ArticlePDF Available

An experimental meat-free diet maintained haematological characteristics in sprint-racing sled dogs

Authors:

Abstract and Figures

A dog's nutrient requirements can theoretically be met from a properly balanced meat-free diet; however, proof for this is lacking. Exercise places additional demands on the body, and dogs fed a meat-free diet may be at increased risk of developing sports anaemia. We hypothesised that exercising dogs would remain in good health and not develop anaemia when fed a nutritionally balanced meat-free diet. To this end, twelve sprint-racing Siberian huskies were fed either a commercial diet recommended for active dogs (n 6), or a meat-free diet formulated to the same nutrient specifications (n 6). The commercial diet contained 43 % poultry meal, whereas soyabean meal and maize gluten made up 43 % of the meat-free diet, as the main protein ingredients. Dogs were fed these diets as their sole nutrient intake for 16 weeks, including 10 weeks of competitive racing. Blood samples were collected at weeks 0, 3, 8 and 16, and veterinary health checks were conducted at weeks 0, 8 and 16. Haematology results for all dogs, irrespective of diet, were within normal range throughout the study and the consulting veterinarian assessed all dogs to be in excellent physical condition. No dogs in the present study developed anaemia. On the contrary, erythrocyte counts and Hb values increased significantly over time (P < 0.01) in both groups of dogs. The present study is the first to demonstrate that a carefully balanced meat-free diet can maintain normal haematological values in exercising dogs.
Content may be subject to copyright.
An experimental meat-free diet maintained haematological characteristics
in sprint-racing sled dogs
Wendy Y. Brown
1
*, Barbara A. Vanselow
2
, Andrew J. Redman
3
and John R. Pluske
4
1
Animal Science, School of Environmental and Rural Science, University of New England, Armidale, NSW 2351, Australia
2
NSW Department of Primary Industries, Beef Industry Centre, University of New England, Armidale, NSW 2351, Australia
3
Mars Petcare Australia, Petcare Place, Wodonga, Vic 3690, Australia
4
School of Veterinary and Biomedical Sciences, Animal Research Institute, Murdoch University, Murdoch, WA 6150, Australia
(Received 2 December 2008 – Revised 19 April 2009 – Accepted 27 April 2009 – First published online 1 June 2009)
A dog’s nutrient requirements can theoretically be met from a properly balanced meat-free diet; however, proof for this is lacking. Exercise places
additional demands on the body, and dogs fed a meat-free diet may be at increased risk of developing sports anaemia. We hypothesised that
exercising dogs would remain in good health and not develop anaemia when fed a nutritionally balanced meat-free diet. To this end, twelve
sprint-racing Siberian huskies were fed either a commercial diet recommended for active dogs (n6), or a meat-free diet formulated to the
same nutrient specifications (n6). The commercial diet contained 43 % poultry meal, whereas soyabean meal and maize gluten made up 43 %
of the meat-free diet, as the main protein ingredients. Dogs were fed these diets as their sole nutrient intake for 16 weeks, including 10 weeks
of competitive racing. Blood samples were collected at weeks 0, 3, 8 and 16, and veterinary health checks were conducted at weeks 0, 8 and 16.
Haematology results for all dogs, irrespective of diet, were within normal range throughout the study and the consulting veterinarian assessed all
dogs to be in excellent physical condition. No dogs in the present study developed anaemia. On the contrary, erythrocyte counts and Hb values
increased significantly over time (P,0·01) in both groups of dogs. The present study is the first to demonstrate that a carefully balanced meat-free
diet can maintain normal haematological values in exercising dogs.
Sled dogs: Exercise: Vegetarian diet: Blood count
There has been a steady increase in the number of articles on
vegetarian nutrition in humans appearing in the biomedical
literature, and this has been attributed to the increased popu-
larity of vegetarianism
(1)
and the documented health benefits
associated with well-balanced vegetarian diets
(2)
. In contrast
to this, there is a dearth of research into vegetarian nutrition
in the canine. In this regard, some dog and cat owners wish
to feed their pets a totally meat-free diet
(3)
for the same ethical
reasons that they themselves are vegetarian
(4)
. However, none
of the currently available meat-free dog and cat foods base
their claims of nutritional adequacy on recognised feeding
protocols, such as those specified by the Association of
American Feed Control Officials (AAFCO)
(5)
. Furthermore,
an independent analysis of two commercial vegan diets for
cats, claiming to be nutritionally complete and balanced,
found the diets to have multiple nutrient deficiencies
(6)
.
Unlike the obligatory carnivorous cat, dogs can synthesise
nutrients such as taurine and vitamin A
(7)
and theoretically
it is possible for the dog to subsist on a diet based solely on
plant ingredients. Commercial dry dog foods typically contain
a high proportion of plant ingredients, as a high grain content
is necessary for successful extrusion
(8)
. It is only a small step
from some of the popular cereal-based dry dog foods to one
that contains no meat at all. Conceptually, however, the gap
is much larger, and demonstrating that a meat-free diet is ade-
quate in sedentary dogs will not change the perception of
many dog owners that meat is required for dogs that are
actively working, or racing
(9)
. For this reason, sprint-racing
sled dogs were chosen for our experiment to challenge the
concept that meat is an essential dietary ingredient for exercis-
ing dogs. Our aim was to develop a nutritionally adequate
meat-free diet, based on chemical analysis, and to demonstrate
nutritional adequacy by feeding the diet in a controlled exper-
iment to active dogs. We hypothesised that dogs would remain
in good health, based on veterinary health checks and haema-
tological characteristics, and not develop anaemia.
Experimental methods
Twelve pure-bred Siberian huskies participated in the study,
which ran from 24 May to 20 September 2004 to coincide
with the Australian sled-dog racing season. The experiment
was of 16 weeks’ duration, incorporating 2 weeks of pre-
race training, 10 weeks of competitive racing and 4 weeks
of recovery. Throughout the study, dogs were fed either the
experimental meat-free diet (n6) or the meat-based control
*Corresponding author: Dr Wendy Yvonne Brown, fax þ61 2 6773 3922, email wbrown@une.edu.au
Abbreviations: BW, body weight; CP, crude protein; Cr, creatine; ME, metabolisable energy; PCV, packed cell volume.
British Journal of Nutrition (2009), 102, 1318–1323 doi:10.1017/S0007114509389254
qThe Authors 2009
British Journal of Nutrition
diet (n6) as their sole nutrient intake. Blood samples (5 ml)
were collected from the cephalic vein of dogs at rest (0, 3, 8
and 16 weeks) and analysed for complete blood count using
an automated cell counter (CellDyn 3500R; Abbott Diagnos-
tics, North Ryde, NSW, Australia). Veterinary health checks
were performed at weeks 0, 8 and 16 by the dog owners’
usual veterinarian, who was blinded to the dietary treatments.
Veterinary health checks consisted of a full physical examin-
ation, auscultation of the heart and lungs, and measurement of
rectal temperatures. Authority to conduct the present study
was granted by the University of New England Animal
Ethics Committee, in accordance with section 25 of the
Animal Research Act (1985).
Animal management
For the duration of the study, dogs were maintained in their
usual environment (Malusky Kennels, Belford, NSW, Austra-
lia), kennelled in pairs, with free access to water at all times.
Dogs were always kennelled with another dog from the same
dietary group to remove any likelihood of dogs accessing the
wrong diet. Each dog had its own bed, and kennels were fully
covered and protected from the weather. A large outdoor
grassed enclosure provided additional social interaction
where dogs were placed twice per d, as a single group,
under the owners’ supervision. The temperature in the kennels
ranged from 258Cto278C over the study period.
