Content uploaded by Barbara Mussi
Author content
All content in this area was uploaded by Barbara Mussi on May 25, 2014
Content may be subject to copyright.
RESPIRATION PATTERNS OF FIN WHALES OFF ISCHIA,
ARCHIPELAGO CAMPANO, MEDITERRANEAN SEA.
1 Díaz López, B., 2 Mussi, B., 2 Miragliuolo, A., 3 Chiota, D.,3 Valerio L.
1CEMMA, Aldea Nova 82, 15220 Ames-A Coruña, España.
2STUDIOMARE, v. D'Abundo 82, 80075, Forio d'Ischia (Na), Italia studiomare@pointel.it
3WWF Italia Oasi Blu, C.P. 45, 04028 Scauri (Lt), Italia.
Abstract:
The observation of this research were carried out during the summer of 1997 and 1998. The surveys were realised
on board of the long sail boat "Barbarian". The routes were chosen to optimise the sights and were determined daily
on the basis of previous sightings. The respiratory cycles of 15 solitary whales was recorded during a total of 19
hours and 26 minutes of observation (mean of 39 minutes per whale). All data were recorded for the longest time
possible, until visual contact with the whales was lost either due to the distance becoming too great or poor weather
conditions. The basis of this study was to see if there was any correlation between the respiratory patterns and the
kind of behaviour of the fin whale. The study of respiratory patterns of fin whale could be a useful method to
investigate the disturbing effect caused by approaching vessels. Fin whales spent 25% of their time at the surface
(sum of surfacing times) and 75% diving. A significant difference in surfacing time was found for the two kinds of
behaviour "curious" and "indifferent" of the fin whales (Student t-test, p<0.01). The outcome of our research
indicates that the whale respiratory patterns vary according to a number of external stimuli, including the influence
of the proximity of vessels and the trophical behaviour. The novelty of our research brings to light that there are two
kinds of behaviour of the fin whale towards the vessels: "positive" and "negative".
Key words: fin whale, respiration patterns, Tyrrhenian sea, behaviour.
INTRODUCTION: The fin whale (Balaenoptera physalus) is an oceanic cetacean, which is
found in every ocean of the World. It is the most common large cetacean inhabiting the
Mediterranean sea (Jefferson, T.A. et al., 1993; Leatherwood, S. et al., 1983). Previous surveys
carried out in the Archipelago Campano area ( Mussi et al. 1997, 1998, 1999) pointed out that
the sightings of fin whale are generally higher during summer months. A similar situation
happens in the Liguro-Provençal basin, where the population of fin whale congregates during the
summer (Aguilar, A. 1985; Zanardelli, M. et al., 1992; Relini, G. et al., 1992; Jahoda, M. et al.,
1993; Nortarbartolo di Sciara, G. et al., 1993; Forcada, J. et al., 1993).
The area of study of our research is that part of the Tyrrhenian sea embracing the islands of
Ischia, Procida and the mainland coast, surveying particularly the submarine canyon of Cuma
(Pennetta et al. 1998). This area, of about 35 square miles, is smaller than the Ligurian one.
The breathing behaviour of whales seems to be influenced by the presence/absence of boats. The
study of respiration patterns of fin whale could be a useful method to investigate the disturbing
effect caused by approaching vessels (Jahoda, M. et al. 1993, 1996; Notarbartolo di Sciara, G. et
al.1996).
In the summer we observed that the level of boat traffic in the studied area is high as a
consequence of the proximity of the land and the increase of tourism.
METHODS: The Archipelago Campano has been the object of a long-term study (1991-1999)
on cetaceans ( Mussi et al. 1997, 1998, 1999). The observation of this research were carried out
during the summer of 1997 and 1998. The surveys were realised on board of the 15 m. long sail-
boat "Barbarian", fully equipped for high-sea navigation. The routes were chosen to optimise the
sights and were determined daily on the basis of previous sightings. No trip was performed in
conditions greater than Sea State 5 (Beaufort). The survey covered an area of about 35 square
miles.
All data were recorded for the longest time possible, until visual contact with the whales was lost
either due to the distance becoming too great, or poor weather conditions. To avoid potential
ambiguities due to contiguous surfacing of indistinguishable individuals, respiration times were
recorded only from lone whales.
The observers collected the data in seconds, using digital stopwatches. Observations consisted of
uninterrupted bouts, from sunrise to sunset, in fine weather condition. The observation period
consists of continuous breathing and diving cycles, from the first time the whale is observed until
it disappears.
