ArticlePDF Available

Norwegian airline passengers are not more afraid of flying after the terror act of September 11. The flight anxiety, however, is significantly attributed to acts of terrorism

Authors:

Abstract and Figures

The aim of this paper is to study: (1) the prevalence of flight anxiety among Norwegian airline passengers; (2) situations that may be of concern during flights and situations not related to flying; (3) whether passengers feel more afraid after the terror act of September 11, 2001; and (4) whether passengers were more afraid in 2002 than in 1986.A questionnaire was distributed during domestic flights in Norway in 1986 and 2002. To asses flight anxiety, a six point scale was used, from 0 = not afraid at all, to 5 = always very afraid, and sometimes avoid flying because of that. A 10-cm visual analogue scale (VAS) was used to measure the degree of anxiety. There were 50.8% who were not afraid at all. There were 12 women (5.2%) and one man (0.4%) with flight phobia. However, 22 (4.5%) had cancelled flights because of anxiety during the last two years. Situations that caused most concern during flights were turbulence and fear of terrorism and highjacking. After September 11, 48% were not more afraid, 38% a little more, 10% moderately, 3% rather much and 2% very much. The passengers, however, were not more afraid of flying in 2002 than in 1986. About 3% of Norwegian airline passengers have a flight phobia. Women are significantly more concerned than men. The impact of the terror act September 11, 2001 was rather moderate. The level of flight anxiety among Norwegian airline passengers was not significantly different in 2002 and 1986.
Content may be subject to copyright.
Personality and Social Psychology
Norwegian airline passengers are not more afraid of flying after the
terror act of September 11. The flight anxiety, however, is significantly
attributed to acts of terrorism
ØIVIND EKEBERG,
1
BERIT FAUSKE
2
and BENTE BERG-HANSEN
3,
1
Department of Acute Medicine Oslo University Hospital, Ulleval, and Department of Behavioral Sciences in Medicine, Faculty of Medicine,
University of Oslo, Norway
2
Sydsiden Legesenter, Tønne Huitfeldtsplass 2, 1767, Halden, Norway
3
SAS, 0080, Oslo, Norway
Ekeberg, Ø., Fauske, B. & Berg-Hansen, B. (2014). Norwegian airline passengers are not more afraid of ying after the terror act of September 11.
The ight anxiety, however, is signicantly attributed to acts of terrorism. Scandinavian Journal of Psychology 55, 464468.
The aim of this paper is to study: (1) the prevalence of ight anxiety among Norwegian airline passengers; (2) situations that may be of concern during
ights and situations not related to ying; (3) whether passengers feel more afraid after the terror act of September 11, 2001; and (4) whether passen-
gers were more afraid in 2002 than in 1986.A questionnaire was distributed during domestic ights in Norway in 1986 and 2002. To asses ight anxi-
ety, a six point scale was used, from 0 = not afraid at all, to 5 = always very afraid, and sometimes avoid ying because of that. A 10-cm visual
analogue scale (VAS) was used to measure the degree of anxiety. There were 50.8% who were not afraid at all. There were 12 women (5.2%) and one
man (0.4%) with ight phobia. However, 22 (4.5%) had cancelled ights because of anxiety during the last two years. Situations that caused most con-
cern during ights were turbulence and fear of terrorism and highjacking. After September 11, 48% were not more afraid, 38% a little more, 10% mod-
erately, 3% rather much and 2% very much. The passengers, however, were not more afraid of ying in 2002 than in 1986. About 3% of Norwegian
airline passengers have a ight phobia. Women are signicantly more concerned than men. The impact of the terror act September 11, 2001 was rather
moderate. The level of ight anxiety among Norwegian airline passengers was not signicantly different in 2002 and 1986.
Key words: Airline passengers, anxiety, ying, phobia, travel.
Øivind Ekeberg, Department of Acute Medicine Oslo University Hospital, Ulleval, Box 4950 Nydalen, 0424 Oslo. Tel: +47 22 11 73 00;
e-mail: oivind.ekeberg@ous-hf.no
Present address: Krusesvingen 4, 2050, Jessheim, Norway.
INTRODUCTION
There are only a few studies on the prevalence of ight anxi-
ety, especially among airline passengers. Most are population
studies, where questionnaires are mailed to the subjects at
home. We are only aware of one study among passengers
made during ight (Ekeberg, Seeberg & Ellertsen, 1988). On
the other hand, there are many studies on different kinds of
treatment for those who suffer from ight anxiety (Van Gerwen
& Diekstra, 2000).
In the study among airline passengers, (Ekeberg et al., 1988)
found that 48% of the respondents reported some ight anxiety
and 2% were considered to have ight phobia. Women were sig-
nicantly more affected than men. In a study on the prevalence
of ight anxiety in Norway, we found that some degree of ight
anxiety was reported by 46% (Ekeberg, Seeberg & Ellertsen,
1989). There were 8% who were considered ight phobics, as
they reported to be always very afraid, but never avoid ying
because of it or never y because of ight anxiety, 14%
among women and 3% men. Nordlund (1983) found that 20
30% of the Swedish population experienced considerable dis-
comfort on each ight, 50% were apprehensive about ying and
10% did not dare to y at all. Arnarson (1987) found that less
than 10% of males and about a quarter of female Icelanders suf-
fered from intense fear of ying. Wilhelm and Roth (1997)
found that 2030% of the US population was apprehensive
about ying. Fredrikson, Annas, Fisher and Wik (1996) found
the point prevalence for DSM-IV (American Psychiatric
Association, 1994) simple phobia (ying) to be 2.6%. In an old
American study, Agras, Sylvester and Oliveau (1969) found that
20% had a moderate and 10% an intense fear of ying. A
German study showed that 15% of the German population has
this fear and that an additional 20% are apprehensive while
ying (M
uhlberger, Herrmann, Wiedemann, Ellgring & Pauli,
2001). In all these studies, women reported more ight anxiety.
Ekeberg et al. (1988, 1989) found that discomfort was mainly
caused by turbulence during ight and heights in situations other
than ying. On the other hand, there are many studies on differ-
ent kinds of treatment for those who suffer from ight anxiety
(Van Gerwen & Diekstra, 2000; Van Gerwen, Diekstra, Arondeus
& Wolfger, 2004).
