ArticlePublisher preview available

Frontier No More: International Consulting Skills as Necessary Minimal Competencies for Consulting Psychologists

American Psychological Association
Consulting Psychology Journal
Authors:
To read the full-text of this research, you can request a copy directly from the author.

Abstract

This article identifies and comments on several themes that derive from the Special Issue on International Organizational Consulting: Consulting Psychology Goes Global. Six issues are identified that are intended to help integrate the Special Issue articles and to extend the four factors each article addressed: (1) how can we generalize from cases to actionable propositions?; (2) does corporate culture trump national culture?; (3) Is country an individual difference variable?; (4) are there international metacompetencies that consulting psychologists must know?; (5) who or what is the ethical arbiter in international contexts?; and (6) how can international organizational consulting psychology skills become routinized?
FRONTIER NO MORE: INTERNATIONAL
CONSULTING SKILLS AS NECESSARY
MINIMAL COMPETENCIES FOR
CONSULTING PSYCHOLOGISTS
Rodney L. Lowman
CSPP/Alliant International University–San Diego and Lowman & Richardson,
Consulting Psychologists, San Diego, California
This article identifies and comments on several themes that derive from the Special Issue on
International Organizational Consulting: Consulting Psychology Goes Global. Six issues are
identified that are intended to help integrate the Special Issue articles and to extend the four
factors each article addressed: (1) how can we generalize from cases to actionable proposi-
tions?; (2) does corporate culture trump national culture?; (3) Is country an individual
difference variable?; (4) are there international metacompetencies that consulting psychol-
ogists must know?; (5) who or what is the ethical arbiter in international contexts?; and (6)
how can international organizational consulting psychology skills become routinized?
Keywords: internationalizing, global consulting, multiculturalism, guidelines
This Special Issue on International Organizational Consulting: Consulting Psychology Goes Global
brings into sharp focus the reality that the world has dramatically changed over the last half century
along with demands that consulting psychologists move forward with it. In this brief article, I
comment upon and attempt to extend Cooper’s (this issue, pp. 243–249) four overarching themes,
namely, the critical importance of the cultural context, worldwide organization development,
national and regional economic development, and the role of consultation in facilitating global social
change.
Although the widespread preoccupation with internationalizing in recent years may seem to
have occurred suddenly, the precursors of change have actually been percolating slowly in prodro-
mal stages for many decades. In the United States, for example, the revolutionary changes associated
with race, gender, sexual orientation, and age arguably have paved the way for understanding
diversity in its broader context of internationalism. It is a small— or at least smaller—step to taking
internationalism seriously after battles have been fought for basic rights for racial and sexual
minorities, women, and those with physical disabilities, laying the ground work for acceptance of
diversity in several of its many forms.
Still, the driving forces for organizational consulting psychology (CP) going global is not so
much an imperative to take human rights to the next level as it has been economic and technological
I thank Special Issue Editor Stewart Cooper and an anonymous reviewer for their helpful comments on a prior
draft of this article.
Correspondence concerning this article should be addressed to Rodney L. Lowman, Organizational
Psychology Programs, CSPP/Alliant International University–San Diego, 10455 Pomerado Road, San Diego,
CA 92131. E-mail: rlowman@alliant.edu
Consulting Psychology Journal: Practice and Research © 2013 American Psychological Association
2012, Vol. 64, No. 4, 338–343 1065-9293/13/$12.00 DOI: 10.1037/a0031676
338
This document is copyrighted by the American Psychological Association or one of its allied publishers.
This article is intended solely for the personal use of the individual user and is not to be disseminated broadly.
... Researchers and practitioners need to know "...what kinds of interventions work under optimal, university-based, research-laboratory-style conditions... [and are]...palatable, feasible, durable, affordable, and sustainable in real-world settings..." (Jensen, Hoagwood, & Trickett, 1999, p. 207). Lowman (2012) argued that psychologists working within a consultation framework not only required well-developed knowledge, but also had an important role as scientist-practitioners in linking practice with research and theory. Relatedly, Newell & Newman (2014) argue that if applied psychological practice is guided by scientific research, then training (including training in consultation) should be the same. ...
... The fact that many organizations, both large and small, are international in scope presents significant challenges for the experienced consultant-even more so for the newly minted consultant who has to consider both his or her consulting and international inexperience. Lowman (2012) has even suggested international consulting skills as minimal competencies for consultants because "specific locations even in isolated and would-be quiescent organizations in rural areas can still experience the impact of having to contend with internationally influenced issues" (p. 339). ...
