ArticlePDF Available

Foraging under Predation Risk in the Wild Guinea Pig Cavia aperea

Authors:

Abstract

Four hypotheses about the foraging-antipredation behavioural conflict using herbivorous rodents Cavia aperea were tested: (a) shorter residence times and (b) greater scanning rates, are expected in foraging areas progressively more distant from cover, because foraging at greater distances from cover would increment predation risk; as group foraging would facilitate predator detection, (c) shorter residence times and (d) greater scanning rates, are expected when cavies are alone than when they are in foraging groups. Over a total of 123 complete foraging bout observations, cavies always foraged at less than four m from the cover. The results support predictions (c) and (d), suggesting that (1) cavies improved their foraging efficiency by joining a group, which allowed them to produce longer bouts and to invest more time in grazing during bouts, and (2) foraging group formation had a role in antipredation defense. (b) was also supported, but in the case of (a), the observed relation was the opposite to the one expected, that is residence times were longer as distance to cover increased. Observed behaviour suggests that cavies reduce risk at greater distance to the cover by increasing their scanning rates and by progressively reaching more distant zones, foraging first in near ones, and returning to the cover in a hurry.
Nordic Society Oikos
Foraging under Predation Risk in the Wild Guinea Pig Cavia aperea
Author(s): M. H. Cassini
Source:
Oikos,
Vol. 62, No. 1 (Oct., 1991), pp. 20-24
Published by: Blackwell Publishing on behalf of Nordic Society Oikos
Stable URL: http://www.jstor.org/stable/3545441
Accessed: 11/06/2009 15:18
Your use of the JSTOR archive indicates your acceptance of JSTOR's Terms and Conditions of Use, available at
http://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsp. JSTOR's Terms and Conditions of Use provides, in part, that unless
you have obtained prior permission, you may not download an entire issue of a journal or multiple copies of articles, and you
may use content in the JSTOR archive only for your personal, non-commercial use.
Please contact the publisher regarding any further use of this work. Publisher contact information may be obtained at
http://www.jstor.org/action/showPublisher?publisherCode=black.
Each copy of any part of a JSTOR transmission must contain the same copyright notice that appears on the screen or printed
page of such transmission.
JSTOR is a not-for-profit organization founded in 1995 to build trusted digital archives for scholarship. We work with the
scholarly community to preserve their work and the materials they rely upon, and to build a common research platform that
promotes the discovery and use of these resources. For more information about JSTOR, please contact support@jstor.org.
Blackwell Publishing and Nordic Society Oikos are collaborating with JSTOR to digitize, preserve and extend
access to Oikos.
http://www.jstor.org
OIKOS
62: 20-24. Copenhagen
1991
Foraging
under predation
risk in the wild guinea
pig
Cavia aperea
M. H. Cassini
Cassini, M. H. 1991. Foraging
under predation
risk in the wild guinea pig Cavia
aperea. - Oikos 62: 20-24
Four
hypotheses
about the foraging-antipredation
behavioural
conflict
using
herbivo-
rous rodents Cavia
aperea
were tested: (a) shorter residence
times and (b) greater
scanning
rates,
are expected
in foraging
areas
progressively
more
distant from
cover,
because
foraging
at greater
distances
from
cover would
increment
predation
risk;
as
group foraging
would facilitate
predator
detection, (c) shorter
residence
times and
(d) greater scanning
rates,
are expected
when cavies
are alone than
when
they are in
foraging
groups. Over a total of 123 complete foraging
bout observations,
cavies
always
foraged
at less than four
m from the cover.
The results
support
predictions (c)
and (d), suggesting
that (1) cavies improved
their foraging
efficiency by joining a
group, which allowed them to produce longer bouts and to invest more time in
grazing during
bouts, and (2) foraging
group
formation had a role in antipredation
defense. (b) was also supported,
but in the case of (a), the observed
relation
was the
opposite
to the one expected,
that is residence
times were
longer
as distance
to cover
increased. Observed behaviour
suggests
that
cavies reduce risk at greater
distance to
the cover by increasing
their scanning
rates and by progressively
reaching
more
distant
zones, foraging
first
in near
ones, and returning
to the cover in a hurry.
M. H. Cassini,
Laboratorio de Fisiologia
del Comportamiento,
Instituto
de Biologia y
Medicina
Experimental,
Obligado
2490, (1428) Buenos Aires, Argentina.
Present
address:
Dept of Zoology, Univ. of Oxford,
Oxford
OXI 3PS, UK
Classical optimal foraging models (e.g., the marginal
value theorem, Charnov 1976) consider an animal ex-
ploiting a food patch as exclusively engaged in foraging
activity. That is, they assume an optimal strategy simply
maximizes the net rate of energy intake or other cur-
rency related to foraging. However, many animals must
attend to other activities which compete with foraging,
such as antipredator vigilance or territorial defence. In
recent years, the trade-off between foraging and preda-
tion avoidance has become an important new field in
behavioural ecology. Insects, fishes, birds, and mam-
mals have been studied with respect to the effect of
predation risk over foraging decision rules such as (1)
how much time to spend foraging (Caraco 1979a, b,
Barnard 1980, Caraco et al. 1980, Gluck 1987a), (2)
which foraging strategy to use (Milinski and Heller
1978, Lima 1985, Lima et al. 1985, Metcalfe et al.
1987b, Pitcher et al. 1988), (3) where to eat (Sih 1980,
Lima et al. 1987, Newman and Caraco 1987, Holbrook
and Schmitt 1988, Werner and Hall 1988), (4) which
types of prey to consume (Metcalfe et al. 1987a, Mor-
gan 1988), and (5) when to leave a patch (Newman et al.
1988).
The aim of this paper is to analyse the effects of
predation risk on the patch exploitation by wild guinea
pigs Cavia aperea, in natural conditions.
Cavias' patch use rules have been studied in the lab-
oratory. Domestic guinea pigs were trained to forage
under different environmental conditions, which in-
cluded manipulations of travel time between patches,
patch gain function, and patch quality between and
within environments (Cassini 1989, Cassini et al. 1990).
