Conference PaperPDF Available

THE SUBMARINE CANYON OF CUMA (SOUTHERN TYRRHENIAN SEA, ITALY), A CETACEAN KEY AREA TO PROTECT

Authors:

Abstract and Figures

The submarine canyon of Cuma is an important habitat very close to the northern part of Ischia island were a particular pelagic assemblage can be found. The constant presence of whales and dolphins, pelagic fishes and marine birds is related to the geological and ecological characteristics of the area. Our research try to define the role played by the canyons in distribution and abundance of trophic resources of cetaceans and to include this area (at least the more coastal part of it) into the future perimeter of the marine protected area proposed by Italian Ministry of Environment called "Regno di Nettuno" (islands of Ischia, Procida and Vivara). The shelf area of the Ischia island in front of the canyon is characterised by Posidonia oceanica (sea grass) beds, rocky banks and rocky cliff with coralligenous formations. During cetaceans surveys in the area it was possible to ascertain the presence of some pelagic fishes as Mobula mobular, Thunnus sp., Xiphias gladius and sea birds as Calonectris diomedea, Puffinus puffinus and Larus ridibundus. The analysis of fin whales' faecal material has revealed the presence of crustacean exoskeleton belonging to the euphasiacean Meganyctiphanes norvegica, a key species in the pelagic trophic web. Every summer we can observe in the area large groups of common (Delphinus delphis), striped (Stenella coeruleoalba), bottlenose (Tursiops truncatus) and Risso's dolphins (Grampus griseus). Feeding and mating behaviours were observed in all species. Newborn were sighted in July and August. The area is also used as feeding ground by fin whales (Balaenoptera physalus), the commonest species in the canyon. The strong impact of the boats on cetaceans is becoming everyday routine especially in summertime: distress and disorientation, collisions and deaths by a propeller strike. Timely management measures to protect cetaceans in this key area are clearly needed.
Content may be subject to copyright.
THE SUBMARINE CANYON OF CUMA (SOUTHERN TYRRHENIAN SEA, ITALY),
A CETACEAN KEY AREA TO PROTECT
Mussi, B., (1) Miragliuolo A., (2) De Pippo, T., (3) Gambi, M.C., (4) and Chiota, D. (5)
(1,2) StudioMare, via D'Abundo 82, 80075 Forio d'Ischia (Napoli), Italy,
(3) Dipartimento Scienze della Terra, Università Federico II, Napoli, Italy,
(4) Stazione Zoologica Anton Dohrn, Villa Comunale, 80121, Napoli Italy,
(5) Dipartimento di Zoologia, Università Ferderico II, Napoli, Italy
Abstract:
The submarine canyon of Cuma is an important habitat very close to the northern part of Ischia island were a particular
pelagic assemblage can be found. The constant presence of whales and dolphins, pelagic fishes and marine birds is
related to the geological and ecological characteristics of the area. Our research try to define the role played by the
canyons in distribution and abundance of trophic resources of cetaceans and to include this area (at least the more
coastal part of it) into the future perimeter of the marine protected area proposed by Italian Ministry of Environment
called "Regno di Nettuno" (islands of Ischia, Procida and Vivara). The shelf area of the Ischia island in front of the
canyon is characterised by Posidonia oceanica (sea grass) beds, rocky banks and rocky cliff with coralligenous
formations. During cetaceans surveys in the area it was possible to ascertain the presence of some pelagic fishes as
Mobula mobular, Thunnus sp., Xiphias gladius and sea birds as Calonectris diomedea, Puffinus puffinus and Larus
ridibundus. The analysis of fin whales' faecal material has revealed the presence of crustacean exoskeleton belonging
to the euphasiacean Meganyctiphanes norvegica, a key species in the pelagic trophic web. Every summer we can
observe in the area large groups of common (Delphinus delphis), striped (Stenella coeruleoalba), bottlenose (Tursiops
truncatus) and Risso's dolphins (Grampus griseus). Feeding and mating behaviours were observed in all species.
