ArticlePDF Available

Abstract

The absence of science-technology-society (STS) interactions and its consequences in the basic teaching of science in Spain are analyzed in the first part of this work. This article proposes the introduction of STS interactions in physics and chemistry classes in conjunction with the teaching/learning model of science as research. When such interactions are not introduced, it can be observed that the students have a vision of science that is removed from the world in which they live and are unfamiliar with the mutual relationships between science, technology and the natural, social environments in which they are immersed. Not only do a large number of textbooks fail to cover STS interactions, but the majority of teachers do not consider interactive STS aspects necessary, nor do they contemplate these aspects in instruction. All of this contributes to the lack of students' interest in physics and chemistry and their rejection of them as subjects. In the second part of the work, students of 16-18 years of age in the last 3 years of secondary education were surveyed, and the results obtained were analyzed. These results confirmed that dealing with STS interactions in the classroom established science as something alive, more complete and integrated in the students' environment. Students subsequently developed an improved comprehension and a more real image of these sciences, which allowed them to understand better the role of scientists and how they work. All of this generated positive attitudes toward the study of physics and chemistry and increased the students' interest in their study. Thus the results of this research make it clear that it is possible to transform the learning of physics and chemistry with the inclusion of STS activities, so that the students can build scientific knowledge. Likewise, students integrate essential aspects that affect the scientific activity and contribute to deepening and consolidating their own knowledge.
THE STS INTERACTIONS AND THE TEACHING OF PHYSICS AND
CHEMISTRY
Solbes, J. and Vilches, A.
Seminar of Investigation and Innovation in Science Education.
University of Valencia. Spain.
(Science Education, 81, 4, 1997, pp. 377-386)
Introduction
In recent years, different lines of investigation have been developed, coinciding with
analyzing the causes of the decreasing interest of students towards the study of physics
and chemistry, as well as possible solutions. In the same manner, the changes in
society and in science-technology, as well as the disconnection between scholastic
science and the reality of a scientifically-oriented society, have forced a re-
establishment of the objectives in the teaching of science. Both paths have converged
in a field that has been fruitful and that is appearing as an effective strategy in science
education, as evidenced by the enormous quantity of literature and studies existing in
respect to this, as well as the development of numerous projects and studies: related to
the treatment of the science, technology and society (STS) interactions in education.
The development of the different STS projects attempts to bring the teaching of
science closer to the needs of the science student as a member of a society which is
more and more technologically developed.
The absence of the STS interactions in the teaching of science
However, what has been stated in theory through didactic investigation in the last
decade as a basic component of the science curriculum for improved comprehension of
the nature of science and scientific work, in practise in many countries isn't recognised
as such and, for one part, a large number of the textbooks fail to cover such aspects,
and for another the teachers aren't only not taking this into account in their teaching,
but also have misconceptions about the nature of science and of the STS interactions
(Rubba and Harkness, l993).
As we have already demonstrated in an earlier study (Solbes and Vilches, l989),
through the analysis of 47 science textbooks for 12 and 13-year olds, and physic and
chemistry textbooks for 15 to 17-year olds, the percentage of the chapters of said
textbooks that included a section, an activity for the student or a paragraph about
diverse aspects of the STS relationships was very low (between 4 and l7%). Thus, it
can be confirmed that the routine teaching contributes to present an image of science
and scientists removed from the real problems of the world, and doesn't take into
account the aspects of the STS relationships that mark scientific development. The
theories are presented without connection to the problems that they try to solve and
related problems and do not take into account science's role in the conception of the
world or in the organisation of social problems, thus demonstrating an image of
neutral science over the ideologies that ignore serious historic conflicts and which
form scientific development. In this way the narrow interactions existing between
scientific knowledge and other fields like philosophy, ethics, religion or economy are
omitted, without taking into account the social influence in the scientific and
technological development, such as the influence of the socially dominant ideas in the
selection of the topics of investigation, the commerical priorities in the technological
innovation, the sources destined for research and development, and the fact,
definitively that science and technology advance in a determined direction influenced
by the kind of society in which they're developed, by the institutions that finance them,
which supposes a clear conditioning to scientific development.
But the work of the men and women in science, like any other human activity, doesn't
take place at the margin of society, of the environment in which they live, and is
logically affected by the historic circumstances of the moment in which it is developed,
as well as influenced at the same time in the social and natural environment in which it
is immersed. It is difficult to accept that real learning can take place isolated from the
real world. However, the idea that science acts as something disconnected from reality
(Penick and Yager, l986) is very widespread in our society, and as we have made clear,
also in education.
In order to test this vision of science as it is taught, we surveyed 212 students that take
the usual physics and chemistry courses. We found, coinciding with other studies
(Schibeci, l986; Aikenhead, l987 and l988; Boyer and Tiberghien, l989; Ryan, l990,
etc.), that in general the students have a vision of science that is removed from the
world in which they live, demonstrate a commonplace image of science, scientists and
the means in which they work, are unfamiliar with the mutual relationships between
science, technology and the natural and social environments in which they are
immersed, and ignore the role played by science throughout the history of humanity, as
well as the external influence of scientific knowledge.