Accepted 17 May 1991
? OIKOS
OIKOS 62:1 (1991)
20
The results of these experiments
confirmed
unequiv-
ocally all predictions
of discrete rate maximizing
(and
delay minimizing)
models. Therefore,
when predation
risk is equalized, cavies leave patches in a way that
seems to approach
the optimization
of their foraging
efficiency.
These results
encouraged
the analysis
of the
effect of predation
risk over patch use behaviour.
This
study
was
performed
in the field because:
(1) wild
cavies
foraging
in natural
conditions are an excellent
biological
model for the study
of predation
feeding-conflicts,
and
(2) although this conflict has been studied in the lab
(Gluck
1987a,
Pitcher et al. 1988),
problems
in working
with simulated
predators
arose (because the effect of
exposure
to the predator
may last over several
trials),
mainly
when a hierarchically
law decision level (as how
long to stay in a patch) was studied
(Krebs
1980).
Wild guinea pigs C. aperea
are neotropical
herbivo-
rous
rodents
(Rood 1972).
Typically,
their
environment
has a cover zone with high
and dense vegetation,
which
they evidently
use as a protection
from
predator
attacks
(Rood 1972), and a foraging
zone where
predation
risk
would depend, among
other environmental
factors,
on
vegetation
height
(the importance
of visibility
in preda-
tor detection has been studied in other
species, e.g., see
Ferguson 1987, Metcalfe 1984). In short vegetation,
cavies
make
a series
of foraging
bouts,
each one consist-
ing of a relatively
brief
visit
to the foraging
zone close to
the cover. While
foraging,
cavies
periodically
stop graz-
ing and
elevate their
heads
from
over the line projected
by their backs. This scanning
or alert behaviour
seems
to have an anti-predator
function
(Rood 1972).
Distance
to cover and foraging
group
size have been
postulated
as two factors
which affect foraging
strate-
gies under
predator
risk (for a review, see Pulliam
and
Caraco 1984). In animals
with foraging
bouts like the
cavies', it has been found that perceived
predation
risk
is greater as the animal
moves further
away from the
protective
cover, because the probability
of escaping
a
detected attack is lower (Davis 1973,
Lima 1985, New-
man and Caraco 1987). Evidence that foraging in a
group
increments
detection of predators
compared
with
foraging
alone has been reported
in several
species
(see
Pulliam
and Caraco
1984).
In this work, the effects of distance
to cover and of
socialization in cavies' foraging behaviour
were ana-
lyzed by testing the following
predictions
(Pulliam
and
Caraco 1984): (1) shorter
patch residence
times (than
those expected
if the behaviour
of cavies has no relation
to the distance to cover, that is, the animals
walk with
constant
probability
of stopping),
and
(2) more
frequent
scanning
behaviour
are expected
at greater
distances to
cover;
(3) shorter
residence
times, and (4) greater
scan-
ning rates are expected when cavies forage alone than
when in a group.
Methods
Cavies C. aperea
from
a natural
population
of the Para-
na Delta (Buenos Aires Province,
Argentina)
were ob-
served. A open garden
of approximately
4000 m2
was
used as study area. There was a well defined limit be-
tween this open ground
and the surrounding
high and
compact secondary
forest vegetation characteristic
of
this
region.
Cavies
inhabit
this "cover
zone" and
leave it
to eat in the open garden, where they were easy to
observe
because the grass
was cut weekly.
Observations
were made in two garden
sites contig-
uous to cover, one 4 m x 21 m and the other 4 m x 12
m, both of which
were divided
into cells of 1 m x 3 m
with
stakes
so as to determine
five categories
of distance
to cover:
0-1 m, 1-2 m, 2-3 m, 3-4 m and >4 m. Cavies
used these sites daily, from 0600 to 1100 h, and from
1700 to 2100
h, approximately.
The two study
sites
were
completely covered by vegetation of homogeneous
height. Therefore,
it could be assumed
that there were
no significant
differences in vegetable
biomass
supply
in
relation to distance to cover. Small ferrets (Galictis
cuja) and domestic
dogs and cats have been observed
attacking cavies in the area. Polyborus plancus, Milvago
chimango, Asio flammeus and Buteo magnirostris are
potential
aerial
predators
(Rood 1972, Dalby 1975).
Observations
were made
during
October
and
Novem-
ber 1989, between 0600 and 2030 h. Animals
were ob-
served
by eye or with
binoculars
from
a 3 m high
obser-
vation site. An IEpson
PX-8 Geneva computer
with a
program
based
on a focal animal
sampling
method
(Alt-
mann 1974) computed
the following
variables
of com-
plete foraging
bout observations:
(1) total duration,
(2)
maximum
distance to cover, (3) maximum
group size
(measured
as the number
of conspecifics
observed
in a
circle of 3 m around
the focal animal), (4) residence
times at each distance category zone (visits without
grazing
behaviour or with agressive
interactions
were
not included
in later
analyses),
(5) numbers
and
rates
of
alert behaviour
at different distances
from cover, (6)
numbers and rates of alert positions when the focal
animal
was alone and when it foraged
in a group.
The cavies
were not individually
marked,
but at least
eight different
cavies visited the two study sites, since
this number
of animals
was observed simultaneously.
Results
were statistically
analyzed
using
the Stat/Trans-
fer program,
and non-parametric
analyses.
Results
A total of 123 complete
foraging
bouts was registered.
Bouts lasted from 4 s to 1452 s, with an average of
211.49
s and
a standard
deviation
of 247.51
s. The mean
alert behaviour
rate was 0.049 s-1 that is, about three
alert positions
per minute.
Total numbers
of observations
of maximal
distances
OIKOS 62:1 (1991) 21
60 man test statistic = 11.48, p = 0.004), (2) no significant
.*A ^^^differences between the 1-2 m and 2-3 m (Wilcoxon
50- test, p > 0.05), and (3) significant differences between
these and 0-1 m (Wilcoxon test, p < 0.02).
40- When foraging in a group, individual cavies made
longer bouts than when they foraged alone (Mann-
30- Whitney test statistic = 293, p = 0.007) (Fig. 3A). On
the other hand, the scanning rates were marginally grea-
20- ter when cavies foraged alone during the whole foraging
bout, than when they did it with other conspecifics at
10- any moment of the bout (Mann-Whitney test statistic =
9.66, p < 0.07)'(Fig. 3B).
