Conference PaperPDF Available

Stereo-Video Methodology for Quantitative Analysis of Fish-Turbine Interactions

Authors:

Abstract and Figures

Tidal power turbines are developed to reach the ambition of supplying coastal communities with renewable energy. However, little is still known about the potential environmental effects on the local ecosystems and what rotor design can do to minimize such effects. The knowledge gap includes fish behavior around tidal power rotors and adequate sampling techniques for such studies. In this contribution stereo-video methodology has been used for monitoring fish movements at an operating model of a vertical-axis tidal turbine rotor. The results show that stereo-video methodology offers excellent opportunities for detailed analysis of fish behavior and several recommendations of how to optimize such sampling are provided. Preliminary results of fish-turbine interactions are presented.
Content may be subject to copyright.
A preview of the PDF is not available
... The GoPros were positioned according to a stereo-video system (Hammar et al. 2012, Harvey et al. 2004, 2008 (Figure 31) that was calibrated using a chess-board of black and white squares of known length before diving ( Figure 32). The videos obtained by the front and rear cameras will be analysed using the VideoSync software and will enable measuring the different objects. ...
Technical Report
Full-text available
This is the cruise report of the Belgica 121 expedition to the Gerlache Strait
... De Vos et al., 2014), analysing fish interactions with artificial structures (e.g. Hammar et al., 2012) and seagrass assessments to help monitor dugong and sea turtle habitats using citizen scientists (e.g. McKenzie et al., 2014). ...
Technical Report
Full-text available
Artificial reefs have been constructed and deployed in over 50 countries around the world to enhance the productivity of aquatic habitats and fishing experiences. In April 2013, two purpose-built concrete artificial reefs were deployed in Geographe Bay, Western Australia to provide additional fish habitat and increase upwelling and thus enhance recreational fishing opportunities. Due to the relatively high cost of planning, purchasing and deploying these structures, it is important to understand spatial and temporal usage of the reef by fish assemblages, in order to determine the extent to which fishing opportunities are actually enhanced. One potential method to reduce monitoring costs is to utilise volunteers from the general public to collect data, i.e. citizen science. The overall objective of this project was to determine whether recreational fishers, through a citizen science program, could potentially provide an effective means for monitoring artificial reefs. Following a recruitment drive and underwater camera trial, a small number of recreational fishers were provided underwater drop video cameras and asked to record footage on the Bunbury and Dunsborough artificial reefs and also nearby natural reefs. Unfortunately, only very limited amounts of data (~1 hour) were received due to a combination of a lack of participation/engagement, unseasonal weather and the short timeframe of the project. However, enough videos were received to undertake a preliminary analysis of the differences in the characteristics of the fish faunas of the two types of reef, i.e. natural vs artificial. The results indicate that artificial reefs may potentially harbour greater numbers of species and a larger total maximum abundance. Multivariate statistical analyses did not detect any differences in the fish faunal compositions between natural and artificial reefs, which were likely due to the dominance of King Wrasse (Coris auricularis) on both reefs. Furthermore, large amount of variability between replicates caused by the differences in recording time, which, although standardised, was still an artefact in the resultant data and may have masked any ‘real’ differences among the reef types. Given the limited data provided by the above monitoring program, a critical review of the citizen science components of the project was completed and a set of key recommendations for use in future projects using recreational fishers to collect video footage provided. These included: (i) enhancing the methods of contacting and recruiting volunteers to include social media and encouraging communication among participants, (ii) using a GoPro camera mounted on Baited Remote Underwater Video (BRUV) systems to ensure that the footage collected is of high quality (resolution), (iii) providing simplified and consistent instructions and (iv) ensuring regular communication and engagement with volunteers. A global literature review on citizen science and the benefits and limitations using this type of project for research purposes was also undertaken together