ArticlePDF Available

Hidden in Plain Sight: Clinical Observations on Prostitution

Hidden in Plain Sight: Clinical Observations on Prostitution
Judith Lewis Herman, M.D.
Published in Melissa Farley, Ph.D. (Ed.), Prostitution, Trafficking and Traumatic Stress.
New York: Haworth Press, 2003, pp. 1-13.
Prostitution is everywhere. Everyone knows this; we just don’t particularly want to know
(MacKinnon, 2001). Who can bear to think for too long about a worldwide enterprise that
condemns millions of women and children to social death (Patterson, 1982), and often to literal
death, for the sexual pleasure and profit of men? The choice to avoid knowing operates at the
edges of our consciousness; this is how dissociation is practiced as a social norm.
Thirty years ago, rape, domestic violence, and incest were similarly invisible, despite
their high prevalence. A mass movement was required to bring these abuses into public
awareness. In the social analysis developed by feminists, these crimes were understood as
intrinsic features of a system of male dominance. It was recognized that the purpose of these
crimes is to impose power, and that the methods used in furtherance of this goal are essentially
the same as the methods of torture practiced in political prisons worldwide (Amnesty
International, 1973; Russell, 1984).
One question that this analysis left unanswered was how individual batterers and sex
offenders came to learn these often quite sophisticated methods of domination. In state-
sponsored political violence, the practice of torture is organized within secret police forces and
“irregular” military units, who presumably teach these methods to carefully selected new
recruits. Knowledge of these methods may be shared among clandestine military units of
different countries; indeed, according to declassified documents, such methods have been
taught in the US at the notorious School of the Americas (Haugaard, 1997; Nelson-Pallmeyer,
1997). But this mode of transmission can not account for the widespread practice of methods of
coercive control in sexual and domestic life. Powerful as they may be, secret military and police
units are relatively small in number even within dictatorships, whereas batterers and sex
offenders are legion, not only in authoritarian political systems, but also in democratic societies.
It is theoretically possible, of course, that each abuser might spontaneously re-invent the
basic methods of coercive control for himself, but this seems quite unlikely, given the constancy
and uniformity of these practices across class and culture. It is more likely that this knowledge
is transmitted within all-male groups that promote an ideology of male dominance and contempt
for women, what Brownmiller (1975) calls the “men’s house culture.” It is already known that
sexual assault is common among young men who belong to groups such as sports teams and
fraternities (Koss, 1987). In such groups, the exchange of women or a shared visit to a brothel
is often the means by which male bonding and solidarity is affirmed. The ritual display of the
power to command sex from women is also a common custom in many business and political
enterprises and, of course, in armies worldwide (Johnson, 2000; Goldstein, 2001). It is
conceivable, then, that the prostitution industry, which operates in virtually every society, might
be a primary vector for socialization in the practices of coercive control, and the pimp might be
among world’s most common instructors in the arts of torture.
For helping professionals, it is difficult enough to face the reality of sexual and domestic
violence as it operates in a single family, and to engage in a therapeutic relationship with a
battered woman or abused child. How much more difficult, then, to face the reality of sexual
violence as exercised by an organized criminal enterprise that operates freely in every
community, hidden in plain sight, and to engage with victims who have been systematically
reduced to the condition of slavery. Even those of us who are seasoned clinicians may find
ourselves overcome with feelings of disgust, fascination, or pervasive dread, reactions which
interfere with the formation of a successful therapeutic alliance. Like bystanders everywhere,
we may choose not to see, hear, or speak about what in fact we already know.
Recently, when preparing a lecture for a conference on trauma, I proposed to address
the subject of prostitution. The conference organizer was not pleased with my suggestion.
Most of the program was devoted to the response to terrorist attacks and the formation of a
national center for traumatic stress in children. Here was plenty of “clean” trauma, with many
innocent victims whose plight aroused general sympathy. Prostitution, by contrast, was
embarrassing, shameful, in a word, dirty. Did it even make sense to speak of victims? Wasn’t
prostitution, after all, a “victimless crime?”
I noted that our staff at the Victims of Violence Program (Department of Psychiatry, The
Cambridge Hospital, Cambridge, MA) were seeing a remarkable number of patients who had
been used in prostitution, and that these were among the most cruelly abused people we had
ever treated. My colleague acknowledged that he, too, had seen such cases, but surely they
were unusual. I suggested as an empirical test that we poll the audience at the conference. If
few of the participants had seen such cases, I promised not to pursue the subject any further.
At the start of my lecture, with about 600 people in attendance, I asked how many had
treated or were currently treating patients who had been used in prostitution. By my rough
visual estimate, 450 people (75%) raised their hands. It was a moment of surprise, not only for
my colleague, the conference organizer, but for those in the audience as well. Here was a
common experience that by common, unspoken consent was simply not discussed in public, not
even by a group of mental health professionals who had already amply proved their willingness
to bear witness to terrible stories. It was also a moment of illumination and relief, as members
of the audience looked around and realized they had lots of company. With the
acknowledgement and support of colleagues, perhaps we clinicians could overcome our own
resistance to engagement with victims who are generally viewed as neither “clean” nor
We have a great deal to learn from these patients. The complex traumatic syndromes
from which they suffer are among the most difficult to understand and the most challenging to
treat. They define for us the far edges of the spectrum of traumatic disorders, and the frontiers
of our current knowledge.
