ArticlePDF Available

Performance analysis and testing of a 250 kW medium-speed brushless doubly-fed induction generator

Wiley
IET Renewable Power Generation
Authors:

Abstract and Figures

This study presents the performance analysis and testing of a 250 kW medium-speed brushless doubly-fed induction generator (DFIG), and its associated power electronics and control systems. The experimental tests confirm the design, and show the system's steady-state and dynamic performance and grid low-voltage ride-through capability. The medium-speed brushless DFIG in combination with a simplified two-stage gearbox promises a low-cost low-maintenance and reliable drivetrain for wind turbine applications.
Content may be subject to copyright.
Published in IET Renewable Power Generation
Received on 13th September 2012
Revised on 22nd February 2013
Accepted on 12th April 2013
doi: 10.1049/iet-rpg.2012.0234
ISSN 1752-1416
Performance analysis and testing of a 250 kW
medium-speed brushless doubly-fed induction
generator
Ehsan Abdi1, Richard McMahon2, Paul Malliband1, Shiyi Shao1, Mmamolatelo Ezekiel
Mathekga2, Peter Tavner1,3, Salman Abdi2, Ashknaz Oraee2, Teng Long2, Mark Tatlow1
1
Wind Technologies Ltd., Cambridge Science Park, Cambridge CB4 0EY, UK
2
Electrical Engineering Division, Cambridge University, 9 JJ Thomson Avenue, Cambridge CB3 0FA, UK
3
School of Engineering, Durham University, South Road, Durham DH1 3LE, UK
E-mail: ehsan.abdi@windtechnologies.com
Abstract: This study presents the performance analysis and testing of a 250 kW medium-speed brushless doubly-fed induction
generator (DFIG), and its associated power electronics and control systems. The experimental tests conrm the design, and show
the systems steady-state and dynamic performance and grid low-voltage ride-through capability. The medium-speed brushless
DFIG in combination with a simplied two-stage gearbox promises a low-cost low-maintenance and reliable drivetrain for wind
turbine applications.
1 Introduction
The brushless doubly-fed induction generator (DFIG), also
known as the brushless doubly-fed machine (BDFM), is an
alternative to the well-established DFIG for use in wind
turbines [1]. The brushless DFIG retains the benetof
utilising a partially rated converter, but offers higher
reliability, and hence lower cost of ownership, than the
DFIG because of absence of brush gear and slip-rings [2].
In addition, the brushless DFIG is intrinsically a
medium-speed machine, enabling the use of a simplied
one or two-stage gearbox; hence, reducing the cost and
weight of the overall drivetrain and further improving
reliability [3]. A schematic of the brushless DFIG drivetrain
is shown in Fig. 1.
In most countries, there is now a requirement that wind
turbines stay connected and supply reactive current to the
grid during voltage dips [4]. In doubly-fed machines, the
stator ux is exposed directly to the grid and any voltage
dips will result in a sudden loss of magnetisation,
producing a current surge in the machine side converter [5].
This current is typically large and without appropriate
control strategies and, in most cases, additional hardware
such as a crowbar may cause damage to the converter [6].
The use of crowbar increases system cost and limits
reactive current injection dynamics.
In contrast, the brushless DFIG has been shown to have a
superior low-voltage ride-through (LVRT) capability
without a need for additional hardware [7]. It has an
intrinsically larger seriesinductance, and hence
experiences a reduced transient current in the machine side
inverter (MSI) than that of an equivalent DFIG [8]. As a
result, the system cost can be reduced and the MSI can be
utilised to support the supply of reactive current during the
entire fault cycle; hence, giving fast dynamics.
To date, several groups have reported experimental brushless
DFIGs [1, 915] and there have been attempts to construct
machines of higher power to conrm the machines
suitability for MW power applications [12, 13, 15], but few
details of machine performance have been published.
The modern brushless DFIG concept as a variable speed
drive or generator comprises two electrically separate stator
windings, one connected directly to the mains, called the
power winding (PW), and the other supplied from a
variable voltage and frequency converter, called the control
winding (CW). The pole numbers of the two stator
windings are chosen so as to avoid direct coupling and a
special rotor design is used to couple between the two
stator windings, the nested-loop design being commonly
used [1]. The machine therefore contains three
magnetomotive forces (MMFs), the rst in the stator
directly supplied from the mains, the second in the stator
supplied from the converter and the third induced in the
rotor. The normal mode of operation of the brushless DFIG
is as a synchronous machine with the rotor rotating at a
speed determined by the winding pole numbers and the
mains and converter frequencies.
The design of the brushless DFIG is not straightforward as
there are more variables to consider than in a conventional
induction machine. The rotor design has a crucial affect on
the performance of the brushless DFIG and its turns ratio
determines the relative magnitude of the two main uxes.
The uneven distribution of rotor-loop currents in the widely
used nested-loop design makes the evaluation of the electric
www.ietdl.org
IET Renew. Power Gener., pp. 18 1
doi: 10.1049/iet-rpg.2012.0234 &The Institution of Engineering and Technology 2013
loading difcult. The denition of specic magnetic loading
in the brushless DFIG is not straightforward because of the
presence of two main elds with different magnitudes and
frequencies. In addition, the optimal allocation of electric
and magnetic loadings between the two stator windings is
not trivial. The analyses presented by the authors in [1]
describe how the above issues can be addressed.
Nevertheless, attempts have been made to manufacture
large brushless DFIGs, beginning in Brazil with the 75 kW
machine of Carlson et al. [12] and more recently in China
with the design of a 200 kW machine by Liu and Xu [13].
