Article

A centenary review of transport planning in Canberra, Australia

Authors:
To read the full-text of this research, you can request a copy directly from the author.

Abstract

For the most important periods in its 100-year history, Canberra, Australia, has been planned around the car, with eliminating traffic congestion the number one planning goal. During the last decade, this vision of Canberra has been increasingly questioned, with both Territory and Commonwealth planning bodies advocating a more ‘transit-oriented’ urban form. Trends in transport usage rates and mode shares have not, however, followed the new planning directions: the car remains dominant, while public transport usage rates remain much lower than those achieved in Canberra in past decades.

No full-text available

Request Full-text Paper PDF

To read the full-text of this research,
you can request a copy directly from the author.

... The proposal centered on Capital Hill and was planned around three main axes: the first is the main axis from south to north, with the central triangular section of this axis as the center of the city, around which are arranged political, cultural, and artistic national buildings; the second is east-west through the Griffin Lake visual axis, with the western side of the Black Mountain as the opposite view; the third is the axis from Capital Hill to the city's commercial and service centers, forming a visual corridor. The third axis is the visual corridor from Capital Hill to the city's commercial and service centers, which also serves as one of the city's main transportation routes [17,18]. The scheme was influenced by the Washington planning, the 'city beautification movement', and the 'idyllic city', and used the topography to set up urban axes, with a network of polygons and radial roads to form a coherent whole. ...
Article
Full-text available
In recent years, the development of urbanization in China has entered a new stage with “quality” as its core. In the process of sustainable urban development, urban planning and construction relics are precious historical warnings and educational resources, and in the stage of accelerated urbanization, social transformation, and industrial upgrading, urban sites face severe pressure and challenges for conservation. This paper presents a summary analysis of various international charters concerning historical and cultural heritage in recent times, and analyzes the urban spatial structure, urban functional zoning, and the differences and evolutionary characteristics of urban construction sites between the pseudo-Manchukuo Xinjing plan and other regions of the world in the same period from a global perspective. The city of Changchun is also used as an example to systematically analyze the existing relics in Changchun using a historical-geographical perspective and spatial analysis methods. The results show that, firstly, the conservation objects of Chinese relics are being enriched and the scope of protection is being expanded, but that there is a lack of protection and utilization of urban heritage and its surrounding environment. Secondly, that the road network system and spatial structure of the pseudo-Manchukuo Xinjing city planning are basically preserved, that the urban green space and functional zoning have been changed, and that the architectural relics show a spatial distribution trend of north-north-east. Thirdly, that the urban functional zoning has been used to construct an urban relics protection area in which three suggestions for the protection of urban relics have been put forward: to establish a holistic protection system for urban planning functional areas; to establish a “district-axis-point” trinity protection model to promote the effective function recovery of urban planning and construction functional areas; and to continue the effective functions of the city. This provides reference for the study of modern urban planning ideas and solutions for current sustainable urban development, upgrading of public service facilities, and green low-carbon urban transformation.
... Despite of these results, there is an ongoing debate on whether hard policies alone lead to reduced car use (Stopher, 2004), and on whether soft policies have a direct effect on reduced car use (Möser & Bamberg, 2008). In parallel to this, there are many promising TDM policy interventions, especially soft policies, applied both in small and large scale cases with successful results, mostly in the developed world (Mees, 2014;Richter et al., 2010). Therefore, it is believed that TDM policies offer noteworthy potentials (Bueno, Gomez, Peters, & Vassallo, 2017;Petrunoff, Wen, & Rissel, 2016). ...
Article
Designed as an 'ideal city' and emblem of the nation, Canberra has long been a source of ambivalence for many Australians. In this charming and concise book, Nicholas Brown challenges these ideas and looks beyond the clichés to illuminate the unique, layered and often colourful history of Australia's capital. Brown covers Canberra's selection as the site of the national capital, the turbulent path of Walter Burley Griffin's plan for the city and the many phases of its construction. He surveys citizens' diverse experiences of the city, the impact of the Second World War on Canberra's growth and explores the city's political history with insight and wit. A History of Canberra is informed by the interplay of three themes central to Canberra's identity: government, community and environment. Canberra's distinctive social and cultural history as a centre for the public service and national institutions is vividly rendered.