A diving time is defined as an interval between two breaths lasting longer than 36 seconds
(Jahoda, M. et al. 1993).
A surfacing time is defined as the time the fin whale swims on the surface.
The surfacing rate is defined as the number of surfacings per whale in an hour.
A cycle is defined as a diving followed by a surfacing time (Jahoda, M. et al. 1993).
Only complete diving-surfacing cycles were considered for the analysis (Jahoda, M. et al. 1993).
For each record of the surfacing rate the observation period was at least of 30 minutes (Friis,
L.W. et al., 1992).
Respiration patterns were related to different behavioural states.
"Indifference" and "Investigating" were chosen to point out the different attitude of the fin whale.
We say that a fin whale in indifferent if it is observed at a distance of more than 100 meters from
the boat: the whale isn’t affected at all from the presence of vessels and continues swimming
with a speed of 1-3 Kn.
We say that a fin whale is investigating if it is observed at a distance of less than 100 meters
from the boat: the whale shows interest for the vessels and swims milling with a speed < 1 Kn.
We characterised four different behavioural categories: indifferent diving (INDD), indifferent
surfacing (INDS), investigating diving (INVD), investigating surfacing (INVS).
We also identified two parameters: indifferent surfacing rate (INDSR) and investigating
surfacing rate (INVSR).
RESULTS: During the whole period of research 159 diving/surfacing cycles were timed from
fifteen lone whales for a total of 19 hrs. 26 min of net observation, corresponding at a mean of 39
minutes per whale.
Fin whales spent 25.01 % of their time at the surface (sum of surfacing times) and 74,98% diving
(Figure 1).
Temporal distribution in the dive-surfacing cycle
25%
75%
Dive Surfacing
Figure 1
The value of diving/surfacing medium times are respectively 283,57 sec. diving (Std. Err.
11,007) and 110,08 sec. surfacing (Std. Err. 7,082).
A significant difference in surfacing time was found for the two kinds of behaviour
"investigating" and "indifferent" of the fin whales (Student t-test, p < 0,01) (Figures 2-3-4).
0
50
100
150
200
250
300
Investigating whales
Mean (sec) 262,68 144,98
Std.Err 21,3 17,49
Dive Surfacing
0
50
100
150
200
250
300
Indifferent whales
Mean (sec) 293,85 91,63
Std.Err 12,6 4,82
Dive Surfacing
Figure 2, 3
Dive-surfacing lengths in different behavioural states
293,85
91,63
262,68
144,98
12,6 4,82 21,3 17,49
0
50
100
150
200
250
300
350
Indifference
Dive
Indifference
Surface
Investigating
Dive
Investigating
Surface
Mean (sec)
Std.Err
Figure 4
On the contrary no difference emerges from diving time analysis nor from the values of the two
parameters INDSR/INVSR (Student t-test, p > 0,05).
The surfacing rate changes with the trophical behaviour during the day: during our observation
the surfacing rate was higher at daybreak than during daytime showing a little increment at
sunset (Figure 5).
12,28
1,11
9,42
1
9,03
0,81
8,31
0,78
7,54
0,42
8,05
0,51
0
2
4
6
8
10
12
14
7-9 hrs 9-11 hrs 11-13 hrs 13-15 hrs 15-17 hrs 17-19 hrs
Surfacing rates during the day
Mean
Std.Err
Figure 5
The direct study of the whale’s behaviour with the observation of convoluted courses, circle
swimming, bubble production and defecation episodes suggested a foraging activity during this
hours. (Mussi et al., 1999).
CONCLUSIONS: The outcome of our research indicates that the whale respiration patterns
vary according to a number of external stimuli, including the influence of the proximity of
vessels and the trophical behaviour.
The surfacing rate could depend on the area of observation, the day-time and is related to the
behaviour of the fin whale. This specie, in this area, has a high level of "curiosity" towards the
boats, this takes the animals to get close to them, staying more time on the surface than the
"indifferent" one.
This kind of influenced behaviour could be considered "positive" because it increases the
surfacing time. The whales spend more time at the surface than those observed by other
researchers working in the Italian seas. In that case the presence of vessels could be considered
"negative" because diminishes the surface time and increases the swimming speed (Nortarbartolo
di Sciara, G. et al., 1996). A negative influence was observed as well by other researchers
studying the Balaena mysticetus in the Beaufort Sea (Richardson, W.J. et al., 1985).