All of this contributes to the disinterest of the students towards physics and chemistry
and the rejection of such study, as was shown in the study through the negative
evaluation that the 212 students made of the instruction received in physics and
chemistry, including the disinterested and even negative evaluation labels that physics
and chemistry represent for them. This can be understood if we take into account the
above-mentioned manner in which education habitually presents this material.
However, by recalling the history of science, one realises the passionate characteristics
that scientific development has always had which guides the necessity to recover this
dimension of the science, the historic aspects, STS relationships, adding to its role of
showing a more complete and contextualized image, a potentially motivating factor.
In fact, the students who were interviewed cited many aspects and concrete topics
related to the STS interactions in order to include a physics and chemistry course that
would be interesting to them, such as concrete applications of both disciplines and the
problems that they resolved or raised, the use of new materials and technologies,
debates about the current scientific topics, the study of coloring and additive
chemistry, topics related to the environment and the problems that development has
generated (acid rain, problems in the ozone layer), or activities outside the learning
center.
This disinterest on the part of the students was also checked in a questionnaire that we
made previously, from another perspective, in which the students were asked to give
the reasons for choosing or not choosing physics and chemistry courses, which are
optional courses in the last two terms of secondary education. The results indicated
(Table I) that when the students choose these disciplines the majority do not do so
because they are interested in them, because the study of them seems something
appealing or interesting in itself, but rather because they are necessary for further
studies that they consider doing and only a fourth of this students declared a theoretical
interest in their choice of study.
Not only the abscence of the treatment of the STS relationships in the textbooks
contributes to the decontextualized vision of science that the students have, but also to
this is added the slight importance given by the teaching profession to these aspects in
instruction. This was made clear in a study made in order to test the hypothesis
according to which we thought that a great part of the teaching profession didn't
adequately value the inclusion to the STS interactive aspects in the instruction of
physics and chemistry, and that it could be reflected in different situations, such as
their appraisal over the possible causes of the disinterest of the students towards the
study of physics and chemistry in the analysis or elaboration that they made in routine
materials in instruction.
The teachers and the STS relationships
A high percentage (66.6%) of the teaching profession consulted (l03 in-service
teachers involved in training and improvement courses) declared that one of the causes
of the students' disinterested attitude and, in some cases, rejection of physics and
chemistry is the socially-decontextualized image habitually presented of the sciences,
that their study is not interesting to the student, indicating the disconnection between
what they learn and the world in which they live, the apparent uselessness of what they
study, the image of science that is removed from reality without taking into the social
implications, without treating the historical aspects in which they are contextualized
and without explaining the role of scientists in the evolution of society. Other causes
most cited were related to the methodology (82.5%) and in a lower degree with the
difficulty of the disciplines (29.1%).
However, despite considering that the absence of the STS interactions in education is
the cause of the disinterest of the students, it is significant that there are many teachers
(89.2%) who ignore these aspects upon analyzing materials used routinely in physics
and chemistry classes. Thus, concerning the analysis of the introduction of the concept
of energy in a secondary education textbook in which the relative aspects of STS aren't
presented, the results clearly showed the slight consideration the majority of teachers
gave toward such aspects, in which only 10.8% noted the absence of these aspects in
the material upon analization, pointing them out as something to take into account in
instruction. Therefore it's to be expected that if the majority of the teachers don't take
into account the absence of the interactive STS aspects as something necessary, then
they evidentally don't transmit a complete and contextualized image of science to the
students. Many explain their attitude of not opening up the discipline to the daily life
as the base of structural problems, the time schedule (lack of time), the extention of
the official contents, etc., and carry out programs that allow the students to accede to
previous scientific studies,but without developing those that promote the acquisition of
useful knowledge in order to comprehend the scientific and technical environment.
In the same manner, coinciding with other studies (Hodson, 1992) while working on
our investigation, creating concrete activities of the STS relationships, the lack of
interest on a great part of the teachers for some of the fundamental STS aspects (some
even think that they don't have to take these into account in instruction, that these
aspects aren't their job to exercise in the discipline, supporting the "neutral" character
of science as the deposit of an impartial knowledge that ignores the serious historical
conflicts) was evident (Table II). Although a large number (55.8%) of the 120 teachers
consulted in this case proposed activities of interaction between science and
technology, in general they were simple technical applications of science, confirming
the idea that they are less conflictive, constitute the most "neutral" aspects and are less
"removed" from the scientific content. The multiple activities established contained all
the STS relationships, together with other types of activities. The examples described
refer to the implications of science in the environment, in society or in technology, but
in no case the opposite, that is, there weren't any activities about the implications of
technological development, society or environment in scientific progress, for example.
The results are consistent with our hypothesis, which is easily explained if we consider
the teacher training, where the STS aspects aren't taken into account and, therefore,
there are few reasons to hope that the teachers will have visions of science and STS
relationships different from the students (Fleming, l988).