Another topic to study is whether occurrences like the terror
act of September 11, 2001 made passengers more afraid of ying.
Many articles were written about September 11, but we have only
found one related to fear of ying. M
uhlberger, Alpers and Pauli
(2005), found that the number of German airline passengers
declined sharply in the months following the attacks. Most air-
lines in the US and Europe reported a noticeable decline in the
number of passengers after the attacks, probably a consequence
of this having been a prominent topic in the US and European
© 2014 Oslo University Hospital. Scandinavian Journal of Psychology published by Scandinavian Psychological Associations and John Wiley & Sons Ltd.
This is an open access article under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivs License, which permits use and
distribution in any medium, provided the original work is properly cited, the use is non-commercial and no modications or adaptations are made.
Scandinavian Journal of Psychology, 2014, 55, 464468 DOI: 10.1111/sjop.12137
media. In Germany there was a 5080% increase in cancellations
due to passengers reporting sick in the four months after the
attacks. Was this a result of increased fear of ying? Because
they had coincidentally collected data for the standardization of
the German version of the Fear of Flying Scale in the months
before September 11, they were able to examine whether the
prevalence of fear of ying increased in Germany as a conse-
quence of the attacks. They found no evidence for an increase in
fear of ying. They did not observe an increase in avoidance of
ights, other specic ying-related fears, or trait anxiety in the
wake of the September 11 attacks. Other studies have also shown
a decline in airline passengers after September 11, among those
Ito and Lee (2005) and Gigerenzer (2004).
The aims of this study are to investigate:
1. the prevalence of ight anxiety among Norwegian airline
passengers;
2. how this prevalence relates to sociodemographic variables;
3. what kinds of concerns are related to ight anxiety during
ights;
4. the passengers opinion about the frequency of ight acci-
dents, the mortality when accidents occur and whether air
trafc authorities do enough to ensure safety;
5. whether passengers feel more afraid after the terror act of
September 11, 2001; and
6. were Norwegian airline passengers more afraid of ying in
2002 than in 1986?
METHODS
Procedure
The study was conducted during the period October 2730, 2002, in coop-
eration with the Norwegian airline Braathens (later absorbed by SAS). This
is the same airline as in the study in 1986 (Ekeberg et al., 1988). Fifteen
Norwegian domestic ights were randomly selected to cover unequal days
and all hours. On each ight, 50 questionnaires were to be distributed by
the cabin attendants to random passengers while seated. They were
informed to try to limit the distribution to passengers in the age group 18
70 years and to invite passengers seated on aisle, middle or window seats
and front, middle or back in the cabin to get a representative sample. If
there were less than 50 passengers, the number of distributed question-
naires should be registered in order to assess the response rate. The ques-
tionnaires were collected by the cabin crew after landing. The cabin crew
received written and verbal information on the procedures and that it was
approved by the airline company. The passengers got written information
about the purpose of the study and that it was approved by the company.
The written information pointed out that it was voluntary to participate and
that all responses were anonymous. There were no names or other informa-
tion that might identify the respondents.
Participants
On the 15 ights, 606 questionnaires were distributed, 1950 question-
naires on each ight, and 484 participated (79.7%), with 48.1% women
(mean age 40.8 years, range 1378) and 51.9% men (mean age
43.0 years, range 1878).
The majority of the passengers were married (47.5%) or cohabitants
(18.8%), whereas 21.1% were single. There were 91.5% who had
children, and 83.5% were in regular work. There were 60.5% who had
to y in connection with their work, 45.0% of the women and 74.8% of
the men (chi-square = 21.2, p < 0.001).
There were 2.5% who had not own during the last two years,
whereas 8.2% had own more than 50 times (Table 1).
Comparisons with the level of ight anxiety in Norway 1986 were
made by using the same questionnaire (Ekeberg et al., 1988) in addition
to new questions on the impact of the September 11, 2001 terror acts in
the USA, safety measures at the airports and air safety.
Assessments
The questionnaire contained 47 items. Ten items covered background
variables like gender, age, marital and occupational status, number of
children and ight habits.
A 10-cm visual analogue scale (VAS) was used to measure the degree
of 21 possible concerns in relation to a ight, like re in an engine,
engine trouble, foreign objects in the engine, unfamiliar sounds, terror
acts etc. The end points (0 = no anxiety and 10 = maximum anxiety)
were verbally anchored.
In addition, the subjects were asked to indicate their anxiety on the
VAS for six situations not related to ying, namely, riding elevators, big
gatherings, enclosement, walking across open spaces, traveling by bus/
train and heights, as these are situations that commonly may cause anxi-
ety without necessarily being related to ight anxiety.
The degree of ight anxiety was assessed on a six point scale ranging
from 0 = not afraid at all, 1 = sometimes a little afraid, 2 = always a lit-
tle afraid, 3 = sometimes very afraid, 4 = always very afraid, but never
cancel ights because of that and 5 = always very afraid, and sometimes
avoid ying because of that. Grades 4 and 5 were considered at the level
of ight phobia. Those who were afraid should also answer three ques-
tions concerning (a) the duration of the anxiety, (b) whether the fear was
caused by a frightening ight experience and (c) whether they became
more afraid after having children (yes/no).
The passengers were asked if they had become more afraid of
ying after the terror acts at the World Trade Center and Pentagon on
September 11, 2001 and to what degree they feel that the airport staff
and airline companies do enough to ensure safety, measured on a ve
point Likert scale from 1 = not at all to 5 = very much. Finally, there
were two items about air safety. The passengers should choose one of
seven alternatives and answer how often they believed that a passenger
aircraft in scheduled traf c were involved in accidents and estimate the
percentage of fatalities in an average plane crash.
Statistics
Comparisons between groups were made using students t-test,
chi-square, Mann-Whitney U, Kruskal-Wallis and Pearsons correlation
coefcient. Data are presented as means +/ SE. P < 0.05 was consid-
ered statistically signicant. Data were analyzed with SPSS version 15
(IBM, Chicago, IL).
Ethics
The anonymous study was approved by the airline company SAS.
