ArticlePDF Available

Change-Readiness of the Blind: A Hospital Based Study in a Coastal Town of South India

Authors:

Abstract and Figures

Blindness is a devastating condition with psychosocial and economic effects. The shortcomings result in a burden to the blind person, the family and society. Rehabilitation of the blind can transform their lives. The aim of this study was to assess the "change-readiness" of the blind to undergo a "change-management". The study was a semi-structured pre-tested questionnaire-based study of 50 blind subjects in a medical college hospital. The blind participants were assessed for depression using the Beck Depression Inventory II, for the perceived effect of blindness on family, social life and occupation. The participants were counseled to undergo psychiatric management, vocational training, use blind aids and learn Braille. The willingness of the participants with reasons was assessed using a verbal analogue scale. Pearson Chi-square test, ANOVA and the t-test were used for statistical analysis. Over two-thirds of the subjects were depressed. Family life, social life and occupation were perceived to be affected by 44%, 66% and 74%, respectively. Change-readiness scores were low for low vision and blind aids, vocational training, psychiatric management, change of job and learning Braille. The low score was due to the associated taboo, dependence, lack of skills, embarrassment, etc., The most valuable feature was the family cohesiveness. The results suggest that there is a need to modify health policy to include blind rehabilitation, to improve visibility of blind rehabilitation centers, to include family members and co-professionals while managing the blind so that we treat the "blind person" and not a "pair of blind eyes".
Content may be subject to copyright.
158 Middle East African Journal of Ophthalmology, Volume 21, Number 2, April - June 2014
Departments of Ophthalmology, and 1Ophthalmology, Yenepoya Medical College, Yenepoya University, Mangalore, Karnataka, India
Corresponding Author: Dr. Uma D. Kulkarni, Lakshmi Keshava, 4th Cross, Shivabagh, Mangalore ‑ 575 002, Karnataka, India.
E‑mail: umasripada@gmail.com, umakulkarni@yenepoya.edu.in
INTRODUCTION
Blindness is a devastating condition and its magnitude
in India is vast (15 million).1 The consequences of
blindness range from depression,2‑4 loss of jobs,5 jeopardized
relationships6,7 to meager economic conditions.8 Faced
by challenges, people with blindness become a burden to
themselves, the family and society.
At present, the National Program for Control of Blindness (NPCB)
policies of the government of India9 focus on prevention and
cure of blindness, but not rehabilitation. It is reported that
without adequate rehabilitation measures, many blind persons
resort to begging.8 The same is true in India, but there is no
literature quoting statistics. On the other hand, there are blind
persons who have been “achievers” in the fields of art, music,
sports, politics, etc., Appropriate rehabilitation can transform
a blind person into a “blind achiever.”
The authors adopt the term “change‑management”10 for the
comprehensive blind rehabilitation strategy, which includes
solutions to psychiatric, vocational, mobility and visual
problems faced by the blind. The aim of the study was to
assess the willingness or “change‑readiness” of the blind to
“change‑management” strategy.
ABSTRACT
Purpose: Blindness is a devastating condition with psychosocial and economic effects. The
shortcomings result in a burden to the blind person, the family and society. Rehabilitation of
the blind can transform their lives. The aim of this study was to assess the “change‑readiness”
of the blind to undergo a “change‑management.”
Materials and Methods: The study was a semi‑structured pre‑tested questionnaire‑based study
of 50 blind subjects in a medical college hospital. The blind participants were assessed for
depression using the Beck Depression Inventory II, for the perceived effect of blindness on
family, social life and occupation. The participants were counseled to undergo psychiatric
management, vocational training, use blind aids and learn Braille. The willingness of the
participants with reasons was assessed using a verbal analogue scale. Pearson Chi‑square
test, ANOVA and the
t
‑test were used for statistical analysis.
Results: Over two‑thirds of the subjects were depressed. Family life, social life and occupation
were perceived to be affected by 44%, 66% and 74%, respectively. Change‑readiness scores
were low for low vision and blind aids, vocational training, psychiatric management, change
of job and learning Braille. The low score was due to the associated taboo, dependence, lack
of skills, embarrassment, etc., The most valuable feature was the family cohesiveness.
Conclusion: The results suggest that there is a need to modify health policy to include blind
rehabilitation, to improve visibility of blind rehabilitation centers, to include family members
and co‑professionals while managing the blind so that we treat the “blind person” and not a
“pair of blind eyes.”
Key words: Blindness, Change‑Management, Change‑Readiness, Depression, Rehabilitation
Change‑Readiness of the Blind: A Hospital Based
Study in a Coastal Town of South India
Ramya Shetty, Uma D. Kulkarni1
Original Article
Access this article online
Website:
www.meajo.org
DOI:
10.4103/0974-9233.129768
Quick Response Code:
[Downloaded free from http://www.meajo.org on Thursday, May 26, 2016, IP: 14.139.155.194]
Shetty and Kulkarni: Are we Turning a Blind Eye Toward the Blind?
Middle East African Journal of Ophthalmology, Volume 21, Number 2, April - June 2014 159
The objectives were to assess:
• Depressionandthe “perceived” effect of blindness on
day‑to‑day aspects of life
• “Change‑readiness”tothe“change‑management”protocol
encompassing psychiatric management, vocational and
blind rehabilitation measures
• Factorsaffecting“change‑readiness”.
MATERIALS AND METHODS
The study was a cross‑sectional semi‑structured pre‑tested
questionnaire‑based study of the blind subjects conducted in
the Yenepoya Medical College Hospital, Mangalore from May
to July, 2011. A convenience sample of 50 adult participants
with blindness as defined by Indian modification of World
Health Organization (WHO) classification11 was included.
The blind subjects were selected by purposive sampling from
the patients attending the out‑patient department. Cases of
blindness over 18 years with vision less than 3/60 in the better
eye were included. Unilateral blindness, visual impairment,11
curable blindness (including cataract blindness) and children
with blindness were excluded.
Methodology
The consenting blind participants were enrolled for the study
after a detailed clinical history and ophthalmic evaluation
including visual acuity assessment, anterior and posterior
segment evaluation using slit‑lamp accessories and ultrasound
imaging when required to diagnose blindness and its cause.