Secrecy is the first and most serious obstacle to forming a therapeutic alliance. People
engaged in prostitution, if they seek treatment at all, are likely to conceal or minimize their
involvement in prostitution. The shame and stigma attached to prostitution are so severe that
most people will go to great lengths to hide this aspect of their experience, even in a confidential
therapy relationship that depends for its success on frank and full disclosure (Baldwin, this
volume). Given the widespread prevalence of prostitution, it would seem advisable for
clinicians to learn to incorporate questions regarding this experience into routine history-taking
(for examples see Stark & Hodgson, this volume). Clinicians working with trauma populations
should be especially alert to this possibility, given the vulnerability of childhood abuse survivors
to revictimization in general (Coid, et. al., 2001), and to recruitment for pornography and
prostitution in particular (Russell 1986).
People in prostitution also commonly suffer from serious neurobiological and personality
disorders that hinder the formation of a cooperative working relationship. Moreover, the realities
of their daily lives are often so precarious and dangerous that without sustained and well-
organized social intervention, ordinary therapeutic measures are unlikely to have any
meaningful effect. Some of the problems encountered in treating this group of patients are
illustrated by the following case vignettes, drawn from the records of the Victims of Violence
Program. Details that might permit identification of individuals have been omitted or disguised.
Neurobiological Problems
These include very complex and confusing ego states (Ross & Farley, this volume), and
severe forms of emotional and bodily dysregulation. While somatic and affective dysregulation
are commonly seen in complex PTSD (van der Kolk et. al., 1996), the conditions of prostitution
exacerbate this problem. Control of bodily functions is an established method of coercion well
known to clandestine police forces and criminal organizations worldwide. It is systematically
practiced by pimps and traffickers in the sex industry, not only to intimidate victims and break
their resistance, but also to train them for sexual performance.
The ultimate goal in this, as in all systems of domination, is to destroy the autonomy of
the victim and induce as far as possible a state of willing submission. This may require the
intentional induction of altered states of consciousness and the development of dissociated ego
states in which the enslaved person is given a new name and a new identity as a whore (Stark
& Hodgson, this volume). An example can be found in the autobiographical account of Linda
Marciano, who describes being first raped and beaten into submission, and then trained with the
aid of hypnosis to suppress her gag reflex, in order to perform her role as “Linda Lovelace” in
the famous pornographic film Deep Throat (Lovelace & McGrady, 1980). Here the colonization
of the body extends to the suppression of the most basic autonomic functions.
Under conditions of prostitution, autonomous self-regulation of any sort is a form of
insubordination; it is expressly forbidden and actively suppressed. In the absence of normal
self-soothing, substance abuse provides the most accessible route to bodily calm and emotional
comfort. Addiction further complicates an already complicated clinical picture. When chemical
means of self-regulation fail, self-harming behavior and suicide attempts are often the last
Case example One.
Jenny, a 35-year old single woman, entered outpatient treatment complaining of
depression and post-traumatic stress symptoms. She was living alone in a condominium owned
by her father and working part time in the office of one of her father’s business associates. She
complained of feeling controlled and bullied by her father, who had sexually abused her when
she was a child, but depended on him for financial support.
The initial treatment plan focused on stabilization of symptoms and development of a
workable safety plan. Ostensibly Jenny agreed with this plan and seemed highly motivated to
carry it out. However, despite her best efforts and those of her treatment team, apparently well-
crafted safety plans were repeatedly and inexplicably breached. Her sense desperation and
helplessness deepened, and she became actively suicidal. Her treatment team was puzzled by
her deteriorating condition. Clearly, some major piece of information was missing.
Finally, two years into her treatment, it was recognized that “Jenny” was the host
personality in a patient with Dissociative Identity Disorder. Our experienced clinicians had
previously failed to make the diagnosis, despite their general familiarity with dissociative
disorders and a high index of suspicion in this particular case. It became clear that the patient
had intentionally concealed her dissociative symptoms. Some of her numerous alters disclosed
that they had been actively collaborating with the father, who operated a private sex ring. The
patient reported that her father had been pimping her since the age of 14, rewarding her with
money and cocaine. He was fully aware of her dissociative disorder and routinely summoned
specific alters, who identified themselves as willing prostitutes, to perform the desired sexual
In his original study of 100 cases of Dissociative Identity Disorder, Putnam (1986) noted
that the average length of time between entry into the mental health system and correct
diagnosis was six years. The two year delay in diagnosing this case, while it might represent an
improvement over the norms of 20 years ago, certainly leaves much to be desired. It seems
clear in retrospect that the key to the diagnosis in this complex case was recognition of the
patient’s ongoing involvement in prostitution. Specific questioning regarding prostitution might
have uncovered this essential fact earlier.