The STS interactions in physics and chemistry classes. A proposal for setting up a
new model for the teaching/learning of the sciences
After establishing the problem, a proposal developed that, in the context of a new
model for teaching/learning, could contribute to improve the interest and attitude of the
students towards the sciences and their study, contributing to show a vision of science
which is more contextualized and more in accord with the current philosophical and
historical positions of science.
With a minimally detailed treatment of STS interactions in teaching, we think that it is
possible to improve the attitude of the students'towards physics and chemistry,
increasing their interest to the study of science in general, and improving their
learning, providing a more complete and appropriate image of science and how
scientists work.
The proposal is basically founded on the establishment of a new model of
teaching/learning which carries out the experience of dealing with the STS
relationships. In this way, the work can bring together many projects which set up
learning with a consructivist orientation, such as the treatment of problematic
situations of interest unifying the habitual separation between activities of the
introduction of concepts, the solution of problems and practical work, responding to
the characteristics of a directed investigation, (Gil et al, l99l) in which the students'
learning is organized as a constructuion of knowledge following their own conceptions
and involving them in an investigative activity directed by the teacher.
The parallel established between the learning of science and investigation allows
integration of new didactic advances and among those directing the attention towards
other aspects inseparably related to the work of scientists as they are the frame in
which the said scientific knowledge is developed. This teaching method also
emphasizes the relationship between scientists and the outer environment, that is the
influence of society in scientific and technological progress, the problems that their
development generates or resolves, the necessity or convenience of development in a
determined direction, the influence of scientific knowledge in society, in the exchange
of ideas, in other words, the complex STS interactions which mark scientific
development.
The inclusion of these aspects in the teaching of the sciences will encourage:
a) demonstrating a more socially contextualized image of scientific knowledge.
b) making a careful study of the problematics associated in their construction, which
will aid in better understanding the role of science and tecnology,and the scientist.
c) engaging the students in the solution of serious problems which mortgage the future
of humanity: the destruction of the natural environment, polarization of rich and poor
populations, diseases, nuclear arms, etc.
d) succeeding in transforming the teaching of sciences into a fundamental element of
our culture, in order to train critical and responsible citizens (Gagliardi and Giordan,
l986; Hlebbowist and Hudson, l99l), not only for their professional efficiency, but also
so that they can actively participate in social matters, contributing in this way to give
meaning to studies made and favoring interest and positive attitudes.
This proposes the concept of the curriculum such as programs of activities through
which the students can construct and acquire knowledge, at the same time they
familiarize themselves with the basic characteristics of scientific work and they acquire
a critical interest for science and its repercussions. In such programs the introduction
of the STS activities is consistent with the established model, pervading all aspects of
learning (Vilches, l993), from the solution of problems, practical work or the
introduction of concepts to their own process of evaluation. That is, not renouncing the
construction of coherent bodies of knowledge, nor presenting the construction of the
same as something removed from the STS interactions.
This doesn't imply increasing the curriculum, it doesn't mean adding something new to
the scientific studies with the object of forming scientists or future citizens of society,
but rather it deals with trying to provide a more contextualized idea of science
pervading the development of didactic units with activities that take into account the
cited aspects, converging with the idea that the main objective of teaching science
should extend itself beyond the scientific contents, recognizing the role of science and
technology as a method of solving problems of humanity with the benefits and
inconveniences that their development raises.
Developing as the objective the integrated comprehension of the scientific knowledge,
the social themes that surround the tecnological development and potentially
increasing abilities in order to make decisions in a technological society (Fleming,
1989), will remove that ambivalent feeling generated between scientific and
technological development and its social role that opposes a primarily optimistic vision
based on the idea of technology as an instrument of prosperity with a rejection of the
products the technological era and its consequences.
Instruments developed
In order to move ahead with the project, first we prepared materials for the
introduction of STS interactive activities in the classes of physics and chemistry, which
were used with 240 students of 15-17 years of age in the secondary levels by different
teachers and in different centers during the 1990-1991 and 1991-1991 courses, using
the same methodology.
The project dealt with carefully planned and studied programs in which the activities
of the STS relationships were presented in each of the aspects of learning, aiming for
an internal consistency in the development of the topic, integrated in such a way trying
to give meaning to the work of the students, contemplating the entirety of the complex
interactions, without forgetting the more conflictive aspects. Students are involved in
different actvities from technical applications and the influence of the technological
development in the scientific advancement, to the mutual implications of science and
technology in society, in the environment, at present and throughout history, from the
different social, economic, cultural, philosophic, etc, points of view, to evaluate
activities and make decisions about different aspects such as economic and social
transformations, large scale military projects, different effects of development,
environmental impact, contribution of science and technology to the solution of
problems, etc.
