ArticlePDF Available

The impact of Positive Reinforcement on Employees’ Performance in Organizations

DOI:10.4236/ajibm.2014.41002
Authors:
Assoc. Prof. Dr. Rashad Yazdanifard at Sunway University
Assoc. Prof. Dr. Rashad Yazdanifard
Download full-text PDF
Read full-text
Download citation

Abstract

Each employee’s performance is important in an organization. A way to motivate it is through the application of reinforcement theory which is developed by B. F. Skinner. One of the most commonly used methods is positive reinforcement in which one’s behavior is strengthened or increased based on consequences. This paper aims to review the impact of positive reinforcement on the performances of employees in organizations. It can be applied by utilizing extrinsic reward or intrinsic reward. Extrinsic rewards include salary, bonus and fringe benefit while intrinsic rewards are praise, encouragement and empowerment. By applying positive reinforcement in these factors, desired positive behaviors are encouraged and negative behaviors are eliminated. Financial and non-financial incentives have a positive relationship with the efficiency and effectiveness of staffs.
Content uploaded by Assoc. Prof. Dr. Rashad Yazdanifard
Author content
All content in this area was uploaded by Assoc. Prof. Dr. Rashad Yazdanifard on Feb 18, 2014
Content may be subject to copyright.
A preview of the PDF is not available
... These results underscore the significance of addressing areas in need of improvement to enhance overall performance. Additionally, the research literature highlights the efficacy of positive reinforcement-based consequences in organizational settings (Wei & Yazdanifard, 2014). ...
... Additionally, it would have been valuable to have a treatment group without the use of colored badges to isolate the effects of these extrinsic reinforcers. Previous studies have explored the impact of monetary rewards as extrinsic reinforcers (Scott, Farh, & Podsakoff, 1988;Wei & Yazdanifard, 2014), but analyzing the distinct nature of the badges used in this study would provide further insights. ...
IMPROVING CORPORATE COACHING THROUGH STRUCTURED FEEDBACK AND POSITIVE REINFORCEMENT IN A TELEMARKETING SETTING
Article
  • Jul 2023
This study investigates the effects of structured feedback and positive reinforcement on coaching quality within a telemarketing company. A corporate audit template was developed, consisting of five competency levels, allowing superior managers to provide personalized feedback to intermediate managers on the quality of their action plans for enhancing agents' performance. Additionally, five custom-designed badges, resembling the order of colors on karate belts, were implemented to publicly recognize the coaching quality of intermediate managers. These badges served as positive reinforcement for adhering to the criteria outlined in the audit template. Results revealed a significant improvement in coaching quality, as measured by the audit template, from pre-treatment to post-treatment and during a three-month follow-up period. The study also emphasizes the importance of utilizing scientific psychology to enhance performance beyond traditional methods such as in-class learning.
View
... The findings obtained from this study are also consistent with previous research (Al-Belushi & Khan, 2017), which states that monetary incentives have a direct influence on employee motivation. Besides, Wei and Yazdanifard (2014) confirmed that 'monetary and financial rewards lead to satisfaction over the short-term'. Mabaso and Dlamini (2018) believed that in terms of short-term benefits, 'tangible extrinsic rewards' may be advantageous to heighten employee's level effort and reduce discontent. ...
Impact of performance incentives on employees’ performance in a university in KwaZulu-Natal
Article
Full-text available
  • Nov 2023
Orientation: Rewarding employees for meeting the organisation’s targets is crucial in order to motivate staff members to improve their performance.Research purpose: The aim of the study was to investigate if the incentive plans given to the employees at a comprehensive university in KwaZulu-Natal province have a positive impact on employee performance.Motivation for the study: Studies linking the role of performance incentives in driving performance in higher education, specifically academics, are limited, and this study aims to fill this gap of knowledge in the literature.Research approach/design and method: The study followed a qualitative approach where data were collected through interviews. An investigation was conducted with academics in the Faculty of Commerce, Law and Administration on the role of performance incentives in driving performance at a faculty from a comprehensive university in KwaZulu-Natal. The collected data were analysed using NVIVO.Main findings: The overall findings of the study showed a strong link between performance incentives and employees’ performance. It was found that financial incentives in the form of performance bonuses influenced the employees to work harder to meet the performance targets.Practical/managerial implications: The results of this study will assist human resource managers in higher education institutions to identify financial and non-financial incentives that seek to drive performance.Contribution/value-add: The results of the study revealed a strong link between performance incentives and employee performance. For this reason, it will add value to the reward strategies employed by universities in improving performance.