• Assessmentoftheeffectofblindness:
a. Assessment of depression was performed with the
BeckDepressionInventoryII(BDI‑II)12 administered
verbally by the investigator. The chosen response
wasmarked and scored for depression. Depression
was classified as no/minimal (0‑13), mild (14‑19),
moderate (20‑28) and severe (29‑63)
b. The “perceived” effect of blindness on the professional
and socio‑economic aspects was assessed using a
verbally administered semi‑structured questionnaire
c. Functional vision was assessed by the ability of the blind
to recognize faces and objects and move about avoiding
obstacles. Such participants were considered suitable for
the optical low vision aid like magnifiers. Participants
without physical disability like hemiparesis, amputated
diabetic limbs were considered as suitable for blind aids
like the walking cane. Since the hospital caters primarily
to the rural and socio‑economically underprivileged
population, the choice of expensive computer aided low
vision devices is not routinely practical. Hence, the study
included “magnifiers” as a form of low vision device,
which could be used for day‑to‑day activities only.
• “Change‑management” strategy was suggested: The
participants were counseled to undergo/use:
a. Psycho‑pharmacotherapy and counseling
b. Vocational training and change of job
c. Blind aids like white cane and low vision devices such
as magnifiers.
• “Change‑readiness”wasassessedusingtheverbalanalogue
scale for the change‑management strategy suggested to
them:
a. The subjects were asked to imagine a scale with markings
0‑10, where “zero” indicated “Not at all willing
for change” and “10” indicated “completely willing
for change or already changing.” The respondents
were asked to quote a number from 0 to 10 which
correspond to their level of agreement for change.
This number was considered as the “change‑readiness
score” for that attribute.
b. The subjects were asked to enumerate reasons for
choosing that particular score for each attribute.
Statistical analysis
Analysis was performed using percentages and proportions.
Significance of differences in responses between different
comparable groups was performed using Pearson Chi‑square
test, ANOVA and the t‑test. P < 0.05 was considered to be
statistically significant.
Ethics
The study was conducted after obtaining clearance from and
in accordance with the regulations of the Institutional Ethics
Committee. An informed written consent was administered to
the subject after verbally discussing the same in the presence of
a bystander. The questionnaire was administered with empathy
and sensitivity for every blind participant.
RESULTS
The 50 blind participants included 29 males and
21 females (M: F 1.38:1). The mean age was 56.64 years
(range: 20‑103; peak: 7th‑8th decade). There was no gender or
age‑wise statistically significant difference in the proportion of
blind cases (Pearson Chi‑square = 0.080, P = 0.961). The
distribution is plotted in Figure 1.
Only 16% had completed higher education and 46% had
schooling up to class 10th; nearly, 38% were illiterate [Figure 2].
Blindness was statistically significantly greater in the lower
educational groups (Chi‑square = 7.149, P = 0.0280). About
54% were unemployed and one, a student. The proportion of
blindness in the various groups of employment was statistically
comparable (Chi‑square = 9.351, P = 0.096).
[Downloaded free from http://www.meajo.org on Thursday, May 26, 2016, IP: 14.139.155.194]
Shetty and Kulkarni: Are we Turning a Blind Eye Toward the Blind?
160 Middle East African Journal of Ophthalmology, Volume 21, Number 2, April - June 2014
The etiology of blindness included retinal pathology (38%),
glaucoma (20%), corneal opacity and optic atrophy
(14% each), post‑operative complications (12%) and congenital
anomalies (2%). Sixteen (32%) perceived their eyes to be
disfigured and 36% complained of ocular pain. The average
duration of blindness was 7.75 years with no statistically significant
difference between genders (Chi‑square = 0.643, P = 0.7251).
Most had simultaneous bilateral blindness, whereas
32% had previously experienced unilateral blindness for
2‑48 years (mean = 21.2 years).
The various aspects of life perceived to be affected by the
blind are presented in Figure 3. The majority felt that their
occupation (74%) and income (66%) were affected due
to blindness. This perception was statistically significantly
greater in males (Chi‑square = 6.515, P = 0.038). Family
relations were “perceived” to be affected by 44% with no
statistically significant gender differences (Chi‑square = 2.043,
P = 0.360). Social life was perceived to be affected in
66% with males perceiving it significantly more than
females (Chi‑square = 8.499, P = 0.014).
TheaverageBDIscorewas17.22(male:female16.51:18.19).
The majority had mild and moderate depression [Figure 4].
Proportion of depression was highest in 7th decade and
severity was greatest in the 4‑5th decades. These differences
were statistically comparable in different age groups and
gender (Chi‑square test: P =0.703; Chi‑square = 0.722,
P = 0.868). The severity of depression was not related to the
duration of blindness (Kruskal‑Wallis test = 3.907; P = 0.272).
The change‑readiness scores are shown in Figure 5. There was
no statistically significant gender difference in change‑readiness
for psychiatric counseling and pharmacotherapy. (Levene’s test
for equality variance, t = 0.401, P = 0.690 for psychiatric
counseling, t = 1.13, P = 0.264 for pharmacotherapy). Only
6% had already taken psychiatric counseling and none was
receiving pharmacotherapy. There was no statistically significant
difference in the change‑readiness scores in different severities
of depression (ANOVA; F = 0.815, P = 0.492).
The average change‑readiness score for “change of the job”
was statistically significantly greater in males (Levene’s test
for equality of variance t = 2.723; P = 0.009). There was
no significant gender difference in the scores for vocational
training (Levene’s test for equality of variance t = 2.001;
P = 0.051), for blind aids, learning Braille and for low
vision aids (Levene’s t‑test for equality of variance t = 1.867;


  



!
)HPDOHV
0DOHV
1XPEHURIEOLQG
$JHUDQJHLQ\HDUV
Figure 1: Age and gender distribution ophthalmologists, the society, the family of the blind and not solely on the blind

   
,OOLWHUDWH
OLWHUDWHSULPDU\VFKRRO
0LGGOHVFKRRO
+LJKVFKRRO
'LSORPD38&
*UDGXDWH3RVWJUDGXDWH
3URIHVVLRQDO+RQRXUV
)HPDOHV
0DOHV
1XPEHURIEOLQG
(GXFDWLRQOHYHO
Figure 2: Education of the blind subjects
[Downloaded free from http://www.meajo.org on Thursday, May 26, 2016, IP: 14.139.155.194]
Shetty and Kulkarni: Are we Turning a Blind Eye Toward the Blind?