0 Cavies usually did not visit distant cover zones by
0- 1 1 - 2 2 - 3 3 - 4 travelling to them directly. Instead, they used to stop
Maximal distance (meters) several times to forage in nearer zones. However, they
commonly returned from distant zones quickly and
600 without stopping. This observation was supported by
B
R the result that residence times in the first metre to cover
0-1 1 -2 2-3 3-4
Maximal distance (meters)
Fig. 1. Absolute frequencies of foraging bouts (A), and mean
duration (+ standard deviation) of foraging bout (B), in rela-
tion to maximal distance to cover. N = 123.
c
0
0
0)
O
a)
0)
0
0)
la
0
a(
OL
200 A
100-
0-
T
*
0-1 1-2 2-3
Distance to cover (meters)
reached per foraging bout are represented in Fig. 1A.
The number of ocurrences were inversely related to
maximal distances (r = -0.99, t = -28.67, n = 4, p =
0.001). On the other hand, Fig. 1B shows that complete
foraging bouts were longer as maximal distances in-
creased (r = 0.54, t = 7.12, n = 123, p < 0.001). That is,
bouts in which cavies travel long distances became more
rare but resulted in longer total durations.
Mean residence times related to distance from cover
are shown in Fig. 2A. A Friedman test shows that there
were significant differences between residence times
(Friedman test statistic = 11.48, p = 0.003). Multiple
comparisons between means pointed out that residence
time within the first metre was significantly lower than
at greater distances (Wilcoxon tests, ps < 0.001), while
there were no statistical differences between the means
of the second and the third distance categories (p >
0.05).
The same comparisons were made for scanning rates,
showing the same tendencies (Fig. 2B): (1) over-all
significant differences among the three means (Fried-
s'
C
0
._
0
C
co
c(
0.06
0.05 -
0.04 -
0.03 -
0.02 -
0.01 -
0.00 -
B I
u-
*
0-1 1-2 2-3
Distance to cover (meters)
Fig. 2. Mean patch residence time (A) and mean scanning rate
(B) in relation to distance to cover. Asterisks show statistical
differences. (*: p<0.02) N = 28 for each distance category.
Only samples are included in which cavies foraged at the three
distance categories in the same bout are included.
OIKOS 62:1 (1991)
c
0
co
0
cU
m
0
0
0
._
co
0
0
22
0
a
o
c
0
0
0
._
0
LL
400
300-
200-
100-
0-
A
*
Alone In groups
Sociality
o
0
0
0)
c
._
0
0
0)
0.06
0.05
0.04
0.03
0.02
0.01
0.00 Alone In groups
Sociality
Fig. 3. Mean foraging bout duration, and mean scanning rate
when cavies foraging alone (n=70) or in a group (n=15).
Asterisks show statistical differences (*: p <0.05).
were significantly greater when cavies went out (mean
= 57.43 s, SE = 10.00 s) than when they returned
(mean = 15.16 s, SE = 6.23 s) to cover (Wilcoxon test,
p < 0.0001).
Discussion
The aim of this study was to analyse how cavies ex-
ploited their environment when they were under preda-
tion risk. The effects of distance to cover and foraging in
a group on visit duration and scanning rate were stud-
ied.
The first tested prediction was that patch residence
times should be shorter as distance increases, in order to
reduce exposure time to predators, because the prob-
ability of escaping a detected attack would be lower at
greater distances to protective cover. Most of the stud-
ies on the effect of predation risk on patch exploitation
examined patch selection rather than patch residence
time (Holmes 1984, Brown et al. 1988, Holbrook and
Schmitt 1988). Only one work (Newman et al. 1988),
dealing with the effect of distance from protective cover
on patch departure rule was found. In this work, gray
squirrels, Sciurus carolinensis, showed shorter residence
times at greater distance to cover, as was expected.
However, the results obtained with cavies showed the
opposite trend to this prediction: animals stayed for
shorter periods of time at the nearest areas. Lima et al.
(1987) found that three species of passerine birds (Junco
hyemalis, Melospiza melodia and Pipilo erithrophtal-
mus) rarely foraged as close as possible to cover. The
authors suggested that these birds perceive cover as a
protective place but also as an attack source, and pro-
posed that the use of space in this case reflects a trade-
off between the perceived risk of foraging too near to
the cover, and foraging too far from it. This interpreta-
tion could explain why cavies showed shorter residence
times in the nearest zones. The prediction that patch
residence times should be shorter as distance increases
is based on the assumption that food quality and quan-
tity is the same in the whole foraging area. An alterna-
tive explanation can be reached if this assumption is not
fulfilled. Under these conditions, cavies should stay
longer at greater distances where they can find better
patches. Independent measures of food types used by
cavies in natural conditions would be necessary to dis-
tinguish this hypothesis from that which postulate that
the cover per se is avoided.
The second prediction tested was that scanning rates
should increase at greater distances to cover because of
the increased predation risk. This prediction found sup-
port in the present results: cavies scanned less fre-
quently at shorter distances. However, results in other
species have not always agreed with this prediction. For
example, Lima (1987) observed just the opposite trend
in the house sparrow, Passer domesticus. In this species,
the antipredation strategy might be to minimize the
exposure time to predators by eating more quickly and
scanning less frequently, which results in shorter visits
to more distant places. An extreme case of this beha-
viour is that of the black-capped chikadee Parus atrica-
pillus or the squirrel S. carolinensis, both of which carry
the food to cover; in this case, the decision to consume
or to carry the food depends, apart from the distance to
cover, on the handling time and the carrying cost of
different food types (Lima 1985, Lima et al. 1985).
In summary, wild guinea pigs reduce predation risk at
grater distances to cover by increasing scanning rates
and by reaching more distant zones progressively forag-
ing first in near zones and returning to the cover in a
hurry. This strategy differs from those of other prey
species, which diminish their exposure time at longer
distances by eating faster and scanning less, or by carry-
ing the food to cover.