Considered as useful tools in learning, the STS activities were always implemented
when possible. The abstract and decontextualized activities of solving problems or the
introduction of concepts for others put the student in contact with the world around
him/her, with current problems and their possible solutions, establishing at the same
time activities outside the learning center, discussion of scientific news, visits to the
rooms of professionals or experts in dealing with questions. Some of the STS activities
established a mode of introduction like the previous discussion of the interest of
problems posed, favoring in this way a more positive attitude toward the work being
done; other activities used upon finishing the topics, of a globalizing form, included
various aspects to the mode of summary and of reviewing the work dealt with as a
possible evaluation of the learning process.
By making a detailed examination of the STS interactions in the science classes, the
students were able to develop a more complete and contextualized image of physics
and chemistry, as well as an increase of interest towards their study. A selection of
items that reflected the ideas of the students was used which referred to the STS
relationships as well as the students interest towards the study of science that was
already used in the first part of the work (Solbes and Vilches, 1992) in order to make
the ideas of the students clear as to their image of science and scientists in the situation
that they are given in routine teaching that doesn't take into account the STS
relationships as they are established in this article.
Results
At the end of the courses, the ideas of the STS aspects, implied in the first
questionnaire, which dealt with bringing to light the image of science and scientists,
were passed onto the students.
Differences exist in some items: between the groups of our students (Experimental
Group 2) and those of the other teachers (Experimental Group 1) that followed the
same methodology and materials, but in all cases, significant differences were
observed in respect to the students that didn't take a course involving the STS
interactions (Control Group).
The results showed globally that significant differences between the educational levels
analyzed were not observed. The results (Table III) confirmed that the students
developed an improved image (more real and contextualized) of physics/chemistry.
Dealing with the STS interactions in the classes established science as something live,
more complete and integrated in their environment, in the continuing evolution that
helps in solving problems that ought to help resolve those that development generates,
allowing the students to better understand their role and that, at the same time, as was
observed in the debates and responses, contributes to generate a "critically" positive
attitude towards physics/chemistry and their study.
The students that didn't take a course in which the STS activities were established
throughout the topics, not only weren't capable of making a critical evaluation in
44.8% of the cases, but also when they were asked to critically analyze the role played
by physics/chemistry in the lives of men and women, weighing the advantages and
inconveniences, which for the majority of the students were much more serious
(destruction of the planet! end of humanity! pollution, nuclear bombs) and irreversible
than the advantages, confused in the majority of cases science with the most negative
consequences of social and political development like the arms race of the destruction
of the natural environment. However, we think that the discussion of the social role of
science, the myth of the neutrality of the scientist or the conditioning of scientific
progress clearly contribute to the returning the potency and vitality to the teaching of
the sciences.
It was observed in Table IV that we showed only the results related to the fact that the
students who took a STS course showed an improved attitude towards
physics/chemistry and their learning, and a greater interest for their study when they
included interactive STS activities.
When asked which factors would contribute to increase their interest in the study of
physics/chemistry (item 2), the highest percentage in the experimental groups (79.6%)
as well as in the control groups (76.%), corresponded to aspects related to the
methodology used by the teaching staff and also in a high percentage in the case of the
experimental groups (44.6%) to include aspects related to the STS interactions. It's
interesting to note that only a percentage of 10.4 of the experimental groups and 9.0 of
the control groups pointed out the difficulty of the subject as a factor that could
contribute to the disinterest or the negative attitude towards physics/chemistry, citing
however in high percentages (80.2 control group and 88.3 experimental group) aspects
related to the teacher's method as factors directly related to their negative attitude or
disinterest.
When asked more concretely which topics could be dealt with in a physics or
chemistry course that would make it interesting for them (item 3), both groups of
students pointed out a significant percentage of aspects related to the STS interactions,
(greater logically in the case of the experimental groups that had been in contact with
the STS interactions throughout the course), current topics, environmental
relationships, relevant to their daily lives, applications of the subject, influences in
technological development, relationships between science and the natural environment,
and science/technology and society.
Conclusion and perspectives
The results of the investigation make clear that it is possible to transform the physics
and science material with the inclusion of the STS activities along with the
development of each topic, in such a way that the students can build scientific
knowledge, integrating essential aspects that affect the scientific activity and contribute
to deepening their knowledge.
On the other hand, it can be observed that: a) the students that had taken a course
which dealt with the STS activities in the didactic model have a more contextualized,
more real image of science, showing significant differences in all cases regarding the
student that has taken a course without taking into account these aspects; b) it is
possible to improve the attitude of the students and to increase their interest in the
study of physics and chemistry dealing with the aspects pointed out by the students.
But the most global solution will be that it confronts taking into account the problem of
the attitude towards science penetrating all aspects of learning, from the forms in the
introduction of the concepts or the orientation of practical work to the contents or the
atmosphere of the classroom. It will be necessary to establish concrete proposals from
the different aspects of the teaching, tending to generate postitive attitudes towards
science and the learning of it, maximizing if we take into account as the didactic
investigation has made clear, that a positive attitude towards science in the students
develops an improved comprehension and achieves the best results overall in the
learning of the subject. (Yager and McCormack, l989).
