Conference PaperPDF Available

CETACEAN SIGHTINGS AND INTERACTIONS WITH FISHERIES IN THE ARCHIPELAGO PONTINO CAMPANO, SOUTHERN TYRRHENIAN SEA, 1991-1995

Authors:
CETACEAN SIGHTINGS AND INTERACTIONS WITH FISHERIES IN THE
ARCHIPELAGO PONTINO CAMPANO, SOUTHERN TYRRHENIAN SEA, 1991-1995.
Mussi, B.1-2, Gabriele, R.2, Miragliuolo, A. 1-2, Battaglia, M. 2
1 Studiomare, via Botteniga 39, 31100 Treviso, Italia
2 WWF Oasi Blu, c.p. 45, 04028 Scauri (LT), Italia
INTRODUCTION We chose this area because in the past it has never been object of a detailed
systematic study on marine mammals. This is a preliminary report of five years observations.
The purpose of this project was to initiate a long term study on cetaceans in a sample area, to record
the most common species, analyse seasonal variations in their presence, verify the existence of
resident cetaceans and study interaction with fishery.
METHODS: The archipelago Pontino Campano is composed by nine volcanic islands, forming
three distinct groups, old eruptive centres, separated from each other by about 40 km. During the
research we adopted two different methods: between June 1991 and June 1993 data were collected
by ferries, cargo and fishing boats sailing in the area. The recordings were discontinuous but allow
to find out the winter presence of cetaceans in the area. From 1993 to 1995 to get more information
we used a 15 m. sailing boat, “Barbarian”, equipped for high seas navigation with a GPS, recording
data base and a hydrophone system. A constant watch was kept for cetaceans and all sightings
noted with their position, group size, behaviour, associated species, presence of juveniles, sea state
and wind strength. Trips were conducted daily from May to October. No trip was started in
conditions greater than sea state 5. Travel was always made by sails.
RESULTS A total of 330 sightings comprising 3494 individuals of seven cetacean species were
recorded during the period of the research (fig.1). Seasonal changes in sightings frequency are
presented in fig.2. We tried to quantify the observers' effort from 1993 to 1995. Despite all
dependent variables (sea state, light condition, observers' height, boat and cetacean behaviour) a
sightings frequency was calculated dividing the number of individuals by the travelled distance
(Km). These indices varied between 0,09 in 1993, 0,12 in 1994 and 0,13 in 1995 (mean frequency
1,11).
Striped dolphins (Stenella coeruleoalba) They were the most frequent cetacean encountered, with
a total of 183 sightings, comprising 2557 individuals. The great majority were sightings of groups
of 6-10 individuals (mean group size = 13.97) with a maximum group of 350 animals and
concentrated in the south waters of the islands, at an average depth of 700 m. The number of
sightings increased to a peak in the month of September. In the same month we recorded the highest
concentration of juveniles in striped dolphin’s groups.
Bottlenosed dolphins (Tursiops truncatus) They were distributed in coastal waters particularly at
the mouth of the river Volturno, and around Ventotene and Ischia islands at an average depth of 100
m. A total of 68 sightings comprising 501 individuals were recorded during the study. Most
sightings were groups of 2-5 individuals (mean group size = 7.36) with a maximum group size of
100 individuals. Sightings frequency increase to a peak in June, with the highest concentration of
juveniles from May to August. A resident group of 15 individuals had been photo-identified and
studied since 1993: the group was composed of four females, six males, one subadult and four
juveniles. The home range of this group was extended from Ischia to Ponza, but the most frequently
observations were made around Ventotene.
Sperm whales (Physeter macrocephalus) They were recorded during the survey with 29 sightings
of 39 individuals. Sightings were largely confined to the southern waters of the islands at an
average depth of 700 m.; most sightings were of a single animal (mean group size = 1.34) and with
greatest frequency in August and September. They were recorded near the coast at night, during the
breeding season of “European flying squids” (Ommastrephes sagittatus), making use of the high
concentration of squids near fishermen's lights.
Risso’s dolphins (Grampus griseus) They were relatively uncommon, with 13 sightings of 101
individuals. They were encountered very closed to the shore of the islands, in groups of 7-10
individuals (mean group size = 7.76) with a maximum of 15 individuals. Sightings occurred in all
years, decreasing in winter and increasing in September. Juveniles were recorded in April, May,
June and September.