The last two predictions tested are related to the
advantages of group foraging. As predicted, patch resi-
OIKOS 62:1 (1991) 23
dence times were greater and scanning rates lower when
cavies were foraging among group members than when
they foraged alone. These results suggest that individual
wild guinea pigs improved their foraging efficiency by
joining a group, which allowed them to (1) feed longer,
and (2) invest more time in grazing during bouts. Fur-
thermore, if vigilance was shared among group mem-
bers, then a cavie would gain protection against preda-
tion by joining a group. Evidence supporting such
group-derived benefits has been obtained in several spe-
cies, e.g., fishes Pimphales notatus (Morgan 1988), os-
triches Struthio camelus (Bertram 1980), swallows Hi-
rundo pyrrhonota (Brown and Brown 1987), juncos
Junco phaeonotus (Caraco 1979b), goldfinches Cardue-
lis carduelis (Gluck 1987b), herons Ardea herodias
(Krebs 1974), and prairie dogs Cynomys spp. (Hoo-
gland 1981).
In summary, foraging in a group seems to reduce
predation risk and/or increase foraging rates, and cavies
grouping tendencies can be included in this general
phenomenon.
Acknowledgements
- I thank
L. Vila, A. Kacelnik,
G. Flores,
P. Lemoine and M. Gabelli
for their
comments on the manu-
script,
and 0. Suarez for lending
me her house in The Delta.
This research was partly funded by a research
grant from
CONICET
(Argentina)
to E. T. Segura.
The paper
was com-
pleted while I was visiting the AFRC Unit of Ecology and
Evolution (Director: J. R. Krebs FRS), Dept of Zoology,
Univ. of Oxford,
supported
by a Royal Society
scholarship.
Literature
Altmann,
J. 1974.
The observational
study
of behaviour: sam-
pling methods.
- Behaviour 49: 227-267.
Barnard,
C. J. 1980. Flock feeding and time budgets
in the
house sparrow
(Passer
domesticus
L.). - Anim. Behav. 28:
295-309.
Bertram,
B. C. R. 1980.
Vigilance
and
group
size in ostriches.
- Anim. Behav. 28: 278-286.
Brown, C. R. and Brown, B. M. 1987. Group-living
in cliff
swallows
as an advantage
in avoiding
predators.
- Behav.
Ecol. Sociobiol.
21: 97-107.
Brown,
J. S., Kotler,
B. P., Smith,
R. S. and
Wirtz,
W. 0. II.
1988.
The effects
of owl predation
on the foraging
behavior
of heteromyd
rodents.
- Oecologia
(Berl.) 28: 408-415.
Caraco,
T. 1979a.
Time budgeting
and group
size: a theory.
-
Ecology
60: 611-617.
- 1979b. Time budgeting
and group
size: a test of theory.
-
Ecology
60: 618-627.
-, Martindale,
S. and
Pulliam,
H. R. 1980. Avian
flocking
in
the presence
of a predator.
- Nature,
Lond. 285: 400-401.
Cassini, M. H. 1989. El comportamiento
alimentario de los
cavias y la teoria de forrajeo
optimo. - Unpublished
D.
Phil. thesis, Univ. of Buenos
Aires.
- ,Kacelnik,
A. and
Segura,
E. T. 1990. The tale of the hairy
screaming
armadillo,
the guinea
pig and
the marginal
value
theorem.
- Anim. Behav. 39: 1030-1050.
Charnov,
E. L. 1976. Optimal
foraging,
the marginal
value
theorem.
- Theor. Popul. Biol. 9: 129-136.
Dalby, P. L. 1975. The biology of pampa
rodents, Balcarce
area, Argentina.
- Publications of The Museum,
Michigan
State Univ. 5: 151-271.
Davis, J. 1973.
Habitat
preferences
and
competition
of winter-
ing juncos and golden-crowned
sparrows.
- Ecology 56:
335-345.
24
Ferguson,
J. W. H. 1987.
Vigilance
behaviour in white-browed
sparrow
weavers
Plocepasser
mahal. - Ethology
76: 223-
235.
Gluck,
E. 1987a.
An experimental
study
of feeding,
vigilance,
and
predator
avoidance in a single
bird.
- Oecologia
(Berl.)
71: 268-272.
- 1987b. Benefits and costs of social foraging
and optimal
flock size in goldfinches
(Carduelis
carduelis).
- Ethology
74: 65-79.
Holbrook,
S. J. and
Schmitt,
R. J. 1988. The combined
effects
of predation
risk and food reward
on patch selection. -
Ecology
69: 125-134.
Holmes, W. G. 1984.
Predation risk
and foraging
behavior
of
the hoary
marmot in Alaska.
- Behav. Ecol. Sociobiol.
15:
293-301.
Hoogland,
J. L. 1981. The evolution of coloniality
in white-
tailed and black-tailed
prairie
dogs (Sciuridae:
Cynomys
leucunus
and Ludovicianus).
- Ecology
62: 252-272.
Krebs,
J. R. 1974.
Colonial
nesting
and
social
feeding
as strate-
gies for exploiting
food resources in the great blue heron
(Ardea
herodias).
- Behaviour
48: 216-267.
- 1980. Optimal
foraging,
predation
risk and territory
de-
fence. - Ardea 68: 83-90.
Lima, S. L. 1985. Maximizing feeding efficiency and mini-
mizing
time exposed
to predators:
a trade-off
in the black-
capped
chikadee.
- Oecologia
(Berl.) 66: 60-67.
- 1987.
Distance to cover,
visual
obstructions
and
vigilance
in
house sparrows.
- Behaviour 102:
231-238.
-, Valone, T. J. and Caraco,
T. 1985. Foraging-efficiency-
predation-risk
trade-off
in the grey squirrel.
- Anim. Be-
hav. 33: 155-165.
- Wiebe,
K. L. and
Dill, L. M. 1987.
Protective
cover
and
the
use of space by finches: is closer better?. - Oikos 50:
225-230.
Metcalfe,
N. B. 1984.
The effect of habitat
on the vigilance
of
shorebirds:
is visibility
important?
- Anim. Behav.
32: 981-
985.
-, Huntingford,
F A. and Thorpe, J. E. 1987a.
Predation
risk impairs
diet selection in juvenile salmon. - Anim.
Behav. 35: 931-933.
-, Huntingford,
F A. and Thorpe,
J. E. 1987b.
The influ-
ence of predation
risk on the feeding
motivation
and
forag-
ing strategy
of juvenil
Atlantic
salmon.
- Anim. Behav.
35:
901-911.