At 6 weeks before commencing the experiment, dogs were
administered booster vaccinations against canine distemper,
hepatitis and parvovirus (Canvace3; CSL, Parkville, Vic,
Australia) by subcutaneous injection. Dogs were weighed
and treated orally with anthelmintic (Drontal
w
Allwormer
w
;
Bayer Australia Ltd, Pymble, NSW, Australia) worming
tablets (active ingredients: praziquantel, 50 mg; pyrantel
embonate, 49·8 mg; febantel, 250 mg) at the recommended
dose rate (one tablet per 10 kg body weight (BW)) at week
0 and again at week 5.
Diets and feeding
Two diets were compared in the present study, a meat-based
and a meat-free diet of similar nutrient composition
(Tables 1 and 2). The meat-based diet was a commercial
dog food recommended for active dogs (Pedigree
w
Advancee
Energy – chicken; Mars Petcare Australia, Raglan, NSW,
Australia) and contained 43 % poultry meal (before extrusion)
as its main protein source. The experimental meat-free diet
(manufactured at the Mars Petcare pilot plant, Wodonga, Vic,
Australia) contained maize gluten and fine soya meal (passed
through a 1 mm sieve) as its main protein sources, which together
made up 43 % of the pre-extrusion ingredients. The meat-free diet
was coated with stabilised vegetable oil, whereas the meat-based
diet was coated with poultrytallow and poultry digest. A balanced
amino acid ratio was achieved in the meat-free diet without the use
of crystalline amino acids. Dogs were fed their allocated diets in
individual bowls as a single meal each evening, and this com-
prised their sole nutrient intake for the duration of the 16-week
experiment. Dogs were observed during feeding to confirm that
each individual consumed its allocated ration. Individual feed
intakes were recorded daily and BW were measured fortnightly.
Individual feeding levels were adjusted as necessary to maintain
ideal BW. Ideal BW were determined by the trainer and equated
to a body condition score of 4 using a standard nine-point scale
(Purina Body Condition System) ranging from 1 (emaciated) to
9 (severely obese).
As the meat-free diet had not been manufactured pre-
viously, a separate feeding trial was conducted to determine
digestibility coefficients of the experimental diet. For the
digestibility trial, eight dogs of mixed breeds were individu-
ally housed on concrete floors at the University of New
England Dog Research Facility. Following an adaptation
period, the experimental diet was fed solely for 12 d and
all faeces produced during the final 4 d were collected for
determination of total-tract apparent digestibility.
Exercise and racing schedule
Dogs were trained and raced in teams (a six-dog team, a four-
dog team, and a two-dog team) by their usual trainers. Within
teams, each dog was paired with another dog of similar ability,
based on the trainer’s assessment of performance before the
commencement of the trial. Each dog was harnessed to its
allocated exercise partner for all training and racing activities.
Within each exercise pair, one dog was allocated to diet 1 and
the other to diet 2, maintaining an even distribution for sex,
BW and age between the two dietary groups. Following allo-
cation of dogs into diet groups 1 and 2, the test diets were then
arbitrarily designated: the meat-free as diet 1 and meat-based
as diet 2. Each group comprised three female and three male
dogs; mean age and BW were 3·7 years and 19·7kg respect-
ively for dogs fed the meat-free diet and 3·2 years and
20·2 kg for dogs fed the meat-based diet. One dog from each
group was neutered; all others were entire.
Pre-race training commenced with the onset of cooler
weather in April, and involved dogs pulling heavily laden
carts at slow speed. The final 2 weeks of this phase of training
were included in the experiment, during which the dogs com-
pleted seven training runs of 6 km distances at an average
speed of 12 km/h. The next 10 weeks involved competitive
racing in addition to the training runs which continued three
or four times per week. The heavily weighted rigs were
replaced with light-weight rigs, and the training runs became
faster (20 km/h) and longer (6 –10 km runs). Dogs participated
in sprint races approximately once a fortnight, from 12 June
(week 2) until the 14 August (week 12). Sprint races were
run in accordance with Australian Sled-dog Sports Association
Table 1. Composition of diets before extrusion
Diet
Ingredient (g/kg) Meat-based Meat-free
Rice (broken) 120 120
Maize (whole) 170 250
Sorghum 140 –
Poultry meal 430
Maize gluten 60 300
Fine soya meal 130
Sodium caseinate 60
Vegetable mix 60
Sugarbeet pulp 30
Vitamin and mineral mix 50 80
Meat-free diet sustains exercising dogs 1319
British Journal of Nutrition
(ASSA) rules, the maximum distance for a sprint race being
12 km for a team of six, 9 km for a team of four, and 2 km
for a team of two. Following the 10-week racing phase, train-
ing was gradually reduced over the 4-week recovery period.
Chemical analysis of diets
Representative samples of the two diets were finely ground
before chemical analyses. N content was determined using
an FP-2000 LECO Nitrogen Analyzer (LECO Corp.,
St Joseph, MO, USA), from which crude protein (CP) concen-
tration was calculated (CP ¼N£6·25). The gross energy of
the diets was determined with an IKA
w
-Werke C7000 bomb
calorimeter (IKA
w
Group, Staufen, Germany). The metabolis-
able energy (ME) content was calculated from digestible CP
and gross energy using a correction factor of 5023 kJ/g for
energy lost in urine
(5)
. Fat content was determined by Soxhlet
extraction with chloroform
(10)
. Total starch content was deter-
mined using the Megazyme Total Starch assay kit (Megazyme
Australia Pty, Warriewood, NSW, Australia). The NSP
content of the diets was determined by a combination
of the methods of Englyst & Hudson
(11)
and Theander &
Westerlund
(12)
. Amino acid analysis was conducted by the
Department of Primary Industries (Werribee, Vic, Australia).
The amino acids, apart from tryptophan, were assayed using
cation exchange chromatography following acid hydrolysis.
Methionine and cystine were first pre-oxidised with formic
acid before acid hydrolysis. Tryptophan was determined
by alkaline hydrolysis using a reverse-phase column with
UV detection at 280 nm. Mineral content was determined
using a Reagent-FreeeIon Chromatograph (ICS-2000 Ion
Chromatography System; Dionex Corp., Sunnyvale, CA,
USA) and AS40 Autosampler (Dionex Corp.).
Statistical methods
ANOVA for repeated measures was performed on haematolo-
gical data using the Super ANOVA statistical software pack-
age (Abacus Concepts, Berkley, CA, USA). Factors fitted to
the model were diet, time and their interaction. Duncan’s
new multiple-range test was used to separate the means
which differed significantly. Data are presented as mean
values with their standard errors. Haematological values
differed between the dietary groups at the commencement of
the study (week 0) for erythrocytes, Hb and packed cell
volume (PCV). To enable interpretation of the effect of diet
on these variables, values measured at week 0 for each dog
were subtracted from values measured at subsequent weeks
and these differences from the initial baseline values were
then subjected to statistical analysis.
Results
Both the meat-based and the meat-free diets were readily
consumed. Average daily nutrient intakes are presented in
Table 2. Based on chemical analyses, both of the diets fed
in the present study exceeded the recommended nutrient
requirements for maintenance in adult dogs
(13)
(Table 3).
All nutrients were within the known minimum and safe maxi-
mum upper limits. From the digestibility trial, DM, gross
energy, CP and starch digestibility for the meat-free diet
were: 83·1 (SEM 0·91), 87·5 (SEM 0·69), 89·4 (SEM 0·61) and
97·7 (SEM 0·11) % respectively.
Dogs performed well at a national level in races; the six-dog
team was placed fourth overall from twenty-nine competitors
(dog teams) and the four-dog team finished seventh out of
thirty-six competitors in the 2004 Australian Sled-dog Sports
Association (ASSA) National Point Scores. Veterinary
health checks conducted at weeks 0, 8 and 16 found all
dogs to be in good health and no abnormalities were detected.
Haematology results were consistent with published normal
ranges for haematological values for dogs
(14)
throughout the
study. Erythrocyte counts, PCV and Hb concentration
increased significantly (P,0·01) with time in both groups of
dogs (Table 4). There was no significant effect of diet, and
no significant interaction between diet and time, on any of
the blood characteristics measured in the present study.
