Article

Disability, Workplace Characteristics and Job Satisfaction

Authors:
To read the full-text of this research, you can request a copy directly from the author.

Abstract

Purpose Previous research has shown that individuals with disabilities are likely to be less satisfied with their jobs as compared to the able‐bodied. None of them explain the reasons for this difference. The purpose of this paper is to contend that this might be due to certain factors such as discrimination, harassment, or other conditions at the workplace. It might also be due to lower relative incomes. Design/methodology/approach The paper uses nationally representative Canadian data and attempts to account for the low levels of job satisfaction among Canadians with disabilities. Findings The results show that when certain workplace characteristics are introduced into the model, individuals with a mobility disability are no longer likely to be less satisfied as compared to individuals without disabilities. However, the negative effect for certain other types of disabilities remains, though the magnitude decreases. It is concluded that absence of assistive technology or employer accommodations might be the reason for the remaining satisfaction difference between those with disabilities and the able‐bodied. Originality/value This paper adds to the existing literature on job satisfaction by studying the relationship between disability, workplace characteristics and job satisfaction.

No full-text available

Request Full-text Paper PDF

To read the full-text of this research,
you can request a copy directly from the author.

... With two exceptions all studies used a level of significance of 0.05, considering findings with p-values below 0.5 as significant. The two studies used a significance level of 0.1 [46,47]. ...
... Most studies focusing on outcomes in the well-being cluster studied job [46,47,52,54,57,58], work [59] or needs [48,60] satisfaction. The other outcomes include positive experiences (resilience [52], self-esteem [50], work engagement [61], social integration [62], and thriving at work [55]) and negative experiences (emotional exhaustion [50], presenteeism [52] (1)) experiences of EWD. ...
... The study of Novak and Rogan [62] found positive relationships between conditions of contact and workplace culture on the one hand, and well-being (social integration) of EWD on the other. Workplace relations and organizational culture can also affect job satisfaction negatively: through discrimination [47,57], harassment and poor interpersonal relationships [47]. ...
Article
Full-text available
Purpose This review and synthesis aims to answer the following question: what do existing empirical studies tell us about the relationship between organizational practices and their outcomes in terms of the performance, well-being and sustainable employment of employees with disabilities? Methods This review builds on a scoping review of empirical studies of organizational practices aimed at the hiring and retention of people with disabilities. It focuses on a specific group of studies identified in the scoping review: studies examining outcomes of organizational practices for employees with disabilities (EWD). Additional selection criteria were: (1) studies focused on the performance, well-being and sustainable employment of EWD; (2) studies used quantitative methods; and (3) studies were published in high-quality journals. This resulted in 27 articles. Results Three clusters of organizational practices received most attention in the articles: workplace relations and organizational culture; accommodations; and leadership. The studies found significant positive and negative relationships between practices in these clusters and the three outcomes mentioned above. These empirical findings were supported by the theoretical perspectives used in the studies. Although diverse, most of these theoretical perspectives share their focus on interactions between individuals and their (work) environment. Discussion We recommend that future research into the outcomes of organizational practices for EWD should be both broader (examining more clusters of practices and their outcomes for people with and without disabilities) and deeper (examining similar practices-outcome combinations in different contexts). This will increase our understanding of what practices work for whom under what circumstances.
... 임금의 절대적 수준뿐만 아니 라 상대적 임금(relative income)도 직무만족과 연관이 있다 (Clark & Oswald, 1996). 상대적 임 금은 근로자의 인적특성과 직무특성을 고려할 때 평균적으로 받을 수 있는 임금을 기준으로 근로자가 실제로 받는 임금의 수준을 의미하 며, 직무만족과 유의한 연관성을 가지고 있다 (Clark & Oswald, 1996;Sloane & Williams, 2000 (Artz, 2010;Kim & Cho, 2013;Uppal, 2005 (Clark, 1997;Lee, Yoon, Choi, & Yoon, 2019;Pagán-Rodríguez, 2015;Sloane & Williams, 2000 (Bae, 2008;Clark & Oswald, 1996). 근로자의 나이도 직무만족과 연관성이 있으며, 나이가 많을수 록 직무만족도가 높은 경향이 있다 (Lee, Yoon, Choi, & Yoon, 2019). ...
... 근로자의 나이도 직무만족과 연관성이 있으며, 나이가 많을수 록 직무만족도가 높은 경향이 있다 (Lee, Yoon, Choi, & Yoon, 2019). 교육수준의 경우 학력이 높을수록 직무만족도가 높은 경향이 있으며, 이는 학력이 높을수록 소득과 전문성이 높은 직업을 갖는 경향으로 설명된다 (Bae, 2008;Uppal, 2005 (Colella, DeNisi, & Varma, 1997;Stone & Colella, 1996) (Kim & Ko, 2012;Markel & Barclay, 2009;Song, 2012), 전반적인 삶의 만족에도 부정적인 영향을 미치는 것으로 나타났다 (Kim, 2013;Yeum & Lee, 2014 (Blinder, 1973;Oaxaca, 1973 (Colella et al., 1997;Stone & Colella, 1996). Stone과 Colella(1996) Brooks, 2019;Uppal, 2005). ...
... 교육수준의 경우 학력이 높을수록 직무만족도가 높은 경향이 있으며, 이는 학력이 높을수록 소득과 전문성이 높은 직업을 갖는 경향으로 설명된다 (Bae, 2008;Uppal, 2005 (Colella, DeNisi, & Varma, 1997;Stone & Colella, 1996) (Kim & Ko, 2012;Markel & Barclay, 2009;Song, 2012), 전반적인 삶의 만족에도 부정적인 영향을 미치는 것으로 나타났다 (Kim, 2013;Yeum & Lee, 2014 (Blinder, 1973;Oaxaca, 1973 (Colella et al., 1997;Stone & Colella, 1996). Stone과 Colella(1996) Brooks, 2019;Uppal, 2005). 기존 연구의 방법 과는 달리 본 연구는 매개분석을 이용하였으 며, 이 방법은 변수들 간의 이론적인 연관성 을 연구하는데 더 적합한 방법으로 여겨진다 (Baron & Kenny, 1986;Hayes, 2017 & Choi, 2017;Choi & Yeum, 2019;Han, 2020;Jeon, 2020;Joo & Han, 2010;Jun, Nam, & Ryu, 2011;Kang & Lim, 2017;Kim, 2011;Kim, 2013;Kim, 2017;Kim & Ko, 2012;Kim, Park, & Kim, 2014;Lee, 2009;Lee, 2014;Lee, 2018;Lee & Lee, 2007;Lee & Seo, 2014;Lee & Shin, 2019;Park, Hu, & Jung, 2011;Park & Kim, 2017;Park, Kim, & Kang, 2010;Park, Lee, & Lee, 2013;Park & Yang, 2013;Song, 2012;Yeum, Kim, & Baek, 2013;Yeum & Lee, 2014 ...
Article
Full-text available
Despite increasing interest among researchers in the job satisfaction of disabled employees, surprisingly little attention has been directed to the difference in job satisfaction between disabled and non-disabled employees in Korea. This research intends to understand the levels of job satisfaction between employees with and without disability. Another important goal of the current research is to understand which job characteristics can explain the difference in job satisfaction between disabled and non-disabled employees. This paper analyzed Korean Labor and Income Panel Study (KLIPS) data collected in 2018. The result showed that disabled paid workers’ job satisfaction was lower than that of non-disabled workers. Mediation tests indicated that the difference in job satisfaction can be explained by several job properties such as lower monthly income, fewer fringe benefits, mismatch between job and skill, and greater proportion of part-time workers of disabled (vs. non-disabled) employees.
... According to Kampkötter (2017), some workers (e.g. with disabilities) may suffer restrictions in how they organise their work and perform their tasks and obligations, which contribute to reducing significantly their levels of job satisfaction. Focusing on workers with disabilities, Uppal (2005) finds that these groups of workers are very concerned with how much they earn as compared to the earnings of other individuals with similar characteristics. If we apply this idea to our case of performance appraisal and follow the foundations of the Equity Theory, we may argue that, for example, the presence of rigid rules and inflexible procedures, excessive bureaucracy, un-trained supervisors, tangible and intangible barriers, and inadequate information systems may lead to a sense of unfair treatment for all workers. ...
... Overall and consistent with the previous literature on job satisfaction and disability (e.g. McAfee and McNaughton 1997;Burke 1999;Renaud 2002;Uppal 2005;Schur et al. 2009;Pagan and Malo 2009;Pagan 2011Pagan , 2014, we find that workers with disabilities (both males and females) have lower levels of job satisfaction as compared to workers without disabilities. For males, the overall job satisfaction differential is 1.6 points, whereas for ...
... Firstly, we have used the test proposed by Verbeek and Nijman (1992) for fixed-effects models in order to test the existence of a problem of selectivity in our estimations. To do this, these authors suggest the inclusion in Equation (1) Turning to the econometric results shown in Table 2, as we expected, the coefficient on the variable "disabled" is negative and significant at the 1% level for the male and female samples (and again statistically equal according to a test of equality of coefficients), providing support for the previous studies of Burke (1999), Renaud (2002), Uppal (2005), Pagan and Malo (2009) and Pagan (2011Pagan ( , 2014. We also find that only those workers receiving performance appraisal with monetary effects have a premium in terms of job satisfaction as compared to those who are not subject to performance appraisal (reference category). ...
Article
Full-text available
This study analyses the effects of performance appraisal on the levels of job satisfaction reported by workers without and with disabilities (aged 16-64) by gender. Particularly, we are interested in investigating the impact of monetary rewards such as pay, bonuses, future raises and potential promotion on job satisfaction by disability status and checking differences by gender. Our data come from the German Socio-Economic Panel (SOEP) for the years 2004, 2008, 2011 and 2016. We estimate job satisfaction equations running a fixed effect "Probit Adapted OLS" model. We find that males with disabilities are less likely to be satisfied with their jobs when they are subject to performance appraisal with monetary effects (appraisals with both short and long-term rewards explain this result), whereas the opposite result is found for females with disabilities (in the case of receiving long-term rewards). We estimate the association of these performance appraisal schemes with recognition from superiors, and with their efforts, personal advances and pay, and we find a coherent pattern with previous results.
... 41 On the other hand, employed adults with VI have been reported to have low job satisfaction and work- related stress that may often lead to mental health issues, limited social functioning, and poor quality of life. [42][43][44][45] Underemployment is also reported to be high among adults with VI. 46 These diverging outcomes among employed persons with VI may, in-part, be reflective of the level of adequate integration of workplace accommodations and rehabilitation services for individuals with VI. 47,48 Accordingly, negative attitudes, stereotypes, and misconceptions about people with VI by employers as well as lack of freedom to make decisions, insufficient training, lack of recognition for accomplishments, limited opportunities to develop new skills, lack of support and adequate salary, which all lead to poor employment outcomes in this population have been recognized as factors that lead to heightened workrelated stress and low job satisfaction. 43,47,49 All these psychological factors, coupled with the lower socioeconomic position of adults with VI 50 may explain the high risk of CVD among employed adults with VI observed in our study of adults predominantly from LMICs. ...