Middle East African Journal of Ophthalmology, Volume 21, Number 2, April - June 2014 161
P = 0.068 for blind aids; t = 1.222; P = 0.261 for learning
Braille: t = 0.272; P = 0.790 for low vision aids). Only 48%
were suitable for using magnifiers for day‑to‑day activities.
Only 6% had visited a low vision center and used a low vision
aid, which included spectacle magnifiers by two and hand held
magnifier by one.
A considerable proportion of the blind subjects showed an
absolute lack of change‑readiness for undergoing psychiatric,
vocational and blind rehabilitation [Figure 6]. The reasons
quoted for high and low score are listed in Table 1.
DISCUSSION
Blindness is a major public health problem influencing various aspects
of the life of the blind. Rehabilitation of the blind does not feature in
major health policies in India. Currently, there is no published data
on the proportion of the blind undergoing rehabilitation or regarding
their attitude to “change” in order to improve their quality‑of‑life.
Our study assessed the impact of blindness and the change‑readiness
of the blind to undergo a comprehensive strategy comprising
psychiatric management, blind‑rehabilitation and vocational training,
which the authors termed “change‑management.”







    
2FFXSDWLRQ
,QFRPH
)DPLO\UHODWLRQV
6RFLDOOLIH
)HPDOHV
0DOHV
1XPEHURIEOLQG
$VSHFWVRIOLIH
SHUFHLYHGDVDIIHFWHG
Figure 3: Aspects of life “perceived” as affected



0LOGGHSUHVVLRQ
0RGHUDWHGHSUHVVLRQ
6HYHUHGHSUHVVLRQ )HPDOHV
0DOHV
1XPEHURIEOLQG
6HFXULW\RI
GHSUHVVLRQ
Figure 4: Severity of depression












3V\FKLDWULFFRXQVHOOLQJ
3V\FKLDWULFSKDUPDFRWKHUDS\
&KDQJHRIMRE
9RFDWLRQDOWUDLQLQJ
%OLQGUHKDELOLWDWLRQ
%UDLOOH
/RZYLVLRQDLG
0DOHV
)HPDOHV
&KDQJH5HDGLQHVVVFRUHVRQDVFDOHRIWHQ
Figure 5: Change‑readiness scores for change‑management
[Downloaded free from http://www.meajo.org on Thursday, May 26, 2016, IP: 14.139.155.194]
Shetty and Kulkarni: Are we Turning a Blind Eye Toward the Blind?
162 Middle East African Journal of Ophthalmology, Volume 21, Number 2, April - June 2014
may be attributed to for such variation. This may also reflect the
social, cultural and religious barriers for the females for seeking
hospital services.
The mean age in the current study was less than previous
studies15,16 and this is likely due to the exclusion of cataract,
the most common cause of blindness in the aged. The higher
proportion of blindness was among the groups with lower
educational and was consistent with the WHO data.9 The causes
of blindness were identical to the NPCB9 data when cataract
was excluded.
Impact of blindness
Depressionwas present in 68% of subjects inour study,
comparable to other studies which have reported between
26.4% and 90%.2‑4,8,17TheaverageBDIscorewashigherthanin
other studies2 indicating that depression was more severe. The
BDIscoreswereidenticalinbothgendersasalsoobservedina
study by Hayman.18Depressionwasmorecommonintheolder
individuals, although its severity was greater in the younger age
groups. Visual impairment in working adults is known to lower
levels of mental health.19 The presence and severity of depression
did not correlate with the duration of blindness. “Blindness
reaction” has been likened to “grief,” in which patients “mourn”
the loss of a sighted self.20 An initial denial followed by gradual
acceptance may account for depression in short duration of
blindness whereas the feeling of loss, isolation, dependence,
loneliness and incompetence may account for depression in
long‑term blindness. In our study, factors such as financial stress,
loss of job, strained social and family life may have aggravated
depression. In the current study, approximately a third of the
participants perceived their eyes as “deformed” and had ocular
pain. These factors may have further intensified the depression.
Despitethehighproportionofdepression,thechange‑readiness
scores were low and only one‑third expressed change‑readiness






      
3V\FKLDWULFFRXQVHOOLQJ
3V\FKLDWULFSKDUPDFRWKHUDS\
&KDQJHRIMRE
9RFDWLRQDOWUDLQLQJ
%OLQGDLGV
%UDLOOH
]HUR
7HQ
1XPEHURIEOLQG
Figure 6: 0 and 10 “change‑readiness” scores
Table 1: Reasons quoted for low and high “change‑readiness”
scores
Reasons for low change‑
readiness
Reasons for high change‑
readiness
For psychiatric management
Need to depend for
consultation
Want to get relieved of depression
Need for assistance To improve their relationship with
family members
Need for vehicle To regain confidence
Not aware of depressive
symptoms
To live a better life
Taboo associated Pharmacotherapy is convenient
than counseling
Financial burden
Poor accessibility
Not interested
Poor acceptability
For change of job and vocational
training
Not acceptable To improve financial condition of
family
Presence of tremors due to
old age
To earn respectfully
Don’t have artistic skill To keep occupied
Learning is difficult in old age To overcome the problems posed by
the present job due to poor vision
Not interested in art To become independent financially
For blind aids, low vision aids
and learning Braille
Feel embarrassed using white
cane
Low vision gave hopes of regaining
lost vision
Restricted indoors and hence
don’t need white cane
White cane will enable them to walk
and cross roads without assistance
Braille is new and may be
difficult to learn
White cane will ensure safety while
walking at night and when there is
no assistance
Learning is difficult in old age White cane will protect from street
dogs
Braille learning may be
sophisticated and expensive
Males comprised a greater proportion of the blind in our study
in contrast to other data.13,14 The hospital‑based study design
[Downloaded free from http://www.meajo.org on Thursday, May 26, 2016, IP: 14.139.155.194]
Shetty and Kulkarni: Are we Turning a Blind Eye Toward the Blind?
Middle East African Journal of Ophthalmology, Volume 21, Number 2, April - June 2014 163
for psychiatric management. Reasons quoted for low awareness
suggested poor motivation, dependence on family and the taboo
associated with psychiatric problems.
