Conference PaperPDF Available

Through-the-wall surveillance technologies


Abstract and Figures

Invited paper, pp. 30-33 IEEE X-plore
Content may be subject to copyright.
Ultrawideband and Ultrashort Impulse Signals, 17-21 September, 2012, Sevastopol, Ukraine pp. 30-33
©2012 IEEE
Yanovsky F. J., Ivashchuk V. E., and Prokhorenko V. P.
National Aviation University, Kiev, Ukraine
This paper will present a brief overview of methods for solving the problem of
surveillance behind the opaque wall. A low cost method for detecting moving objects
behind the wall, based on the analysis of reflected pulse UWB signal is considered in
more details. Demonstration of real work of the method is carried out with use of the
operating breadboard model of the device implementing this method.
Keywords: Through-the-wall radar, UWB radar, GPR.
The possibility to see through obstructions that are
opaque to visible light always was very attractive for
human. However until recently such vision seemed
impracticable dream. Now several approaches to solve
different problems of through-the-wall surveillance
are known.
Considerable progress in this area is caused by co-
incidence in time of two circumstances: a) the in-
creased needs of the modern society caused by
activization of terrorist activity, and also increase of
requirements to the efficiency of rescue operations
after natural cataclysms like earthquakes and volcanic
activity that became more frequent; b) development of
new methods for generating and radiation of signals in
a wide frequency range, including ultra wideband
(UWB) signals, and advent of fast and effective de-
vices of digital signal processing. In other words, de-
mand increase has coincided with occurrence of new
engineering possibilities.
That is why through-the-wall imaging has recently
become a topic of intense research as it concerns de-
tection and localization of people behind impenetrable
walls [1].
Possible applications of such devices are ranging
from rescue operations in rubble up to terrorists'
movements tracking inside a building as well as other
law enforcement operations.
There were different techniques proposed using
millimeter electromagnetic radiation [18, 21], UWB
sounding signals [19], acoustic signals [20], etc.
This paper will present a brief overview of methods
for solving the problem of surveillance behind the
opaque wall.
One of methods for detecting moving objects be-
hind the wall, based on the analysis of reflected pulse
UWB signal is considered in more details. Demon-
stration of real work of the method is carried out with
use of the operating breadboard model of the device
implementing this method.
In this overview we restrict ourselves to the con-
sideration of radar techniques only.
First of all it is logical to consider continuous wave
(CW) and pulse radar systems. Both kinds of sound-
ing waveforms were considered to be used for
Through-the-Wall Surveillance (TWS). Pulse sound-
ing waveforms can be: short pulse (without intrapulse
modulation) and long pulse sounding waveforms with
intrapulse modulation [2]. Application of short pulses
is more frequent for TWS because of technological
reasons and absence of range sidelobes worsening
signal selection after processing.
In work [3], short pulse sounding waveforms with
carrier and without carrier (videopulses) were com-
pared, and pulses with carrier were recommended as
preferable because (according to [3]) matched filtra-
tion or correlation processing with transmitted signals
as templates are possible for them in contrast to pulses
without carrier. Nevertheless, the disadvantage of
pulses with carrier is the growth of signal attenuation
in construction materials with increasing frequency,
and this disadvantage may have a crucial influence in
some cases, particularly for thick and concrete walls.
Another classification distinguishes Doppler radars
[4] and interferometric radars [5, 6]. Doppler radar
usually uses CW sounding waveform but it can be
also a pulse (pulse-coherent) system.
While the Doppler and interferometric radars are
normally narrow band systems, the pulse TWS radars
[7, 8] are normally UWB systems.
2 Ultrawideband and Ultrashort Impulse Signals, 17-21 September, 2012, Sevastopol, Ukraine
There are some works on TWS radar based on
noise sounding waveforms [9, 10]
Various signal processing algorithms can be used
including even SAR principle [11] and compressed
sensing technology [22].
Development of the microwave ultra-wide band
step-frequency radar and application of the radar for
through-obstacles object detection and imaging sys-
tems is presented in [12]. The radar quickly sweeps
through frequency range sequentially generating a set
of equally distributed frequencies and collects re-
ceived signal on each frequency. Sensitivity of the
radar for the behind wall objects is improved by
build-in hardware first reflection suppression sub-
system. Tests of the system have shown its ability to:
track position of the target even behind three brick
walls; detect breathing and heartbeat of a human
throw several meters of soil; obtain image of human
behind wall by applying tomography processing to
data collected by the radar.