... [42][43][44][45] Underemployment is also reported to be high among adults with VI. 46 These diverging outcomes among employed persons with VI may, in-part, be reflective of the level of adequate integration of workplace accommodations and rehabilitation services for individuals with VI. 47,48 Accordingly, negative attitudes, stereotypes, and misconceptions about people with VI by employers as well as lack of freedom to make decisions, insufficient training, lack of recognition for accomplishments, limited opportunities to develop new skills, lack of support and adequate salary, which all lead to poor employment outcomes in this population have been recognized as factors that lead to heightened workrelated stress and low job satisfaction. 43,47,49 All these psychological factors, coupled with the lower socioeconomic position of adults with VI 50 may explain the high risk of CVD among employed adults with VI observed in our study of adults predominantly from LMICs. Indeed, the considerable lack of services like assistive vision device use, vision rehabilitations and access to healthcare services have been reported to negatively impact adults with VI living in LMICs. ...
Article
Purpose The limited evidence for cardiovascular disease (CVD) among adults with vision impairment (VI) has often been from developed countries using self-reported VI. This study evaluated the association of objectively-determined VI with the risk of CVD among adults from low-, middle-, and high-income countries. Methods Data were from 32,268 adults aged 30–74 years without CVD or blindness from China, Ghana, India, Mexico, Russian Federation, South Africa, and the United States during 2007–2010. VI and severe VI was defined as presenting visual acuity worse than 6/18, and 6/60, respectively. The Framingham risk algorithm was used to estimate the risk for incident CVD. Logistic regression was used to calculate odds ratios (OR) and 95% confidence intervals. Results The mean age of participants was 46.4 years, with half of them being women (49.3%). The age-adjusted prevalence of VI ranged from 1.1% (United States) to 14.2% (South Africa) while severe VI ranged from 0.4% (United States) to 4.5% (Ghana). In models adjusting for country, sociodemographic factors, waist girth, healthcare use, activities of daily living and other health-related factors, VI was associated with CVD risk ≥ 10% (OR = 1.69, 95% CI: 1.22–2.36). This observed association was largely consistent across countries (p = 0.119). The observed CVD risk was similar among adults with moderate or severe VI (OR = 0.95, 95% CI: 0.50–1.83). CVD risk was higher among adults with VI who were <65 years old (OR = 1.89, 95% CI: 1.36–2.63) or were employed (OR = 2.24, 95% CI: 1.58–3.16). Conclusions This cross-national study shows that individuals with VI are at high risk for future CVD.
... Other researchers have found comparable outcomes to this one, including Uppal (2005), who discovered a substantial positive link between paid leave and increased work satisfaction. According to Uppal's (2005) research, providing paid leave enhanced employee satisfaction since workers benefited from such fringe benefits. ...
... Other researchers have found comparable outcomes to this one, including Uppal (2005), who discovered a substantial positive link between paid leave and increased work satisfaction. According to Uppal's (2005) research, providing paid leave enhanced employee satisfaction since workers benefited from such fringe benefits. In addition, Freeman (1978), Weiss (1984), Clegg (1983), and other researchers discovered a favourable association between the provision of extra benefits and vacation time and employee satisfaction. ...
Thesis
Full-text available
Paternity leave is one of the topics discussed in society in this era. Paternity leave is also a benefit provided by the organisation and has been written into the law in other countries. However, Malaysia still has no law that states paternity leave, and not all organisations provide paternity leave to their employee. Maslow's Hierarchy of Needs Theory, Expectancy Theory and Herzberg's Two Factory Theory were adopted and incorporated in this study. A cross-sectional study is conducted whereby the data gathered is from the collection of questionnaires as the main instrument. The data was collected through an online survey. Participants of this study included 147 male individuals, 18 years old and above with working experience. The data collected was further analysed using SPSS software for descriptive statistics for each variable. The independent variable, namely: Paternity leave, had a significant effect on all the dependent variables, namely: Employee Productivity, Organisation Productivity and Employee Satisfaction. This study is crucial to guide other researchers in understanding better paternity leave in Malaysia. It is also beneficial for organisations, especially since management will start to provide paternity leave to their employees.
... Within the existing literature, we can find a few studies have focused on the particular relationship between disability and job satisfaction (e.g., Renaud 2002;Uppal 2005;Schur et al. 2009;Pagán and Malo 2009;Pagán 2011aPagán , 2013Pagán , 2014Pagán , 2017. For example, Uppal (2005) finds, using a sample of 4,474 Canadian individuals aged 15-64 (of which 443 are disabled) for the year 1991, that when certain workplace characteristics are introduced into the ▶ job satisfaction equation, individuals with a mobility disability are no longer likely to be less satisfied as compared to individuals without disabilities. ...
... Within the existing literature, we can find a few studies have focused on the particular relationship between disability and job satisfaction (e.g., Renaud 2002;Uppal 2005;Schur et al. 2009;Pagán and Malo 2009;Pagán 2011aPagán , 2013Pagán , 2014Pagán , 2017. For example, Uppal (2005) finds, using a sample of 4,474 Canadian individuals aged 15-64 (of which 443 are disabled) for the year 1991, that when certain workplace characteristics are introduced into the ▶ job satisfaction equation, individuals with a mobility disability are no longer likely to be less satisfied as compared to individuals without disabilities. Schur, Kruse, Blasi, and Blank (2009) also find that people with disabilities report a greater average likelihood of turnover, less loyalty and willingness to work hard for the company, and lower average levels of job satisfaction. ...
... In a Canadian study, people with disabilities had lower job satisfaction than those without disabilities, and workers with visual impairments had the lowest job satisfaction (Uppal, 2005). ...
... The major factors that negatively influenced job satisfaction were interpersonal work problems, workload demands, and the potential for layoff (Uppal, 2005). Employees with visual impairments in Europe and Israel scored lower than sighted employees on several measures concerning employment, including job satisfaction, freedom to make decisions in their jobs, support in difficult situations, recognition of their work, opportunities to develop new skills, and adequate salaries (Mojon-Azzi et al., 2010). ...
Article
Introduction: Job satisfaction research has focused on the general population or specific careers. Little attention has focused on the job satisfaction of persons with visual impairments, particularly using standardized measures of job satisfaction. This study examined how relationships with colleagues and supervisors, opportunities for advancement, and employee demographics predict job satisfaction for employees with visual impairments. Methods: Researchers analyzed data from 195 employed participants from a larger study on job retention and career advancement. The Brief Job Satisfaction Measure II measured job satisfaction, and predictor variables focused on relationships with colleagues and supervisors, promotion opportunities, and demographics. Researchers used multiple linear regression to identify predictors of job satisfaction. Results: Individuals with visual impairments had high job satisfaction if they believed colleagues treated them the same as sighted colleagues and had supervisor support. Underemployed individuals with visual impairments experienced lower job satisfaction. Employees who identified their race as other, those who experienced vision loss after their first job, and participants with an additional disability had higher job satisfaction. Discussion: Social interactions with colleagues and supervisors contributed to the job satisfaction of employees with visual impairments. These interactions may make employees with visual impairments feel comfortable asking for workplace accommodations and more integrated into the workspace. While income was not a predictor of job satisfaction, underemployment was, indicating that individuals with visual impairments may not have achieved their maximum vocational potential. Implications for Practitioners: Individuals with visual impairments and service providers should look for opportunities to promote social interactions at work. Training co-workers and supervisors about working with persons with visual impairments and accommodations could be beneficial. Vocational rehabilitation counselors should also ensure program participants have employment opportunities that are both economically sustainable and commensurate with their interests and abilities.
... Tüm engellilik türlerinde "çalışma" ile ilgili ortak temalar özetle ekonomik açıdan kendi kendine yeterlilik, psikolojik refah ve değerli bir sosyal rol sağlamak olarak ortaya çıkmaktadır. Bununla birlikte, engelli çalışanların işyerinde yaşadıkları engeller nedeniyle engelsizlere göre çalışmadan daha az memnuniyet duyduğu belirtilmektedir (Uppal, 2005;MacGregor, 2012;Schur, Kruse, Blasi ve Blanck, 2009;Jones, 2016). Engelli bireyler açısından çalışmanın amacı "normal yaşama" ulaşmaları şeklinde yorumlanmaktadır. ...
... İlgili kodlamalar, Kahn (1990)'ın çalışmanın anlamlı olması için işveren ve iş arkadaşları ile kaliteli sosyo-duygusal bağ kurması gerekliliğine yaptığı vurgunun ne kadar önemli olduğunu göstermektedir. Çalıştığı ortamda duygusal kopukluk yaşayanlar, kötü koşullarda çalışanlar çalışmayı anlamsız (Shuck, 2011;Steger vd., 2011;Shuck ve Rose, 2013) ve/veya daha az anlamlı (Uppal, 2005;MacGregor, 2012;Schur vd., 2009;Jones, 2016) bulmaktadır. Aynı zamanda çalışmanın (görme) engelliler için anlamlı olması işyeri ve iş arkadaşları tarafından değer görmelerine de bağlıdır (Cameron, 2014, s. 29). ...
Article
Full-text available
z Çalışmak, gelir, sosyal statü, sosyal ilişkiler ve topluma aidiyet duygusu gibi pek çok önemli bireysel, ekonomik ve psiko-sosyal işlevleri yerine getirmektedir. Bütün bu işlevleri ile çalışmak, (görme) engellilerin de toplumla bağının kopmaması, toplumsal yaşama katılmasında merkezi rol oynamaktadır. Bu çalışma, nitel araştırma yöntemi ile çalışma yaşamına aktif olarak katılan görme engelli bireylerin çalışmayı nasıl anlamlandırdıkları, çalışmanın engelli bireyler için işlevlerini incelemekte ve ortaya koymaktadır. Bulgular, görme engelli bireyler için "çalışma"nın anlamlı ve önemli olduğunu göstermektedir. Çalışmak, para kazanmanın ötesinde, görme engelli olmanın yol açtığı olumsuz psikolojik, sosyal, duyusal sonuçları bertaraf etmede ve yaşadıkları topluma dahil olma duygusunu pekiştirmede değerli bir işlev görmektedir. [Görme] engellilere yönelik önyargılı işveren/iş arkadaşı tutumlarının varlığı ve işyeri düzenlemelerinin (görme) engeline göre yapılmaması gibi olumsuzluklar, "çalışma"nın görme engelli çalışanlar açısından psiko-sosyal, bireysel faydalarını azalttığı çalışmada ulaşılan diğer bulgulardır. Anahtar kelimeler: Görme engelliler, çalışmanın anlamı, çalışmanın işlevleri, nitel araştırma Abstract Working provides income, social status, social relations, and a sense of belonging to society, among other important individual, economic, and psycho-social functions. Working with all these functions plays a central role in the (visually) disabled people's keeping their ties with society and participating in social life. The study examines and reveals how visually impaired individuals actively participating in working life make sense of work and the functions of work for them with the qualitative research method. Findings show that "work" is meaningful and important for visually impaired individuals. Working, beyond earning money, has a valuable function in eliminating the negative psychological, social, and sensory consequences of not seeing and reinforcing the sense of being included in the society they live in. The presence of negative attitudes such as prejudiced employer/colleague attitudes towards the [visually] disabled and the lack of workplace arrangements according to the (visually) disabled are other findings of the study, which reduces the psycho-social and individual benefits of work for visually impaired employees.