Long finned pilot whales (Globicephala melas) They were rarely encountered in the area, with six
sightings comprising 64 individuals. They were observed most frequently in groups of 6 (mean
group size = 10.66) with a maximum of 35 individuals and were most abundant in October, in south
westerly waters of the islands. Photo-ID studies revealed the seasonal presence of recognisable
individuals in a single location (around Ventotene).
Common dolphins ( Delphinus delphis) They were the rarest cetacean in the area with only four
sighting of seven individuals. They were always in association with large groups of striped
dolphins. Two juveniles were recorded near Ponza, swimming near their mother. In 1996 (data still
being analysed) one sighing of 15 individuals of common dolphin was recorded without any
association with striped dolphin.
Fin Whales (Balaenoptera physalus) They were recorded throughout the area with 16 sightings of
28 individuals. The majority were sightings of single animals (mean group size = 1.75), with a
maximum group size of three individuals. They were most abundant in summer time, from May to
September. The number of juveniles reached a peak in the month of September.
Unidentified They were recorded mainly in 1991-1993 during the ferry-census, for a total of 12
sightings comprising 197 individuals.
Interactions with fishery were recorded in the area with illuminated handlines for squids, surface
longlines, trawling nets, bottom gillnets and drift nets.
Illuminated handlines for squids: interactions occurred with striped dolphins, Risso’s dolphins,
long finned pilot whale and sperm whale. In all cases an opportunistic feeding was completed by
small groups (of 2-5) or single animal (sperm whale); cetaceans waited near the fishing boats until
gear's light had attracted a great number of squids under the boats and then they quickly swam to
catch their prey; this technique may be repeated several time in one night.
Surface longlines: one interaction was recorded with a sperm whale. We found an abandoned gear
in which a decomposed sperm whale was entangled, probably drowned in the course of capturing
his prey.
Trawling nets: interactions were recorded with striped and bottlenosed dolphin, in both cases
involving an opportunistic feeding by small groups (of 2-5): making long dives, dolphins fed all
around and within the net especially at the end of the haul.
Bottom gillnets are used in the area only by artisanal fishermen. Around the island of Ventotene
and Ischia, interactions were recorded with bottlenosed dolphins: every year, in the months of
March, May and September they were observed preying from the nets. Dolphins made long dives
around the net, and produced large rips to catch their prey.
Drift nets are used in all the area especially in June, July and August. Interactions recorded were
with striped dolphin and sperm whale: we found on the high sea, two specimens of striped dolphin
without their tails (sometimes fishermen cut the tail to more easily extract the cetacean from the
net); a juvenile of sperm whale probably caught, was found dead near Naples with an oblique cut
from throat to tail. In 1995 we spent 28 nights from June to August with the boat adrift, between
about 55 swordfish boats that were in the area. Our aim was to record the vocalisations of any
cetaceans in difficulty. Every night, from Ponza to Capri (about 120 km.) fishermen set two
interrupted barrages (exactly along 1000 m. and 700 m. depth’s lines): the boats are co-ordinated
by radio and the nets set one after another, leaving a minimal security distance between the boats;
drift nets were set at 20:30 hours and retrieved at 03:00 hours. During 243 hours of workable
underwater listening we never heard a click: cetacean biosonar regularly entered in our hearing
range at 05:30 hours and disappeared at 21:00 hours.
CONCLUSIONS: Five years of observations have allowed to establish the rich variety of cetacean
species around the archipelago Pontino Campano: seven species were identified in total, one baleen
whale, three toothed whales and three small dolphins. We also verify the existence of resident
bottlenosed dolphins and a seasonal presence of five photo-identified individuals of long finned
pilot whale around Ventotene island.
Our main objective is to make a long-term study in a sample area of the Mediterranean sea. Long
term study provides a powerful way for developing an understanding of the social lives of long
lived animals such cetaceans, besides which we are interested in improving our knowledge about
fishing interactions so that a conservation programme can be initiated despite all the difficulties
involved. Of course, in general, several years will be necessary to adequately conduct analyses of
such observations.
