Reproductive aspects of two Enyalius lizards from the Atlantic forest in Southeastern Brazil

Full text

The lizard genus Enyalius (Leiosauridae) currently
comprises nine species distributed mainly in the
Atlantic Forest domain of South America, and in the
Brazilian Amazon rainforest, Cerrado, and Caatinga
(Frost et al., 2001; Rodrigues et al., 2006; Uetz, 2013).
Species of Enyalius are insectivorous, diurnal, with
arboreal or semi-arboreal habits (Jackson, 1978; Vitt
et al., 1996; Zamprogno et al., 2001; Van Sluys et al.,
2004; Rautenberg and Laps, 2010; Barreto-Lima and
Sousa, 2011). Enyalius iheringii Boulenger, 1885 and
E. perditus Jackson, 1978 are two species endemic
to the Brazilian Atlantic forest in southeastern Brazil
(Jackson, 1978), whose natural history, especially
their reproductive aspects, is poorly known (Marques
and Sazima, 2004; Barreto-Lima and Sousa, 2006;
Rautenberg and Laps, 2010; Sturaro and Silva, 2010).
Herein, we provide novel information on reproductive
aspects of E. iheringii and E. perditus from São Paulo,
southeastern Brazil.
On 3 November 2012 at 11:10 h (mid-spring), a
couple of E. perditus (both with snout-vent length
between 120-130 mm, approximately) were found in
a copulation attempt, during a herpetofaunal survey in
a fragment of Atlantic Forest with approximately 52
km2 at Juquiazinho district, in Juquitiba, São Paulo (-
23.97203, -47.02294; datum=WGS84; 730 m a.s.l.),
south-eastern Brazil. The couple was on a tree trunk
about 1 m above ground. The male was biting the
female’s neck when suddenly both fell from the trunk
on the leaf litter. After the fall, the male remained on
the back of the female, biting her neck in an attempt to
immobilize her (Fig. 1). Both remained in this position
for about 30 seconds. After this, the female disengaged
from the male and escaped, followed by the male a few
seconds later. Effective copulation was not observed.
Courtship was previously reported for at least three
species of Enyalius. Vitt et al. (1996) reported a possible
courtship in eld conditions for E. leechii (Boulenger,
1885), whereas Grantsau (1966) and Barreto-Lima and
Sousa (2006) reported courtship and mating in captive
conditions for E. catenatus and E. perditus. To our
knowledge, our observation was the rst courtship
conrmed taken in eld conditions for a species of
Enyalius. In both captive reports, male bit females
during attempted copulation. The pattern of courtship
behaviour observed in nature was similar to those taken
in captive conditions (Grantsau, 1966; Barreto-Lima
and Sousa, 2006).
The period of courtship (spring) was coincident with
the period of vitellogenesis and courtship/mating in
captivity previously reported for the species (Barreto-
Lima and Souza, 2006; Sturaro and Silva, 2010;
Table 1). Coincidently, the same female involved in
this courtship/mating episode was observed in the
previous night. The individual was recognized for
being in process of shedding skin (Fig. 2), in addition
to the presence of a callosity in the tail. The shedding
process is associated with the mating season of lizards
and snakes (Mason and Gutzke, 1990; Marques et al.,
2009), and several authors have suggested that shedding
is part of the oestrus signal (Aldridge and Duvall,
2002). The proposed mechanism is that reproductive
pheromones released at the time of shedding stimulate
male courtship behaviour (Mason and Gutzke, 1990;
Mason, 1992). Additionally, this female showed some
light orange spots on the neck and throat during the
copulation attempt, similarly to the observed by Sturaro
and Silva (2010) in reproductive females, suggesting
that this feature is an important courtship stimulator for
Herpetology Notes, volume 7: 273-276 (2014) (published online on 25 April 2014)
Reproductive aspects of two Enyalius
lizards from the Atlantic forest in Southeastern Brazil
Serena Najara Migliore1,2, Henrique Bartolomeu Braz1 and Selma Maria Almeida-Santos1
1Laboratório de Ecologia e Evolução, Instituto Butantan - Av.
