ArticlePDF Available

Why Tough Tactics Fail and Rapport Gets Results: Observing Rapport-Based Interpersonal Techniques (ORBIT) to Generate Useful Information From Terrorists

DOI:10.1037/a0034564
Authors:
Laurence John Alison at University of Liverpool
Laurence John Alison
Emily Alison at University of Liverpool
Emily Alison
Geraldine Noone at University of Liverpool
Geraldine Noone
Stamatis Elntib at The Open University (UK)
Stamatis Elntib
Show all 5 authorsHide
Download full-text PDF
Read full-text
Download citation

Abstract and Figures

This field observation examines 58 police interrogators’ rapport-based behaviors with terrorist suspects; specifically, whether rapport helps elicit meaningful intelligence and information. The Observing Rapport-Based Interpersonal Techniques (ORBIT; Alison, Alison, Elntib & Noone, 2012) is a coding framework with 3 elements. The first 2 measures are as follows: (i) 5 strategies adopted from the motivational interviewing (Miller & Rollnick, 2009) literature in the counseling domain: autonomy, acceptance, adaptation, empathy, and evocation and (ii) an “Interpersonal Behavior Circle” (adopted from Interpersonal theories, Leary, 1957) for coding interpersonal interactions between interrogator and suspect along 2 orthogonal dimensions (authoritative-passive and challenging-cooperative); where each quadrant has an interpersonally adaptive and maladaptive variant. The third (outcome) measure of ORBIT includes a measure of evidentially useful information (the “interview yield”) and considers the extent to which suspects reveal information pertaining to capability, opportunity and motive as well as evidence relevant to people, actions, locations and times. Data included 418 video interviews (representing 288 hours of footage), with all suspects subsequently convicted for a variety of terrorist offenses. Structural equation modeling revealed that motivational interviewing was positively associated with adaptive interpersonal behavior from the suspect, which, in turn, increased interview yield. Conversely, even minimal expression of maladaptive interpersonal interrogator behavior increased maladaptive interviewee behavior as well as directly reducing yield. The study provides the first well-defined and empirically validated analysis of the benefits of a rapport-based, interpersonally skilled approach to interviewing terrorists in an operational field setting. (PsycINFO Database Record (c) 2013 APA, all rights reserved)
Figures - uploaded by Laurence John Alison
Author content
All figure content in this area was uploaded by Laurence John Alison
Content may be subject to copyright.
Content uploaded by Laurence John Alison
Author content
All content in this area was uploaded by Laurence John Alison on Jun 27, 2014
Content may be subject to copyright.
A preview of the PDF is not available
  • A preview of this full-text is provided by American Psychological Association.
  • Learn more
Preview content only
Content available from Psychology Public Policy and Law
This content is subject to copyright. Terms and conditions apply.
... PLATO details are of interest in intelligence-gathering settings because specific types of information are at times needed to link events or to comprehend what happened during the target event (Alison et al., 2013;Soufan, 2011). Complications and verifiable sources can also result in more intelligence. ...
EXPOSING SUSPECTS TO THEIR SKETCHES 1 Exposing Suspects to Their Sketches in Repeated Interviews to Elicit Information and Veracity Cues
Article
Full-text available
  • Nov 2023
Research has shown that sketching while narrating facilitates the elicitation of information and verbal veracity cues in single interviews. We examined if these effects are retained when suspects are shown their sketch after one week in a repeated interview. Participants (N = 173) completed a mock mission and then told the truth or lied about it in an immediate interview (Interview 1). Participants either verbally reported the mission (Free recall condition) or sketched it while describing what they were sketching (Sketch condition). After one week, all participants were asked for a free recall without sketching (Interview 2). Half of the participants in the Sketch condition had access to their sketch while they verbally reported the event whereas the remaining half did not access the sketch. Truth tellers provided more information than lie tellers in both interviews, and sketching elicited more information than a Free recall but only in Interview 1. Participants who had access to their sketch in Interview 2 repeated more information than those who did not have access, but accessing the sketch did not have an effect on veracity cues. Thus, sketching enhanced the elicitation of information in Interview 1 and access to the sketch in Interview 2 seemed helpful for recalling previously reported information.