A noncoherent, stepped-frequency TWS system
approach, based on a trilateration technique, is pre-
sented in [13]. This approach involves multiple inde-
pendent radar units and, as such, provides flexibility
in positioning the units with various stand-off distanc-
es and inter-element spacing.
The interplay between coherent and non-coherent
data fusion in a widely distributed MIMO sensor net-
work is considered in [14] and seems to be a very
interesting topic.
Another attempt to use a MIMO configuration and
UWB signals in order to detect scatterers behind a
wall is discussed in [15], where method of Decompo-
sition of the Time Reversal Operator (DORT) is pro-
posed for detection and localization of a moving
target behind a wall. According to [15] one of the
DORT method major strengths is that detection re-
mains possible through a distorting medium.
Spectral variations of the reflections using
videopulses are used in UWB radar for human being
detection [16]. Novelty of the proposed [16] system
radar lies in its large operational bandwidth combined
with excellent time stability. It has been shown that
due to breathing the range to a person varies within
0.6 cm.
As a rule, operating frequencies in all methods are
rather high. They lie in the frequency band of 1 to 4
GHz. Due to strong attenuation of electromagnetic
radiation in the material of main walls a thick wall
still is a problem.
The proposed UWB system is based on the princi-
ple used previously in the prototype of ground pene-
trating radar (GPR) [17]. However in contrast to GPR,
which survey normally a stable situation under the
ground, in the system, a motion is the feature to detect
Actually a living person as any breather is always
characterized by a kind of motion including its wig-
gling and even a movement of the chest when breath-
ing. So, the system should detect any movement. Let
us distinguish between two kinds of movement: a)
indubitable movements like walking, and 2) small
movements, say, caused by breathing.
Actually, presence of a moving target causes
change of the situation behind the wall. Let us sup-
pose that we are able to compare the reflected signal
over a period of the order of
s. In this case we can
definitely detect the change of the situation, if a target
or any part of the target is changing its position during
s. Detection of a movement means presence of the
target in the resolution volume.
Two principle problems of this approach are re-
quired high resolution of the system and good pene-
trability of the radiation that is used.
In order to detect small movements a system with
high range resolution is necessary. Wideband and
UWB technology is suitable to solve the problem of
high resolution.
Another problem is to provide a detectable level of
reflection from the object behind the wall in spite of
twofold passage through the wall. All construction
materials and soils cause attenuation of a propagating
radiation (sounding signal). Especially important is
the fact that the attenuation on average increases con-
siderably when frequency increases. Therefore, for
penetration of the sounding signal through the thick-
ness of obstruction, the operating frequency of the
system should be as low as possible; and this is one of
the features of the accepted approach to design the
system. Thus, the system for searching people under
the rubble and behind thick walls should use an UWB
signal that maximizes the receive power at compara-
tively low operating frequency.
The operating principle of the system for searching
for people behind the wall and under the rubble is
illustrated in Fig. 1
Fig. 1. Operating principle of the system for
searching for people under the rubble or wall
The transmitter sends a short UWB pulse into the
direction of a wall or rubble. The receiver takes scat-
tering signals from different objects in rubble or be-
hind the wall. The processing system that can be
based on a laptop compares the signals over the given
Short Paper Title
Ultrawideband and Ultrashort Impulse Signals, 17-21 September, 2012, Sevastopol, Ukraine 3
If the shape of the signals was changed, there was a
movement. If there are no changes, that means no
The estimated parameters of the system prototype
are following:
Frequency range 100 ... 1000 MHz
The pulse duration 1 .. 10 ns
Maximum depth of detection (thickness of a wall)
up to 5 m
Average radiated power< 250 mW
The test of the system was done in the building us-
ing the plastered brick wall of about one meter thick-
ness. A man was sitting on the chair, making different
kind of movements, namely:
test 1: waving his hand from side to side;
test 2: bending the body from side to side;
test 3: just breathing, keeping the body in the stable
The result of the experiment is presented in Fig. 2,
where the screen of the laptop is indicated. One can
see very strong changes in the picture that correspond
to test 1 and test 2, as well as comparatively weak but
still detectable change of the picture corresponding to
test 3.