Table 1. Number of ights the last two years according to gender
Men% Women% Total%
0 1.6 3.5 2.5
110 33.0 55.8 44.1
1120 23.5 25.1 24.3
2150 23.9 11.3 17.7
More than 50 13.6 2.6 8.2
Several times, but no specic
number of ights
4.5 1.7 3.2
Total 100.1 100.0 100.0
© 2014 Oslo University Hospital. Scandinavian Journal of Psychology published by Scandinavian Psychological Associations and John Wiley & Sons Ltd.
Flight anxiety among airline passengers 465Scand J Psychol 55 (2014)
RESULTS
Prevalence of ight anxiety according to sociodemographic
variables
There were 50.8% of the passengers who were not afraid of y-
ing at all (Table 2). Thirteen passengers (2.8%) were in grades 4
and 5, and were considered to have ight phobia, 12 (5.2%)
women and one (0.4%) man. Women reported signicantly more
ight anxiety than men (chi-square = 42.6, p < 0.001).
There were 22 (4.5%) who had cancelled at least one ight
because of ight anxiety during the last two years, 17 women
and ve men. Thirteen of these passengers were in grades 03.
Anxiety did not differ across age levels ( 29, 3049 and
50 years).
Of the passengers, 310 (46.8% women) answered the question
whether they had become more afraid of ying after having chil-
dren. Signicantly more women (21.4%) than men (3.0%) had
become quite much or very much more afraid after having
children (chi-square = 37.8, p < 0.001).
There were 84 (17.4%; 67% women) who answered the ques-
tion how many years they had been afraid of ying. Of these,
7.1% had been afraid less than one year and 70.2% for more than
10 years (73.2% of the women and 64.3% of the men, n.s.).
There were 94 (19.4%; 64% women) who answered the ques-
tion whether they had become more afraid after a frightening
ight, and 37.2% answered yes.
Situations that cause concern during ight
The scores for the passengers according to situations that cause
concern during ight were signicantly higher for women than
for men (Fig. 1). The items with the highest scores were: turbu-
lence 2.3, terrorism 2.2, highjacking 2.1, collision in air 2.1 and
foreign objects in the engine 2.0.
The mean anxiety score according to situations other than
ying was 1.0, signicantly higher for women (1.3) than for men
(0.7), t = 5.7, p < 0.001. The average scores were highest for
heights (2.9), riding elevators (0.8) and enclosement (0.8). There
was a medium, positive correlation (r = 0.31, p < 0.00), between
the degree of ight anxiety and anxiety in other situations.
Passengers
opinion about safety and ight accidents
Men felt signicantly more condent that airline companies
and airport staff do enough to ensure safety than women
((3.7 0.07 vs. 3.4 0.08), t = 3.17, p < 0.01). There were
15.7% who thought that only not at all or a little was made,
and 17.8% very much.
Table 2. Degree of ight anxiety according to gender
Women%
(n = 229)
Men%
(n = 247)
Total%
(n = 476)
Not afraid at all
(Grade 0)
36.7 64.0 50.8
Sometimes a little afraid
(Grade 1)
45.4 30.4 37.8
Always a little afraid
(Grade 2)
10.0 4.5 7.1
Sometimes very afraid
(Grade 3)
2.6 0.8 1.7
Always very afraid,
but never cancel ights
because of that (Grade 4)
3.1 0.0 1.5
Always very afraid, and
sometimes avoid ying
because of that (Grade 5)
2.2 0.4 1.3
Total 100.0 100.1 100.2
Note: Grades 4 and 5 in bold are considered ight phobia.
0
0,5
1
1,5
2
2,5
3
3,5
Fire in engine
Engine trouble
Engine fall of plane
Extraneous matter in engine
Wings break
Pressure falls in cabin
Collision in air
Turbulence
L
ightning in plane
Pilot
loses controll
Unknown sounds
W
heels puncture
Landing gear failure
The plane doesn` t climb
Miss the runway
Enclosement
No control
Afra
id of being ill
Lose controll/panic
Terror act
Capturing
Means Men
Means Women
Fig. 1. Discomfort during ights according to sex (mean and standard error).
© 2014 Oslo University Hospital. Scandinavian Journal of Psychology published by Scandinavian Psychological Associations and John Wiley & Sons Ltd.
466 Ø. Ekeberg et al. Scand J Psychol 55 (2014)
There were no signicant gender differences according to the
estimate of the frequency of ight accidents as 5,1% thought that
the frequency was 1 per 10 000 ights or more often whereas
70.9% thought that the frequency was from 1 per million or per
10 million. Among those with ight phobia (grades 4 and 5),
33.3% thought that the frequency was 1 per 10 000 or more
often, thus considering the risk signicantly higher than those
without phobia (chi-square = 62.3, p < 0.001).
Neither were there signicant gender differences concerning
the estimated mortality rate in an airplane accident. 42.7% esti-
mated the mortality rate to be more than 90%, and 17.9% 50%
or less. Among those with ight phobia, signicantly more
(91%) thought that the mortality rate was 90% or more
(chi-square = 8.3, p < 0.01).
More ight anxiety after the terror attacks September 11, 2001?
More women than men reported more ight anxiety after the
terror attacks against the World Trade Center and Pentagon,
USA on September 11, 2001, 8.7% and 1.3% respectively being
quite much, or very much more afraid of ying (chi-square =
36.8, p < 0.001) (Table 3).
Were Norwegian airline passengers more afraid of ying
in 2002 than in 1986?
As shown in Table 4, there were no signicant differences in the
level of ight anxiety in Norway in 1986 and 2002.
DISCUSSION
About one half of the airline passengers experience some degree
of apprehension during ight, and 2.8% were considered to have
ight phobia. Many other passengers experience some discom-
fort when ying, often related to specic situations, but not to
the level of ight phobia. It was not possible to make a formal
diagnosis of ight (specic) phobia with this study design. The
fact that 4.5% of the passengers had cancelled at least one ight
because of ight anxiety during the last two years indicates that
the estimated level of ight phobia is a minimum gure.
