ArticlePDF Available

Nocturnal Position in the Panamanian Golden Frog, Atelopus zeteki (Anura, Bufonidae), with Notes on Fluorescent Pigment Tracking

Authors:
  • Independent Researcher

Abstract and Figures

The endangered Panamanian golden frog, Atelopus zeteki, is a stream dweller of middle elevation rain forests of the Panamanian isthmus. In order to better understand this species for conservation, we set out to determine the nocturnal whereabouts of this diurnally activeanimal. It was expected that adult males and juveniles might occupy different nocturnal microhabitats based on differences in size, coloration and patterning. Findings presented here demonstrate that adult males climb significantly higher than juveniles at night and that movement distances to final resting positions also significantlydiffered. This change in diurnal and nocturnal position in adult males may be related to predator vigilance and avoidance. Lastly, this study demonstrated that individual rain forest amphibians can be successfully tracked over short to moderate distances in humid to wet environments using fluorescent pigments.
Content may be subject to copyright.
Phyllomedusa
- 6(1), June 2007
37
Nocturnal position in the Panamanian Golden Frog,
Atelopus zeteki (Anura, Bufonidae), with notes on
fluorescent pigment tracking
Erik D. Lindquist1,2 , Scott A. Sapoznick2,3, Edgardo J. Griffith Rodriguez4, Peter B.
Johantgen5, and Joni M. Criswell6
1Department of Biological Sciences, Messiah College, One College Avenue, Grantham, Pennsylvania 17027, USA.
E-mail: quist@messiah.edu (present address).
2Department of Natural Sciences and Mathematics, Lee University, Cleveland, Tennessee 37311, USA.
3Division of Biological Sciences, University of Missouri, Columbia, Missouri 65211, USA. E-mail: sashw6@mizzou.edu.
4Departamento de Zoología, Universidad de Panamá, Ciudad de Panamá, Panamá. E-mail: virolasboy01@yahoo.com.
5Shores Department, Columbus Zoo and Aquarium, 9990 Riverside Drive, P.O. Box 400, Powell, OH 43065, USA.
E-mail: pete.johantgen@columbuszoo.org.
6Department of Evolution, Ecology and Organismal Biology, The Ohio State University, Columbus, Ohio 43210, USA.
E-mail: criswell.13@osu.edu.
Received 4 October 2006.
Accepted 13 February 2007.
Distributed June 2007.
Phyllomedusa 6(1):37-44, 2007
© 2007 Departamento de Ciências Biológicas - ESALQ - USP
ISSN 1519-1397
Abstract
Nocturnal position in the Panamanian Golden Frog, Atelopus zeteki (Anura,
Bufonidae), with notes on fluorescent pigment tracking. The endangered
Panamanian golden frog, Atelopus zeteki, is a stream dweller of middle elevation rain
forests of the Panamanian isthmus. In order to better understand this species for
conservation, we set out to determine the nocturnal whereabouts of this diurnally active
animal. It was expected that adult males and juveniles might occupy different nocturnal
microhabitats based on differences in size, coloration and patterning. Findings
presented here demonstrate that adult males climb significantly higher than juveniles
at night and that movement distances to final resting positions also significantly
differed. This change in diurnal and nocturnal position in adult males may be related
to predator vigilance and avoidance. Lastly, this study demonstrated that individual
rain forest amphibians can be successfully tracked over short to moderate distances
in humid to wet environments using fluorescent pigments.
Keywords: Anura, Bufonidae, Atelopus zeteki, aposematic coloration, behavioral
ecology, climbing, fluorescent pigment.
Phyllomedusa
- 6(1), June 2007
38
Resumen
Posición nocturna en la rana dorada de Panamá, Atelopus zeteki (Anura,
Bufonidae), con notas respecto al rastreo con el uso de pigmentos fluorescentes.
La rana dorada de Panamá, Atelopus zeteki, una especie en peligro de extinción, habita
en los ríos de los bosques lluviosos de mediana elevación del istmo panameño. Con
el propósito de conocer mejor ésta especie para su conservación, decidimos determinar
los sitios de descanso nocturno de estos animales, los cuales se caracterizan por ser
activos durante el día. Suponíamos que los machos adultos y los juveniles podrían
ocupar micro hábitat distintos durante la noche, basándose en las diferencias en
tamaños y patrones de coloración. Los resultados presentados aquí demuestran que,
al caer la noche los machos adultos trepan significativamente más alto que los juveniles
y que la distancia de estos movimientos desde el punto inicial hasta la posición final
de descanso es también significativamente diferente. Estos cambios de posición durante
el día y la noche de los machos adultos podrían estar relacionados con una conducta
antipredatoria. Finalmente este estudio demuestra que con el uso de pigmentos
fluorescentes es posible rastrear anfibios en los bosques lluviosos con habitates
húmedos a mojados a través de distancias cortas a moderadas de manera exitosa.
Palabras clave: Anura, Bufonidae, Atelopus zeteki, coloración aposemática,
comportamiento de subir, ecología del comportamiento, pigmento fluorescente.