... Tüm engellilik türlerinde "çalışma" ile ilgili ortak temalar özetle ekonomik açıdan kendi kendine yeterlilik, psikolojik refah ve değerli bir sosyal rol sağlamak olarak ortaya çıkmaktadır. Bununla birlikte, engelli çalışanların işyerinde yaşadıkları engeller nedeniyle engelsizlere göre çalışmadan daha az memnuniyet duyduğu belirtilmektedir (Uppal, 2005;MacGregor, 2012;Schur, Kruse, Blasi ve Blanck, 2009;Jones, 2016). Engelli bireyler açısından çalışmanın amacı "normal yaşama" ulaşmaları şeklinde yorumlanmaktadır. ...
... İlgili kodlamalar, Kahn (1990)'ın çalışmanın anlamlı olması için işveren ve iş arkadaşları ile kaliteli sosyo-duygusal bağ kurması gerekliliğine yaptığı vurgunun ne kadar önemli olduğunu göstermektedir. Çalıştığı ortamda duygusal kopukluk yaşayanlar, kötü koşullarda çalışanlar çalışmayı anlamsız (Shuck, 2011;Steger vd., 2011;Shuck ve Rose, 2013) ve/veya daha az anlamlı (Uppal, 2005;MacGregor, 2012;Schur vd., 2009;Jones, 2016) bulmaktadır. Aynı zamanda çalışmanın (görme) engelliler için anlamlı olması işyeri ve iş arkadaşları tarafından değer görmelerine de bağlıdır (Cameron, 2014, s. 29). ...
Article
Full-text available
Çalışmak, gelir, sosyal statü, sosyal ilişkiler ve topluma aidiyet duygusu gibi pek çok önemli bireysel, ekonomik ve psiko-sosyal işlevleri yerine getirmektedir. Bütün bu işlevleri ile çalışmak, (görme) engellilerin de toplumla bağının kopmaması, toplumsal yaşama katılmasında merkezi rol oynamaktadır. Çalışma, nitel araştırma yöntemi ile çalışma yaşamına aktif katılan görme engelli bireylerin çalışmayı nasıl anlamlandırdıkları, çalışmanın onlar için işlevleri incelemekte ve ortaya koymaktadır. Bulgular, görme engelli bireyler için “çalışma”nın anlamlı ve önemli olduğunu göstermektedir. Çalışmak, para kazanmanın ötesinde, gör(e)memenin yol açtığı olumsuz psikolojik, sosyal, duyusal sonuçları bertaraf etmede ve yaşadıkları topluma dahil olma duygusunu pekiştirmede değerli bir işlev görmektedir. [Görme] engellilere yönelik önyargılı işveren/iş arkadaşı tutumlarının ve işyeri düzenlemelerinin (görme) engeline göre yapılmaması gibi olumsuzlukların varlığı ise, çalışmanın görme engelli çalışanlar açısından psiko-sosyal, bireysel faydalarını azalttığı çalışmada ulaşılan diğer bulgulardır.
... Unfortunately, those with severe disabilities account for only 0.26 percent of all formal workers (ILO, 2017). People with disabilities have lower levels of job opportunities, job satisfaction, higher levels of job dissatisfaction, and a higher likelihood of discrimination than non-disabled employees (Nilawaty, 2019;Uppal, 2005). As with salaries, the amount received by disabled employees varies, they do not receive insurance or other benefits, and they work fewer hours. ...
... Job satisfaction can be any combination of psychological, physiological and environmental circumstances that cause a feeling of satisfaction, affective orientations of individuals toward work roles, the way how people feel about their job and its various aspects, a combination of positive or negative feelings that workers have towards their work (whether expectation is matched), the organizational outcomes resulted from job satisfaction, intrinsic rewards, the attitudes and feelings people have about their work. Therefore, the concept of job satisfaction may relate with needs fulfilment, affective orientation or feeling of like or dislike toward job, intrinsic motivation, challenge, or any factors affecting satisfaction (Aziri, 2011;Uppal, 2005). ...
Article
Full-text available
Main Objectives: This study aims to evaluate the moderating role of psychological empowerment on the relationship between benevolent leadership and employees’ well-being.Novelty: Since research involving disabled employees is rare, this study adds to the current body of knowledge by confirming the links between benevolent leadership, job satisfaction, and perceived discrimination. It also aims to find out how psychological empowerment influences the relationship between benevolent leadership and job satisfaction, as well as the association between benevolent leadership and perceived discrimination. Research methods: This research involves 85 respondents. They are employees with various disabilities working in different organizations. Moderated regression analysis is employed to analyze the data. Finding/Results: This study found that benevolent leadership significantly affect employees’ well-being: job satisfaction, and perceived discrimination. In addition, as expected, psychological empowerment strengthens the positive impact of benevolent leadership on job satisfaction. On the contrary, psychological empowerment weakens the negative impact of benevolent leadership on perceived discrimination. Conclusion: Based on the conservation of resources theory, resources provided by the organization, in this case is benevolent leadership, perceived by employees with disabilities as a recovery of the loss of resources (disabilities). Recruiting benevolent leaders or developing existing leaders to be more benevolence is important to improve disabilities employees’ well-being.
... In 1993, Jayaratne published a wide review of literature on job satisfaction stressing that there was a little research on the impact of perceived discrimination on job satisfaction. Later in the years 2000, the impact of the perception of discrimination on job satisfaction has been increasingly analysed, in particular on the basis of age (Furunes & Mikletun, 2010), gender (Bender, Donohue & Heywood, 2005), disability (Uppal, 2005;Pagan, 2011Pagan, , 2013 and ethnicity (Miller & Travers, 2005;King, Dawson, Kravitz & Gulick, 2012). Much less literature was produced, instead, on the relation between perception of sexual orientation discrimination and job satisfaction 1 . ...
... Nevertheless, if workers with disability are generally and moderately more satisfied than those without but they happen to experience more discrimination, they can report similar (or lower) levels of job satisfaction to those of workers without disability (Stone & Colella, 1996;Perry, Hendricks & Broadbent, 2000). It should be added that diverse types of disabilities are exposed to diverse levels of discrimination (Uppal, 2005). ...
Article
Full-text available
This research contributes to the debate in the human resources management (HRM) literature by examining the impact of some HRM practices on workers’ overall job satisfaction and the determinants of workers’ perception of discrimination. The novelty of our study consists in the deepening of the relation between HRM practices and the employees’ perception of discrimination in workplace: a largely unexplored topic, until now. Our aim is to add value to existing literature by assessing the synergy effect between perception of discrimination and HRM practices on workers’ job satisfaction, performing a probit regression analysis of a selection of variables drawn from the sixth wave of European Working Condition Survey data, collected in 2015. We also provide a comparison of different types of discrimination, examining the moderating effect of the perception of discrimination on the relationship between HRM practices and employees’ job satisfaction, assuming that the strength of the above relation is weaker for discriminated workers. Our findings highlight that HRM practices we analysed (except for autonomy of the work-group and job-intensity) have a positive impact on workers’ satisfaction and reduce the perception of discrimination. Moreover, we find that the perception of every kind of discrimination have a negative impact on workers’ job satisfaction. Our results also suggest that the perception of discrimination has a moderator role in the relation between HRM practices and job satisfaction. Policy implications are finally discussed.
... The second conclusion of the related research is that workers with disabilities are more satisfied with their job compared to the workers without disabilities. Due to health restrictions, absence of assistive technology, wage inequality and difficulties in socialising in organisations, workers with disabilities report lower levels of job satisfaction compared to their non-disabled counterparts (McAfee & McNaughton, 1997;Uppal, 2005). Considering the dissatisfaction effects of disability, it is important to explore the relationship between f lexible employment schemes and job satisfaction for two main reasons. ...
... As the third reason for the dissatisfaction, Uppal (2005) found that absence of assistive technology in the workplace increased the dissatisfaction of disabled workers. Although, the role of f lexible employment schemes on job satisfaction is not analysed, f lexible employment arrangements can be a solution reducing the negative consequences of the absence of these technologies. ...
... In other words, a company's financial and non-financial support positively impacts employee job performance [61], and this job performance leads to job satisfaction [62]. In addition, it has been shown that the greater the variety of welfare programs provided, the higher the job satisfaction of employees [63]. Consequently, satisfaction with the welfare provided by the company and the diversity of welfare programs can be said to influence employees' overall job satisfaction. ...
Article
Full-text available
This study explores the determinants of job satisfaction among IT industry employees in the U.S. and South Korea, focusing on how cultural and socio-economic contexts influence employee well-being and organizational sustainability. Given the high turnover rates in the IT industry, understanding the key factors affecting job satisfaction and dissatisfaction is critical for promoting sustainable organizational practices. By comparing reviews from Glassdoor and Jobplanet, this study uncovers cultural and organizational differences that directly affect employee retention and job satisfaction, offering actionable insights for multinational IT companies seeking to align their strategies with sustainable HR practices. The research utilizes Contextualized Topic Modeling (CTM), a cutting-edge method leveraging Sentence-BERT embeddings, to analyze user-generated reviews. CTM identifies key topics such as attendance management, career development, organizational culture, welfare support, salary, and job autonomy, revealing distinct cultural influences. For example, attendance management and organizational culture positively influenced job satisfaction in U.S. companies, while welfare benefits were more significant in the U.S. than in South Korea. Salary had a positive effect in South Korea but a negative effect in the U.S. The comparative analysis also highlights the higher satisfaction levels among current employees, underscoring factors critical for long-term retention. This study contributes to the literature by leveraging user-generated content to reveal context-specific factors, including new elements such as “technological capabilities” and “location and accessibility,” which are often overlooked in traditional survey-based research. The findings provide actionable insights for IT companies to refine HR practices in ways that enhance employee satisfaction, contributing to both organizational sustainability and the well-being of employees.
... Engellileri konu edinen Kanada'da yapılmış bir çalışmada da erişilebilirlik konusunun engelliler açısından önemi ön plana çıkmaktadır. Araştırmada, fiziki açıdan uygunluk ve yardımcı teknolojilerin bulunması gibi işyeri özelliklerinin engelli çalışanların işlerinden daha fazla memnun olmaları ile ilişkili olabileceği belirtilmiştir(Uppal, 2005). Buna paralel olarak diğer çalışmalarda da benzer bulgulara rastlanmaktadır(Karakuyu, 2017;Narayanan, 2018; Wahidin vd., 2018; Kanyılmaz Polat, 2020; Makkawy ve Long, 2021). ...