Conference Paper
Full-text available
The objective of current paper is to provide an impressionistic overview of 19 papers, taken from academic journals, that narrate histories of urban transport, and to consider how insights from this overview might be used in the construction of narratives of future urban transport. The selected papers provide narratives of specific cities as well as those of urban transport developments on broader scales (i.e. national and continental), and put particular emphasis upon changes in the transport system in the 1960s and 1970s, which was a period of great transition both in urban transport and in the wider economy more generally. Given the widely different geo-political trajectories of different world regions in this period, narratives are restricted to the (relatively homogenous) ‘western democracies’, covering (most of) Western Europe, North America and Australia. A distinction is made between the historical aspects of the papers (the events that are recounted by the narratives) and their historiographical aspects (how the histories are written). The paper concludes that it is the former that are more controversial when being used to help think about the future, and suggests that transport futures thinking can be enhanced by seeing the analogies between changes in the transport system in the 1960s/70s and potential changes in a future transition period associated with the ‘end of neoliberalism’.
Article
Full-text available
Article
Bus rapid transit (BRT) is increasingly advocated as a lower-cost, more flexible alternative to urban rail, with Ottawa hailed as the pre-eminent BRT success story. However, there has been little detailed analysis of the effectiveness of Ottawa's BRT system in bringing about a mode shift away from the car. This article seeks to address this deficiency by analysing the performance of the city's public transport and the role of BRT in this performance. We conclude that public transport in Ottawa can indeed be considered successful, but that BRT is not the main reason for this success. The cause was rather an integrated package of policies introduced in the 1970s, which changed the relative convenience of car and public transport travel. These policies, rather than the precise technology used for the trunk section of the public tranport system, should be the focus of planning for reduced automobile dependence.
Article
Canberra will in a few years reach the limits of sensible urbanisation within the ACT. Urban policy for Canberra over the last two decades has taken on the perspectives of a city-state, not interested in the prospect of urban life beyond its walls. This might explain why ACT planners and administrators have embraced the urban consolidation fad so avidly as to foster a huge oversupply of medium-density dwellings against strong community resistance.
Article
a b s t r a c t Public transport faces an increasingly intense conflict between patronage goals and coverage goals. Broadly speaking, patronage goals seek to maximize patronage of all types, while coverage goals lead to the provision of service despite low patronage – to achieve social inclusion objectives for example. The conflict between these goals follows inevitably from the underlying structure of the public transport product, including both its costs and geometry. The tradeoff between patronage and coverage is the type of value-judgment that elected officials are paid to make. The paper presents a means of quantifying the tradeoff, to facilitate public discussion and decisions on how to balance these priorities. These strategies are designed to ensure that the decision about how to balance social versus patronage goals is made consciously rather than inadvertently, with a clear understanding of the consequences of the choice.
Canberra's planners suppress the transit city
  • La Trahison
La Trahison des Clercs: Canberra's planners suppress the transit city............................ 17
24 6.2. Bellingham to the rescue
  • A European
  • ............................................................................................... Transport
A European city with an American transport system?....................................... 24 6.2. Bellingham to the rescue........................................................... 25
Canberra: Myths and models. Hamburg: Institute of Asian Affairs
  • K F Fischer
Fischer, K. F. (1984). Canberra: Myths and models. Hamburg: Institute of Asian Affairs.
Gordon Stephenson and the long term planning of Canberra. Paper presented at the 14th International Planning History Society Conference
  • R Freestone
Freestone, R. (2010). Gordon Stephenson and the long term planning of Canberra. Paper presented at the 14th International Planning History Society Conference.
Planning for man and motor: Gordon Stephen-son's 'experimental' Canberra neighbourhoods. Paper presented at the 3rd World Planning Schools Conference
  • R Freestone
Freestone, R. (2011). Planning for man and motor: Gordon Stephen-son's 'experimental' Canberra neighbourhoods. Paper presented at the 3rd World Planning Schools Conference. Govt has no overall strategy on buses: Coe. (12 February 2012).
Review of ACTION's Services
  • R Graham