Vision is a major determinant of virtually any profession.
Traditionally, males are the bread earners for the family;
commensurate occupation was perceived to be affected
significantly greater in males. Most of the blind were unemployed,
the findings being similar to a report which stated that 25%
retired or changed to part‑time jobs after the onset of visual
impairment.5 A Nigerian report states that lack of education and
inadequate rehabilitation services turned the blind into street
beggars.8 None of our study participants had resorted to begging
probably due to the support offered by the family, whereas
beggary is indeed a form of profession adopted by many beggars
in India, as seen in temples, railways and public areas, although
no statistical data is available. Factors forcing the blind to resort
to beggary may have a contribution from the socio‑economic
status and the rehabilitation measures provided to them.
Despitethe finding that more than halfof the blind were
unemployed, change‑readiness for vocational rehabilitation
and change of the job was low. Males were more change‑ready
for the same likely due to the increasing financial constraints.
Furthermore, learning handicrafts and art needs some level of
motor skills and patience, which the blind participants perceived
to be lacking in themselves.
Blindness has a negative impact on personal relationships.
Separation from a committed relationship was seen in 50% of
visually impaired.6 In our study, 22% felt that family relations
were strained although none was separated from a committed
relationship. This possibly reflects a strong tendency for family
bonding. However, stress in the family members cannot be ruled
out as reported in a study that 35.4% of caregivers of the blind
were identified to be at risk for depression.7
Two‑thirds indicated that social life was affected. The stigma and
limitations associated with blindness may result in social neglect
of the blind. This is identical to the findings from other studies
that 53% of the visually impaired participants experienced
restrictions in socializing21 and 39.5% stopped participating in
leisure activities.5
Willingness for low vision aids was better than for other
rehabilitation measures. This is understandable because low
vision aid is the only rehabilitation measure, which offers a
chance of regaining vision. Horowitz et al.22 proposed that
optical devices optimize residual vision and thus allow for
greater continuity in the way tasks are accomplished, whereas
blind aids involve learning new methods to compensate for the
lost functions and thus is not as desirable either functionally
or psychologically. Similarly, in our study, willingness to use
blind aids such as a white cane was low and met with barriers
including embarrassment and stigma. Willingness to learn Braille
was the least as many were unaware of Braille and they found
it sophisticated and difficult.
The awareness about blind rehabilitation in Canada was 71%
and 81% had participated in low vision rehabilitation.23 In the
United States, the proportion of employment among the blind
is as high as 90% in Braille literates and is as low as 33% in the
Braille illiterate.24 The inclination of the blind for rehabilitation
in this study is poor as is expected in a developing country
where rehabilitation centers are few, education level low and
socio‑cultural barriers rampant despite the high magnitude of
blindness.
In stark contrast to the Nigerian study,8 where many blind
ended up as street beggars, there have been “blind achievers”
in various fields including sports.25 The blind population should
follow examples of Indian blind achievers like blind chess
players trained by the All India chess federation for the blind,26
blind Indian musicians like Ravindra Jain and the black concert
group, social workers and many others. The success of the blind
achievers indicates that an overall development of the blind is
possible although, only through a planned strategy.
The reasons quoted for high change‑readiness scores indicated
good motivation and enthusiasm to improve their living condition
and the reasons for poor change‑readiness indicate barriers to
effective blind rehabilitation. These factors can be used as a
“guide” in planning and implementing blind rehabilitation
programs. The most valuable factor noted in our study was
the strong family support and bonding. This attribute should
act as a scaffold on which the blind persons can take steps for
rehabilitation.
CONCLUSION
Blindness not only affects visual perception, but is also likely to
cause depression, affect family and social life, occupation and
mobility. The NPCB in India should focus on empowering the
blind by extending blind rehabilitation services to encompass all
the blind in India. Centers offering blind rehabilitation facilities
need increased visibility, funding and promotion so that their
facilities may be extended to all the individuals with irreversible
blindness. There is a need to identify residual functional vision in
ever y blind person and help transform this into their strength using
appropriate low vision devices. Hospitals and ophthalmologists
need to treat the “blind person” and not the “blind eye”
through a multidisciplinary approach. Coordination with other
centers namely, low vision centers, vocational training centers,
motility centers, psychiatry department, psychology department,
medico‑social workers, etc., should become a routine practice in
the management of the blind. A general awareness of blindness,
[Downloaded free from http://www.meajo.org on Thursday, May 26, 2016, IP: 14.139.155.194]
Shetty and Kulkarni: Are we Turning a Blind Eye Toward the Blind?
164 Middle East African Journal of Ophthalmology, Volume 21, Number 2, April - June 2014
its impact on the person, family and society and the need for
rehabilitation should be imparted in the general population.
Social issues such as taboos should be addressed. The proactive
involvement of the family members in the rehabilitation of the
blind should be emphasized and internalized so that it becomes
effortless to make a blind individual an independent motivated
achiever. Change‑management is what the blind needs and
change‑readiness is poor. Are we turning a blind eye toward the
blind? The onus of responsibility rests on the shoulders of the
health policy makers, rehabilitation centers, hospitals.
ACKNOWLEDGMENTS
The authors acknowledge the support of ICMR STS program for the
encouragement and financial support and also thank to Ms. Neevan,
Yenepoya University for helping with the statistical analysis.
REFERENCES
1. World Health Organization. Available from: http://www.who.
int/blindness/en/index.html. [Last accessed on 2011 Sep 10].
2. Koenes SG, Karshmer JF. Depression: A comparison study
between blind and sighted adolescents. Issues Ment Health
Nurs 2000;21:269‑79.
3. Banerjee A, Kumar S, Kulhara P, Gupta A. Prevalence
of depression and its effect on disability in patients with
age‑related macular degeneration. Indian J Ophthalmol
2008;56:469‑74.
4. Fitzgerald RG. Reactions to blindness. An exploratory study
of adults with recent loss of sight. Arch Gen Psychiatry
1970;22:370‑9.
5. Rasmussen ML. The eye amputated‑consequences of eye
amputation with emphasis on clinical aspects, phantom eye
syndrome and quality of life. Acta Ophthalmol 2010;88 Thesis
2:1‑26.