As people with ight phobia y less or not at all, the preva-
lence of ight anxiety is lower among airline passengers than in
the general population. The nding of 2.7% with ight phobia in
the present study and the ndings of Ekeberg et al. (1988) that
5% of the general Norwegian population never y because of
ight anxiety indicate that Fredrikson et al.s (1996) nding of
2.6% with ight phobia in the general Swedish population is
most likely an underestimate. The prevalence is expected to be
quite similar in the two neighbouring countries.
Women who y are signicantly more afraid than men. Their
ight anxiety more often increased after having children than
mens. Women were also more afraid in situations other than
ying. This is in accordance with the fact that symptoms of pho-
bias and anxiety are more common among women than men
(Van Gerwen & Diekstra, 2000). Fear and having a phobia is
not the same, but reect different levels of the same phenome-
non. Women may be more willing to admit fears and phobias.
The studies of Ekeberg et al. (1988, 1989), however, showed
that women seemed to report the same level of ight anxiety
when asked during ight or at home, whereas men reported
somewhat more anxiety during ight. After correcting for this
however, women still reported signicantly more ight anxiety.
Another reason may be that men y more often than women, in
particular related to their job. It is likely that those who y most
have less ight anxiety because they y more.
Only 37% attributed their ight anxiety to a speci c frighten-
ing ight. Thus, in the majority of cases, ight anxiety devel-
oped in the absence of a particular frightening event. This may
indicate that there has been a general apprehension of ying that
has been increasing. This is in accordance with the experience
that anxiety often is related to the fear of new attacks of anxiety,
that is, a negative snowball effect, even in the absence of a par-
ticularly frightening event. The nding that 70% of those with
ight anxiety had been afraid for more than 10 years shows that
there is a signicant risk of chronic concerns for those who do
not get help. We did not ask whether those who were afraid had
been seeking professional help.
Turbulence, foreign sounds, terrorism and highjacking caused
most concern during ight and nearly at the same degree. The
nding that turbulence is of major concern is in accordance with
previous studies (Ekeberg
et al., 1988, 1989). The nding that
the passengers were not more afraid than in 1986 indicates that
the passengers are more inclined to attribute their anxiety to ter-
rorism and highjacking, but that it has no effect on the total
level of ight anxiety.
Heights caused by far the most concern in situations other
than ying for both sexes, and particularly in women. This is
also in accordance with phobia and anxiety being more common
among women than men (Van Gerwen & Diekstra, 2000). In
general, the level of anxiety in other situations was quite low.
The moderate correlation between ight anxiety and anxiety in
Table 3. Inuence of the terror attacks 11.09.2001 on ight anxiety
Women%
(n = 208)
Men%
(n = 225)
Total%
(n = 433)
Not at all 34.6 60.0 47.8
A little 42.8 32.9 37.6
Moderate 13.9 5.8 9.7
Quite much 5.8 0.9 3.2
Very much 2.9 0.4 1.6
Total 100.0 100.0 99.9
Table 4. Degree of ight anxiety among Norwegian airline passengers
in 1986 and 2002
1986 (%)
(n = 300)
2002 (%)
(n = 476)
Grade 0 52 51
Grade 1 36 38
Grade 2 8 7
Grade 3 2 2
Grade 4 1 2
Grade 5 1 1
Total 100 101
Note: Grades 4 and 5 in bold are considered ight phobia.
© 2014 Oslo University Hospital. Scandinavian Journal of Psychology published by Scandinavian Psychological Associations and John Wiley & Sons Ltd.
Flight anxiety among airline passengers 467Scand J Psychol 55 (2014)
other situations may indicate that many people experience ight
anxiety without other concerns and vice versa.
The fatal accident rate per million departures for the world-
wide commercial jet eet 20022011 was 0.39 (www.boeing.
com). Accordingly, 70.9% of the passengers had a realistic view
of how often accidents happen. About 50% die in a ight acci-
dent (www.boeing.com). Among the passengers, there were
8.8% who believed that from 41%60% perished, whereas the
majority thought that over 70% died. Those with most anxiety
also had the greatest assessment of the risk.
The degree of ight anxiety among Norwegian passengers
was the same in 2002 as in 1986. The same questionnaire and
method were used. This indicates that attribution is important,
and that the passengers attribute their anxiety to terror acts like
September 11, or other possible events. The safety associated
with ights and airports is even better than in the 1980s, where
the last study was conducted. The number of ights has also
increased signicantly, but the level of anxiety among the
passengers is the same.
Strengths and limitations
A strength of the study is that the questionnaires were distributed
onboard the airplanes. It is most likely that the passengers
answers are more reliable when they are studied in a real life sit-
uation. The same questionnaires and methods were used in the
present study and the one from 1986. The response rate was also
good. The random selection of ights with the same airline com-
pany is also a strength. The lack of a formal diagnosis of ight
anxiety is a limitation. The degree of anxiety, however, can be
reliably assessed without a diagnosis. Most likely, passengers
who travel on international ights are less afraid of ying than
those who make domestic ights. Accordingly, assessments on
international ights should also be conducted. Some passengers
do not board the aircraft because of ight anxiety. This does not
happen on every ight, and the number is so small that it does
not represent a signicant bias.
CONCLUSION
A signicant number of airline passengers are apprehensive
about ying. Women are more afraid than men. Passengers are
most concerned about turbulence, foreign sounds and terrorism/
highjacking. The impact of the terror attacks on September 11
2001 is rather moderate and transient, and does not seem to have
made passengers more afraid than before, even though more
anxiety is attributed to terrorism. The prevalence of ight anxi-
ety among Norwegian passengers was not different in 2002
compared with 1986.
REFERENCES
Agras, S., Sylvester, D. & Oliveau, D. (1969). The epidemiology of
common fears and phobia. Comprehensive Psychiatry, 2, 151156.
American Psychiatric Association (1994). Diagnostic and statistical
manual of mental disorders (4th edn). Washington, DC: APA.
Arnarson, E. Ø. (1987). The prevalence of ight phobias among Iceland-
ers. Abstract presented at the rst Nordic Meeting, Aviation and
Space Medicine, Oslo, September 1820, 1987.
Ekeberg, O., Seeberg, I. & Ellertsen, B. B. (1988). The prevalence of
ight anxiety in Norwegian airline passengers. Scandinavian Journal
of Behaviour Therapy, 17, 213222.
