ArticlePDF Available

Farming in a rural settlement in central Italy: cultural and environmental implications of crop production through the transition from Lombard to Frankish influence (8th–11th centuries A.D.)


Abstract and Figures

Plant macrofossil (carpological) and morpho-metric analyses were carried out on plant remains from the medieval castle of Miranduolo, Siena, a rural settlement in central Italy with a long sequence of occupation between the 8th and the 11th centuries A.D. The presence of Triticum aestivum/durum and Vicia faba var. minor from the first phase of the Lombard farming village suggests continuity with the agricultural tradition of the preceding Roman world, and the use of good cultivation techniques that allowed quality yields to be obtained from rather poor soils. At the same time, the significant presence of the primitive cereal T. monococcum, compared with the ar-chaeobotanical literature of north-central Italy, allows to us consider it as a ''cultural'' element of Lombard farming. In the next cultural phases, with the Carolingian manor and then with the feudal castle, the stable presence of T. aes-tivum/durum and the reduction of T. monococcum in favour of more productive cereals such as Secale cereale and Hordeum vulgare indicate a further improvement in pro-ductivity. This is also confirmed by the appearance of fruits and nuts such as Castanea sativa, Vitis vinifera and Prunus persica. The increase in caryopsis sizes of T. monococcum and T. aestivum/durum in the transition from the village to the manorial phase is a consequence of the improvements in farming. The decrease in caryopsis size of T. mono-coccum from the manor phase to that of the castle testifies the decreasing importance of this cereal. The good date resolution of this research allows us to detect the crops, the storage and the processing practices, as well as the changing role of crop plants in the rural economy. This highlights the geographical, historical-cultural and political factors of the medieval transition from the Lombard to the Carolingian and then to the feudal period in central Italy.
Content may be subject to copyright.
Farming in a rural settlement in central Italy: cultural
and environmental implications of crop production
through the transition from Lombard to Frankish influence
(8th–11th centuries A.D.)
Mauro Buonincontri Daniela Moser
Emilia Allevato Boris Basile Gaetano Di Pasquale
Received: 14 May 2013 / Accepted: 19 December 2013
ÓSpringer-Verlag Berlin Heidelberg 2014
Abstract Plant macrofossil (carpological) and morpho-
metric analyses were carried out on plant remains from the
medieval castle of Miranduolo, Siena, a rural settlement in
central Italy with a long sequence of occupation between
the 8th and the 11th centuries A.D. The presence of Triticum
aestivum/durum and Vicia faba var. minor from the first
phase of the Lombard farming village suggests continuity
with the agricultural tradition of the preceding Roman
world, and the use of good cultivation techniques that
allowed quality yields to be obtained from rather poor
soils. At the same time, the significant presence of the
primitive cereal T. monococcum, compared with the ar-
chaeobotanical literature of north-central Italy, allows to us
consider it as a ‘‘cultural’’ element of Lombard farming. In
the next cultural phases, with the Carolingian manor and
then with the feudal castle, the stable presence of T. aes-
tivum/durum and the reduction of T. monococcum in favour
of more productive cereals such as Secale cereale and
Hordeum vulgare indicate a further improvement in pro-
ductivity. This is also confirmed by the appearance of fruits
and nuts such as Castanea sativa,Vitis vinifera and Prunus
persica. The increase in caryopsis sizes of T. monococcum
and T. aestivum/durum in the transition from the village to
the manorial phase is a consequence of the improvements
in farming. The decrease in caryopsis size of T. mono-
coccum from the manor phase to that of the castle testifies
the decreasing importance of this cereal. The good date
resolution of this research allows us to detect the crops, the
storage and the processing practices, as well as the
changing role of crop plants in the rural economy. This
highlights the geographical, historical-cultural and political
factors of the medieval transition from the Lombard to the
Carolingian and then to the feudal period in central Italy.
Keywords Farming history Middle Ages Seeds/fruits
Morphometric analysis Triticum aestivum/durum
Triticum monococcum
Since 2001 the castle of Miranduolo, 40 km from Siena,
southern Tuscany, Italy, has been the focus of archaeo-
logical investigations by the University of Siena (Fig. 1a;
Valenti 2006,2009,2011). This excavation belongs to a
wider research programme which has been carried out for
decades on the settlement history of west-central Italy
between the end of the late Roman period and the middle
centuries of the medieval period. In the province of Siena,
archaeological investigations have shown that after a first
phase of spontaneous occupation of the hilltops during the
7th century A.D., a reorganization of settlements started
from the 8th century A.D., due to the presence of the
Lombard and Carolingian aristocracies (Augenti 2000;
Francovich and Hodges 2003; Valenti 2004; Bianchi
2010), which held their power by land ownership and
For central Italy, historians have always considered the
medieval farming economy as backward in comparison
Communicated by F. Bittmann.
Electronic supplementary material The online version of this
article (doi:10.1007/s00334-013-0429-8) contains supplementary
material, which is available to authorized users.
M. Buonincontri (&)D. Moser E. Allevato B. Basile
G. Di Pasquale
Laboratory of Vegetation History and Wood Anatomy,
Department of Agriculture, University of Naples ‘‘Federico II’’,
Via Universita
`, 100, 80055 Portici, Italy
Veget Hist Archaeobot
DOI 10.1007/s00334-013-0429-8
with the preceding Roman economy. Medieval farming
was characterized by subsistence agriculture, mainly aim-
ing to diversify farming to avoid the consequences of poor
harvests (Montanari 1979). Even though the medieval
agricultural system was characterized by a surprising
variety of crops, historians consider it inadequate because
of the decline of wheat cultivation and the predominance of
minor cereals and small grains (Montanari 1979,2002;
Andreolli 1981; Cortonesi 2002). In spite of the great
potential for archaeobotanical analysis, the data relevant to
the Italian peninsula are mostly published in grey literature,
which is often difficult to trace (for a review of archaeo-
botanical studies in the Middle Ages, see Grasso and Fio-
rentino 2009).
The archaeobotanical data from northern Italy show an
agricultural world in crisis both in urban and rural sites
(Castelletti and Maspero 1988; Castelletti and Motella De
Carlo 1999; Castiglioni et al. 1999; Nisbet 1999; Augenti
Fig. 1 The archaeological site of Miranduolo. aLocation map of the
site, bAerial view of the castle of Miranduolo (Source http://; cThe landscape sur-
rounding the site: arable field along the river Merse and hills of the
Colline Metallifere; dPlan of the archaeological features of the vil-
lage phase, second half of the 8th century A.D. to first half of the 9th
century A.D.(Source modified
pmapper/map.phtml); e, Plan of the archaeological features of the
manor phase, second half of the 9th century A.D. to last quarter of the
10th century A.D.; fPlan of the archaeological features of the castle
phase, last quarter of the 10th century A.D. to first quarter of the 11th
century A.D
Veget Hist Archaeobot
et al. 2006). Only from the 10th c. A.D. did farming again
become rich and diverse, reaching the quality of the Roman
period, and supplying food to urban markets in Firenze/
Florence (Buonincontri et al. 2007a; Mariotti Lippi et al.
2013), Ferrara (Bandini Mazzanti et al. 2005; Bosi et al.
2009) and Parma (Bosi et al. 2011) between the Communal
Age, based on allegiances between city states, and the
The geographical distribution of cultivated cereals does
not fully agree with those reported by historical sources.
Indeed, the high spatial resolution of archaeobotanical data
detects the peculiarity related to local environmental con-
ditions such as climate and soils, and to different socio-
cultural factors. Archaeobotanical research shows that
crops of the Roman period persisted in those areas sub-
jected to strong political-ecclesiastical controls, where the
climate was favourable and soils were fertile (Castelletti
1977; Costantini et al. 1983; Van der Veen 1985; Bakels
2002; Caracuta and Fiorentino 2009). The analysis of the
botanical remains from Miranduolo provides a special
opportunity to improve our knowledge of plant husbandry
during the Middle Ages in central Italy, providing infor-
mation about the crops, the storage and the processing
practices. One particular feature of interest, due to the long
time span covered, is to detect the roles and the changes of
crop plants in the economic agrarian system.
Study area
The territory of Miranduolo is located on the eastern slopes
of the hilly area of the Colline Metallifere, between 350
and 750 m a.s.l., 40 km southwest of Siena (Fig. 1a), and it
is crossed by the river Merse on the plain located to the
north. The closest meteorological station of Pentolina
(450 m a.s.l.) indicates minimum average temperatures of
the coldest month (February) of 2 °C and maximum
average temperatures of the hottest month (August) of
29 °C; rainfall is around 1,000–1,100 mm/year.
Mixed deciduous woodlands, mainly of Quercus cerris
L. (turkey oak) and Q. pubescens Willd. (downy oak),
cover the surrounding area; abandoned Castanea sativa
Miller (chestnut) stands with several ancient trees are also
present. On the tops of the hills, evergreen vegetation is
dominated by Q. ilex L. (holly oak). In the plain close to
the river Merse, natural vegetation is represented by iso-
lated trees of downy oak and Fraxinus oxycarpa Bieb.
(ash), as well as by riparian vegetation with Populus nigra
L. (poplar), Salix alba L., S. caprea L. and S. eleagnus L.
The soils on the hillsides are rather infertile; the plains
consist of fluvial deposits (Fig. 1c) and locally of sandy
and clay soils, with some chalk, which are a limiting factor
for the yields of crops (Costantini et al. 2006; Regione
Toscana unpublished).