Graham, R. (1997). Review of ACTION's Services. Canberra.
Walter Burley Griff, landscape, architect. Can-berra: National Library of Australia
  • P Harrison
Harrison, P. (1995). Walter Burley Griff, landscape, architect. Can-berra: National Library of Australia.
Gough Whitlam: A moment in history
  • J Hocking
Hocking, J. (2008). Gough Whitlam: A moment in history. Melbourne: Miegunyah Press.
Principles and practice of town and country planning
  • L Keeble
Keeble, L. (1968). Principles and practice of town and country planning (4th ed.). London: The Estates Press.
Fifty years of public transport planning in Canber
  • P Mees
Mees, P. (2012). Fifty years of public transport planning in Canber-rahttp://www.atrf.info/papers/2012/2012_Mees.pdf.
Canberra and the car: A love story
  • P Mees
Mees, P. (2013). Canberra and the car: A love story?.
Transport policy at the crossroads: Travel to work in Australian capital cities
  • P Mees
  • L Groenhart
Mees, P., & Groenhart, L. (2012). Transport policy at the crossroads: Travel to work in Australian capital cities 1976–2011.
The Canberra Short Term Transportation Study ACT strategic public transport network plan: Final report The Griffin Legacy Canberra Area Transportation Study The Future Canberra Tomorrow's Canberra: Planning for Growth and Change Annual report
  • R Morris
  • O Flaherty
  • C Paterson
Morris, R., O'Flaherty, C., & Paterson, J. (1976). The Canberra Short Term Transportation Study. MRCagney. (2009). ACT strategic public transport network plan: Final report. Canberra: MRCagney. NCA. (2004). The Griffin Legacy. Canberra: NCA. NCDC. (1961). Canberra Area Transportation Study. Canberra: NCDC. P. Mees / Progress in Planning 87 (2014) 1–32 NCDC. (1965). The Future Canberra. Sydney: Angus & Robertson. NCDC. (1970). Tomorrow's Canberra: Planning for Growth and Change. Canberra. NCDC. (1974). Annual report 1973–1974.
Metropolitan issues Metropolitan issues: Transport (single-page flyer)
  • Ncdc Canberra
  • Ncdc
Canberra: NCDC. NCDC. (1980a). Metropolitan issues. Canberra: NCDC. NCDC. (1980b). Metropolitan issues: Transport (single-page flyer).
Metropolitan Canberra Y-Plan Review: 3. Transport and Environment Metropolitan Canberra: Policy plan, development plan The way we are Metropolitan Canberra: Urban Consolidation
  • Ncdc Canberra
  • Ncdc
Canberra: NCDC. NCDC. (1984a). Metropolitan Canberra Y-Plan Review: 3. Transport and Environment. Canberra: NCDC. NCDC. (1984b). Metropolitan Canberra: Policy plan, development plan. Canberra: NCDC. NCDC. (1985). The way we are. Canberra: NCDC. NCDC. (1986). Metropolitan Canberra: Urban Consolidation, Tech-nical Paper 50. Canberra: NCDC.
Towards a more sustainable Canberra. Perth: Institute for Science and Technology Policy Principles of Urban Consolidation
  • P Newman
  • J Kenworthy
Newman, P., & Kenworthy, J. (1991). Towards a more sustainable Canberra. Perth: Institute for Science and Technology Policy, Murdoch University. Nielsen Associates. (1986). Principles of Urban Consolidation', in NCDC (1986).
Public Transport – Planning the networks, HiTrans Best Practice Guide 2 Canberra Short Term Transport Planning Study
  • G Nielsen
Nielsen, G. (2005). Public Transport – Planning the networks, HiTrans Best Practice Guide 2. Stavanger, Norway. Pak-Poy & Associates Pty. Ltd., & John Paterson Urban Systems Pty. Ltd. (1977). Canberra Short Term Transport Planning Study. Canberra.
The changing nature of planning: From Philo-sopher King to Municipal Dog Catcher
  • J Paterson
Paterson, J. (1976). The changing nature of planning: From Philo-sopher King to Municipal Dog Catcher.
Canberra Melbourne: Melbourne University Press. Response to Commissioner's Report
  • J Reps
Reps, J. (1997). Canberra 1912. Melbourne: Melbourne University Press. Response to Commissioner's Report. (1975). Appendix B. In NCDCM (Ed.), Molonglo Arterial, Canberra: Technical paper
Transportation Requirements for Canberra. Paper presented at Canberra 63: The 1963 Canberra Convention. Canberra: Royal Aust. Planning Inst Readings in urban transportation
  • A B Sinclair
Sinclair, A. B. (1973). Transportation Requirements for Canberra. Paper presented at Canberra 63: The 1963 Canberra Convention. Canberra: Royal Aust. Planning Inst. Smerk, G. M. (Ed.). (1968). Readings in urban transportation. Bloomington: Indiana University Press. Standing Committee on Planning and Urban Services. (2001). Propo-sals for the Gungahlin Drive Extension, Report No. 67. Canberra.
Long Term Planning for Canberra. Paper presented at Canberra 63: The 1963 Canberra Convention
  • G Stephenson
  • P Harrison
Stephenson, G., & Harrison, P. (1973). Long Term Planning for Canberra. Paper presented at Canberra 63: The 1963 Canberra Convention. Canberra: RAPI. Stone, J., & Mees, P. (2011). Spatial distribution of the journey to work by sustainable modes in Australian cities.
Ideas for Australian cities Melbourne: Georgian House
  • H Stretton
Stretton, H. (1975). Ideas for Australian cities (2nd ed.). Melbourne: Georgian House.
Canberra land use transportation study: General plan concept Timed transfer system planning, design and operation
  • A M Voorhees
  • Pty Ltd
Voorhees, A. M., & Associates Pty Ltd. (1967). Canberra land use transportation study: General plan concept. Mclean, Virginia. Vuchic, V., Clarke, R., & Molinero, A. (1981). Timed transfer system planning, design and operation. Washington, DC: University of Pennsylvania.