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS: The research was funded by Studiomare and WWF Italia. Thanks to
Antonio Di Natale and AQUASTUDIO for their valuable comments and assistance during all the
different phases of the study.
REFERENCES:
Cagnolaro, L., Di Natale, A., Notarbartolo Di Sciara, G. 1983. Cetacei, Guida per il riconoscimento
delle specie animali delle acque lagunari e costiere italiane, C:N:R:, 9:1-185.
Di Natale, A. 1992 A impact of fisheries on cetaceans in the Mediterranean sea. European Research
on Cetaceans -6:18 (Editor P.G.H. Evans). Proc. 6th Ann. Conf. ECS, San Remo, Italy, 20-22 Feb
1992.
Evans, P.G.H., 1987The natural history of whale and dolphins. Cristopher Helm, London: I-XVI 1-
343.
Marini L., Consiglio, C., Angradi, A.M. and Sanna, A. 1993. Cetaceans in the Central Tyrrhenian
Sea: third (and last?) year of sightings survey. Preliminary results. European Research on Cetaceans
-7: 148-149 (Editor P.G.H. Evans). Proc. 7th Ann. Conf. ECS, Inverness, Scotland, 18-21 Feb 1993.
Notarbartolo Di Sciara, G. and Demma, M., 1994. Guida dei mammiferi marini del Mediterraneo.
Franco Muzzio editore, Padova, Italia:1-262.
Podestà, M., Bortolotto, A., Borri, M. and Cagnolaro, L. 1997. Ten years of activity of the Italian
Centro Studi Cetacei. European Research on Cetaceans -11:83-86 (Editor P.G.H. Evans). Proc. 11th
Ann. Conf. ECS, Straslund, Germany, 10-12 March 1997.
... Although a driftnet ban was introduced in 2002, illegal setting of driftnets continued for several years (Cornax & Pardo, 2009), and may still persist (Carpentieri et al., 2021). Other gear types in which sperm whales have been reported bycaught include bottom otter trawls, gillnets, and longlines (Duguy et al., 1983a, b;Di Natale & Mangano, 1983b;Mussi et al., 1998;ACCOBAMS, 2008ACCOBAMS, , 2019Carpentieri et al., 2021). Without dedicated observer programmes in all of these fisheries, it is very difficult to determine bycatch rates for this species. ...
... Present knowledge indicates that most interactions with marine mammals are those used by small-scale fisheries in coastal areas, including bottom-set gillnets and trammel nets targeting several demersal species and few records shows incidental bycatch with deep cetacean divers. Drifting longline has been reported to bycatch some individuals of long-finned pilot whales, Globicephala melas and Risso's dolphins, Grampus gri seus as well as one sperm whale Physeter microceph alus in the Western Mediterranean [81,82]. ...
Chapter
Full-text available
Use the following formats to cite this publication: Full referenced chapter (one set of authors): Example: Sakellariou D.
... Present knowledge indicates that most interactions with marine mammals are those used by small-scale fisheries in coastal areas, including bottom-set gillnets and trammel nets targeting several demersal species and few records shows incidental bycatch with deep cetacean divers. Drifting longline has been reported to bycatch some individuals of long-finned pilot whales, Globicephala melas and Risso's dolphins, Grampus gri seus as well as one sperm whale Physeter microceph alus in the Western Mediterranean [81,82]. ...
... Three other odontocete families were represented by a single species each: Phocoenidae by the harbour porpoise, Physeteridae by the sperm whale Physeter macrocephalus, and Ziphiidae by the northern bottlenose whale Hyperoodon ampullatus (Table 2). We are not aware of any published record of mysticetes foraging behind trawlers, though a few observations of fin whales Balaenoptera physalus (Mussi et al. 1998) and minke whales B. acutorostrata (Perez 2003) were included in the grey literature. A minke whale was observed during a hauling operation 25-30 m from a single midwater trawler that was targeting herring in Scottish waters (Pierce et al. 2002), but it is not known whether the animal was actively following the trawler. ...