Dr. Vital Brazil, 1500 – Butantã, São Paulo-SP, CEP 05503-
900.
2Corresponding author:
serena_891@hotmail.com; serena.migliore@butantan.gov.br

Serena Najara Migliore et al.
274
males (Baird, 2004). Taken together, shedding process
and colour signal suggest that the female of E. perditus
was probably signalling her condition to the male.
Reproductive observations on Enyalius iheringii were
taken from a female (voucher specimen: IBSPCR 0425;
Instituto Butantan, São Paulo, Coleção de Referência)
collected on 3 March 2012, in the Serra do Mar State
Park, Ubatuba, São Paulo, southeastern Brazil. The
female measured 103 mm of snout-vent length (SVL)
and 203 mm of tail length (TL). It was kept in a cage
containing branches and leaf litter. On 2 April 2012, it
laid 18 eggs within the cage. Five eggs were infertile.
The remaining 13 eggs were measured, using a digital
calliper (to the nearest 0.1 mm) and weighed, using a
digital balance (to the nearest 0.01 g). Eggs averaged
15.0 ± 0.5 mm in length (range = 14.1–15.7 mm), 9.7 ±
0.7 mm in width (range = 8.8–11.2 mm), and 0.81 ± 0.10
g in mass (range = 0.70–1.05 g). After oviposition, the
female weighed 24.0 g. The relative clutch mass (RCM;
total clutch mass/maternal body mass after oviposition
+ total clutch mass; following Vitt and Price, 1982) was
0.378. Thirteen eggs were incubated. Eggs were housed
in a plastic container, half-buried with moistened
vermiculite, and maintained at room temperature
Figure 1. Copulation attempt in Enyalius perditus (Juquiazinho, Juquitiba, São Paulo, Brazil). Notice the male (green individual)
biting female’s neck (brownish individual) in attempt to immobilize her.
Table 1.
Species Courtship Mating Vitellogenesis Gravidity or
egg-laying
Corpus luteum Hatching Clutch size
E. perditus Spring
(Nov-Dec)
1,5
Spring
(Nov-Dec)
1
Spring
(Nov)
2
Spring
(Dec) and
summer (Jan)
2
Summer
(Feb and Mar)
2
- 7-14
2
E. iheringii - - Spring
(Dec) and
Summer (Jan)
4
Summer
(Jan and Feb) and
Autumn (Apr)
3,4,5
- Winter
(Aug)
5
10-18
3,4,5
(1) Barreto-Lima and Sousa (2006); (2) Sturaro and Silva (20 10); (3) Marques and Sazima (2004); (4) Rautenberg and Laps (2010); (5) Present study.
Table 1. Timing of reproductive events recorded for Enyalius perditus and E. iheringii in the literature and present study.

averaging 24° C. Eight eggs spoiled over incubation
period due to fungal contamination. Hatchings (n =
4) occurred between 23 and 28 August 2012, after an
incubation period ranging from 143 to 148 days. One egg
failed to hatch. This egg was dissected, and it contained
one full-term dead embryo with a malformation in the
tail. Hatchlings averaged 27.5 ± 3.5 mm SVL (range =
25–30 mm), 49.0 ± 8.5 mm TL (range = 43–55 mm),
and 0.77 ± 0.01 g (range = 0.76–0.78 g).
There are no data on RCM for other Enyalius but the
value observed here in E. iheringii is high and close
to the upper limit observed in other lizards (Vitt and
Price, 1982). In lizards, RCM and foraging modes
are associated. RCM tends to be relatively low within
species that forage actively, and relatively high within
species using the “sit-and-wait” foraging mode (Vitt and
Price, 1982). Since females of Enyalius species appears
to be “sit-and-wait” foragers (Sousa and Cruz, 2008;
Borges et al., 2013) and move shorter distances than
males (Barreto-Lima et al., 2013), the high RCM value
observed here in E. iheringii appears to be congruent
with such association.