Considering that the treatment of the STS interactions contribute to improve the image
of science. to increase the interest of the students in the subject and study of physics
and chemistry not only by its motivating character, but also overall because it helps to
show a more contextualized image of these disciplines, the inclusion of the study of
said aspects in the teaching will be important not only for the forming of future citizens
of a society that is penetrated more and more by science and technology, so that in the
future they can adopt an attitude that is responsible and founded in facing scientific
and technological development, leaving behind visions of "pure" science, without
relating it to the outer environment and with the problematic that its development
generates.
Also one consequence of the investigation could be the design of STS subjects for the
students that do not choose science options in the line of demonstrating science as one
of the fundamental elements of the culture of our time, contributing to the development
of one of the most fruitful fields of didactic investigation of the sciences in recent years
and that permits a better understanding of the situation of change that teaching and the
sciences are experiencing in the philosophic and historic fields.
References
AIKENHEAD, G.S. (1987). High-School graduates' beliefs about Science-
Technology-Society.III. Characteristics and limitations of scientific knowledge.
Science Education, 71(4), 459-487.
AIKENHEAD, G.S. (1988). An Analysis of four ways of assessing student beliefs
about STS topics. Journal of Research in Science Teaching, 25(8), 607-629.
BOYER, R. and TIBERGHIEN, A. (1989). Las finalidades de la enseñanza de la
Física y la Química vistas por profesores y alumnos franceses. Enseñanza de las
Ciencias, 7(3), 213-222.
FLEMING, R. (1988). Undergraduate science students' views on the relationship
between Science, Technology and Society. International Journal of Science Education,
10(4), 449-463.
FLEMING, R. (1989). Literacy for a technological age. Science Education, 73(4), 391-
404.
GAGLIARDI, R. and GIORDAN, A. (1986). La historia de las ciencias: una
herramienta para la enseñanza. Enseñanza de las ciencias, 4(3), 253-259.
GIL, D., CARRASCOSA, J., FURIÓ, C. and MARTÍNEZ, J. (1991). La Enseñanza de
las Ciencias en la Educación Secundaria. (Horsori: Barcelona).
HLEBOWITSH, P.S. and HUDSON, S.E. (1991). Science education and the
reawakening of the general education ideal. Science Education,75(5), 563-576.
HODSON, D. (1992). In search of a meaningful relationship: an exploration of some
issues relating to integration in science and science education. International Journal of
Science Education, 14(5), 541-562.
PENICK, J.E. and YAGER, R.E. (1986). Trends in science education: some
observatios of exemplary programme in the United States. European Journal of
Science Education, 8(1), 1-8.
RUBBA, P.A. and HARKNESS W.L. (1993). Examination of preservice and in-
Service secondary science teachers' beliefs about Science-Technology-Society
Interactions. Science Education, 77(4), 407-431.
RYAN, A.G. (1990). Los efectos de la región, número de asignaturas de ciencias
cursadas y sexo sobre la opinión de los estudiantes canadienses en cuestiones de
ciencia, técnica y sociedad. Enseñanza de las Ciencias, 8(1), 3-10.
SCHIBECI, R.A. (1986). Images of science, scientists and science education. Science
Education, 70(2), 139-149.
SOLBES, J. and VILCHES, A. (1989). Interacciones Ciencia/ Técnica/ Sociedad. Un
instrumento de cambio actitudinal. Enseñanza de las Ciencias, 7(1), 14-20.
SOLBES, J. and VILCHES, A. (1992). El modelo constructivista y las relaciones
Ciencia, Técnica, Sociedad. Enseñanza de las Ciencias, 10(2), 181-186.
VILCHES, A. (1993). Las Interacciones CTS y la Enseñanza de las Ciencias Físico-
químicas. Tesis Doctoral. Universidad de Valencia.
YAGER, R.E. and Mc CORMACK, A.J. (1989). Assessing Teaching/ Learning in
multiple domains of science and science education. Science Education, 73(1), 45-58.
TABLE I
STUDENTS' INTEREST IN PHYSICS AND/OR CHEMISTRY
Students who choose physics and/or chemistry because: Percentage
(N=212)
It is necessary for their professional study 44.9
It seems like an interesting subject 25.2
Something less bad: they don't like or are less interested in the other
options 19.5
There wasn't any other option, thus they chose this one 10.3
TABLE II
PROPOSAL OF ACTIVITIES BY THE TEACHERS
Teachers, in preparing materials, proposed STS activities of: Percentage
(N=120)
Science/Technology relationship 55.8
Science/Society relationship 10.8
Science/Environment relationship 8.3
Science/History relationship 0.8
Activities outside the learning institution 4.2
NON-STS activities 7.5
Multiple activities 13.3
TABLE III
STUDENTS' VIEW OF PHYSICS/CHEMISTRY AND THE STS RELATIONSHIPS
Percentage of students that indicated: Control
N=212 Exp. 1
N=91 Exp.2
N=149
A critically positive image of
physics/chemistry 33.5
68.8
68.8
An uncommonplace view of scientists 5.7
33.0
55.0
Five or more technical applications of
physics/chemistry 13.2
51.6
75.2
Three or more influences of physics/chemistry
in society 8.0
31.9
59.7
Three or more influences of society in
physics/chemistry 4.2
15.4
33.6
Three or more influences of physics/chemistry
in the environment
8.0
20.9
46.3
They were capable of making a critical
evaluation 55.2
83.5
96.0
TABLE IV
STUDENTS' INTEREST IN PHYSICS/CHEMISTRY AND THE STS
RELATIONSHIPS
Percentage of students who: Control
N=212 Exper.