Characterological Problems
Victimization does not generally improve a person’s character. Personality disorders are
a common feature of the complex traumatic syndrome that results from prolonged and repeated
trauma in relationships of coercive control (Herman, 1992). Many survivors develop a
stigmatized, negative identity and have difficulty establishing stable, cooperative and mutually
rewarding relationships. Identity and relational problems reflect the degree of moral degradation
to which the person has been subjected, and the resultant shame, resentment and mistrust
which she brings to any new relationship. It is common for survivors to engage in a pattern of
intense, unstable and highly conflictual relationships.
Even when the prostitution secret has been revealed, other forms of dissembling and
dishonesty may continue. People who have been used in prostitution are keenly aware of the
hypocrisy of the supposedly respectable people who seek out their services. They are further
exposed to the ideology of the criminal class that exploits them, in which every sort of immoral
behavior is rationalized and even glorified, on the grounds that the whole society is exploitative
and corrupt, and the only way to preserve one’s dignity is to “beat the system.” Relationships,
including the therapeutic relationship, are often approached with the assumption that people are
generally selfish or perverse, and that only a limited number of roles are possible: one can be a
perpetrator, an accomplice, a well-meaning but useless bystander, a victim, or, perhaps, a
rescuer. The concept of a freely chosen, honest and fair relationship, in which both parties work
hard to fulfill their responsibilities and both parties benefit, may be completely foreign to the
patient’s world-view or experience.
To counter this cynical and despairing view of human relationships, the rules of
engagement in psychotherapy must be clearly explained, and the therapist must make it clear
that both parties are accountable for honoring them. Honesty, fairness, and respect are mutual
obligations. The patient should be encouraged to voice any complaints she may have about her
treatment, especially any behavior that she views as unjust, dishonest or disrespectful.
Similarly, the therapist should deal openly with dishonest or disrespectful behavior on the part of
the patient, both in and outside of the office. Treating patients with dignity includes the
expectation that they take reasonable responsibility for their actions.
In general, clinicians aspire to create a therapeutic climate that is accepting, warm and
non-judgmental. Confronting a patient’s unacceptable behavior, while maintaining an attitude of
caring and respect, is one of the therapist’s most difficult and challenging tasks. When working
with people in prostitution, clinicians may bend over backward to avoid seeming prudish or
judgmental. In the effort to overcome their own prejudices, clinicians may be tempted to
overlook or excuse antisocial behavior. This stance, while well-intentioned, ultimately
undermines the therapy relationship. Patients do not appreciate being patronized. On the
contrary, patients often express their appreciation for therapists who recognize them as moral
beings, using expressions such as “she never let me get over on her,” or “he believed in me.”
Case Example Two:
Katarina is a 24 year old mother of a 2 year old son. In the course of her treatment, she
had successfully ended a relationship with a pimp and was living in a small apartment with a
new boyfriend, who, like herself, was a recovering addict. She supported herself by providing
home daycare for several children. Daily contact with the children reminded her of how
profoundly neglected she had been as a child and how deeply she longed for both attention and
material possessions. She acknowledged that she missed the extravagant spending that was
part of her life in prostitution, even though she recognized that her pimp controlled all the money
and that she herself had always been desperately poor.
Just before Christmas, Katarina reported that while in a store with her son she had
impulsively stolen a bracelet. Her initial feeling of entitlement and triumph had quickly given
way to shame and regret as she realized how seriously she had put herself and her child at risk.
She was very relieved that she had not been caught, but getting away with shoplifting didn’t feel
right either; now she couldn’t even stand to wear the bracelet.
The therapist was glad Katarina had confided in her, and told her so, but also made it
clear that she did not approve of stealing. She asked whether Katarina had considered
returning the bracelet. This idea came as a complete surprise to the patient, who had never
entertained the possibility that she could make things right. Her eventual choice to return the
bracelet gave her a new sense of agency and self-respect.
In this case, the therapist was able to maintain the distinction between moral and
therapeutic neutrality. To clarify the distinction: moral neutrality means declining to take a stand
on the abstract question whether stealing is right or wrong. Therapeutic neutrality means
declining to take a stand regarding the patient’s inner conflicts about stealing. Here, the
therapist was able to convey a clear moral position against shoplifting, while maintaining a
confidential and accepting stance toward the patient. This allowed the patient to explore her
conflicted feelings about what she had done and come to her own resolution of her dilemma.
The therapeutic alliance was enhanced, to the mutual satisfaction of patient and therapist, and
the therapy progressed well.
In other cases, however, where crimes against persons rather than property crimes are
at issue, neutrality of any sort may be impossible to maintain. If the patient’s behavior is putting
others at risk, the therapist may be morally or even legally obligated to take a stand, even at the
cost of violating confidentiality or jeopardizing the therapy relationship.
Case example Three
Nicole, a 22 year old single mother, came to the clinic seeking medication to help her
panic attacks and counseling to help her cope with the behavior of her 5 year old daughter.