Introduction
The Panamanian golden frog, Atelopus zeteki
Dunn (1933), is a bufonid that inhabits mountain
streams of the Cordillera Central in rain and
cloud forests in western-central Panama (Savage
1972, Cocroft et al. 1990, Lindquist and
Hetherington 1998a). Although historically
abundant, most golden frog populations have
become extirpated or currently are in decline
due to excessive collection and habitat
destruction (pers. obs.). In response to these
pressures in 1975, this species was listed under
endangerment Appendix I under the CITES
(CITES 2004). In the past ten years, the fungal
pathogen Batrachochytrium dendrobatidis has
caused the extinction of many Atelopus species
(Lips et al. 2005, 2006, Johnson 2006, Pounds
et al. 2006). Within three months of this
manuscript’s submission, each of our study
populations had been effectively driven to
extirpation (Lips et al. 2006, pers. obs. EDL,
EJGR). Life history and ecological data is
largely limited to descriptive work on this
species (Savage 1972, Miller 1987, Lindquist
and Hetherington 1998a). Acoustic and visual
communicative behaviors have been reported by
Lindquist and Hetherington (1996, 1998b), but
knowledge of territoriality, ritualized agonistic
displays, and microhabitat use remain
incomplete. Moreover, most data have been
gathered on males, as streamside sex ratios
strongly favor males during the majority of the
year. Diurnally, adult males have been observed
on the ground alongside or upon rocks and logs
in or near streams. Typical diurnal activity of
males includes foraging, calling, semaphoring,
and sporadic agonistic encounters (Lindquist &
Hetherington 1996, 1998b, pers. obs,). Casual
observations have indicated that adult male and,
on occasion, female golden frogs climb and
perch on vegetation near the stream banks at
night (Miller 1987, pers. obs.). The diurnal
whereabouts of both females and juveniles have
Lindquist et al.
Phyllomedusa
- 6(1), June 2007
39
been difficult to establish beyond occasional
stream and trail sightings during reproductive
migrations and metamorphic emergence
respectively (pers. obs.). It has been reported in
this and other Central American Atelopus
species that females and juveniles
predominantly seek cover under forest canopy
and/or in rock crevices along stream banks
(Crump 1986, G. Angehr pers. com.), although
no studies have been able to confirm this. Yet
the authors regularly have seen cryptic young in
the daytime and nighttime upon moss-covered
rocks bordering streams.
The study described here set out to establish
and quantify the nocturnal whereabouts of adult
males and juveniles, as compared to their
diurnal locations, and to determine if there was a
difference between age cohorts with respect to
perching position. Movements of adult females
are not reported in this study due to their
scarcity along the stream study sites (only three
were encountered during the study period).
The study discussed here employed pigment
tracking on a rain forest frog species. We set out
to test whether adult males climb to higher
nocturnal roosting sites and cover greater
distances to do so than do juveniles as witnessed
by casual observation. Establishing whether or
not these differences actually exist could offer
insights on potential selection pressures and/or
other aspects of the species’ biology. We
expected no difference in cohort movement
distance between population sites. Lastly, the
study set out to determine whether any
difference in final nocturnal perching positions
exists with respect to the stream edge.
Materials and Methods
During study trips taken in March 2001,
January 2002, July 2002 and January 2003, we
visited golden frog populations in the Parque
Nacional General Omar Torríjos – El Copé,
Coclé Province, Panamá (PNGOT, hereafter)
and a tributary to the Río Chame near Sorá,
Panamá Province, Panamá (Chame, hereafter).
The populations under investigation have been
identified as two unique evolutionary significant
units (ESU) and therefore the authors used
statistical treatments that included both pooled
and unpooled site data to clarify differences and
similarities (Zippel et al. 2007). Individuals
were assigned as juvenile (<28.2 mm) or adult
(>36.2 mm) by Snout-Vent Length (SVL). The
absence of this size class along streams is
corroborated by data gathered in a two year
study on the species (Lindquist et al. in prep.;
Griffith pers. obs.). Over the course of the study
period, 9 adult males (SVL 0 = 43.2 mm; range
= 39.5-46.7 mm) and 28 juveniles (SVL 0 =
16.3 mm; range = 9.9-26.8 mm) from PNGOT
and 13 adult males (SVL 0 = 41.8 mm; range =
36.2-44.8 mm) and 10 juveniles (SVL 0 = 22.7
mm; range = 15.2-28.2 mm) from Chame were
tracked.
Thermoplastic fluorescent pigments (JST-
300 series) were purchased from the Radiant
Color Company (Richmond, CA, USA) and
placed in 250 ml plastic containers. These
pigments range in particle size from 2 to 4 ìm
and are capable of indefinite storage. Five colors
were used in this study (JS-CH3020, JS-
GR3011, JS-OY3022, JS-OR3034, and JS-PK
3017). Pigment containers were kept in
individual Ziploc® freezer bags to reduce cross
contamination in the field. Dual-tube fluorescent
Coleman® lanterns were used for pigment
illumination. Lanterns were modified by
outfitting them with black fluorescent light tubes
(long wavelength UV BLB; 365 nm = dominant
ë) and inserting three mirrored glass panels
inside the bulb case to allow unidirectional light
projection and to enhance light intensity.
Individual animals were captured by hand
between 13:00 and 17:00 h. Subjects had
pigment applied within 90 min of capture and
were released immediately afterward. Pigment
application consisted of grasping an individual
dorsolaterally while placing much of the venter
into the fluorescent powder held in a plastic
container. Pigment contact included ventral
palmar, plantar, and abdominal surfaces. Once
Nocturnal position in the Panamanian Golden Frog, Atelopus zeteki (Anura, Bufonidae)
Phyllomedusa
- 6(1), June 2007
40
sufficiently applied, the animal was released
alongside the stream and the initial release area
was marked with fluorescent vinyl flagging to
indicate where to return at night for tracking. To
prevent cross contamination of trails, frogs were
powdered away from the site of release, and
placed at the location of capture. Investigators
returned to stream sites after dark (ca. 19:00 h)
to track pigmented individuals.
Once returning to each release site, the
pigment trail was then followed under black
light until the tracked subject was found.
Pigment residues left behind from contact with
substrate were remarkably robust. Once the
subject was found, nylon twine was overlaid
along the pigment trail (straight line distance
between tracks) and measured to obtain a total
distance tracked (TDT) in m. Fluorescent
colored twine was used to permit better visibility
under black light illumination of pigment tracks.