The authorsown work on a 20 kW brushless DFIG has
conrmed that a brushless DFIG can be designed to a
specication to work in a wind turbine an important part
was the implementation of an effective controller for the
machine, which is unstable in the open loop over the
normally used wind turbine speed range [14]. More than
three yearsoperational experience with this turbine has
given condence in the proposition of a large scale
brushless DFIG; the 250 kW machine was conceived as a
stepping-stone towards a megawatt (MW) scale brushless
DFIG wind turbine.
2 Generator specification and design
As noted above, the rating of the machine was chosen as an
intermediate step between the 20 kW machine described in
[14] and a machine of 3 MW. The size chosen involves
construction and winding techniques appropriate to larger
machines.
Earlier studies have shown that a two-stage gearbox and a
brushless DFIG form a highly reliable combination [2] and
that a 4/8 pole brushless DFIG is a reasonable generator
choice, having a natural speed of 500 rev/min when the CW
is fed with DC. To allow for the range of speeds
experienced in a typical wind turbine, the speed range was
set to be 320680 rev/min, corresponding to a converter
output of ± 18 Hz. This implies a minimum converter
rating of 36% of the total output, that is, 90 kW for a
250 kW generator [1]. However, allowance must be made
for magnetising current, power factor compensation and an
overhead for proper operation of a controller. The stator PW
voltage was set at 690 V in conformity with current large
wind turbine practice.
4 and 8 pole windings were adopted for the power and
CWs, respectively, as this arrangement has the benetof
offering a range of speeds around the natural speed
unconstrained by the limit imposed by the synchronous
speed of the lower pole number winding, 750 rev/min in
this case. The nested-loop type of rotor fabricated with
solid conductors was adopted. This approach gives a good
slot ll factor and does not encounter signicant skin effect
issues for the bar size used.
The speed of a brushless DFIG is given by
N=60 f1+f2
p1+p2
(1)
where f
1
and f
2
are PW and CW supply frequencies and p
1
and
p
2
are their pole pair numbers, respectively. Combinations of
pole numbers for the two windings are chosen to avoid direct
transformer coupling. Consideration was given to 2/6, 2/8, 4/8
and 2/10 combinations; the 4/8 arrangement was adopted as it
had been successfully used previously [14] and as it gives a
speed in the desired range. The natural speed of a brushless
DFIG is given by
N=60 f1
p1+p2
(2)
This equates to 500 rev/min for a 4/8 machine. The range of
speeds is determined from wind turbine practice and is 320
680 rev/min.
The design procedure is shown schematically in Fig. 2.
During the rst stage, an analytical approach in conjunction
with equivalent circuit analysis [16] was employed to
achieve initial designs against machine specications.
Fig. 2 Design procedure for the brushless DFIG system
Fig. 1 Brushless DFIG drivetrain
Table 1 Brushless DFIG specifications
frame size 400
speed range 500 rev/min ± 36%
rated torque 3670 Nm
rated power 250 kW at 680 rev/min
PW pole number 4
PW rated voltage 690 V (50 Hz, delta)
PW rated current 178 A (line)
stack length 0.82 m
IP class IP55
efficiency (full load) >95%
CW pole number 8
CW rated voltage 620 V (18 Hz, delta)
CW rated current 73 A (line)
www.ietdl.org
2IET Renew. Power Gener., pp. 18
&The Institution of Engineering and Technology 2013 doi: 10.1049/iet-rpg.2012.0234
Discussion with the machine manufacturer was essential to
incorporate construction practicalities in the design.
Subsequently, these designs were analysed using
coupled-circuit analysis as a cross-check and to give a more
accurate assessment of the nested-loop rotor [17]. Finally,
designs were veried using nite element (FE) analysis. In
particular, this yields two important outputs, namely the
peak ux densities in the iron and a better estimate of
magnetising current. The last stage was to assess the system
performance, including dynamics, control and stability and
LVRT, which led to nal adjustments to the design.
3 Machine and test rig construction
The nal design was constructed at ATB Laurence Scott as a
frame size 400 machine with a stack length of 820 mm. The
frame was a type normally used for totally enclosed fan
cooled motors. As the brushless DFIG is a variable speed
machine, a fan with its own drive motor was tted to
ensure effective cooling at all speeds. The stator windings
were form-wound from copper strip. The PW was rated at
690 V, 178 A at 50 Hz and the CW was designed for 620 V
at 18 Hz and rated at 73 A. Both stator windings were
Fig. 3 Brushless DFIG system and its test rig
aSchematic of the test rig
b250 kW brushless DFIG (right front) on test bed
cConverter, comprising GSI (on the left) and MSI (on the right)
dMeasurement electronics, Bluetooth transmitter and rechargeable batteries installed on the rotor shaft [18]
www.ietdl.org
IET Renew. Power Gener., pp. 18 3
doi: 10.1049/iet-rpg.2012.0234 &The Institution of Engineering and Technology 2013
connected in delta. The rotor comprised six sets of nests each
with multiple loops, the conductors being solid bars with one
common end ring. The machine specications are shown in
Table 1. The machine was instrumented extensively to
allow assessment of its performance. The stator was tted
with sixteen temperature sensors and duplicate sets of 4-
and 8-pole ux search coils and search coils around stator
teeth and back iron.
The rotor was also tted with temperature sensors and tooth
ux search coils, and Rogowski coils for measuring rotor bar
currents. The signals from the rotor sensors, following
amplication and ltering, are digitised and transmitted via
Bluetooth to a static receiver. The electronics on the rotor
are powered by a rechargeable battery [18]. The electronic
hardware installed on the shaft is shown in Fig. 3.
The stator CW is fed from an ACAC converter comprising
a grid side inverter (GSI), which is an off-the-shelf Control
TechniquesUnidrive SP6601, and a MSI, which is a
Semikron full-bridge Semistack SKS 84F. The GSI has a
built-in controller, which stabilises the DC-link voltage. The
MSI does not have a built-in controller and its gate drives
are controlled by PWM signals provided by the control
system described below. The converter has specications
provided in Table 2 and is shown in Fig. 3.