View
... In addition, employee performance is tied to positive reinforcement, which is highly effective at strengthening and increasing behaviors. Salary, performance-based incentives, and fringe benefits are the most common reinforcers (Wei & Yazdanifard, 2014). These factors motivate employees to give their all to the company and perform at their best. ...
Correlation Between Reinforcers and Level of Self-Esteem
Article
Full-text available
  • Nov 2023
This study, conducted during the academic year 2022-2023 at the University of Cebu Main Campus, aimed to establish the correlation between effective reinforcers and the self-esteem of fourth-year psychology students. Utilizing the Slovin formula, a sample size of 120 students was selected from the total population of 166. The Descriptive Correlational Method was employed to explore the connection between effective reinforcers and self-esteem, with a focus on these senior students who might be susceptible to academic stress and burnout. The study employed the Rosenberg Self-Esteem questionnaire for self-esteem assessment and conducted a pilot test to ensure questionnaire reliability. Data were collected via Google Forms, and a chi-square test was utilized to assess the relationship between student profiles, self-esteem, and effective reinforcers. Also, the Wilcoxon Signed Rank Test was run to determine the relationship between self-esteem and effective reinforcers. The results revealed that natural reinforcers were the most effective in boosting self-esteem, with no significant relationship between student output and the variables. However, a significant connection was found between self-esteem and effective reinforcers. This study underscores the vital role of effective reinforcers in enhancing self-esteem.
View
... Sekiranya persekitaran tempat kerja telus dan selamat, pekerja turut terpengaruh untuk mencipta potensi serta keupayaan berdasarkan persekitaran kerja yang sihat. Dengan itu syarikat mendapat manfaat tenaga kerja yang lebih berdaya saing dan memiliki idea baharu dan kreativiti untuk perkembangan syarikat (Kajian Wei & Yazdanifard, 2014). Salah satu kaedah yang paling biasa digunakan ialah peneguhan positif, dengan tingkah laku seseorang itu diperkukuh atau meningkat berdasarkan akibat. ...
Teori-Teori Terpilih dalam Sains Sosial
Book
Full-text available
  • Sep 2023
Buku ini dimulakan denganmembincangkan teori klasik dalam pembentukan identiti etnik iaitu teori primordial, teori instrumental dan teori konstruktivisme. Ketiga-tiga teori ini adalah perintis kepada perbahasan identiti etnik sehingga terbentuknya identiti ‘biracial’ dan identiti ‘multiracial’ dan persoalan identiti nasionalisme. Walaupun teori ini telah muncul lebih kurang 60 tahun lampau, sehingga kini masih digunakan oleh para sarjana dalam membuktikan kesahihan kajian mereka. Amat penting mengenal dan mendalami kesemua teori ini dalam mengenal pasti bagaimana sesebuah kumpulan etnik menentukan identiti etnik mereka sehingga menjadi satu gugusan etnik yang kukuh sehingga hari ini. Teori primordial melihat identiti adalah tetap dan sudah tersedia ada dalam setiap kumpulan. Manakala teori instrumental dan konstruktivisme pula berada dalam kategori situasional iaitu identiti etnik adalah mengikut situasi. Sumbangan dan kritikan terhadap teori-teori tersebut turut dibincangkan dengan lebih jelas dalam bab ini.
View
... Positive reinforcement, according to (Catania, 2001), is a strategy that adds rewards and incentives rather than removing advantages in order to elicit and enhance new behaviors. It may be used at work through perks, compensation, and advancement opportunities (Wei and Yazdanifard, 2014). When a subject has learned a new behavior in the next stage, an intermittent reinforcement plan might be applied (Skinner, 1965(Skinner, , 1989Woolfolk, 1998). ...
Application of Gamification model in the internship orientation program: A proposed conceptual model from the private university context of BangladeshStaj oryantasyon programında Oyunlaştırma modelinin uygulanması: Bangladeş'teki özel üniversite bağlamından önerilen bir kavramsal model
Article
Full-text available
  • Jun 2023
Even though Bangladesh ranks 8th in the world in terms of population density, it is one of the countries with the most underdeveloped manpower resources in the world. In order to stimulate learning within the masses, the demand for flipped classroom settings and innovative phenomena like gamification can appear as a solution. In this paper, the idea of gamification has been explored as a teaching mechanism for the pre-internship training for the graduate school students. For this purpose, two models have been presented, which respects the previously established theories.