Vertical perch positions (Y) of individuals were
noted by measuring the perpendicular distance
from the final nocturnal perching location to the
substrate immediately below. If an individual
(n=3, all juveniles) was tracked to a burrow, a
vertical distance of zero was entered (see Figure
1). Likewise, horizontal perch positions (X) of
individuals were noted by measuring the
distance from the final nocturnal location to the
nearest stream edge. If an individual was found
at a location at or above the stream, a horizontal
distance of zero was entered. Afterward residual
pigment was rinsed from recovered frogs. Each
individual was tracked once to avoid pseudo-
replication error and to determine an estimate of
TDT, Y, and X for the two age classes identified
in this study. Statistical analyses and calcula-
tions in this study used the VassarStats Web Site
for Statistical Computation (Lowry, 2004).
Results
Vertical perch position
Findings from our study demonstrated that
adults and juveniles differentially utilize
nocturnal microhabitats with respect to vertical
distance from the substrate. Vertical distance
from substrate (Y) was significantly greater in
adult males (0 = 0.96 m; sd = 0.68) than in
juveniles (0 = 0.14 m; sd = 0.23) (P = <0.0001,
z = 4.85, nadult = 22, njuvenile = 38; Mann-Whitney
U test, one-tailed; data from pooled sites).
Within each population, detected differences in
Y were highly significant at PNGOT (P =
0.0002, z = 3.54, nadult = 9, njuvenile = 28; Mann-
Whitney U test, one-tailed) and at Chame (P =
0.0110, z = 2.29, nadult = 13, njuvenile = 10; Mann-
Whitney U test, one-tailed). A positive
correlation between SVL and Y for combined
sites is depicted in the scatter plot given in
Figure 1. Differences in Y were not significant
between adult males from both population sites
(0Chame = 0.86 m; sdChame = 0.57; 0PNGOT = 1.094
m; sdPNGOT = 0.84) (P = 0.3192, z = 0.47, nChame =
13, nPNGOT = 9; Mann-Whitney U test, one-
tailed). However, there appeared to be a
significant difference in Y between juveniles
from different populations (0Chame = 0.33 m;
sdChame = 0.35; 0PNGOT = 0.08 m; sdPNGOT = 0.13)
(P = 0.0294, z = 1.89, nChame = 28, nPNGOT = 10;
Mann-Whitney U test, one-tailed).
Horizontal perch position
Study results indicated that adults and
juveniles did not differentially utilize nocturnal
microhabitats with respect to X. Both juvenile
and adult X positions were variable (Xmin-juvenile =
0.35 m, Xmax-juvenile = 4.6 m, 0juvenile = 1.79 m, sd
juvenile = 1.12 m; Xmin-adult = 0 m, Xmax-adult = 6.35 m,
0adult = 1.25 m, sd adult = 1.10 m; data from pooled
sites). An analysis of variance of X showed no
difference between juveniles and adults exists (P
= <0.0001, F = -2.2596, nadult = 22, njuvenile = 38;
ANOVA; data from pooled sites).
Total distance tracked
This study determined that subjects were
capable of being followed to a maximum TDT of
16.65 m with fluorescent pigments in streamside
Lindquist et al.
Phyllomedusa
- 6(1), June 2007
41
Figure 1 - XY scatter plot showing correlation between snout-vent length (SVL) and vertical distance from substrate
(Y). Individuals represented by markers: open (General Omar Torrijos National Park) and solid (Chame River);
circle (individual above ground) and square (below ground).
Figure 2 - XY scatter plot showing correlation between snout-vent length (SVL) and total distance tracked (TDT).
Individuals represented by circular markers: open (General Omar Torrijos National Park) and solid (Chame
River).
Nocturnal position in the Panamanian Golden Frog, Atelopus zeteki (Anura, Bufonidae)
Phyllomedusa
- 6(1), June 2007
42
tropical rain forest habitat. TDT was
significantly longer in adult males (0 = 7.06 m;
sd = 3.96) than in juveniles (0 = 2.22 m; sd =
1.09) (P = <0.0001, z = 5.13, nadult = 22, njuvenile =
38; Mann-Whitney U test, one-tailed; data for
pooled sites). Within each population, detected
differences in TDT were significant at PNGOT
(0juvenile = 2.09 m, sd juvenile = 0.92 m; 0adult = 5.43
m, sd adult = 1.82 m) (P = 0.0001, z = 3.88, nadult =
9, njuvenile = 28; Mann-Whitney U test, one-tailed)
and at Chame (0juvenile = 2.58 m, sd juvenile = 1.46
m; 0adult = 8.18 m, sdadult = 4.68 m) (P = 0.002, z
= 2.88, nadult = 13, njuvenile = 10; Mann-Whitney U
test, one-tailed). A positive correlation between
SVL and TDT for combined sites is depicted in
the scatter plot given in Figure 2. There was also
a significant difference in TDT between the two
populations (0Chame = 5.74 m; sdChame = 4.57 m;
0PNGOT = 2.90 m; sdPNGOT = 1.86) (P = <0.0084, z
= 2.39, nChame = 23, nPNGOT = 37; Mann-Whitney
U test, one-tailed). This likely was due to having
a juvenile constituency of 75.65% at the
PNGOT sample compared to 38.46% of Chame.
Lastly, there exists a significant correlation
between Y and TDT for pooled data (P = <
0.0001, t = -8.81, npooled; paired t-Test for
Correlated Samples, one tailed).
Pathways to nocturnal positions
In this study we found that movement
distance from the release site to the nocturnal
perch positions in adult males varied
dramatically, but generally involved finding the
base of a woody plant (e.g. shrub or liana) and
climbing to a leaf, leaf axil, or branch that was
away from the plant’s main trunk. Occasionally
herbaceous vines were used. Large ferns were
also used as perch sites for adults, with the tips
of fronds being primarily used. Rarely were
adults found at the base of branches or leaves.
Juveniles generally took their nocturnal position
in rock crevices or on the ends of small fern
fronds or shrubs. The riparian habitat at each
study site has potentially climbable herbaceous
and woody vegetation from ground level to
approximately 25 m high that, aside from height,
could have served as suitable perching sites.