She had recently moved into the home of a wealthy, divorced older man whom she had met at
the nightclub where she worked as a stripper. She saw this move as a great improvement in
her life. She was estranged both from her abusive parents and from the father of her child, who
had beaten her and had never provided any financial support. Her new boyfriend treated her
“like a queen.” The only problem was her daughter, who had turned into a “brat.” The child had
become alternately clingy and defiant, had started wetting the bed, and was refusing to accept
her new “daddy.” Over time Nicole disclosed that this man had a prior conviction for rape and
was currently under permanent court order to have no contact with his two teenage daughters,
who had accused him of incest. Nicole believed his assurances that in both cases he had been
falsely accused by conniving women who were after his money. She frequently left her
daughter alone in his care, despite the child’s protests.
The therapist expressed his concern about the situation. He attempted to engage
Nicole’s protective feelings for her daughter and to raise her awareness regarding the possibility
of abuse, but Nicole adamantly refused to entertain the idea that her child could be in any
danger. The therapist shared his dilemma with the patient. He explained that he did not want
to take action without her consent, but he could not remain a passive bystander when he
suspected that the child might be at risk. He reminded Nicole how much she had longed for
someone to intervene when she herself was being abused as a child. In this case, he
explained, there were clear warning signals, and he would be negligent if he failed to pay
attention. Furthermore, as a mandated reporter he was required by law to bring his concern
about the child’s safety to the attention of protective services. Enraged, Nicole called the
therapist a “fucking pig” and stormed out of the office. An investigation by the state Department
of Social Services confirmed sexual abuse, and the child was placed in foster care.
In this case, despite the therapist’s best efforts, it was not possible to engage the patient
in the project of establishing safety. The treatment alliance failed, and the therapist was obliged
to act unilaterally. Though the intervention was necessary, the outcome was tragic for both the
patient and her daughter. It was also painful for therapist, who was placed in an untenable
position, forced to choose between passive complicity in the ongoing abuse of a child and
drastic action that invoked the intervention of the state. In general, because violence and
exploitation are an intrinsic part of the daily lives of people in prostitution, therapists who work
with them may often be placed in the uncomfortable position of a bystander and faced with
similar moral dilemmas regarding intervention.
Social Problems
The numerous social problems encountered by people in prostitution are reviewed by
several authors in this volume (Carter; Hedin & Manson; Hotaling et al; Rabinovitch). Of
particular concern are the dangers and practical difficulties of leaving prostitution. Like battered
women, prostituted women can expect an escalation of violence should they attempt to escape
from their abusers, and may need a great deal of assistance to obtain shelter and rudimentary
physical safety. Several attempts may be necessary to before safety is achieved. Caregivers
who assist women attempting to leave prostitution may feel frustrated and overwhelmed by the
complexity of the task; they may also occasionally feel threatened and endangered along with
their patients.
Case example Four
Yvette, a 28 year old woman with a 15 year history of prostitution and drug addiction,
finally made a decision to leave her pimp. Support for this decision required intensive
involvement and sustained cooperation among numerous agencies. She was hospitalized on
several occasions, first for detoxification and then for severe depression. She was eventually
granted disability on the basis of psychiatric impairment and was assigned a case manager.
Supervised housing was arranged through the state Department of Mental Health. A victim
advocate assisted her in seeking a court order to prevent the pimp from pursuing her in her new
For several months after the court order was granted, Yvette had no contact with her
pimp and was consistently abstinent from drugs and alcohol for the first time since early
adolescence. Safety was maintained until she was discharged (against her therapist’s advice)
from the halfway house where she had been living and moved to an unsupervised apartment in
an unfamiliar community. Within two weeks she relapsed and called one of the pimp’s
associates, looking for drugs. Shortly thereafter she was found by the police wandering on the
street at night, dazed and bleeding, and brought to the local emergency room. She initially
stated that her pimp had tracked her down and beaten her, but soon retracted her story and
refused to cooperate further with law enforcement.
When she recovered from her injuries, Yvette was discharged from the hospital to a
secure residential placement. She is currently sober and to the best of our knowledge has had
no further contact with her pimp. In therapy she acknowledges that was indeed the pimp who
attacked her, but she is afraid that he might kill her if she ever dared to press criminal charges
against him. Her therapist considers this to be a reasonable fear.
Consultation was sought with the victim witness advocacy service in the district
attorney’s office, regarding potential danger to the therapist as well as the patient. In the
advocate’s judgment, the pimp appeared to be a rational criminal entrepreneur who was unlikely
to risk attacking a person with professional status and a strong social support network.
Nevertheless, the therapist has taken additional security precautions to protect herself and her
The investment of service resources in this case was extraordinary. The financial and
emotional costs of this one case were very high, and while significant progress has been made,
the patient’s recovery is still quite fragile. Premature attempts to move the patient to a less
intensive (and less costly) care environment resulted in relapse and placed her in serious
danger. Though this case may represent an extreme, some comparable degree of resource
mobilization may be necessary for many people in prostitution. Effective recovery programs are
likely to require coordination of many types of service, including health, mental health and
addiction services, disability or other forms of public assistance (Baldwin, this volume), housing
support, and victim advocacy. Any social policy approach to this problem must include a
realistic appraisal of the cost and cost-effectiveness of rehabilitation services.