Milinski,
M. and Heller, R. 1978. Influence of a predator
on
the optimal
foraging
behaviour
for sticklebacks
(Gasteros-
teus
aculeatus
L.). - Nature,
Lond. 275: 642-644.
Morgan,
M. J. 1988.
The influence of hunger,
shoal size and
predator
presence on foraging
in bluntnose minnows. -
Anim. Behav. 36: 1317-1322.
Newman, J. A. and Caraco, T. 1987. Foraging,
predation
hazard
and
patch
use in grey squirrels.
- Anim. Behav. 35:
1804-1813.
-, Recer, G. M., Zwicker, S. M. and Caraco, T. 1988.
Effects of predation hazard on foraging "constraints":
patch-use
strategies
in grey squirrels.
- Oikos 53: 93-97.
Pitcher,
T. J., Lang, S. L. and Turner,
J. A. 1988. A risk-
balancing
trade-off
between foraging
rewards
and preda-
tion hazard
in a shoaling
fish. - Behav. Ecol. Sociobiol.
22:
225-228.
Pulliam,
H. R. and Caraco,
T. 1984.
Living
in groups:
is there
an optimal
group
size. - In: Krebs J. R. and Davis N. B.
(eds), Behavioural ecology, an evolutionary
approach.
Blackwell,
Oxford,
pp. 122-147.
Rood, J.P. 1972. Ecological and behavioral
comparisons
of
three
genera
of Argentina
cavies.
- Anim. Behav.
Monogr.
5: 1-83.
Sih, A. 1980. Optimal
behaviour:
can foragers
balance two
conflicting
demands?
- Science
210: 1041-1043.
Werner,
E. E. and
Hall, D. J. 1988.
Ontogenetic
habitat
shifts
in bluegill: the foraging rate-predation
risk trade-off. -
Ecology
69: 1352-1366.
OIKOS 62:1 (1991)
... In early evening during summer, when copperheads were most active at our study sites, road surface temperature may exceed preferred copperhead body temperature. Second, avoidance of roads may reflect a more general avoidance of open areas because of higher risk of predation (Barnard, 1980;Leger et al., 1983;Cassini, 1991;Longland and Price, 1991). Third, copperheads in the fragmented site may avoid roads because of relatively heavy foot and vehicle traffic on the university thoroughfares. ...
... Studies on a variety of small, terrestrial vertebrate taxa suggest that protective cover provided by vegetation is an important habitat resource. For example, in both small mammals (e.g., California ground squirrels [Spermophilus beecheyi]) as well as in birds (e.g., house sparrows [Passer domesticus]), individuals tend to avoid foraging in open areas away from vegetative cover (Barnard, 1980;Leger et al., 1983;Cassini, 1991). Moreover, rodents may experience increased predation when active in open habitat without canopy cover (Longland and Price, 1991). ...
... For instance, Tchabovsky et al. (2001) argued that sand rats (Psammomys obesus) decrease their vigilance in habitats with a complex vegetation structure, as they perceive the dense cover as good protection. Degus (Octodon degus) perceive higher predation risk in open areas (Cassini, 1991;Leger et al., 1983;Vásquez et al., 2002). However, for other species, vegetation cover is perceived as obstructive, thus reducing the likelihood of early predator detection and increasing the associated predation risk (Ekman, 1987;Hogan, 2010). ...
Article
The perceived predation risk of animals is often influenced by the structure and complexity of vegetation communities. Plateau pikas (Ochotona curzoniae) are considered a pest species in alpine meadows when their densities exceed a certain threshold. The changes in vegetation structure caused by reseeding Elymus nutans can reduce pika densities, which may result from the increased risk of predation for pikas. However, whether the changes in community structure caused by reseeding of E. nutans is sufficient to alter the perceived predation risk for pikas, remains unknown. In this study, we measured the running speed (spontaneous without stimulation), alert distance (AD) and vigilance to a potential human predator in E. nutans habitat and open habitat by video review to assess perceived predation risk for plateau pikas in the two habitat types. Our results showed that body mass and habitat type influenced the running speed, group size and the habitat type influenced AD, and habitat type and group size influenced vigilance. The running speed of pikas was 1.67 times faster in the E. nutans compared to in open habitat, the AD of pikas was 1.79 times longer in the open than in the E. nutans habitat, and pikas were more vigilant in E. nutans than pikas in open habitat. The shorter AD indicates pikas have poor visibility due to higher vegetation height. The faster running speed and higher vigilance suggest a higher perceived predation risk for pikas in E. nutans habitat. Therefore, we believe that structural changes in vegetation following reseeding of E. nutans can increase the perceived predation risk for pikas, and could be responsible for the decrease in the pika population densities in these areas.
... Secondly, animals in risky habitats may adopt different behaviours to minimise the risk of mortality, for example by forming groups to dilute predation risk (Heithaus & Dill 2002) or by increasing vigilance (e.g. Cassini 1991). Such strategies may have an energetic cost for prey through increased intraspecific competition for food or the loss of foraging opportunities (Banks 2001). ...
Thesis
p>Previous work indicated that badger predation may regulate hedgehog populations and predicted that in areas where badgers are abundant, predation pressure would exclude hedgehogs from their preferred agricultural habitats. Surveys of hedgehogs in rural areas of England, carried out in the present study, confirmed this prediction and identified a negative spatial relationship between badger density and hedgehog occurrence and abundance in suburban micro-habitats, which are thought to provide hedgehogs with spatial refuges from predation. When badger abundance was reduced by culling, hedgehog population density in suburban micro-habitats doubled, while remaining unchanged in controls. The growth rate of hedgehog populations appeared to be negatively related to indices of badger abundance, indicative of top-down control by predation. There was evidence that hedgehog population growth rates were density dependent, potentially leading to two stable states of abundance according to the magnitude of predation. In the control treatment, a lower equilibrium population size indicated regulation by predators, whereas in areas where badgers were culled, an equilibrium population size some three times the density was observed. Predation risk may have influenced habitat use by hedgehogs. After badger culling, pastoral habitats were used more and suburban habitat less, although the effect was marginal. In combination with previous results, this study has provided evidence that predation by badgers determines the distribution and abundance of hedgehog populations and that spatial refugia, in the form of suburban micro-habitats, allow predator and prey to co-exist at a landscape scale.</p
... It would be the case of the Hyrax (Mares and Lacher, 1987), Procavia johnstoni, Marmota flaviventris (Blumstein and Armitage, 1997;Blumstein and Daniel, 2004;Bozinovic and Gallardo, 2006), gray squirrel (McRae and Green, 2017) and suricates (Manser, Seyfarth and Cheney, 2002). Hydrochoerus' habitat is open but more humid and forested than the mocó's Caatinga, and more like cavies (Cassini, 1991;Dias et al., 2020). ...