Estimates on gravidity period and clutch size available
in the literature for Enyalius were largely obtained from
dissection of preserved females (Rand, 1982; Vitt et
al., 1996; Marques and Sazima, 2004; Rautenberg and
Laps, 2010; Sturaro and Silva, 2010). This is the rst
report of egg size, incubation period, and hatchling size
of an Enyalius species. Gravid females of E. iheringii
were previously found in January and February
(Table 1) suggesting that the species presents some
reproductive seasonality (Marques and Sazima, 2004;
Rautenberg and Laps, 2010; R. Rautenberg, pers. com.).
Our observation of egg laying in April corroborates this
assumption but suggests that oviposition may be further
extended (at least to early autumn) than previously
thought. Considering the period of encounter of
gravid females of E. iheringii and our hatching report,
recruitment appears to occur from autumn to mid-winter
(Table 1).
The few information available for E. perditus and E.
iheringii impair broad comparisons between species and
denitive generalization on the timing of reproductive
events. However, taken together our data and literature
Figure 2. (A) The female Enyalius perditus observed one night before the copulation attempt. (B) Detail of the female’s head
highlighting the piece of skin in the head above the eye, indicating the process of shedding.
Reproductive aspects of two Enyalius lizards from the Atlantic forest 275

information indicate certain similarity between species,
at least on the timing of vitellogenesis and gravidity
(Table 1). However, gravidity period appears to extend
further (to early autumn) in E. iheringii. Detailed studies
are clearly needed to fully understand the reproductive
cycles of these species and test this assumption.
Acknowledgements. We thank M. T. Rodrigues, F. F. Curcio,
and V. J. Germano for taxonomic identication of the specimens,
and R. Recoder for the critical reading and comments on the
manuscript. We also thank R. Rautenberg, A. F. Barreto-Lima,
and B. Rocha for information on Enyalius specimens, and A.
Silveira for assistance with hatchlings. PAP (Programa de
Aprimoramento Prossional) provided a fellowship to S. N.
Migliore, and FAPESP (Fundação de Amparo à Pesquisa do
Estado de São Paulo) to H. B. Braz (grant no. 2009/54478-3).
References
Aldridge, R.D., Duvall, D. (2002): Evolution of the mating season
in the pitvipers of North America. Herpetological Monographs
16: 1-25.
Baird, T.A. (2004): Reproductive coloration in female collared
lizards, Crotaphytus collaris, stimulates courtship by males.
Herpetologica 60: 337-348.
Barreto-Lima, A.F., Sousa, B.M. (2006): Court and copulation
behaviors of Enyalius perditus Jackson, 1978 (Squamata,
Leiosauridae) in captivity conditions. Revista Brasileira de
Zoociências 8: 193-197.
Barreto-Lima, A.F., Sousa, B.M. (2011): Feeding ecology and
sexual dimorphism of Enyalius perditus in an Atlantic forest,
Brazil. Herpetological Bulletin 118: 1-9.
Barreto-Lima, A.F., Pires, E.O., Sousa, B.M. (2013): Activity,
foraging mode and microhabitat use of Enyalius perditus
(Squamata) in a disturbed Atlantic rainforest in southeastern
Brazil. Salamandra 49: 177-185.
Borges, V.S., Pires, R.C., Linares, A.M., Eterovick, P.C. (2013):
Diet of Enyalius bilineatus (Leiosauridae: Squamata) at a site in
southeastern Brazil: effects of phylogeny and prey availability.
Journal of Natural History 47: 2785-2794.
Boulenger, G.A. (1885): Catalogue of the lizards in the British
Museum (Natural History), 2nd Edition. London: British
Museum (Natural History).
Frost, D.R., Etheridge, R., Janies, D., Titus, T.A. (2001): Total
evidence, sequence alignment, evolution of Polychrotid lizards,
and a reclassication of the Iguania (Squamata: Iguania).
American Museum Novitates 3343: 1-38.