Ekeberg, O., Seeberg, I. & Ellertsen, B. B. (1989). The prevalence of
ight anxiety in Norway. Nordic Journal of Psychiatry, 43, 443448.
Fredrikson, M., Annas, P., Fischer, H. & Wik, G. (1996). Gender and
age differences in the prevalence of specic fears and phobia.
Behaviour Research and Therapy, 34,3339.
Gigerenzer, G. (2004). Dread risk, September 11, and fatal trafc
accidents. Psychological Science, 15, 286287.
Ito, H. & Lee, D. (2005). Assessing the impact of the September 11
terrorist attacks on US airline demand. Journal of Economics and
Business, 57,7595.
M
uhlberger, A., Alpers, G. W. & Pauli, P. (2005). Fear of ying in the
wake of September 11: No evidence for an increase in a German
sample. Anxiety, Stress & Coping, 18, 343349.
M
uhlberger, A., Herrmann, M. J., Wiedemann, G., Ellgring, H. & Pauli,
P. (2001). Repeated exposure of ight phobics to ights in virtual
reality. Behaviour Research and Therapy, 39, 10331050.
Nordlund, C. L. (1983). A questionnaire of Swedes fear of ying.
Scandinavian Journal of Behavior Therapy, 12, 150168.
Van Gerwen, L. J. & Diekstra, R. F. (2000). Fear of ying treatment
programs for passengers: An international review. Aviation, Space,
and Environmental Medicine, 71, 430437.
Van Gerwen, L. J., Diekstra, R. F., Arondeus, J. M. & Wolfger, R.
(2004). Fear of ying treatment programs for passengers: An interna-
tional update. Travel Medicine and Infectious Disease, 2,2735.
Wilhelm, F. H. & Roth, W. T. (1997). Clinical characteristics of ight
phobia. Journal of Anxiety Disorders, 11, 241261.
Received 29 November 2013, accepted 17 April 2014
© 2014 Oslo University Hospital. Scandinavian Journal of Psychology published by Scandinavian Psychological Associations and John Wiley & Sons Ltd.
468 Ø. Ekeberg et al. Scand J Psychol 55 (2014)
... Up to 40% of the population in industrialized countries suffers from a fear of flying; another 20% experiences strong fear during flying [1,2]. In order to control their fear, many use coping strategies that include the avoidance of fear-related situations, self-medication or alcohol [3]. ...
... These patterns were partially confirmed by the statistical analysis. ANOVA revealed significant main effects of the factor flight (F 1 14). Further t-tests for the first flight showed that all pairs were significant (p < .05), ...
... Excluding the two older participants, an ANOVA revealed significant main effects of the factor flight (F 1 that all pairs were significant (p < .05), except the pair (c1/t2: p = .533). ...
Article
Full-text available
Background Although there is solid evidence for the efficacy of in vivo and virtual reality (VR) exposure therapy for a specific phobia, there is a significant debate over whether techniques promoting distraction or relaxation have impairing or enhancing effects on treatment outcome. In the present pilot study, we investigated the effect of diaphragmatic breathing (DB) as a relaxation technique during VR exposure treatment. Method Twenty-nine patients with aviophobia were randomly assigned to VR exposure treatment either with or without diaphragmatic breathing (six cycles per minute). Subjective fear ratings, heart rate and skin conductance were assessed as indicators of fear during both the exposure and the test session one week later. ResultsThe group that experienced VR exposure combined with diaphragmatic breathing showed a higher tendency to effectively overcome the fear of flying. Psychophysiological measures of fear decreased and self-efficacy increased in both groups with no significant difference between the groups. Conclusions Our findings indicate that diaphragmatic breathing during VR exposure does not interfere with the treatment outcome and may even enhance treatment effects of VR exposure therapy for aviophobic patients. Trial registrationRetrospectively registered. ClinicalTrials.gov NCT02990208. Registered 07 December 2016.
... 27 This is corroborated by studies that analyze the economic repercussions of terrorism, including its effect on tourism and financial markets. [28][29][30] These broader economic impacts underscore the need for a holistic approach to counter-terrorism that includes economic resilience and recovery strategies in addition to traditional security measures. [31][32] The high fatality rate observed in North America, predominantly driven by the September 11 attacks, underscores the profound impact of singular high-casualty events on both statistical trends and public consciousness. ...
Article
Full-text available
Objectives Terrorist attacks on the aviation sector represent a significant security challenge due to the high-profile status of airports and aircraft. These attacks not only jeopardize global security but also have severe public health repercussions, leading to widespread casualties and psychological distress. Methods This study conducted a comprehensive retrospective analysis using data from the Global Terrorism Database to explore the patterns, frequencies, and impacts of terrorist attacks on the aviation sector worldwide. The analysis spanned incidents from 1970 to 2020, focusing on attack types, affected regions, and the direct and indirect health consequences arising from these incidents. Results Over the 50-year period, the study identified 1183 terrorist attacks targeting the aviation sector. Bombings and explosions emerged as the most common and deadliest forms of attack, responsible for the majority of fatalities and injuries. The data also highlighted significant regional disparities, with certain areas experiencing higher frequencies of attacks and more severe outcomes. Notably, North America bore a disproportionately high number of fatalities, primarily due to the events of September 11, 2001. Conclusions The findings emphasize the ongoing and evolving threat of terrorism in the aviation industry, underscoring the critical need for a proactive and comprehensive approach to security and public health preparedness. Future strategies should prioritize the integration of advanced technological solutions, enhanced international cooperation, and thorough public health planning to mitigate the impact of terrorist attacks on aviation effectively.