Article
Full-text available
Çalışma hayatının sorunları genel olarak sanayi devriminin başlangıcından bu yana hem ulusal hem de uluslararası düzlemde birçok boyutuyla tartışılmaktadır. Bugün gelinen noktada her ne kadar birçok ilerleme kaydedilmiş gibi görünse de halen önemli bir tartışma alanı olarak güncelliğini korumaktadır. Bireyin günlük hayatını devam ettirebilmesi ve insan onuruna yaraşır bir iş ihtiyacı tartışmalarının gölgesinde gündeme gelen bir başka konu ise dezavantajlıların sistem içerisinde karşılaştıkları zorluklardır. Çalışma hayatının rekabete dayalı ve sürekli yüksek performans odaklı bir alan olarak tanımlanması, süreci engelliler için daha da zorlaştırmaktadır. Bu çerçevede çalışmada, görme engelli bireylerin çalışma hayatı içerisinde yaşadıkları deneyimlere odaklanılmış ve bu deneyimlere yönelik değerlendirmeleri ele alınmaya çalışılmıştır. Nitel araştırma desenli yürütülen çalışmada ruh sağlığı alanında çalışan 10 görme engelli uzmana ulaşılmıştır. Araştırma bulgularından hareketle, uzmanların mesleki deneyimlerinin şekillenmesinde görme engelli olmaları yanında çalışma ortamları, mesleki rollerini uygulamaya aktarabilmeleri noktasında kurumların sağladığı imkânlar, danışanların özellikleri ve ihtiyaçları gibi hususların da belirleyici olduğu görülmüştür.
... Given these disparities in job outcomes, workers with disabilities commonly report lower levels of job satisfaction than workers without disabilities (e.g., Jones, 2016;Uppal, 2005). ...
Article
Full-text available
BACKGROUND: More than 1 in 4 adult Americans have a disability limiting their daily functioning to earn living wages. Meanwhile, the shortage of U.S. professionals in STEM fields persists because of underrepresentation of specific groups, such as racial and ethnic minorities, women, and people with disabilities. OBJECTIVE: The study investigates the determinants of wages among Americans with disabilities in non-STEM and STEM occupations to explore the feasibility of broadening their participation in STEM careers where they may earn higher wages and thereby, close the wage-gap with their non-disabled peers. METHODS: The study used a research design based on Mincer’s earnings regression model to analyze select variables as wage determinants based on data from the 2018 American Community Survey (ACS). RESULTS: While the findings suggest that within the Americans with disabilities group, working in a STEM occupation with a college degree in a STEM field was the best route to attain maximum wages, significant wage disparities exist compared to Americans without disabilities. CONCLUSION: Implications of the findings for Vocational Rehabilitation providers are discussed.
... The integrating capacity of any employment depends on the satisfaction it provides to the worker, which is a function, among other factors, of the perceived quality of the job in terms of wage, the attitude of co-workers, supervisors, and employers, the opportunities for promotion and training, the matching between the employment and the skills of the worker, and finally the personal contacts obtained through this position. Empirical evidence shows that there may be significant differences between workers with and without disabilities in all of these areas (Witte, Philips, and Kakela 1998;Uppal 2005;Schur et al. 2009;Shantz, Wang, and Malik 2018;Vornholt et al. 2018). Therefore, to understand the status of graduates with disabilities in the labour market, we need to consider other dimensions that provide a comprehensive assessment of the quality of their employment. ...
... According to the findings of Woodbury's (1983) study, employees view their benefits and earnings as being interchangeable, and they are willing to sacrifice their wages in exchange for increased benefits. According to the findings of Uppal's (2005) research, a positive relationship exists between fringe benefits and employee satisfaction. The findings were validated by Benz (2005), who discovered that just two of the nine fringe benefits investigated were positively connected to satisfaction. ...
Article
Full-text available
Specifically, the purpose of this research was to determine which aspects of the public service incentives system in Rivers State, Port Harcourt, would contribute to employee happiness. There were a total of 327 responders, and they were all given a questionnaire that they could fill out on their own time. There was an 89% return on the survey's initial query. All of the predictors showed a substantial contribution to employee satisfaction in the Rivers State Civil Service, according to regression and Pearson correlation analyses. Employee satisfaction was found to be highest with regard to salary and lowest with regard to bonuses and other incentives. The results show that a company's rewards system has a positive effect on how happy workers are with their jobs. Introduction The level of employee satisfaction is a hot topic in management, psychology, and especially in the fields of organizational behavior and human resource management. Management should prioritize employees' happiness and well-being by considering both financial and in-kind benefits. Workers' happiness and the public sector's reward system are often discussed together. Reward programs for government employees have been shown to increase morale and job satisfaction. Danish and Usman (2010) say that the rewards system is the most variable way to keep workers' morale and enthusiasm high.
... This study examined the effect of JBC's compensation system on satisfaction with the mediating effect of employee motivation, and the findings indicate a strong link between the compensation system and staff satisfaction through the partial mediation impact of employee motivation. The study findings were supported by the study of Uppal (2005), who discovered that employee compensation (fringe benefits) was positively connected to employee job satisfaction. However, in the link between compensation and employee satisfaction, employee performance was discussed rather than the role of motivation as mediator (Candradewi and Dewi 2019). ...
Article
Full-text available
The compensation system, employee motivation, and employee satisfaction have received much attention from academics for many years. Existing research, however, does not yet detail the mediation effect of employee motivation on the relationship between the entire compensation system and employee satisfaction. The study explores the influence of the compensation structure on employee satisfaction using employee motivation as mediation. This research embraced a quantitative design, positivism paradigm, deductive approach, and explanatory research. Cross-sectional data from 100 employees were drawn with a random sampling technique using a self-administered survey questionnaire. First, in sequence of analysis, descriptive statistics were conducted. After that, a reliability test was used to test internal consistency. Finally, a correlation test, direct effect, indirect effect, and total effect were used to test the hypotheses at the 0.05 level while analyzing the data. The findings show that the compensation system has a favorable impact on employee satisfaction by partially mediating motivation. Concurrently, this study establishes awareness intending to revise a robust compensation strategy so that employee morale, engagement will increase and turnover will reduce. The study outcomes will assist policymakers in improving the situation of the existing workforce in insurance companies and other financial companies in Bangladesh.
... Là encore, si la loi NRE de 2001, en obligeant les entreprises à communiquer sur les actions de celles-ci en faveur du handicap et de l'intégration de personnes handicapées, a accru la visibilité de la responsabilité sociale de l'entreprise à cet égard, on observe souvent un décalage de communication au vu des moyens réels mis en oeuvre pour les travailleurs handicapés (Point, Charles-Fontaine & Barthélemé, 2010). Une des illustrations en est l'inadaptation fréquente de l'aménagement des postes de travail (Jones, 1997 ;Baldridge & Veiga, 2001 ;Uppal, 2005 ;Point, Charles-Fontaine & Barthélemé, 2010). Influencée par une approche très managériale, développée par des courants de recherche comme « l'Intégrative Disability Management » (Angeloni, 2013) ou « le Disability management » (Akabas, Gates & Galvin, 1992) qui insistent sur une performance économique et sociale très forte de ces politiques dans leur discours, tout en ne précisant jamais concrètement en quoi elles consistent, on assiste ainsi à un blanchiment de la politique handicap. ...
Article
Full-text available
Peu d’articles cherchent à rendre compte de la politique du handicap dans toute sa complexité. L’approche part trop souvent d’un regard en surplomb au sein duquel la performance du salarié handicapé est évoquée sans vraiment la qualifier. On a donc tendance à homogénéiser toute forme de handicap et à en oublier la diversité des manifestations. Dans la majorité des cas, la solution apportée se résume à l’aménagement du poste de travail (Richard, 2016). Ce type d’approche favorise le développement d’un phénomène que d’aucuns qualifient, de nos jours, en anglais, de : « disable washing ». Ce phénomène se caractérise par un marketing des ressources humaines dont l’objectif est de séduire les parties prenantes, les candidats potentiels et les salariés en situation de handicap, au détriment des moyens pouvant satisfaire les besoins de ces derniers ; il met aussi en évidence les biais possibles que peuvent prendre certaines organisations par ailleurs reconnues comme « handi-accueillantes ». Face à ces constats, cet article propose une approche qui privilégie la co-construction en matière de politique du handicap, pour mettre fin à une forme de myopie qui existe dans les univers organisés contemporains par rapport à cette question.
... Kamuda yer alan okul ve eğitim kurumlarında çalışan memurların böyle eylemlere maruz kalması kişileri bulundukları kuruma karşı iş hayatından zevk alamama ve mutsuzluk gibi negatif eylemlere itmektedir. Uppal (2005) iş görenlerin iş doyumları ile iş tatmin düzeylerini düşüren pek çok faktör arasında, işyerinde yıldırmanın önemli bir etkiye sahip olduğunu ileri sürmektedir. Halbur (2005) işyerinde yıldırmanın, örgütlerde iş görenlerin devamsızlığına, devir hızının azalmasına, moralsizliğe ve iş görenlerin performansının düşmesi neden olduğunu belirtmektedir. ...
Conference Paper
Full-text available
In this study, firstly, It is anonymized although, not necessarily attributed and again in the same way the historical process of the terms of “the gypsies”, sometimes as “romans”, will be told as a legacy of Ottoman heritage and so called “72,5 Nations” in the multi-cultural enviroment in Turkey with cultural paradigmas. Aftermath, the society which mentioned above will be analyzed in the light of academical results with Cultural Dimensions of whom developed by Hofstede.
... Kamuda yer alan okul ve eğitim kurumlarında çalışan memurların böyle eylemlere maruz kalması kişileri bulundukları kuruma karşı mutsuz ve olumsuz durumlara itmektedir. Uppal (2005) iş ortamında farklı faktörlerin iç içe olduğu durumlarda, işyerinde yıldırma algısının önemli bir etkiye sahip olduğunu ileri sürmektedir. Halbur (2005) ise yıldırma algısını; örgüt içinde yer alan çalışanların maruz kalması durumda devamsızlığa, çalışma hızının azalmasına, moralsizliğe ve çalışanların performansının düşmesi neden olduğunu ifade etmiştir. ...
Article
Full-text available
ZET Amaç: Bu çalışmada, Hatay ilinde görev yapan beden eğitimi ve spor öğretmenleri ile diğer branş öğretmenlerinin okul ortamında maruz kalabilecekleri mobbing ile örgütsel iklim algılarının belirlenmesi ve aralarındaki ilişkinin incelenmesi amaçlanmıştır. Yöntem: Araştırmanın evrenini 2019-2020 eğitim-öğretim yılında eğitim veren toplam 892 öğretmen oluşturmaktadır. Örneklem ise Hatay, Osmaniye ve Kilis il ve ilçe merkezlerinde görev yapan; tesadüfi örneklem yöntemi ile seçilen 297 beden eğitimi ve spor öğretmeni, 172 görsel sanatlar, 184 müzik öğretmeni olmak üzere toplamda 653 öğretmen oluşturmuştur. Araştırmada veri toplama aracı olarak Einarsen ve Raknes (1997) tarafından geliştirilen, Cemaloğlu (2007) tarafından Türkçeye uyarlanan Olumsuz Davranışlar Anketi "NAQ (Negative Acts Questionnaire)" ile Steve Hoy ve Tarter (1997) tarafından geliştirilen, Yılmaz ve Altınkurt (2013) tarafından Türkçeye uyarlanan "Örgütsel İklim Ölçeği (ÖİÖ)" kullanılmıştır. Bulgular ve Sonuç: Alt problemlere bağlı verilerin çözümlenmesinde t-testi, tek yönlü varyans analizi (Oneway ANOVA) ve korelasyon analizi uygulanmıştır. Araştırma sonucunda, öğretmenlerin Olumsuz Davranışlar Anketi ve Örgütsel İklim Ölçeği puan ortalamaları dikkate alındığında; cinsiyet ve branş farklılıkları arasında anlamlı farklılık olduğu tespit edilmiştir.
