Variability of pesticide residues among food items is very important for consumer food safety evaluation and risk assessment. To estimate the residue variability of selected pesticides in individual food items of medium (eggplant) and large size vegetable commodities (cabbage, cauliflower and melon) an effective multi-residue method is required. Therefore, four multi-residue methods have been developed and validated by employing the quick, easy, cheap, effective, rugged, and safe (QuEChERS) extraction technique coupled with liquid chromatography-triple quadrupole mass spectrometry (LC-MS/MS) for the determination of thirteen pesticides in/on eggplant, ten pesticides in melon, and seven pesticides in/on cabbage and cauliflower, respectively. All the methods are simple, efficient, easy, accurate, and rapid. The average recoveries for all of the selected pesticides ranged from 71.8 to 112% with RSDr ≤ 16.2% for eggplant; 82 to 106% with RSDr ≤ 6% for melon; 80 to 110% with RSDr ≤ 16% for cabbage; 74-110% with RSDr ≤ 8% for cauliflower when processing samples of four fortification levels of 0.01, 0.05, 0.10 and 0.20 mg/Kg with all of the selected matrices except for eggplant for which the respective levels were 0.01, 0.05, 0.10 and 0.50 mg/Kg. The LOD values ranged from 0.001 to 0.003 mg/Kg for all the analytes. The LOQ was set at 0.01 mg/kg for all the analytes that was lower than the respective EU-MRLs. The correlation coefficients (R2) were ≥0.997 for all of the selected pesticides when matrix matched calibration standards were used. Matrix effects of eggplant, melon, cabbage and cauliflower for all the selected pesticides were estimated in this study. The effect of the matrix was prominent in eggplant for thiamethoxam, cypermethrin and deltamethrin and it was -69%, +57% and +93%, respectively, in melon for thiamethoxam and deltamethrin and it was -53% and +135%, respectively, in cabbage for cypermethrin and deltamethrin and it was +49% and +97%, respectively, and in cauliflower for cypermethrin and deltamethrin and it was +90% and +145%, respectively.
Variability is defined as the variation in concentrations of pesticide residues among individual units of any commodity. Variability factor is defined as the ratio between the 97.5th percentile of the residue levels and the mean of residue level of the same lot of a certain commodity. Variability factors are used in the acute dietary intake assessment of pesticides to account for the unit-to-unit residue variability in the composite samples.
All the analytical methods were applied successfully for pesticide residue analysis of eggplant, melon, cabbage and cauliflower fruits collected from different market places in Thessaloniki, Greece for the purpose of estimating the respective residue variability factors of pesticide residues existing among items of these commodities. A total of 142 samples of eggplant were analyzed. Among the analyzed samples, 67 (47% of the total no. of samples) had pesticide residues, of which 9 had multiple pesticides residues and 58 had single pesticide residues. Only one sample was found contaminated with dimethoate at a level above the EU-MRLs (European Commission, 2005). In the case of melon, a total of 122 samples were analyzed. Among the analyzed samples, 32 (26% of the total no. of samples) had pesticide residues, of which 2 had multiple pesticide residues and 30 had single pesticide residues. None of the samples were found contaminated with the detected pesticide residues at levels above the EU-MRLs (European Commission, 2005 & European Food Safety Authority, 2014).
A total of 132 fresh cabbage samples were analyzed. Among the analyzed samples, 41 (31% of the total no. of samples) had pesticide residues, of which 2 had multiple pesticide residues and 39 had single pesticide residues. Only one sample was found contaminated with deltamethrin at a level above the EU-MRLs (European Commission, 2005). In the case of cauliflower, a total of 120 samples were analyzed. Among the analyzed samples, 48 (40% of the total no. of samples) had pesticide residues. None of the samples were found contaminated with multiple pesticides residues. Only one sample was found contaminated with chlorpyrifos at a level above the EU-MRLs (European Commission, 2005).
Variability of pesticide residues originating from the analyisis of eggplant and cauliflower individual fruit units collected from respective supervised field trials were also estimated in this study. In these supervised field trials, cypermethrin and deltamethrin in mixture at the recommended application rates were applied as the last pre-harvest application and samples were collected at the specified PHI (pre-harvest interval). The estimated variability factors for cypermethrin and deltamethrin residues were 2.38 and 2.32, respectively for the samples of cauliflower, while it was 2.54 and 2.51, respectively for the samples of eggplant. Comparison between the residue levels estimated from the individual units and the composite samples of eggplant and cauliflower were investigated and found that the mean residue levels of both pesticides were higher in the composite samples than the mean of residue levels estimated from the individual samples.
In this study, the variation of cypermethrin and deltamethrin residue levels present in the exposed and non exposed (fruits covered with leaves) cauliflower units was also investigated and found that exposed cauliflower units bare higher concentrations of pesticide residues than those present in the cauliflower units covered with leaves (non-exposed). Furthermore, the variation of pesticide residue concentrations present in the upper and lower sections of individual cauliflower units was also investigated and it was found that most of the cypermethrin and deltamethrin residues were present in the upper portion of the cauliflowers units.
Within plants of eggplant unit to unit residue variation was also studied. The results revealed that exposed units of eggplant fruits (fruits collected from the outer periphery of the plant) had higher residues for both pesticides compared to the non exposed units of eggplant (fruits collected from the inner section of the plant).
The variability factors from the marketed samples of eggplant, melon, cabbage and cauliflower, respectively, were also estimated in this study. A total of 517 samples of 4 vegetables were collected from different market places of Thessaloniki in Greece. For eggplant, the estimated variability factors ranged from 1.00 to 7.09 with the detected pesticides; for melon, it was from 1.00 to 4.85; for cabbage, it was from 1.00 to 6.75, and for cauliflower, it was from 2.40 to7.12 with the detected pesticides. The average VFs for eggplant, melon, cabbage, and cauliflower were 3.89, 2.89, 5.00, and 5.11, respectively. Considering the commodity groups, the average VF for medium-sized crops was 3.89 while it was 4.33 for the large-sized crops. However, the average VF for all commodity crops was 4.11. Generally, the residue variability factors estimated from the marketed samples were higher than those found for the samples collected from the field trials. On the basis of the experimental data presented here a default VF value of 3 for field trials is adequately appropriate to be used in acute dietary intake assessment but for the marketed samples, a VF value should be reconsidered when more data are available, especially data concerning large-sized crops.