Newborn were sighted in July and August. The area is also used as feeding ground by fin whales (Balaenoptera
physalus), the commonest species in the canyon. The strong impact of the boats on cetaceans is becoming everyday
routine especially in summertime: distress and disorientation, collisions and deaths by a propeller strike. Timely
management measures to protect cetaceans in this key area are clearly needed.
INTRODUCTION: The waters off the island of Ischia (Gulf of Naples) are long-term monitored
for a study on cetaceans since 1991 (Mussi et al., 1997, 1998). From 1997 the research focused in
the area on the north coast of the island, corresponding to the submarine canyon of Cuma, a
particular habitat characterised by a remarkable biodiversity and concentration of pelagic fauna
(Mussi et al., 1999).
The aim of this work is to examine closely the distribution of the different species of cetaceans with
particular attention to the area corresponding to the submarine canyon of Cuma, in order to include
this area (at least the more coastal part of it) into the future perimeter of the marine protected area
proposed by Italian Ministry of Environment, named "Regno di Nettuno" (islands of Ischia, Procida
and Vivara).
Every summer we could observe in the area large groups of common (Delphinus delphis), striped
(Stenella coeruleoalba), bottlenose (Tursiops truncatus) and Risso's dolphins (Grampus griseus).
Feeding and mating behaviours were observed for all species. Newborns were sighted in July and
August. The area is also used as feeding ground by fin whales (Balaenoptera physalus), the most
common species in the canyon.
During cetacean surveys in the area the presence also of some pelagic fishes as Mobula mobular,
Thunnus sp., Xiphias gladius and sea birds as Calonectris diomedea, Puffinus puffinus and Larus
ridibundus, was noted. The analysis of fin whales' faecal material revealed the presence of
crustacean exoskeletons belonging to the euphasiacean Meganyctiphanes norvegica, a key species
in the pelagic trophic web.
METHODS: In the periods 09/07/97-31/08/97; 03/07/98-19/08/98; 20/03/99-10/05/99 the
observations occurred on board of "Barbarian", a 15 m sail boat equipped for underwater listening
with towed hydrophones. From 20/06/00 to 30/08/00, following the wreck of the lab boat, the
studies were continued on board of “Jean Gab”, a 17.7 m long cutter equipped, in addition to the
previous system, with an underwater video camera fixed at the bow of the boat. Audio and video
signals were synchronically recorded with a BetaCam support.
The routes were chosen to optimise the sights and were determined daily on the basis of previous
sightings; particular attention was paid to follow the bottom topography and depth profiles. No trip
was performed in conditions greater than sea state 5 (Beaufort). Shots were made using automatic
cameras with objectives 70]200 mm/f:1-2,8 zoom, films Kodak ektacrome 200 Asa, with exposition
time inferior to 1/250. Along with weather conditions (sea and wind), also distance from the coast
and depth were recorded.
RESULTS: 211 outgoing have been carried out, 2970 nautical miles have been covered, for a total
amount of 197.6 hours of direct observation, and 166 cetacean sightings. The most common species
was fin whale with an amount of 66 sightings. In the studied area cetaceans reveal a coastal habit,
the average depth of the sighting was 197m (±128.2 SD, range 2.5-700), and the average distance
from the nearest coast was 4.1 Km (±2.9 SD; range 0.05-14.4). Sightings were located on the bank
of Forio, or mostly on the bathymetric lines of 200 and 300m off the north coast of Ischia. This
area, corresponding to the promontory of the island defined by Punta Vico and Punta Cornacchia,
represents the most coastal part of the canyon of Cuma where a great concentration of cetaceans
takes place.
The canyon of Cuma is a large deep submarine valley, which, starting from the areas close to Cuma
and Ischia island reaches a maximum depth of 800 m between the islands of Ischia and Ventotene.
This canyon represents a great sedimentary basin for materials which are carried along the coast by
Volturno and Garigliano rivers (Gulf of Gaeta); the canyon increases the upwelling speed and acts
also as conveying duct to the waters of the deep basin (De Pippo et al., 2000). The shelf area of the
Ischia island in front of the canyon is characterised by Posidonia oceanica (sea grass) beds, rocky
banks and rocky cliff with coralligenous formations.