Discussion
Dog foods are tested for their nutritional adequacy in the first
instance by means of chemical analysis. However, not all of
the nutrients present in the dog food will necessarily be avail-
able to the dog. This is why recognised feeding protocols are
Table 2. Analysed chemical composition of diets (as fed) and average daily intakes in twelve Siberian huskies
(Mean values and standard deviations for six animals per group)
Daily intake (per kg body weight
0·7 5
)
Content in diet (per kg) Meat-based diet Meat-free diet
Meat-based Meat-free Mean SD Mean SD
DM (g) 927 936 30·36 4·28 27·59 3·15
Gross energy (MJ) 20·9 21·1 0·68 0·10 0·73 0·08
Crude protein (g) 306 289 10·02 1·41 10·02 1·15
Crude fat (g) 166 165 5·44 0·77 5·72 0·64
Starch (g) 310 296 10·15 1·43 10·26 1·17
Free sugars (g) 7·5 19·8 0·25 0·03 0·69 0·08
Soluble NSP (g) 4·6 3·6 0·15 0·02 0·13 0·01
Insoluble NSP (g) 29·7 38·8 0·97 0·14 1·35 0·15
Total NSP (g) 34·3 42·4 1·12 0·16 1·48 0·17
W. Y. Brown et al.1320
British Journal of Nutrition
used to support nutritional adequacy claims. Where diets are
specifically formulated and marketed for active dogs, it
would seem that testing these diets in actively exercising
dogs would be a more appropriate test of the diet’s nutritional
adequacy for its designated purpose.
The present study is the first to demonstrate using a short
feeding trial that a meat-free diet can be nutritionally adequate
for exercising dogs. Whilst longer-term trials are necessary to
prove this claim, nutritional adequacy was shown by chemical
analyses, and this was further demonstrated by feeding the
diet, in a controlled experiment, to actively exercising dogs.
Each dog fed the meat-free diet was harnessed to a dog fed
the meat-based diet and therefore did exactly the same inten-
sity and amount of exercise. Blood profiles and veterinary
examinations indicated that all the dogs remained in good
health throughout the study irrespective of whether they
were fed diets based on animal or plant proteins. There is
only one other study reported in the literature that examines
a meat-free diet in exercising dogs and, in that study, dogs
fed the vegetable-protein diet developed anaemia (evidenced
by a significant decrease in Hb and erythrocyte counts)
whilst dogs fed the animal-protein diet showed no significant
haematological changes
(15)
.
Many human vegetarians have achieved prowess as athletes
and the nutritional considerations for vegetarian athletes have
been well documented
(16)
. Studies reported in the scientific
literature have found no differences in fitness or performance
between vegetarian and non-vegetarian athletes
(17,18)
and have
concluded that a balanced meat-free diet is not detrimental to
athletic performance
(19,20)
. All of the amino acids that are
known to be essential for man and for dogs can be obtained
from plant sources. However, there appears to be a propensity
for human vegetarians to have lower mean muscle creatine
(Cr) concentrations than omnivores
(21)
and as Cr is an import-
ant component of the energy delivery process, it has been
suggested that this could affect exercise performance. Supple-
menting diets with Cr has been shown to increase exercise
potential in humans, and it has been suggested that an
adequate supply of dietary Cr might also be important
for exercising dogs. Whilst moderate intakes of Cr could
be expected from consuming raw meat, commercial dog
foods provide very little Cr due to its degradation by heat
Table 3. Nutrient content of experimental diets and National Research
Council (NRC) recommended
(13)
allowances for maintenance in adult dogs*
Diet
Nutrient Meat-based Meat-free NRC recommended
Crude protein (g) 75·8 71·2 25·0
Essential amino acids
Arginine (g) 4·53 3·65 0·88
Histidine (g) 1·61 1·93 0·48
Isoleucine (g) 3·07 3·16 0·95
Leucine (g) 7·08 8·84 1·70
Lysine (g) 2·55 2·76 0·88
Methionine (g) 1·07 1·42 0·83
Phenylalanine (g) 3·62 4·09 1·13
Threonine (g) 3·02 2·78 1·08
Tryptophan (g) 0·50 0·55 0·35
Valine (g) 4·19 3·88 1·23
Crude fat (g) 41·1 40·7 13·8
Minerals
Ca (g) 3·5 2·3 1·0
P (g) 2·5 1·7 1·0
Mg (g) 0·3 0·3 0·2
Na (g) 2·2 2·1 0·2
K (g) 1·6 2·9 1·0
Fe (mg) 53·0 30·6 7·5
Cu (mg) 4·9 6·0 1·5
Zn (mg) 123·2 35·2 15·0
Mn (mg) 3·6 5·9 1·2
* All values reported are per 4184 kJ (1000 kcal) metabolisable energy.
Table 4. Changes in blood variables measured in Siberian huskies during a racing season in which dogs were fed either
meat-free or meat-based diets as their sole nutrient intake for 16 weeks
(Mean values with their standard errors for six animals per group)
Meat-based diet Meat-free diet P
Variable Mean SEM Mean SEM Diet Time Diet £time
Erythrocyte count ( £10
12
/l)* 0·54 0·002 0·46
Week 0† 6·52
a
0·27 6·02
a,b
0·12
Week 3 20·08
a
0·21 20·08
a
0·18
Week 8 0·47
b
0·34 0·28
a,b
0·25
Week 16 0·73
b
0·25 0·35
b
0·21
Hb (g/l)‡ 0·66 0·006 0·81
Week 0† 150·4
a
5·2 143·8
a,b
3·1
Week 3 20·8
a
4·1 21·9
a
3·9
Week 8 10·3
b
6·8 5·4
a,b
5·1
Week 16 9·4
b
5·4 7·1
b
3·4
Packed cell volume (%)§ 0·73 0·01 0·71
Week 0† 43·96
a
1·55 41·85
a
0·80
Week 3 20·35
a
1·39 20·10
a
1·14
Week 8 2·97
b
2·17 1·81
b
1·50
Week 16 3·22
b
1·61 2·14
b
1·15
a,b
Mean values for a variable within a column with unlike superscript letters were significantly different (P,0·05).
* The normal range for erythrocyte count in dogs is 5·5 to 8·5 £10
12
/l.
Values measured at week 0 are baseline values. Data presented for weeks 3 to 16 are differences from baseline values.
‡ The normal range for Hb in dogs is 120 to 180 g/l.
§ The normal range for packed cell volume in dogs is 37 to 55 %.
Meat-free diet sustains exercising dogs 1321
British Journal of Nutrition
processing
(22)
. However, it is not essential for mammals to
have Cr in the diet, as it is synthesised in the body from the
amino acids arginine and glycine. Based on findings that
oral Cr supplementation did not lead to corresponding
increases in muscle concentrations in caged beagles
(23)
or in
racing greyhounds, and that Cr supplementation in racing
greyhounds did not improve performance
(24)
, it is unlikely
that a lack of dietary Cr would have any detrimental effect
on exercising dogs, provided that dietary intakes of arginine
and glycine are adequate.
Extraordinarily high daily ME intakes (4100 kJ/kg BW
0· 7 5
per d) have been recorded in Alaskan sled dogs racing long
distances (490 km) in freezing conditions
(25)
, whereas the
sled dogs in the present study raced over short distances in
mild climatic conditions. The average daily ME intakes of
the sled dogs in our experiment were calculated to be 572
(SEM 71) kJ/kg BW
0·7 5
per d and this is consistent with ME
requirements reported for moderately active border collies
(26)
.