Grantsau, R. (1966): Enyalius catenatus, das Brasilianische
“Cameleon”. Aquarien Terrarien Zeitschrift 19: 217-219.
Jackson, J.F. (1978): Differentiation in the genera Enyalius and
Strobilurus (Iguanidae): implications for Pleistocene climatic
changes in eastern Brazil. Arquivos de Zoologia 30: 1-79.
Marques, O.A.V., Almeida-Santos, S.M., Rodrigues, M.G.,
Camargo, R. (2009): Mating and reproductive cycle in the
Neotropical colubrid snake Chironius bicarinatus. South
American Journal of Herpetology 4: 76-80.
Marques, O.A.V., Sazima, I. (2004): História natural dos répteis da
Estação Ecológica Juréia-Itatins. In: História Natural da Estação
Ecológica Juréia-Itatins: Ambiente Físico, Flora e Fauna, p.
257-277. Marques, O.A.V., Duleba, W., Eds., Ribeirão Preto,
Holos.
Mason, R.T., Gutzke, W.H.N. (1990): Sex recognition in the
leopard gecko, Eublepharis macularius (Sauria: Gekkonidae).
Possible mediation by skin-derived semiochemicals. Journal of
Chemical Ecology. 16: 27-36.
Mason, R.T. (1992): Reptilian pheromones. In: Biology of the
Reptilia, Volume 18, Physiology E, Hormones, Brain, and
Behavior, p. 114–228. Gans, C., Crews, D., Eds., Chicago, The
University of Chicago Press.
Rand, A.S. (1982): Clutch and egg size in Brazilian iguanid lizards.
Herpetologica 38: 171-178.
Rautenberg, R., Laps, R.R. (2010): Natural history of the lizard
Enyalius iheringii (Squamata, Leiosauridae) in southern
Brazilian Atlantic forest. Iheringia Série Zoologia 100: 287-
290.
Rodrigues, M.T., Freitas, M.A., Silva, T.F.S., Bertolotto, C.E.V.
(2006): A new species of lizard genus Enyalius (Squamata,
Leiosauridae) from the highlands of Chapada Diamantina, state
of Bahia, Brazil, with a key to species. Phyllomedusa 5: 11-24.
Sousa, B.M., Cruz, C.A.G. (2008): Hábitos alimentares de
Enyalius perditus (Squamata, Leiosauridae) no Parque Estadual
do Ibitipoca, Minas Gerais, Brasil. Iheringia, Série Zoologia 98:
260-265.
Sturaro, M.J., Silva, V.X. (2010): Natural history of the lizard
Enyalius perditus (Squamata: Leiosauridae) from an Atlantic
forest remnant in southeastern Brazil. Journal of Natural History
44: 1225-1238.
Uetz, P. (2013): Enyalius, The Reptile Database. Available at:
http://www.reptile-database.org. Last accessed on 19 September
2013.
Van Sluys, M., Ferreira, V.M., Rocha, C.F.D. (2004): Natural
history of the lizard Enyalius brasiliensis (Lesson, 1828)
(Leiosauridae) from an Atlantic forest of southeastern Brazil.
Brazilian Journal of Biology 64:353-356.
Vitt, L.J., Price, H.J. (1982): Ecological and evolutionary
determinants of relative clutch mass in lizards. Herpetologica
38: 237-255.
Vitt, L.J., Ávila-Pires, T.C.S., Zani, P.A. (1996): Observations
on the ecology of the rare Amazonian lizard, Enyalius leechii
(Polychrotidae). Herpetological Natural History 4: 77-82.
Zamprogno, C., Zamprogno, M.G.F., Teixeira, R.L. (2001):
Evidence of terrestrial feeding in the arboreal lizard Enyalius
bilineatus (Sauria, Polychrotidae) of south-eastern Brazil.
Revista Brasileira de Biologia 61: 91-94.
Serena Najara Migliore et al.
276
Accepted by Diogo Provete;
Managing Editor: Diogo Provete