All species of Odontocetes used the area of Cuma either as breeding or as feeding ground. In 27%
of the sightings mating and socialising were registered. The abundance of food resources probably
favour the wean of calves without wasting energies, in fact, in Cuma we had a high number of
newborns in dolphins' groups.
The peaks of cetaceans' births corresponds with the period of maximum tourists crowding along the
coast of Ischia, newborns have today to face a new threat constituted by the screws of the speed
pleasure crafts.
It is to be pointed out the presence of the rare common dolphin with 38 sightings. The
Mediterranean short beaked common dolphin and its habitat are today at risk because of the
probable joint effect of high levels of pollution, accidental or deliberate captures in fishing gears,
decrease in resources because of over fishing, intense sea traffic and general degradation of the
habitat. In Cuma area, it was possible to observe periodically a great group of about 80 individuals
of common dolphin. Photo-identified individuals, re-detected from 1997 to 2000, suggest that it is
a unique group which resorts to the utilisation of the area in the most favourable period.
CONCLUSIONS: The submarine canyon of Cuma is a very important habitat close to the northern
coast of the Ischia island where a particular pelagic assemblage can be found. The constant presence
of whales and dolphins, pelagic fishes and marine birds is related to the geological and ecological
characteristics of the area. The strong impact of the boats on cetaceans is becoming everyday
routine especially in summertime: distress and disorientation, collisions and deaths by a propeller
strike. Timely management measures to protect cetaceans in this key area are clearly needed,
regardless of its inclusion in the area proposed for the Marine Park.
REFERENCES:
De Pippo, T., Donadio, C., Pennetta, M., Terlizzi, F. e Vecchione, C., 2000. Caratteri morfologici
del canyon di Cuma (Campania, Italia). 2° Convegno Nazionale delle Scienze del Mare.
CoNISMA, Genova 22-25 Novembre 2000, Abstract: . Pagine ??
Mussi, B., Miragliuolo, A. e Battaglia M., 1997. Cetacei nell' arcipelago delle isole Pontine e
Campane. Atti del 5° Seminario Internazionale di Studi sull'Ecosistema marino. Gaeta, Napoli,
Ustica, Italia. Oasi Blu del WWF, Gaeta, Italia. Pagine ??
Mussi, B., Gabriele, R., Miragliuolo, A. and Battaglia, M., 1998. Cetacean sightings and
interaction with fisheries in the Archipelago Pontino-Campano, South Tyrrhenian sea, 1991-1995.
European Research on Cetaceans,12: 63-65
Mussi, B., Miragliuolo, A., Monzini, E., Diaz Lopez, B. and Battaglia, M., 1999. Fin whale
(Balaenoptera physalus) feeding ground in the coastal water of Ischia (archipelago Campano).
European Research on Cetacean, 13: 330-335
Pennetta, M et al. (gli altri AA vanno citati ), 1998. Influenza della morfologia costiera sulla
circolazione e sedimentazione sulla piattaforma continentale tra Gaeta e Cuma (Italia Meridionale)
Boll. Soc. Geol. It., 117 (1998), 281-295.
HUMAN-CETACEAN INTERACTIONS
Fig.1: The impact of fin whales with the shipping companies is documented with difficulty.
Fig. 2: Traces of collisions remain on the bodies of the cetaceans under form of scars or cuts
on the back.
Fig. 3: A 80cm long striped dolphin with the skull wide opened by a propeller strike.
Fig. 4: Risso's dolphins harassed by pleasure boaters: a dramatic human-dolphin interaction
with a high stranding risk.