with a brief description of such programs that have been or are being conducted in aquatic environments in WA. To test the suggestions the BRUV systems with a GoPro camera constructed from readily available materials could be deployed by recreational fishers as a citizen science artificial reef monitoring tool, Ecotone Consulting built one of these units and deployed it randomly around the Dunsborough artificial reef. The resultant footage was found to be of much higher quality than that obtained using the drop camera. The GoPro videos were analysed to determine whether there was a difference in fish assemblages between artificial reef modules and the surrounding area, i.e. videos where the camera directly faced one or more of the artificial reef modules were vs those were no modules could be observed in the camera’s field of view. The results demonstrated that mean number of species and the mean number of benthic and epibenthic species were greater on footage recorded when the camera faced the modules. There was also a difference in the faunal composition, with 52.63% more recreational target species being found on artificial reefs than in surrounding areas. It was also concluded that the BRUV technology could be used, by citizen scientists, to monitor the fish faunas of artificial reefs. Another potential method to reduce the cost of monitoring programs for the fish faunas of artificial reefs is to use citizens to analyse the footage as part of their studies. However, if such a program was to proceed using volunteers with limited experience, i.e. undergraduate students, it is important to ensure that the fish data extracted from the video is reliable. Thus, to investigate the impact of observer bias, the BRUV footage collected from the Dunsborough artificial reef was analysed by having multiple observers, with similar levels of marine science training and recreational fishing experience. It was found that whilst observers recorded similar mean numbers of species and total abundance counts, significant differences in species composition were detected. This was due to observers misidentifying members of particular families, i.e. the leatherjackets and trevallies. This suggests that, while observers with limited experience may be able to detect common species, misidentification of less common and/or less distinct species can lead to significant variation in the data due to observer bias. Therefore, if university students are to be used as part of any citizen science monitoring project, it is recommended that participants should receive additional training in species identification, and be subjected to an initial trial where their results are compared to that of a more experienced observer until a minimum similarity of 90% is consistently recorded. The provision of BRUV footage from the Bunbury artificial reef by Ecotone Consulting allowed statistical analysis of fish faunas on both reefs to be undertaken to identify what level of information could be obtained using the BRUVs. Analysis of the data found both the mean number of species and total abundance were greater at the Dunsborough artificial reef and that there was also a significant difference in species composition. While, more data are required to provide a more accurate picture of any differences, this does highlight the fact that the BRUV footage can be employed to test for differences in the fish faunas of these reefs and possibly also nearby natural reef or other areas. It is concluded that recreational fishers did not provide an effective means for monitoring artificial reefs during this project. This result, however, is a consequence of a lack of data stemming from an absence of volunteer engagement in a limited pilot project with a short time frame and unseasonal weather. This does not exclude the potential for using citizen scientists to monitor artificial reefs, following some changes in the methodology, technology and management of citizen science protocols, and thus it is possible to utilise recreational fishers as an effective means for monitoring artificial reefs. This project was subjected to restrictive and limiting factors but more importantly, discovered ways to overcome these issues by provided key recommendations on technology, methodologies and community engagement that should be followed to increase the effectiveness of using recreational fishers to provide sound scientific information in the future and these have been actively employed in a new citizen science program for monitoring the fish fauna of the Bunbury and Dunsborough artificial reefs Reef Vision.
... De Vos et al, 2014), analysing fish interactions with artificial structures (e.g. Hammar et al, 2012) and seagrass assessments to help monitor dugong and sea turtle habitats using citizen scientists (e.g. McKenzie et al, 2014). ...