The haematology results from the present study reveal some
interesting findings, but it should be emphasised that all values
were always within normal range. It should also be noted that
the observed increases in erythrocyte counts, PCV and Hb
were greatest in dogs fed the meat-based diet and that the
sample size (n6) might have been insufficient to detect signifi-
cant differences between the two dietary groups. In our experi-
ment, erythrocyte counts and PCV increased significantly
over time (P,0·01) in all dogs, whether they were fed the
meat-based or the meat-free diet. In contrast to this, both
PCV and erythrocytes decreased significantly (P,0·05) over
time in twelve sprint-racing Alaskan huskies during a
24-week training and racing season
(27)
. The Alaskan huskies
were fed diets that contained 20 and 24 % CP (as fed),
which is considerably less than the CP content of the diets
used in the present study (approximately 30 % CP). Another
experiment with thirty-two Alaskan sled dogs
(28)
found that
PCV and erythrocytes increased after training in dogs fed
diets of higher protein content (3·6, 5·3 and 6·1 g/kg BW per d)
but decreased in identically exercised dogs fed the diet with
the lowest CP content (3·0 g/kg BW per d). Dogs in the present
study received 4·7 g CP/kg BW per d, and the increase in
PCV and erythrocytes observed in our dogs is consistent
with these results. Human studies have shown that exercise
increases erythrocyte destruction
(29)
, but provided that this
does not exceed erythrocyte production then no detrimental
effects occur
(30)
. From the present study, and the work of
Reynolds et al.
(28)
, it appears that feeding dogs a higher
concentration of protein enabled a higher rate of erythrocyte
production, in excess of the numbers destroyed by exercise.
These findings highlight the importance of providing sufficient
dietary protein for exercising dogs, irrespective of whether
the protein is of plant or animal origin.
Conclusions
The present study is the first to demonstrate the potential for a
meat-free diet to be nutritionally adequate for exercising dogs.
In a 16-week controlled experiment, a meat-free diet main-
tained haematological characteristics in sprint-racing sled
dogs (Siberian huskies). Importantly, these findings pave the
way for commercial pet food manufacturers to produce nutri-
tionally adequate meat-free diets for dogs.
Acknowledgements
The present study was funded by an Australian Research
Council Linkage Grant to which Mars Petcare Australia
contributed as the industry partner. The authors would like
to thank Anne and Donal McIntyre (Malusky Kennels,
Belford, NSW, Australia) for allowing their dogs to participate
in the present study, and for their assistance throughout
the trial; and Dr Dorothy Robinson of NSW Department of
Primary Industries (Beef Industry Centre) for her assistance
with the statistical analysis.
An abstract of this research was presented at the 18th
Symposium of ‘Recent Advances in Animal Nutrition in
Australia’ (June 2005), University of New England, Armidale,
NSW, Australia.
Author contributions were as follows: W. Y. B., canine nutri-
tion, study design and oversight; B. A. V., veterinary haematol-
ogy; A. J. R., diet formulations; J. R. P., nutrition and physiology.
A. J. R. was employed by Mars Petcare Australia. None of
the other authors has any conflicts of interest to declare.
References
1. Sabate J, Duk A & Lee CL (1999) Publication trends of
vegetarian nutrition articles in biomedical literature, 1966– 1995.
Am J Clin Nutr 70, 601S–607S.
2. White R & Frank E (1994) Health effects and prevalence of
vegetarianism. West J Med 160, 465 470.
3. Dzanis DA (1999) Vegetarian diets for pets? In FDA Veterinar-
ian Newsletter, vol. XIV, no. III, pp. 3 5. Rockville, MD: FDA
Veterinarian, Center for Veterinary Medicine.
4. Wakefield LA, Shofer FS & Michel KE (2006) Evaluation of
cats fed vegetarian diets and attitudes of their caregivers.
J Am Vet Med Assoc 229, 70 73.
5. Association of American Feed Control Officials (2007) Official
Publication of the Association of Feed Control Officials. Atlanta,
GA: Association of American Feed Control Officials Inc.
6. Gray CM, Sellon RK & Freeman LM (2004) Nutritional
adequacy of two vegan diets for cats. J Am Vet Med Assoc
225, 16701675.
7. MacDonald ML, Rogers QR & Morris JG (1984) Nutrition of
the domestic cat, a mammalian carnivore. Annu Rev Nutr 4,
521562.
8. Dzanis D (2003) Petfood types, quality assessment and
feeding management. In Petfood Technology, 1st ed., pp. 68
[JL Kvamme and TD Phillips, editors]. Mt Morris, IL: Watt
Publishing Co.
9. Griffiths BC (1969) Nutrition of the greyhound. Vet Rec 84,
654656.
10. Association of Official Analytical Chemists (1995) Official
Methods of Analysis, 15th ed. Washington, DC: Association of
Official Analytical Chemists.
11. Englyst HN & Hudson GJ (1993) Dietary fiber and starch:
classification and measurement. In Dietary Fiber and Human
Nutrition, 2nd ed., pp. 5371 [G Spiller, editor]. Boca Raton,
FL: CRC Press, Inc.
12. Theander O & Westerlund E (1993) Determination of individual
components of dietary fiber. In Dietary Fiber and Human Nutri-
tion, 2nd ed., pp. 77 98 [G Spiller, editor]. Boca Raton, FL:
CRC Press, Inc.
13. National Research Council (2006) Nutrient Requirements of Dogs
and Cats. Washington, DC: The National Academies Press.
14. Bentinck-Smith J (1980) A roster of normal values for
dogs and cats. In Current Veterinary Therapy, 7th ed.,
W. Y. Brown et al.1322
British Journal of Nutrition
pp. 13211330 [RW Kirk, editor]. Philadelphia, PA: W.B.
Saunders Company.
15. Yamada T, Tohori M, Ashida T, et al. (1987) Comparison
of effects of vegetable protein diet and animal protein diet on
the initiation of anemia during vigorous physical training
(sports anemia) in dogs and rats. J Nutr Sci Vitaminol (Tokyo) 33,
129–149.
16. Barr SI & Rideout CA (2004) Nutritional considerations for
vegetarian athletes. Nutrition 20, 696703.
17. Nieman DC (1988) Vegetarian dietary practices and endurance
performance. Am J Clin Nutr 48, 754 761.
18. Hanne N, Dlin R & Rotstein A (1986) Physical fitness, anthro-
pometric and metabolic parameters in vegetarian athletes.
J Sports Med Phys Fitness 26, 180 185.
19. Eisinger M, Plath M, Jung K, et al. (1994) Nutrient intake of
endurance runners with ovo-lacto-vegetarian diet and regular
Western diet. Z Erna
¨hrungswiss 33, 217229.
20. Nieman DC (1999) Physical fitness and vegetarian diets: is there
a relation? Am J Clin Nutr 70, 570S 575S.
21. Venderley AM & Campbell WW (2006) Vegetarian diets:
nutritional considerations for athletes. Sports Med 36,
293305.
22. Harris RC, Lowe JA, Warnes K, et al. (1997) The concentration
of creatine in meat, offal and commercial dog food. Res Vet Sci
62, 5862.
23. Lowe JA, Murphy M & Nash V (1998) Changes in plasma and
muscle creatine concentration after increases in supplementary
dietary creatine in dogs. J Nutr 128, 2691S 2693S.
24. National Research Council (2006) Physical activity and
environment. In Nutrient Requirements of Dogs and Cats,
pp. 300301. Washington, DC: The National Academies Press.
25. Hinchcliff K, Reinhart G, Burr J, et al. (1997) Metabolizable
energy intake and sustained energy expenditure of Alaskan
sled dogs during heavy exertion in the cold. Am J Vet Res 58,
14571462.
26. Burger IH (1994) Energy needs of companion animals: match-
ing food intakes to requirements throughout the life cycle.
J Nutr 124, 2584S2593S.
27. Querengaesser A, Iben C & Leibetseder J (1994) Blood changes
during training and racing in sled dogs. J Nutr 124,
2760S2764S.