Article
Full-text available
Many clinical psychologists have been finding that consulting is a rewarding, interesting, and challenging undertaking, often changing careers to become full-time consultants. However, the role of the consultant is, in a number of ways, different than that of the clinician, requiring a dramatic change in perspective. This article by 2 consultants who made the leap discusses many of these differences. We begin by discussing some of the steps in preparing to be a consultant. In this context, we stress self-assessment and ethical considerations, along with a suggestion for acquiring basic and advanced training and note educational opportunities for the psychologist making the transition to consulting. A review of different consulting settings leads to a discussion of reframing basic assumptions to which clinical psychologists are subject. An orientation to consulting suggests that 2 topics, organizational systems and culture, can contribute to the transition process and assist in the reframing process. A table compares some issues faced by clinicians and consultants.
... Without such training, school psychologists will continue to operate in a direct service model. Lowman (2012), in a special CPJ issue on international organizational consulting, suggested that international organizational consulting should become less noted "for its exceptionalness and more a common part of practice and education for practice" (p. 341). ...
Article
Full-text available
Over the last decade, consultation services conducted by school psychologists have been thriving in many schools, demonstrating a paradigm shift from direct services based largely on assessment of students. The literature supporting this change is reviewed. However, the lack of consistent training and supervision of practitioners in consultation skills is a cause for concern. Among the skills needed are team leadership, organizational knowledge, and relationship building. A second shift is that educational consultation is developing a global presence, as is organizational consultation in other areas.
Article
Full-text available
Introduction. The paper rationalizes the urgency of creating a modern university monitoring model which analyses the development of practice-oriented competences of a future educational psychologist. The construction of practice-oriented competences on an interdisciplinary competence basis is fast becoming a key instrument in education. Of much importance is the strategy when the integrated organization of comprehensive monitoring procedures emerges from scientific and methodological resources. The review of modern ideas plays a pivotal role in our research. We describe the modern university monitoring model as a system of assessment and control procedures ensuring the psychic professional and personal developments of future educational psychologist. Practice-oriented competences play a critical role in future effective professional activity. The purpose of the paper is to characterize the structure and content of the practice-oriented competences of future educational psychologist, to justify and reveal the model of monitoring competences' development with the help of the example of a Russian university. Materials and methods. Data were collected using the monitoring models that function in modern practices of Russian universities. The study began with the qualitative review of specific scientific literature devoted to the problem of practice-oriented competences of educa-tional psychologist. The main method is analytical description. We rated various experiences of assessing the competences' development describing the design of their structure and content, as well as justifying the model of their monitoring in Russian universities. Results. In our research we provide much suggestive evidence to substantiate the list of practice-oriented competences of future educational psychologist. Our interesting findings are the structure and the content of the competences under analysis. The most meaningful finding is a modern theoretical monitoring model which is critical for an insightful analysis of practice-oriented competences, as well as the scientific and methodological resources of its implementation in Russian universities. One of the most significant achievements to emerge from the study is the set of evaluation tools and monitoring procedures which ensures its successful approbation in one of Russian universities. Discussion. Multiple analysis revealed that the adequacy of assessing practice-oriented competences of the future educational psychologist emerges from a set of sufficient evaluation tools. The present study identified that the monitoring procedures allow to describe step-by-step the state of the competencies under analysis, as well as their dynamics. Overall, the study strengthens the idea of improving the monitoring system of practice-oriented competences' development in Russian universities. The study also outlines the prospects of the monitoring system's implementation. Conclusion. The following conclusions can be drawn from the present study. To prepare skilled educational psychologist with high professional qualification it is critical to develop the set of tasks to identify the list of practice-oriented competences. The structure and content of the tasks, as well as the development of assessment tools play a crucial role in a stage-by-stage application of monitoring procedures in Russian universities. The findings will be of interest for professionals who are open to innovation and development.
Chapter
What does it take to be a successful global consultant, and how can we develop successful global consultants? This chapter attempts to answer these two questions by drawing upon our personal experiences of global consulting in industrial/organizational (I/O) psychology as well as relevant research on this topic. Although an I/O consultant may provide consulting services and/or work on applied projects in many areas, we present a competency model for global consultants based on our past work, accumulated experience, and collective knowledge. From the ten competencies in our model, three core competencies consistently appear as essential for success in almost any consulting role, whether it be global or not: managing time and resources, teamwork, and applied problem solving.