6. Bernbaum M, Albert SG, Duckro PN, Merkel W. Personal
and family stress in individuals with diabetes and vision loss.
J Clin Psychol 1993;49:670‑7.
7. Bambara JK, Owsley C, Wadley V, Martin R, Porter C,
Dreer LE. Family caregiver social problem‑solving abilities
and adjustment to caring for a relative with vision loss. Invest
Ophthalmol Vis Sci 2009;50:1585‑92.
8. Ademola‑Popoola DS, Tunde‑Ayinmode MF, Akande TM.
Psychosocial characteristics of totally blind people in a Nigerian
city. Middle East Afr J Ophthalmol 2010;17:335‑42.
9. National Programme for Control of Blindness. Ministry of Health
and Family Welgare, India. Available from: http://npcb.nic.
in/. [Last accessed on 2013 Jul 9].
10. KLR‑Change‑management. Available from: http://www.klr.com/
articles/Articles_ChangeManagement _change_readiness_
assessement.pdf. [Last accessed on 2013 Jul 9].
11. Sihota R, Tandon R. Parsons’ Diseases of the Eye. 19th ed.
New Delhi: Elsevier Publications; 2003.
12. Richter P, Werner J, Heerlein A, Kraus A, Sauer H. On the validity
of the beck depression inventory. A review. Psychopathology
1998;31:160‑8.
13. Available from: http://whqlibdoc.who.int/gender/2002/a85574.
pdf. [Last accessed on 2013 Jul 9].
14. Abou‑Gareeb I, Lewallen S, Bassett K, Courtright P. Gender and
blindness: A meta‑analysis of population‑based prevalence
surveys. Ophthalmic Epidemiol 2001;8:39‑56.
15. Available from: http://updateox.com/india/
state‑wise‑sex‑ratio‑in‑india‑in‑2011‑compared‑with‑
2001‑census/. [Last accessed on 2013 Jul 9].
16. Dineen B, Foster A, Faal H. A proposed rapid methodology
to assess the prevalence and causes of blindness and visual
impairment. Ophthalmic Epidemiol 2006;13:31‑4.
17. Rees G, Tee HW, Marella M, Fenwick E, Dirani M, Lamoureux EL.
Vision‑specific distress and depressive symptoms in people with
vision impairment. Invest Ophthalmol Vis Sci 2010;51:2891‑6.
18. Hayman KJ, Kerse NM, La Grow SJ, Wouldes T, Robertson MC,
Campbell AJ. Depression in older people: Visual impairment
and subjective ratings of health. Optom Vis Sci 2007;84:1024‑30.
19. Nyman SR, Gosney MA, Victor CR. Psychosocial impact of
visual impairment in working‑age adults. Br J Ophthalmol
2010;94:1427‑31.
20. Shulz PJ. Reaction to the loss of sight. In: Pearlman J, Adams G,
Sloan S, editors. Psychiatric Problems in Ophthalmology.
Springfield, IL: Charles C Thomas; 1977. p. 60‑73.
21. Alma MA, van der Mei SF, Melis‑Dankers BJ, van Tilburg TG,
Groothoff JW, Suurmeijer TP. Participation of the elderly after
vision loss. Disabil Rehabil 2011;33:63‑72.
22. Horowitz A, Brennan M, Reinhardt JP, Macmillan T. The impact
of assistive device use on disability and depression among
older adults with age‑related vision impairments. J Gerontol
B Psychol Sci Soc Sci 2006;61:S274‑80.
23. Mwilambwe A, Wittich W, Freeman EE. Disparities in awareness
and use of low‑vision rehabilitation. Can J Ophthalmol
2009;44:686‑91.
24. Available from: http://www.blindmassageintl.com/
news/3/2010‑8‑17/Braille‑literacy‑statistics.html. [Last accessed
on 2011 Sep 10].
25. Available from: http://www.disabled‑world.com/artman/
publish/famous‑blind.shtml. [Last accessed on 2011 Sep 10].
26. Available from: http://www.aicfb.in/index.asp. [Last accessed
on 2013 Jul 04].
Cite this article as: Shetty R, Kulkarni UD. Change-readiness of the blind:
A hospital based study in a coastal town of South India. Middle East Afr J
Ophthalmol 2014;21:158-64.
Source of Support: ICMR STS program 2011 in the form of stipend to the
student for conducting the research , Conict of Interest: None declared.
[Downloaded free from http://www.meajo.org on Thursday, May 26, 2016, IP: 14.139.155.194]
... Blindness, with attendant losses of occupation and mobility, has profound consequences for the victim, family, and society [1]. According to the World Health Organization (WHO) estimates, there are 76 million people in the world who are blind by 2020 [1,2]. ...
... Blindness, with attendant losses of occupation and mobility, has profound consequences for the victim, family, and society [1]. According to the World Health Organization (WHO) estimates, there are 76 million people in the world who are blind by 2020 [1,2]. In Sudan, population-based data in relation to the prevalence of blindness in Sudan are rather deficient. ...
Article
Full-text available
Background Blindness has profound consequences for the victim, family, and society. The impact of vision loss on daily life activities could lead to psychological stress. Early treatment of depression may reduce the added disability that is associated with vision loss. This study aimed to assess the extent and associated factors with depression among the Sudanese blind people in Khartoum, Sudan. A cross-section facility-based study was conducted, in which depression among the participants was assessed using the Beck Depression Inventory Scale. A chi-square test was implemented to determine the relationship between categorical variables and the significance level for all analyses was set at p < 0.05. Results A total of 185 participants were included in the study. Out of them, 84.3% were male and near half of the participants (42.2%) were born blind. The prevalence of depression among the participants was 11.4%. There were significantly higher rates of depression in those who were illiterate ( χ 2 = 6.233, p = 0.044) and in those whose loss of vision was due to accidents or traumatic causes and loss of vision due to accidents or traumatic causes ( χ 2 = 12.840, p = 0.002). There was significantly lower rate of depression in those who were born with blindness compared to others ( χ 2 = 10.504, p = 0.005). Conclusions People who were born blind have a lower rate of depression and people who lost their sight due to trauma have a higher rate of depression, and therefore, requiring more psychiatric support. Despite the relatively low percentage of depression, establishing programs for early identification and combating depression among the blind population in our setting is highly recommended.
