increased intake. In Experiment 2, high drinkers paired with high drinkers did not significantly change their intake level or preference, nor did low drinkers paired with low drinkers, and no changes occurred during the subsequent isolation. In Experiment 3, there was no change in saccharin intake or preference when high drinkers were paired with high drinkers or low paired with low, or in the subsequent isolation. Alcohol drinking of prairie voles can be altered under social conditions, such that 1 animal changes its alcohol intake to more closely match the intake of the other animal, helping to explain previous findings of correlated alcohol drinking. The effect does not extend to saccharin, a naturally rewarding sweet substance. This behavior can be used to model the peer pressure that can often affect alcohol intake in humans.
    Full-text · Article · May 2011 · Alcoholism Clinical and Experimental Research
  • [Show abstract] [Hide abstract]
    ABSTRACT: Establishing subgroups in clinical practice is important for treatment planning. The aim of the study was to cluster the study group subjects according to personality traits and psychological health variables and to establish possible differences in treatment outcome in terms of: (i) drinking outcomes (gram and number of drinking days); (ii) perceived physiological health; and (iii) use of treatment resources (length of time in treatment and number of visits) among 134 treatment-seeking women with alcohol problems in a clinical context, between the two clusters obtained. Data were collected from 134 consecutive women at a Swedish clinic specialised in treating women with alcohol problems. A hierarchical cluster analysis was performed on the basis of self-rated personality scale scores and psychological health variables. Two clusters were identified: one in which the women displayed personality and psychological health scores indicating problems (Cluster 1); and another where the women showed personality and psychological health scores within the norm range (Cluster 2). Alcohol consumption rates at the start of treatment were the same in both clusters. The consumption rates were also the same at the end of treatment for the cluster, showing a significant decrease in alcohol consumption in each. The Cluster 1 women, however, had a significantly higher number of visits at the clinic, and rated the consequences of their alcohol drinking as being significantly worse than Cluster 2 women. The importance of individual differences according to personality traits for treatment planning is discussed in terms of the need for variation in treatment time and methods.
    No preview · Article · Aug 2010 · Drug and Alcohol Review
  • [Show abstract] [Hide abstract]
    ABSTRACT: Samenvatting Dit artikel vormt een hoofdstuk uit het in november 2011 te verschijnen boek Protocollaire behandelingen voor volwassenen met psychische klachten, onder redactie van Ger Keijsers, Agnes van Minnen en Kees Hoogduin. Alcoholproblematiek vormt, samen met angststoornissen en depressie, de top-3 van meest voorkomende psychische stoornissen. Motiverende gespreksvoering en cognitieve gedragstherapie worden zowel nationaal als internationaal als eerstekeuzebehandeling voorgeschreven door richtlijnen voor de behandeling van stoornissen in het gebruik van alcohol. De hier gepresenteerde protocollaire behandeling beschrijft de toepassing van deze methodieken. Het protocol is zowel te gebruiken bij patiënten die zich met een alcoholprobleem in de verslavingszorg melden, als bij patiënten die zich in de GGZ aanmelden met een andere klacht of stoornis in combinatie met overmatig alcoholgebruik. Conform de stepped care-principes bestaat de behandeling uit een kortdurende motiverende interventie, die, indien geïndiceerd, gevolgd kan worden door een cognitieve gedragstherapie. Valkuilen en tips worden gegeven voor de toepassing van het behandelprotocol in de dagelijkse praktijk. Abstract This article displays a chapter of the book Protocollaire behandelingen voor volwassenen met psychische klachten [Protocolized treatments for adults with psychological problems], edited by Ger Keijsers, Agnes van Minnen en Kees Hoogduin (available november 2011). Alcohol use disorders (AUDs) are among the most prevalent psychiatric disorders. National and international guidelines prescribe Motivational Interviewing and Cognitive Behavioral Therapy as treatments of first choice in AUDs. In this article a treatment manual is presented which describes how to conduct these interventions. The manual-based treatment can be used in alcoholic patients admitted in substance use treatment centres, as well as in alcohol abusing psychiatric patients. According to the stepped care principles, the treatment consists of a brief motivational intervention which can be extented, if indicated, with a cognitive behavioral therapy. Pitfalls and tips are described for using the treatment manual in daily practice.
    No preview · Article · Jan 2011 · Dth
Show more