Fig. 2. Imaging of three types of movements (Test 1
is movement of a hand; Test 2 is movement of a body;
Test 3 is movement of a chest when breathing)
Another experiment was on detection a person who
walked up and down behind the combined (brick and
concrete) wall of 1 m thickness. The result is present-
ed in Fig. 3.
Fig. 3. The image of sequential (in time) situations,
when a person went past behind a thick (1 m) wall
seven times
There are a wide variety of UWB radar techniques
for TWS with different configurations, sounding sig-
nals and signal processing.
A possibility to detect moving objects under the
rubble and behind the thick wall with a simple low
cost UWB pulse radar has been demonstrated. Range
resolution is achieved using UWB signal. Relatively
big depth of penetration through the thick walls is
provided by “low” frequency.
High sensitivity of motion detection is provided by
special signal processing software. All parameters of
the implemented physical demonstrating model can be
significantly improved during the research work and
modernized prototype development.
1. Baranoski, E. J. 2008, ‘Through-wall imaging:
Historical perspective and future directions,’
Journal of the Franklin Institute, Vol. 345, 556-
2. Sachs, J., et al. 2008, ‘Detection and tracking of
moving or trapped people hidden by obstacles
using ultra-wideband pseudo-noise radar,’ Euro-
pean Radar Conference, EuRAD 2008, 408-411.
3. Chernyak, V. 2009, ‘On Probing Signals of
UWB Radars for Searching People trough Wall
and in Rubble,’ International Radar Symposium,
IRS 2009, 661-665.
4 Ultrawideband and Ultrashort Impulse Signals, 17-21 September, 2012, Sevastopol, Ukraine
4. Bimpas, M., Nikellis, K., Paraskevopoulos, N.,
Ecouonou, D., and Uzunoglu, N. 2003, ‘Devel-
opment and Testing of a Detector System for
Trapped Humans in Building Ruins,’ 33 Europe-
an Microwave Conference, October 2003, Vol. 3,
pp. 999 - 1002.
5. Arai, I. 2001, ‘Survivor Search Radar System for
Persons Trapped under Earthquake Rubble,’
Proceeding of the IEEE Microwave Conference,
Vol. 2, December 2001, pp. 663-668.
6. Chuang, H., Chen, Y., and Chen, K.M. 1999,
‘Microprocessor Controlled Automatic Clutter-
Cancellation Circuits for Microwave Systems to
Sense Physiological Movements Remotely
through the Rubble,Proceedings of the IEEE
International Conference on Instrumentation and
Measurement Technology, February 1999, pp.
7. Ossberger, G., Buchegger, T., Schimback, E.,
Stelzer, A., and Weigel, R. 2004, ‘Non-Invasive
Respiratory Movement Detection and Monitor-
ing of Hidden Humans Using Ultra Wideband
Pulse Radar,’ Proceedings of the International
Workshop on Ultrawideband Systems and Tech-
nologies, May 2004, pp. 395-399.
8. Prokhorenko, V. P., Ivashchuk, V. E., and
Korsun, S. V. 2004, ‘The VIY-2 Ground Pene-
trating Radar,’ Ultra Wideband and Ultra Short
Impulse Signals, UWBUSIS-2004, 19-22 Sep-
tember, 2004, Sevastopol, Ukraine, 1-3.
9. Narayanan, R. M. 2008, ‘Through-wall radar
imaging using UWB noise waveforms,’ Journal
of the Franklin Institute, vol. 345, no. 6, pp. 659-
10. Grodensky, Daniel, Kravitz, Daniel, and Zadok,
Avi 2012, ‘Ultra-Wideband Noise Radar Based
on Optical Waveform Generation,’ IEEE Pho-
tonics Technology Letters, Issue 10, May15,
2012, 839 – 841.
11. Jiabing Zhu, Hongmei Xu, Liang Tao, Yi Hong
2009, ‘An Analysis of Through-Wall Radar
Based on UWB Impulse Technique,’ 11th Inter-
national Radar Symposium, IRS 2010, 1-5.