N=240
positively valued the teaching of physics/chemistry 26.4
54.2
indicated the STS interactions as a factor that could
increases their interest for physics/chemistry
15.1
44.6
cited aspects of the STS interactions as interesting
during the course
37.4
65.8
THE STS INTERACTIONS AND THE TEACHING OF PHYSICS AND
CHEMISTRY
Solbes J. and Vilches A.
Seminar of Investigation and Innovation in Science Education.
University of Valencia. Spain.
Address of contact:
J. Solbes and A. Vilches
CEP Valencia
c/ Juan de Garay 25
46017 Valencia (España)
Ph 963787052
Fax 963572456
ABSTRACT
The absence of STS interactions in the usual teaching of science in Spain is analysed in
this work. It goes on the proposal of introduction of STS interactions in Physics and
Chemistry classes in conjunction with the teaching/learning model of science as
investigation.
ABSTRACT
The absence of STS interactions and its consequences in the usual teaching of science
in Spain is analysed in the first part of this work. (It goes on the proposal of
introduction of STS interactions in Physics and Chemistry classes in conjunction with
the teaching/learning model of science as investigation). When such interactions are
not introduced, a wiew (of the science) remote from everyday reality and the ignorance
of the relationships between science and technology is shown by the students. This
leads them to a lack of interest in the study of Physics and Chemistry. Not only the
absence of STS interactions in the textbooks contributes to an out of context view of
the science but also, the fact that just a few teachers attach some importance to the
teaching of all these aspects.
In the second part of the article, the results obtained were taken from an experience
carried out with students of the three last courses in the secondary levels (16-18 years).
By using STS interactions activities in Physics and Chemistry classes significant
improvements have been achieved. The students get to have a comprehensive
knowledge and a more accurate view of these sciences and, moreover, they are able to
understand they way scientists work. All this will help the students to improve their
interest and attitude to the study of physics and chemistry. The results of this research
highlight the possibility of bringing about changes in the materials used in physics and
chemistry, with the introduction of STS interactions, so that the students may build
scientific knowledge. Likewise, they will elaborate essential aspects which will affect
the scientific activity and contribute to the depth and consolidation of their own
knowledge.
... Thus, the decontextualization of Science was the starting point for the STS (Science, Technology and Society) projects, which confirmed that students' interest grows with these kinds of projects (Solbes & Vilches, 1997). ...
... It is unquestionable that the issue of students' motivation towards the learning of any science subject is a major concern for teachers (Solbes & Vilches, 1997). It seems clear that the interactions and contextual aspects found in the classrooms must be taken into account. ...
Article
Full-text available
Considering students’ increasing lack of interest and motivation for science subjects, it becomes almost imperative to introduce different methodology approaches in classrooms. Besides, decontextualized science teaching, where hands on activities are not sufficiently taken into account, can make the students attitude toward science-learning even worse. Inquiry Based Learning where elements such as games, toys and short experiments are included is showed as a useful methodological proposal. This paper presents how the use of these entertaining science activities can improve students’ interest and encourage them to speak about science, acquiring better argumentation and inquiry skills when they are properly performed in a formal classroom context.
... In this section of the paper, we focus on the qualitative aspect of our study, examining a test specifically designed to gather students' subjective perspectives and insights regarding the methodology implemented within the classroom. This qualitative test, consisting of open-ended questions and prompts, aimed to capture the essence of the students' experiences, perceptions, and reflections on the pedagogical strategies employed [42][43][44]. Table 3 describes the qualitative questions that were asked of the students in the post-test questionnaire. Responses to each question were categorized into different sub-categories, shown in Table 3. Table 3. Qualitative questions used in the post-test and expected replies. ...
Article
Full-text available
This study aims to assess the knowledge of geology and sustainability among 14- and 15-year-old secondary school students in Spain and to evaluate the effectiveness of active experiential methodologies in improving academic performance in these subjects. Involving 132 students, we used pre-test and post-test questionnaires for data collection, with both control and experimental groups. Our findings showed that integrating Earth history, the Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs), and public speaking enhances scientific literacy by fostering problem-solving and interdisciplinary understanding. The study highlights the importance of integrating scientific methods, revealing a preference for experimental approaches over traditional methods among students; however, when the results are analyzed independently by topic, similar results are obtained with active and traditional teaching methodologies. Therefore, a holistic and flexible approach not only meets the requirements of modern curricula but also helps students address complex global challenges.