The presence of the castle, located on a hill at 411 m a.s.l.
(Fig. 1b), is attested by historical sources from the end of the
10th century A.D., but archaeological excavation has shown
that there had been three earlier phases of settlement (Valenti
2006). Miranduolo was firstly settled in the Lombard period in
the 7th century A.D. as a mining village of huts with a church.
In the second half of the 8th century A.D. it became a farming
village, consisting of peasants’ huts with silo pits for crop
storage (Fig. 1d). From the second half of the 9th century A.D.,
during the Carolingian period, the village developed into a
manor (Fig. 1e). In this phase, the top of the hill became the
manorial court, defended by two ditches and a fence, with
several barns and other buildings related to crop processing.
This area was controlled by a lord who directed agricultural
production. The village was located on the lower part of the
hill (Fig. 1e). The stone castle was built from the last quarter
of the 10th century; in this phase, the settlement arrangement
did not change. The defended area of the hilltop was still used
for food processing and storage (Fig. 1f). Several fires
affected the site and these caused charring and the preserva-
tion of a great quantity of botanical material in the stores.
Materials and methods
Samples were taken from 20 archaeological layers which
are referred to here as stratigraphic units (SUs), consisting
of fills of silo pits and occupation surfaces, related to ten
archaeological structures and 13 contexts (Table 1). With
the term ‘‘archaeological structure’’ we indicate the pre-
sumed function of the features, such as storehouses, huts or
silos, in each phase of the settlement. Every archaeological
structure includes a ‘‘context’’, consisting of various SUs,
showing the activities and events there. The remains from
SUs relating to floors, storage areas and the collapsed
remains of the same archaeological structures (hut C24,
storehouse C01, ditch F06 and storehouse C12) were ana-
lyzed together. In the silo pits, only sediments from the
bottom were sampled.
Sediment samples were labelled according to the SU.
Structure identification follows the same numbering system
as the excavation webgis (
8080/pmapper/map.phtml). SUs cover three chronological
ranges: the village, the manor, and the castle phases
(Table 1). The total volume of the treated sediment was
408 l and the volume per sample ranged from 2 to 60 l
(Table 1).
The samples were processed with an ‘‘Ankara’’ type flo-
tation machine equipped with a 0.5 mm mesh in the floating
tank. Floated-out macroremains were recovered from mesh
sizes 4, 2, 1, 0.50 and 0.25 mm. After the flotation, the heavier
Veget Hist Archaeobot
residues were screened for other organic remains. All recov-
ered plant remains were observed; subsamples were analysed
only in five cases (50 % of each fraction from SUs 320, 1215
and 1228; 75 % from SUs 1103 and 1193). Seeds and fruits
were separated into ‘‘individuals’’ and ‘‘fragments’’ and then
counted. We use the term ‘‘individual’’ when the fragments
had diagnostic features that allowed us to count them as entire,
following the principle of the ‘‘minimum number of indi-
viduals’’ (Jones 1990; Antolı
`n and Buxo
`2011): for cereals
this was when the embryo end of the grain was preserved, for
pulses when the hilum was preserved, and for grape pips when
the stalk was preserved. Identified fragments without these
characteristics were counted and named as fragments.
The taxonomical identification was carried out by
comparing with a reference seed collection, atlases and
specialist literature (Renfrew 1973; Schoch et al. 1988;
Viggiani 1991; Hubbard 1992; Maier 1996; Sadori and
Susanna 2005). Since grain remains of naked wheat cannot
be identified to species (Maier 1996; Alonso Martinez
2005; Ruas et al. 2005; Jacomet 2008), the term Triticum
aestivum/durum is used in accordance with Jacomet
All percentages and frequencies were calculated for
each taxon considering only the individuals and excluding
the fragments; rachis forks were included in percentage
calculations for cereals; similarly grape pedicels were
considered in the calculations for fruits. When only frag-
ments were available for specific taxa, these were consid-
ered as individuals.
The archaeobotanical record is an obvious source of data
for examining changes in plant morphology associated with
the cultivation process (Lepofsky et al. 1998). For each
studied settlement phase, the length, the width, and the
thickness of50 caryopses belonging to T. aestivum/durum and
T. monococcum were measured following Van Zeist (1970)
and Hubbard (1992). Caryopses from central Florence dated
to the 13th–14th centuries were also measured, so as to pro-
vide an external comparison (Buonincontri et al. 2007a;
Buonincontri unpublished data). The comparison with
remains from a different chrono-cultural context provided the
opportunity to obtain important information about the capa-
bilities and the changes in medieval crop growing. For these
measurements we used only intact caryopses without any
deformation or protrusions deriving from charring. The
Table 1 List of samples from Miranduolo
Chronology Archaeological structure SU Sample vol. (l) Feature
Village phase 2nd half 8th–1st half 9th c. A.D. Hut C24 95 2 Layer from the floor
97 2 Layer from the floor
Hut C26 320* 20 Fill of the silo pit
Manor phase 2nd half 9th–last quarter 10th c. A.D. Hut C28 125 4 Fill of the silo pit
Warehouse C01 150 60 Layer from the storing surface
162 24 Layer from the storing surface
238 12 Layer from the storing surface
239 12 Layer from the storing surface
400 24 Layer from the storing surface
Ditch F06 211 24 Collapse of the warehouse C01
212 12 Collapse of the warehouse C01
Warehouse C12 1215* 12 Layer from the surface of storing
Storage area SF11 1228 5 Fill of the silo pit A
1344* 40 Fill of the silo pit B
1361* 9 Fill of the silo pit C
1364 29 Fill of the silo pit D
Castle phase Last quarter 10th–1st quarter 11th c. A.D. Warehouse EDM04 558 24 Layer from the storing surface
Warehouse C12 1103 24 Layer from the storing surface
1193* 60 Layer from the storing surface
Crop processing area
1153 9 Layer from the floor
Sequence of the stratigraphic units (SU) sampled, grouped by archaeological context of provenance and chronological phase of settlement. The
volume of sediment sampled is indicated for each sample. The asterisks indicate the SU of provenance of caryopses submitted for biometric
analysis: with regard to the village phase the caryopses come from the silo pit of hut C26; with regard to the manor phase they come from the silo
pits B and C of the storage area SF11 and from the surface of storehouse C12; with regard to the castle phase, they come from the surface of the
warehouse C12
Veget Hist Archaeobot
length, the width and the thickness data were used to estimate
the volume of each caryopsis, assuming their shape as an
ellipsoid. The significance of differences between settlement
phases was assessed by one-way analysis of variance
(ANOVA) using the Duncan test (PB0.05) as a post hoc test
for separation of means. One-way ANOVA is a statistical tool
that examines the significance of difference in the means of a
quantitative parameter among two or more groups defined by
a categorical variable (treatment). In our study the quantita-
tive parameters were the caryopsis length, width, thickness
and volume, and the categorical variable was the ‘‘settlement
phase’’ that divided our individuals into four groups (village,
manor, castle and Florence). The term ‘‘one-way’’ refers to the
fact that only one categorical variable was included in the
analysis. Since ANOVA does not provide information about
the significance of the difference between specific couples of
means, we used the Duncan’s multiple range to test the sig-
nificance of the difference between any pair of means. All the
statistical analyses were performed using the SPSS statistical
software package (IBM SPSS Statistics, IBM Corporation,
Somers, NY, USA).
The results are given as absolute counts and grouped by
archaeological structures and related contexts in ESM 1;
silo pits were kept separate to show information about
storage techniques.
A total of 104,878 charred remains were recovered; a
total of 39 taxa were identified and these included 25
cultivated or cultivable taxa, 13 weed taxa and one taxon of
woody wild plants (ESM 1). Crop plants were the most
common remains found in all the studied phases. In the
8th–9th centuries A.D. village, crops represented 94.7 % of
the remains (Fig. 2), 99.5 % in the 9th–10th centuries A.D.
manor (Fig. 3) and 95.8 % in the 10th–11th centuries A.D.
castle (Fig. 4).
Crop plants
The village phase: from the 2nd half of the 8th century A.D.
to the 1st half of the 9th century A.D.
Eleven taxa, all crop plants, including seven cereal taxa
were identified (ESM 1; Fig. 2). The data from the floor
represent what was used during the period of occupation of
the hut: cereals were predominant, but only three taxa were
present. T. monococcum was the most represented cereal
(46.8 %) followed by T. aestivum/durum (35.1 %),
whereas hulled Hordeum vulgare (4.3 %) and Avena sp.
(3.2 %) were less abundant. In the silo, where all seven
taxa were found, T. aestivum/durum was most common
(51.2 %), followed by T. monococcum (20.2 %), Avena sp.
(13.1 %), Panicum miliaceum (8.3 %) and hulled H.
vulgare (3.6 %); Secale cereale and T. dicoccum were less
than 1 %.
Fig. 2 Crop plants from the
village phase (second half of the
8th century A.D. to first half of
the 9th century A.D.): graphs by
phase and archaeological
context. The pie graphs show
the percentages of each
taxonomic group out of the total
individuals recovered; the bar
graphs show the percentages of
the individuals of the taxa from
the total sum of cereals and
legumes; for raw data see ESM
Veget Hist Archaeobot
Four taxa were identified among pulses (Fig. 2). Spo-
radic remains of seeds of Lathyrus sp. were found in both
the contexts. Vicia faba var. minor and V. ervilia were
found only in the silo pit, whereas cf. Pisum was found
only in the hut.