12. Vertiy, A. A., Voynovskyy, I. V., Sunullah,
Özbek 2005, ‘Microwave through-obstacles life-
signs detection system,’ Microwaves, Radar and
Remote Sensing Symposium MRRS-2005, 261-
13. Fauzia, Ahmad, Amin, M. G. 2006,
‘Noncoherent approach to through-the-wall radar
localization,’ IEEE Transactions on Aerospace
and Electronic Systems, Vol.42, No 4, Oct 2006,
14. Thomä, R. S., Hirsch, O., Sachs, J., Zetik, R.
2007, ‘UWB Sensor Networks for Position Loca-
tion and Imaging of Objects and Environments,’
European Conference on Antennas and Propaga-
tion EUCAP 2007, 11-16 November 2007, Edin-
burg, UK, 1-9.
15. Davy M., Lepetit, T, de Rosny, J., Prada C., and
Fink, M. 2010, ‘Detection and Imaging of Hu-
man Beings Behind a Wall Using the Dort Meth-
od,’ Progress In Electromagnetics Research,
Vol. 110, 353-369.
16. Yarovoy, A. G., Ligthart, L. P., Matuzas, J., and
Levitas, B. 2006, ‘UWB Radar for Human Being
Detection,’ IEEE Aerospace and Electronic Sys-
tems Magazine, March 2006, 10-14.
17. Prokhorenko, V., Ivashchuk, V., Korsun, S., and
Stefanyshyn, I. 2006, ‘Ground Penetrating Radar
Survey in Podil’lya Karst Area (Ternopil Region,
Ukraine),’ 11th International Conference on
Ground Penetrating Radar, June 19-22, 2006,
Columbus Ohio, USA, 1-4.
18. Yanovsky, F. J. 2008, ‘Millimeter Wave Radar:
Principles and Applications,’ Book chapter in:
Millimeter Wave Technology in Wireless PAN,
LAN, and MAN, Editors: Shao-Qiu Xiao, Ming-
Tuo Zhou, Yan Zhang, Chapter 10, pp.305-376,
CRC Press, 464 pp.
19. Taylor, J. D. 2012, ‘Ultrawideband Radar: Ap-
plications and Design,’ May 18, 2012, CRC
Press 536 pp.
20. Yanovsky F. J., Sinitsyn R. B. 2006,
‘Ultrawideband Signal Processing Algorithms
for Radars and Sodars,’ 3d International Confer-
ence on Ultra Wideband and Ultra Short Impulse
Signals, UWBUSIS-2006, 18-22 September,
2006, Sevastopol, Ukraine, pp. 66-71.
21. González-Partida, J. T., Almorox-González, P.,
Burgos-García, M., Dorta-Naranjo, B. P., and
Alonso, J. I. 2009, ‘Through-the-Wall Surveil-
lance With Millimeter-Wave LFMCW Radars,’
IEEE Transactions on Geoscience and Remote
Sensing, Vol. 47, No. 6, June 2009, 1796-1805.
22. Suksmono, A. B., Bharata, E., A. Andaya Les-
tari, A. A., Yarovoy, A., and Ligthart, L.P. 2008,
‘A Compressive SFCW-GPR System,’ 12th In-
ternational Conference on Ground Penetrating
Radar, June 16-19, 2008, Birmingham, UK, 1-6.
... Now the specific "throw-the-wall" radars are widely used [1,2]. The application of recognition technologies based on neural networks provides additional possibilities of object radio images discrimination [3][4][5]. ...
Conference Paper
The algorithm of inverse aperture synthesis using generalized inverse filtering with evolutionary control realized in spatial frequency domain is considered. Optimal values of regularization parameters of filtration with evolutionary control by numerical simulation have been obtained. The optimal values provide the maximization of sharpness of the edges of the reconstructed radio image in combination with minimization of parasitic ripples in it. In contradistinction to the traditional inverse aperture synthesis for single-frequency signal, proposed approach is applied to the samples of signal obtained by transformation of multifrequency measured data to time domain. The suggested method provides improving sharpness of the radio image synthesized.
... In previous works we have developed ultra-wideband radars and signal processing for GPR [22], ultra-wideband noise radars in meteorology [14,21], investigated nonparametric signal processing methods for radars and acoustic radars [14,15,16,23], and suggested a new nonparametric variant of the ambiguity function -the copula ambiguity function [17], which we applied to wideband radars and sodars [18]. ...