This case also raises philosophical and legal questions regarding responsibility, and
choice. Should a criminal case could be brought against the pimp, despite the patient’s refusal
to cooperate, based on her initial “excited utterance” in the emergency room and her
documented injuries? Would such an “evidence-based” prosecution be in her best interest, or
would it further disempower or endanger her? Given the extreme degree of coercive control
exercised by pimps, and the general reluctance of their victims to testify against them, is such
paternalistic intervention ever warranted (Buzawa & Buzawa, 2003; Epstein, 1999; Mills, 1998)?
Finally, most people who attempt to leave prostitution are also very poor and lack basic
education or the rudimentary job skills that might enable them to support themselves
independently. They also frequently lack the social skills required for participation in ordinary,
non-exploitative relationships. The code of “getting over,” although it might conceivably be
adaptive within highly stigmatized social groups, is completely maladaptive for a person
attempting to enter into the “straight” world. A structured peer support group may offer the
most meaningful opportunity for the survivor to develop a new identity as a valued and
responsible member of a community (see, for example, Carter, this volume; Rabinovitch, this
volume; Hotaling et. al., this volume).
Case Example Five
Kevin, a 21 year old man, had escaped from his abusive family at the age of 17 by
running away to live with an older man whom he met in an internet chat room. At first, the
relationship seemed very romantic, and Kevin was “happier than I had ever been in my life.”
Gradually, however, he became disillusioned, as his partner began to pressure him into
prostitution, threatening to throw him out of the house if he refused. Kevin became increasingly
frightened as his the men his partner brought home insisted on increasingly risky and painful
sexual practices. Finally, feeling lost and betrayed, he fled to a homeless shelter and sought
psychiatric treatment.
In the course of his recovery, Kevin moved into a rooming house, got a job at a fast-food
restaurant, and entered a program to get his high school diploma. Though he had succeeded in
getting safe, he complained that he was lonely and bored and acknowledged that he was
strongly tempted to return to“tricking.” He reported a dream in which he escaped from a swamp
filled with dangerous creatures, only to find himself all alone in a cold, antiseptic swimming pool.
It became apparent that Kevin had no idea how to make friends with people his own age, let
alone how to form an intimate relationship. He felt that he didn’t belong anywhere.
With his therapist’s encouragement, Kevin joined a group for male survivors of sexual
abuse. In this group he experienced a sense of belonging and felt understood by his peers, and
he was able to explore complicated issues such as confusion about his sexual orientation. He
also gained self-respect from the experience of being supportive to others. After some time in
the group, he began volunteering at an animal shelter, where he found that he could bond with
others who shared his concern for abandoned and mistreated animals.
These case vignettes suggest that the basic principles of trauma treatment-- establishing
safety, working through the trauma, reconnecting with a community--are potentially useful and
effective for survivors of prostitution. Many of the issues illustrated in these case examples are
already familiar to clinicians working with trauma survivors. Themes of secrecy, social
alienation and stigma are common to victims of many types of oppression, particularly those
forms that are socially condoned. Even seasoned clinicians, however, may be shocked to
discover the extent of prostitution in their own communities and horrified by the extreme
violence and degradation to which people in prostitution are subjected. The contagion of
trauma produces a range of predictable countertransference reactions that mirror the symptoms
of the posttraumatic disorders. Hyperarousal reactions may include heightened anxiety,
embarrassment, fascination, or even sexual excitement. Numbing reactions may include denial,
disgust, aversion and avoidance. These intense countertransference reactions have slowed
recognition of the problem of prostitution within the trauma field. Furthermore, clinicians are not
immune to the prejudices of the larger community. The dishonor attached to prostitution is so
profound that it affects all social interactions, including the therapy relationship.
This special issue of JTS is designed to raise awareness of prostitution among clinicians
and to foster public conversation on a subject that has hitherto largely been avoided. For the
three out of four clinicians who have already worked with survivors of prostitution, but have done
their work in isolation, this special issue is designed to build support and community. For the
one out of four who has not yet (knowingly) treated a patient with a history of prostitution, this
special issue is designed as preparation for an encounter that is very likely to happen sooner or
later. Clinicians who work with traumatized people have borne witness to many kinds of
atrocity; we are capable of facing this one, too, as long as we do not have to face it alone.
Amnesty International (1973). Report on Torture. New York: Farrar, Straus & Giroux.
Baldwin, MA (2003). Living in longing: Prostitution, trauma recovery, and public
assistance. Journal of Trauma Practice (in press).
Brownmiller, S (1975). Against Our Will: Men, Women, and Rape. New York: Simon &
Buzawa, ES & Buzawa, CG (2003). Domestic Violence: The Criminal Justice Response (Third
Edition). Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage.