... There are studies from Low income countries on causes of blindness in schools for blind people and the importance of rehabilitating blind children, but few on paid employment for these students after leaving school [18]. Also in low income countries rehabilitation services may not be available, it may not be accessible or not desirable [19,20]. Rehabilitation should include education, training in blindness skills and vocational training. ...
... The sample size was calculated from a sampling frame of 206 registered blind of Nigeria Association of blind people -Ogun State branch using a prevalence of 37% employment rate for blind people (Bell & Mino, and Nyman), and Leslie-Kish method of calculating sample size for population less than 10,000 [2,3,20,22]. N 1 =Z 2 P(1-P)/(d) 2 where N 1 is sample size for population more than 10000. ...
Article
Background: Rehabilitation of blind people is one of the components of Vision 2020. Despite advancement in technology and low vision rehabilitation, it is still difficult for blind people to gain paid employment especially in low income countries. This study was embarked upon to determine employment status of the rehabilitated blind in Ogun State and factors that enhance paid employment. Methodology: A cross sectional study of sixty six blind adults was recruited from Nigerian Society of blind people Ogun State branch from May 2017-November 2017. An interviewer-administered questionnaire was used to collect data on personal data, academic qualifications, mode of rehabilitation, employment status, and Braille literacy. One hundred and one potential employers from six sectors of the economy were also recruited into the study to assess their willingness to employ blind persons and the qualifications required. Result: The age range of respondents in this study was 17-68 years, mean 38.51±11.97 years. Forty two (63.66%) were males, 25(37.9%) had tertiary education, 35(53%) were Braille literate and 18(27.2%) had paid employment 16 of whom were by the Government. Education was significantly associated with paid employment (P=0.008). Amongst prospective employers 55(54.5%) would employ a blind person but did not know in what capacity. Conclusion: The rate of paid employment for blind subjects is low. Tertiary education as a component of rehabilitation is important for blind people to get paid employment. Employers are ignorant of capabilities of blind subjects and forum of interactions between the two should be encouraged
... c) Surgical management: Convincing a patient for surgical management for conditions like cataract, glaucoma and retinal disorders is mostly straightforward for a motivated and educated patient. It may pose difficulties in some patients, who are either not motivated [9] or in whom the visual prognosis has been predicted to be poor. However, ocular surgery is well known and generally acceptable to patients. ...
... Many patients "give up" due to failure of improvement in vision by other modalities of management tried at different centres and by different ophthalmologists, over the past several years. "Loss of hope of gaining back vision" is known to cause "depression" [9] and suicidal tendencies among patients with blindness. Several socio-economic factors like, dependence on others, rejection by family and financial burden add to the complexity. ...
Article
Full-text available
Aim: Explore the challenges faced by an ophthalmologist during evaluation and counselling of a patient with low vision. Material and methods: After establishment of the new LVA centre, the challenges faced at various steps in the establishment and running of the LV centre are described under the heading 1) Establishing the LV centre 2) Introducing LVA to the patients 3) Motivating patients with LV for LVA 4) Evaluation using other ancillary tests 5) Dealing with 'no improvement in vision' 6) C ounseling Observation and discussion: Even though setting up of a low vision centre was not difficult, the patients' awareness about such services was poor due to the 'weird appearance' and 'closer working distance' of these LVAs. Patients had more preference for spectacles, medical or surgical management for their low vision rather than LVAs. Most patients were poorly motivated, and manifested a ' given up' attitude probably as a result of psychological impact of low vision. Performing ancillary visual tests was found to be more time consuming and added no value to the result. It was also difficult to explain to some patients why they did not improve with low vision aids which may worsen their already depressed state of mind. The authors felt the need for a trained counsellor for motivation and counselling of patients with low vision, more so in cases where there was futility of treatment and perceived lack of family support. Conclusion: Active and sustained efforts are required in motivating the LV patients for LVA. They should be holistically managed with contributions from counsellor, psychiatrist or psychologists with equal contribution from the patient and the care takers.
... The lower productivity due to low vision leads to poorer financial gains. Accordingto a study in this geographical area two-thirds of the patients with blindness were diagnosed to have depression and three-fourths of them perceived a negative impact of blindness on their occupation [13]. The resulting lower socioeconomic status leads to poor health care access and poor rehabilitation measures. ...
Article
Full-text available
Introduction: Low vision is defined as visual impairment despite treatment, surgery, or standard refractive correction, but with the potential to use the residual vision. The aim of the study was to explore the clinical profile of patients requiring Low Vision Aids (LVA) and assess the effectiveness, of LVA among patients with low vision. Material and Methods: Fifty patients fulfilling the criteria of low vision were recruited after obtaining informed written consent and detailed ocular evaluation was done to detect the cause of low vision. A trial of LVAs was done for near using hand-held magnifiers (+6D, +14D, +20D), stand magnifiers (+8D, +14D, +20D) and spectacle magnifiers (+6D, +10D, +14D, +20D) and visual improvement was noted. Similarly, LVAs were tried for distance using telescope 2.5X and clip-on telescope 3X. Results: The majority of the participants (72%) belonged to the upper lower class. The most common causes of low vision were heritable conditions like retinitis pigmentosa (24%), bilateral primary optic atrophy (18%), and macular dystrophies (16%). The most effective low vision aids were handheld and stand magnifiers which improved vision by one to four lines. The magnifiers were most effective in eyes with macular dystrophy, retinitis pigmentosa, and age-related macular degeneration. Conclusion: Low vision aids are potential methods of improving the residual vision in low vision patients. In the background of the high and increasing prevalence of low vision and poor awareness about low vision aids among them, efforts are necessary to rehabilitate them with affordable and accessible low vision services.
Article
A deficiência visual provoca alterações biopsicossociais e favorece o desenvolvimento de sintomas depressivos. Este estudo avaliou a ocorrência de sintomas de depressão na cegueira e seus determinantes e utilizou: entrevista semiestruturada; inventário de depressão de Beck; teste de acuidade visual. A amostra avaliou 68 pessoas, maioria do sexo masculino (60,3%), faixa etária acima de 50 anos (33,8%), solteiros (57,3%), ensino superior a pós-graduação (44,1%) e renda familiar entre 1-3 salários mínimos (36,7%).