View
... Other researchers expanded upon these tactics by incorporating principles of motivational interviewing ('MI') and interpersonal circle theory to create Observing Rapport-Based Interpersonal Techniques ('ORBIT'), a research tool initially used to study the impact of rapport-based interview techniques on information elicitation. 68 The MI is a directive, client-centred counselling style that helps clients resolve ambivalence and change behaviour. The interpersonal circle theory maps adaptive interview behaviours (responses that lead to a positive outcome) and maladaptive interview behaviours (responses that lead to negative outcome) to promote interpersonal competence and versatility. ...
Interviewing and Interrogation: A Review of Research and Practice Since World War II E-Offprint
Chapter
Full-text available
  • Nov 2023
This chapter describes the evolution of suspect interview training at the US Department of Homeland Security Federal Law Enforcement Training Centers (FLETC). This evolution reflects recent advances in empirical understanding of harmful and beneficial interview practices along with the development of new evidence-based techniques. This chapter firsts present an overview of FLETC’s previous training, which centered around the Five Step Interview Model. Next discussed are several challenges and facilitators associated with the transition of research findings into practice. The chapter concludes with a description of research that influenced FLETC’s transition to their current evidence-based interview training along with a summary of this current training.
View
... Offense characteristics associated with confession relate mostly to the nature of the crime and its gravity, a less serious or nonviolent crime being more readily confessed to (Holmberg & Christianson, 2002;Moston et al., 1992;St -Yves, 2002). Finally, situational factors most influencing suspectsÕ decision to confess are the perceived quality of evidence held against them (Brimbal & Luke, 2019;Moston & Engelberg, 2011), not having used legal advice (Deslauriers-Varin et al., 2009;Snook et al., 2015;Stephenson & Moston, 1994), and the interrogation techniques and strategies used by investigators -empathetic approaches favoring confession (Alison et al., 2013;Clemens et al., 2020;Holmberg & Christianson, 2002;Kebbell et al., 2008). However, the study of different types of factors separately is insufficient, as it does not take into account the dynamic and multifactorial reality of investigative interviewing (Deslauriers-Varin, 2022). ...
Intrinsic and extrinsic factors associated with confession in an investigative interviewing context among men who have committed a sexual offense
Article
Full-text available
  • Jul 2023
Very few studies have evaluated the combination of factors enabling the prediction of the confession of a sexual offense. This is particularly worrying when considering that confession rates are lower among those who have committed a sexual offense compared to those having committed other types of crime, and their confession is often the sole evidence available. A case-control study was conducted to (1) examine individual characteristics, offense details, and situational factors predicting the confession of a sexual offense, and (2) elaborate a multivariate model to better understand the decision to confess. Seventy-eight adult males convicted of sexual offenses were recruited at the Regional Reception Centre, a federal correctional facility located in Quebec (Canada). They were divided into two groups (confessors versus nonconfessors). Results highlighted the contribution of situational factors pertaining to the investigation (e.g., type of evidence, consultation of a lawyer, setting of the interrogation room) related to the confession of sexual offending. The results also support the use of integrative approaches that take into account individual, offense and situational factors in investigative interviews seeking confession of a sexual offense. Further discussion is offered in relation to the implications of the present findings for police practices in the interrogation room. Keywords; Investigative interviewing, sexual offending, confession, police, Quebec
View
... This highlights the practical need to move away from deceptive tactics and toward a practice characterized by frank and forthright communication. 35 Third, a perception that the interviewer was willing to accept risk and accountability for how he supported the source increased affective trust perceptions while also showing a negative impact on cognitive trust perceptions. As such, interviewers must carefully balance risk perceptions when engaging in trust-building efforts by, for example, avoiding actions that might be viewed as unethical or inappropriate. ...