Following initial acceptance tests, the machine was set up
at the manufacturers facility in the arrangement shown in
Fig. 3. The brushless DFIG was driven via a torque
transducer by a 355 kW 8-pole ABB induction motor fed
from a 400 kW ABB ACS800 inverter. The torque
transducer has an accuracy of 0.1% when measuring
4000 Nm. The PW was connected to the mains through a
690/415 V step-down transformer and the CW was supplied
from the converter. Speed and position signals are obtained
from an incremental encoder with a resolution of 10 000
pulses per revolution. The voltages and currents of each
stator phase are measured by LEM AV100-750 and LEM
LA 205/305-s transducers, respectively, with corresponding
accuracies of 1.5 and 0.8%.
For normal operation, the brushless DFIG operates in
synchronous mode and a controller is needed to ensure stable
operation over the whole of the desired speed range. A vector
controller [19], implemented in a real-time hardware, was
used for this purpose. To achieve effective control, rapid
updating of the frequency and voltage is necessary. As
normal industry standard converter interfaces do not allow
this, the machine side Semikron inverter was controlled by
gate control signals emanating from the real-time controller,
which takes signals from the encoder, voltage and current
transducers described above. The whole test system was
computer controlled. Operation in synchronous, cascade and
simple induction modes was possible and transition to the
synchronous mode was automatic. For more details about the
various operating modes, see [1, 16].
4 Experimental verification of performance
The tests described in Table 3 were carried out to conrm the
output of the machine and to measure losses and efciency at
various speeds and driving torques, the ultimate being
conrmation of the rating through temperature rise
measurements on both the stator and rotor. The
conrmation of the stability of the controller and machine
capability to ride through grid faults was also an aim.
4.1 Magnetic ux measurements
In order to verify the magnetic design and assess saturation
effects in the iron circuit, stator and rotor ux densities
were measured using ux search coils installed around the
teeth and back iron. Fig. 4 shows the measured stator tooth
ux density compared with predictions from the FE
analysis. The machine was run at 650 rev/min and full load.
The stator windings were supplied at their rated voltages,
hence nominal ux density in the iron circuit was expected.
As can be seen from Fig. 4, the peak ux density in the
tooth is around 1.75 T, which is close to the design
specication of 1.8 T. The predictions from the FE analysis
are in agreement with the measured results.
4.2 Machine parameters extraction
The equivalent circuit model is a simple method for
representing the steady-state performance of the BDFM
[16]. Since the meaning of the parameters has a clear
Table 3 Description of the tests carried out on the brushless
DFIG
Test Description
1 magnetising test tests were carried out in induction
mode at no load, synchronous speed
to derive the magnetising reactances.
Each stator winding was excited in
turn whereas the other left open
2 parameter extraction tests were carried out in the cascade
mode to derive the machine
equivalent circuit parameters
3 steady-state tests tests were carried out at no load, ¼,
½, ¾ and full load conditions and at
different speeds and reactive powers
and steady-state performance of the
machine was recorded
4 long-run temperature
rise tests
the machine was run at full load
condition at the rated speed for a
long time and the stator and rotor
windings temperature rise was
recorded
5 dynamic tests the controller performance and
stability was tested under different
conditions by varying the PW real
and reactive powers
6 LVRT tests several grid fault conditions were
applied to the test rig and the
performance of the system was
assessed
Table 2 Converter specifications
Specifications for the GSI
type control techniques unidrive SP6601
rated voltage, rms 690 V
frequency 50 Hz
rated current, rms 100 A
over-load current, rms 125 A
over-load power 110 kW
Specifications for the MSI
type Semikron Semistack SKS 84F
rated current, rms 84 A (T
amb
= 35°C)
switching frequency 10 kHz
DC-link capacitance 5880 μF/1100 V
DC-link rated voltage 1000 V
cooling fan
thermal trip 71°C
www.ietdl.org
4IET Renew. Power Gener., pp. 18
&The Institution of Engineering and Technology 2013 doi: 10.1049/iet-rpg.2012.0234
physical interpretation, the model is useful for understanding
the design and optimisation of the machine. The equivalent
circuit model offers a straightforward way of calculating the
efciency, power factor and other steady-state measures of
the machine to a practical accuracy.
One form of the equivalent circuit for the BDFM is shown
in Fig. 5, where all the parameters are referred to the PW [16].
s
1
and s
2
are the power and CWs slips and are dened as
s1W
v
1p1
v
r
v
1
(3)
s2W
v
2p2
v
r
v
2
(4)
where ω
1
and ω
2
are angular frequencies of the supplies to the
PW and CW, respectively, and ω
r
is the rotor mechanical
angular velocity.
The parameters of the equivalent circuit model can be
calculated from the machine geometry at the design stage
using the method described in [17]. The accuracy of these
calculations depends on having good physical data for the
machine. In particular, it is hard to obtain precise estimates
of certain parameters such as the leakage reactances of
end-windings.
The equivalent circuit parameters can also be extracted
from experimental tests using curve-tting methods as
described in [16]. Using the parameter values estimated
from experimental tests lead to more accurate predictions.
In order to extract machine parameters, experimental tests
were performed in the cascade and induction modes of
operation and the parameters were obtained using a
curve-tting method, except the stator winding resistances
that were obtained from DC measurements. The estimated
machine parameters from experiments are shown in Table 4.
4.3 Efciency measurements
The efciency of the machine measured over a range of
output powers is shown in Fig. 6. The maximum efciency
at each load was obtained by adjusting the CW excitation.