... Employee commitment has been identified as important for ensuring the successful implantation of service quality programmes [64]. Without commitment, service quality will fail. ...
Article
Full-text available
Higher education service quality and performance in technical and vocational education and training (TVET) is critical for developing human capital for economic survival; however, the effects of service quality on organisational performance are still unclear. Furthermore, neglecting employee soft factors and ignoring higher education-specific models have hindered efforts to develop a comprehensive model for service quality excellence in order to improve higher education performance for organisations. This study aims to assess higher education service quality based on a modified higher education performance (modified HEdPERF) model, as well as consideration of the mediating effects of soft factors (i.e., job satisfaction and organisational commitment) in Malaysian polytechnic institutions. Based on random sampling, 214 department heads from 33 polytechnic institutes in Malaysia participated in this study. Data were collected through self-administered questionnaires and were analysed using AMOS. The results uncover that service quality significantly affects job satisfaction, thus positively affecting organisational commitment, which enhances organisational performance sustainability. The findings also reveal that job satisfaction fully mediates the relationship between service quality and organisational commitment. Similarly, organisational commitment fully mediates the relationship between job satisfaction and organisational performance sustainability. The results have important implications for enhancing organisational performance sustainability in a TVET context when implementing the modified HEdPERF service quality model with simultaneous attention paid towards employee soft factors.
... However, it is worth exploring the topic of job satisfaction with a focus on workers with disabilities because of their unique circumstances in the labor market: low wages, high unemployment rate, segregation in low-paying occupations, and productivity limitations. While these intrinsic differences in circumstances are likely to generate a different level of subjective wellbeing among workers with disabilities, only a limited number of studies have focused on their job satisfaction, and the focus has been on comparisons of job satisfaction between nondisabled and disabled workers [11,12]. There is less evidence on how disabled workers feel about their job and workplace. ...
Article
Full-text available
This paper explores the association between job satisfaction and gender for workers with disabilities, using data from the Panel Survey of Employment for the Disabled, which interviews officially registered persons with disabilities in Korea. To take full advantage of the longitudinal data, we apply random-effects ordered probit models to investigate the underlying factors that affect gender differentials in job satisfaction. Our findings reveal that merely different work values between women and men do not account for the significantly higher job satisfaction among women. We suggest that workers’ expectations play a role in explaining why female workers are happier in the workplace than their male counterparts; that is, holding other factors constant, women’s expectations from jobs are lower than men’s. This hypothesis is partially supported by the empirical analyses that gender differentials diminish among the highly educated workers, for whom there is less likely to be a gender gap in terms of job expectations.
... 6.2.7 Fringe benefits and employee turnover Mamun and Hasan (2017) noted that a fringe benefits affect performance and employee retention of organizations. On a similar note Uppal (2005) noted that fringe benefits contribute to the higher level of satisfaction of employees which in turn ensures employee retention. ...
Conference Paper
Full-text available
This study explores the employee turnover of a tea manufacturing company in Sri Lanka (MND). This study identifies the factors that contribute to the labour turnover of MND and propose strategies to overcome the high employee turnover through incorporating a qualitative case study approach, adopting Person Environment Fit Theory (PEFT). The factors which affect labour turnover are: heavy work load and high work pressure, low wage rate, long working hours, unclear job roles, less appealing work environment, lack of opportunity for career development, lack of fringe benefits, weak relationship with supervisors and weak relationship with peers. Among the above factors the working environment; relationships with supervisors and team members did not have a major impact on triggering employee turnover. This study also illuminates the strategies that to overcome the high employee turnover: easing off the pressure put on employees to reach targets by hiring the required number of employees; paying an industry par wage rate; giving appropriate breaks for employees to ensure that they are not over worked; and offering a job role for employees specifying the tasks expected by them. To strengthen person organization fit, MND could improve the work environment, provide opportunities for employees to develop their career, providing more fringe benefits. However, our study identified that person team fit and person supervisor fit did not have a significant impact in the increase of labour turnover at MND. 2
... While these workplace characteristics appear to increase job satisfaction across all employees, they might be particularly effective in addressing the job satisfaction levels of employees from certain social groups. Researchers find evidence for the role of positive workplace characteristics on narrowing the gap between both abled and disabled employees (Uppal, 2005) and between ethnic majority and minority employees (Shields and Price, 2002). This suggests that workplace characteristics might moderate the relationship between minority status and job satisfaction, including for sexual minorities. ...
Article
Full-text available
Studies looking at patterns of labour market outcomes among lesbian, gay and bisexual (LGB) individuals focus mostly on earnings, while non-pecuniary outcomes of LGB individuals have remained a relatively under-researched area. Using the latest wave of the Workplace Employment Relations Study (WERS), this article investigates the job satisfaction levels of LGB individuals compared to their heterosexual peers for the first time in Britain. The results show significantly lower job satisfaction levels only for bisexual men, compared to their heterosexual counterparts. Moreover, the findings do not show a direct impact of LGB(T)-related workplace policies on job satisfaction levels.
... However, previous research revealed that employed people with physical disabilities have experienced social discrimination because of their disabilities and were less likely to be satisfied with their jobs compared to the general population (Kaye et al. 2011;Uppal 2005). With the implementation of The Americans with Disabilities Act in 1990, disability discrimination is prohibited in any aspect of employment, including hiring, firing, assignment of duties, pay, and promotions (EEOC 2020). ...
Article
Full-text available
Empirical studies on work-life balance (WLB) among employees without disabilities are abundant; in contrast, insufficient research exists on WLB and quality of life issues among employees with physical disabilities from Asian countries. This study used a nation-wide survey to examine how job satisfaction, leisure satisfaction, and satisfaction with family relationships, and satisfaction with friend relationships were positively associated with life satisfaction among employees with physical disabilities in South Korea. The results of the study demonstrated that job satisfaction, leisure satisfaction, and family and friend relationships contributed significantly to the life satisfaction of employees with physical disabilities. Job satisfaction and leisure satisfaction were positively correlated (Pearson’s r = .606). Participants who were satisfied with job and leisure were 16.86 times [95% confidence interval (CI): 10.04–28.31)] more likely to be satisfied with their lives compared to those who were not satisfied with either their jobs or leisure activities. Participants satisfied with either their jobs or leisure activities were 4.49 times (OR 4.49, 95% CI: 2.64–7.65) more likely to be satisfied with their lives compared to those not satisfied with either their jobs or leisure activities. These findings suggest that managing a healthy balance between work and leisure may are critical to enhancing life satisfaction among the population with disabilities. Future research should include cross-cultural studies with sub-dimensions of the measurement scales to improve life satisfaction in this population.
... Hence, work stress depends on the balance between efforts and rewards (Raab, 2019). Uppal (2005) utilized a measure involved the quantity of incidental advantages representatives get and finds this has emphatically identified with work fulfillment. Plus, work fulfillment has ascended while benefits fulfillment has raised. ...
Article
Full-text available
It is very important that the managers responsible for the performance of their employees know the reasons that affect their job satisfaction in order to carry the organizations to the future and continuity. From this point, the involvement of employees in the development of the organization, the achievement or dissatisfaction of loyalties depends on the people in the Organization. It has shown on various events that one of the ways to deal with get the best execution out of agents is to make them pleasant and perky. Workers everything being equivalent and levels of pay continue getting dynamically hopeless at work - an extended stretch example that should concern supervisors. How, by then do directors make satisfied agents? Since pay has been a fundamental thought of pushing delegates in an Organization. The present investigation broke down the issue of pay and compensation based satisfaction. Data was accumulated and separated similar to drawing in experiences, and the analysis of the data was done through the SPSS package program with a 95% confidence interval. Chi-square test was used to investigate with frequencies and explanatory information. The other purpose of this study is to examine the tweets of people who use social media, based on their own declarations, who have a high job satisfaction due to their salary, and those who work with less salary, and as a result of the analysis on tweets sent by these people, the employees who love their job are distinctive. to make clear differences. In this study, data mining, machine learning and data science methods are applied to data captured on Twitter. A total of 142,656 tweets were made and these tweets were worked on. Among the applied algorithms, the highest success rate belongs to the Grandient Boosted Tree and it can accurately classify on a nearly balanced and bipolar dataset with a success over 99%. As a result of the applied machine learning algorithms, it was observed that there was a significant difference between the sentence structures, the words used and the posts made by those who were satisfied and dissatisfied with the salary they received. Thanks to machine learning, people who have high job satisfaction and who do not have high job satisfaction can be learned by analyzing their twitter accounts. Other machine learning algorithms can also be attempted when sufficient hardware capacity is available. Techniques have used to test the importance of association among pay and compensation based satisfaction. The result demonstrated that there is no significant association among compensation and delegate occupation satisfaction among the respondents. In any case portions of pay, for instance, livelihood improvement and business dependability were significant contributing factors to delegate occupation satisfaction. The assessment recommended that better conveyor headway openings should be given to the agents to assemble work satisfaction.
... For example, Blaser (2000) found that individual-level variables (education, race, tenure, union membership) predicted the perceptions of workplace practices (promotion, training, etc.) by employees with disabilities. Uppal (2005) showed that male disabled employees were more satisfied than female ones about the availability of work facilities in Canada. Another study revealed that disabled employees who hold graduate degrees reported higher satisfaction toward the treatment of other employees in the organization compared to respondents who hold high school or less (Ababneh, 2016). ...
Article
Purpose This study aims to identify the level of human resource management difficulties (job suitability, training and development, motivation and performance appraisal) women employees with disabilities face in the Jordanian public sector, the satisfaction of the availability of the work facilities, difficulties they face when interacting with supervisors and colleagues as well as with clients at work. Design/methodology/approach A descriptive analytical approach has been used through designing a questionnaire aimed to examine the study dimensions. A random convenient sample of 306 women with disabilities was chosen. Data were analyzed using SPSS software. Findings Analysis revealed that the overall level of human resource management difficulties in the Jordanian public sector as perceived by women with disabilities was moderate (mean = 3). The participants reported a moderate level of assessment (mean = 2.80) about the availability of the work facilities. In addition, they showed a moderate level of satisfaction about both the treatment they receive from supervisors and colleagues as well as from clients with mean values of 2.85 and 2.91, respectively. The participants with physical disability and who hold administrative jobs reported higher level of difficulties of human resources management. Data showed that about 82% of women with disabilities were hired based on a social/humanitarian base instead of merit system. Practical implications This study has a significant practical contribution in providing information that will help policy makers and human resource managers to identify job-related difficulties and develop policies and programs to alleviate them to provide a better work environment to integrate employees with disabilities. Originality/value This study has a crucial value in filling the knowledge gap in examining the work-life of persons with disabilities in Jordan and in the Arab world.