Carter V (2003). Providing services to African-American prostituted women. Journal of Trauma
Practice (in press).
Coid J, Petruckevitch A, Feder G, Chung W-S, Richardson J, Moorey S (2001). Relation
between childhood sexual and physical abuse and risk of revictimisation in women: A cross-
sectional survey. The Lancet: 358; 450-454.
Epstein, D (1999). Effective intervention in domestic violence cases: Rethinking the role of
prosecutors, judges, and the court system. Yale Journal of Law and Feminism: 11; 3-50.
Goldstein, J. (2001). War and Gender: How Gender Shapes the War System and Vice Versa.
New York: Cambridge University Press.
Haugaard, L (1997). Declassified Army and CIA Manuals Used in Latin America: An Analysis of
Their Content. Washington, D.C.: Latin America Working Group.
Hedin U-C & Manson SA(2003). The importance of supportive relationships among women
leaving prostitution. Journal of Trauma Practice (in press).
Herman JL (1992). Trauma and Recovery. New York: Basic Books.
Hotaling N, Burris A, Johnson J, Bird YM (2003). Been there done that: A peer leadership
model among prostitution survivors. Journal of Trauma Practice (in press).
Johnson, C (2000). Blowback: The Costs and Consequences of American Empire. New York:
Metropolitan Books.
Koss, M (1987). Hidden rape: Sexual aggression and victimization in a national sample of
students of higher education. In AW Burgess (Ed): Rape and Sexual Assault, vol. 2. New York:
Garland; 3-26.
Lovelace L & McGrady, M (1980). Ordeal. Secaucus, NJ: Citadel.
MacKinnon, CA (2001). Sex Equality. NY: Foundation Press. Chapter 10.
Mills, L (1998). The Heart of Intimate Abuse: New Interventions in Child Welfare, Criminal
Justice, and Health Settings. New York: Springer.
Nelson-Pallmeyer, J (1997). School of Assassins: The Case for Closing the School of the
Americas and for Fundamentally Changing U.S. Foreign Policy. Maryknoll, NY: Orbis Books.
Patterson, O (1982). Slavery and Social Death: A Comparative Study. Cambridge, MA: Harvard
University Press.
Putnam FW, Guroff JJ, Silberman EK The clinical phenomenology of multiple
personality disorder: Review of 100 recent cases. Journal of Clinical Psychiatry 47; 285-293.
Rabinovitch, J (2003). PEERS: The prostitutes empowerment, education and resource society.
Journal of Trauma Practice (in press).
Ross C & Farley M (2003). Dissociation among women in prostitution. Journal of Trauma
Practice (in press).
Russell, DEH (1984). Sexual Exploitation. Beverly Hills, CA: Sage.
Russell, DEH (1986). The Secret Trauma: Incest in the Lives of Girls and Women. New York:
Basic Books.
Stark C & Hodgson C (2003). Sister oppressions: A comparison of wife-battering and
prostitution. Journal of Trauma Practice (in press).
van der Kolk BA, Pelcovitz D, Roth S, Mandel F, McFarlane A, Herman JL (1996). Dissociation,
affect dysregulation and somatization: The complexity of adaptation to trauma. American
Journal of Psychiatry; 153 (Festschrift Supplement): 83-93.
... 49). As such conditions are commonly found in relationships between sex traffickers and their victims (Herman, 2003;Spidel et al., 2007;Stark & Hodgson, 2003), it is unsurprising that trauma bonding occurs. ...
A trauma bond is an emotional attachment between an abuser and victim. Trauma bonds in sex trafficking compel victims to submit to continued exploitation and protect the trafficker. This scoping review examines trauma bonds in sex trafficking situations, its conceptualizations, and key characteristics. Ten databases were searched using sex trafficking AND trauma bonding–related terms; sex trafficking AND Stockholm syndrome, attachment, coercion, and manipulation. Articles were included if they featured trauma bonding, were published in English after 2013, or featured sex trafficking victims or traffickers in a Western country. Fifteen articles were included. The features of trauma bonding identified in these articles were (1) imbalance of power that favors trafficker, (2) traffickers’ deliberate use of positive and negative interactions, (3) victim’s gratitude for positive interactions and self-blame for the negative, and (4) victim’s internalization of perpetrator’s view. We also identified four aspects related to trauma bonding: (1) prior trauma made victims vulnerable, (2) victim’s feelings of love remained even after exiting trafficking, (3) love is why victims do not prosecute traffickers, and (4) traffickers’ intentional cultivation of the trauma bond. No article indicated how trauma bonds could be severed and replaced with healthy attachments. These findings reveal the need for practitioners and law enforcement and criminal justice professionals to address trauma bonding in both trafficking and posttrafficking situations. The findings also represent potential targets for urgently needed interventions that promote the replacement of trauma bonds with healthy attachments.