Article
Full-text available
Several populations of odontocete cetaceans, including at least 19 species, have modified their behavior and adapted to foraging in association with trawlers. We review information on odontocete interactions with different types of trawlers across 13 Food and Agriculture Organization fishing areas around the world. We also review knowledge gaps, the effects on odontocete ecology, distribution, behavior and social organization, the main mitigation options, and some management avenues that could help reduce incidental mortality. Trawlers involved in the interactions varied greatly in gear and target species, implying odontocetes have developed behavioral specializations to forage under a variety of conditions. Specialized behavior included venturing into a moving trawl net to feed on the organisms trapped in the net, feeding on fish stirred up by the net, extracting fish from the outer mesh, feeding on catch lost during hauling, and scavenging on discarded catch. Foraging behind trawlers facilitates access to prey, and in some instances may compensate for scarcity of natural prey within areas exposed to intensive fishing or environmental degradation. This opportunistic foraging strategy, however, exposes the animals to potential harm and mortality in trawl gear. The combined effect of facilitated foraging and bycatch on the status and trends of odontocete populations is unknown. The economic damage caused by odontocetes, e.g. in terms of loss of marketable catch and gear damage, remains largely conjectural. Attempts to reduce depredation and/or bycatch in trawl gear have included acoustic deterrents and exclusion devices installed in nets, although neither technique has proven to be consistently effective. --- https://doi.org/10.1007/s11160-022-09712-z
... Les senneurs qui pêchent aussi parfois des globicéphales dans leurs filets (Di Natale, 1990). Une étude sur Campano Pontins archipel, sud de la mer Tyrrhénienne, a noté que les cétacés se nourrissant de calamars sont attirés par la lumière artificielle vers la surface (Mussi et al. 1998). David et al. (2006) dans une étude sur les prises accidentelles de cétacés dans les pêcheries au filet maillant dérivant pour le thon et l'espadon français, a montré que les des globicéphales étaient capturés dans le sud de la France, mais la population est peu importante et on ne sait pas ces quelques captures pourraient avoir un impact majeur sur cette population. ...
... The very low number of fish remains in the stomachs of this study suggests that fish are of relatively low dietary importance for sperm whales in Greece but caution is required when interpreting such results due to the high susceptibility of fish bones to chemical degradation in the stomach (Harvey, 1989). Mediterranean sperm whales have not been reported to attack longlines but entanglements in them (Di Natale and Mangano, 1983;Mussi et al., 1998) and anecdotal reports of presence of hooks in their stomachs (Mazzariol et al., 2011) suggest feeding attempts on hooked fish or cephalopods may occur (Bearzi, 2002). ...
Article
Sperm whales (Physeter macrocephalus) inhabiting the world’s oceans, prey mainly on cephalopods, but also feed on fish when found in higher latitudes. However, the feeding habits of endangered Mediterranean sperm whales have received little attention with thus far only two individuals analysed for their stomach contents. This study expands the available knowledge using analysis of the stomach contents from nine individuals stranded in Greece between 2005 and 2014. 48,166 prey remains were examined in total and 28,258 of them were identified to show that sperm whales fed on 18 prey species (17 cephalopods and one teleost) from 14 different families. 15 of these species were deep-sea squids, which are not presently targeted by fisheries. The most important prey species, both in terms of numerical abundance (%N) and abundance by weight (%W), was the oceanic squid Histioteuthis bonnellii (%N=48.4, %W=66.3) followed by H. reversa (%N=28.4, %W=13.8) and Octopoteuthis sicula (%N=8.5, %W=17.2). Calf sperm whales consumed smaller cephalopods of these three prey species than non-calves, probably because larger cephalopods are more difficult to catch. The vast majority of ingested cephalopods were gelatinous, slow-swimming and small. Therefore, sperm whales inhabiting the Greek Seas and likely the whole eastern Mediterranean Sea, appear to target prey that are easy to catch, but need to be consumed in great numbers to fulfil the energy requirements of the whales.
... Interactions between marine mammals and longlines in the Mediterranean Sea are documented in several studies (e.g. Di Natale 1991, Mussi et al., 1998Macías López et al., 2012). However, longline fisheries have been traditionally defined as having a low impact on marine mammals (Macías López et al., 2012), often because the animals are released alive at sea by fishers or are able to disentangle themselves. ...