The manor phase: from the 2nd half of the 9th century A.D.
to the last quarter of the 10th century A.D.
Preliminary results from the storehouse C12 and the floor
in SF08 have already been reported by Buonincontri et al.
Fig. 3 Crop plants from the
manor phase (second half of the
9th century A.D. to last quarter of
the 10th century A.D.): graphs
by phase and archaeological
context; silo pits were kept
separate to collect information
about storage techniques. The
pie graphs show the percentages
of each taxonomic group out of
the total individuals recovered;
the bar graphs show the
percentages of the individual
taxa from the total sum of
cereals, legumes and fruits. In
contexts where only fragments
of a taxon were found, these
specimens have been included,
for raw data see ESM 1 (Plan
Veget Hist Archaeobot
(2007b); in this study we are presenting the complete
dataset. 21 taxa among the 33 identified were crop plants
(ESM 1; Fig. 3). Cereals predominate in the seed assem-
blage with ten taxa (Fig. 3). In the silo pits located in the
storage area, T. aestivum/durum,T. monococcum, hulled H.
vulgare and P. miliaceum were the most common cereals,
followed in percentage by Avena sp., Setaria italica, and T.
dicoccum.Secale cereale and cf. Sorghum bicolor were
also present in small amounts. In the storehouse C01,
cereals represented less than 25 % of the seed assemblage,
which was mostly T. aestivum/durum (19.9 %), followed
by hulled H. vulgare (2.4 %) and S. cereale (2.0 %). In the
storehouse C12, S. cereale (54.7 %) was the predominant
species, followed by T. aestivum/durum (36.2 %). In both
storehouses, Avena sp., T. monococcum,T. dicoccum and
P. miliaceum were also found in low percentages, whereas
T. spelta was sporadic. In the silo pit of hut C28, T. aes-
tivum/durum (77.6 %) predominated, followed by S. italica
(9.3 %); T. dicoccum,T. monococcum,Avena sp., S.
cereale and hulled H. vulgare also appeared. The collapse
of the C01 on the ditch F06 yielded only T. aestivum/durum
(61.4 %).
Six pulse taxa were identified (ESM 1; Fig. 3). V.
faba var. minor and Lathyrus were the most common
remains; in details (Fig. 3), in the storage area SF11, V.
faba var. minor (99.2 %) was the only taxon in the
filling of silo pit A, whereas L. cicera and L. sativus
were the most represented in C01 (54.8 and 13.4 %,
respectively) and in the collapse on the ditch F06 (26.7
and 6.2 %, respectively). The remaining taxa, such as cf.
Pisum and V. ervilia, were present in more than half of
the sampled contexts, although they were found in very
small amounts. Four fruit taxa appeared in this phase,
including mainly Vitis vinifera.Castanea sativa,Juglans
regia,Prunus persica and Ficus carica were also present
(ESM 1; Fig. 3).
Fig. 4 Crop plants from the
castle phase (last quarter of the
10th century A.D. to first quarter
of the 11th century A.D.): graphs
by phase and archaeological
context. The pie graphs show
the percentages of each
taxonomic group out of the total
individuals recovered; the bar
graphs show the percentages of
the individuals of the taxa from
the total sum of cereals and
legumes and fruits. In contexts
where only fragments of a taxon
were found, these specimens
have been included; for raw
data, see ESM 1 (Plan http://
Veget Hist Archaeobot
The castle phase: last quarter of the 10th century A.D.
to first quarter of the 11th century A.D.
There were 31 identified taxa, including 21 crop plants
(ESM 1; Fig. 4). Cereals dominated the seed assemblage
and eight taxa were identified among them (Fig. 4). Only
three cereal taxa were present in the storehouse EDM04:
hulled H. vulgare (23.8 %) was most abundant, followed
by T. aestivum/durum (16.9 %) and S. cereale (16.8 %).
Seven cereal taxa were identified in the storehouse C12:
T. aestivum/durum (40.5 %) was the main taxon, followed
by S. cereale (33.7 %); hulled H. vulgare and T. mono-
coccum appeared below 10 %; finally, Avena sp. and the
minute grains of P. miliaceum and Setaria italica were
present in very low percentages. Seven cereal taxa were
found in samples from the floor of the crop processing area
SF08, where T. aestivum/durum (56.0 %) and T. mono-
coccum (21.9 %) were most abundant, followed by T. di-
coccum, hulled H. vulgare and Avena sp.
Seven pulse taxa were identified (ESM 1; Fig. 4). V.
faba var. minor was the main one, especially in EDM04
(41.0 %). V. cf. sativa and Lathyrus, with L. sativus and L.
cicera, were found in more than half of the contexts; Cicer
Table 2 Length (L), width (W) and thickness (T) of caryopses of
Triticum aestivum/durum and T. monococcum (in mm) collected at
three settlement phases of Miranduolo and at Florence
Phase Triticum aestivum/durum Triticum monococcum
Village 4.70b 3.30b 2.67b 5.40ab 2.68ab 2.83ab
Manor 5.12a 3.58a 2.90a 5.55a 2.83a 2.91a
Castle 5.02a 3.56a 2.86a 5.27b 2.53b 2.73b
Florence 4.98a 3.52a 2.94a 5.15b 2.22c 2.54c
Within columns, any couple of means followed by different letters are
significantly different according to the Duncan test (PB0.05). This
means, for instance, that the length of T. aestivum/durum caryopses
was significantly smaller in the village phase (mean value followed by
the letter ‘‘b’’) than in the other two phases and Florence (mean values
followed by the letter ‘‘a’’). Similarly, the length of T. monococcum
caryopses in the village phase (mean value followed by the letters
‘ab’’) was not different from those in the manor phase (mean value
followed by the letter ‘‘a’’) and, at the same time, it did not differ from
those from the castle phase and Florence (mean values followed by
the letter ‘‘b’’)
Fig. 6 Column A Comparison of the percentages of cereals, legumes
and fruits out of the total of the reference group, in the three
chronological phases between the second half of the 8th century A.D.
and the first quarter of the 11th; Column B comparison of the
frequency index of cereals, legumes and fruits out of the total of the
reference group, by archaeological contexts in the three chronological
phases between the second half of the 8th century A.D. and the first
quarter of the 11th. The percentages and the frequencies are
calculated on the basis of the individuals found, but in the contexts
where only fragments of a taxon have been found, these have been
Fig. 5 Changes in caryopsis volume of Triticum aestivum/durum and
T. monococcum between the 8th and the 11th century
Mirandulo, compared with the 14th century caryopses from Florence
(grey area). Vertical bars represent standard errors of the means.
Different letters indicate means significantly different according to
the Duncan test (PB0.05). Upper case and lower case letters were
used for T. aestivum/durum and T. monococcum, respectively
Veget Hist Archaeobot
arietinum,V. ervilia and cf. Pisum were present only in the
assemblage from the storehouse C12.
Six fruit taxa were found (ESM 1; Fig. 4). Vitis vinifera
and Castanea sativa were the commonest, while J. regia,
cf. Malus sp., P. persica and P. avium/cerasus appeared in
low amounts.
Weeds and wild plants
Thirteen wild plant taxa were identified (ESM 1). Cary-
opses of Poaceae were found in the village phase, while in
the manor and castle phases, 11 and 13 taxa were found,
respectively. The identified taxa belonged mainly to rud-
erals and weeds of cultivated fields and among cereals. The
only taxon belonging to wild woodland vegetation was
Quercus sp.
Caryopsis size of T. aestivum/durum and T.
Caryopsis length, width, thickness and volume of T. aes-
tivum/durum from the village phase were significantly
smaller compared to both the other settlement phases and
the caryopses from Florence dated to the 13th–14th cen-
turies A.D. (Table 2; Fig. 5). No significant difference was
found in the caryopsis size of T. monococcum between the
village and the manor phases (Table 2; Fig. 5), whereas the
length, width, thickness and volume of T. monococcum
caryopses decreased significantly passing from these pha-
ses to the castle phase and from this to the 13th–14th
centuries A.D. in Florence (Table 2; Fig. 5).
The village
The samples from the floor levels of hut C24 indicate what
was cultivated during the period of its occupation (Fig. 2),
thus they can provide a good idea of the agricultural
economy of the village. The storage silo pit in hut C26 had
a very low concentration of plant remains (24.3 per litre)
and the finds were not homogeneous. Thus we can suppose
that the seeds were probably related to residues of the
products stored during its use, from the bottom of the pit.
However these data were very similar to those from the
floor of hut C24. All the identified crops were cultivated in
Italy during the Roman period (Castelletti et al. 2001; Forni
2002), thus we can hypothesize that there was high quality
farming in this phase; the noticeable presence of T.
monococcum (einkorn) represents an element of disconti-
nuity with Roman agriculture (Fig. 6).
According to historians, agriculture in the High Middle
Ages experienced difficulties because of the collapse of
Roman agrarian organisation together with incapacity and
technical deficiency (Montanari 1979,2002; Sadori and
Susanna 2005). However, our data suggest a good know-
ledge about both crop requirements and soil properties.
Indeed, although soils were not very fertile, because of the
presence of sand, clay and chalk, farming was mainly
based on the cultivation of cereals and also of naked wheats
(T. aestivum/durum), which represented the best choice for
achieving good crop yields and quality from the farming of
the settlement (Fig. 6). Furthermore, farmers used crops
which were more resistant to environmental adversities.