Discussion
Some of the statistical differences detected
between juveniles from each study population,
with respect to Y, might be explained by the
disparate sizes between juveniles from the two
populations, genetic (ESU) differences, or small
sample sizes (see Figures). Nonetheless, a clear
trend exists for adult male A. zeteki to perch
significantly higher than juveniles in both
pooled and unpooled data sets. Also, the
statistically significant difference in TDT
between populations might be explained by
differences in the age cohort constituency
(sample size) within populations and may not
necessarily represent actual differences between
populations. Lastly, the strong correlation
between Y and TDT in this study may attest to
the fact that individuals that climb higher at
night move further to do so than those that stay
lower to the ground. TDT was measured in this
study in large part to detect and quantify the
complexity of paths taken to nocturnal roosting
positions as well as to determine the viability of
fluorescent pigment tracking for this species.
Although statistical differences were not
detected, X was measured specifically to gauge
preferences with respect to the primary water
source.
The information provided in this study is
intended to help conservation efforts in two
ways. The first application is that nighttime
stream surveys by national park authorities can
be better completed by knowing the range in
perch heights for adults and juveniles. Second,
this information will help zoos and aquariums
that currently hold living A. zeteki in their
collections for captive breeding. It is anticipated
that information of this nature would assist
breeding professionals in arranging enclosures
in ways that might reduce stress on captive
animals and potentially increase reproductive
success and output.
Lindquist et al.
Phyllomedusa
- 6(1), June 2007
43
The benefits of using fluorescent pigment
tracking in this study were surprising. This
technique allowed us to track the actual paths
chosen by individual animals. Paths taken to
final roosting destinations were complex for
adult males, involving trunk, branch, and vine
climbing, yet were generally uncomplicated and
restrictive for juveniles which generally
remained near the ground. In addition to
microhabitat utilization, another advantage
afforded by this technique is its resilience
against light to moderate rainfall. In numerous
cases of moderate rainfall, the investigators set
out to return to sites expecting a complete loss
of pigment tracks, yet found most intact. Four
juveniles and six adult males (not included in
tracking data sets) were pigmented and had their
tracks removed by heavy rains. Yet, in some
cases, pigments could withstand brief distances
of swimming by the subject. The success rate for
tracking this species with fluorescent pigments
in this study was 60 of 70 total attempts
(85.7%). Pigment use was most effective in dry
conditions, yet surprisingly suitable in the
tropical rain forests and cloud forests in which
this species resides.
Lastly, the reality that adult males
nocturnally perch significantly higher than
juveniles possibly may be adaptive for many
reasons. One possible impetus to drive adult
males to climb vegetation at night, as opposed to
burrowing, hiding in rock crevices, and/or
maintaining daytime position, could be due to
shifting predator detection strategies. It was
evident that a full size range of perches was
available at all heights for both juveniles and
adults; likewise for crevice sizes on the ground.
Anti-predator vigilance would largely be visual
during daytime, whereas perching upon
vegetation at night might allow the tactile
sensation of an approaching predator via the
movement of the perch branch. This may be
important for adults that cannot find hiding
places that are unreachable by predators.
Presumably, this would not be a problem for
substantially smaller juveniles. Potential
nocturnal stream dwelling predators such as
Liophis epinephalus (Reptilia, Colubridae), are
known to be capable of metabolizing key skin
toxins in Central American Atelopus
(Shindelman et al. 1969, Brown et al. 1977,
Daly et al. 1987, Pounds 2000, Yotsu-Yamashita
et al. 2004). Predation of adult A. zeteki by L.
epinephalus has been witnessed firsthand by two
of us (EJGR and EDL). Changing location based
on a shift in sensory cues to improve predator
vigilance from day to night might be the most
logical explanation.
Acknowledgements
This work was undertaken as part of the
Proyecto Rana Dorada (Project Golden Frog)
conservation initiative and in part was funded by
grants from the American Zoo and Aquarium
Association’s Disney Conservation Endowment
Fund, Lee University Faculty Scholarship grants
(EDL), and by the Garden Clubs of America
(SAS). Special thanks are given to B. Lewis, A.
Wisnieski, N. Ellis, and E. Kiester for their
assistance in refinement of the technique.
Likewise we appreciate M. Freake, J. Sander,
and K. Terry for assisting in taking
measurements. We thank G. Diehl for the
information on track persistence with respect to
rainfall. We also are indebted to G. Diehl and K.
Larson for reviews of earlier manuscripts.
Animal care protocol review was provided by
Lee University. Finally, we thank La Autoridad
Nacional del Ambiente for providing permits for
this work.
References
Brown, G. B., Y. H. Kim, H. Küntzel, H. S. Mosher, G. J.
Fuhrman, and F. A. Fuhrman. 1977. Chemistry and
pharmacology of skin toxins from the frog Atelopus
zeteki (Atelopidtoxin: zetekitoxin). Toxicon 15: 115–128.
[CITES] Convention on International Trade in Endangered
Species of Wild Fauna and Flora. CITES home page.
<http//www.cites.org> Captured on Mar 15, 2006.
Cocroft, R. B., R. W. McDiarmid, A. P. Jaslow, and P. M.
Nocturnal position in the Panamanian Golden Frog, Atelopus zeteki (Anura, Bufonidae)
Phyllomedusa
- 6(1), June 2007
44
Ruiz-Carranza. 1990. Vocalizations of eight species of
Atelopus (Anura: Bufonidae) with comments on
communication in the genus. Copeia 1990: 631–643.
Crump, M. 1986. Homing and site fidelity in a neotropical
frog, Atelopus varius (Bufonidae). Copeia 1986: 438–
444.
Daly, J. W., C. W. Myers and N. Whittaker. 1987. Further
classification of skin alkaloids from Neotropical
poison frogs (Dendrobatidae), with a general survey of
toxic/noxious substances in the amphibian. Toxicon
25: 1023–1095.
Dunn, E. R. 1933. Amphibians and reptiles from El Valle
de Anton, Panama. Occasional Papers of the Boston
Society of Natural History 8: 65–79.