... En el departamento del Tolima, en 2010 se contaba con 155 investigadores activos, que representaban tan solo el 1 % del total nacional (Gobernación del Tolima, 2012). Por lo anterior, la educación en los niveles de básica y media debería constituirse en la principal fuente de información y conocimiento frente a los avances científicos y tecnológicos que actualmente afronta la sociedad, a través de una adecuada alfabetización científica que permita a los ciudadanos reflexionar y tomar decisiones apropiadas en temas relacionados con la ciencia y la tecnología (Arteta, 2009;Solbes & Vilches, 1997). ...
Book
Full-text available
Este libro recopila experiencias que la Universidad de Ibagué ha desarrollado a través de programas, proyectos y actividades de extensión, proyección social, responsabilidad social universitaria y en cumplimiento de su política de Responsabilidad Social Integral, la cual enmarca un conjunto de normas y principios que organizan las acciones en las que la Universidad participa con los demás actores sociales para promover procesos de desarrollo regional. La publicación de este libro permite llevar a cabo una lectura de lo que ha pasado históricamente en la Universidad de Ibagué, más específicamente desde que el Consejo Superior de la Universidad creó la Dirección de Proyección Social, hoy Unidad de Responsabilidad Social Integral adscrita a la Dirección de Extensión, ello implicó recolectar, analizar, documentar y reflexionar considerando la memoria institucional, a través de las experiencias cimentadas y validadas a lo largo del tiempo por diversos actores que han tenido que ver con el desarrollo de programas, proyectos y actividades, y que de alguna manera han aportado a la construcción de un modelo de responsabilidad social pertinente, el que cada vez más busca articularse de manera transversal al proyecto de universidad regional; en este contexto se considera pertinente comprender las experiencias significativas que ha liderado la Universidad de Ibagué.
... In the four frameworks, addressing the grand challenges of our time is associated with an interdisciplinary perspective [3]. Science education research has tried to emphasize the productiveness of interdisciplinary perspectives by including, for example, issues located at the intersection of science, society and technology (STS) to transform the learning of basic natural sciences [68]. However, traditionally, when health issues have been taught in science education, a disciplinary point of view has still mostly been adopted. ...
Article
Full-text available
In this paper, we explore Science|Environment|Health, One Health, Planetary Health, and Sustainability/Education for Sustainable Development in the context of the 2030 Agenda as four major frameworks that take a step toward investigating health from different angles to tackle the grand challenges that lie ahead of humanity. In most of these frameworks, the topic of health is no longer limited to the health of humans; it also encompasses the health of ecosystems and planetary systems. Therefore, our ways of teaching and discussing health in science education may need to be adjusted. To this aim, we first shortly characterize the four frameworks and then analyze the concepts of health, the contributing sciences, and the role of values in the frameworks. In our opinion, three main questions have to be settled: (1) Which concept of health lies at the root of each framework? (2) Which sciences should be considered when teaching about health, and what role will they take in an interdisciplinary, integrative approach and under complexity restraints? (3) What is the role of values in these frameworks, and how can the is–ought fallacy be avoided? We finally discuss our findings in light of the concept of two-eyed seeing in science education. This concept helps us disentangle and sharpen the three main questions and draw implications for teaching about health in school science.
Article
Full-text available
A questão dos letramentos e da inovação demonstram-se fundamentais em períodos históricos como o atual, onde as práticas de ensino-aprendizagem tornam-se cada vez mais complexas, que requerem novas abordagens teóricas para compreendermos possibilidades alternativas de ensino. Tendo estas questões em mente, este artigo visa indicar relações possíveis entre o antifundacionismo, o pensamento de Paul Feyerabend e os letramentos científicos. Em um primeiro momento indicaremos questões relativas ao antifundacionismo, e em seguida verificaremos como tal questão se efetiva no pensamento de Feyerabend. Finalizaremos avaliando como esta abordagem pode fundamentar novas práticas educacionais.
Article
Full-text available
Se presentan los primeros resultados de aprendizaje significativo en la enseñanza de una tecnociencia en Ingeniería, empleando la estrategia pedagógica-didáctica de resolución de problemas
Conference Paper
The process of career development has been shown to be different for young people living in rural areas, as compared to those living in urban areas [1] [2]. This paper fills an important gap in the research literature by demonstrating the current need for tailored career education programs for students in rural and urban areas of Nova Scotia, Canada, especially as pertaining to ocean sciences and the marine industry. Here, we investigate data from a large study performed in Nova Scotia wherein students in grades 6-9 were asked about their career intentions and perceptions. Significant differences were noted between students living in urban and rural areas, especially regarding their readiness to begin thinking about a range of career paths. These differences can be leveraged with career education initiatives to improve career opportunities for rural students, and by extension, the local economy.