View
Police interviewers’ experiences of the Tactical Interview Model (TIM): an exploratory study of suspect interviewing in Norway
Article
  • Nov 2023
The purpose of the study was to qualitatively explore how police investigators in Norway experience interviewing suspects. Specifically, we sought to investigate the relationship between theory (the Tactical Interview Model) and practice concerning how police interviewers establish the interviewee’s account and disclose potential evidence-related information. To explore processes relevant to the research objective, four focus group interviews of police interviewers were conducted (n = 29). The data was analysed using a thematic analysis which resulted in four main themes: (1) Planning and preparing: considering potentially evidence-relevant information – Its possible value, alternative explanations, and influence on the interview process, (2) Establishing rapport and balancing dilemmas: Providing sufficient information without affecting the interviewee’s account, (3) Exploring the interviewee’s account through questioning and ‘closing doors’, and (4) Challenge through clarification: disclosure of potential evidence-related information and adapting to the interviewee. The findings are discussed in relation to the Tactical Interview Model. Implications for practice and future directions are presented.
View
Criminal justice interventions for preventing radicalisation, violent extremism and terrorism: An evidence and gap map
Article
  • Nov 2023
Background Criminal justice agencies are well positioned to help prevent the radicalisation of individuals and groups, stop those radicalised from engaging in violence, and reduce the likelihood of terrorist attacks. This Evidence and Gap Map (EGM) presents the existing evidence and gaps in the evaluation research. Objectives To identify the existing evidence that considers the effectiveness of criminal justice interventions in preventing radicalisation, violent extremism and terrorism. Search Methods We conducted a comprehensive search of the academic and grey literature to locate relevant studies for the EGM. Our search locations included the Global Policing Database (GPD), eight electronic platforms encompassing over 20 academic databases, five trial registries and over 30 government and non‐government websites. The systematic search was carried out between 8 June 2022 and 1 August 2022. Selection Criteria We captured criminal justice interventions published between January 2002 and December 2021 that aimed to prevent radicalisation, violent extremism, and/or terrorism. Criminal justice agencies were broadly defined to include police, courts, and corrections (both custodial and community). Eligible populations included criminal justice practitioners, places, communities or family members, victims, or individuals/groups who are radicalised or at risk of becoming radicalised. Our map includes systematic reviews, randomised controlled trials, and strong quasi‐experimental studies. We placed no limits on study outcomes, language, or geographic location. Data Collection and Analysis Our screening approach differed slightly for the different sources, but all documents were assessed in the systematic review software program DistillerSR on the same final eligibility criteria. Once included, we extracted information from studies using a standardised form that allowed us to collect key data for our EGM. Eligible systematic reviews were assessed for risk of bias using the AMSTAR 2 critical appraisal tool. Main Results The systematic search identified 63,763 unique records. After screening, there were 70 studies eligible for the EGM (from 71 documents), of which two were systematic reviews (assessed as moderate quality), 16 were randomised controlled trials, and 52 were strong quasi‐experimental studies. The majority of studies ( n = 58) reported on policing interventions. Limited evidence was found related to courts or corrections interventions. The impact of these interventions was measured by a wide variety of outcomes ( n = 50). These measures were thematically grouped under nine broad categories including (1) terrorism, (2) extremism or radicalisation, (3) non‐terror related crime and recidivism, (4) citizen perceptions/intentions toward the criminal justice system and government, (5) psychosocial, (6) criminal justice practitioner behaviours/attitudes/beliefs, (7) racially targeted criminal justice practices, (8) investigation efficacy, and (9) organisational factors. The most commonly assessed outcomes included measures of terrorism, investigation efficacy, and organisational factors. Very limited research assessed intervention effectiveness against measures of extremism and/or radicalisation. Authors’ Conclusions Conducting high‐quality evaluation research on rare and hidden problems presents a challenge for criminal justice research. The map reveals a number of significant gaps in studies evaluating criminal justice responses to terrorism and radicalisation. We conclude that future research should focus attention on studies that consolidate sound measurement of terrorism‐related outcomes to better capture the potential benefits and harms of counter‐terrorism programs, policies and practices which involve criminal justice agencies.