Article
Full-text available
Introduction The level of labor integration of people with disability (PwD) is notably lower than that of people without disabilities. In order to evaluate the success of the labor market integration of people with disabilities, it is necessary to establish a series of indicators that go beyond hiring rates. Hence, the objective of this study is to develop a list of indicators with their specified individual weight that will serve to evaluate the success of the labor market insertion of PwD in conventional companies. Methodology The Delphi method was used. In Phase 1, an open-ended questionnaire was distributed to 48 human resources and disability experts. From this qualitative analysis, a list of 52 indicators was drawn up and the experts were asked to evaluate their importance using a scale from 0 to 10 points. The convergence of opinion was obtained in the third phase. To evaluate the degree of stability of the experts’ responses in the different phases, the Wilcoxon test was applied. Finally, a factor analysis was carried out in relation to the indicators. Results After the development of the three phases and the factor analysis, a list of 26 indicators was obtained to measure the success of inclusive employability, structured in four factors: Work Performance, Labor Management, Social and Organizational Impact, Competency Assessment. Conclusions This project has provided a list of indicators that can be the basis for the creation of a scale to assess the successful integration of people with disabilities in the conventional company.
Article
Full-text available
Background This study conducted a longitudinal analysis of the association between job satisfaction and stress or depressive symptoms of employed persons with disabilities (PWDs) based on the data from the 1st to 8th Pannel Survey of Employment for the Disabled (PSED). Methods After excluding missing values, data on 1614 participants at baseline (1st wave) were analyzed using the chi-square test and generalized estimating equation (GEE) model for data from 1st to 8thPSED. Results It was found that for each one-unit increase in the job satisfaction score, the stress scale decreased by 0.004 (B: −0.004, 95% CI: −0.006–−0.002, p-value: < 0.0001). Compared to the very high job satisfaction group, the low job satisfaction group was more likely to experience perceived stress (odds ratio [OR]: 2.127, p-value: 0.001) and experience depressive symptoms (OR: 3.557, p-value < 0.0001). Furthermore, in terms of the overall satisfaction with their current job among the PWDs, compared to the ‘satisfied’ group, the ‘unsatisfied’ group had higher perceived stress (OR: 1.593, p-value < 0.0001) and depressive symptoms (OR: 2.688, p-value < 0.0001). Conclusions There was a close association between job satisfaction and stress or depressive symptoms among employed PWDS. This study’s findings may serve as foundational research to support improving mental health in this population. In addition, it is anticipated that these findings can be used as evidence to improve the work environment for PWDs within the context of Korean corporate culture.
Article
Purpose People with disabilities (PwDs) encounter several impediments to employment prospects, contributing to India's huge employment gap. Entrepreneurship offers a different avenue for PwDs to overcome these constraints. Entrepreneurship Support Organizations (ESOs) play a significant role in assisting PwD entrepreneurs. The present study aims to explore challenges encountered by entrepreneurs with disabilities (EwDs) in starting or sustaining a business in an Indian ecosystem. The study further aims to examine the status of entrepreneurial outcomes while comprehending the intersection of the challenges of disability and entrepreneurship. The study draws on stakeholder and social identity theories to understand this critical connection. Design/methodology/approach A qualitative approach is applied to study the phenomenon. Semi-structured interviews were conducted with 13 EWDs and 5 ESOs to explore the challenges faced and the available support in the Indian context. The study explores the level of coordination and roles these organizations play in fostering an entrepreneurial culture for PWDs. Findings The research findings explore novel challenges and facilitators of entrepreneurial pursuits of EwDs. The study further offers implications for policymakers to foster inclusive infrastructure, financial institutions to provide accessible credit options, and ESOs to amplify tailored assistance. Importantly, these dynamics have implications for advancing relevant Sustainable Development Goals. Originality/value The intersectional lens of disability and entrepreneurial challenges offered to study PwD entrepreneurship highlights new directions for exploring the phenomenon in deeper detail. Further, the theoretical underpinnings of stakeholder and social identity theories provide practical and indispensable insights into the phenomenon.
Chapter
Full-text available
Depending on various factors in the workplace, employees are exposed to some effects such as stress and workload. The main purpose of this study is one way to explore whether stress and workload encountered in working life can cause many physical, mental, and spiritual effects on employees, and the other is determining which strategies can be developed regarding stress and workload. Within the scope of the study, concepts of stress and workload were defined within a literature review. This study tries to sort and classify which strategies could be used when faced with stress and workload. It is possible that effective strategies applied when encountering negative situations in organizations where the employees are able to cope with stress and workload will result in positive outcomes. Managing of both concepts is possible with the help of effective strategies.
Chapter
Depending on various factors in the workplace, employees are exposed to some effects such as stress and workload. The main purpose of this study is one way to explore whether stress and workload encountered in working life can cause many physical, mental, and spiritual effects on employees, and the other is determining which strategies can be developed regarding stress and workload. Within the scope of the study, concepts of stress and workload were defined within a literature review. This study tries to sort and classify which strategies could be used when faced with stress and workload. It is possible that effective strategies applied when encountering negative situations in organizations where the employees are able to cope with stress and workload will result in positive outcomes. Managing of both concepts is possible with the help of effective strategies.
Article
Full-text available
La problemática del acoso sexual laboral a las mujeres con discapacidad particularidades específicas como la doble vulnerabilidad (ser mujer y tener discapacidad), la falta de reconocimiento social de los derechos sexuales y reproductivos, la invisibilización del colectivo en los datos estadísticos en los Ministerios. Por consiguiente, el objetivo general de la presente investigación cualitativa es determinar si la normativa laboral peruana respeta, promueve y asegura el derecho a las mujeres con discapacidad a un trabajo libre de violencia y acoso en conformidad con el Convenio N°190 de la OIT. Es por ello que la herramienta de recolección de datos será 01 cuestionario aplicado a 30 mujeres con discapacidad. Por ultimo, El problema del acoso sexual en el trabajo de las mujeres con discapacidad tiene características específicas como la doble vulnerabilidad (ser mujer y tener una discapacidad), la falta de reconocimiento social de los derechos sexuales y reproductivos, y la invisibilidad del grupo en los datos estadísticos de los Ministerios. Por lo tanto, el objetivo general de esta investigación cualitativa es determinar si la legislación laboral peruana respeta, promueve y garantiza el derecho de las mujeres con discapacidad al trabajo libre de violencia y acoso de acuerdo con el Convenio 190 de la OIT. La herramienta de recolección de datos será un cuestionario aplicado a 30 mujeres con discapacidad.
Chapter
Depending on various factors in the workplace, employees are exposed to some effects such as stress and workload. The main purpose of this study is one way to explore whether stress and workload encountered in working life can cause many physical, mental, and spiritual effects on employees, and the other is determining which strategies can be developed regarding stress and workload. Within the scope of the study, concepts of stress and workload were defined within a literature review. This study tries to sort and classify which strategies could be used when faced with stress and workload. It is possible that effective strategies applied when encountering negative situations in organizations where the employees are able to cope with stress and workload will result in positive outcomes. Managing of both concepts is possible with the help of effective strategies.
Book
Full-text available
QUALITY CHANGES THROUGH RESEARCH– EXPERIENCES, EXPECTATIONS & ENHANCEMENT Editors DR.P.R.MUTHUSWAMY Conference Director & Principal Dr.N.G.P.Arts & Science College DR.V.RAMAKRISHNAN Conference Director & Principal Dr.N.G.P.College of Education DR.S.SARAVANAN Organising Secretary& Head, Commerce (IT) Dr.N.G.P.Arts & Science College DR.V.SHANMUGARAJU Organising Secretary& Head, Biotechnology Dr.N.G.P.Arts & Science College K.JAISHREE Joint Secretary& Assistant Professor Dr.N.G.P.College of Education K.PRABHU Joint Secretary& Assistant Professor Dr.N.G.P.College of Education
Thesis
Réduire la stigmatisation des personnes en situation de handicap est un enjeu de société important mais complexe, qui nécessite des interventions efficaces. Cette question de la stigmatisation préoccupe également les entreprises. Pour favoriser l'accès à l'emploi des personnes en situation de handicap et leur maintien en emploi, il semble nécessaire de réduire leur stigmatisation. Les travaux de recherche sur les relations intergroupes des cinquante dernières années ont montré que les personnes en contact avec des membres exogroupes, réduisent les stéréotypes et préjugés à leur égard, dès les premiers contacts, et face à des groupes variés. Par la suite, d'autres études se sont intéressées au contact indirect comme le contact via une vidéo ou le contact imaginé. Ces contacts indirects seraient également efficaces pour réduire les préjugés face à un exogroupe, mais parfois dans une moindre mesure. Pour renforcer les études sur le contact intergroupe comme moyen de réduire les préjugés face au handicap, nos travaux se sont intéressés aux contacts imaginé, vidéo et incarné, avec comme objectif d'adresser certaines limites existantes dans ce champ de recherche. La thèse principale défendue ici stipule que les effets du contact imaginé, relevant principalement de l'élaboration et de l'imagination, se maintiendraient à long terme. De plus, outre la réduction des préjugés par un changement de perspective cognitive (i.e. contact vidéo et imaginé), le changement de perspective corporelle serait également un moyen efficace de réduire les préjugés (i.e. contact incarné). Ces interventions sont efficaces pour réduire les préjugés face au handicap chez des salariés d'entreprise, et donc généralisables hors du milieu sanitaire et médico-social. Pour soutenir cette thèse, les effets du contact imaginé ont été étudiés en lien avec le niveau d'élaboration cognitive de la tâche d'imagination, afin de comprendre la place de ce processus dans la diminution des attitudes négatives face à la maladie mentale (étude 1). Les effets du contact imaginé ont ensuite été étudiés à moyen terme (étude 2) puis, afin d'en généraliser au maximum les effets, à plus long terme et chez des salariés (étude 3). Le contact vidéo a également été étudié à court, moyen et long terme chez des salariés (étude 3). Par la suite, une action de sensibilisation proposée en entreprise, visant à permettre aux salariés de changer de perspective à un niveau corporel, en réalisant un atelier de cuisine en situation de handicap, a été testée (étude 4). Enfin, de façon plus exploratoire et fondamentale, le contact incarné a été étudié par la mise en situation de handicap dans une tâche d'immobilisation, chez des étudiants (étude 5).Nos résultats ont permis de renforcer la validité du contact imaginé, comme relevant principalement de l'imagination et de l'élaboration dans la tâche, et de fait pas d'un effet de demande expérimentale. Les effets du contact imaginé sur la réduction de la stigmatisation de la maladie mentale ont également été montrés à long terme, sur plus de six mois, et ont été généralisés à des salariés d'une grande entreprise du secteur de l'énergie (i.e. hors du secteur sanitaire et médico-social). Toutefois, le contact imaginé n'a pas permis de réduire les biais implicites face à la maladie mentale dans notre étude et les effets du contact vidéo semblent faibles. En outre, le contact incarné semble une piste prometteuse pour réduire les attitudes implicites face au handicap. Cette thèse CIFRE avait également pour objectif de proposer le contenu d'un outil de formation en ligne, à destination de tous les salariés de l'entreprise (GRDF). Ce cahier des charges a été rédigé au regard des résultats de ces travaux, et plus largement des avancées scientifiques dans le champ des relations intergroupes. Finalement, l'ensemble de ces résultats est discuté et des pistes de recherches futures sont proposées.