Article
Our knowledge about the acoustic behavior of Caviinae species drove us to investigate Kerodon rupestris’s (Caviidae: Hydrochoerinae) repertoire. This species is endemic to Caatinga and states as vulnerable in the Brazilian list of endangered species. We recorded sounds uttered by individuals from Santa Luzia, State of Paraíba, Brazil. We promoted interactions among 13 animals during intra and intersexual pairing sessions, under undisturbed interactions in captivity, and in free-living conditions. We found a repertoire of 13 call types, most of them (all except three) shared with Cavia and only five possibly shared also with Hydrochoerus: (1) Close contact and cohesion: tonal and noisy contact calls, tweet, slow-whistle; (2) Social regulation (incitement, subordination or auto-defense): whine, peep-squeak, yelp; (3) Offensive aggression and status display: roar, snort, and teeth-chattering (4) Warning or intimidation: alarm-whistle, drrr, and drumming; (5) Courtship: purr and slow-whistle. The similarity of Kerodon signals to Hydrochoerinae species, despite the ecological differences, needs to be understood in comparative phylogenetic studies tracing back the origin of the courtship display in Caviidae. Thus, future research should focus on playback studies to test signals' biological function hypothesis.
... It is a natural phenomenon of prey species in an ecosystem to seek protection from predation (Cowlishaw [16], Sih [17]). Refuge habitats are of different types, such as burrows, trees, cliff faces, or dense vegetation (Clarke et al. [18], Dill and Houtman [19], Berger [20], Cassine [21]). Coral reefs provide refuge for prey fish (Friedlander and Martine [22], Sandinet al. [23]). ...
Article
Full-text available
In this paper, we consider a predator-prey model incorporating fear and refuge. Our results show that the predator-free equilibrium is globally asymptotically stable if the ratio between the death rate of predators and the conversion rate of prey into predator is greater than the value of prey in refuge at equilibrium. We also show that the co-existence equilibrium points are locally asymptotically stable if the value of the prey outside refuge is greater than half of the carrying capacity. Numerical simulations show that when the intensity of fear increases, the fraction of the prey inside refuge increases; however, it has no effect on the fraction of the prey outside refuge, in the long run. It is shown that the intensity of fear harms predator population size. Numerical simulations show that the application of Z-control will force the system to reach any desired state within a limited time, whether the desired state is a constant state or a periodic state. Our results show that when the refuge size is taken to be a non-constant function of the prey outside refuge, the systems change their dynamics. Namely, when it is a linear function or an exponential function, the system always reaches the predator-free equilibrium. However, when it is taken as a logistic equation, the system reaches the co-existence equilibrium after long term oscillations.
... In social species, individuals live together and interact for a range of purposes, for example to facilitate reproduction (Schülke et al., 2010) and to increase foraging efficiency (Cassini, 1991) and predator avoidance (Ebensperger & Blumstein, 2006). Social structure results from behavioral interactions at the individual level (Whitehead, 2008). ...
Article
Full-text available
Social network analysis (SNA) has recently emerged as a fundamental tool to study animal behavior. While many studies have analyzed the relationship between environmental factors and behavior across large, complex animal populations, few have focused on species living in small groups due to limitations of the statistical methods currently employed. Some of the difficulties are often in comparing social structure across different sized groups and accounting for zero‐inflation generated by analyzing small social units. Here, we use a case study to highlight how Generalized Linear Mixed Models (GLMMs) and hurdle models can overcome the issues inherent to study of social network metrics of groups that are small and variable in size. We applied this approach to study aggressive behavior in the Alpine marmot (Marmota marmota) using an eight‐year long dataset of behavioral interactions across 17 small family groups (7.4 ± 3.3 individuals). We analyzed the effect of individual and group‐level factors on aggression, including predictors frequently inferred in species with larger groups, as the closely related yellow‐bellied marmot (Marmota flaviventris). Our approach included the use of hurdle GLMMs to analyze the zero‐inflated metrics that are typical of aggressive networks of small social groups. Additionally, our results confirmed previously reported effects of dominance and social status on aggression levels, thus supporting the efficacy of our approach. We found differences between males and females in terms of levels of aggression and on the roles occupied by each in agonistic networks that were not predicted in a socially monogamous species. Finally, we provide some perspectives on social network analysis as applied to small social groups to inform subsequent studies.
... No entanto, o conhecimento sobre a biologia de C. intermedia ainda é escasso, principalmente no que se refere à reprodução e à população, o que inviabiliza a aplicação da AVP. Estas análises necessitam de uma séria de dados biológicos e ambientais ainda não disponíveis (e.g., Brito & Fernandez, 2000;Lacy et al., 2005 Rood, 1972;Olimpio, 1991;Ximenez, 1980;Cassini, 1991;Cassini & Galante, 1992;Kraus & Rödel, 2004). Os outros dois possíveis predadores da lista de Bege & Pauli (1988), coruja-buraqueira (Speotyto cunicularia) e falcão-peregrino (Falco peregrinus), não foram observados na ilha durante o estudo. ...