Indeed, H. vulgare (barley) and P. miliaceum (common
millet) are suitable for growing on poor soils and under
severe drought, completing their life cycle in a short time.
Einkorn adapts better than naked wheats to poor soils
because of its hardiness (Zohary and Hopf 2004).
Morphological features did not allow differentiation
between Avena fatua (wild oat) and A. sativa (cultivated
oat), but we hypothesize that these caryopses can be
attributed to the cultivated species because it was present
with high frequency and percentages (Fig. 6) especially in
the silo destined for domestic foodstuffs (Fig. 2). In this
phase, T. dicoccum (emmer) and S. cereale (rye) were
present only in the silo pit (Fig. 2) and in amounts that
were too small to infer their cultivation and deliberate
storage (Fig. 6). Indeed, it was reported that low levels of
minor cereals can contaminate the dominant cultigens
because of their similar growing habitat and harvest time
(Jones and Halstead 1995). Similarly, some Fabaceae
found in the silo pit, V. ervilia (bitter vetch) and Lathyrus
sativus/cicera (grass/red pea), and on the floor surface,
Pisum sativum (pea), could be contaminating taxa (Fig. 2).
However, at Miranduolo, grass/red pea was found on the
floor surface in the same amounts as the hulled barley
(Fig. 2), and thus it can be hypothesized that it was also
cultivated, and it could have been grown on the poorest
soils thanks to its hardiness.
Even V. faba var. minor (broad bean, horse bean) was
found in the silo pit in sufficient quantity to be considered a
cultivated plant (Fig. 2). According to Castelletti et al.
(2001), in Italy during the High Middle Ages, bitter V.
ervilia lost its importance and V. faba predominated
together with Pisum and L. sativus/cicero.
In general in this phase, we observed that the crops were
carefully processed before storage, since small amounts of
spikelet forks and glume caryopses were found (Fig. 2).
Seed sizes of Poaceae and Fabaceae weeds or contaminants
are generally very similar to those of cultivated cereals, and
this complicates their elimination from the grain during
both sieving and hand cleaning (Hillman 1981,1984; Jones
Veget Hist Archaeobot
The discontinuity with the Roman world was shown by
the important role of T. monococcum, and although it
produces bread with characteristics comparable to the best
wheat breads, it is rarely found in remains from the Roman
period and always in smaller amounts than T. dicoccum
(Castelletti et al. 2001). At Miranduolo, in addition to T.
monococcum, we found crops such as Secale,T. dicoccum
and Hordeum which are more productive under adverse
growing conditions and also easier to process than wheats.
Thus it becomes important to understand the role of T.
monococcum. Between the 6th and 10th centuries A.D.,
einkorn characterized the cereal assemblages both in urban
and rural sites in northern and central Italy, often being
more abundant than naked wheats, rye and barley. In the
north, this was observed in the towns of Brescia (Castelletti
and Maspero 1988; Castiglioni et al. 1999), Alba (Castel-
letti and Motella De Carlo 1999) and Parma (Bosi et al.
2011); in central Italy, in the village of Montarrenti, a site
20 km from Miranduolo (Cantini 2003). It is interesting to
note that these areas of northern Italy and Colline Metal-
lifere were mainly settled by Lombards (Brogiolo 1993;
Micheletto 2000; Azzara 2004; Valenti 2012), a Scandi-
navian population found in Italy from A.D. 569 until 774.
Thus we wonder whether T. monococcum should be con-
sidered a cereal cultivated by the Lombard people for
cultural reasons and/or eating preference. This possibility
has an interesting parallel in the Iberian Peninsula where T.
monococcum was used for making bread during the time of
Arabian dominance (Pen
˜a-Chocarro and Zapata Pen
1998). On the other hand, archaeological sources suggest a
domestic and subsistence crop production in the High
Middle Ages, as indicated by the absence of buildings for
crop storage in the settlements (Bianchi and Grassi 2012).
The historical sources show that the local aristocracy did
not interfere with the economic choices and the manage-
ment of agricultural resources of the villages (Wickham
2005). Thus, the low productivity of T. monococcum does
not disagree with these low-income economic contexts; in
fact, the agrarian economy during the village phase of
Miranduolo had a domestic and subsistence character, as
suggested by the storage in silo pits for the needs of single
family units.
The manor
The assemblages from the manorial phase, between the 9th
and 10th centuries A.D., showed that the farming of the
settlement was intended to produce valuable crops (Fig. 6).
The fillings of silo A and the remains in hut C28 mainly
contained single stored crops, V. faba and T. aestivum/
durum, respectively (Fig. 3). According to historical sour-
ces, these crops were sown, harvested and stored separately
from other cereals and legumes (Montanari 1979). As in
the previous phase, the fills of silo pits B, C and D con-
sisted of pit bottom residues from several goods succes-
sively stored during their use, mainly T. aestivum/durum,T.
monococcum, hulled Hordeum and P. miliaceum (Fig. 3).
These cereals were the same as those of the previous phase,
thus the manor continued and stabilized crop production in
the village.
The storehouses were the most important structures for
storage in the manorial court: the differences between the
records from the silo pits and the storehouses were sig-
nificant (Fig. 3). The similarity among the layers of ditch
F06 and storehouse C01 (Fig. 3) is explained by the fact
that the layer sampled in the ditch was located close to the
storehouse and it was therefore affected by the scattering of
seeds caused by fire and the collapse of this building. In
fact, in the storehouses, the predominance of large seeds
and free-threshing grains (L. sativus/cicera,T. aestivum/
durum,Secale cereal and V. faba), suggests that they had
probably been selected before being stored in the manorial
court. In late medieval Ferrara, the archaeobotanical record
suggests that some taxa with unusually large seeds or fruits
were considered to be better quality foods for the table of
the Este family court (Bosi et al. 2009). For Miranduolo,
our hypothesis is that the lord asked for grains of quality
not only for food, but also to be marketed elsewhere. The
small percentage of other crops (hulled Hordeum,P. mil-
iaceum and T. monococcum) could be interpreted as con-
taminants as suggested by Jones and Halstead (1995).
Our data show that among pulses, V. faba was common
in all the contexts and held a major role in farming (Fig. 6).
Among the species within the genus Lathyrus,L. sativus
(grass pea) is very similar to L. cicera (red pea), a weed of
cereals. The character used to differentiate between the two
species in the charred seeds of Miranduolo was the position
of the small oval hilum as previously described (Helbæk
1969; Renfrew 1973; Sadori and Susanna 2005). In medi-
eval sites the role of L. sativus and L. cicera as crops is
often ambiguous (Ruas 2005). Sadori and Susanna (2005)
indicated the use of L. sativus in a poor late Roman set-
tlement, suggesting either poor cultivation techniques or
the harvesting of wild plants. In Miranduolo, L. sativus and
L. cicera can be interpreted as cultivated because they were
found in large amounts in the storehouse (Fig. 3). These
pulses could be grown on the poorest soils and this indi-
cates the will to cultivate even the most difficult soils. L.
sativus is currently cultivated in central Italy and in Spain
both as fodder and as food (Pen
˜a-Chocarro and Zapata
Other minor cereals found in this phase were T. dicoc-
cum and Avena, and these could be considered as con-
tamination of the cereal crops, where they were tolerated
by farmers (Fig. 6; Castelletti et al. 2001). In general, our
data confirmed the lack of interest in emmer and oat
Veget Hist Archaeobot
cultivation as inferred from both historical sources and
previous archaeobotanical studies in Italy (Montanari
1979; Costantini et al. 1983; Castelletti et al. 2001).
Other pulses were found in so low percentages that our
data cannot certainly support the hypothesis of their culti-
vation (Fig. 6); nevertheless, because of their characteris-
tics, it is also conceivable that they were probably sown on
the poorest soils. It is noteworthy that until few decades
ago in central Italy, the ‘Mociarino’ (the local name of V.
ervilia) was often considered the only alternative to
growing Secale. It was still sown between the ditches and
on the trampled borders of the fields.
Remains of charred fruit came from several contexts
related to the manorial court (Fig. 3); this evidence sug-
gests that their consumption was probably reserved for the
leading social class. Fruit and nut growing appears in this
phase; Juglans regia (walnut) and Prunus persica (peach)
are sporadic in the manor as well as in the castle, but in this
latter phase they were present in more than half of the
contexts (Fig. 6); the presence of luxury foods confirms the
abandonment of subsistence farming. P. persica stones
from the early Middle Ages are very rare in Italy and
mainly linked to urban sites (Sadori et al. 2009). Our data
show that during the High Middle Ages, peach trees were
even cultivated far from the towns. Castanea sativa
(chestnut) finds follow a similar pattern to P. persica and J.
regia; however, the charcoal analyses carried out on
material from the site revealed that Castanea was widely
used as timber in the village phase (Di Pasquale, unpub-
lished data). This indicates a change in the management of
Castanea which leads us to suppose that Castanea growing
started locally in the second half of the 9th century A.D.
These data disagree with the idea that Castanea cultivation
developed in the Roman period, and highlights the fact that
in central-southern Italy Castanea was used mainly for
timber until the early Middle Ages (Di Pasquale et al.
2010; Allevato et al. 2012). In wider terms, the quality of
the fruit taxa seems to show awareness of good cultivation
practices, and this does not support the common hypothesis
that during the Middle Age the gathering of wild plants was
more common than cultivation (Montanari 2002). Only a
few seeds and pedicels of Vitis vinifera ssp. vinifera
(grapevine) were found, and we hypothesize that its culti-
vation was limited to the production of the wine required
for church purposes at the site.