As can be seen, an efciency of more than 95% is achieved
over a wide range of operations, which is competitive with
commercial machines of this size. The highest efciency is
96.1 at 60% load. The stator winding temperature during
the test was measured at 70°C. The variation of efciency
against load shown in Fig. 6 is similar to that of a typical
induction machine, in that higher efciency is achieved at
partial loads.
Fig. 7ashows the variation of efciency over a wide range
of PW reactive powers when the machine was operating at
650 rev/min, 240 kW. The control system varied the PW
reactive power from 0.06 to 0.76 p.u. The negative sign
indicates generating reactive power. The machines
efciency change is not signicant, within the range 94
95.5%. The corresponding PW power factor is shown in
Fig. 7b, which indicates that unity power factor operation
can be achieved.
Fig. 4 Measured and predicted (by FE) stator tooth ux density
Fig. 5 Per-phase equivalent circuit for the BDFM [16]
Table 4 Parameter values for the equivalent circuit
R
1
,ΩL
m1
,mH R
r
,ΩL
r
,mH R
2
,ΩL
m2
,mH
0.097 104 0.114 12.5 0.102 53
Fig. 6 Measured efciency of brushless DFIG at different loads
Fig. 7 Variation of efciency with PW reactive power variation
aMachine efciency variation with PW reactive power
bPower factor variation with PW reactive power
www.ietdl.org
IET Renew. Power Gener., pp. 18 5
doi: 10.1049/iet-rpg.2012.0234 &The Institution of Engineering and Technology 2013
4.4 Long-run temperature rise measurement
The temperature rise of the machine under various loading
conditions was explored. The stator windings temperature
rises when the machine was operating at full load and
680 rev/min is shown in Fig. 8. The PW reactive power was
controlled to be 105 kVAr, so that the currents in both
stator windings were at nominal values. The stator
temperature rise is 105 K, with about a 15 K difference
between the two windings. The stator temperature rise is
within specication for the insulation. This conrms that
the nominal rating of 250 kW is achieved.
4.5 Control system dynamic performance
The control system is able to control the real and reactive
power of the PW under a rapid and stable dynamic
transient, as required in wind turbine applications. In order
to examine the dynamic performance of the control system,
a full power change was applied to the machine whereas the
rotor speed was set via the load machine at 680 rev/min.
The PW real power (P
1
) was changed from 0 to 185 kW
(full load) at the rate of 100 kW/s, equivalent to the total
machines output power of 250 kW. The rate of change was
limited by the converter DC-link voltage, since at 680 rev/
min, most of its capacity is already occupied. In fact, in
practical wind turbine applications, the rate of change of
real power is believed to be modest and well below than
that of implemented in the tests [20]. The PW reactive
power (Q
1
) was held constant at 150 kVAr. The results are
shown in Fig. 9. As can be seen from the results, there is
good agreement between the simulation and experimental
results and the required dynamic performance is achieved.
4.6 LVRT tests
The grid code by E.ON was utilised as a reference for
assessing the performance of the brushless DFIG system
under grid low-voltage faults. During symmetrical
low-voltage faults, according to the grid code, wind
turbines are required to: (a) ride through a period of zero
voltage up to 0.15 s and a further period of grid voltage
recovery up to 1.35 s and (b) inject reactive current at
nominal value to the grid during the entire 1.5 s
low-voltage fault [7].
As part of the testing programme, the performance of the
brushless DFIG under grid fault conditions was explored.
Several fault conditions including symmetrical and
asymmetrical faults were examined. Details of the
modelling, control approach and experimental results for
symmetrical grid faults are provided in [7]. No additional
hardware such as crowbar was utilised during the grid fault
tests. The symmetrical three-phase fault often represents the
most severe conditions on the converter current and
therefore results shown in this paper present the brushless
DFIG performance under these conditions.
A fault emulator comprising an auto-transformer and a
number of programmable logic controller (PLC) controlled
contactors were utilised to create zero-voltage fault, that is,
short circuit on the PW. The GSI was connected to the grid
during the LVRT tests to stabilise the DC-link voltage. The
aim of the test was therefore to assess the brushless DFIG
dynamics and performance of the MSI controller [7].
The test results for the LVRT performance of the brushless
DFIG system with a symmetrical three-phase short-circuit are
shown in Fig. 10. The machine was run at 625 rev/min and its
nominal load. A short-circuit fault occurs at t= 1 s, lasting for
2 s. As can be seen from Fig. 10, the surge current in the stator
Fig. 8 Temperature rise of stator windings at full load
Fig. 9 Dynamic performance of the control system, when a full real power change is applied
www.ietdl.org
6IET Renew. Power Gener., pp. 18
&The Institution of Engineering and Technology 2013 doi: 10.1049/iet-rpg.2012.0234
CW is lower than 2 p.u. of the IGBTsrated current; hence no
active compensation voltage was required. Typically,
commercial converters are able to handle transient currents
as large as 2 p.u. of their nominal rating [21]. Without the
obligation of reducing the surge current, the converter is
fully able to provide reactive current. Prior to the fault, the
real current in the PW is at its nominal value and the
reactive current is controlled to be zero, that is, the PW is
operating at its nominal rating with unity power factor.
When the short-circuit fault occurs at t= 1 s, the fault
detector triggers an LVRT controller and a pair of new
targets including rated reactive current and zero real current,
is set [7]. The proposed control loop is able to achieve
these targets with a fast response, less than 40 ms.
The MSI currents were within limits showing that grid
ride through is possible without additional measures or
signicantly over-rating of the converter. The LVRT tests
were independently witnessed and a certicate issued to
conrm compliance with grid codes.
5 Conclusions
Tests have conrmed correct brushless DFIG operation, with
currents and ux densities close to expected values. The
250 kW brushless DFIG is, to the best of the authors
belief, the largest machine of this type ever constructed.