Thesis
Full-text available
The study on Cavia intermedia allowed a theoretical and practical approach to one of the most important tools for species’ conservation, Population Viability Analysis (PVA), as well as the Island Syndrome, i.e. the set of characteristics manifested by rodent populations isolated on islands. The study took 17 months and it had a sample effort of 5542 trap-night. During the study, 144 individuals was marked and captured 689 times. C. intermedia showed most typical characteristics of its genus, such as offspring born well developed, poorly defined reproductive season and sexual dimorfism with bigger males. Other unusual characteristics of the genus coincided with those expected from the Island Syndrome, such as small littler size, delayed sexual maturity and small home range size. The population size and its structure (sex and age) were stable and its dynamics presented markedly density-dependence mortality. Although the average density of four individual/ha was higher than expected for an species of this genus, the number of individuals between 30 and 60 animals is small for the whole species and C. intermedia can be considered one of the rarest mammals of the World. According to official criteria, C. intermedia can be considered at the second most threatened category, “Endangered”, due to the probability of extinction higher than 20% in 20 years. However, it is convenient to consider C. intermedia at the most threatened category, “Critically Endangered”, so that has less than 50 mature individuals. Theoretically, random events can be a threat for the small populations’ persistence, but these risks may be overestimated and can bias the PVA results as observed. The preservation of C. intermedia’s habitat is one of the most effective options for its conservation and it should be prioritized, because it can mitigate its main threats as well as increase its persistence, rather than other more risky and uncertain options.
... Under this hypothesis there are progressively more eyes scanning the environment for predators as group size increases (Lima 1995). This enables individuals to spend a greater proportion of their time in other activities such as feeding as the per capita time spent engaged in vigilance decreases (Hoogland 1979a;Cassini 1991). ...
Thesis
In this thesis I investigate the impact of ecological factors on the costs and benefits of group living in a population of banded mongooses (Mungos mungo) in Queen Elizabeth National Park, Uganda, and test several of the theoretical predictions generated by reproductive skew models. Despite two earlier studies of this species, this represents the first comparative study examining the effects of ecological (food availability, predation pressure, potential for dispersal) and social factors on survival and reproduction. Breeding in the banded mongoose is egalitarian, with offspring raised communally. By assessing the effect of pack size on individual variation in body condition, reproduction and probability of dispersal, I show that optimal pack size varied with the differing costs and benefits of sociality in males and females. Males were competing more for mates, whilst females benefited from the availability of helpers. Individuals were more likely to disperse from large packs and animals were more likely to emigrate in groups rather than alone. Dominance rank did not affect the survival or reproduction of either sex and there was no evidence of reproductive suppression. These findings support the prediction of reproductive skew models which states that low skew within groups is expected when there are no substantial differences between fighting abilities of group members. Although predation risks were not different for individuals in large and small packs, the vigilance system was more costly for individuals living in small packs. The effect of temporal variation in food resources on reproduction and survival was limited, but varied according to the type of prey available. Large packs consistently had better access to richer food resources. They were also able to forage more efficiently when food abundance was low due to the advantages of co-operative foraging.
Article
To investigate the utility of ramps as enrichment and as a method for establishing demand for commodities, the latency to climb a ramp of increasing slope to obtain food was measured in four guinea pigs. The average height where guinea pigs failed to climb was 29.1 cm (slope 14.2 degrees). In addition, the increasing slope altered climbing behavior; when climbing speed was tested using the same slope for all trials within a single session, the guinea pigs maintained their climbing speed as the gradient increased across sessions. In comparison, when the slope was increased with each successful climb within a session, climbing speed was not maintained. Installing the maximum slope climbed can promote increased exercise and foraging but avoid physical harm or barriers to resources. Furthermore, these results indicate that climbing, a simple behavior with measurable differences as a function of slope and thus, effort, could be used as a method for testing the demand for commodities, such as food type or enrichment items, to be included in the husbandry of guinea pigs to improve welfare of the small cavy.
Article
Full-text available
Cavia tschudii inhabits coastal and Andean wetlands where it is important prey for medium carnivores, but its habitat selection and its role in the wetlands are unknown. In order to reduce this lack of knowledge, we evaluated changes in the abundance for two seasons and the habitat selection of C. tschudii in a wetland on the central coast of Peru. Additionally, we report information on their movement distances and provide comments on their predators. We carried out six evaluations during the autumn and spring of 2019, with nine grids in three plant communities: grassland, bulrush community, and cattail community. Each captured individual was marked with a numbered ear tag. We compared the relative abundance between seasons using the Mann-Whitney U test, and calculated the relative abundance per evaluated month and carried out regressions to model its behavior. The use/availability of habitat was evaluated with the Chi-square test together with Bonferroni confidence intervals to show habitat selection. Finally, we estimate the mean maximum distance moved (MMDM) of recaptured individuals. The results show significant differences between the seasons, with higher relative abundance in autumn. The relative abundance showed a peak in April, from which the values decrease. Likewise, we found significant differences in habitat selection, showing positive selection for the cattail community, neutral selection for the bulrush community, and negative selection for the grassland. The MMDM was 36.5 ± 15.7 m. We report a decrease in the relative abundance of C. tschudii, possibly related to seasonal changes in habitat quality or to the presence of predators. The peak of abundance in mid-autumn and the apparent decrease in the population until late spring resembles the annual dynamics reported for C. aperea. It is also confirmed that C. tschudii, like other Cavia, select environments with greater plant coverage, possibly as an anti-predation strategy. We report dogs predating C. tschudii and provide a list of other potential predators. This study increases the information on C. tschudii in coastal wetlands and gives a first approach to the necessary knowledge for its management and conservation within these fragile ecosystems.