Preventing child sex trafficking remains an urgent concern for public health and criminal justice professionals. Using crime script analysis, this study identified a typology of child sex traffickers (CSTs). Data for this study were drawn from 78 child sex trafficking cases involving 54 CSTs and 48 victims of commercial sexual exploitation of children (CSEC) investigated by the Child Protective Investigation Unit in a predominately rural and suburban county. Using a decision tree model, we identified subtypes of child sex traffickers (CSTs) and explored patterns and variation in the victim recruitment tactics used by these subtypes during three phases of the victim recruitment crime script – find, groom, and exploit. Seven types of CSTs emerged from the cases: Peer/Acquaintance, Organized Crime, Family Abuser, Romantic Coercive Conman, “Mate Crime” Predator, Opportunistic, and Cyber traffickers. Both shared and unique tactics were identified such as social media and peer recruitment to find victims, promises, and gifts to groom victims, and threats and violence to ensnare victims. Based upon the study findings, we recommend specific prevention strategies and education themes related to the various at-risk situational scenarios and documented tactics used by CSTs at each phase of victim recruitment.
This chapter describes relevant theories and proposed models for understanding the nature of traumatization that results from the experience of sex trafficking, including a focus on trauma and gender violence. The discussion focuses on complex posttraumatic stress disorder (cPTSD), sociocultural theories of traumatization, and the relevance of intimate partner violence (IPV) and the battered woman syndrome (BWS) to understanding the experience of sex trafficking survivors.KeywordsSex traffickingVictimSurvivorTraumatizationcPTSDComplex posttraumatic stress disorder
This chapter will comprise an organizing framework for trauma-informed practice with survivors of sex trafficking, guided by the three-phrase model for treating complex trauma, with an emphasis on safety and practical considerations, therapeutic relationship, skills acquisition, and considerations for trauma processing. Clinical recommendations for evidence-based practice will include an emphasis on the importance of interprofessional collaboration and service provision when working with this population.
This paper proposes a distinction between fantasy and imagination, and endeavors to investigate its interconnectedness with trauma, as well as its implications to the therapeutic encounter with the psychic areas of trauma, dissociation, and repetition. Whereas imagination is an active phenomenon which resides within the dialectic of inner and outer worlds, increases psychic movement and works in the service of linking self-states within the subject and with his or her fellow subjects, fantasy is a phenomenon which is caused by trauma and isolates the subject both from his core self as well as from any sense of reality and connection with others. The paper offers a detailed exploration of these two modes of being and experiencing and of the psychic structures which comprise them, and demonstrates the ways by which the movement between imagination and fantasy, each with its own unique qualities, can enable patient and analyst to encounter, together, the experiences which were traumatized and dissociated. The clinical implications are discussed, and a detailed vignette is presented in order to demonstrate the elusive ways in which fantasy acts between patient and therapist in an effort to resuscitate deadened parts of the patient’s traumatized psychic life and bring them to the world of imagination and human connection.
Full-text available
This article assesses the moral arguments presented in the contemporary debate on the legalization of prostitution. The first section analyzes the positions that defend legal regulation as the best alternative to face the problems that this activity entails. The second section discusses abolitionist arguments whose purpose is to support an eradication policy since this practice rests on a gender injustice. Finally, the need to consider both moral arguments and empirical data are discussed for determining the best policy for the treatment of prostitution.
Background : Growing evidence suggests that emotion dysregulation may be predictive of posttraumatic stress disorder (PTSD) severity, with emotional non-acceptance, lack of counter strategies, impulse control deficits, and lack of emotional awareness all being positive predictors. However, findings have been mixed. This may be due to no previous study examining the association between emotion dysregulation and PTSD severity with shame, a maintaining factor of PTSD, as a potential moderator. Methods : The present study examined the relationship between emotion dysregulation, shame, and PTSD severity among 78 male combat veterans (mean age = 42.19) upon their admission to a residential combat PTSD program. Results : Results demonstrated that shame and all facets of emotion dysregulation (except lack of emotional awareness & clarity) were positively associated with PTSD severity. Shame moderated the relationship between lack of emotional awareness and strategies. Among those at or below the sample mean on shame, lack of access to strategies was a positive predictor of PTSD severity. Comparatively, among those with high levels of shame, emotional awareness predicted greater PTSD severity, while among those with low levels of shame, emotional awareness predicted lower PTSD severity. Limitations : Limitations included reliance on self-report questionnaires and an all-male sample. Conclusions : Thus, emotion dysregulation may only predict PTSD severity among those reporting lower levels of shame, suggesting the importance of addressing shame as well as emotion dysregulation deficits among those with PTSD. Moreover, emotional awareness may be either a risk or protective factor depending on levels of shame.