The novelty that our research brings to light is that there are two kinds of behaviour of the fin
whale towards the vessels: "positive" and "negative".
We observed that the whales spent much more time on the surface at daybreak (Figure 5), which
is probably associated with the vertical nyctemerial migrations of preyed euphausiaceans (Friis,
W.L. et al., 1992; Relini, G. et al., 1992; Mussi et al., 1999).
In future researches the study of "indifferent" whales should be recorded from longer distances to
obtain more objective results in order to compare the different levels of human’s influence.
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS: Studiomare and WWF Oasi Blu funded the research. Thanks to
C.E.M.MA. Many people contributed to the success of this manuscript, a special thank to
Stanislao Migliaccio, Bettina Buttgehen and Michela Muzzi. We wish to thank the anonymous
referees for their valuable suggestions and contribution to the final draft of the manuscript.
Kodak furnished the films. Many thanks to Oberon and DS telematica.
REFERENCES:
Aguilar, A. 1985. Biología y dinámica poblacional del rorcual común (Balaenoptera physalus) en las aguas
atlánticas ibéricas. Ph. thesis Univ. de Barcelona, 487 pp.
Forcada, J., Aguilar, A., Hammond, P., Pastor, X. and Aguilar, R. 1993. Distribucion and abundance of fin whales in
the Western Mediterranean Sea during the summer. In: European Research on cetaceans -7. Proc. Seventh Ann.
Conf. E.C.S., Inverness, Scotland. (Ed. P.G.H. Evans), 128-131. ECS, Cambridge, England.
Friis, L. W., Pedersen, J.U., Rebsdorf, M. and Skytte, E. 1992. Fin whale, Balaenoptera physalus, surfacing rates in
west Geenland. In: European Research on cetaceans -6. Proc. Sixth Ann. Conf. E.C.S., San Remo, Italy. (Ed.
P.G.H. Evans), 90-94. ECS, Cambridge, England.
Gannier, A. and Gannier, O. 1993. The winter presence of the fin whale in the Liguro-Provençal Basin: preliminary
study. In: European Research on cetaceans -7. Proc. Seventh Ann. Conf. E.C.S., Inverness, Scotland. (Ed. P.G.H.
Evans), 131-135. ECS, Cambridge, England.
Gili, J.M., Murillo, J. and Ros, J. 1989. The distribution pattern of benthic Cnidarians in the Western Mediterranean.
Sci. Mar. 53 (1): 19-35.
Jahoda, M. and Nortarbartolo di Sciara, G. 1993. Respiratory patterns of fin whales summering in the Ligurian Sea.
In: European Research on cetaceans -7. Proc. Seventh Ann. Conf. E.C.S., Inverness, Scotland. (Ed. P.G.H. Evans),
237-241. ECS, Cambridge, England.
Jahoda, M., Airoldi, S., Azzelino, A., Biassoni, N., Borsani, J.F., Cianfanelli, L., Lauriano, G., Nortarbartolo di
Sciara, G., Panigada, S., Vallini, C. and Zanardelli, M. 1996. Behavioural reactions to biopsi-darting on
Mediterranean fin whales. In: European Research on cetaceans -10. Proc. Tenth Ann. Conf. E.C.S., Lisbon,
Portugal. (Ed. P.G.H. Evans), 43-48. ECS, Kiel, Germany.
Jefferson, T.A., Leatherwood, S. and Webber, M.A. 1993. FAO species identification guide. Marine mammals of
the world. Rome, FAO, 320 pp.
Leatherwood, S. and Reeves, R.R. and Foster, L. 1983. The Sierra Club Handbook of Whales and Dolphins. Sierra
Club Books. San Francisco, 303 pp.
Marini, L., Consiglio, C., Angradi, A.M. and Sanna, A. 1991. Preliminary results of the firstyear od a sightings
survey of cetaceans in the Central Tyrrhenian Sea. In: European Research on cetaceans -5. Proc. Fifth Ann. Conf.
E.C.S., Sandefjord, Norway. (Ed. P.G.H. Evans), 22-25. ECS, Cambridge, England.
Marini, L., Consiglio, C., Maria, A., Sanna, A. and Valentini, T. 1992. Cetacean sighting campaign in the Central
Tyrrhenian Sea : Results of the second year of activity. In: European Research on cetaceans -6. Proc. Sixth Ann.
Conf. E.C.S., San Remo, Italy. (Ed. P.G.H. Evans), 66-69. ECS, Cambridge, England.