Article
Full-text available
Use of space by small birds is strongly influenced by dense vegetation which serves as protection from attacking predators. Current evidence suggests that birds dependent upon such cover for safety will venture away from it only if their energy intake rate is significantly enhanced in doing so. Three species of Emberizidae (dark-eyed junco Junco hyemalis, song sparrow Melospiza melodia, rufous-sided towhee Pipilo erythrophthalmus) regularly fed well away from cover without a corresponding increase in energy intake rate. The birds perceived cover as both safety and a source of attacks: birds fed farther away from cover containing visual obstructions that might conceal predators lying in ambush. Use of space appeared to reflect a trade-off between the perceived risk of feeding too close to cover vs that of feeding too far away. This trade-off was also influenced by a bird's social environment; subordinate species fed farther from cover than dominant ones in an apparent effort to avoid direct aggression.-from Authors
Article
Full-text available
Examined the effects of predation hazard on patch-residence time and meal size (usually taken as foraging decisions), as well as on travel time, handling time, and the gain function (usually taken as constraints on foraging decisions). Sciurus carolinensis were presented with 8 artificial patches of sunflower seeds of the same initial density (either 25, 50, 100 or 200) at one distance to cover (either 5 or 15 m). Squirrels ate the same quantity of seeds farther from cover, but they ate them significantly faster. Squirrels also travelled significantly faster between patches, and handled seeds significantly faster within patches when farther from cover. The change in the handling times caused the squirrels' gain functions to be higher farther from cover. -from Authors
Article
Full-text available
Foraging by screaming hairy armadillos, Chaetophractus vellerosus, and guinea pigs, Cavia porcellus, was studied in the laboratory. The main question was whether patch exploitation varies with overall capture rate as predicted by the marginal value theorem (MVT). Armadillos in experiment I and guinea pigs in experiment II experienced a single travel time between depleting patches of two kinds: good and poor. There were two treatments, which differed in the quality of poor patches. MVT predicts that within a treatment, more prey should be taken from good than from poor patches and between treatments, good patches should be exploited in inverse relation to the quality of poor patches and poor patches should be exploited in direct relation to their own quality. In experiment III, guinea pigs experienced three treatments which differed in the travel requirement, while the two patch types remained the same. MVT predicts that within a treatment more prey should be taken from good than from poor patches and that between treatments more prey should be taken from both patch types as travel requirement increases. The qualitative predictions were supported in the three experiments. The quantitative fit was good but there was a bias towards more severe patch exploitation than predicted. The results indicate that in these species patch exploitation depends on overall food availability as predicted by the MVT when overall food availability differs either because of patch type composition or because of differences in travel requirement between patches.
Article
Trapping and banding of wintering juncos and golden-crowned sparrows was carried out from 1964 to 1968 along the opposite edges of an old field. The juncos ranged freely along the field borders but the golden-crowns were largely restricted to dense willow thickets in one part of the field. An attempt to assess possible competition between the two species by removing juncos in 1966-67 was unsuccessful because of infiltration of new birds from outside the study area. Removal of golden-crowns in 1967-68 reduced their population markedly and resulted in significant increase in use of the willow thickets by juncos. Although juncos are primarily seed eaters in winter, and seeds are a steadily dwindling resource at that season, competition for food between the two species was alleviated because the sparrows subsisted in large part on sprouting annuals, a resource renewed continuously after sprouting started following the fall rains. Further, the green food eaten by the sparrows undoubtedly satisfied their water requirements to a great extent and reduced competition for water sources. The competition demonstrated by removal experiments resulted not from direct competition for the same set of resources but from the proximity of a water trough, an important junco resource, to the heavy cover preferred by the sparrows. Although outnumbered about 5:2, the larger sparrows were able to exclude the juncos from this cover to an appreciable extent.
Article
In this paper I present data collected to test certain predictions arising from the hypothesis that colonial nesting and social feeding in birds are adaptations that enhance the efficiency of exploitation of unpredictable food supplies. The hypothesis suggests that individuals benefit from nesting in colonies because they have the opportunity to learn about good feeding areas by following other birds from the nesting colony to the feeding grounds. If a bird is unsuccessful on one foraging trip, it will observe and follow more successful birds on subsequent trips; in this way the colony acts as an 'information centre'. I collected two types of data to test this idea as applied to the Great Blue Heron (Ardea herodias). (i) I recorded flights of parent birds. (ii) I measured the rate of food intake of birds hunting for food in flocks of different sizes. The analysis of foraging flights from the colony showed the following: (a) The birds used different feeding grounds on different days; this suggests that the food supply is ephemeral. (b) The birds tended to leave the colony in groups, which would be expected if they were following each other. (c) Birds from neighbouring nests tended to use the same feeding grounds and tended to leave the colony in groups (within the overall grouping of the colony as a whole). This would be expected if birds mainly copy their near neighbours. All these results support the idea of an information centre. I did not collect any data on whether successful birds were being followed by unsuccessful ones, but the data do seem to show that birds follow one another. On the feeding grounds, I showed by use of models that herons are attracted to feed in areas where there are other birds, and that they are more attracted by a group than by a single bird. If flock feeding helps in locating good feeding places, we can expect that flock birds would do better in terms of food intake than solitary individuals. A step-wise multiple regression showed that rate of food intake of a bird (grams of fish caught per minute) is an asymptotic function of flock size. A bird in a flock of 20 gets about 5 times as much food per minute as a solitary bird. Further, the percent success (i.e. strikes resulting in a capture) is higher in flocks, and the coefficient of variation of feeding rate is lower. Thus flock birds get more food for relatively less effort and stand a smaller chance of doing very badly in terms of food intake. I discuss various possible explanations of the advantage of the flock birds, and conclude that it is not a result of searching harder, less 'nervousness' of predators or stirring up the fish to make them easy to catch. It is a consequence of the fact that flocks only build up where feeding conditions are good. I present a simple graphical model to show how this happens. In conclusion, my results support the idea that colonial nesting and social feeding are adaptations concerned with finding food, but there are also other factors involved in the evolution of sociality in ardeids and other birds.
Article
Wild ostriches were observed while feeding alone or in groups of up to four birds, and their vigilance (proportion of time with the head up) recorded. Individual vigilance declined as group size increased, mainly through a decrease in the frequency with which the head was raised. Males were more vigilant than females, mainly because they kept their heads up for longer. Vigilance was influenced more by the presence than by the vigilance of a companion. When a head would stay down for a long time was impossible for a predator to predict. It is concluded that grouping by ostriches when feeding results in only a slight reduction in the group's vulnerability to successful predator attack, but in a considerable decrease in individual vulnerability.
Article
Foraging flocks of granivorous Yellow-eyed Juncos (Junco phaeonotus) were studied for two winters to test hypothesized relationships between group size and time budgets. Required feeding time is so large that it constrains aggression. At low temperatures (high foraging requirements) a large flock forms in the area of maximal food availability. Group size decreases at warmer temperatures, since the constraints on aggression are reduced. Group size variance responds similarly. As group size increases, individuals scan less often for approaching predators. The time saved is employed to increase feeding rates, unless aggression levels are extremely high. Rates of aggressive interaction increase with group size, and with both ambient temperature and food density. Dominants apparently forage more efficiently than subordinates because of differences in habitat utilization and time allocation. These differences are consistent with the hypothesized correlation between increasing dominance and greater overwinter survivorship.