Johnson, P. T. J. 2006. Amphibian diversity: decimation
by disease. Proceedings of the National Academy of
Sciences 103: 3011–3012.
Lindquist, E. D. and T. E. Hetherington. 1996. Field
studies on visual and acoustic signaling in the
“earless” Panamanian golden frog, Atelopus zeteki.
Journal of Herpetology 30: 347–354.
Lindquist, E. D. and T. E. Hetherington. 1998a. Tadpole
and juveniles of the Panamanian golden frog, Atelopus
zeteki (Bufonidae) with information on development
of coloration and patterning. Herpetologica 54: 370–
376.
Lindquist, E. D. and T. E. Hetherington. 1998b.
Semaphoring in an earless frog: the origin of a novel
visual signal. Animal Cognition 1: 83–87.
Lips, K. R., P. A. Burrows, J. R. Mendelson III, and G.
Parra-Olea. 2005. Amphibian declines in Latin
America: widespread population declines, extinctions,
and impacts. Biotropica 37: 163–165.
Lips, K. R., F. Brem, R. Brenes, J. D. Reeve, R. A. Alford,
J. Voyles, C. Carey, L. Livo, A. P. Pessier, and J. P.
Collins. 2006. Emerging infectious disease and the loss
of biodiversity in a Neotropical amphibian community.
Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences 103:
3165–3170.
Lowry, R. 2004. VassarStats: Web Site for Statistical
Computation. <http://faculty.vassar.edu/lowry/
VassarStats.html> Accessed Mar 12, 2006.
Miller, T. 1987. Notes on Central American Atelopus. The
Herpetoculturist 1: 25–28.
Pounds, J. A. 2000. Amphibians and reptiles. Pp. 149–
177 in N. M. Nadkarni and N. T. Wheelwright
(eds.), Monteverde: Ecology and Conservation of a
Tropical Cloud Forest. New York. Oxford
University Press.
Pounds, J. A., M. R. Bustamante, L. A. Coloma, J. A.
Consuegra, M. P. L. Fogden, P. N. Foster, E. La Mar-
ca, K. L. Masters, A. Merino-Viteri, R. Puschendorf,
S. R. Ron, G. A. Sánchez-Azofeifa, C. J. Still, and B.
E. Young. 2006. Widespread amphibian extinctions
from epidemic disease driven by global warming.
Nature 439: 161–167.
Savage, J. M. 1972. The harlequin frogs, genus Atelopus,
of Costa Rica and western Panama. Herpetologica 28:
77–94.
Shindelman, J., H. S. Mosher and F. A. Fuhrman. 1969.
Atelopidtoxin from the Panamanian frog, Atelopus
zeteki. Toxicon 7: 315–319.
Yotsu-Yamashita, M., Y. H. Kim, S. C. Dudley, Jr., G.
Choudhary, A. Pfahnl, Y. Oshima,and J. Daly. 2004.
The structure of zetekitoxin AB, a saxitoxin analog
from the Panamanian golden frog, Atelopus zeteki: a
potent sodium channel blocker. Proceedings of the
National Academy of Sciences 101: 4346–4351.
Zippel, K. C., R. Ibáñez D., E. D. Lindquist, C. L.
Richards, C. Jaramillo, E. J. Griffith. 2007. Implica-
ciones en la conservación de las ranas doradas de Pa-
namá, asociadas con su revisión taxonómica. Herpeto-
trópicos 3: 29–39.
Lindquist et al.
... In many species, males maintain their territories on stream banks at least throughout parts of the year where they can occur in high densities (Crump 1988;Ringler et al. 2022;Señaris et al. 2023). Females, on the other hand, are scattered throughout the forest farther from streams, returning to their spawning sites only for reproduction (Lindquist et al. 2007;Ringler et al. 2022). These differences in life history and consequently microhabitat, can likely influence the expression of ventral melanization, e.g. ...
... As far as we are aware, there are only a few documented cases of predation on adult harlequin toads. These include predation by the carunculated caracara (Phalcoboenus carunculatus; De Vries et al. 1983), a fire-bellied snake (Erythrolamprus epinephalus; Greene 1997;Lindquist et al. 2007 Pinto and Costa-Campos 2015). It is interesting that four of these observations document aquatic predators, which are potential visual receivers of ventral coloration. ...
Article
Full-text available
Hidden colors are a widespread phenomenon in the animal kingdom, particularly in an-urans. In some cases, hidden colors are suddenly exposed during defensive displays to startle predators, others seemingly remain hidden-particularly from researchers. Amazonian species of Neotropical harlequin toads (genus Atelopus) show striking and consistent ventral sexual dichromatism where females show and males generally lack melanization. Inspired by these observations we undertook a deeper inquiry across this species-rich genus. We collected data on ventral sexual dichromatism in Atelopus species and scored expression of sex-specific ventral melanization (i.e. black, brown and/or grey coloration). Ventral sexual dichromatism was present throughout the entire range of the genus and in almost all phylogenetic groups. However, there was a clear geographic signal with this trait being most common and widespread in Amazonian Atelopus species. Ventral mela-nization was correlated with temperature and elevation. Focusing on the Amazonian species , we present hypotheses on potential functions of sexually dimorphic ventral patterns and sex-specific ventral melanization as a baseline to further investigate the dynamics of sexual and natural selection as potential drivers of these traits. Selective pressures on less exposed body parts, such as ventral sides, likely differ considerably from those on dorsal appearance. Given the amount of research on amphibian coloration, it is remarkable how little we know about the evolution, function and underlying mechanisms of ventral appearance. We hope our work will spark more interest in the flip side of amphibians, thereby broadening our understanding of animal coloration.