Several modelling approaches have been used during the
design process, including an equivalent circuit model to
perform preliminary optimisation of the design, a
coupled-circuit approach to improve equivalent circuit
parameter values and to verify dynamic behaviour including
harmonic effects and the time-stepping FE model to
conrm the machines magnetic behaviour and to obtain
corrections for saturation and harmonic effects.
Testing the 250 kW BDFIG shows that expected
performance is achieved and that the machine can be
controlled stably. CW converter requirements are as
predicted. No undue harmonic components were present in
the stator currents. A direct comparison with the DFIG is
hard as there is very little information on DFIG parameters
available in the literature as DFIGs are usually made
specically for a particular wind turbine builder.
Differences in speed range further complicate the comparison.
The methods of construction employed in building the
brushless DFIG, such as form-wound stator coils, are
generally suitable for larger machines. The totally enclosed
fan cooled (TEFC) frame was chosen as it was conveniently
available, but would not be used in a MW scale machine
that would have ducted cooling. It is possible that
form-wound coils, instead of solid bars, would be used for
the rotor to limit the consequences of skin effect.
The most important conclusion is that a large scale
brushless DFIG is practical and is scalable upwards. The
Fig. 10 Experimental LVRT performance of brushless DFIG system; the converter current and voltage are the line values; the PW dq currents
are the peak values
www.ietdl.org
IET Renew. Power Gener., pp. 18 7
doi: 10.1049/iet-rpg.2012.0234 &The Institution of Engineering and Technology 2013
brushless DFIG offers brushless operation, reduced converter
ratings and does not need any expensive magnets. Recent
work indicates that a signicant reduction in operational
cost is possible, using a brushless DFIG and this will feed
through to a lower cost of energy.
6 Acknowledgment
The authors would like to acknowledge funding support
from the Carbon Trust.
7 References
1 McMahon, R., Wang, X., Abdi, E., Tavner, P., Roberts,
P., Jagiela, M.: The BDFM as a generator in wind
turbines. Power Electronics and Motion Control
Conf., Portoroz, Slovenia, 2006, pp. 18591865
2 Tavner, P.J., Higgins, A., Arabian, H., Long, H., Feng,
Y.: Using an FMEA method to compare prospective
wind turbine design reliabilities. European Wind
Energy Conf. 2010 Technical Track, Warsaw, Poland,
April 2010
3 Polinder, H., van der Pijl, F.F.A., de Vilder, G.-J.,
Tavner, P.J.: Comparison of direct-drive and geared
generator concepts for wind turbines,IEEE Trans.
Energy Convers., 2006, 21, (3), pp. 725733
4 Piwko, R., Miller, N., Girad, R., MacDowell, J., Clark,
K.: Generator fault tolerance and grid codes,IEEE
Power Energy Mag., 2010, 8, (2), pp. 1826
5 Morren, J., de Haan, S.W.H.: Short-circuit current of
wind turbines with doubly fed induction generator,
IEEE Trans. Energy Convers., 2007, 22, (1), pp.
174180
6 Seman, S., Niiranen, J., Kanerva, S.: Performance study
of a doubly fed wind-power induction generator under
network disturbances,IEEE Trans. Energy Convers.,
2006, 21, (4), pp. 883890
7 Long, T., Shao, S., Abdi, E., et al:Symmetrical low
voltage ride-through of a 250 kW brushless DFIG.
Sixth IET Int. Conf. Power Electronics, Machines and
Drives (PEMD), Bristol, UK, March 2012, pp. 16
8 Shao, S., Abdi, E., McMahon, R.: Dynamic analysis of
the brushless doubly-fed induction generator during
symmetrical three-phase voltage dips. Int. Conf.
Power Electronics and Drive Systems (PEDS), Taipei,
Taiwan, November 2009, pp. 464469
9 Boger, M., Wallace, A., Spee, R., Li, R.: General pole
number model of the brushless doubly-fed machine,
IEEE Trans. Ind. Appl., 1995, 31, (5), pp. 10221028
10 Williamson, S., Ferreira, A.C.: Generalised theory of
the brushless doubly-fed machine. Part 2: model
verication and performance,IET Proc. Electr. Power
Appl., 1997, 144, pp. 123129
11 Poza, J., Oyarbide, E., Sarasola, I., Rodriguez, M.:
Vector control design and experimental evaluation for
the brushless doubly fed machine,IET Proc. Electr.
Power Appl., 2009, 3, (4), pp. 247256
12 Carlson, R., Voltolini, H., Runcos, F., Kuo-Peng, P.,
Baristela, N.: Performance analysis with power factor
compensation of a 75 kW brushless doubly fed
induction generator prototype. IEEE Int. Conf.
Electric Machines & Drives, Antalya, Turkey, May
2007, vol. 2, pp. 15021507
13 Liu, H., Xu, L.: Design and performance analysis of a
doubly excited brushless machine for wind power
generator application. IEEE Int. Symp. Power
Electronics for Distributed Generation Systems, Hefei,
China, June 2010, pp. 597601
14 Logan, T., Warrington, J., Shao, S., McMahon, R.:
Practical deployment of the brushless doubly-fed
machine in a medium scale wind turbine. Int. Conf.
Power Electron. Drive Syst., 2009, pp. 470475
15 McMahon, R.A., Abdi, E., Malliband, P.D., Shao, S.,
Mathekga, M.E., Tavner, P.J.: Design and testing of a
250 kW medium-speed brushless DFIG. Sixth IET
Int. Conf. Power Electronics, Machines and Drives
(PEMD), Bristol, UK, March 2012, pp. 16
16 Roberts, P.C., McMahon, R.A., Tavner, P.J.,
Maciejowski, J.M., Flack, T.J.: Equivalent circuit for
the brushless doubly fed machine (BDFM) including
parameter estimation and experimental verication,
IET Proc. Electr. Power Appl., 2005, 152, (4), pp.