In this phase the amount of weed seeds was larger than
in the previous periods even though it remained low
(Fig. 3). In addition, a small number of spikelet forks were
found and this allows us to suggest that careful cleaning
operations were carried out before storage. In addition, the
presence of Secale,Hordeum and the dominant T. aes-
tivum/durum shows the selection of productive crops,
suggesting an improvement in farming management and in
resource selection (Fig. 6). T. monococcum cultivation did
not disappear, but cereals with better yields and easier
processing were preferred at that time. The low produc-
tivity of T. monococcum and the difficulty in dehusking it
probably conflicted with the new economic system.
The Lombard dominion in Italy was ended in central-
northern Italy by the Franks of Charlemagne in A.D. 774;
the transition from the village to the manorial court coin-
cided with the diffusion of the Carolingian feudal eco-
nomic system, when the great landlords began to control
the economies of the villages (Wickham 2005). In the
Colline Metallifere, archaeological sources show that
storehouses were built in the settlements between the 9th
and the 10th centuries A.D., in parallel with the new farming
system (Bianchi and Grassi 2012). In Miranduolo, a clear-
cut change in crop management happened: at this time the
largest pulses and the most productive and free-threshing
of the cereals were selected to be stored in the barns of the
manor court; this centralization of the best products was
part of the manorial economy.
The castle
The transition from manorial court to the castle coincided
with the establishment of the feudal economic system
(Wickham 2005). Cereals and pulses kept in storehouses
were analogous to the previous phase (Fig. 4), confirming
the preference for keeping stocks of major economic
importance in barns, and this is in agreement with this new
economic system. In one of the storehouses, V. faba was
the predominant pulse; L. sativus/cicera,V. sativa,V.
ervilia and Pisum sativum continued to be present, while
Cicer arietinum (chick pea) appeared (Fig. 4). These pulses
were often present in more than half of the contexts, but
their small percentages cannot fully support their cultiva-
tion in this phase (Fig. 6).
The data from the floor of the crop processing area show
that cereals were processed there (Fig. 4). The role of T.
monococcum in local farming is evident, but it was absent
from the storehouse.
Grapevine was indicated by grape pips and also by
charred pruning remains (Di Pasquale, unpublished data),
confirming the presence of a vineyard. The use of fruit and
nuts increased; Castanea and P. persica remains were
present in more than half of the contexts (Fig. 6).
In this phase, the presence of weeds was greater than in
the preceding phase (Fig. 4) and clearly this was due to less
care in the post-harvest cleaning. We wonder whether this
could be interpreted as the consequence of the new eco-
nomic structure in this area, which led to the necessity to
satisfy quickly and abundantly the rising demand from the
markets for agricultural products.
Veget Hist Archaeobot
Dimensional variation of caryopsis size of T. aestivum/
durum and T. monococcum
The analysis of the size changes variation of the grains of
naked wheat and einkorn reinforces the interpretative pic-
ture already discussed. A significant increase in caryopsis
length, width and thickness of T. aestivum/durum was
found in the transition from the village to the manorial
phase, whereas from the manorial to the castle phase the
caryopsis size remained similar (Table 2; Fig. 5). This size
increase can be considered a consequence of improvements
in farming. This improvement in grain quality, since large
fruit size is among the most desirable traits, could be the
result of human selection for specific plant attributes
(Lepofsky et al. 1998), by the intentional harvesting of the
best quality wheats to satisfy the lord’s request (Bosi et al.
2009). Furthermore, the size of T. aestivum/durum grains
from Miranduolo was even similar to those found at
Florence from the Communal Age (13th–14th centuries
A.D.) (Table 2; Fig. 5). This similarity is especially note-
worthy because it is known that in this period, Florence had
an advanced urban structure and thus excellent food
resources (Buonincontri et al. 2007a; Mariotti Lippi et al.
2013). This indicates that the selection of wheats with
larger grains took place in the rural settlements of the
manors and castles before the Communal Age. Production
surplus and trade were probably possible because of the use
of these crops; caryopsis sizes between the 9th and the 11th
centuries A.D. were probably the most which could be
achieved, at least until the 13th–14th centuries A.D.
On the contrary, grains of T. monococcum significantly
decreased in size from the beginning of the manor phase,
with values similar to those from Florence in the 13th–14th
centuries (Table 2; Fig. 5). Size reduction suggests a
change in the role of this cereal, which became more
marginal, starting from the Carolingian phase. On the other
hand, its continued presence in the assemblages shows
continuity in the choice of this cereal. Thus, this size
reduction could be a further confirmation of the cultural
significance of T. monococcum during the Lombard period.
Between the 9th and the 11th centuries A.D. and then
during the whole late Middle Ages in central Italy, T.
monococcum appears in such small quantities that it is
considered to have been a weed (Costantini et al. 1983;
Clark et al. 1989; Castiglioni and Rottoli 1997; Buonin-
contri et al. 2007a), or it is absent from the archaeobo-
tanical records (Nisbet 1999; Bandini Mazzanti et al. 2005;
Fiorentino et al. 2007). The range of T. monococcum has
receded to such a point since then, that today in Italy it is
grown only in tiny areas of the Daunian Apennines as a
local crop, often for bulgur or as animal feed (Perrino and
Hammer 1982; Hammer and Perrino 1984). These lands
belonged to the Duchy of Benevento, which survived as
Lombard up to the Norman conquest in the 11th century
A.D. A decrease in T. monococcum was also found in the
southwest French Massif Central, where from the 9th
century A.D., T. monococcum was found in such small
quantities that it was considered as a subsidiary crop or
even a tolerated weed (Ruas 2007).
This study has allowed us, for the first time in central Italy,
to understand from a deep and detailed time sequence,
from the middle of the 8th to the first quarter of the 11th
century A.D., the cultivation of crops by a rural settlement
during its transition from a Lombard farming village to a
Carolingian manorial court, and finally to a feudal castle
under the strong control of a landlord.
The presence of valuable crops such as T. aestivum/durum
and V. faba suggests continuity with the agricultural tradition
of the Roman world. Already from the 8th century A.D. the
inhabitants were able to produce good quality yields on
unfavourable soils, thanks to careful cultivation techniques.
The constant presence of hardier cereals such as T.
monococcum,Hordeum,Secale and P. miliaceum shows
the will to grow a wide range of crops in order to manage
any bad harvests, and it indicates the inhabitants’ aware-
ness of the low agricultural potential of the land. T.
monococcum can be considered a ‘‘cultural’’ element of
Lombard crops.
In the Carolingian period, the reduction of T. mono-
coccum in favour of more productive crops such as Secale
and Hordeum indicates a further improvement of produc-
tive capacity as also confirmed by the appearance of luxury
fruit trees. The final phase of the Carolingian empire and of
the period under a feudal economic system is characterized
by greater attention to an economy devoted to achieving a
production surplus.
Morphometric analysis validated the supposed
improvements of the productive processes from the village
to the manorial phase and the following significant loss of
importance of T. monococcum. This confirmed the cultural
significance of this crop in the Lombard period.
Acknowledgments This research was funded by the ‘‘Archeologia
dei Paesaggi Medievali’’ Project. The authors dedicate this work to the
memory of Professor Riccardo Francovich. We are grateful to the ref-
erees for their helpful and constructive suggestions through the paper.
Allevato E, Buonincontri MP, Vairo MR, Pecci A, Cau MA, Yoneda
M, De Simone GF, Aoyagi M, Angelelli C, Matsuyama S,
Veget Hist Archaeobot
Takeuchi K, Di Pasquale G (2012) Persistence of the cultural
landscape in Campania (Southern Italy) before the A.D. 472
Vesuvius eruption: archaeoenvironmental data. J Archaeol Sci
39:399–406. doi:10.1016/j.jas.2011.09.026
Alonso Martinez N (2005) Agriculture and food from the Roman to
the Islamic Period in the North-East of the Iberian peninsula:
archaeobotanical studies in the city of Lleida (Catalonia, Spain).
Veget Hist Archaeobot 14:341–361. doi:10.1007/s00334-005-
Andreolli B (1981) I prodotti alimentari nei contratti agrari toscani
dell’Alto Medioevo. Archeol Mediev 8:117–126
`n F, Buxo
`R (2011) Proposal for the systematic description and
taphonomic study of carbonized cereal grain assemblages: a case
study of an early Neolithic funerary context in the cave of Can
`(Begues, Barcelona province, Spain). Veget Hist
Archaeobot 20:53–66. doi:10.1007/s00334-010-0255-1
Augenti A (2000) Dai castra tardoantichi ai castelli del secolo X: il
caso della Toscana. In: Francovich R, Ginatempo M (eds)
Castelli, storia e archeologia del potere nella Toscana medievale,
vol I. All’Insegna del Giglio, Firenze, pp 25–66
Augenti A, Bondi M, Carra M, Cirelli E, Malaguti C, Rizzi M (2006)
Indagini archeologiche a Classe (scavi 2004): primi risultati sulle
fasi di eta
`altomedievale e dati archeobotanici. In: Francovich R,
Valenti M (eds) IV Congresso Nazionale di Archeologia
Medievale. All’Insegna del Giglio, Firenze, pp 153–161
Azzara C (2004) Parma nell’Emilia longobarda. Reti Mediev Riv
Bakels CC (2002) Plant remains from Sardinia, Italy, with notes on
barley and grape. Veget Hist Archaeobot 11:3–8
Bandini Mazzanti M, Bosi G, Mercuri AM, Accorsi CA, Guarnieri C
(2005) Plant use in a city in Northern Italy during the late
Mediaeval and Renaissance periods: results of the archaeobo-
tanical investigation of ‘‘The Mirror Pit’’ (14th-15th century A.D.)
in Ferrara. Veget Hist Archaeobot 14:442–452. doi:10.1007/
Bianchi G (2010) Dominare e gestire un territorio. Ascesa e sviluppo
delle ‘signorie forti’ nella Maremma toscana del Centro Nord tra
X e meta
`XII secolo. Archeol Mediev 37:93–104
Bianchi G, Grassi F (2012) Sistemi di stoccaggio nelle campagne
italiane (secc. VII–XIII): l’evidenza archeologica dal caso di
Rocca degli Alberti in Toscana. In: Vigil-Escalera Guirado A,
Bianchi G, Quiro
´s Castillo JA (eds) Horrea, barns and silos.
