ArticlePDF Available

Dancing on the Canon: Embodiments of Value in Popular Dance by Sherril Dodds (review)

Authors:

Abstract

If there ever was a canon of dance scholarship to be unseated by transgressive dancing in "Doc Marten boots, stiletto heels, old skool trainers and all other kinds of vernacular footwear" (200), the dirty deed was a fait accompli a decade before the release of Dancing on the Canon. Over the past fifteen years, popular dance scholarship has exploded, outpacing scholarship on Western art dance to such a degree that it seems anachronistic to suggest that popular dance is still undervalued in the academy. Granted, dance departments in the United States and Britain still value teaching technique and performance of art dance over teaching popular dance practice (you are much more likely to find university technique classes in ballet or contemporary dance than in Burlesque or headbanging). However, popular dance as a scholarly subject of research has not only become acceptable, it is downright trendy. The political intervention turned academic discipline of cultural studies, whose founding fathers examined how power structures were maintained and disrupted through popular culture, has influenced dance scholarship since the early 1990s to the degree that, as Gay Morris has suggested (2009), the field has been renamed "dance studies." Given the relative cornucopia of popular dance scholarship compared to that of the 1990s, I had difficulty accepting the basic premise of Sherril Dodds's project—to elevate the value of popular dance within dance scholarship. Setting aside her somewhat outdated portrayal of the field, however, Dodds does contribute to continued expansion and depth in popular dance research through rich and nuanced analysis of her own ethnographic data presented later in the monograph. The book is divided into two sections. In the first, "Understanding Value," Dodds undertakes a systematic exploration of the major concepts that undergird her project—dance scholarship's canon, cultural studies, popular dance, and value—examining how each has been defined and delineated by existing scholarship. Her literature review is impressive in size and will no doubt serve as a key reference for many readers. The seemingly encyclopedic catalog does, at times, come up short. For example, Dodds rarely cites any scholarship published more recently than 2000, especially in her first two chapters when she makes a case for the marginalization of popular dance scholarship in both dance studies and cultural studies. Thus, although her characterization of these fields accurately represents their situation in the 1990s, she misses an opportunity to celebrate the progress that has been achieved over the past decade in this area, due in part to the work of scholars like Dodds, herself. Not only has Dodds been publishing scholarship on popular dance since 1997, but she has been the driving force behind the formation of an Society of Dance History Scholars (SDHS) working group on popular dance and the annual PoP Moves symposium on popular dance research. The fruits of these labors have been bountiful, and it strikes me as ironic that Dodds is still trying to wage a war that she has already helped to win. One of Dodds's major theoretical contributions is to examine a contested definition of "popular dance" and its relationship to concepts such as social dance, folk dance, vernacular dance, mass culture, and culture industry. After brief summaries of how other scholars have conceived of the popular in relation to these terms, Dodds proposes a working definition of popular dance that includes so many qualifications and contingencies that it extends several paragraphs. For example, she writes: In relation to context, popular dance occupies a range of sites that include stage, screen or "street" locations (by which I mean common public spaces such as municipal halls, clubs, ballrooms, village greens, high streets and leisure centres), and can be performed by amateurs or professionals, depending on the "performance context." Although I would argue that it is generally positioned as distinct from "art culture," it can occupy "art spaces" such as galleries, museums, and subsidized performance venues. As with other aspects of her definition, it seems accurate, if somewhat cumbersome. Although I was persuaded that her working definition was plausible, I was never convinced that the project of trying to define popular dance served her greater goal of destabilizing a perceived hierarchy within dance and dance...
A preview of the PDF is not available
ResearchGate has not been able to resolve any citations for this publication.
Book