28. Reynolds A, Reinhart G, Carey D, et al. (1999) Effect of protein
intake during training on biochemical and performance variables
in sled dogs. Am J Vet Res 60, 789 795.
29. Smith J, Kolbuch-Braddon M, Gillam I, et al. (1995) Changes in
the susceptibility of red blood cells to oxidative and osmotic
stress following submaximal exercise. Eur J Appl Physiol
Occup Physiol 70, 427436.
30. Smith J (1995) Exercise, training and red blood cell turnover.
Sports Med 19, 931.
Meat-free diet sustains exercising dogs 1323
British Journal of Nutrition
... This important adaptation also enabled dogs to continue their co-existence with early humans during the agricultural revolution. The result is reflected in modern dogs, where even canine endurance athletes are able to maintain a high level of performance without animal-derived products in their diet [6]. Increasing awareness of industrial food animal production's central role in driving accelerated anthropogenic climate change, environmental degradation, disease patterns as well as social injustices, has impacted consumer behaviors and fueled a growing interest in products developed without animal-sourced ingredients [4,7]. ...
... Changing societal trends have created an increasing demand for non-conventional dog foods, which has also triggered questions about the nutritional adequacy of such diets and their impact on cardiac and other health outcomes in canine consumers [8][9][10][11][12][13]. While short-term studies have supported the adequacy of K9PBN [4,6,14], the need for long-term studies has remained. Bridging this knowledge gap served as the rationale driving this study. ...
... Table). Our results align with previously published, short term, studies reporting on the outcomes in dogs fed K9PBN [4,6,14]. A recent study by Cavanaugh, et al, evaluated the same diet as used in our study (including peas as a primary protein source) in dogs over a shorter time period [14]. ...
Article
Full-text available
Domestic dogs can maintain health on complete and well-balanced canine plant-based nutrition (K9PBN). Novel insight on health outcomes in dogs consuming K9PBN is of relevance to veterinary professionals and consumers given a growing interest in non-traditional dog foods with perceived health benefits, while considering potential safety concerns. We aimed to investigate nutritional equivalence by measuring clinical health outcomes in adult dogs fed K9PBN over twelve months compared to a meat-based diet at baseline. We enrolled fifteen clinically healthy adult dogs living in households in Los Angeles County, California in a prospective cohort study and evaluated clinical, hematological, and nutritional parameters in dogs at 0, 6, and 12 months, including complete blood count (CBC), blood chemistry, cardiac biomarkers, plasma amino acids, and serum vitamin concentrations. The study found that clinically healthy, client-owned, adult dogs maintain health, based on physical exams, complete blood count, serum chemistry, plasma amino acids, serum vitamins, and cardiac biomarkers combined with client-reported observations, when fed commercial K9PBN over a twelve-month period. This study is the most comprehensive and longest known K9PBN investigation to date and provides clinically relevant evidence-based nutrition data and new knowledge on outcomes in clinically healthy dogs who thrive without consumption of animal-derived ingredients. These results also provide a valuable foundation for the future study of K9PBN as a potential nutritional intervention for clinically relevant pathologies in canine medicine. Lastly, it is of major relevance to One Health paradigms since ingredients produced independent of industrial food animal production are both more sustainable and help to circumvent ethical dilemmas for maintenance of health in domestic dogs.
... This important adaptation also enabled dogs to continue their co-existence with early humans during the agricultural revolution. The result is reflected in modern dogs, where even canine endurance athletes are able to maintain a high level of performance without animal-derived products in their diet 5 . Increasing awareness of industrial food animal production's central role in driving accelerated anthropogenic climate change, environmental degradation, disease patterns as well as social injustices, has impacted consumer behaviors and fueled a growing interest in products developed without animal-sourced ingredients 3,6 . ...
... Changing societal trends have created an increasing demand for non-conventional dog foods, which has also triggered questions about the nutritional adequacy of such diets and their impact on cardiac and other health outcomes in canine consumers [7][8][9][10][11][12] . While short-term studies have supported the adequacy of K9PBN 3,5,13 , the need for long-term studies has remained. Bridging this knowledge gap served as the rationale driving this study. ...
... No reuse allowed without permission. Our results align with previously published, short term, studies reporting on the outcomes in dogs fed K9PBN 3,5,13 . A recent study by Cavanaugh, et al, evaluated the same diet as used in our study (including peas as a primary protein source) in dogs over a shorter time period 13 . ...
Preprint
Objective Domestic dogs can maintain health on complete and well-balanced canine plant-based nutrition (K9PBN). Novel insight on health outcomes in dogs consuming K9PBN is of relevance to veterinary professionals and consumers given a growing interest in non-traditional dog foods with perceived health benefits, while considering potential safety concerns. We aimed to investigate nutritional equivalence by measuring clinical health outcomes in adult dogs fed K9PBN over twelve months compared to a meat-based diet at baseline. Animals Fifteen clinically healthy adult dogs living in households in Los Angeles County, California. Procedures Prospective cohort study evaluating clinical, hematological, and nutritional parameters in dogs at 0, 6, and 12 months, including complete blood count (CBC), blood chemistry, cardiac biomarkers, plasma amino acids, and serum vitamin concentrations. Results Clinically healthy, client-owned, adult dogs maintain health, based on physical exams, CBC, serum chemistry, plasma amino acids, serum vitamins, and cardiac biomarkers combined with client-reported observations, when fed commercial K9PBN over a twelve-month period. Clinical Relevance This study is the most comprehensive and longest known K9PBN investigation to date. It provides clinically important evidence-based nutrition data and new knowledge on outcomes in clinically healthy dogs who maintain health without consumption of animal-derived ingredients. Also, it is of major relevance to One Health paradigms since ingredients produced independent of industrial food animal production are both more sustainable and help to circumvent ethical dilemmas for maintenance of health in domestic dogs.
... A considerable body of recent evidence indicates that provided such diets are formulated to be nutritionally-sound, as modern commercial vegan diets usually are [15], dogs and cats maintained on vegan diets can have longevity and health at least equivalent, and in some respects superior, to those maintained on conventional meat-based diets. Such results are evident within studies of health outcomes in both dogs (nine studies: [16][17][18][19][20][21][22][23][24]) and cats (four studies: [23,[25][26][27]). ...
... However, a sizeable and rapidly-growing body of evidence has now shown that both dogs and cats can thrive on nutritionally-sound vegan diets. Such results are evident within both canine (nine studies: [16][17][18][19][20][21][22][23][24]) and feline (four studies: [23,[25][26][27]) studies of health outcomes. Furthermore, their behavioural needs and welfare are not compromised by such diets [28]. ...
Article
Full-text available
Environmental impacts of the livestock sector are proportional to consumption levels. To assess the relative consumption of livestock animals within the diets of dogs, cats and people, this study examined their dietary energy needs within the US in 2020, and globally in 2018. Also studied were US pet food ingredients, and environmental sustainability indicators for plant- and animal-based foods consumed globally. Relative consumptions of average livestock animals were: US: dogs– 17.7%, cats– 2.3%, humans– 80.0%; and globally: dogs– 7.7%, cats– 1.2%, humans– 91.1%. Full transition to nutritionally-sound vegan diets would spare from slaughter the following numbers of terrestrial livestock animals annually (billions): US: dogs– 1.7, cats– 0.2, humans– 7.8, and globally: dogs– 6.0, cats– 0.9, humans– 71.3, as well as billions of aquatic animals in all dietary groups. Very large impact reductions were also associated with land and water use, emissions of greenhouse gases (GHGs), acidifying and eutrophifying gases, and biocide use, in all dietary groups. If implemented globally, nutritionally-sound vegan diets would free up land larger than the following nations: dogs–Saudi Arabia or Mexico, cats–Japan or Germany, humans–Russia–the world’s largest country–combined with India. Such diets would save freshwater volumes greater than all renewable freshwater in the following nations: dogs–Denmark, cats–Jordan, humans–Cuba. Such diets would reduce GHGs by amounts greater than all GHG emissions from following nations: dogs–South Africa or the UK, cats–Israel or New Zealand, humans–India or the entire EU. The numbers of additional people who could be fed using food energy savings associated with vegan diets exceeded the 2018 human populations of the following nations: dogs–the entire European Union, cats–France or the UK, humans–every single nation or collective region on Earth, as defined by the World Bank. All of these estimates are conservative.