Storage and incomes in Early Medieval Europe. Servicio
editorial de la UPV/EHU, Bilbao, pp 58–77
Bosi G, Mercuri AM, Guarnieri C, Bandini Mazzanti M (2009)
Luxury food and ornamental plants at the 15th century A.D.
Renaissance court of the Este family (Ferrara, northern Italy).
Veget Hist Archaeobot 18:389–402. doi:10.1007/s00334-009-
Bosi G, Mazzanti MB, Florenzano A, N’siala Massamba I, Pederzoli
A, Rinaldi R, Torri P, Mercuri AM (2011) Seeds/fruits, pollen
and parasite remains as evidence of site function: piazza
Garibaldi: Parma (N Italy) in Roman and Mediaeval times.
J Archaeol Sci 38:1,621–1,633. doi:10.1016/j.jas.2011.02.027
Brogiolo GP (1993) Brescia altomedievale: urbanistica ed edilizia dal
IV al IX secolo. (Documenti di Archeologia 2) Societa
Archeologica Padana, Mantova
Buonincontri MP, Corbino CA, Di Pasquale G, Donnini D, Mori
Secci M, Pecci A, Salvini L, Pignattelli S, Terzani M (2007a)
Alimentazione e ambiente a Firenze nel XIII secolo: un
approccio integrato. In: Cantini F, Cianferoni C, Francovich R,
Scampoli E (eds) Firenze prima degli Uffizi. Lo scavo di via
de’ Castellani: contributi per un’archeologia urbana fra tardo
antico ed eta
`moderna. All’Insegna del Giglio, Firenze,
pp 662–682
Buonincontri MP, Di Falco G, Moser D, Donnini D, Di Pasquale G
(2007b) Il castello di Miranduolo (Siena): dati archeobotanici
per il X-XI secolo. Atti Soc Nat Mat Modena 137:355–372
Cantini F (2003) Il Castello di Montarrenti. Lo scavo archeologico
(1982–1987). Per la storia della formazione del villaggio
medievale in Toscana (secc. VII–XV). All’Insegna del Giglio,
Caracuta V, Fiorentino G (2009) L’analisi archeobotanica nell’inse-
diamento di Faragola (FG): il paesaggio vegetale tra spinte
antropiche e caratteristiche ambientali tra Tardoantico e Altome-
dioevo. In: Volpe G, Favia P (eds) V Congresso Nazionale di
Archeologia Medievale. All’Insegna del Giglio, Firenze,
pp 371–377
Castelletti L (1977) Legni carbonizzati e altri resti vegetali macro-
scopici. In: Frova A (ed) Scavi di Luni II. Relazione delle
campagne di scavo 1972–74. Bretschneider, Roma, pp 736–741
Castelletti L, Maspero A (1988) Analisi di resti vegetali macroscopici.
In: Panazza G, Brogiolo GP (eds) Ricerche su Brescia altomedi-
oevale, vol 1. Lo scavo di via Alberto Mario. Ateneo di Brescia
Accademia di Scienze Lettere ed Arti, Brescia, pp 125–132
Castelletti L, Motella De Carlo S (1999) Il paesaggio nel Medioevo
attraverso lo studio dei resti vegetali. In: Micheletto E (ed) Una
`nel Medioevo. Archeologia e architettura ad Alba dal VI al
XV secolo. Omega, Alba, pp 291–301
Castelletti L, Castiglioni E, Rottoli M (2001) L’agricoltura dell’Italia
settentrionale dal Neolitico al Medioevo. In: Failla O, Forni G
(eds) Le piante coltivate e la loro storia. FrancoAngeli, Milano,
pp 33–84
Castiglioni E, Rottoli M (1997) I macroresti vegetali. In: Molinari A
(ed) Segesta II. Il castello e la Moschea. Scavi 1989–1995.
Palermo, pp 235–257
Castiglioni E, Cottini M, Rottoli M (1999) I resti botanici di Santa
Giulia a Brescia. In: Brogiolo GP (ed) Giulia di Brescia, gli scavi
dal 1980 al 1992. Reperti preromani, romani e altomedievali.
All’Insegna del Giglio, Firenze, pp 401–424
Clark G, Costantini L, Finetti A, Giorgi J, Jones A, Reese D,
Sutherland S, Whitehouse D (1989) The food refuse of an
affluent urban household in the late fourteenth century: faunal
and botanical remains from Palazzo Vitelleschi, Tarquinia
(Viterbo). Pap Br Sch Rome 57:200–321
Cortonesi A (2002) Agricoltura e tecniche nell’Italia medievale. I
cereali, la vite, l’olivo. In: Cortonesi A, Pasquali G, Piccinni G
(eds) Uomini e campagne nell’Italia medievale. Roma-Bari,
Laterza, pp 190–270
Costantini L, Costantini L, Napolitano G, Whitehouse D (1983) Cereali
e legumi medievali provenienti dalle mura di Santo Stefano,
Anguillara Sabazia (Roma). Archeol Mediev 10:393–414
Costantini EAC, Barbetti R, Bucelli P, Cimato A, Franchini E,
L’Abate G, Pellegrini S, Storchi P, Vignozzi N (2006) Zonaz-
ione viticola ed olivicola della provincia di Siena. Grafiche
Boccacci Editore, Colle val d’Elsa (SI)
Di Pasquale G, Allevato E, Russo Ermolli E, Coubray S, Lubritto C,
Marzaioli F, Yoneda M, Takeuchi K, Kano Y, Matsuyama S, De
Simone GF (2010) Reworking the idea of chestnut (Castanea
sativa Mill.) cultivation in Roman times: new data from ancient
Campania. Plant Biosyst 144:865–873. doi:10.1080/11263504.
Fiorentino G, Colaianni G, Novellis D (2007) Analisi archeobotaniche
al Monastero medievale di Jure Vetere: ricostruzione ambientale e
uso delle risorse vegetali. In: Fonseca C, Roubis D, Sogliani F
(eds) Jure Vetere. Ricerche archeologiche nella prima fondazione
monastica di Giacchino da Fiore (indagini 2001–2005). Catanz-
aro, pp 243–267
Forni G (2002) Colture, lavori, tecniche, rendimenti. In: Forni G,
Marcone A (eds) Storia dell’agricoltura italiana. 1. L’Italia
Veget Hist Archaeobot
antica. 2 Eta
`romana. Accademia dei Georgofili, Firenze,
pp 63–156
Francovich R, Hodges R (2003) Villa to village. Bristol Classical
Press, London
Grasso AM, Fiorentino G (2009) Studi archeobotanici per l’Italia
medievale: una sintesi. In: Volpe G, Favia P (eds) V Congresso
Nazionale di Archeologia Medievale. All’Insegna del Giglio,
Firenze, pp 120–125
Hammer K, Perrino P (1984) Further information on farro (Triticum
monococcum L. and T. dicoccon Schrank) in South Italy.
Kulturpflanze 32:143–151
Helbæk H (1969) Plant collecting, dry-farming and irrigation
agriculture in prehistoric Deh Luran. In: Hole F, Flannery KV,
Neely JA (eds) Prehistory and human ecology of Deh Luran
Plain. (Memoirs of the Museum of Anthropology, vol 1).
University of Michigan, Ann Arbor, pp 383–426
Hillman GC (1981) Reconstructing crop husbandry practices from
charred remains of crops. In: Mercer R (ed) Farming practice in
British prehistory. Edinburgh University Press, Edinburgh,
pp 123–162
Hillman GC (1984) Interpretation of archaeological plant remains: the
application of ethnographic models from Turkey. In: Van Zeist
W, Casparie WA (eds) Plants and ancient man: studies in the
palaeoethnobotany. Balkema, Rotterdam, pp 1–42
Hubbard RNLB (1992) Dichotomous keys for the identification of the
major Old World crops. Rev Palaeobot Palynol 73:105–115.
Jacomet S (2008) Identification of cereal remains from archaeological
sites, 2nd edn. IPNA Basel,
Accessed 7 May 2013
Jones G (1984) Interpretation of archaeological plant remains:
ethnographic models from Greece. In: Van Zeist W, Casparie
WA (eds) Plants and ancient man: studies in palaeoethnobotany.