... Consequently, exploring cetacean seasonal variability is a leading way to understand their presence and distribution and how these parameters relate with environmental and anthropogenic factors for conservation purposes. Mediterranean (Azzellino, Gaspari, Airoldi, & Nani, 2008;Cominelli, Moulins, Rosso, & Tepsich, 2016;Fiori, Giancardo, Aïssi, Alessi, & Vassallo, 2014;Gnone et al., 2011;Notarbartolo di Sciara, Agardy, Hyrenbach, Scovazzi, & Van Klaveren, 2008;Panigada et al., 2008;Tepsich, Rosso, Halpin, & Moulins, 2014), in the southern Mediterranean latitudes, especially on potential fin whale wintering areas in the Sicilian channel and Messina Strait (Canese et al., 2006;Celona & Comparetto, 2006;Sciacca et al., 2015), on specific cetacean hot spot areas, such as the Cuma Canyon (Mussi, Miragliuolo, De Pippo, Gambi, & Chiota, 2004) and the Alboran Sea (Cañadas, Sagarminaga, De Stephanis, Urquiola, & Hammond, 2005), or on more coastal areas focusing on bottlenose dolphins (Blasi & Boitani, 2014;Diaz López, 2006;Gnone et al., 2011). A few large-scale surveys have also provided information on wider portions of the western Mediterranean basin (Aissi et al., 2008;Cotté, Guinet, Taupier-Letage, Mate, & Petiau, 2009;Gannier, 2005;Panigada et al., 2011), but these occurred over a short time frame and predominantly focused on only one species. ...
Article
1. Cetaceans are key biological indicators of the status of marine waters and are protected under an extensive legislative framework. Research about these highly dynamic species is challenging, so seasonal cycles and patterns of distribution, especially in high sea areas, are still poorly understood. 2. This study contributes to improving knowledge about cetacean occurrence in largely unexplored areas of medium‐latitudes in the western Mediterranean Sea. Systematic surveys were conducted along a trans‐regional transect over 3 years (October 2012 to September 2015) allowing consistent data collection over almost 60 000 km of effort through all seasons. 3. Seasonal cetacean diversity wasinvestigated using a25km2 grid cell as a statistical unit to explore patterns of abundance, distribution, and habitat use in three marine sectors (Sardinian–Balearic, Bonifacio Strait, Tyrrhenian). All cetacean species regularly present in the Mediterranean basin were detected, with highest occurrence in fin whale and striped dolphin, followed by bottlenose dolphin and sperm whale. 4. The Sardinian–Balearic sector generally showed higher species richness and diversity than the Tyrrhenian, where seasonal variations were more pronounced. The study suggested seasonal movements, especially for fin whale and striped dolphin, in the Sardinian–Balearic sector with peaks of occurrence during spring/summer and lower numbers during winter/autumn, and also delivered interesting insights to rarer pelagic species. 5. The study identified areas/seasons in which the combined effect of high species diversity, abundance, significance of hot spots and presence of juveniles require increasing conservation effort. Results underline the important contribution of continuous monitoring in high sea areas to the implementation of adaptive protection measures. http://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1002/aqc.2758/full Full text available at: https://rdcu.be/2rsa
... Acting as a connecting corridor between continental shelf areas and the deep-sea, they play a major role in enhancing oceanographic processes and enriching the deep-sea food web (Canals et al. 2006, De Leo et al. 2010. As a consequence, submarine canyons are widely recognized as hotspots in cetacean distributions (Hooker et al. 1999, Mussi et al. 2001, Moulins et al. 2008. Previous interspecific comparisons suggest that a spatial (Moulins et al. 2008) or temporal (Azzellino et al. 2008) segregation may facilitate the coexistence of the 2 species in canyons. ...
Article
Full-text available
We used generalized additive models (GAMs) as exploratory habitat models for describing the distribution of 2 deep-diving species, Cuvier’s beaked whale Ziphius cavirostris Cuvier, 1823 and sperm whale Physeter catodon Linnaeus, 1758, in the Pelagos Sanctuary (northwestern Mediterranean). We analyzed data collected from research surveys and whale-watching activities during summer months from 2004 to 2007. The dataset encompassed 147 Cuvier’s beaked whale sightings and 52 sperm whale sightings. We defined and applied a post hoc workflow to the data, to minimize false absence bias arising from the unique ecology of the species and the lack of a dedicated sampling design. We calculated a novel topographic predictor, distance from the canyon axis, as a covariate for use in the habitat model. Given the complex topography of the area, the analysis was performed on a high-resolution spatial grid (1 km). Our methods allowed effective use of the non-dedicated sampling dataset for building habitat models of elusive and cryptic species (Cuvier’s beaked whale final model sensitivity = 0.88 and specificity = 0.84; sperm whale final model sensitivity = 0.65 and specificity = 0.77). The GAM results confirmed the preference for submarine canyons for both species and also highlighted the importance of the deeper portion of the Ligurian basin, especially for Cuvier’s beaked whale. Habitat overlap nevertheless is resolved by a well-defined spatial partitioning of the area, with sperm whale occupying the western part and Cuvier’s beaked whale the central and eastern parts.