... Five studies performed hematological and biochemical profiles in dogs to assess essential amino acids, vitamin, mineral, and folic acid levels when compared to a meatbased diet, or after changing to a vegan alternative. Brown et al., 2009 reported an increase in erythrocyte count, hemoglobin, and packed cell volume, although these stayed within reference ranges without signs of anemia or health disorders [32]. Higher hemoglobin values were also reported in 28 dogs by Cavanaugh et al., 2021 [33]. ...
... Five studies performed hematological and biochemical profiles in dogs to assess essential amino acids, vitamin, mineral, and folic acid levels when compared to a meatbased diet, or after changing to a vegan alternative. Brown et al., 2009 reported an increase in erythrocyte count, hemoglobin, and packed cell volume, although these stayed within reference ranges without signs of anemia or health disorders [32]. Higher hemoglobin values were also reported in 28 dogs by Cavanaugh et al., 2021 [33]. ...
Article
Full-text available
Simple Summary There has been controversy within the scientific literature, and in the popular press and online media, around the safety of feeding vegan diets to dogs and cats. With an increase in adherence to meat-free diets in the human population, many guardians may be considering providing these diets to their companion animals. Concerns arise due to dog and cat gut physiology which has adapted to a complete meat-based diet (cats) or largely meat-based diet (dogs). Particular concerns have been raised around deficiencies in certain amino acids such as taurine, and vitamins such as B12 (cobalamin) and B9 (folate). To date, there has been no formal assimilation of the scientific evidence on this topic, with a focus on actual health impacts of diets, as opposed to nutritional composition. In this review, we conducted a formal assessment of the evidence in the form of a systematic review. We found that there has been limited scientific study on the impact of vegan diets on cat and dog health. In addition, the studies that have been conducted tended to employ small sample sizes, with study designs which are considered less reliable in evidence-based practice. Whilst there have been several survey studies with larger sample sizes, these types of studies can be subject to selection bias based on the disposition of the respondents towards alternative diets, or since answers may relate to subjective concepts such as body condition. However, there is little evidence of adverse effects arising in dogs and cats on vegan diets. In addition, some of the evidence on adverse health impacts is contradicted in other studies. Additionally, there is some evidence of benefits, particularly arising from guardians’ perceptions of the diets. Given the lack of large population-based studies, a cautious approach is recommended. If guardians wish to implement a vegan diet, it is recommended that commercial foods are used. Abstract There has been an increase in vegetarianism and veganism in human populations. This trend also appears to be occurring in companion animals, with guardians preferring to feed their animals in accordance with their own dietary values and choices. However, there has been controversy amongst vets and online commentators about the safety of feeding vegan diets to carnivorous species, such as cats and dogs. In spite of this controversy, to date there has been no systematic evaluation of the evidence on this topic. A systematic search of Medline, Scopus, and Web of Science was performed, identifying 16 studies on the impact of vegan diets on cat and dog health. Studies were appraised for quality using established critical appraisal tools or reporting guidelines. There was considerable heterogeneity in the outcomes measured, and study designs employed, with few studies evaluating key outcomes of interest. Grading of Recommendations, Assessment, Development and Evaluation (GRADE) was utilized for assessment of certainty in the evidence, with the evidence for most outcomes being assessed as low or very low. Whilst the quality and amount of evidence needs to be considered in formulating recommendations, there was no overwhelming evidence of adverse effects arising from use of these diets and there was some evidence of benefits. It is, however, recommended that future high-quality studies, with standardized outcome measures and large sample sizes, be conducted. At the current time, if guardians wish to feed their companion animals vegan diets, a cautious approach should be taken using commercially produced diets which have been formulated considering the nutritional needs of the target species.
... Brown and colleague's 2009 study of sprint racing Siberian Huskies [19], did not record anaemia or other detectable health problems, in dogs fed either meat or VP-based diets (each n = 6) over 16 weeks, including 10 weeks of competitive racing. Both timeframe and sample size were larger than those used by Yamada and colleagues [18], although this sample size remained limited. ...
Article
To compare health outcomes between dogs fed meat and vegan diets, we surveyed 2,536 dog guardians who provided data and opinions about dogs fed conventional meat (1,370 = 54 %), raw meat (830 = 33 %) or vegan (336 = 13 %) diets for at least one year. We examined seven general indicators of illness: increased numbers of veterinary visits, medication use, progression onto a therapeutic diet after initial maintenance on a vegan or meat-based diet, reported veterinary assessment of being unwell, reported veterinary assessment and guardian opinion of increased illness severity, and number of health disorders per unwell dog. We also considered the prevalence of 22 specific health disorders, based on reported veterinary assessments. In each dietary group the proportions of dogs considered to have suffered from health disorders were: conventional meat – 49 %, raw meat – 43 % and vegan – 36 %. Probabilities of suffering from a disorder respectively appeared highest in dogs fed conventional meat for 11 disorders, raw meat for eight disorders, and vegan diets for three disorders. We conducted regression analyses to control for differences in medically-relevant canine demographic variables, including age, sex, neutering status, breed size and unusually high exercise levels. Dogs fed vegan diets had the best health outcomes. This trend was clear and consistent, with dogs fed vegan diets usually having substantial and statistically significant decreases in risks of these seven general indicators of illness. These ranged from 14.4 % to 51.3 % compared to dogs fed conventional meat-based diets. For six specific disorders, vegan diets were associated with statistically significant risk reductions of 50 %–61 % compared to dogs fed conventional meat. After pooling our results with related studies published to date, vegan dog food was consistently associated with lowered risks of multiple specific health disorders. No health disorder was consistently more prevalent in dogs fed vegan diets.
... Cats on an economical diet experienced severe anemia, primarily as a result of decreased hemoglobin synthesis. Cats fed an economical diet have signi cantly less red blood cells in their peripheral blood(Brown et al., 2009). ...
Preprint
Full-text available
Cats, belonging to the feline family, have been domesticated by humans for millennia, undergoing a gradual process divided into animal breeding and animal keeping phases. As obligate carnivores, cats require diets rich in protein, moderate in fat, and low in carbohydrates, with dietary needs evolving throughout their lifetimes. The aim of the current study is to compare the nutritional value and health consequences from eating economic diets with premium diets. Twelve cats (7 eating economic diets and 5 eating premium diets as control) were enrolled into the study. The animals went through clinical consultation and laboratory investigations. Based on the results from the current study, economic ready to eat food supplement impact the overall immune system and the defense mechanisms in the cats due to a marked reduction the number of white blood cells in the peripheral blood in particular the lymphocytes and the monocytes. Cats consuming economic diets experienced anemia due to an impaired hemoglobin production therefore impacted the rate of red blood cell production. Moreover, thrombocytopenia, conditions marked by reduced platelet counts, are linked to economic diets and nutrient deficiencies in cats in the study. In conclusion, proper nutrition is pivotal in preserving overall health and preventing hematological anomalies. Regular veterinary attention and a balanced diet are imperative for the management and prevention of such conditions in feline companions.
... Given these findings, it would be expected that dogs fed vegan diets may be at increased risk of nutritional deficiencies and clinical manifestations of irregularities in body composition, calcium, phosphorus, and vitamin D metabolism. Previous studies have demonstrated a lack of effect on physical examination, haematological and serum biochemical characteristics (21,22), and/or some additional serum nutrient evaluations (22). Impacts on digestibility, fecal microbiota, and glycemic and insulinemic responses have also recently been investigated in dogs (23)(24)(25). ...