Balkema, Rotterdam, pp 43–61
Jones G (1990) The application of present-day cereal processing
studies to charred archaeobotanical remains. Circaea 6:91–96
Jones G, Halstead P (1995) Maslins, mixtures and monocrops: on the
interpretation of archaeobotanical crop samples of heterogeneous
composition. J Archaeol Sci 22:103–114. doi:10.1016/S0305-
Lepofsky D, Kirch PV, Lertzman KP (1998) Metric analyses of
prehistoric morphological change in cultivated fruits and nuts: an
example from island Melanesia. J Archaeol Sci 25:1,001–1,014
Maier U (1996) Morphological studies of free-threshing wheat ears
from a Neolithic site in southwest Germany, and the history of
the naked wheats. Veget Hist Archaeobot 5:39–55. doi:10.1007/
Mariotti Lippi M, Bellini C, Mori Secci M, Gonnelli T, Pallecchi P
(2013) Archaeobotany in Florence (Italy): landscape and urban
development from the late Roman to the Middle Ages. Plant
Biosyst 2013:1–12. doi:10.1080/11263504.2013.822433
Micheletto E (2000) Il quartiere di San Lorenzo ad Alba (secoli V–
XIII). In: Brogiolo GP (ed) II Congresso Nazionale di Arche-
ologia Medievale. All’Insegna del Giglio, Firenze, pp 60–66
Montanari M (1979) L’alimentazione contadina nell’alto Medioevo.
Liguori, Napoli
Montanari M (2002) Colture, lavori, tecniche, rendimenti. In: Pinto G,
Poni C, Tucci U (eds) Storia dell’agricoltura italiana. 2. Il
medioevo e l’eta
`moderna. Accademia dei Georgofili, Firenze,
pp 59–81
Nisbet R (1999) I macroresti vegetali. In: Negro Ponzi Mancini MM
(ed) San Michele di Trino (VC). Dal villaggio romano al castello
medievale. All’Insegna del Giglio, Firenze, pp 621–630
˜a-Chocarro L, Zapata Pen
˜a L (1998) Hulled wheats in Spain:
history of minor cereals. In: Jaradat AA (ed) Triticeae III.
Science Publishers, New Hampshire, pp 45–52
˜a-Chocarro L, Zapata Pen
˜a L (1999) History and traditional
cultivation of Lathyrus sativus L. and Lathyrus cicera L. in the
Iberian peninsula. Veget Hist Archaeobot 8:49–52. doi:10.1007/
Perrino P, Hammer K (1982) Triticum monococcum L. and T.
dicoccon Schrank are still cultivated in Italy. Presence, collect-
ing and actions. Genet Agrar 36:343–352
Renfrew JM (1973) Palaeoethnobotany. Columbia University Press,
New York
Ruas MP (2005) Aspects of early medieval farming from sites in
Mediterranean France. Veget Hist Archaeobot 14:400–415.
Ruas MP (2007) La parole des grains: enque
ˆte arche
´obotanique sur
l’engrain (Triticum monococcum L.) au Moyen en France
´ridionale. In: Durand A (ed) Plantes exploite
´es, plantes
´es. Cultures, techniques et discours. Etudes offertes a
Georges Comet. Publications de l’Universite
`de Provence, Aix-
en-Provence, pp 149–170
Ruas MP, Bouby L, Py V, Cazes JP (2005) An 11th century A.D. burnt
granary at La Gravette, south-western France: preliminary
archaeobotanical results. Veget Hist Archaeobot 14:416–426.
Sadori L, Susanna F (2005) Hints of economic change during the late
Roman Empire period in central Italy: a study of charred plant
remains from ‘‘La Fontanaccia’’, near Rome. Veget Hist
Archaeobot 14:386–393. doi:10.1007/s00334-005-0010-1
Sadori L, Allevato E, Bosi G, Caneva G, Castiglioni E, Celant A, Di
Pasqual G, Giardini M, Mazzanti M, Rinaldi R, Rottoli M,
Susanna F (2009) The introduction and diffusion of peach in
ancient Italy. In: Morel JP, Mercuri AM (eds) Plants and culture:
seeds of the cultural heritage of Europe. Edipuglia, Bari, pp 45–61
Schoch WH, Pawlik B, Schweingruber FH (1988) Botanische
Makroreste. Paul Haupt, Bern
Valenti M (2004) L’insediamento altomedievale nelle campagne
toscane. Paesaggi, popolamento e villaggi tra VI e X secolo.
All’Insegna del Giglio, Firenze
Valenti M (2006) Miranduolo (Chiusdino, SI). Dal villaggio di
capanne al castello in materiali misti. In: Francovich R, Valenti
M (eds) IV Congresso Nazionale di Archeologia Medievale.
All’Insegna del Giglio, Firenze, pp 257–262
Valenti M (2009) Chiusdino (SI). Miranduolo. Not Soprintend Beni
Archeol Toscana 4:530–548
Valenti M (2011) Miranduolo (Chiusdino, SI). Campagna 2011.
(FOLD&R Italy Series 241)
FOLDER-it-2011-241.pdf. Accessed 7 May 2013
Valenti M (2012) Villaggi e comunita
`nella Toscana tra VII e X
secolo: la ricerca archeologica. In: Galetti P (ed) Paesaggi,
`, Villaggi. Fondazione Centro italiano di Studi
sull’Alto Medioevo, Spoleto, pp 477–504
Van der Veen M (1985) An Early Medievalhilltop settlement in Molise:
the plant remains from D85. Pap Br Sch Rome 53:211–224
Van Zeist W (1970) Prehistoric and early historic food plants in the
Netherlands. Palaeohist 14:41–173
Viggiani P (1991) Erbe spontanee e infestanti: tecniche di riconosci-
mento. Edagricole, Milano
Wickham C (2005) Framing the early middle ages: Europe and the
Mediterranean, 400–800. Oxford University Press, New York
Zohary D, Hopf M (2004) Domestication of plants in the Old World,
3rd edn. Oxford University Press, Oxford
Veget Hist Archaeobot
... The explanation may be contact between Lombards from the territory of Moravia and northern Italy. Lombards in northern Italy cultivated and ate millet (Buonincontri et al., 2014;Ganzarolli et al., 2018). There is the possibility that these outliers are members of the same cultural entitymigrants from a region where millet was consumed. ...
The diet of the Lombard (Langobard) population of the Kyjov site (5th-6th centuries AD, Moravia, Czech Republic) was reconstructed from carbon (δ13C) and nitrogen (δ15N) isotopic values in the bone collagen from 73 human and 19 faunal samples. Results indicate that the diet of the Lombard population sample was based on C3 plants and animal proteins. The presence of three outliers with δ13C values above−18‰, however, suggests that millet was accessible and consumed by at least some members of the community in substantial quantities. Given the dating and exogenous character of the grave goods, these individuals are most probably members of the indigenous population of Moravia who grew millet before the arrival of the Lombards. The Lombard population shows a sex-based difference in the consumption of animal protein, with males on average showing higher values of δ15N than females. These findings match well with the (limited) prior isotopic research into the Central European phase of the Lombard migration. This study thus significantly enhances our knowledge about general trends in the dietary behaviour of Central European Lombards.
... The analysis of charcoal macro-remains from archaeological excavations (so called on-site research), together with other plant remains such as pollen, seeds and fruits, is an important area of research for archaeologists and palaeoecologists (Aniceti and Pescini, 2014;Mercuri et al., 2014;Buonincontri et al., 2014;Pescini, 2013;Dufraisse, 2006;Smart and Hoffman, 1988). This has provided knowledge about technological aspects related to the use of woody resources (influences in the selection of species to be used as fuel, context-related variations in the preservation of wood fuel remains) in addition to providing information on past land bearing trees and their management. ...
... The two species most on the site confirm their great importance in the Middle Ages and continuity with the agricultural tradition of the preceding Roman world (Buonincontri et al. 2014). A more in-depth analysis of the two largest grain deposits can provide more detail on the most widely used Triticum species in the territory under the control of the Brina castle. ...
Full-text available
This paper presents the results of the first study of the archaeobotanical finds from the medieval settlement of Brina (X-XVI century A.D.) located in a hilly territory in the lower Magra valley near Sarzana (La Spezia - Italy) (Figure 1). These macroremains are mostly represented by a large amount of charred wheat caryopses and broad bean seeds, in addition to a small amount of seeds and / or fruits of wild species. All these macroremains were found in two distinct areas inside the settlement walls and in ground pits in a storage area and from vessels used in a sort of a ‘dry kiln’ used in the XI century AD. What remained belonged to agricultural production of crops that supposedly were not in close proximity to the settlement, given the topographical position of the castle yet in the same territory of jurisdiction of the castle .
... The transfer of sorghum into Mediterranean agriculture, in central and northern Italy (e.g. Bosi et al. 2009;Buonincontri et al. 2014), notably also involved race bicolor having similar cultivation, storage and processing requirements to Setaria italica and Panicum miliaceum that were already well-established. ...