Conference Paper
This paper describes briefly the basic ideas underlying different methods of determining the coordinates of objects by passive acoustic methods (passive acoustic location) for wideband acoustic signals, performs comparative analysis, and introduces a modified algorithm for localization of moving objects using the maximum of ambiguity function in application to passive acoustic localization of different noisy objects under various conditions
... At the same time the signals which are used in passive radars are wideband. Therefore, the methods, which are used in wideband radars are useful [19]. ...
Conference Paper
The moving target detection and tracking method for passive radars is investigated. The original algorithm, which is based on the wideband ambiguity function calculation, is suggested. The effectiveness of the suggested algorithm is proved by experimental measurements.
Conference Paper
The aim of the study is verification of applicability in space domain of the inverse filtering of the evolution control under noise presence for implementation of aperture synthesizing. We determine its resolution by testing the ability to resolve several closely placed objects. We used experimental data of radar scanning of metal strips with a horn antenna. To automate the process we use original software.
Conference Paper
This work is based on the theoretical and experimental examination of ground-penetrating radar (GPR) operation characteristics during real-time detection and identification of foreign objects burried into the subsoil media. A technical approch is proposed regarding the spatial diversity based on two receiving antennas ranged from the transmitter at the those distances that allow to estimate experimentally and theoretically the depth of the burried foreign object, its permittivity, as well as permittivities of the multilayered subsoil structures surrounded the baried object. This approach fully differs from the exiting canonical approaches and techniques that usually used transmitter and receiver antennas assembled together at the radar, and therefore, cannot exactly estimate parameters of the burried object. The created geometic-optical model of radio wave propagation through the multilayered subsoil structure containing inhomogeneous layers with different electrical parameters, permittivity, permeability and conductivity, accounting for refraction on layered structures and separately ranged receiving antennas, with respect to the transmitting one, gives precise prediction of the burried object depth, its electrical properties, and information on subsoil structures, comparing with actual expeiments carried out both in built-up areas and along the roads above the metopolitan underground routs.
This paper considers the problem of tomographic area mapping using radio frequency measurements gathered by a network of mobile nodes. Termed radio tomographic imaging, the technique has shown potential for object tracking, imaging static obstacles, and even through-wall imaging. Our approach addresses substantial issues for the practical implementation of such a system, namely, the mitigation of multipath signal effects and the characterization of a large number of uncalibrated network links. We propose a system that utilizes ultrawideband direct path signal strength measurements as a means of reducing the effects of the multipath fading. Furthermore, we address the estimation of unknown path loss and link bias parameters online through the framework of a linear mixed effects model. This permits the estimation of a static area map without a prohibitive calibration of these parameters prior to deployment, which is crucial in a network that may contain hundreds of links. Our model is posed as a convex optimization problem using the elastic net for regularization. Bayesian performance bounds are derived and our method shows positive results in simulation. We then demonstrate the efficacy of our solution on real tomographic data gathered from our cognitive spectrum operations testbed.
Full-text available
Conference Paper
Full-text available
Data acquisition speed is an inherent problem of the stepped-frequency continuous wave (SFCW) radars, which discouraging further usage and development of this technolo-gy. We propose an emerging paradigm called the compressed sensing (CS), to manage this problem. In the CS, a signal can be reconstructed exactly based on only a few samples below the Nyquist rate. Accordingly, the data acquisition speed can be increased significantly. A novel design of SFCW ground penetrating radar (GPR) with a high acquisition speed capa-bility is proposed and evaluated. Simulation by a monocycle waveform and actual measurement by a Vector Network Ana-lyzer in a GPR test-range confirm the implementability of the proposed system.
Full-text available
In recent years, through the wall imaging has become a topic of intense research due to its promising applications in police, fire and rescue or emergency relief operations. In this paper, we propose to use the DORT method (French acronym for Decomposition of the Time Reversal Operator) to detect and localize a moving target behind a wall. One of the DORT method major strengths is that detection remains possible through a distorting medium. In this paper, the DORT method is successfully applied to detect and track moving human beings behind a thick concrete wall. The smallest detectable displacement is also investigated.