Article
Full-text available
El propósito de este trabajo de revisión bibliográfica es examinar el debate actual sobre el papel educativo que tienen las visitas escolares a los museos de ciencias en el aprendizaje de las ciencias. Nosotros situamos este debate dentro de la línea de investigación de la enseñanza de las ciencias en contextos no formales y en la propuesta de investigación sobre ciencia, tecnología, sociedad y ambiente (CTSA) y sobre naturaleza de la ciencia (NC). Empezaremos nuestra revisión distinguiendo diferentes categorías en los museos de ciencias. A continuación nos centraremos en las investigaciones realizadas en los museos interactivos de ciencias que es la categoría de MC mayoritaria tanto en España como en el ámbito internacional. Estas investigaciones incluyen aprendizaje de las ciencias en contextos no formales, diferentes enfoques de aprendizaje, análisis de visitas escolares a museos y diferentes propuestas para mejorar el aprendizaje en MC. Para finalizar, comentaremos las implicaciones didácticas para la enseñanza de las ciencias.
Conference Paper
Full-text available
Os programas escolares europeus têm variado ao logo dos tempos e se em várias alturas foram mais práticos, noutras foram mais teóricos. As duas abordagens têm vantagens e desvantagens. Entre as duas guerras mundiais do século XX procurou-se que fossem mais práticos e com exemplos do dia a dia, mas foi só depois dos anos 1960 que estes começam a ter mais preocupações sociais, culminando nos anos 1990 e 2000 nos programas envolvendo uma grande componente societal. Por outro lado, em vários países sentiu-se que as áreas científicas e de engenharia começavam a ter pouca atratividade (Portugal é interessante por não terem tido quase até ao final do século XX) e implementam-se programas que valorizam essas atividades em detrimento dos societais. Esta comunicação visa traçar uma história dessa evolução centrando-se na água e no mar. Palavras-chave: Ensino básico, Perfil do aluno, Programas oficiais, Sociedade e educação objeTivos Nesta comunicação pretende-se fazer um resumo dos programas educacionais europeus ligados à água e ao mar.
Article
Full-text available
Este texto muestra la definición de la ciencia, la cual nos lleva al mismo tiempo a diferenciar entre la ciencia y los medios con los cuales la ciencia se hace; es decir, las instituciones y los hombres.
Article
Full-text available
The National Science Teachers Association in the United States undertook a major new project in 1982‐a Search for Excellence in Science Education. For the first year Project Synthesis desired state descriptions were used as criteria for searches conducted in each state. Subsequently, new task forces were at work defining excellence and developing search criteria from a variety of views. A total of 104 exemplary programmes have been selected to date. An analysis of the Focus on Excellence monographs reveals some national trends in school science. These major trends include: (1) significant involvement of local communities in programme development and instruction; (2) science/technology/society as a curriculum focus; (3) laboratories defined as the real world; and (4) a focus first on qualitative considerations and later on quantitative ones. These trends are discussed, analysed and exemplified with the exemplary programmes identified across the United States.
Article
Full-text available
The study investigated the degree of ambiguity harbored by four different response modes used to monitor student beliefs about science-technology-society topics: Likert-type, written paragraph, semistrue tured interview, and empirically developed multiple choice. The study also explored the sources of those beliefs. Grade-12 students in a Canadian urban setting responded, in each of the four modes, to statements from Views on Science-Technology-Society. It was discovered that TV had far more influence on what students believed about science and its social, technological context than did numerous science courses. The challenge to science educators is to use the media effectively in combating naive views about science. Regarding ambiguity in student assessment, the Likert-type responses were the most inaccurate, offering only a guess at student beliefs. Such guesswork calls into question the use of Likert-type standardized tests that claim to assess student views about science. Student paragraph responses contained significant ambiguities in about 50% of the cases. The empirically developed multiple choices, however, reduced the ambiguity to the 20% level. Predictably, the semistructured interview was the least ambiguous of all four response modes, but it required the most time to administer. These findings encourage researchers to develop instruments grounded in the empirical data of student viewpoints, rather than relying solely on instruments structured by the philosophical stances of science educators.
Article
This study examines undergraduate science students’ views of the nature of the relationship between science, technology and society. Two hundred students responded to items on the VOSTS‐CDN 2 instrument. Based on these responses, questions were designed and, using semi‐structured interviews, posed to 30 students. The interviews focused on the issues: the nature of science and the role of science in our society. The VOSTS results indicate that the science students’ views are remarkably similar to those of high school graduates. The interview results show that scientific facts‐‐their creation, verification or existence‐‐are the central concern when dealing with the nature of science. When discussing the role of science in society, mission‐oriented science clashed with pure research. Implications for STS teacher education are briefly discussed.
Article
The long‐running debate about the desirability of separate courses in biology, chemistry and physics versus the merits of integrated science, co‐ordinated science or combined science, the case for ‘balanced’ science within a Science for All programme, and the unresolved question of ‘process’ versus ‘product’ orientation in science curriculum design each relates to fundamental philosophical problems concerning the nature of science and scientific practice and to issues concerning the goals and practice of science education. This article examines the philosophical validity of claims for the conceptual and methodological integration of the sciences and explores the possibilities for constructing coherent science courses based on alternative integrating elements rooted in educational theory.