View
... Appreciation and recognition have been frequently documented as motivators for public service delivery among public sector employees. This is in accordance with the positive reinforcement theory that when employees are recognized by their manager, they feel appreciated and strives to perform better (Wei and Yazdanifard, 2014). ...
An exploratory study of workplace spirituality and employee well-being affecting public service motivation: an institutional perspective
Article
  • Nov 2021
Purpose The present study aimed to find out the relationship of public service motivation (PSM) with other positive aspects, that is workplace spirituality and employee well-being among academic staff of public sector higher education institutions. Design/methodology/approach In order to capture the full picture of the institutional factors that may be responsible for initiating and improving public service motivation among employees, 23 interviews were carried out with employees placed in leadership positions in the public sector universities. The data were qualitatively analyzed through NVivo 12 to gain institutional perspective regarding various organizational factors that could influence PSM. Findings The finding of this study elaborates that, although PSM is a personal attribute of the individual, there are many other organizational factors that exert a substantial effect in promoting PSM. The results of qualitative data also affirmed a significant relationship between PSM and workplace spirituality (a type of organizational culture) and the influence of employee well-being in improving the motivation of public employees towards service provision. Research limitations/implications The data were collected from the specific population that is academic staff of public sector universities which limits the generalizability of the results. Practical implications PSM is a vital concept in public organizations where individuals must understand and focus on public concerns to improve the quality of public service. Therefore, public sector organizations faced the challenge of nurturing an organizational culture in which selfless public service becomes the norm and individuals are driven by the effective accomplishments of their services. Therefore, an organization that is highly oriented towards spirituality likely to improve employee well-being, which is a challenging and important concept in organizations in promoting PSM among employees. Originality/value This study is unique in terms of identifying workplace spirituality and employee well-being as organizational influencers in promoting PSM among employees.
View
... For example, Susanto, Lim, Linda, Tarigan, and Wijaya (2011) established that positive reinforcement directly stimulates happiness, motivation, and consequently, productivity among individuals. Similarly, Wei and Yazdanifard (2014) discovered that positive reinforcement improves employees" performance, where financial and non-financial rewards lead to staff members' efficiency and effectiveness. Additionally, while reinforcement or reward is acknowledged for increasing motivation, Cameron and Pierce (1994) found that verbal praise and positive feedback enhance individuals" intrinsic interest. ...
Paid but underpaid: Stipend and work productivity among graduate interns
Article
Full-text available
  • Mar 2023
Graduate unemployment is one of the major socioeconomic development problems in South Africa and many other developing countries. Previous research has described various factors causing graduate unemployment, one of which is a lack of relevant work experience. Internships are increasingly supported to address this problem. However, internships have been criticised for being exploitative, illegal, and unjust. This paper seeks to present a new perspective on internships. It seeks to examine the perspectives on the impact of stipend level on graduate intern work productivity. Thus, the objectives of this study are to: explore the impact of stipend level on the work productivity of graduate interns; explore the exploitative nature of internship as perceived by participants; and explore the concerns of graduate interns over compensation. This study is qualitative and exploratory in nature. Fifty semi-structured interviews were conducted with interns, mentors, and HR managers at eThekwini municipality, Durban, South Africa, to address these research objectives. Data from interviews Indexed by IBSS, EBSCO, ERIH PLUS, COPERNICUS, ProQuest, SABINET and J-Gate. Volume 13, Number 1, March 2023 pp 265-286 Paid but underpaid: Stipend and work productivity … 266 was analysed through thematic analysis. The results indicate that there is a relationship between the level of stipend earned by interns and their work productivity. This study found that low pay is associated with low work productivity. Therefore, work compensation is the primary motivator of productivity, not only for full-time employees but also for graduate interns.