933942
17 Roberts, P.C.: A study of brushless doubly-fed
(induction) machines. PhD thesis, University of
Cambridge, 2004
18 Abdi, E., McMahon, R.A.: Application of real-time
rotor current measurements using Bluetooth wireless
technology in study of the brushless doubly-fed
(induction) machine (BDFM). Industry Applications
Society (IAS) Annual Conf., California, USA, October
2006, pp. 15571561
19 Shao, S., Abdi, E., Barati, F., McMahon, R.:
Stator-ux-oriented vector control for brushless
doubly fed induction generator,IEEE Trans. Ind.
Electron., 2009, 56, (10), pp. 42204228
20 Muller, S., Deicke, M., De Doncker, R.W.: Doubly fed
induction generator systems for wind turbines,IEEE
Ind. Appl. Mag., 2002, 8, (3), pp. 2633
21 Xiang, D., Ran, L., Tavner, P.J., Yang, S.: Control of a
doubly fed induction generator in a wind turbine during
grid fault ride-through,IEEE Trans. Energy Convers.,
2006, 21, (3), pp. 652662
www.ietdl.org
8IET Renew. Power Gener., pp. 18
&The Institution of Engineering and Technology 2013 doi: 10.1049/iet-rpg.2012.0234
... The two machines were integrated into a single enclosure with a cage rotor and a special combination of pole pairs to obtain a BDFIM. The results of tests on a 250 kW machine are reported in [12]. ...
... From (10), the complex stator and rotor currents are = 11 + 12 , = 21 + 22 (12) where ( 11 12 ...
... The complex current command is obtained using (17), and the currents and are computed from (12). The voltage is obtained from the second equation of (10). ...
Article
Brushless doubly-fed induction machines offer a potential alternative to regular doubly-fed induction generators for wind turbines, due to higher reliability and lower maintenance costs. As motors and generators, the brushless machines could also be part of new technological solutions for hybrid-electric propulsion, including aircraft propulsion. A main advantage is that most of the power would be transferred from generators to motors without electronic conversion. The paper proposes a new speed control algorithm that maximizes the available torque within the limits of the control winding currents and ensures anti-windup protection. The maximum torque and the control variables are obtained through simple analytical computations. The derivations of the paper are based on a complex-variable representation that simplifies the mathematical model and the control algorithm. Compact formulas specify the controller parameters as functions of the machine parameters and of the desired closed-loop behavior. The results are tested on a laboratory testbed using a cascaded doubly-fed induction motor and demonstrate fast responses reaching torque limits that are computed in real-time by the algorithm. While control is achieved through the converter interfaced with the control windings, the data shows that most of the active and reactive power is exchanged directly through the power windings. Similar results are obtained in simulations of a larger brushless doubly-fed induction motor.
... T He Brushless Doubly-Fed induction Machine (BDFM) is an attractive proposition for variable speed applications, especially in wind power generation [1], [2]. Several experimental BDFMs have been built ranging from small laboratory sizes up to several hundreds of kilowatts including a 250 kW size built by the authors [3], [4] and most recently, an 800 kW machine built for hydropower generation by Chen et al. [5]. Research on the BDFM has gained a fresh momentum in recent years which has led to significant improvement in the understanding, design and control of the machine [6]- [23]. ...
... The vast majority of experimental BDFMs have utilised a nested-loop design for the rotor, which comprises symmetrical nests each containing one or several concentric loops [3], [14]- [16], [28]- [37]. The loops are often made of solid bars which are shorted at one end of the rotor with a common end ring. ...
Article
Full-text available
This paper presents a method to estimate the BDFM equivalent circuit rotor current from rotor bar current measurements. Rotor currents are measured using a specially designed hardware that incorporates Rogowski coils and Bluetooth wireless transmission. The measurement of rotor currents enables the parameters in the BDFM's full equivalent circuit to be extracted unambiguously. In particular, stator and rotor leakage inductances can be estimated from experimental tests, which was not possible before from terminal measurement. The method is presented for a nested-loop rotor design and experimental measurements are shown for a prototype D180 frame BDFM.
... The 5.5 kW power rating is considered because it is a popularly used small machine rating. The 250 kW BDFM in [22] is the largest BDFM reportedly built to date, therefore this power rating is also considered. 75 kW is taken as a reasonable power rating between 5.5 and 250 kW. ...
... This is because this combination suffers from an unbalanced magnetic pull, however, this may be less noticeable in low power BDFMs [12]. The 2/4 combination is commonly examined in literature [12], [22], [26], [27], and is considered for all the power ratings. The 4/6 combination is examined from 75 kW upwards, while the 4/8 and 6/8 combinations are examined only at the MW level. ...
... A wind turbine is a rotating machine which converts the kinetic energy of air into mechanical energy. e mechanical power output of the wind turbine, P T , is given by (18) [ [23][24][25][26][27][28].: ...
... Dynamic equations of BDFIM in d-q reference frame can be derived using generalized machine theory [19,20]. Equations (23)(24)(25) provide voltage equations for one rotor winding and two stator windings, flux equations, electromagnetic torque equations, and real power through the SPW and APW (27): ...