Article
Full-text available
Purpose. To assess the degree of participation of the visually impaired elderly and to make a comparison with population-based reference data. Method. This cross-sectional study included visually impaired elderly persons (≥55 years; n=173) who were referred to a low-vision rehabilitation centre. Based on the International Classification of Functioning, Disability and Health (ICF) participation in: 1) domestic life, 2) interpersonal interactions and relationships, 3) major life areas, and 4) community, social and civic life was assessed by means of telephone interviews. In addition, we assessed perceived participation restrictions. Results. Comparison with reference data of the elderly showed that visually impaired elderly persons participated less in heavy household activities, recreational activities and sports activities. No differences were found for the interpersonal interactions and relationships domain. Participants experienced restrictions in household activities (84%), socializing (53%), paid or voluntary work (92%), and leisure activities (88%). Conclusions. Visually impaired elderly persons participate in society, but they participate less than their peers. They experience restrictions as a result of vision loss. These findings are relevant, since participation is an indicator for successful aging and has a positive influence on health and subjective well-being.
Article
Full-text available
To characterize the demographic and psychosocial problems of a group of blind people as a way of attracting more attention to and providing data that can improve the psychosocial care of the visually impaired. A cross-sectional descriptive study of a population of totally blind people in Ilorin, Nigeria using a self-report questionnaire (SRQ). The questionnaire was verbally administered by the study personnel in the local language. Simple frequency tables were obtained and the Chi-square test was performed to determine significant differences between variables. P value <0.05 was considered statistically significant. Sixty one blind patients consented to participate. Most participants were engaged in street begging for their livelihood. Most subjects desired a job change, signifying dissatisfaction with the present occupation. Up to 80% of the cohort was married and had spouses who were also blind in at least one eye. Approximately two-thirds had five or more children and majority lived with family members who were responsible for taking care of their personal hygiene, cooking and mobility. The majority developed blindness in childhood and 16% had a family history of blindness and 77% had never used conventional eye care, with corneal disease being the most frequent cause of blindness. Many feared that their children may also become blind. Thirty-one (51%) scored ≥5 on SRQ and were classified as probable cases of psychological disorder. Blindness in a majority of cases that started in childhood was probably preventable. Inaccessibility to or failure of the formal rehabilitation and social welfare systems may have caused this psychosocial dilemma. The high level of social and family interaction provides opportunity for organized preventive ophthalmology, community health care services and psychosocial care.
Article
Full-text available
To assess the degree of participation of the visually impaired elderly and to make a comparison with population-based reference data. This cross-sectional study included visually impaired elderly persons (≥55 years; n = 173) who were referred to a low-vision rehabilitation centre. Based on the International Classification of Functioning, Disability and Health (ICF) participation in: (1) domestic life, (2) interpersonal interactions and relationships, (3) major life areas, and (4) community, social and civic life was assessed by means of telephone interviews. In addition, we assessed perceived participation restrictions. Comparison with reference data of the elderly showed that visually impaired elderly persons participated less in heavy household activities, recreational activities and sports activities. No differences were found for the interpersonal interactions and relationships domain. Participants experienced restrictions in household activities (84%), socializing (53%), paid or voluntary work (92%), and leisure activities (88%). Visually impaired elderly persons participate in society, but they participate less than their peers. They experience restrictions as a result of vision loss. These findings are relevant, since participation is an indicator for successful aging and has a positive influence on health and subjective well-being.
Article
Full-text available
To describe the demographic, visual, health, and psychological variables associated with awareness and use of low-vision rehabilitation services in Montreal, Que. Hospital-based cross-sectional study. Four hundred forty-eight patients with best-corrected visual acuity worse than 20/70 in their better eye recruited from 4 ophthalmology departments. Patients answered questions about their awareness and use of low-vision services. Visual acuity was recorded and patients answered the Brief Cope and Center for Epidemiologic Studies - Depression Scale questionnaires and provided information on demographics and health status. Multiple logistic regression was used to identify independent predictors of awareness and use of low-vision rehabilitation services. A majority of patients in the sample (71%) were aware of low-vision rehabilitation. Of those who were aware, 81% reported participating in low-vision rehabilitation. Black patients, those whose first language was French, those with less severe visual acuity loss, and those who reported less acceptance on the Brief Cope questionnaire were less likely to know about low-vision services (p < 0.05). Of those who knew about low-vision services, those with less severe visual acuity loss were less likely to have participated in low-vision services (p < 0.05). It is important that all those who qualify for low-vision rehabilitation services can access them. Although the patients in this Montreal area study showed a high rate of awareness and use of low-vision rehabilitation, awareness and use could be improved in certain demographic populations and in those with less severe vision loss.
Article
Full-text available
To review the evidence for the presence of lower levels of psychosocial well-being in working-age adults with visual impairment and for interventions to improve such levels of psychosocial well-being. Systematic review of quantitative studies published in English from 2001 to July 2008 that measured depression/mental health, anxiety, quality of life, social functioning or social support. Included were 29 studies that measured one or more outcomes (N = 52). Working-age adults with visual impairment were significantly more likely to report lower levels of mental health (mean difference = 14.51/100), social functioning (MD = 11.55/100) and quality of life. Studies regarding the prevalence of depressive symptoms produced inconsistent results but had methodological limitations. Future research is required into the prevalence of loneliness, anxiety and depression in adults with visual impairment, and to evaluate the effectiveness of interventions for improving psychosocial well-being such as counselling, peer support and employment programmes.
Article
Full-text available
To examine the prevalence of persons at risk for depression among family caregivers of visually impaired persons and the extent to which social problem-solving abilities are associated with caregiver depressive symptomatology and life satisfaction. Family caregivers were defined as adults who accompanied their adult relative to an appointment at a low-vision rehabilitation clinic and self-identified themselves as the primary family caregiver responsible for providing some form of assistance for their relative due to vision impairment. Demographic variables, depressive symptoms, life satisfaction, caregiver burden, and social problem-solving abilities were assessed in caregivers. The patient's visual acuity and depressive symptoms and their relationship to the caregiver's depressive symptoms and life satisfaction were also examined. Ninety-six family caregivers were enrolled. Of those, 35.4% were identified as at risk for depression. Among caregivers, dysfunctional or ineffective social problem-solving abilities were significantly associated with greater depressive symptomatology and decreased life satisfaction after adjustment for caregiver burden and demographic and medical variables for both the caregiver and the visually impaired patient. Problem orientation or motivation to solving problems was also significantly associated with caregiver depression and satisfaction with life. A substantial number of caregivers of visually impaired adults experience psychosocial distress, particularly among those who possess poor social problem-solving abilities. These results underscore the need for routine screening and treatment of emotional distress among individuals caring for relatives with vision impairments. Future research should examine the extent to which psychosocial interventions targeting caregiver social problem-solving skills may be useful not only in improving caregiver quality of life but also in subsequently enhancing rehabilitation outcomes for the visually impaired care recipient.