Thesis
Artificial reefs have been constructed and deployed globally to enhance the productivity of aquatic habitats. In April 2013, two artificial reefs were deployed in Geographe Bay, Western Australia for the purpose of enhancing recreational fishing opportunities. These reefs are designed to create varied complex spaces and habitats, as well as to create shallow water upwelling to drive nutrients up into the water column. The deployment of artificial reefs in Australia has recently become the subject of specific focus of policy makers and regulators. Monitoring costs to meet legislative requirements can be prohibitive, however, a potential method to reduce these costs is to utilise volunteers from the general public to collect data (i.e. citizen science). Thus, the overall objective of this project was to determine whether recreational fishers could potentially provide an effective means for monitoring artificial reefs. A small number of recreational fishers were provided with underwater video cameras and asked to record footage of artificial reefs and nearby natural reefs. Unfortunately, only limited amounts of data were received due to the lack of participation, unseasonal weather and the short timeframe of the project. However, enough videos were received to undertake a preliminary analysis of the differences in the characteristics of the fish faunas of the two types of reef. The results demonstrated that artificial reefs had much higher levels of mean and maximum abundance, number of species and ecological group affinities. However, multivariate statistical analyses did not detect any differences between the fish faunal compositions between artificial and natural reefs. This was due to the dominance of the labrid Coris auricularis and the large amount of variability between replicates. Given the limited data provided by the above citizen science program, a literature review on other similar projects to evaluate the effectiveness of the citizen science components of the pilot project was completed and provided a set of key recommendations. These included enhancing the methods of contacting and recruiting volunteers, providing simplified and consistent instructions and consistent communication and engagement with volunteers. Finally, Baited Remote Underwater Video (BRUV) systems, constructed from readily available materials, were deployed randomly around the Busselton artificial reef to test the applicability of this method for future use as a citizen science artificial reef monitoring tool. The video footage was analysed to determine whether there was a difference in fish assemblages between artificial reef modules and the surrounding area, i.e. videos observing areas in which artificial reef modules were, and were not, observed in the camera’s field of view. The results demonstrated that mean number of species and the number of benthic and epibenthic species were greater on footage recorded when the camera faced the modules. There was also a difference in the faunal composition. The footage observing artificial reef modules also exhibited 52.63% more recreational target species than surrounding areas. It was concluded that the BRUV technology employed here could be used, by citizen scientists, to monitor the fish faunas of artificial reefs. However, as this study has also demonstrated that there were significant differences in the characteristics of the fish faunas recorded depending on the direction the camera was facing, consideration is needed to design an unbiased and robust quantitative monitoring regime. It is concluded that recreational fishers did not provide an effective means for monitoring artificial reefs during this project. This result, however, is a consequence of a lack of data stemming from an absence of volunteer engagement in a limited pilot project with a short time frame and unseasonal weather. This does not exclude the potential for using citizen scientists to monitor artificial reefs, following some changes in the methodology, technology and management of citizen science protocols, and thus it is possible to utilise recreational fishers as an effective means for monitoring artificial reefs. This project was subjected to restrictive and limiting factors but more importantly, discovered ways to overcome these issues by provided key recommendations on technology, methodologies and community engagement that should be followed to increase the effectiveness of using recreational fishers to provide sound scientific information in the future.
... De Vos et al, 2014), analysing fish interactions with artificial structures (e.g. Hammar et al, 2012) and seagrass assessments to help monitor dugong and sea turtle habitats using citizen scientists (e.g. McKenzie et al, 2014). ...