Book
Full-text available
This first issue of The State of Mediterranean and Black Sea Fisheries is a comprehensive review of the status and trends of fisheries in the Mediterranean and Black Sea. It includes eight chapters, separated in two parts: a first part on the status and trends of Mediterranean and Black Sea fisheries under different aspects such as fleet, catches, socio-economic variables, bycatch, small-scale fisheries and stock status, and a second part describing management measures adopted by the GFCM towar ds the sustainability of fisheries in its area of application. The report is based to a large extent on the most up-to-date data available submitted by GFCM contracting and cooperating non-contracting parties, including information on stock status, national catches, fleet and socio-economic information up to 2014. It is also complemented with information from other sources, including literature review and, for small-scale fisheries, the outcomes of the First Regional Symposium on Sustainable Small-Scale Fisheries in the Mediterranean and Black Sea, organized in 2013 in Malta.
... Interactions between dolphins and coastal, small-scale commercial fisheries in the Mediterranean Sea have a long history (Reeves et al., 2001; Bearzi, 2002; Diaz Lopez et al., 2005; Diaz Lopez, 2006; Lauriano et al., 2009; Fossa et al., 2011), mainly involving trammel and gill-nets. Interactions involving bottom trawlers frequently occur here as in other parts of the world, with the main species implicated being the CBD (Northridge, 1984; Consiglio et al., 1992; Silvani et al., 1992; Goffman et al., 1995; Marini et al., 1995; Fertl & Leatherwood, 1997; Trites et al., 1997; Mussi et al., 1998; Pace et al., 1999; Bearzi et al., 2008a; Gonzalvo et al., 2008). Based on the available data, by-catch in trawling nets appears to be a relatively uncommon occurrence in most Mediterranean areas (Bearzi, 2002; Gonzalvo et al., 2008). ...
Article
Full-text available
Common bottlenose dolphin (CBD) and bottom trawlers exploit the same ecological niche. The estimated CBD population along the Israeli coastline consumes roughly 1280 t of prey annually, similar to the mean annual trawl-fishery yield of 1300 t. In the ultra-oligotrophic Levantine Basin, the potential for competition for limited resources therefore exists. We aimed to examine whether the two consumers indeed harvest the same trophic level of the food web and the same members of that level. These questions were addressed by stomach content and stable isotope (d 15 N and d 13 C) analyses. The database included 26 prey-containing stomachs collected between 1996 and 2008 and muscle tissue samples of 23 dolphins and of 27 species of commercial fish and invertebrates for stable isotopes analysis. The 59.3 kg combined stomach content included at least 754 prey items, 97.3% of which were fish, belonging to 22 identified species. About half (46.4%) of the prey mass had medium-to-high commercial value. The overall similarity of the composition of the pooled biomass and that of the average commercial catch was expressed by a Pianka index of 0.49. Sparidae (sea bream) was the only family important for both consumers. The mean d 15 N value of CBD muscle was found to be relatively low compared to other geographical areas and the estimated mean d 15 N of its diet fell below that of most commercial species tested. Our findings suggest that CBD and the fisheries only partly share resources, with CBD having an overall minor effect on the bottom trawl fishery, mainly on the Sparidae catch.
Article
Full-text available
A review of the last 399 years (1624–2023) on fin whales (Balaenoptera physalus) in the Mediterranean Sea was conducted, based on an extensive compilation of records published in the scientific literature, technical reports, public databases, journals, and social media. A total of 10,716 sightings and 575 mortality events have been computed, analysed by semesters and mapped in order to compare the summer–winter seasons especially and their implications on migration–residence. Visual and acoustic detections, feedings, migrations, primary production areas (chlorophyll), threats and causes of death and their relations have been addressed, and a mini-review on heavy metals and pollutants has been carried out on fin whales in the Mediterranean Sea. Mortality events were most frequent between November and April, coinciding with the decreased sighting period. Ship strikes posed the greatest threat, peaking between May and October, when marine traffic tends to increase in the Mediterranean Sea. Two populations coexist in the Mediterranean Sea, one resident and the other migratory, the latter using the Strait of Gibraltar for its biannual movements. Two areas with a presence of calves (up to 7 m in length) between October and February were detected: one scattered in the northern Mediterranean and the Strait of Gibraltar and its surroundings. A critical zone for collisions has been established according to the results for fin whales in the Mediterranean Sea.