... Ačkoliv oba typy studií jednoznačně dokládají negativní působení terorismu na turismus, ani jeden z nich nepřichází s definitivním tvrzením, že by terorismus představoval nejzávažnější hrozbu pro turistické chování. Některé studie sice dokládají, že terorismus patří mezi přední hrozby ovlivňující turistické chování (Bowen, Fidgeon, & Page, 2014;Ekeberg, Fauske, & Berg-Hansen, 2014;Gray & Wilson, 2009;Karl, Muskat, & Ritchie, 2020;Norton, 1987;Sönmez & Graefe, 1998), jiné však poukazují na jeho relativně omezené působení, a to i vůči jiným bezpečnostním hrozbám (Brun, Wolff, & Larsen, 2011;Larsen, Brun, & Øgaard, 2009;Neumayer, 2004;Parida et al., 2017;Rittichainuwat & Chakraborty, 2009;Saha & Yap, 2014;Wolff & Larsen, 2014;Yap & Saha, 2013). Již v úvodu bylo nastíněno, že jeden z důvodů rozdílných zjištění spočívá v charakteru uvažovaných destinací a teroristických incidentů. ...
Article
Full-text available
Previous research showed that terrorism mostly influences tourism negatively. The influence, however, varies depending on many factors. These include the intensity and communication range of terrorist incidents. Previous literature focused almost exclusively on destinations hit by high-scale terrorism. As a result, the topic of the influence of low-scale terrorism on tourism remains understudied. Therefore, the article aims to reveal whether and in what ways the tourists’ reactions change towards destinations hit by low-scale terrorism. Both potential and actual tourists’ reactions are addressed. For this purpose, the article employs secondary and primary data based on the case of Munich, Germany, hit by a terrorist incident in 2016. The article discovered that low-scale terrorism changes (potential) tourists’ reactions. The influence on tourism demand existed, was negative and not marginal. In the case of tourists who arrived at the destination, no substantial changes in behaviour occurred. Nevertheless, even they perceived the threat of terrorism. Domestic tourism demand was more resilient than the foreign one. Neither of the present studies proved that interregional tourists would react more sensitively than tourists from more distant source markets. Visible security measures and organising various social events were identified as appropriate tools for improving tourists’ reactions possibly influenced by terrorism. Dosavadní výzkum odhalil, že terorismus povětšinou negativně působí na turismus. Zmíněný dopad se však různí v závislosti na mnoha faktorech. Jedná se i o intenzitu a komunikační rozsah teroristických incidentů. Předchozí výzkum se nicméně zaměřoval takřka výhradně na destinace zasažené terorismem velkého rozsahu, a tudíž téma dopadů terorismu malého rozsahu na turismus zůstává neprobádané. Cílem článku tak je odhalit, zda a jakým způsobem se proměňují reakce turistů vůči destinacím zasažených terorismem malého rozsahu. Zkoumány jsou jak reakce potenciálních turistů, tak těch skutečných, kteří do destinace přicestovali. Za tímto účelem článek využívá sekundárních i primárních dat, a to na příkladu německého Mnichova, kde se v roce 2016 uskutečnil teroristický incident. Odhaleno bylo, že i terorismus malého rozsahu proměňuje reakce (potenciálních) turistů. Vliv na poptávku v turismu existoval, byl negativní a nikoliv marginální. V případě turistů, kteří do destinace skutečně dorazili, nedocházelo k zásadním změnám v chování, nicméně i oni hrozbu terorismu vnímali. Reakce domácí poptávky v turismu pak byla podstatně odolnější než reakce té zahraniční. Ani jedna z předložených studií však neprokázala, že by interregionální turisté reagovali citlivěji než turisté z bližších trhů. Viditelná bezpečnostní opatření a pořádání nejrůznějších společenských událostí byly identifikovány jako vhodné nástroje, jak vylepšit reakce turistů potenciálně ovlivněné terorismem.
... According to several studies, terrorism belongs among the main threats affecting tourists ' risk perceptions, feelings, and decisions (e.g., Bowen et al., 2014;Ekeberg et al., 2014;Gray & Wilson, 2009;Karl et al., 2020;Sönmez & Graefe, 1998b). Apart from purposefully induced fear, the substantial influence of terrorism can be explained by cognitive biases accompanying decision-making processes. ...
Article
Full-text available
Even though research on tourists' psychological responses to terrorism is substantial, it largely ignores on-site cognitive assessments and emotional responses. As a result, little is known about how location-related factors influence these responses. The present study intended to address these gaps in the context of urban tourism. Therefore, it aimed to evaluate on-site tourists' psychological responses to terrorism in a city destination, while the emphasis was on identifying location-related factors that influence them. The study was based on framework analysis of fear-arousing walking interviews with foreign tourists (n = 24) in the city centre of Munich, Germany. Many participants self-reported the absence of fear of terrorism. However, all participants appraised terrorist attacks as possible within the city centre. The perceived probability varied among participants and visited sites. The differences can be explained by 12 identified location-related factors, of which the number of people and antiterrorism measures were key. Other factors, such as the way participants comprehended terrorism, also influenced their psychological responses to it. Theoretical and managerial implications are discussed.
... For example, airline passengers developed an increased fear of flying after September 11, 2001. Most airlines in the US and Europe reported a noticeable decline in passengers after September 11 (Ekeberg et al., 2014). The resulting economic damage was so devastating that in the immediate aftermath of the attacks, Congress moved to stabilize the airline industry by enacting the Air Transportation Safety and System Stabilization Act to provide financial assistance to an airline industry potentially threatened with collapse as a result of the terrorist attacks (Campbell, 2012). ...
Article
Full-text available
Purpose This study investigates restaurant patrons' comfort level with the sudden shift in the dining-in climate within the state of Massachusetts during the onset of the COVID-19 pandemic. Design/methodology/approach An exploratory study utilized learning algorithms via gradient boosting techniques on surveyed restaurant patrons to identify which restaurant operational attributes and patron demographics predict in-dining comfort levels. Findings Past consumers' eating habits determine how much their behavior will change during a pandemic. However, their dining-in frequency is not a predictor of their post-pandemic dining-in outlook. The individuals who were more comfortable dining in prior to the pandemic dined in more often during the COVID pandemic. However, they had a poorer outlook on when dining in would return to normal. Although there are no clear indicators of when and how customers will embrace the new norm (a combination of pre-, peri-, and post-pandemic), the results show that some innovative approaches, such as limiting service offerings, are not well accepted by customers. Practical implications The study offers several managerial implications for foodservice providers (i.e. restaurants, delivery services, pick-up) and investors. In particular, the study provides insights into the cognitive factors that determine diners' behavioral change in response to a pandemic and their comfort level. Operators must pay attention to these factors and consider different offering strategies when preparing to operate their business amid a pandemic. Originality/value This is a study of a specific location and period. It was conducted in Massachusetts before a vaccine was available. The restaurant industry was beset with uncertainty. It fills a gap in the current literature focused on the COVID-19 pandemic in customers' transition from pre-COVID-19 dining-in behaviors to customers' refreshed COVID-19 outlook and industry compliance with newly established hygiene and safety standards.