Article
In this thesis the term eye amputation (EA) covers the removing of an eye by: evisceration, enucleation and exenteration. Amputation of an eye is most frequently the end-stage in a complicated disease, or the primary treatment in trauma and neoplasm. In 2010 the literature is extensive due to knowledge about types of surgery, implants and surgical technique. However, not much is known about the time past surgery. The purpose of the PhD thesis was: To indentify the number of EA, the causative diagnosis and the indication for surgical removal of the eye, the chosen surgical technique and to evaluate a possible change in surgical technique in Denmark from 1996 until 2003 (paper I); To describe the phantom eye syndrome and its prevalence of visual hallucinations, phantom pain and phantom sensations (paper II); To characterise the quality of phantom eye pain, including its intensity and frequency among EA patients. We attempted to identify patients with increased risk of developing pain after EA and investigated if preoperative pain is a risk factor for a later development of phantom pain (paper III); In addition we wanted to investigate the health related quality of life, perceived stress, self rated health, job separation due to illness or disability and socio-economic position of the EA in comparison with the general Danish population (paper IV). The studies were based on: Records on 431 EA patients, clinical ophthalmological examination and an interview study of 173 EA patients and a questionnaire answered by 120 EA patients. Conclusions: The most frequent indications for EA in Denmark were painful blind eye (37%) and neoplasm (34%). During the study period 1996–2003, the annual number of eye amputations was stable, but an increase in bulbar eviscerations was noticed. Orbital implants were used with an increasing tendency until 2003. The Phantom eye syndrome is frequent among EA patients. Visual hallucinations were described by 42% of the patients. The content were mainly elementary visual hallucinations, with white or colored light as a continuous sharp light or as moving dots. The most frequent triggers were darkness, closing of the eyes, fatigue and psychological stress. Fifty-four percent of the patients had visual hallucinations more than once a week. Ten patients were so visually disturbed that it interfered with their daily life. Approximately 23% of all EA experience phantom pain for several years after the surgery. Phantom pain was reported to be of three different qualities: (i) cutting, penetrating, gnawing or oppressive (n = 19); (ii) radiating, zapping or shooting (n = 8); (iii) superficial burning or stinging (n = 5); or a mixture of these different pain qualities (n = 7). The median intensity on a visual analogue scale, ranging from 0 to 100, was 36 [range: 1–89]. One-third of the patients experienced phantom pain every day. Chilliness, windy weather and psychological stress/fatigue were the most commonly reported triggers for pain. Factors associated with phantom pain were: ophthalmic pain before EA, the presence of implant and a patient reported high degree of conjunctival secretion. A common reason for EA is the presence of a painful blind eye. However, one third of these patients continue to have pain after the EA. Phantom sensations were present in 2% of the patients. The impact of an eye amputation is considerable. EA patients have poorer health related quality of life, poorer self-rated health and more perceived stress than does the general population. The largest differences in health related quality of life between the EA patients and the general population were related to role limitations due to emotional problems and mental health. Patients with the indication painful blind eye are having lower scores in all aspects of health related quality of life and perceived stress than patients with the indication neoplasm and trauma. The percentage of eye amputated which is divorced or separated was twice as high as in the general population. Furthermore, 25% retired or changed to part-time jobs due to eye disease and 39.5% stopped participating in leisure activities due to their EAs.
Article
To determine the unique contribution of vision-specific distress in predicting depressive symptoms in people with vision impairment attending a tertiary eye care clinic. In this cross-sectional study, interview-administered surveys were conducted with 143 adult patients who had presenting visual acuity <0.3 logMAR. Depressive symptoms were assessed with the Patient Health Questionnaire-9 and vision-specific distress was assessed with the Impact of Vision Impairment (IVI) Questionnaire emotional well-being subscale. In addition, level of restriction of participation in common daily activities due to vision impairment was assessed with the IVI and measures of general physical health and social support were included. Twenty-one (14.7%) of 143 participants reported clinically significant depressive symptoms and an additional 27.3% (n = 39) had mild depressive symptoms. Vision-specific distress was the strongest unique predictor of depressive symptoms (beta = 0.37, P < 0.001), with physical health (beta = -0.22, P < 0.01), age (beta = -0.18, P < 0.05), and experience of a negative life event (beta = 0.15, P < 0.05) also contributing significantly to depressive symptoms. Results also indicated that vision-specific distress mediates the impact of participation restriction due to vision impairment on depressive symptoms. An assessment of vision-specific distress may be a useful tool with which to identify those at risk of depression or in need of early intervention in eye care or rehabilitation settings. Depression treatment approaches or depression prevention strategies for people with vision impairment may benefit from a focus on vision-specific distress.
Article
To estimate depression in patients with age-related macular degeneration (AMD) and study the relationships among depression, visual acuity, and disability. It was a cross-sectional study with consecutive sampling (n = 53) of patients with AMD aged 50 years and above attending the retina clinic of a tertiary care hospital in North India. Depression, general disability and vision-specific disability were assessed in subjects meeting selection criteria. Assessments were done using the fourth edition of Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of mental disorders (DSM- IV) Geriatric Depression Scale (GDS), Structured Clinical Interview for DSM-IV Axis -I Disorders, Clinical Version (SCID-CV), World Health Organization Disability Assessment Schedule-II (WHODAS-II) and Daily Living Tasks dependent on Vision scale (DLTV). Non-parametric correlation analyses and regression analyses were performed. Out of 53 participants, 26.4% (n = 14) met DSM-IV criteria for the diagnosis of depressive disorder. Depressed patients had significantly greater levels of general and vision-specific disability than non-depressed patients. General disability was predicted better by depression and vision-specific disability than by visual acuity. Depression is a major concern in patients with AMD and contributes more to disability than visual impairment.