Marini, L., Consiglio, C., Catalano, B., Valentini, T. and Villetti, G. 1996. Aerial behaviour in fin whales
(Balaenoptera physalus)in the Mediterranean sea. Marine Mammal Science 12 (3): 489-495.
Mussi, B., Miragliuolo, A. e Battaglia M., 1997. Cetacei nell’arcipelago delle isole Pontine e Campane. Atti del 5°
Seminario Internazionale di Studi sull’Ecosistema marino. Gaeta, Napoli, Ustica, Italia. (Ed. L. Valerio), Pp:157-
167.Oasi Blu del WWF Italia, Gaeta, Italia.
Mussi, B., Miragliuolo, A. e Battaglia M., 1997. Osservazioni sul comportamento di Stenella coeruleoalba (Meyen,
1833) nell’arcipelago Pontino – Campano, Tirreno Centro Meridionale. 3° Convegno Nazionale sui cetacei,
Abstracts. 5-6 Dicembre 1997, Napoli, Italia. Centro Studi cetacei della Società Italiana di Scienze Naturali.
Mussi, B., Gabriele, R., Miragliuolo, A. e Battaglia, M., 1998. Cetacean sightings and interactions with fisheries in
the Archipelago Pontino Campano, South Tyrrhenian sea, 1991-1995. European Research on Cetacean -12: 63 - 65.
(Editor P.G.H. Evans). Proc. 12th Ann. Conf. ECS, Monaco, France, 20 –24 January 1998.
Mussi, B., Miragliuolo, A., Monzini, E., Diaz Lopez, B. and Battaglia, M., 1999. Fin whale (Balaenoptera physalus)
feeding ground in the coastal water of Ischia (Archipelago Campano). European Research on Cetacean (Abstracts) -
13: 92. 13th Ann. Conf. ECS, Valencia, Spain, 5-8 April, 1999.
Nortarbartolo di Sciara, G., Forcada, J., Acquarone, M. and Fabbri, F. 1993. Population estimates of fin whales and
striped dolphins summering in the Corso-Ligurian Basin. In: European Research on cetaceans -7. Proc. Seventh
Ann. Conf. E.C.S., Inverness, Scotland. (Ed. P.G.H. Evans), 135-139. ECS, Cambridge, England.
Nortarbartolo Di Sciara, G., Bérubé, M., Zanardelli, M. and Panigada, S. 1995. The role of the Mediterranean in fin
whale ecology: insight trhough genetics. In: European Research on cetaceans -9. Proc. Ninth Ann. Conf. E.C.S.,
Lugano, Switzerland. (Ed. P.G.H. Evans & H. Nice), 218-219. ECS, Kiel, Germany.
Nortarbartolo di Sciara, G., Jahoda, M., Biassioni, N. and Lafortuna, C. 1996. Reactions of fin whales to
approaching vessels assessed by means of a laser rangefinder. In: European Research on cetaceans -10. Proc. Tenth
Ann. Conf. E.C.S., Lisbon, Portugal. (Ed. P.G.H. Evans), 38-43. ECS, Kiel, Germany.
Relini, L.O. and Giordano, A. 1992. Summer feeding of the fin whale, Balaenoptera physalus, in the Liguro-
Provençal Basin. In: European Research on cetaceans -6. Proc. Sixth Ann. Conf. E.C.S., San Remo, Italy. (Ed.
P.G.H. Evans), 134-138. ECS, Cambridge, England.
Relini, L.O., Relini, G., Cima, C., Palandri, G., Relini, M. and Torchia, G. 1994. Meganyctiphanes norvegica and fin
whales in the Ligurian Sea: new seasonal patterns. In: European Research on cetaceans -8. Proc. Eighth Ann. Conf.
E.C.S., Montpellier, France. (Ed. P.G.H. Evans), 179-183. ECS, Lugano, Switzerland.
Richardson, W.J., Fraker, M.A., Würsig, B. and Wells, R.S. 1985. Behaviour of bowhead whales Balaena
mysticetus summer in the Beaufort Sea: Reactions to industrial activities. Biol. Conserv., 32(3): 195-230.
Zanardelli, M., Nortarbartolo Di Sciara, G. and Jahoda, M. 1992. Photo-identification and behavioural observation
of fin whales summering in the Ligurian Sea. In: European Research on cetaceans -6. Proc. Sixth Ann. Conf.
E.C.S., San Remo, Italy. (Ed. P.G.H. Evans), 86-90. ECS, Cambridge, England.