... However, the results of previous studies that looked at the influence of the media as a contributing factor to informational acquisition of FF are controversial: some studies show negligible effects, others show a measurable impact [25]. Ekeberg et al. [28] show that after the September 11 attacks in the USA, FF among women rose up by 8.7%. As the most common ways to avoid FF among our participants were listening to music, using medications and drinking alcohol, it has been suggested that the golden rule for FF patients is the avoidance of alcohol [6]. ...
Article
Objective: Because of the increasing use of air travel and the increased mobility of people, different health conditions may arise during the trip in the flight cabin or in the destination country. We aimed to determine the health conditions/problems associated with air travel and stays in a foreign country.Methods: The research included an electronic questionnaire completed by 1014 Estonian residents who travelled by plane during the last five years on holiday and/or on a cultural trip.Results: Health disorders occurred mostly during long trips of 1-4 hours, and the main health problems during plane travel were earaches, headaches, and flatulence. Fear of flying occurred in nearly in a third of the subjects on both short- and long-distance flights. It manifested in episodes of tachycardia and pre-travel insomnia. To cope with these situations, female passengers preferred to listen to music, and male passengers preferred to consume alcohol. In total, 59 different countries were visited, and the most frequent destinations were southern countries: Turkey, Spain, and Italy. Diarrhea, sunburn, severe headaches, fevers and flu-like symptoms were the main health problems in the destination countries. These problems were mostly caused by bad hygiene, consumption of local food, not applying sunblock creams and the change of the environment. The major share of information about the potential dangers of a trip was received from the Internet or from friends.Conclusions: People who decide to travel by plane are usually frequent flyers, and the preferred destinations were mostly warmer climates and not very distant but also not neighbor countries. Health problems occurred most frequently during flights of medium length (1-4 hours). The frequent health disorders at destinations were characteristic for northern tourists visiting southern countries.
... It is estimated that more than a third of all people find flying difficult and distressing. Fear of flying (FOF, aviophobia) is a debilitating disorder affecting 10% -15% of the general population in the western world (Oakes and Bor 2010a;Ekeberg et al. 2014). Nearly all of these people either avoid flying, or fly with the help of medication, drugs or alcohol. ...
Article
Full-text available
Objective: To examine the predictive value of cognitive coping strategies at pretreatment and the value of changes in these strategies during cognitive-behavioral treatment for aviophobia for long-term therapy results. Method: Data from baseline, after therapy at 2 months, short-term follow-up at 5 months, and long-term follow-up at 41 months were analyzed (N = 59). Results: Participants were in a long-term process of change, which continued positively after therapy for maladaptive cognitive coping strategies. The use of cognitive coping strategies at baseline was not predictive of long-term outcome. However, a greater increase in the use of adaptive coping strategies, and more importantly, a greater decrease in the use of maladaptive coping strategies were predictive of improvements indicated in self-report of flight anxiety and actual flight behavior at long-term follow-up. Conclusion: Improvement of maladaptive cognitive coping strategies is possibly a key mechanism of change in cognitive-behavioral therapy for aviophobia.
Article
Full-text available
Point prevalence of specific fears and phobias was determined in 704 respondents of 1000 randomly selected adults aged 18-70 yr. A phobia for lightning, enclosed spaces, darkness, flying, heights, spiders, snakes, injections, dentists and/or injuries was defined if subjects reported a fear that was out of conscious control, interfered with life and lead to the avoidance of the feared object [American Psychiatric Association, 1994. Diagnostic and statistical manual of mental disorders (4th edn). Washington, DC: American Psychiatric Press.] Fear intensity was assessed using visual analogue scales. A factor analysis generally supported the classification of fears and phobias into: (1) situational phobias (lightning, enclosed spaces, darkness, flying and heights); (2) animal phobias (spiders and snakes); and (3) mutilation phobias (injections, dentists, injuries). Total point prevalence of any specific phobia was 19.9% (26.5% for females and 12.4% for males). In total, 21.2% women and 10.9% men met criterias for any single specific phobia. Multiple phobias was reported by 5.4% of the females and 1.5% of the males. Animal phobia had a prevalence of 12.1% in women and 3.3% in men. Point prevalence of situational phobia was 17.4% in women and 8.5% in men. For mutilation phobia no gender difference was observed, being presented in 3.2% of the women and 2.7% of the men. Women as compared to men gave higher fear ratings for all objects and situations. Inanimate object fears and phobias were more common in older than younger individuals. Animal fears were more intense in younger than in older individuals. Fear of flying increased and fear of injections decreased as a function of age in women but not in men. Thus, specific fears and phobias are heterogeneous with respect to sex and age distribution.
Article
Full-text available
There are facilities established around the world for treating passenger flight anxiety, often as a joint activity of airlines and private entrepreneurs or mental health professionals. In the scientific and professional literature, there is little information about how these facilities operate and what the components of their treatment programs are. This paper is the first review to date to provide this information. There were 212 airlines and treatment facilities approached for information on treatment programs for flying phobia, 43 of which were active in this field. Extensive information could be obtained from 15, which were the best known and well-developed. Information was collected both with a questionnaire and by meeting representatives from 15 international fear of flying treatment facilities that participated in the First International Conference on Fear of Flying (Feb. 1996). Fear of flying among passengers is a phenomenon with epidemic proportions, effecting roughly 10-40% of the adult population. All treatment programs share two basic elements, an information component and a test flight. The programs vary considerably in terms of treatment components. However, there is little available information on efficacy. To date there is a wide variety between facilities for the treatment for fear of flying in terms of methods and protocols used. Experts agree on the clear-cut need for standardization of a "best" minimum protocol for fear of flying treatment programs for which the main components where identified.