Chapter
La recherche en sciences de gestion s’intéresse au comportement en entreprise des travailleurs handicapés. Elle compare leur performance à celle des travailleurs non handicapés et propose des explications des différences observées, notamment en termes de satisfaction au travail. Mais des problèmes d’ordre méthodologique portant sur les données et les échelles de mesure limitent la portée des résultats de ses travaux. Les auteurs du présent chapitre se proposent de reprendre entièrement la question de la performance des personnes handicapées, dans une optique de comparaison avec les personnes non handicapées. Ils retiennent les principaux construits du comportement organisationnel ainsi que leurs échelles de mesure les plus reconnues par la littérature. Ils fournissent un questionnaire à 420 personnes handicapées et 462 personnes non handicapées. Ils mènent ainsi une recherche quantitative exploratoire et discutent de leur résultat principal : l’existence d’une dynamique de performance chez les personnes handicapées.
Chapter
This chapter embarks from the increasing number of disabled individuals in private companies and public institutions and examines the working conditions of disabled employees in these organizations. Although this case is relevant to a considerable number of international contexts, the author focuses on Turkey as a case, illustrative of countries going through similar processes. The author starts by providing an introduction followed by literature on organizational culture. Next, the author discusses the recent legislation regarding the employment of disabled individuals and discusses with literature on their workplace performance. Next, the author focuses on the relationships between the organizational culture and workplace performance of disabled employees. Finally, the author concludes by recommendations for future practice to enhance performance of disabled employees and future research to conduct robust studies in the area. The chapter assumes that organizations can enhance performance of everyone by creating an inclusive culture surrounded by elements involving positive attitudes, equity, equality, and beliefs of productivity.
Article
Full-text available
Even when they are able to secure employment, people with cognitive disabilities typically encounter significant difficulties in the workplace. In this paper, we focus on Mixed-Ability workplaces: work settings in which people without disabilities and with different types of disabilities collaborate on a daily basis. The case study for our exploratory research is a university library that has been able to support a mixed-ability work setting for over four years. We describe how a theory from cognitive linguistics (Conceptual Metaphor Theory) can be used to explore the challenges that people encounter in mixed-ability workplaces, identify the cognitive processes that differ between neurotypical team leaders and workers with cognitive disabilities, and translate these findings into design recommendations for embodied technologies that support mixed-ability workplaces.
Article
Full-text available
Literatura dotycząca zarządzania niepełnosprawnymi pracownikami koncentruje się głównie na zagadnieniach związanych z początkowym okresem ich funkcjonowania w organizacjach. Najczęściej opisywany jest etap rekrutacji i selekcji. Niewiele wiadomo na temat sposobów motywowania tej grupy pracowników. Autorka stawia pytanie, czy osoby niepełnosprawne i ich bezpośredni przełożeni postrzegają zagadnienie motywowania pracowników w organizacjach w podobny sposób? Jaki rodzaj motywatorów stosowany jest wobec niepełnosprawnych pracowników i ich pełnosprawnych kolegów? Jakiej motywacji potr zebują osoby niepełnosprawne? W artykule zaprezentowano wyniki analizy badania kwestionariuszowego pracowników z niepełnosprawnością (92 osoby) oraz ich bezpośrednich przełożonych (50 osób) zatrudnionych w przedsiębiorstwach otwartego rynku pracy. Wyniki wskazują na pewne rozbieżności w sposobach motywowania osób niepełnosprawnych przez obie badane grupy.
Article
The article examines the link between workplace disability (WD) and workplace job satisfaction (JS) using data from WERS2011. Controlling for a rich set of workplace characteristics including organisational culture, the study finds a significant negative relationship between JS and the share of disabled respondents within workplaces. Notably, Seemingly Unrelated Regression (SUR)-based analysis distinguishing between disabled and non-disabled respondents reveals that the negative relationship found is specific to non-disabled respondents. Moreover, disability equality policies are found to be significantly positively related with disabled respondents’ JS while they are negatively related with the JS of their non-disabled counterparts. The article ponders if there is a co-worker aspect to the WD–JS link and whether HR policies may need to take heed of co-worker dynamics in this respect.
Article
The wage gap between workers with and without a disability has been widely documented. However, wages and salaries account for less than 70% of the total hourly cost of compensation for an average U.S. worker. In this study, we construct a measure of total compensation by linking the American Community Survey to a restricted‐access version of the Employer Cost for Employee Compensation database, which contains detailed benefit measures for the years 2008–2014. After controlling for selection into full‐time employment and other observed characteristics, we find that the percentage total compensation gap between full‐time male workers with and without a disability is substantially larger than the percentage wage and salary gap. The opposite pattern is observed for full‐time female workers. Our results suggest that considering only wage and salary may mask the true gaps in total compensation from employment. We also document a persistent benefits gap between workers with and without a disability. We discuss possible explanatory factors for the observed patterns in total compensation and benefit gaps.
Article
Objective To evaluate the measurement structure of the Job Satisfaction of Persons with Disabilities Scale (JSPDS) in a sample of employed U.S. Americans with disabilities. Design A quantitative descriptive design using exploratory factor analysis (EFA) and correlational analysis. Participants Two hundred and fifty-nine individuals with disabilities who were employed at least 10 hours per week. Results The EFA indicated a two-factor structure accounting for 42.99% of the total variance. The internal consistency reliability coefficients for the Integrated Work Environment and Job Quality factors were .87 and .74 respectively. Both factors correlated with selected employment and well-being variables in logical directions. Conclusion The two-factor measurement structure of the JSPDS appears to be valid and interpretable, and can be used in research and clinical settings in order to develop effective strategies for long-term employment success of people with disabilities.
Article
L’objectif de cette enquête est d’explorer le statut d’emploi et les caractéristiques d’intégration dans l’emploi des étudiants ayant des incapacités et ayant obtenu un diplôme de l’Université Laval. L’enquête cible tous les diplômés ayant au moins une incapacité et ayant été soutenus par le Centre d’aide aux étudiants entre 2007 et 2015. Les répondants (n=78) ont été rejoints au moyen d’un sondage en ligne auto-administré. Les résultats obtenus indiquent qu’une majorité de diplômés (62,8 %) accèdent à l’emploi et que leur intégration s’effectue généralement sans difficulté (75,5 %), et ce, avec une aide à la recherche d’emploi peu sollicitée (9,6 %). Les emplois obtenus sont de bonne qualité et en lien avec la formation (75,5 %). Nos résultats suggèrent que les stages contribuent à une meilleure intégration. Ils suggèrent également que le besoin d’accommodement pour les étudiants ayant des incapacités lors du cheminement universitaire s’expliquerait davantage par les contraintes qui s’appliquent aux modalités d’enseignement et d’évaluation. L’absence de ces contraintes une fois en emploi permettrait à ces mêmes étudiants de performer dans l’emploi sans accommodement ou presque.
Article
Purpose The purpose of this paper is to quantify the labor market outcomes of people with disabilities (PwD) in Indonesia and compares them to people without disabilities. It first studies the labor force participation of PwD before examining the large and persistent wage gaps they face. It explores whether these wage gaps are explained by differences in productivity, a distinction which has important implications for policies addressing these gaps. Design/methodology/approach The analysis is based on the Indonesian Family Life Survey Wave 5, which includes unique questions allowing for several definitions of disability. Multinomial logistic regression is used to study differences in type of employment for PwD. Wage gaps are estimated and corrected for selection using propensity score matching, supported by a Heckman selection model and Oaxaca–Blinder decomposition. Comparisons with other physically disadvantaged subgroups and the analysis of heterogeneity by job requirements and sector of work explore whether productivity gaps help explain wage gaps. Findings PwD generally have lower unconditional labor force participation, but disparities largely disappear when controlling for characteristics. Moreover, patterns vary depending on whether the measure of disability used depends on prior medical diagnosis. PwD that do not require prior diagnosis tend to work in more vulnerable employment. When they are employed for wages, people with these types of disabilities face lower wages, up to 22% lower. Meanwhile, (surprisingly) those with medically diagnosed conditions face no difference or a wage premium. This paper finds compelling evidence that, where a wage penalty exists, a substantial part is unexplained by observable characteristics. Originality/value Previous literature on disability has been mostly based on studies of high-income economies. This paper extends the literature to Indonesia, which differs from high-income contexts due to lack of mental healthcare resources and assistive technologies, as well as weaker rule of law. It provides unique insights based on types of disability and the salient dimensions of disability in the workplace. It also provides evidence that productivity differences do not explain the wage gap.
Article
Full-text available
A theory of social inequity, with special consideration given to wage inequities is presented. A special case of Festinger's cognitive dissonance, the theory specifies the conditions under which inequity will arise and the means by which it may be reduced or eliminated. Observational field studies supporting the theory and laboratory experiments designed to test certain aspects of it are described. (20 ref.) (PsycINFO Database Record (c) 2012 APA, all rights reserved)
Article
Full-text available
This paper attempts to test the hypothesis that utility depends on income relative to a ‘comparison’ or reference level. Using data on 5,000 British workers, it provides two findings. First, workers' reported satisfaction levels are shown to be inversely related to their comparison wage rates. Second, holding income constant, satisfaction levels are shown to be strongly declining in the level of education. More generally, the paper tries to help begin the task of constructing an economics of job satisfaction.
Article
Full-text available
I. Introduction, 589. — II. An optimal negative income tax model, 591. — III. The maximin criterion, 594. — IV. A utilitarian social objective, 597. — V. Conclusion, 598. Our theory … depends upon the validity of a single hypothesis, viz.: that the utility index is a function of relative rather than absolute consumption expenditure. — J. Duesenberry Income, Saving and the Theory of Consumer Behavior
Article
The level of job satisfaction of 236 workers with disabilities was examined, Workers expressed moderately positive general job satisfaction. Personal characteristics, experiences and job/employer characteristics were examined as predictors of job satisfaction. Sex, school background, vocational training, disability category and length of employment in present position were related to variability in job satisfaction. The relationship between job satisfaction and other aspects of transition is also explored.
Article
Presents the findings of a questionnaire sent to nine occupational groups where women predominate such as healthcare, teaching and childcare, together with other forms placed in day-care and women’s centres in Ontario. Looks at disability, personal demographics, the work situation, workplace stress, physical demands, psychosomatic symptoms, job satisfaction, insecurity, harassment and family pressures. Discusses findings suggesting that disabled women tend to have more negative work experiences, possibly due to previous education problems, discrimination and the nature of roles offered which lead to lower income levels in lower status roles.
Article
This paper examines differences in the level of job satisfaction reported by union workers and non-union employees. There is a strong belief in the literature that union status reduces job satisfaction. Based on different national probability samples, previous studies have generally failed to adequately control for differences in working conditions between the two sectors while studying the impacts of unions on job satisfaction. Union workers generally have a poorer working environment. The negative relationship reported between union status and job satisfaction might only reflect this differential if differences in working conditions are not taken into account. Using a large representative sample of 3,352 workers from the Canadian General Social Survey of 1989, this study replicates previous econometric specifications. The results of ordered-probit regression show a negative relationship between union status and job satisfaction, but as expected, this relationship disappears when an adequate control for differences in working conditions is applied. It is concluded that union status is not negatively associated with job satisfaction in Canada.