View
View
View
View
Rapport como técnica para obtenção de informações em Entrevistas Investigativas
Article
Full-text available
  • Aug 2023
Em uma investigação criminal, as oitivas de vítimas, testemunhas e suspeitos possuem papel central na elucidação do caso. Estudos empíricos das últimas décadas apontam que estabelecer o rapport, um relacionamento positivo e livre de julgamento entre entrevistado e entrevistador, é uma técnica que aumenta a quantidade e a qualidade das informações coletadas de vítimas, testemunhas e suspeitos. Neste artigo, apresentamos uma revisão do estado da arte da literatura científica no que tange à utilização do rapport no contexto investigativo. São apresentados os diferentes componentes do rapport (atenção mútua, positividade e coordenação), para então discutir, por meio de evidências de estudos empíricos, como a entrevista com testemunhas, vítimas e suspeitos pode ser mais efetiva. Por fim, é exposto como o rapporté utilizado nos principais protocolos internacionais de entrevistas investigativas, assim como recomendações para aplicação na prática policial brasileira.
View
Interpersonal Problems, Attachment Styles, and Outcome in Brief Dynamic Psychotherapy
Article
Full-text available
  • Aug 1993
The Inventory of Interpersonal Problems (IIP) has been used to identify dysfunctional patterns in interpersonal interactions. Interpersonal problems can be organized in two dimensions, and the two-dimensional space can be divided into eight equal sectors (octants). Subscales of the IIP describe each of these octants. The instrument has been used to identify (a) interpersonal problems that are discussed most often in a brief dynamic psychotherapy and (b) problems that are treated most easily. The results show that problems in the “exploitable” octant improve most frequently, whereas problems in the “dominating,” “vindictive,” and “cold” octants do not improve as readily. Attachment styles in adulthood were examined (following a model proposed by Bowlby), and different attachment styles were found to correspond to different types of interpersonal problems. Finally, these variables were related to the ability to describe other people clearly. The article also discusses implications for brief dynamic psychotherapy.
View
The SAGE Handbook of Personality Theory and Assessment: Volume 1 — Personality Theories and Models
Book
Full-text available
  • Jan 2008
A definitive, authoritative and up-to-date resource for anyone interested in the theories, models and assessment methods used for understanding the many factes of Human personality and individual differences. Volume 1: Personality Theories and Models deals with the major theoretical models underlying personality instruments.
View
View
View
Psychotherapy and the interpersonal octagon
Article
The interpersonal octagon is a theoretical structure within which relating is defined along a close/distant, horizontal axis and an upper/lower, vertical axis. Its eight octants are created by inserting intermediate positions between the four poles of the axes. The theory distinguishes between positive (competent) and negative (incompetent) relating. The Person's Relating to Others Questionnaire (PROQ2) measures negative relating. It has eight scales which correspond to the eight octants. Three NHS psychotherapycentres have routinely administered the PROQ2 to patients at the start and at the end of therapy over a number of years. In a combined sample of 219 patients from the three centres, significant drops in mean PROQ2 scores were recorded on six of the eight scales. Women patients had higher start of therapy scores than men but recorded larger drops. One centre tested a limited sample of 51 patients at the time of assessmentfor therapy and another limited sample of 56 patients at the time of follow-up. In the first, no significant changes in mean scores were recorded from time of assessment to start of therapy. In the second, thedrop in mean scores at follow-up was slightly less impressive than at the end of therapy.
View
View
The effect of rapport in forensic interviewing
Article
  • Jun 2002
The psychological literature suggests that establishing rapport between interviewer and subject – whether in clinical, experimental or forensic settings – is likely to enhance the quality of the interaction. Yet there are surprisingly few studies that test this assumption. This article reports a study of the effect of rapport on eyewitness recall of a dramatic videotaped event by creating three interviewer-attitude conditions – “rapport”, “neutral” and “abrupt”. Participants were randomly assigned to the three conditions, and recall was elicited by two methods – free narrative and a semi-structured questionnaire. The results indicate participants in the rapport interview recalled more correct information, and the same amount of incorrect information as participants in the other two conditions. However, prompting via the semi-structured questionnaire yielded additional correct as well as incorrect information for the neutral and abrupt conditions. The results are discussed for their relevance to interviews conducted in forensic settings, and to highlight the need for more specific and improved interview training for police and other justice personnel.
View
View
View
View