View
Empowering Human Development: Bridging the Skills Gap for IR 4.0 through Digital Transformation addressing ICT, IoT, and Artificial Intelligence
Thesis
  • Sep 2023
Globally, ICT and artificial intelligence are powerful tools that enhance millions of people’s quality of life. Besides providing access to healthcare, education, and financial services, they can also reduce poverty and inequality. In addition, they enhance pro- ductivity, efficiency, and safety at work. As Bangladesh faces development challenges, particularly concerning its workforce, this report focuses on how AI (artificial intelli- gence) and ICT knowledge development can reduce the skills gap between graduates and industrial workers based on current market demand. To explore the topic of employ- ability and the skills gap between recent graduates and industry demand, the author conducted a thorough review of previous studies and collected data from 2014 to 2022. This resulted in over 100 publications, refined through manual filtering to a final selec- tion of 42 for the study. Throughout the research report, we learn about the labor force’s potential, the need for education and training, and the impact of the Fourth Industrial Revolution. This research analysis included a project to improve basic ICT skills and industries’ automated machine operational knowledge by installing additional AI (artifi- cial intelligence) and ICT (information and communication technology) equipment. The project is expected to provide the labor force with the skills required to transition from manual labor to high-tech jobs. It also seeks to increase job opportunities for the labor force and provide them with the training they need to take advantage of them. Finally, the project is expected to reduce poverty and inequality in Bangladesh. Moreover, the project contributes to UN Sustainable Development Goals 4, 8, and 9 by aligning with Bangladesh’s Perspective Plan 2021–2041. Keywords— Artificial intelligence, Decent work, Industrial labor, Industrial revolution 4.0, Market demand, Project management, Quality Education, Skill development, Sustainable Development Goal
View
“HappyBin” Remodifying Social Behaviors
Conference Paper
  • Jul 2023
In most Indian cities, the littering problem stems from a lack of awareness and the unavailability of resources. The new smart cities call for more innovative approaches to solve challenges related to waste disposal. Hence, engaging people and spreading awareness about the appropriate use of dustbins are essential. HappyBin is a design project that tries to modify people’s behavior by harnessing the power of positive reinforcement, IoT, and behavioral theories. The project aimed to change the perception of dustbins in India and make them an integral part of the urban landscape. This behavioral change will lead to efficient dustbins and improved waste disposal. The research project includes designing and prototyping HappyBin, testing and conducting a user survey. The various feedbacks from the users were analyzed to improve the product. We found that “HappyBin” achieved two critical goals: Firstly, it generated curiosity among the users due to its innovativeness and instant gratification. Secondly, the overall design of the HappyBin changed the perception of dustbins through its simple functionality and engagement with the users. Thus, this research paper highlights that the power of smart design combined with behavioral studies can develop a new genre of interactive products that leads to a better society.
View
Sustainability Targets in Executive Remuneration Contracts and Corporate Sustainability Performance in the United Kingdom and European Union
Article
Full-text available
  • Mar 2023
This study investigates the impact of the integration of sustainability criteria in executive remuneration on corporate sustainability performance (CSP). The paper tests the pooled OLS models on a cross-country sample comprising 279 firms from 19 European Union countries and the United Kingdom under the period from 2014 to 2018. The results suggest that there is a significant positive impact of sustainability-related executive remuneration on CSP. Furthermore, there is no significant statistical evidence for the moderating impact of the sustainability committee on the relationship between sustainability-related contracting and CSP. Moreover, the results reveal that the moderating effects of official CSR disclosure and external assurance for sustainability reports are significantly negative. We suggest that regulators and practitioners promote the integration of sustainability targets in executive remuneration to improve CSP and review the quality of sustainability reporting systems.
View
Assessment of effect of empowerment on employees performance (case study telecommunication company)
Article
Full-text available
  • Mar 2018
The main purpose of this paper is to determining the effect of Empowerment implementation by considering the three factors of delegation, implementation of participating management, encouragement and giving reward and also determination of classification of priority and importance of effect of each factor with employee’s performance improvement in Golestan Telecommunication Company in Iran. The research method has been descriptive and causal comparative and statistical sample under study was 226 people in order to collected data, two questionnaires and existing documents about rate of employee performance were used in two periods of time before and after Empowerment implementation. The tools validity with Content method and their Reliability by Cornbach method coefficients 0.98, 0.95 has been confirmed. In order to analyze the data, Spearman correlation method, Wilcoxon tests method, and multiple regressions, were used. Findings showed that there is significant difference between rate of employee’s performance before and after Empowerment implementing, by the way Empowerment implementing emphasizing the factors, delegation, participating management and encouragement and giving reward cause employee’s performance to improve.
View
View
THE USE OF NON-MONETARY MOTIVATORS IN SMALL BUSINESS
Article
Full-text available
The present paper provides small business owners and entrepreneurs with a variety of techniques that can be used to motivate employees without increasing salaries. Small business owners and entrepreneurs have an advantage over larger businesses by being able to know their employees, treating them as individuals, and tying rewards to the things that these employees value. The things that employees might value, such as being treated with respect and having a flexible work schedule, might be an advantage that small businesses can offer, which might increase the ability of small business owners to attract and retain quality employees. Additionally, employees can be developed in ways that will benefit both the employee and the small business, and represents a level of involvement that these employees might not find in larger organizations. These actions by small businesses can result in situations where the performance of small businesses can be improved without tying up limited financial resources.