Article
Satisfaction with pay, promotions, co-workers, supervision and work conditions of 236 workers with disabilities was examined using the Job Descriptive Index. Workers with disabilities expressed strong dissatisfaction with pay and mild dissatisfaction with promotions. Workers also expressed mild satisfaction with work conditions and high satisfaction with supervision and co-workers. Personal characteristics and transitional experiences were examined as predictors of each area of job satisfaction through model comparison procedures. Analysis revealed that workers who had participated in transition programs that included the best practices of inclusive secondary education, extensive and early vocational education and continuing post-secondary education were more satisfied with the social contexts of their employment (supervision and co-workers) and with the actual work performed. Best practices were not related to satisfaction with pay or promotions.
Article
The level of job satisfaction of 236 workers with disabilities was examined. Workers expressed moderately positive general job satisfaction. Personal characteristics, experiences and job/employer characteristics were examined as predictors of job satisfaction. Sex, school background, vocational training, disability category and length of employment in present position were related to variability in job satisfaction. The relationship between job satisfaction and other aspects of transition is also explored.
Article
In initial cross-section estimates using data from the 1991-94 British Household Panel Study, the authors find that union members had lower overall job satisfaction than non-union members, and public sector workers had higher satisfaction than private ...
Book
'Conspicuous consumption of valuable goods is a means of reputability to the gentleman of leisure.' In The Theory of the Leisure Class Thorstein Veblen sets out 'to discuss the place and value of the leisure class as an economic factor in modern life'. In so doing he produced a landmark study of affluent American society that exposes, with brilliant ruthlessness, the habits of production and waste that link invidious business tactics and barbaric social behaviour. Veblen's analysis of the evolutionary process sees greed as the overriding motive in the modern economy; with an impartial gaze he examines the human cost paid when social institutions exploit the consumption of unessential goods for the sake of personal profit. Fashion, beauty, animals, sports, the home, the clergy, scholars - all are assessed for their true usefulness and found wanting. The targets of Veblen's coruscating satire are as evident today as they were a century ago, and his book still has the power to shock and enlighten. Veblen's uncompromising arguments and the influential literary force of his writing are assessed in Martha Banta's Introduction.
Article
By most objective standards, women's jobs are worse than men's, yet women report higher levels of job satisfaction than do men. This paper uses a recent large-scale British survey to document the extent of this gender differential for eight measures of job satisfaction and to evaluate the proposition that identical men and women in identical jobs should be equally satisfied. Neither the different jobs that men and women do, their different work values, nor sample selection account for the gender satisfaction differential. The paper's proposed explanation appeals to the notion of relative well-being, especially relative to workers' expectations. An identical man and woman with the same jobs and expectations would indeed report identical job satisfaction, but women's expectations are argued to be lower than men's. This hypothesis is supported by the finding that the gender satisfaction differential disappears for the young, the higher-educated, professionals and those in male-dominated workplaces, for all of whom there is less likely to be a gender difference in job expectations.
Article
This paper studies optimal non-linear taxes in a world in which there is altruism and jealousy. A formula for optimal marginal tax rates is derived which turns out to be a simple and intuitively appealing extension of a result due to Mirrlees. The paper shows that in this sort of economy all of optimal tax theory's general results either no longer hold or need not hold, and it sets out appropriate modifications to standard tax rules.
Article
This paper provides a systematic empirical analysis of the effect of union membership on job satisfaction and wages, and shows how the interaction between these effects leads to empirically observable relations between unionization and individual quit probabilities. Using the National Longitudinal Survey of Mature Men, several empirical results were obtained. First, union members, on average, report lower levels of job satisfaction. Interestingly, unionization causes greater dissatisfaction at higher tenure levels. These findings are attributed to both the politicization of the unionized labor force and the fact that union members face flatter earnings profiles. The importance of the latter effect is reflected by the empirical fact that unions have a strong negative effect on quit probabilities at low levels of tenure, but the effect diminishes (absolutely) as tenure increases.
Article
Thesis (Ph. D.)--University of Toronto, 1996. Includes bibliographical references (p. 248-257). Photocopy.
Article
The paper addresses the question whether utility may be viewed as a completely relative concept. In a dynamic setting this means that one has to model both habit formation and utility interdependence. The resulting model contains unobservable variables and requires panel data to be estimated. Using the first two waves of an annual panel in The Netherlands, different specifications of the model are estimated, involving alternative sets of identifying restrictions. It turns out that the data are compatible with the hypothesis that utility is completely relative, but we cannot exclude the possibility that utility is partly relative and partly absolute.
Article
This paper introduces the fair wage-effort hypothesis and explores its implications. This hypothesis is motivated by equity theory in social psychology and social exchange theory in sociology. According to the fair wage-effort hypothesis, workers proportionately withdraw effort as their actual wage falls short of their fair wage. Such behavior causes unemployment and is also consistent with observed cross-section wage differentials and unemployment patterns.
Article
This paper examines the assoication between Canadian unions and their member' attitudes. Data on job satisfaction indicate that unionized workers in Canada are less happy with the quality of their jobs than non-union workers. The former, however, are more satisfied with their financial compensation and job security than non-members.
Article
This paper examines differences in the reported job satisfaction of union members and nonmembers using a multiple equation model that treats union membership, wage rates, and reported satisfaction as endogenously determined. The results indicate that union members differ from nonmembers in how they assess their satisfaction with supervision, co-workers, and job content. Consistent with prior research, union members are found to report lower levels of satisfaction than nonmembers. Although many studies have attributed such findings to the availability of the "voice" option in unionized settings, analyses of the effects of employer tenure and grievance procedure use lend only partial support to the "exit-voice" hypothesis. (Abstract courtesy JSTOR.)
Article
This paper considers job satisfaction in the academic labour market drawing upon a particularly detailed data set of 900 academics from five traditional Scottish Universities. Recent studies have revealed that in the labour force as a whole women generally express themselves as more satisfied with their jobs than men. Our results show that reports of overall job satisfaction do not vary widely by gender. This result is explained through the nature of our dataset, limited as it is to a highly educated workforce, in which female workers are likely to have job expectations comparable to their male counterparts. Ordered probit analysis is used to analyse the determinants of an academic's overall satisfaction at work as well as satisfaction with promotion prospects, job security and salary. Comparison salary is found to be an important influence on academics' overall job satisfaction although evidence suggests that academics place a lower emphasis on pecuniary relative to non pecuniary aspects of work than other sectors of the workforce. Copyright 2000 by Scottish Economic Society.
Article
This paper examines sex differences in job satisfaction by utilizing data from the 1986 UK Social and Economic Life Initiative (SCELI) household survey. It attempts to ascertain the relationship between actual and comparison pay and job satisfaction. Employees were asked on a 0-10 scale how satisfied or dissatisfied they were with their present job. They were also asked to state whether they were equitably, over or underpaid and to say how much pay they thought they deserved. Uniquely, therefore, we are able to analyse the effects of both actual and objective and subjective comparative pay measures on job satisfaction. The paper rejects the view that the higher expressed job satisfaction of women represents an innate difference rather than the results of self&dash;selection into jobs with highly valued attributes. Copyright Fondazione Giacomo Brodolini and Blackwell Publishers Ltd 2000.
Article
Members of trade unions express greater dissatisfaction with the conditions of their jobs than nonmembers. Alternative explanations of this are examined. It is argued that Richard B. Freeman and James L. Medoff's (1984) "voice" model of trade unionism does not provide a satisfactory account of the dissatisfaction expressed by unionists in the Australian youth labor market. Evidence is presented to suggest that the negative relationship between job satisfaction and unionism may be attributable to unpleasant work environments, which both induce dissatisfaction and motivate workers to join unions. Copyright 1990 by Blackwell Publishers Ltd/University of Adelaide and Flinders University of South Australia
Article
The purpose of this paper is to examine these concerns and evaluate the use of job satisfaction (and other subjective variables) in labor market analysis. The main theme is that, while there are good reasons to treat subjective variables gingerly, the answers to questions about how people feel toward their job are not meaningless but rather convey useful information about economic life that should not be ignored. The paper begins with a brief description of the satisfaction questions on major worker surveys, and then considers the use of satisfaction as an independent and as a dependent variable. Satisfaction is shown to be a major determinant of labor market mobility, in part it is argued because it reflects aspects of the work place not captured by standard objective variable8. Satisfaction is also found to depend anomolously on some economic variables (such as unionism) in ways that provide insight into how those factors affect people.
Social and Psychological Foundations of Economic Analysis, Harvester Wheatsheaf Job satisfaction, wages, and unions
  • J Baxter
  • Ny
  • G Borjas
Baxter, J. (1988), Social and Psychological Foundations of Economic Analysis, Harvester Wheatsheaf, New York, NY. Borjas, G. (1979), " Job satisfaction, wages, and unions ", Journal of Human Resources, Vol. 14 No. 1, pp. 21-40.
Econometric Analysis Regression Estimation from Grouped Observations
  • W Greene
Greene, W. (1993), Econometric Analysis, 2nd ed., Macmillan, New York, NY. Haitovsky, Y. (1973), Regression Estimation from Grouped Observations, Griffin, London.
Social behaviour: Its Elementary Forms The Economic Well Being and Labour Market Activity of Persons with Disabilities in Canada, Employment Equity Data Program
  • G Homans
  • Ny
  • D Hum
  • W Simpson
Homans, G. (1961), Social behaviour: Its Elementary Forms, Harcourt Brace, New York, NY. Hum, D. and Simpson, W. (1993), The Economic Well Being and Labour Market Activity of Persons with Disabilities in Canada, Employment Equity Data Program, Statistics Canada, Ottawa.
Changes at Work, Department of Workplace Relations and Small Business
  • A Morehead
  • M Steele
  • M Alexander
  • K Stephen
  • L Duffin
Morehead, A., Steele, M., Alexander, M., Stephen, K. and Duffin, L. (1997), Changes at Work, Department of Workplace Relations and Small Business, Canberra.
Union effects on job satisfaction
  • S Schwochau
Schwochau, S. (1987), " Union effects on job satisfaction ", Industrial and Labour Relations Review, Vol. 40, pp. 209-24.
The Economic Well Being and Labour Market Activity of Persons with Disabilities in Canada, Employment Equity Data Program
  • D Hum
  • W Simpson
Hum, D. and Simpson, W. (1993), The Economic Well Being and Labour Market Activity of Persons with Disabilities in Canada, Employment Equity Data Program, Statistics Canada, Ottawa.
Relative Deprivation and Social Justice
  • W Runciman
  • Kegan Routledge
  • Paul
  • Henley
  • S Schwochau
Runciman, W. (1966), Relative Deprivation and Social Justice, Routledge and Kegan Paul, Henley. Schwochau, S. (1987), "Union effects on job satisfaction", Industrial and Labour Relations Review, Vol. 40, pp. 209-24.
Public Use Microdata File Documentation and User's Guide
  • R Solow
Solow, R. (1990), The Labour Market as a Social Institution, Basil Blackwell, Oxford. Statistics Canada (1992), General Social Survey, Cycle 6, 1991, Public Use Microdata File Documentation and User's Guide, 1991, Statistics Canada, Ottawa.
General Social Survey: An Overview, Housing, Family and Social Statistics Division
Statistics Canada (2000), General Social Survey: An Overview, Housing, Family and Social Statistics Division, Statistics Canada, Ottawa.
Relative Deprivation and Social Justice, Routledge and Kegan Paul
  • W Runciman
Three essays on disability
  • S Uppal