Article
Full-text available
Electricity generation with minimal environmental pollution is required for the world's sustainable future, and wind electric generation is one of them. Brushless doubly fed induction generator (BDFIG), which derives from cascade induction machine technology, has grown in popularity as a wind electric generator due to advantages over doubly fed induction generator (DFIG) and permanent magnet synchronous generator (PMSG) such as the absence of slip rings and brushes and high-cost permanent magnets. Wind energy research is critical for any country's economic development and long-term sustainability. As a result, an experimental setup in a laboratory is required to replicate the behaviour of a wind turbine in the steady state. is study discusses the emulation of wind turbine characteristics in the laboratory using a prototype of a separately excited DC motor mechanically coupled to a brushless doubly fed induction generator (BDFIG). e wind turbine emulator-brushless doubly fed induction machine (WTE-BDFIM) prototype was tested in the laboratory under high power and low wind speed conditions. As a result, the simulation of the same hardware con guration in MATLAB was performed to investigate the overall performance of the BDFIM-based WECS. To determine the equivalent circuit parameters of the BDFIM, which are required for simulation, tests were performed on a prototype of 3.5 kW, 2/6 pole, 400 V, star/delta-star, and BDFIM in two modes, namely, the simple induction mode and the cascade induction mode. Based on the BDFIM parameters, a MATLAB Simulink model of a BDFIG-based wind electric conversion system (WECS) is created and its performance is investigated. Results of both hardware and simulation show that BDFIG can be used as the wind electric generator over a wider speed range compared to that of DFIG, an important feature that is required to get maximum power extraction from the wind turbine.
... Regarding some control strategies without crowbars, the literature indicates that the active and reactive currents of the PW are a rated value and zero under a normal grid voltage. When an LVRT event occurs, the commanded values for the active and reactive currents are set to zero and a rated value, respectively, to output the reactive power to the grid [18,19]. However, large overshoots and oscillations occur in the system using these strategies. ...
Article
Full-text available
In the grid-connected operation dynamics of brushless doubly fed generators (BDFGs), a dip in the grid voltage is equivalent to suddenly adding a reverse voltage source at the parallel node. By deriving the expressions of the transient current of power winding (PW), control winding (CW), and rotor winding (RW) of a BDFG in the complex frequency domain under a natural state, it was concluded that the overshoot and oscillation time are affected by the CW voltage, the drop degree and phase of the grid voltage, and the rotor speed. Therefore, an optimal control strategy is proposed. A state model with the CW current as the state variable was constructed using the Pontryagin minimum principle. The finite-time integral value of the square of the electromagnetic torque was set as the objective function to achieve the minimum value that could suppress the overshoot and oscillation of the electromagnetic torque, and the optimal CW voltage command value was directly solved to accelerate the convergence of the BDFG’s physical quantities, thereby reducing the amplitude. Finally, the feasibility of the optimal control algorithm was verified using tests on an experimental platform.
Article
This paper investigates the magnetic field conversion capacities based on the cascaded and modulated rotors including the staggered dual-cage rotor, the wound rotor, the nest-loop rotor, and the salient-pole rotor for the dual-stator brushless doubly-fed machines. The magnetic field conversion factor of the cascaded rotor is newly derived and the magnetic field conversion behaviors of both cascaded and modulated rotors are studied. The cascade rotor offers the advantage of minimizing undesirable magnetic field harmonics due to its specific winding connections, while the modulation rotor offers a compact structure and improved space utilization. The four machines with the same size are analyzed by the finite element method. The results demonstrate that the staggered dual-cage rotor, with low rotor resistance, resolves the problem of high rotor copper loss in the wound rotor, thus improving efficiency. The nest-loop rotor, utilizing the advantages of short-circuit coil modulation and reluctance effect, achieves a higher capacity for magnetic energy conversion compared to the salient-pole rotor. The experimental prototype validates the accuracy of the theoretical analysis.
Article
The brushless doubly-fed machine (BDFM) can be used in the variable speed constant frequency field. For BDFM, the choice of the pole-pair combination and the design of the rotor are significant. The output factor of the BDFM with 1/5 pole-pair combination is higher than that of the 2/4 pole-pair counterpart. However, the rotor of the BDFM with 1/5 pole-pair combination is hard to design for its wide pole-pair ratio. This paper presents a 1/5 pole-pair combination BDFM used in hydro power with a three-phase symmetrical wound rotor to solve the design challenge. First, the magnetic field modulation theory of the BDFM and the optimal output power in terms of different pole-pair combinations are introduced. Then, the slot-number phase diagram and the ampere-conductor wave method are applied to design windings of a BDFM with 1/5 pole-pair combination. Finally, the finite element (FE) models of the 1/5 and the 2/4 pole-pair combination BDFMs are established for comparison. A prototype of the 1/5 pole-pair combination is manufactured based on the proposed design scheme. Simulated and experimental results verified the feasibility of the design scheme.
Article
The brushless doubly fed generator (BDFG) shows great potential for the variable speed constant frequency ship shaft power generation applications due to its high reliability and low system costs. The rotor topology, which directly couples two stator magnetomotive forces (MMFs) with different pole pairs, is essential for the BDFG. However, existing rotor topologies cannot have both strong magnetic field coupling ability and simple structure. To address this problem, this paper proposes a simplified three-phase wound rotor that can produce two MMFs with different pole pairs simultaneously. Useless harmonics are also eliminated to achieve strong magnetic field coupling ability. The complete design method of a novel integral-slot single-layer winding acting as a basic unit of the compound wound rotor is presented. Two sets of basic winding units are merged into one according to the principle of Ampere-conductor wave, whose approaches are also thoroughly developed with the design example. The maximum number of winding layers and the coil types are reduced to simplify the winding layout. Steady-state performances of a prototype generator are analyzed by both finite element simulations and experimental tests, which verify proposed design methods and schemes.
Article
This article discusses a high-speed brushless doubly-fed machine (BDFM) for aviation turboelectric distributed propulsion application. After a brief overview of the machine fundamentals and propulsion architecture, the electromagnetic properties of the newly designed BDFM are analyzed. An innovative rotor mechanical design is introduced, which allows for a significant increase of speed compared to legacy rotor designs. Experiments were conducted to verify the 12 000-r/min high-speed operation. The findings in this article will give prominence to the feasibility of applying BDFMs for aviation applications.