... Griffith, pers comm.), and with the PGF population presumed to be exclusively in captivity, maximal reproductive output with optimal genetic sustainability and minimal risk to existing individuals is crucial for species survival. Management efforts to promote captive breeding capitalize on knowledge of natural breeding behavior and reproductive cycles [9,10]; however, little data was able to be collected on this species before it disappeared from its native range [9,11]. Several Atelopus species display a unique reproductive behavior, in that amplexus is initiated reliably by the male and lasts for extended periods of time, sometimes up to 60 days or more [12], which is thought to stem from the necessity of males to competitively monopolize females at natural breeding sites until they oviposit [11,13]. ...
... Management efforts to promote captive breeding capitalize on knowledge of natural breeding behavior and reproductive cycles [9,10]; however, little data was able to be collected on this species before it disappeared from its native range [9,11]. Several Atelopus species display a unique reproductive behavior, in that amplexus is initiated reliably by the male and lasts for extended periods of time, sometimes up to 60 days or more [12], which is thought to stem from the necessity of males to competitively monopolize females at natural breeding sites until they oviposit [11,13]. In captivity, extended periods of amplexus result in lack of food intake for several weeks, which depletes existing energy stores, causes poor body condition and can compromise the frog and make it more susceptible to systemic infection, all which contribute to increased risk of mortality [14][15][16]. ...
Article
Full-text available
Background With Panamanian golden frogs (Atelopus zeteki; PGFs) likely extirpated from the wild, ensuring long-term sustainability of captive populations is crucial in order to conserve this critically endangered species. Unfortunately, PGFs display a unique reproductive behavior involving a prolonged period of amplexus leading to challenges in their successful captive propagation. The Maryland Zoo in Baltimore has observed high levels of mortality during the breeding season and suboptimal reproductive success leading to the use of hormone stimulation to aid in reproduction and health management. Methods This project aimed to develop induced ovulation and health management protocols by (1) evaluating different doses of gonadotropin releasing hormone analogue (GnRHa), (2) comparing the efficacy of GnRHa and GnRHa + metoclopramide, (3) determining latency periods and the effects of pulsed hormone sequences; and (4) establish if mortality is impacted by hormone therapy. Female PGFs (n = 174) were given GnRHa either in various concentrations (Experiment 1) or combined with metoclopramide (Experiment 2), and oviposition success, latency, and mortality were measured as binary response variables. Results Overall, the use of exogenous hormones significantly decreased mortality when compared to the control data of natural egg-laying females. GnRHa doses of 0.05 μg/g body weight produced similar ovulation rates compared to higher doses, and the addition of metoclopramide did not increase oviposition success compared to GnRHa alone. Lastly, results indicate the majority of female PGFs will release eggs within 48 h following the initial pulse of hormones with a small percentage ovipositing after a second pulse. Conclusion Findings from this study will benefit captive management of PGFs by documenting the increased survival of females when given hormone stimulation and defining appropriate GnRHa doses and expected latency to spawning.
... R. castaneotica and R. margaritifera) (see Noronha et al. 2013;Oliveira-Souza et al. 2020;Costa-Campos and Pedroso-Santos 2022). This behavior offers advantages in accessing safety from ground-dwelling predators, as well as to resting and foraging sites (Lindquist et al. 2007;Noronha et al. 2013). ...
Article
Our study describes for the first time the trophic ecology of Rhinella lescurei from the eastern Brazilian Amazonia. The stomach contents of the individuals were obtained through the flushing method during the rainy season. A total of 130 stomachs were flushed, of which 75 (57.70%) had stomach contents, with a total of 881 food items distributed among 10 prey categories, with 22 ant genera. Formicidae was the most important prey category. Rhinella lescurei demonstrated a narrow niche breadth, suggesting a more specialist behavior, as observed in the feeding strategy analysis. We found Coleoptera, Araneae and Formicidae as the most abundant prey in the diet shared among the sexes, which showed more than one association in network analysis, and the Crematogaster as the most abundant ants on the diet of males and juveniles, and Sericomyrmex for females. We observed a positive effect of the snout-vent length on the total volume of prey consumed. The Body Condition Index indicated that both smaller and larger individuals have the same nutritional status. Our study adds new data on the natural history of a species still poorly known from the Amazon region.
... R. castaneotica and R. margaritifera) (see Noronha et al. 2013;Oliveira-Souza et al. 2020;Costa-Campos and Pedroso-Santos 2022). This behavior offers advantages in accessing safety from ground-dwelling predators, as well as to resting and foraging sites (Lindquist et al. 2007;Noronha et al. 2013). ...
... However, P. asper is considered to be terrestrial and has no obvious morphological adaptations to climbing (Kusrini, 2013;Alhadi et al., 2021). The obvious advantages to terrestrial bufonids of selecting arboreal resting sites are that they may offer avoidance of predators or parasites, and better access to prey (Lindquist et al., 2007;Granda-Rodriguez et al., 2008;Petrovan et al., 2022). Recently reported similar examples of normally terrestrial bufonids climbing into trees/shrubs have been for Rhinella margaritifera and Rhinella castaneotica in Brazil (De Noronha et al., 2013) and Bufo in Britain (Petrovan et al., 2022). ...
... There are few known Atelopus predators. Erythrolamprus epinephalus is a colubrid snake that has been observed eating A. varius and A. zeteki in the wild (Greene, 1997;Lindquist et al., 2007) and has consumed A. elegans and A. zeteki while in captivity to no ill effect (Myers et al., 1978). However, Myers et al. (1978) do not specify whether these toads were wild-caught or captive-raised. ...
Article
Full-text available
Toads of the genus Atelopus are chemically defended by a unique combination of endogenously synthesizedcardiotoxins (bufadienolides) and neurotoxins which may be sequestered (guanidinium alkaloids). Investigationinto Atelopus small-molecule chemical defenses has been primarily concerned with identifying and characterizingvarious forms of these toxins while largely overlooking their ecological roles and evolutionary implications. Inaddition to describing the extent of knowledge about Atelopus toxin structures, pharmacology, and biologicalsources, we review the detection, identification, and quantification methods used in studies of Atelopus toxins todate and conclude that many known toxin profiles are unlikely to be comprehensive because of methodologicaland sampling limitations. Patterns in existing data suggest that both environmental (toxin availability) andgenetic (capacity to synthesize or sequester toxins) factors influence toxin profiles. From an ecological andevolutionary perspective, we summarize the possible selective pressures acting on Atelopus toxicity and toxinprofiles, including predation, intraspecies communication, disease, and reproductive status. Ultimately, weintend to provide a basis for future ecological, evolutionary, and biochemical research on Atelopus.