Article
Full-text available
Dogs are considered omnivores based on their evolution, consuming diets that include animal tissue. Few feeding trials evaluating the nutritional suitability of exclusively plant-based (vegan) diets in dogs have been published, and the efficacy of vitamin D2 in maintaining canine serum vitamin D levels has not been clearly determined. A blinded dietary trial included 61 healthy desexed adult dogs: 31 fed an experimental extruded vegan diet (PLANT) and 30 fed a commercial extruded meat-based diet (MEAT) for three months. Dogs were screened via veterinary examination and routine laboratory analyses prior to enrolment in the study, at baseline and exit timepoints. Body composition was measured by dual-energy x-ray absorptiometry and blood was collected for vitamin D profiling. All dogs maintained health parameters, body weight and composition throughout the study. Dogs maintained on PLANT demonstrated a significant reduction in platelet count, creatinine, blood urea nitrogen and cholesterol, though values remained within normal reference ranges. Dogs fed PLANT also demonstrated a shift from vitamin D3 to vitamin D2 metabolites, though total vitamin D analogue levels were unchanged, with the exception of 24,25-dihydroxyvitamin D. Bone mineral content and density did not differ from baseline values. Health status was maintained in dogs fed PLANT and vitamin D2 appeared efficacious in maintaining serum total vitamin D concentrations and bone mineralization. Findings support the hypothesis that PLANT was comparable to MEAT for maintenance of healthy adult dogs for at least three months and identified areas where further research is warranted to elucidate the potential risks and benefits of exclusively plant-based vegan diets.
... The protein quality of plant-based ingredients can vary due to source, formulation, and processing conditions and methods (Carciofi et al., 2009). Indeed, several studies have noted good protein quality in plant-based diets with high nutrient digestibility (Bednar et al., 2000;Brown et al., 2009;Carciofi et al., 2009). Plant ingredients can also serve as a fiber source and contribute to hindgut fermentation. ...
Article
Full-text available
This study was conducted to determine the effect of animal protein inclusion rate and grain-free or grain-inclusive diets on macronutrient digestibility, fecal characteristics, metabolites, and microbiota in mixed-breed hounds and Beagles. Four experimental extruded kibble diets were made with varying amounts of animal protein and carbohydrates: 1) high animal protein, grain-inclusive (HA-GI), 2) low animal protein, grain-free (LA-GF), 3) low animal protein, grain-inclusive (LA-GI), and 4) high animal protein, grain-free (HA-GF). Thirty-two Beagles and 33 mixed-breed hounds were assigned to 1 of the 4 treatment groups in a completely randomized design that lasted 180 days. All diets were similar in chemical composition and well-digested by the animals. In general, for fecal metabolites, mixed-breed hounds had a greater concentration of total short-chain fatty acid (SCFA) and ammonia and lower indole concentration than Beagles (P < 0.05). In mixed-breed hounds, LA-GF had a greater (P < 0.05) total SCFA concentration than HA-GI and LA-GI; however, this was not observed in Beagles. There were greater concentrations of ammonia, phenol, and indole in HA-GI than in LA-GF (P < 0.05). Breed affected fecal primary bile acid concentration, as mixed-breed hounds had a greater concentration of cholic acid (CA) than Beagles (P < 0.05). Mixed-breed hounds fed LA-GF resulted in greater CA concentrations than HA-GI and LA-GI (P < 0.05). Dogs who consumed LA-GF had lower fecal secondary bile acid content than the other groups (P < 0.05). The distribution of the fecal microbiota community differed in LA-GF compared with the other groups, with lower α-diversity. However, dogs fed LA-GF had the largest difference in composition with greater Selenomonadaceae, Veillonellaceae, Lactobacillaceae, Streptococcus, Ligilactobacillus, Megamonas, Collinsella aerofaciens, and Bifidobacterium sp. than the other groups. A significant breed effect was noted on nutrient digestibility, fecal metabolites, and microbiota. A treatment effect was observed in LA-GF as it resulted in greater fecal SCFA, lower protein fermentative end-products, greater fecal primary bile acids, lower fecal secondary bile acid concentrations, and shifts in fecal microbiota.
... While nutrient deficiencies have been documented in PB dog foods (Semp, 2014;Zafalon et al., 2020), no adverse health outcomes attributable to diet have been reported. Indeed, even in dogs with exceptional exercise demands, a vegetarian diet was demonstrated to maintain the limited parameters measured within normal limits (Brown et al., 2009). No case studies have been published either demonstrating efficacy of plantbased diets in maintenance of canine health, nor identifying negative health outcomes associated with feeding a plant-based diet to dogs. ...
Article
Full-text available
Background Some dog owners elect to feed their dog a plant-based food either as part of or for their entire dietary intake. Being omnivores or facultative carnivores, a strictly plant-based diet is not the natural type of food dogs evolved to consume, leaving some question as to whether this feeding management strategy is safe and healthy for dogs. Objectives This study surveyed owner perceptions of health and wellbeing of dogs and compared between those fed meat-based and plant-based diets. Methods A web-based questionnaire was distributed to pet owners to collect data on dog characteristics, husbandry, health and wellbeing. Univariate comparisons between diet groups was made by chi square analyses or Kaplan-Meier tests as appropriate, with a significance cut-off value of 0.05. Multivariate models were negative binomial and logistic regression for count and categorical data, respectively. Results Owners feeding plant-based diets to their dog reported fewer health disorders, specifically with respect to ocular or gastrointestinal and hepatic disorders. Dog longevity was reported to be greater for dogs fed plant-based diets. Owners feeding plant-based diets to their dogs relied less on veterinary associates for nutrition information, versus dog owners feeding meat-based diets. Conclusions Dog owners feeding a plant-based diet did not perceive adverse health effects in their dogs. The results might suggest an association between feeding a plant-based diet and perceived health and longevity, however inherent bias and limitations associated with surveys of owner perception must be considered, and objective research is required to determine if plant-based diets truly affect canine health.
Article
Full-text available
Confounding influences of varying fat, protein, and carbohydrate (CHO) levels, training habits, and lifestyle patterns make the interpretation of specific influences of the diet on endurance performance unclear. In general, exhaustion during prolonged, hard endurance exercise is tied to low muscle glycogen stores. Athletes in heavy training are urged to consume 70% of calories as CHO to maximize body CHO stores. A deemphasis in animal products with an emphasis in high-CHO plant foods would facilitate athletes in conforming to nutritional recommendations. Some female athletes may increase their risk of iron deficiency and/or amenorrhea if a restrictive vegetarian diet is adopted. In general, the high-CHO nature of the vegetarian diet can help the endurance athlete in heavy training maximize body glycogen stores and thus the ability to perform. The balanced vegetarian diet provides the athlete with added reduction in coronary risk factors while meeting all known nutritional needs.
Chapter
In recent years, it has become apparent that our understanding of the nutritional effects of dietary fiber (DF) has been considerably hampered by the lack of an appropriate definition of DF and, consequently, a lack of adequate analytical methods. In the original version of our methodology, Theander and Åman proposed that DF could be defined as the sum of nonstarch (amylase-resistant) polysaccharides and Klason lignin and, in conjunction with this chemical definition, published a gas-chromatographic method for analysis and characterization of DF.