Full-text available
Objective: Introduction: Engaging in sex, which is obligatory associated with the extraordinary risks of harm to their own safety and physical health, can be considered as one of the variants of self-destruction. The aim is to analyze the leading descriptors and predictors of self-destructive behavior among female sex workers, on the basis of which to propose measures for their psycho-correction. Patients and methods: Materials and methods: The main group of the study was 135 women - female sex workers, a comparative group of 50 women who had no relation to such activities. The research methods were clinical-psychological, socio-demographic, psycho diagnostic, mathematical-statistical. Results: Results: Suicidal mood was investigated as a descriptor of self-destructive behavior in female sex workers. Features of suicidal ideas and the basis of committing suicide are revealed. The motivating emotions of a suicidal act are shame, anger and resentment. Psychological protection as a mechanism for maintaining risky sexual behavior has been studied. Identified destructive forms of primitive level mechanisms of psychological defense. It was revealed that in women engaged in prostitution the overall viability is not sufficiently formed, mainly due to the low level of inclusion. The presence of sacrifice in the form of increased propensity to active victim behavior has been established. An increased tendency toward an active type of victim behavior has been established. Leading individual psychological and behavioral patterns in the genesis of self-destructive behavior in female sex workers have been identified and its clinical and psychological options have been singled out. Based on the data obtained, a program of measures for differentiated psycho-correction of self-destructive behavior among female sex workers was developed. Conclusion: Conclusions: As a result of work, the conceptualization of occupation of prostitution as a self-destructive behavior is grounded. The isolation of its specific pathognomonic psycho-emotional, individual psychological and behavioral features, made it possible to propose effective measures of its psycho-correction and of psycho-processing.
Background: Important unresolved questions remain concerning the specific vulnerabilities and intervention needs of female adolescents who experience commercial sexual exploitation of children (CSEC), when compared to other highly vulnerable female adolescents. Objective: This study aimed to assess differences in the level of post-traumatic symptoms reported by those who experienced CSEC during adolescence and those who did not. Participants and setting: The study used longitudinal data collected from 125 French-speaking female adolescents who were placed in residential centers between the ages 12 and 17 years. Method: Post-traumatic symptoms were assessed at Time 1 and Time 6, while CSEC involvement was assessed at Times 1-5. One-way ANOVAs were performed to inspect differences in the level of post-traumatic symptoms at Time 6 between the participants who reported CSEC during adolescence (n = 70; 56.0%) and those with no history of CSEC (n = 55; 44.0%). Hierarchical regressions examined the effects of CESC while controlling for age, immigration status, child sexual abuse, and post-traumatic symptoms reported at Time 1. Results: CSEC during adolescence predicted higher levels of general post-traumatic symptoms, anxious arousal, intrusive experiences, defensive avoidance, and dissociation. Conclusions: CSEC experiences intensify the existing vulnerabilities to traumatic sequelae that characterize female adolescents who are placed in residential care.
Introduction: Cognitive limitations are a serious health and social problem, which concerns elderly people. Effective prevention and treatment of cognitive dysfunction is one of the challenges of modern medicine. There is not enough consistent data in the literature to indicate to indicate the relationship between various clinical and demographic factors with cognitive functioning in different age ranges. The aim: To analyze clinical and demographic predictors of mild cognitive impairment by age group. Material and methods: The analysis included 817 participants (669 with normal cognitive function and 148 people with MCI). The evaluation of the level of depressive symptoms was measured by the Short Form Geriatric Depression Scale. All participants were screened for cognitive functioning using the Mini-Mental State Examination and Addenbrooke’s Cognitive Examination-III. Different cognitive domains were evaluated with different neuropsychological tools: the Rey Auditory Verbal Learning test, Clock Drawing test, Verbal Fluency test, Digit Span Test and Trail Making test. Results: It has been shown that independently associated with MCI ware age (OR = 1.09, 95% CI: 1.05-1.13) and level of education (OR = 0.75, 95% CI: 0.69-0.81). Depending on the age, it turned out that in the younger MCI group, age, education and depression were significant, and the age and level of education were significant in the older MCI group. Conclusions: The identification of cognitive dysfunctions is an important element of the diagnostic and therapeutic process.
This paper describes the philosophy of PEERS (Prostitutes’ Empowerment, Education and Resource Society) in Victoria, British Columbia, Canada. PEERS was developed, managed, and staffed by prostitution survivors. PEERS’ programs are culturally relevant, responding to the disproportionately high participation of Aboriginal women and youth in prostitution in Canada. PEERS offers services to those in the sex trade regardless of whether they wish to leave or stay in prostitution. Eighty-six percent of the people who use PEERS services eventually leave the sex trade and move on to further training, education or other employment. The paper further discusses the need for community liaisons, and the triumph as well as the stress of public disclosure of prostitution in one’s life.
The authors summarize four studies on dissociation among women in prostitution, and discuss clinical aspects of the relationship between trauma, dissociation and prostitution. Dissociative disorders are common among those in escort, street, massage, strip club and brothel prostitution, and are frequently accompanied by posttraumatic stress disorder, depression, and substance abuse. These in turn are linked to high rates of childhood physical and sexual abuse, and to violent victimization while in prostitution. The existing data suggest that almost all who are in prostitution suffer from at least one of the following types of disorders; dissociative, posttraumatic, mood or substance abuse. Further research to refine and replicate these findings is warranted.