Sorghum bicolor, one of the world’s five most important crops, originated in Africa. While this has long been clear, accumulating data from both archaeobotany and genetics, provides the basis for a new overview on the domestication process, racial evolution, and geographical dispersal of sorghum. Archaeobotanical finds from 113 sites in Africa and Eurasia are reviewed and mapped. Of these only 16 provide identifications of probable morphological races. Domestication is evidently taking place more than 3000 years BC in the eastern Sudan near the Atbara and Gash rivers. Early domesticated race bicolor then spread to South Asia around 2000 BC and to the Niger Basin in West Africa after 1000 BC. The framework of five cultivated races remains useful, with the original domesticated race bicolor being characterized by tight-fitting hulls requiring dehusking and the other races representing subsequent parallel evolution for free-threshing and larger-grained cultivars. This took place at least three times, including race ‘caudatum’ focused initially on the Sahelian region race ‘durra’ that evolved probably in India, and race ‘guinea’ that evolved in forested West Africa. Early race guinea in turn produced an even more forest adapted ‘mageritiferum’ type that appears to be ancestral to southern African guinea and ‘kafir’ sorghums, implying a dispersal across the central African rainforests. In contrast other eastern African caudatums and ‘bicolor’ types presumably followed a savannah dispersal. In addition to the early dispersal of race bicolor from Africa to India, which was ancestral to East Asian sorghums, a later dispersal of guinea types is inferred to have taken place from southeastern Africa across the Indian Ocean.
... Unfortunately, changes in alimentary habits, the lack (Grassi 1998;Barberis et al. 2001;Chessa et al. 2001;Minonne et al. 2001), diffused, primarily, in four regions of southern Italy (Campania, Calabria, Puglia and Sicily), and in Tuscany. Particularly, archeobotanical researches, combined with historical sources, date the presence of the fig tree from the Neolithic, through the Roman Empire to the Middle Ages (Turfa 2012;Mariotti Lippi et al. 2009;Rattighieri et al. 2013;Buonincontri et al. 2014;Mariotti Lippi et al. 2015) and further on; as a matter of fact, historical references, found in XIII-XVI century documents, report the names of some varieties of fig, Dottato, Verdino, Brogiotto Nero and Brogiotto Bianco, cultivated in Tuscany (Baldini 1953). Even though, in Italy, fig cultivation has a long tradition and its germplasm is still wide, with more than 90 genotypes (Baldini 1953;Basso 1960a, b), information on their genetic identity are scarce and dubious, making their cataloguing very difficult. ...
Full-text available
Common fig (Ficus carica L.) is one of the most ancient domesticated species, originated, supposedly in Arabia, from where it diffused to the Middle East and Asia, and to the Mediterranean basin, where it greatly diffused. More than 600 fig varieties have been described, but it is conceivable that this number is underestimated. Along all the Italian territory, there is a rich germplasm of fig composed of a large number of varieties (approximately 300) of very not well defined origin. Effectively, during several centuries of cultivation and propagation by seed, a large number of genotypes appeared and were selected, leading to the generation of an uncountable number of genotypes, different in numerous traits, particularly in those related to leaves and fruits features. Unfortunately, the extensive existing fig genetic patrimony is facing genetic erosion; for this reason, it is extremely important to study and valorised it, in order to preserve the remaining biodiversity. The purpose of this study was to genetically characterize, with nSSR markers, 79 fig accessions, collected in several areas in Italy. The set of chosen markers resulted highly polymorphic, and allowed the characterization of all the studied accessions. Data were analysed by cluster analysis, and the results demonstrated a great genetic variability within the population. The nSSR used, moreover, allowed us to identify all accessions and to recognised possible homonyms and synonyms, and cases of intravarietal clones.
Why did weeds matter in the Carolingian empire? What was their special significance for writers in eighth- and ninth-century Europe and how was this connected with the growth of real weeds? In early medieval Europe, unwanted plants that persistently appeared among crops created extra work, reduced productivity, and challenged theologians who believed God had made all vegetation good. For the first time, in this book weeds emerge as protagonists in early medieval European history, driving human farming strategies and coloring people's imagination. Early medieval Europeans' effort to create agroecosystems that satisfied their needs and cosmologies that confirmed Christian accounts of vegetable creation both had to come to terms with unruly plants. Using diverse kinds of texts, fresh archaeobotanical data, and even mosaics, this interdisciplinary study reveals how early medieval Europeans interacted with their environments.
In the last few years, large-scale archaeological projects carried out at medieval sites in the Basque Country have obtained a significant collection of archaeobotanical assemblages, creating the opportunity to address, from a fresh perspective, a social history of agriculture in the region. This paper presents the study of the village of Zornoztegi (occupied from the Chalcolithic to the Late Medieval Ages, ca. 2500 BCE-1350 CE) and the estate centre of Aistra (settled during the Early Medieval period, 500–1000 CE), both of them located in the Province of Alava, 5 km apart. The comparison between the two sites, characterized by different food consumption patterns, architectures, everyday assemblages and social structure, sheds light upon food and productive practices, the socio-political structure of early medieval rural sites and the sources of social power in non-Carolingian areas. This paper also discusses site formation processes and their impact on the interpretation of the sites, crop productions and consumption patterns in the context of northern Iberia, and some remarks regarding agriculture production.
Charcoal analysis, applied in sediment facies analysis of the Pecora river palaeochannel (Tyrrhenian southern Tuscany, Italy), detected the occurrence of past fire events in two different fluvial landforms at 800–450 BC and again at AD 650–1300. Taking place in a central Mediterranean district adequately studied through palaeoenvironmental and archaeological research, the investigation determined land changes, time phases and socio-economic driving forces involved in dynamic processes of fire. The fire sequences had purely anthropogenic origins and were linked to forest opening and reduction by local communities. Introduced by the Etruscans, fires dated to 800–450 BC involved mainly the forest cover on the hilly slopes, ensuring agricultural exploitation. From AD 650, fires contributed to Medieval upstream reclamation and vegetation clearing of flat swamplands. From AD 850 to 1050, the use of fire spread over a wider area in the river valley, increasing arable lands. Between AD 1150 and 1300, fires belonged to a regional forest clearance phase. Medieval fire episodes had a paramount importance in shaping and determining the character of the Tuscan Mediterranean landscape. From AD 850, Medieval fire clearing influenced regional vegetation history contributing to the decline of the dominant deciduous Quercus woodland. Open habitats became the new form of a clearly detectable agricultural landscape from AD 950. The use of fire clearing and the resulting landscape changes in the Pecora river valley depended on the political strategies adopted by Medieval authorities and marked, in fact, the progression of a cultural landscape still characterizing central Tyrrhenian Italy.
Full-text available
This paper aims at discussing the importance of environmental factors in the stability of communities at local scale. Two case studies, referred to two medieval monastic communities are chosen as historical examples, under low-carbon conditions, to show the effects of the interplay between a lack of Community Based Adaptation (CBA) and difficult or changing environmental conditions. The case studies refer to the monastery of Bob-bio (Piacenza, Emilia-Romagna, Italy) and Castelletto Cervo (Biella, Pied-mont, Italy). In particular, the first case shows a lack of transformation of harsh regulations to the difficult environmental conditions of that time, which leaded to a revolt inside the monastery. On the other side, the decline of Castelletto Cervo Cluniac priory depended upon a bad management of economic resources in a time of environmental variability, which affected the agricultural yield and the life of many villages in the considered area. The choice analyzing the case of two low-carbon communities (i.e.: before the XVI century, when the massive diffusion and use of coal modified these conditions) depends on the present international political will and plans of decarbonizing our societal lifestyles. This research highlights the hidden environmental causes behind the social instability and, in one case, the collapse of the community. Besides further reasons for historical interest, which are not deepened in this research, these case studies show that environmental factors are often unseen or neglected in planning the life of a community, also exerting a strong influence on real economy at local level. In order to develop appropriate policies to guarantee a long-term resilience for the socio-ecological stability of communities, an adequate monitoring of appropriate environmental and social parameters can support planning activities.
Conference Paper
Full-text available
The aim of this paper is to investigate some native Italian species mainly having an eastern Mediterranean distribution, which, thanks to in-depth investigations, on their Italian sites of occurrence, sometimes associated with archaeological sites, can be assumed as the result of ancient introduction during the Greek or Phoenician colonization. Some of these taxa have been already examined from this point of view, others never before; but for each one, new data are provided. The investigated species are Salvia fruticosa Miller, Origanum onites L., Ferulago nodosa (L.) Boiss., Sarcopoterium spinosum (L.) Spach, Platanus orientalis L., Rhus tripartita (Ucria) Grande, and Ziziphus lotus ( L.) Lam. Our research is based on literature, herbarium specimens and field data aimed at pointing out the exact distribution and their integration into existing vegetation contexts.
Full-text available
The objective of this article is to discuss the theme of castle formation in the Maremma area and the development of seigneuries, in the light of the results of the most recent archeological research, carried out between 2007 and 2010. In the article we trace the settlement phases and the associated material evidence which, from the middle of the 9th century, show the alteration and fortification of an initial group of sites with specific economic vocations, linked to strong political powers before eventually culminating in a more homogeneous panorama, corresponding to the late 10th-11 th century, when we see a larger number of fortified settlements, and the first documented phases of development of the "territorial seigneuries". The 12th century is critically reinterpreted in the light of these new investigations, with an aim to describing the processes that are less standardized than those that have been identified so far for this part of Tuscany, on the basis of the different economic and political strategies, and the strategies of self-representation, of the seigneuries in question.
Two hundred and seventy carbonized naked wheat ears from the Neolithic pile dwelling at Hornstaad-Hörnle IA/Lake Constance (Germany) were analysed. The characteristics of internodes and glumes show that only tetraploid naked wheat types were cultivated. Following the history of free-threshing wheats it seems conceivable that the tetraploid naked wheats spread from their point of origin in the Middle East (7th/8th millennium B.C.) via a Mediterranean route to southwest Europe, reaching the northern foothills of the Alps about 4000 B.C. Key words: Naked wheat - Morphology - Wheat history - Neolithic - Lake Constance