Full-text available
This chapter gives a radar sight to millimeter-waves (MMW) propagation and scattering, considers radar principles, features of subsystems and components of MMW radars. Rather complicated notions of radar theory are stated in very simple manner as a kind of overview. Then application of MMW radar for Intelligent Transportation Systems (ITS) is analyzed in detail as the main section of the chapter. The role of radar sensor in ITS is shown, and frequency allocation for ITS radars is analyzed. Traffic Surveillance Radar that is an element of ITS infrastructure is described. Then automotive radars are categorized on long-range, medium-range and short-range, and each category is considered. On this basis different functional applications of automotive radar are briefly described. The accent is done to the radar-based communications for both car-to-car and entire ITS system. Necessity and possibility of data exchange using WLAN is indicated. MMW radars are employed in a wide range of commercial, military and scientific applications for remote sensing, safety, and measurements. That is why other important MMW radar applications are considered. Finally, the conclusion is done that MMW radar is a universal instrument for numerous promising applications and a device quite enable for a network use and data exchange via wireless networks.
Full-text available
A microwave-photonic ultra-wideband (UWB) noise radar system is proposed and demonstrated. The system brings together photonic generation of UWB waveforms and fiber-optic distribution. The UWB noise waveform is generated using the amplified spontaneous emission that is associated with either stimulated Brillouin scattering in a standard optical fiber, or with erbium-doped fiber amplification. Waveforms of more than 1-GHz bandwidth and arbitrary radio-frequency carriers are generated, and distributed over 10-km fiber to a remote antenna unit. Laboratory experiments demonstrate ranging measurements with 10-cm resolution.
Full-text available
The paper describes ground penetrating radar (GPR) survey in karst area of Podil'lya in Ternopil region, Ukraine that was fulfilled during 2005 year. The GPR exami- nation was made in Ulashkovska and Mlynky caves. The GPR was applied in Ozernaya cave for unknown cavities location. Owing to the GPR survey new gallery was discovered. The research demonstrates an efficiency of the GPR application in gypsum caves for search of discontinuities in rock and sedi- ment including cavities and cracked regions. It is shown that the GPR can also be used for human body detection behind a rocky crust. The results are useful for development of GPR operated in underground conditions, destined, for example, for location of coal gas accumulation and other objects in mines.
This paper examines the results of our research on the use of ultrawideband noise waveforms for imaging objects behind walls. The advantages of using thermally generated noise as a probing signal are introduced. The technique of heterodyne correlation used to inject coherence in the random noise probing signal and to collapse the wideband reflected signal into a single frequency are presented. Central to successful imaging through building walls is the characterization of the wideband propagation properties of wall materials and these are discussed. The basic concepts of synthetic aperture radar image formation using noise waveforms and the unique problems associated with the random nature of the transmit waveform are analyzed. We also address issues related to locating, detection, and tracking humans behind walls, using new tools for human activity characterization, namely the Hilbert-Huang Transform approach. The results indicate that noise radar technology combined with modern signal processing approaches is indeed a viable technique for covert high-resolution imaging of obscured stationary and moving targets.
Conference Paper
Through wall imaging is highly desirable for police, fire and rescue, first responder, and military applications. The ultimate desire of such system is to provide detailed information in areas that cannot be seen using conventional measures. Borrowing from successes in geological and medical imaging environments, researchers are applying radio frequency (RF) and other sensing modes to penetrate wall materials and make intelligent decisions about the contents of rooms and buildings. For this application, they are many propagation differences that provide unique challenges that must be addressed to make through wall penetration sensors operationally viable. This paper outlines the historical context of early research as well as providing new directions for future research in this exciting interplay between electromagnetic propagation, signal processing, and knowledge-based reasoning algorithms.
A microwave-photonic, ultra-wideband (UWB) noise radar system is proposed and demonstrated. The system brings together photonic generation of UWB waveforms and fiber-optic distribution. The use of UWB noise provides high ranging resolution and better immunity to interception and jamming. Distribution over fibers allows for the separation the radar-operating personnel and equipment from the location of the front-end. The noise waveforms are generated using the amplified spontaneous emission that is associated with stimulated Brillouin scattering in a standard optical fiber, or with an erbium-doped fiber amplifier. Our experiments demonstrate a proof of concept for an integrated radar system, driven by optically generated UWB noise waveforms of more than 1 GHz bandwidth that are distributed over 10 km distance. The detection of concealed metallic object and the resolving of two targets with the anticipated ranging resolution are reported.