... In the south-eastern Tyrrhenian Sea, the presence of a common dolphin population off the northern coast of the island of Ischia, Italy has been consistently documented since 1997. The animals have been sighted on a seasonal basis, mostly in the summer, over the submarine canyon of Cuma, a highly productive marine area characterized by significant pelagic biodiversity and multispecies associations (Mussi et al., 2004). ...
Article
Full-text available
1. The recent decline in the Mediterranean population of short‐beaked common dolphins Delphinus delphis has been the subject of scientific controversy and political indifference. Research on these animals has been very limited and there has been no large‐scale, systematic effort to assess and monitor their abundance and distribution. The consequent lack of data has prevented a good understanding of historical and ongoing trends. 2. Nonetheless, literature and osteological collections confirm that common dolphins were widespread and abundant in much of the Mediterranean Sea until the late 1960s and that their decline occurred relatively quickly. Today, common dolphins remain relatively abundant only in the westernmost portion of the basin (Alboràn Sea), with sparse records off Algeria and Tunisia, concentrations around the Maltese islands and in parts of the Aegean Sea, and relict groups in the south‐eastern Tyrrhenian and eastern Ionian Seas. Otherwise, these dolphins are rare in, or completely absent from, Mediterranean areas where information is available. 3. Circumstantial evidence and qualitative judgements by the authors suggest that the following factors may have contributed to the decline of common dolphins: reduced availability of prey caused by overfishing and habitat degradation; contamination by xenobiotic chemicals resulting in immunosuppression and reproductive impairment; environmental changes such as increased water temperatures affecting ecosystem dynamics; and incidental mortality in fishing gear, especially gillnets. The cumulative importance of these factors is poorly understood, and as a result, few conservation measures have been implemented. 4. This paper reviews current knowledge and suggests priorities for action aimed at identifying and mitigating the main threats to common dolphins in the Mediterranean, with the ultimate goal of restoring the species’ favourable conservation status in the region.
Conference Paper
Submarine canyons have long been considered important areas for marine life supporting especially abundant and unique communities of megafauna (including sometimes species not observed in other habitats). These emerged valleys provide also important habitats for various life stages of benthic and demersal fishes and invertebrates along continental margins. Indeed, submarine canyons are recurrent sources of habitat heterogeneity that may also serve as ‘keystone structures’. Besides this enhanced biodiversity, only few studies have reported the affinity between canyons and the aggregation of top predators (like marine mammals, sharks and tuna) in such areas. This work provides to underline the importance of canyons in the ecology of sperm whales inside the Mediterranean basin. Certainly this ‘isolated’ population, as Cuvier’s beaked whale which is also a deep diver cetacean, seems to use areas with special topographic features as habitat. In order to provide distribution and abundance estimates of the sperm whale population, ISHMAEL project financed by TOTAL Foundation have been developed by the Biology Department of the University of Genoa. More than 472 acoustic stations covering Ligurian and Corsican seas have been monitored using single omnidirectional hydrophone. Sperm whale has been detected in 12.7% of acoustic stations. Correlation between whale presence and some physical features of the area have been established. Whales distribution pattern suggest variable wide habitat used by this deep-diving species. In fact, preliminary results may indicate that sperm whale are distributed off the coast of Liguria, Corsica and Sardinia, concentrating mainly in correspondence of a selected number of submarine canyons and seamounts as well as in a limited number of ephemeral oceanographic structures. This study will help to define year round possible habitat areas of sperm whale inside the Mediterranean basin. The refuge role of submarine canyons may be especially important for protecting cetacean populations from extirpation in ecological cul-de-sacs.