Salsa and merengue are now so popular that they are household words for Americans of all ethnic backgrounds. Recent media attention is helping other Caribbean music styles like bachata to attain a similar status. Yet popular Mexican American dances remain unknown and invisible to most non-Latinos. Quebradita, meaning “little break,” is a modern Mexican American dance style that became hugely popular in Los Angeles and across the southwestern United States during the early to mid 1990s. Over the decade of its popularity, this dance craze offered insights into the social and cultural experience of Mexican American youth. Accompanied by banda, an energetic brass band music style, quebradita is recognizable by its western clothing, hat tricks, and daring flips. The dance’s combination of Mexican, Anglo, and African American influences represented a new sensibility that appealed to thousands of young people. Hutchinson argues that, though short-lived, the dance filled political and sociocultural functions, emerging as it did in response to the anti-immigrant and English-only legislation that was then being enacted in California. Her fieldwork and interviews yield rich personal testimony as to the inner workings of the quebradita’s aesthetic development and social significance. The emergence of pasito duranguense, a related yet distinct style originating in Chicago, marks the evolution of the Mexican American youth dance scene. Like the quebradita before it, pasito duranguense has picked up the task of demonstrating the relevance of regional Mexican music and dance within the U.S. context.
Chapter
Prompted by the late twentieth-century, and still growing, interest in World Dance evidenced by the emergence of this rubric in US college circles (including courses in Dance departments and newly developed academic jobs), bookings in performing venues (including World Dance festivals and shows), the support offered through funding agencies invested in arts and cultures, and the attention devoted by dance critics and scholars, as by dancers and dance lovers, I propose to consider some questions related to the discursive formation of this field. These questions are entangled with ethico-political concerns. What does ‘world dance’ actually represent at this historical conjuncture? What is the effect of imposing the ‘world,’ as a qualifying categorization, on ‘dance,’ as a set of aestheticized movement practices, in the era of so-called globalization? How does this totalizing framing (the ‘world’) work to supplement and expand the dance field as it fixes differentiations within it? How are dances from ‘out there’ selected to be included or excluded from ‘world dance’? What kinds of institutional investments, technical knowledges, economic interests, aesthetic and ethical assumptions, political arrangements, pleasures and desires participate in the process of worlding Dance?
Article
Caribbean dance is a broad category that can include everything from nightclubs to sacred ritual. Making Caribbean Dance connects the dance of the islands with their rich multicultural histories and complex identities. Delving deep into the many forms of ritual, social, carnival, staged, experimental, and performance dance, the book explores some of the most mysterious and beloved, as well as rare and little-known, dance traditions of the region. From the evolution of Indian dance in Trinidad to the barely known rituals of los misterios in the Dominican Republic, this volume looks closely at the vibrant and varied movement vocabulary of the islands. With distinctive and highly illuminating chapters on such topics as experimental dance makers in Puerto Rico, the government's use of dance in shaping national identity in Barbados, the role of calypso and soca in linking Anglophone islands, and the invented dances of dance-hall kings and queens of Jamaica, this volume is an evocative and enlightening exploration of some of the world's most dynamic dance cultures.
Article
Thesis (Ph. D.)--University of California, Riverside, 2000. Includes bibliographical references (leaves 419-438).
Dancing Across Borders: Danzas y Bailes Mexicanos
  • Nájera-Ramírez
  • Norma E Olga
  • Brenda M Cantú
  • Romero
Nájera-Ramírez, Olga, Norma E. Cantú, and Brenda M. Romero, eds. 2009. Dancing Across Borders: Danzas y Bailes Mexicanos. Urbana, IL: University of Illinois Press.
Rigidigidim de Bamba de: A Calypso Journey from Start to
  • Cynthia Oliver
Oliver, Cynthia. 2010. " Rigidigidim de Bamba de: A Calypso Journey from Start to... " In Making Caribbean Dance: Continuity and Creativity in Island Cultures, edited by Susanna Sloat, 3–10. Gainesville, FL: University Press of Florida.
Belly Dance: Orientalism, Transnationalism, and Harem Fantasy
  • Anthony Shay
Shay, Anthony, and Barbara Sellers-Young, eds. 2005. Belly Dance: Orientalism, Transnationalism, and Harem Fantasy. Costa Mesa, CA: Mazda Publishers.
In Making Caribbean Dance: Continuity and Creativity in Island Cultures
  • Cynthia Oliver
Oliver, Cynthia. 2010. "Rigidigidim de Bamba de: A Calypso Journey from Start to..." In Making Caribbean Dance: Continuity and Creativity in Island Cultures, edited by Susanna Sloat, 3-10. Gainesville, FL: University Press of Florida.
320 pp., 11 b + w figures, 12 musical examples, references
  • Charles M Stravinsky's Ballets By
  • Joseph
Stravinsky's Ballets by Charles M. Joseph. 2011. New Haven, CT: Yale University Press. 320 pp., 11 b + w figures, 12 musical examples, references, index. $40.00 cloth. doi:10.1017/S014976771200040X