Article
The quality of vegetarian diets to meet nutritional needs and support peak performance among athletes continues to be questioned. Appropriately planned vegetarian diets can provide sufficient energy and an appropriate range of carbohydrate, fat and protein intakes to support performance and health. The acceptable macronutrient distribution ranges for carbohydrate, fat and protein of 45–65%, 20–35% and 10–35%, respectively, are appropriate for vegetarian and non-vegetarian athletes alike, especially those who perform endurance events. Vegetarian athletes can meet their protein needs from predominantly or exclusively plant-based sources when a variety of these foods are consumed daily and energy intake is adequate. Muscle creatine stores are lower in vegetarians than non-vegetarians. Creatine supplementation provides ergogenic responses in both vegetarian and non-vegetarian athletes, with limited data supporting greater ergogenic effects on lean body mass accretion and work performance for vegetarians. The potential adverse effect of a vegetarian diet on iron status is based on the bioavailability of iron from plant foods rather than the amount of total iron present in the diet. Vegetarian and non-vegetarian athletes alike must consume sufficient iron to prevent deficiency, which will adversely affect performance. Other nutrients of concern for vegetarian athletes include zinc, vitamin B12 (cyanocobalamin), vitamin D (cholecalciferol) and calcium. The main sources of these nutrients are animal products; however, they can be found in many food sources suitable for vegetarians, including fortified soy milk and whole grain cereals. Vegetarians have higher antioxidant status for vitamin C (ascorbic acid), vitamin E (tocopherol), and ß-carotene than omnivores, which might help reduce exercise-induced oxidative stress. Research is needed comparing antioxidant defences in vegetarian and non-vegetarian athletes.
Article
The effect of the quality of dietary protein on the initiation of temporary anemia during vigorous physical training (sports anemia) was studied in dogs and rats. In the dog experiment, one group of dogs was fed a crude animal protein (AP) diet and the other a crude vegetable protein (VP) diet. After 6 weeks on the diets in a sedentary state (rest period), all the dogs were forced to run every day for two weeks (exercise period). The rat experiment was carried out using purified nutrient mixtures. Casein (C) was used as AP and gluten (G) as VP. Feeding was done for two weeks in two series with two diet groups of rats. One series was 15% protein feeding (15% C and 15% G) groups and the other 24% protein feeding (24% C and 24% G) groups. In each group, one group remained in a sedentary state (rest group), and the other ran vigorously on a treadmill every day for one week (exercise group). In a sedentary state, there was a slight tendency for the hemoglobin content or erythrocyte count to be reduced, even when the values remained within the normal range, in dogs and rats fed VP. On the other hand, after vigorous running, significant anemia (reduction of hemoglobin) appeared in the VP diet dogs and in all exercise rat groups except the 24% C group. It was confirmed that the anemia was caused by a reduction of erythrocyte resistance to hemolysis, which was closely related to changes in the lipid composition of blood (serum and especially erythrocytes). The change in lipid profile revealed by the experiments was a reduction of free cholesterol in blood associated with an increase of lysolecithin in dogs during the exercise period and in the rat exercise groups. It was suggested that repeated physical exercise increased the activity of LCAT (lecithin-cholesterol-acyltransferase) in the liver, spleen, etc., resulting in the above changes in lipid patterns in the blood. In dogs of AP and rats of 24% C, however, those changes in lipid pattern caused by exercise and sports anemia did not appear significantly. The different effects of the AP diet seemed to be due to the antagonistic effects of lysine, which was present in sufficient amounts in the diet. Thus the theoretical basis for our recommendation of a high amount of AP in the diet to prevent sports anemia was clarified by the present experiments.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 400 WORDS)
Article
Article
From the foregoing discussion of the nutritional requirements and some of the metabolic anomalies of the cat, it is clear that the cat is adapted to eating a carnivorous diet. It may, however, have less capability than omnivores and herbivores to adapt to wide ranges in dietary composition. For example, the lack of ability to synthesize sufficient vitamin A from carotene, ornithine from glutamic acid, arachidonate from linoleate, and taurine from cysteine results from a complete deletion or severe limitation of the enzyme or pathway that makes each nutrient. Other nutrient requirements, such as the absolute requirement for niacin and the high protein requirement, appear to result from the high activity of one or more enzymes and the fact that these enzymes are not adaptive in the cat. For example, the cat cannot decrease picolinic carboxylase in order to force tryptophan toward the niacin-synthetic pathway (244) nor can it decrease the urea cycle enzymes when dietary protein is decreased in the diet in order to conserve nitrogen (209). Indeed, the cat appears to have less capability to adapt to most changes in dietary composition because it cannot change the quantities of enzymes involved in the metabolic pathways (209). This evolutionary development has resulted in more stringent nutritional requirements for cats than for omnivores such as the rat, dog, and man. What little evidence exists for other carnivore species leads us to suggest that this pattern may well be common among other strict carnivores. The metabolic differences between the cat and omnivores provide the researcher with a useful animal model for studying the biochemical basis of some nutrient requirements. For example, because there is no significant conversion of linoleate to arachidonate in cat liver (101, 150, 231), the physiological functions of linoleate can be determined independent of it having a role as a precursor of arachidonate (150). This has not been possible with other species. It is anticipated that further studies of the nutrition of the cat will increase our understanding of metabolic adaptation and nutrient functions.
Article
Red blood cell (RBC) susceptibility to oxidative and osmotic stress in vitro was investigated in cells from trained and untrained men before and after submaximal exercise. Whilst no significant change in peroxidative haemolysis occurred immediately after 1 h of cycling at 60% of maximal aerobic capacity (VO2max), a 20% increase was found 6h later in both groups (P < 0.05). The RBC osmotic fragility decreased by 15% immediately after exercise (P < 0.001) and this was maintained for 6h (P < 0.001). There was an associated decrease in mean cell volume (P < 0.05). Training decreased RBC susceptibility to peroxidative haemolysis (P < 0.025) but it did not influence any other parameter. These exercise-induced changes were smaller in magnitude but qualitatively similar to those found in haemopathological states involving haem-iron incorporation into membrane lipids and the short-circuiting of antioxidant protection. To explore this similarity, a more strenuous and mechanically stressful exercise test was used. Running at 75% VO2max for 45 min reduced the induction time of O2 uptake (peroxidation), consistent with reduced antioxidation capacity, and increased the maximal rate of O2 uptake in RBC challenged with cumene hydroperoxide (P < 0.001). The proportion of high-density RBC increased by 10% immediately after running (P < 0.001) but no change in membrane-incorporated haem-iron occurred. In contrast, treatment of RBC with oxidants (20-50 mumol.l-1) in vitro increased cell density and membrane incorporation of haem-iron substantially. These results showed that single episodes of submaximal exercise caused significant changes in RBC susceptibility to oxidative and osmotic stress. Such responses may account for the increase in RBC turnover found in athletes undertaking strenuous endurance training.
Article
Endurance training can lead to what has been termed ‘sports anaemia’. Although under normal conditions, red blood cells (RBCs) have a lifespan of about 120 days, the rate of aging may increase during intensive training. However, RBC deficiency is rare in athletes, and sports anaemia is probably due to an expanded plasma volume. Cycling, running and swimming have been shown to cause RBC damage. While most investigators measure indices of haemolysis (for example, plasma haemoglobin or haptoglobin), RBC removal is normally an extravascular process that does not involve haemolysis. Attention is now turning to cellular indices (such as antioxidant depletion, or protein or lipid damage) that may be more indicative of exercise-induced damage. RBCs are vulnerable to oxidative damage because of their continuous exposure to oxygen and their high concentrations of polyunsaturated fatty acids and haem iron. As oxidative stress may be proportional to oxygen uptake, it is not surprising that antioxidants in muscle, liver and RBCs can be depleted during exercise. Oxidative damage to RBCs can also perturb ionic homeostasis and facilitate cellular dehydration. These changes impair RBC deformability which can, in turn, impede the passage of RBCs through the microcirculation. This may lead to hypoxia in working muscle during single episodes of exercise and possibly an increased rate of RBC destruction with long term exercise. Providing RBC destruction does not exceed the rate of RBC production, no detrimental effect to athletic performance should occur. An increased rate of RBC turnover may be advantageous because young cells are more efficient in transporting oxygen. Because most techniques examine the RBC population as a whole, more sophisticated methods which analyse cells individually are required to determine the mechanisms involved in exercise-induced damage of RBCs.