... At night, these harlequin frogs can be observed among rocks and roots, as well as perched on vegetation above the ground (Lötters 1996). The use of these microhabitat during the night have been generally reported as resting sites (Crump 1986;Lötters 1996;Lindquist et al. 2007 1. Individuos de la rana arlequín variable Atelopus varius encontrados en la noche cerca del río Cotón, Costa Rica. Individuo activo por la noche y alimentándose de hormigas (A); individuo encaramado con su superficie ventral en contacto con la hoja (B) y dos individuos que descansan entre las raíces (C, D). ...
Article
Atelopus varius is a critically endangered species distributed in Costa Rica and Panama. It has diurnal activity and at night it rests on vegetation or in crevices, with no apparent nocturnal activity. Herein, we report an unusual nocturnal activity for the species at Las Tablas Protected Zone, Costa Rica; we observed an individual on an herbaceous plant at night, performing slow movements while feeding on ants. Despite A. varius being one of the most well-known species of the genera, there are still poorly studied aspects of its natural history. Therefore, we propose to lead research efforts on the nocturnal behaviour of A. varius, with the purpose of filling knowledge gaps for this important species of conservation concern.
... This fact suggests that the acquisition of a new function, here understood as the ability to climb, besides to perform terrestrial locomotion, may have played a relevant role in the origin of the arboreal niche by amphibians. The arboreal niche exhibits considerable opportunities to survive either as a refuge, as resting sites to avoid predators, or as food availability alternatives (Granda- Rodríguez et al., 2008;Lindquist et al., 2007;Toledo et al., 2007). Our study supports the hypothesis of climbing as an alternative to escape, in our case, from a small enclosure, which has already been proposed by de Noronha et al. (2013). ...
Article
Full-text available
Several studies of arboreal anuran species show morphological specializations for clinging onto narrow substrates. However, little is known about these capacities in non-specialized anurans, which is crucial to understand the initial phases of adaptation to a new niche. To assess the functional requirements related to the evolution of arboreality in anurans we analyzed climbing performance, and correlated anatomical traits, in the terrestrial toad Rhinella arenarum, a species choose as a proxy for the ancestral condition regarding the evolution of this specialized niche. We studied the impact of a substrate of wooden rods with different diameters, arrangements, and slopes on locomotion, grasping, and climbing with a comparative framework. Animals were confronted with climbing tests, video recording their behaviors. Preserved specimens were dissected to assess limb myology, osteology, and tendons’ characteristics. Our results show that how terrestrial toad R. arenarum climbs is different from those displayed by specialized tree frogs. Animals flexed their fingers and toes, grasping the substrate displaying hookings and partial graspings. The palm was scarcely involved in the grip, as in specialized anurans. These actions were performed although flexor and extensor muscles of the digits are highly conserved and generalized. Further, we formally assess the evolutionary history of ecological and anatomical traits related to climbing among Rhinella species to improving the comprehension of the relation between morphofunctional patterns and behavioral climbing skills. Our experiments revealed that this terrestrial toad possesses unexpected climbing capacities, suggesting a way in which evolution of new niches could have developed in the evolution of anurans.
... H. Sung, unpublished data), indicating that competition for males may not be intense among females. However, our observed sex ratio should be considered with caution as males are easier to detect because of their calls, and when not mating females may be active in the forest away from the stream, as in some South American stream-dwelling frogs (e.g., Lindquist et al. 2007), and therefore less likely to be detected around the stream. Determining the function and evolutionary mechanism that has driven development of this reproductive behavior will be challenging in a species with such cryptic reproductive habits. ...
Article
Full-text available
Abstract Amphibians exhibit diverse reproductive behaviors, including nine documented types of amplexus, the behavior in which male and female frogs position themselves for courtship, oviposition, and fertilization. All known forms of amplexus involve the male on top of or in line horizontally (cloacal apposition) with the female. Here, we report a novel form of amplexus observed in Lau’s leaf litter toad (Leptobrachella laui; Megophryidae) in Hong Kong, China. Termed “sex‐reversed inguinal amplexus,” the female climbs on top of a male and the male transports the female to a concealed breeding site. We were unable to determine whether this was the amplectant position in which frogs engaged during oviposition or solely during courtship and prior to oviposition, but there are a number of possible evolutionary drivers that may have given rise to this behavior, including limiting suitable oviposition sites or strong competition for males among females. Further research will be necessary to understand the evolutionary origins of this novel reproductive behavior.
Article
Full-text available
We present information on developmental stages (larvae, recent metamorphs, and subadults) and ecology of the Panamanian golden frog (Atelopus zeteki). Tadpoles were found in stream pools away from swift torrents and recent metamorphs were observed on gravel bars adjacent to these pools. Water quality of streams containing A. zeteki was found to have high dissolved oxygen content, neutral pH, and low levels of sulfates, nitrates, reactive phosphorous, and turbidity. As opposed to the aposematically colored adults, metamorphs and subadults of the two populations studied were cryptically colored, suggesting the absence of significant skin toxicity in the latter. Subadult juveniles often were seen in close proximity to adult males. This is unusual because outside of courting gravid females, adult males are aggressive toward other conspecifics within sight.