View
Performance pay improves engagement, progress, and satisfaction in computer-based job skills training of low-income adults
Article
Full-text available
Advancing the education of low-income adults could increase employment and income, but adult education programs have not successfully engaged low-income adults. Monetary reinforcement may be effective in promoting progress in adult education. This experiment evaluated the benefits of providing incentives for performance in a job-skills training program for low-income, unemployed adults. Participants worked on typing and keypad programs for 7 months. Participants randomly assigned to Group A (n = 23) earned hourly and productivity pay on the typing program (productivity pay), but earned only equalized hourly pay on the keypad program (hourly pay). Group B (n = 19) participants had the opposite contingencies. Participants worked more on, advanced further on, and preferred their productivity pay program. These results show that monetary incentives can increase performance in a job-skills training program, and indicate that payment in adult education programs should be delivered contingent on performance in the training program instead of simply on attendance.
View
Punishment as a Price to Pay
Article
Full-text available
  • Mar 2012
Management meted out punishment to enforce rules and encourage adherence. However, the effectiveness depended on how the employees perceive and interpret the policy. Therefore, it was uncertain how to best achieve the target. The paper tested employees’ behavioral responses in two conditions, when employees had to pay fines to employer and when employees had to pay fines to co-workers. Condition one was a typical deterrence policy implemented to punish misconduct in an organization, and condition two tested the behavioral responses to distributive outcomes. Questionnaire was distributed to these employees to investigate perception. The experimental results indicated that employees responded differently to the two conditions, misconduct was significantly reduced in condition two but not in condition one. While employees agreed that the implementation was fair in the two conditions, they did not agree on the punishment outcomes in condition two. The employees perceived paying fines to employer was more acceptable than paying fines to co-workers. Accounting for social norms in the implementation was more successful than formal deterrence.
View
The Impact Of Reward And Recognition Programs On Employee's Motivation And Satisfaction A Co Relational Study
Article
Full-text available
  • Jan 2008
This study highlighted "the impact of reward and recognition programs on employee's motivation and satisfaction" . The study was conducted from October till December; 2008 the Sample chosen for the study is 80 employees of UNILEVER companies. The factors affecting satisfaction were identified; payment (0.86**), promotion (0.74**), working condition (0.61**), personal(0.37*) as Analysis showed immense support for positive relationship between REWARD and EMPLOYEE SATISFICTION. All these results are statistically significant thus providing rigor and generalizability in research. This exploratory study suggests for the positive relationship between reward and satisfaction
View
View
View
Is the Use of Short-Term Incentives Good Organization Strategy?
Article
  • Jan 2013
This article is based on research conducted on Jamaica’s hotel industry. The study sought to determine if there are any advantages to both employers and employees in use of short-term incentives in that industry. Using theories of motivation and the concepts governing incentive compensation to construct a theoretical framework, the article sought to make the link between short-term incentives, motivation and employee productivity. The debate by both academicians and human resource practitioners is about the right types as well as the right mix of workplace motivators. It is acknowledged that there are strong arguments on all sides. This article seeks to add to the academic debate by advancing that what is critical is that (a) the need for employee motivation should not be viewed as optional but must be fully appreciated, planned and implemented thoughtfully by employers; and (b) the motivational processes used will be influenced by the thinking of an organization’s leadership team as well as the culture of the organization. It is posited for this discussion that where organizations are on a quest to improve workforce productivity, their employees need to be motivated by a combination of intrinsic and extrinsic rewards. In turn, the right types and levels of motivation will lead to employees performing at the desired levels.
View
Birmingham City Council links increased contribution and outcomes to reward and recognition
Article
  • Jul 2011
Purpose Describes how a fair and transparent reward system based on performance is giving greater control over outcomes, retaining the best staff for the future and saving money. Methodology/approach/design Explains that the new performance development review (PDR) system has been delivered as part of the award‐winning Excellence in People Management project, which has modernized and refocused people‐management practice at Birmingham City Council, UK. Findings Reveals that the PDR process has given Birmingham City Council the ability to manage effective performance and behaviors and link pay progression to performance rather than time served. Practical implications Details how managers now have the tools to manage their own staff more effectively. Social implications Shows that the PDR has shifted the performance focus more toward how employees contribute to achieving effective outcomes for the citizens of Birmingham and the behaviors employees need to demonstrate. Originality/value Explains that staff that feel valued and rewarded, are more committed and motivated, and are more willing to go the extra mile. Increased productivity and performance, combined with the abolition of incremental pay increases, has realized a saving of around £6m so far.
View