Article
Full-text available
This article presents an overview of the ethical and ethically related legal dilemmas faced by organizational consultants in global environments. It describes the critical factors that make the practice of global consulting complex, ambiguous, and challenging. It offers recommendations as to organizational strategies, guiding principles, and competencies that can help global consultants better navigate the ethical maze their clients face, or that they themselves face as they work with diverse cultures and organizations. We analyze the root cause of failures by global organizational management consultants and consider the difficulty of determining the right approach for all stakeholders within the broader global system.
Article
Full-text available
This case concerns 2 high potential leaders from vastly different cultures who came together as supervisor and supervisee as part of a large corporate merger of 2 American global companies. The case recounts the rocky start of their relationship and the process, facilitated initially by better understanding the cultures of their respective upbringings that ultimately led to their finding their way to having an effective working relationship. Societal cultural dimensions from well-known cross-cultural research served as a helpful framework and tools for helping this dyadic team communicate more effectively and better understand each other. (PsycINFO Database Record (c) 2013 APA, all rights reserved)
Article
Full-text available
This article synthesizes information presented by the other authors in this Special Issue with my own research and experience to address issues in the field of international organizational consulting psychology. This synthesis describes the complexity of the field; sets forth major skills, knowledge, and attitudes necessary to be effective as an international consulting psychologist; and discusses the future of the field.
Article
Full-text available
This article examines the impact of assumptions that consultants, coaches, and trainers (CCTs) make when consulting with clients in cultures that are unfamiliar to them. Three groups of assumptions are examined: (1) assumptions that CCTs make about their clients and the societies in which they are embedded, including (a) culture and customs, (b) organizational structure and size, maturity of national economies, organizational systems and subsystems, and individuals, (c) religion, population, and generational demographics, gender, and language, and (d) national economic and political systems; (2) assumptions about the relationship and expectations between CCTs and their clients; and (3) assumptions about effective leadership, learning, and political and economic systems. Assumptions in the first group refer to areas of ignorance and misunderstanding about culture, customs, and economic and political systems, and assumptions in the second and third groups refer to differences in expectations about the relationship between CCTs and their clients as well disagreements about the effectiveness of divergent beliefs about learning and political and economic systems. The impact of CCTs believing that these assumptions are true without testing them or, worse, not being aware that they are working with untested assumptions is explored. Case examples are included.
Article
Full-text available
This article describes a number of characteristics of contemporary international organizational consulting and training from the experiential perspective of American consultants. Key factors and themes in international organizational consulting are described. Lessons learned from 30 years of experience are elaborated. Emphasis is on the role of corporate culture in non-U.S. nations as it relates to multicultural/international awareness in training high-performing transcultural executives. Issues in assuring the continuing demand for consulting services by organizational consulting psychologists are also identified.
Article
Full-text available
This Special Issue of the Consulting Psychology Journal: Practice and Research on “International Organizational Consulting: Consulting Psychology Goes Global” provides highlights of experienced practitioner consulting psychologists' work in a variety of multinational contexts. A brief description of the context for the Special Issue is provided, followed by an outline of the articles the special issue contains. Questions addressed by the articles include the following: how do the assumptions of organizational consulting psychology as taught and practiced in the United States need to be changed when applied to individual, group, and organizational consultation in other countries? Are there issues specific to international organizational consulting psychology different from those addressed by existing cross-cultural psychology findings? How do practicing consulting psychologists learn how to negotiate international consulting projects from start to finish? What kind of overarching templates are useful when entering a new country of international practice?
Article
Full-text available
This article identifies issues relevant to the scientist-practitioner model espoused by consulting psychology. It asks what it means to be a scientist-practitioner in more than aspirational or superficial terms and notes the frequent gap between science and practice and between practice and science. These gaps, it is argued, call for changed behavior on the part of both practitioners and of researchers. It is argued that the scientific-practitioner model can be differentiating in a highly competitive area of practice, that science can make its research more relevant to practice, and that practitioners have an important role to play in assuring the linkage of practice with research and theory. A recent publication (Nowack, K. M., & Mashihi, S., 2012) is used to illustrate a positive example of the scientist-practitioner model in which practice recommendations derive from scientific findings.
Chapter
his chapter addresses multicultural and international issues in the professional practice faced by psychologists of organizational development and change (ODC) as well as the role and responsibility of psychologists who are not ODC professionals to address the need for multicultural and international changes in the institutions in which they work (see also Volume 1, Chapter 25, this handbook). (PsycINFO Database Record (c) 2017 APA, all rights reserved)