Article
In theory, information obtained from others can be a potential pathway to the development of a phobia. The media coverage of the terrorist attacks on September 11, 2001, obviously had a strong impact on people world-wide. Therefore, we examined whether this influenced the prevalence of fear of flying. In Germans, although living far away, the number of airline passengers declined sharply in the months following the attacks, which has been speculated to be a result of increased fear of flying. We had collected data on fear of flying shortly before September 11. Soon after the attacks we collected data in a second comparable sample, which enabled us to examine whether indirect learning (information through media coverage) has actually increased the prevalence of fear of flying. Although the sample recruited after the attacks reported traumatic experiences more often, fear of flying stayed the same. There were no further differences in any of the specific or general measures of anxiety or fear.
Article
A study of 315 passengers from eight randomly selected domestic flights in Norway was performed to investigate the prevalence of flight anxiety. There were 31% females and 69% males (mean age 34 and 38 yrs. respectively) with a response rate of 85%. The results showed that the females were most affected: 55% were at least sometimes afraid and 21% always afraid as compared to 45% and 8% in the males. For both sexes, 2% were found to be flight phobics. There was no difference in flight anxiety between the sexes for those with more than 10 flights during the last two years. The flight anxiety had lasted for at leat 10 years for 74% of those affected. “Turbulence” was the item causing most discomfort, followed by “the landing phase” and “ascending”. A comparison was made with a group matched according to age and number of flights (> 10 during the previous two years) where the questionnaires were given at home. The males but not the females, reported significantly more anxiety when responding during flights that at home.
Article
Föreliggande arbete avser en enkätundersökning av svenskars flygrädsla. Tvätusen svenska med-borgare i äldrarna 18–75 är erhöll en enkät med 25 frägor angäende flygrädsla och hur denna päverkar viljan att utnyttja trafikflyget.Christer L. Nordlund: A questionnaire of Swedes' fear of flying. During the spring and summer of 1982, 1 992 randomly selected individuals received a written questionnaire concerning fear of flying. 1 484 individuals returned the questionnaire and 169 of the remainders were interviewed by telephone and were included in the material. 76% of the individuals in the material had flown one or more times, while 6% reported that because of fear they had never flown. 17% reported that they could not consider flying, owing to fear, or for other reasons. 10% answered that they experienced relatively great or greater fear when flying, while 15% answered that they felt the same when thinking about flying. When asked about different parts of a flight, 25% revealed that they felt relatively great or greater fear during some part of it, and about 30% reported the same level of fear when clear air turbulence was encountered. The prevalence of flight fear depends upon the definition used. If “daring to fly” is used as a criterion, 10% of the Swedish population, i.e. 600 000 Swedes, can be considered to be afraid of flying. Given that flying is quite safe (from a statistical point of view), anyone experiencing discomfort during a flight could be regarded as demonstrating fear of flying. With this criterion, 50% of the interviewed individuals (= 3 000 000 Swedes) could be regarded as apprehensive about flying.
Article
A random sample of 1000 persons aged 18-75 years was selected for a study of the prevalence of flight anxiety in Norway, and 79% responded. The results showed that 54% were not afraid at all, 22% were always afraid, and 5% would never fly because of flight anxiety. The flight anxiety had lasted for at least 10 years in 83% of those affected. Expectation of “turbulence”, “engine trouble”, and “collision in the air” were the single items found to cause most discomfort. Flight anxiety was far more common among females: 60% were at least apprehensive, and 9% never fly, compared with 33% and 2%, respectively, among males. The condition increases with age and is particularly common among housewives, those retired, and persons with “other nervous problems”. The present findings are in accordance with similar studies made in Sweden and Iceland.
Article
The present study examined the effects of repeated exposure of flight phobics to flights in virtual reality (VR). Flight phobics were randomly assigned either to complete one VR test flight followed by four VR exposure flights (VR group; N=15) in one lengthy session or to complete one VR test flight followed by a lengthy relaxation training session (relaxation group; N=15). All participants completed a second VR test flight at the end of the session. Fear reports and physiological fear reactions (heart rate, skin conductance level) during VR exposures were registered, and fear of flying was assessed psychometrically from 3 weeks before to 3 months after exposure. Exposure to VR flights elicited subjective and physiological fear responses in flight phobics, and these responses attenuated within and across VR flights. Fear reduction associated with repeated VR exposure was greater than fear reduction caused by relaxation training. Fear of flying improved in both treatment groups, but several outcome measures indicated greater effects in the VR treated group than in the relaxation group. These findings indicate that exposure in virtual reality may offer a new and promising approach for the treatment of fear of flying.
Article
This paper assesses the impact of the September 11 terrorist attacks and its after-effects on U.S. airline demand. Using monthly time-series data from 1986 to 2003, we find that September 11 resulted in both a negative transitory shock of over 30% and an ongoing negative demand shock amounting to roughly 7.4% of pre-September 11 demand. This ongoing demand shock has yet to dissipate (as of November 2003) and cannot be explained by economic, seasonal, or other factors.
Article
Incidence and prevalence data for common fears and phobia based on a probability sample of the general population show the frequency of mild phobia to be 76:9/1000 and of severe phobia to be 2.2/1000. Clinical samples are not representative of the distribution of phobia in the general population, agoraphobia being over-represented. The most frequent reason for consulting a physician is for him to minimize a severe fear or phobia of a medical procedure. Psychiatrists tend to see only the more severe phobics, although only a quarter of this group were found to be in treatment.
Article
Sixty-six subjects with severe fear of flying were recruited by advertisement and compared to 21 controls without flying fears. Subjects were interviewed and given several questionnaires to determine DSM-III-R diagnoses, history of flying, and development and course of flying phobia. Our phobic sample had a mean age of 46 and was 89% female. Diagnostically, 27% met criteria for current Panic Disorder with Agoraphobia, and 17% criteria for that diagnosis in the past. These two groups were more concerned with internal or social anxiety stimuli during flight than the group who had never had panic attacks but met criteria for Simple Phobia (flying). All three groups were equally concerned about external dangers. Traumatic flight events were common in phobics and controls, but phobics reported reacting to these events more strongly. Our results suggest a vulnerability-stress model with several vulnerability factors, including cognitive ones. Treatment implications are discussed.