Article
Full-text available
Field studies were conducted on the visual and acoustic behavior of the Panamanian golden frog, Atelopus zeteki, a species lacking a tympanic middle ear. Males displayed three stereotyped behaviors in response to playbacks of male pulsed vocalizations: foot signaling, vocalization, and repositioning orientation. Frequencies of foot signaling and orientation responses were significantly increased by presentation of playback vocalizations. Vocal responses also increased (non-significantly) during the playback period and continued to increase during post-playback silence. These results provide the first experimental evidence that an "earless" anuran species displays behavioral responses to sound, and that vocalization may play an important role in communication. The forefoot waving, and possibly hindfoot raising observed in this species appear to represent visual signals used intraspecifically in male agonistic behavior. male frogs appear to rely preferentially on visual signaling (foot signaling) as compared to acoustic signaling (vocalizing). The existence and preferential use of visual signaling in this species may be correlated with their noisy, montane stream habitat. Orientation by the frogs toward the playback speaker suggests that this "earless" species of anuran is capable of localizing a sound source.
Article
Full-text available
Social communication in anuran amphibians (frogs and toads) is mediated predominantly by acoustic signals. Unlike most anurans, the Panamanian golden frog, Atelopus zeteki, lacks a standard tympanic middle ear and appears to have augmented its communicatory repertoire to include rotational limb motions as visual signals, referred to here as semaphores. The communicatory nature of semaphoring was inferred from experimental manipulations using mirrored self-image presentations and nonresident introductions. Male frogs semaphored significantly more when presented with a mirrored self-image than with a nonreflective control. Novel encounters between resident males and nonresident frogs demonstrated that semaphores were used directionally and were displayed toward target individuals. Females semaphored frequently and this observation represents a rare case of signaling by females in a typically male-biased communicatory regime. Semaphore actions were clearly linked to a locomotory gait pattern and appear to have originated as an elaboration of a standard stepping motion.
Article
Full-text available
Vocalizations of frogs of the genus Atelopus include three discrete types of signals: pulsed calls, pure tone calls, and short calls. Repertoire composition is conservative across species. Repertoires of most species whose calls have been recorded contain two or three of these identifiable call types. Within a call type, details of call structure are very similar across species. This apparent lack of divergence in calls may be related to the rarity of sympatry among species of Atelopus and to the relative importance of visual communication in their social interactions.
Article
The Monteverde Cloud Forest Reserve has captured the worldwide attention of biologists, conservationists, and ecologists and has been the setting for extensive investigation over the past 30 years. Roughly 40,000 ecotourists visit the Cloud Forest each year, and it is often considered the archetypal high-altitude rain forest. This volume brings together some of the most prominent researchers of the region to provide a broad introduction to the biology of the Monteverde, and cloud forests in general. Collecting and synthesizing vital information about the ecosystem and its biota, the book also examines the positive and negative effects of human activity on both the forest and the surrounding communities. Ecologists, tropical biologists, and natural historians will find this volume an indispensable resource, as will all those who are fascinated by the magnificent wonders of the tropical forests.
Article
Homing ability was examined in the neotropical frog, Atelopus varius (Bufonidae), in Costa Rica. Frogs were distributed in and along a mountain stream at 1140 m elevation. Equal numbers of frogs were displaced 10 m upstream and 10 m downstream from their original capture site. Successful homing was defined as return to within 1 m of the original capture site within one week after displacement. Frogs homed equally well downstream and upstream and there was no significant difference between males and females in frequency of homing. "Resident" frogs (individuals known to have stayed within 1.5 m of a particular spot for the previous 10-41 d) homed significantly more often than did "transients" (individuals first found at the time of the experiment, never during the preceding 41 d). There was no significant difference in tendency to home during the dry season vs wet season. The reasons for site fidelity and associated homing behavior in this species are not clear.
Article
Amphibian populations are in decline throughout Latin America; all families of frogs have experienced declines, but the species associated with aquatic habitats in upland areas have been most affected. Declines in Latin America were most common during the 1980s, but new declines continue to be reported. The causes of declines are varied, but they have most often been associated with habitat loss, a pathogenic fungus, and climate change. Scientists are just beginning to grasp the ethical and biological implications of losses of this magnitude. In this Special Section, we provide a general summary of the phenomenon and introduce five contributed papers that provide new data and new insights into Latin American declines. En América Latina se ha documentado un declive generalizado en poblaciones de anfibios. Dicho declive se ha presentado en especies de todas las familias de anfibios, pero especialmente en aquellas asociadas a ambientes acuáticos en zonas montañosas. El declive en América Latina, ocurrió en la década de los 80s, pero en la actualidad todavía se siguen registrando disminuciones. Los investigadores apenas están empezando a a entender las implicaciones éticas y biológicas de pérdidadas de biodiversidad de esta magnitud. Aquí presentamos un resumen general de este fenómeno y la introducción a cinco trabajos que proveen datos nuevos para América Latina.
Article
Chemistry and pharmacology of skin toxins from the frog Atelopus zeteki (atelopidtoxin; zetekitoxin). Toxicon15, 115–128, 1977.—Zetekitoxins were obtained in purified form from skins of the Panamanian frog Atelopus zeteki by a series of steps which used preparative free-flowing electrophoresis in the last stages. The minor, less toxic component (zetekitoxin C) had an ld50 of 80 μg per kg (i.p., mouse), and the major, more toxic component (zetekitoxin AB) had an ld50 of 11 μg per kg. These toxins are water-soluble, low molecular weight, non-polypeptide, non-steroid and non-carbohydrate in nature. The zetekitoxins are clearly different from tetrodotoxin and chiriquitoxin. Atelopus zeteki were resistant to toxin obtained from their own skins. Zetekitoxin AB (1·5–3 μg per kg) produced sustained hypotension in anesthetized dogs and cats, during which time the pressor response to epinephrine and norepinephrine was unchanged, but that to carotid occlusion was reduced. The toxin at a concentration of 0·5 μg per 1 blocked vasoconstriction caused by electrical stimulation of perfused rabbit ear arteries, and this effect was antagonized by dextroamphetamine. It did not reduce contraction of the nicitating membrane or block α-adrenergic receptors (vas deferens). It partially blocked β-adrenergic receptors (guinea pig atria) only in high concentrations above 10 μg per 1.