Article
Dolphin interactions with coastal fisheries are of major concern, reportedly leading to gear damage, which increases the cost of coastal fishing globally and in the Mediterranean Sea. The aim of this study was to determine the effect that gear, target species, mesh size, depth, soaking duration, fishing area, and season have on net depredation frequency and to offer insights on possible mitigation solutions. From November 2013 to February 2016 we monitored 107 active coastal fishers in 22 ports of the northern Aegean Sea coastline, identified the main target species of the fishery and recorded the damages on gill nets and trammel nets caused by dolphins, mainly the common bottlenose dolphin (Tursiops truncatus ). Quasi‐binomial generalized linear models were used to determine the relationship between the examined factors and depredation frequency. The analysis revealed that the gears mostly depredated were gill nets and trammel nets with small mesh sizes, mainly targeting surmullet (Mullus surmuletus ), red mullet (Mullus barbatus ), common sole (Solea solea ), European hake (Merluccius merluccius ), and caramote prawn (Melicertus kerathurus ). The probability of depredation was also significantly dependent on the fishing area.
Article
The Mediterranean Sea is regularly inhabited by eleven cetacean species (fin whale, sperm whale, Cuvier's beaked whale, long-finned pilot whale, Risso's dolphin, common bottlenose dolphin, striped dolphin, short-beaked common dolphin, killer whale, rough-toothed dolphin, and harbor porpoise). Two of these species have very limited ranges: the harbor porpoise, possibly representing a small remnant population in the Aegean Sea, and the killer whale, present only as a small population of a few individuals in the Strait of Gibraltar. There is also a small number of species confined to the Black Sea, some species that are considered 'visitors' (in the sense that the Mediterranean may not fulfil their entire life-cycle needs) and some vagrant individuals entering the Mediterranean Sea from the North Atlantic and Red Sea populations of other species. In this chapter we describe the 11 most common species, providing information on their distribution throughout the Basin, habitat preferences, estimated population density, abundance and known population trends, as well as ecology, principal threats and conservation measures currently in place in the Mediterranean Sea.
Article
Guida dei mammiferi marini del Mediterraneo, Giuseppe Notarbartolo di Sciara e Massimo Demma, prefazione di Danilo Mainardi. . - Padova. NALUAF000574, Franco Muzzio Editore. NAEDAF002348, 1994.
1992 A impact of fisheries on cetaceans in the Mediterranean sea
  • Di Natale
Di Natale, A. 1992 A impact of fisheries on cetaceans in the Mediterranean sea. European Research on Cetaceans -6:18 (Editor P.G.H. Evans). Proc. 6 th Ann. Conf. ECS, San Remo, Italy, 20-22 Feb 1992.
Cetaceans in the Central Tyrrhenian Sea: third (and last?) year of sightings survey. Preliminary results
  • L Marini
  • C Consiglio
  • A M Angradi
  • A Sanna
Marini L., Consiglio, C., Angradi, A.M. and Sanna, A. 1993. Cetaceans in the Central Tyrrhenian Sea: third (and last?) year of sightings survey. Preliminary results. European Research on Cetaceans -7: 148-149 (Editor P.G.H. Evans). Proc. 7 th Ann. Conf. ECS, Inverness, Scotland, 18-21 Feb 1993.
Ten years of activity of the Italian Centro Studi Cetacei
  • M Podestà
  • A Bortolotto
  • M Borri
  • L Cagnolaro
Podestà, M., Bortolotto, A., Borri, M. and Cagnolaro, L. 1997. Ten years of activity of the Italian Centro Studi Cetacei. European Research on Cetaceans -11:83-86 (Editor P.G.H. Evans). Proc. 11 th Ann. Conf. ECS, Straslund, Germany, 10-12 March 1997.
Cetacei, Guida per il riconoscimento delle specie animali delle acque lagunari e costiere italiane
  • L Cagnolaro
  • A Di Natale
  • G Notarbartolo Di Sciara
Cagnolaro, L., Di Natale, A., Notarbartolo Di Sciara, G. 1983. Cetacei, Guida per il riconoscimento delle specie animali delle acque lagunari e costiere italiane, C:N:R:, 9:1-185.