Article
Full-text available
Failure Modes and Effects Analysis (FMEA) has been shown to be an effective way of improving machinery design reliability. This paper applies the FMEA to the design for availability of a 2MW, geared, exemplar R80 wind turbine design used in the EU FP7 ReliaWind Consortium. The technique will be used to compare the prospective reliabilities of three versions of the geared R80 turbine with different drive train solutions. These solutions have been proposed to reduce overall wind turbine failure rate and raise its availability. The first solution incorporates a conventional LV Doubly Fed Induction Generator (DFIG) with partially-rated Electrical Converter and Transformer; the second solution incorporates an innovative Hydraulic Converter coupled to an MV Synchronous Generator (SG) and no Transformer; the third solution incorporates an innovative LV Brushless Doubly Fed Induction Generator (GDFIG) also with a partially-rated Electrical Converter and Transformer. The paper proposes modifications to the FMEA method to analyse and compare reliabilities and applies that approach to these three alternative designs to identify their relative merits.
Conference Paper
Full-text available
The Brushless Doubly-Fed Induction Generator (Brushless DFIG) shows commercial promise for wind power generation due to its lower cost and higher reliability when compared with the conventional Doubly-Fed Induction Generator (DFIG). In the most recent grid codes, wind generators are required to be able to ride through a low voltage fault and meet the reactive current demand from the grid. Hence, a Low-Voltage Ride-Through (LVRT) capability is important for wind generators which are integrated into the grid. In this paper the authors propose a control strategy enabling the Brushless DFIG to successfully ride through a symmetrical voltage dip. The control strategy has been implemented on a 250 kW Brushless DFIG and the experimental results indicate that LVRT is possible without a crowbar.
Article
Full-text available
The paper presents experimental results to assess the performance of a variety of rotors used in a Brushless Doubly Fed Machine (BDFM). In the experiments the torque-speed characteristics were measured on a BDFM fitted with four rotors with five different windings. The measurements were made of the machine excited with just one stator supply with the second stator supply first open circuit, and then short- circuited. The results give valuable insight into how different rotors, including a novel design of BDFM rotor, will perform in a BDFM configured as a variable speed generator. The results highlight important differences between the rotors related to their winding construction.
Conference Paper
Full-text available
The brushless doubly-fed machine (BDFM) shows commercial promise as a variable speed drive or generator. However, for this promise to be realised, the design of the machine must be improved. Accurate machine modelling is therefore required for design optimisation. The measurement of rotor bar currents is of considerable benefit in the process of developing an accurate machine model. The authors present a system of measuring rotor bar currents in real time using a Rogowski coil to transduce the signal and recently available Bluetooth technology to transmit the data from the moving rotor to a standard PC. A coupled-circuit model has been developed for the BDFM to predict its dynamic and stead-state performance. The model has been verified using the proposed measurement system. The experiments were carried out on a frame size 180 BDFM with a nested-loop rotor design
Article
Full-text available
Brushless doubly fed induction generators (BDFIGs) show commercial promise for wind-power generation due to their lower capital and operational costs and higher reliability as compared with doubly fed induction generators. This paper presents a vector-control scheme for a BDFIG operating as a variable-speed generator. The proposed vector controller is developed on the power-winding stator-flux frame and can be used to control both the speed and the reactive power. The machine model and the control system are developed in MATLAB. The test results show that the proposed controller has good dynamic performance when changes in speed and reactive power are applied.
Article
In large interconnected power grids, it is incumbent on each generating plant to do its fair share in maintaining the security and reliability of the grid. The ability of a power plant to continue operation after a grid disturbance is governed by 1) the ability of its generator to recover voltage and remain in synchronism with the power grid after the disturbance (i.e., transient stability) 2) the ability of its turbine generator and auxiliary systems to remain in operation during and after the disturbance (i.e., fault ride-through capability).
Conference Paper
This paper presents the design and testing of a 250 kW medium-speed Brushless Doubly-Fed Induction Generator (Brushless DFIG), and its associated power electronics and control systems. The experimental tests confirm the design, and show the system's steady-state and dynamic performance. The medium-speed Brushless DFIG in combination with a simplified two-stage gearbox promises a low-cost low-maintenance and reliable drive train for wind turbine applications.
Article
In this paper, a novel doubly excited brushless machine (DEBM) with the radially laminated magnetic barrier rotor (RLMB-rotor) for wind power generator application is designed and built. The performance studies of the prototype RLMB-rotor DEBM with 10 rotor pole numbers by using the 2D transient finite element analysis model and the experimental method are presented. The magnetic fields, the no-load and loaded characteristics, the electromagnetic torque characteristics of the prototype machine are investigated. The experiment results validate the theoretical analysis results and all studies in this paper show that the prototype RLMB-rotor DEBM is a high efficiency wind power generator.
Article
A new vector control algorithm for the brushless doubly fed machine (BDFM) has been developed. The goal of BDFM control is to achieve a similar dynamic performance to the doubly fed induction machine (DFIM), exploiting the well-known induction motor vector control philosophy. For this purpose, a recently developed unified reference-frame model has been used to develop the vector control strategy. The theoretical considerations for the vector control design, control loops tuning and limits are shown. In addition, practical considerations for the experimental implementation of vector control for the BDFM are shown. Experimental results in a machine prototype confirm the good dynamic performances of this type of control.
Article
In large interconnected power grids, it is incumbent on each generating plant to do its fair share in maintaining the security and reliability of the grid. Recently, fault ride-through (FRT) requirements have been receiving the most attention. The article review the roots of transient stability requirements and recent developments in FRT requirements for wind plants. It discusses how wind plant FRT requirements are being imposed on conventional plants with synchronous machines and how interpretations of FRT requirements have been growing to cover some aspects of transient stability. It was concluded with a discussion about how FRT requirements should complement the established reliability criteria that provide the basis for the transient stability of power grids.