Thesis
Full-text available
Artificial reefs have been constructed and deployed globally to enhance the productivity of aquatic habitats. In April 2013, two artificial reefs were deployed in Geographe Bay, Western Australia for the purpose of enhancing recreational fishing opportunities. These reefs are designed to create varied complex spaces and habitats, as well as to create shallow water upwelling to drive nutrients up into the water column. The deployment of artificial reefs in Australia has recently become the subject of specific focus of policy makers and regulators. Monitoring costs to meet legislative requirements can be prohibitive, however, a potential method to reduce these costs is to utilise volunteers from the general public to collect data (i.e. citizen science). Thus, the overall objective of this project was to determine whether recreational fishers could potentially provide an effective means for monitoring artificial reefs. A small number of recreational fishers were provided with underwater video cameras and asked to record footage of artificial reefs and nearby natural reefs. Unfortunately, only limited amounts of data were received due to the lack of participation, unseasonal weather and the short timeframe of the project. However, enough videos were received to undertake a preliminary analysis of the differences in the characteristics of the fish faunas of the two types of reef. The results demonstrated that artificial reefs had much higher levels of mean and maximum abundance, number of species and ecological group affinities. However, multivariate statistical analyses did not detect any differences between the fish faunal compositions between artificial and natural reefs. This was due to the dominance of the labrid Coris auricularis and the large amount of variability between replicates. Given the limited data provided by the above citizen science program, a literature review on other similar projects to evaluate the effectiveness of the citizen science components of the pilot project was completed and provided a set of key recommendations. These included enhancing the methods of contacting and recruiting volunteers, providing simplified and consistent instructions and consistent communication and engagement with volunteers. Finally, Baited Remote Underwater Video (BRUV) systems, constructed from readily available materials, were deployed randomly around the Busselton artificial reef to test the applicability of this method for future use as a citizen science artificial reef monitoring tool. The video footage was analysed to determine whether there was a difference in fish assemblages between artificial reef modules and the surrounding area, i.e. videos observing areas in which artificial reef modules were, and were not, observed in the camera’s field of view. The results demonstrated that mean number of species and the number of benthic and epibenthic species were greater on footage recorded when the camera faced the modules. There was also a difference in the faunal composition. The footage observing artificial reef modules also exhibited 52.63% more recreational target species than surrounding areas. It was concluded that the BRUV technology employed here could be used, by citizen scientists, to monitor the fish faunas of artificial reefs. However, as this study has also demonstrated that there were significant differences in the characteristics of the fish faunas recorded depending on the direction the camera was facing, consideration is needed to design an unbiased and robust quantitative monitoring regime. It is concluded that recreational fishers did not provide an effective means for monitoring artificial reefs during this project. This result, however, is a consequence of a lack of data stemming from an absence of volunteer engagement in a limited pilot project with a short time frame and unseasonal weather. This does not exclude the potential for using citizen scientists to monitor artificial reefs, following some changes in the methodology, technology and management of citizen science protocols, and thus it is possible to utilise recreational fishers as an effective means for monitoring artificial reefs. This project was subjected to restrictive and limiting factors but more importantly, discovered ways to overcome these issues by provided key recommendations on technology, methodologies and community engagement that should be followed to increase the effectiveness of using recreational fishers to provide sound scientific information in the future.
... However, most fish have well developed visual senses, particularly nocturnal species and species active in deep water. During the day and most conditions at night fish are likely to detect the turbine and attempt to escape the rotor, as has been observed at field surveys around deployed turbines [12,13,25]. When accounting for light conditions and organism sensing capabilities the results may be altered so that a smaller turbine (e.g. ...
Conference Paper
Full-text available
Advances in tidal power development indicate that many coastal straits and bends with rapid currents will be equipped with in-stream turbines in the future. Considering the variety among turbine designs it is reasonable to assume both large and small rotors will be utilized. Each design implies a different way of interfering with local environment. However, there are very few available reports on fish behaviour in the presence of in-stream turbines. In this paper fish swimming behaviour is investigated in relation to the risk of colliding with different tidal turbine rotors. Based on an existing model and Monte-Carlo simulations with biological data from a field survey the blade-strike probability is calculated for three different and widespread fish taxa (damselfishes, requiem sharks, and barracudas). The results indicate that small turbines carry higher risks, as long as fish are assumed not to detect and actively avoid the rotor. However, the following paper indicates that improvements to the model may alter these results. Furthermore, it is shown that the potential hazard of tidal turbines varies strongly between different fish taxa and individuals. And seemingly it is 'the bad' that has the most reasons to be afraid.
... Recordings from the main systems were used for all but one sampling occasion. The difference in camera positioning between main and spare systems had little effect on fish identification [42] (see Figure 2 for comparison). The stereo-field (the zone allowing for size and distance measurements) was about 1.5 m wide at the centre of the rotor and 6 m wide at 5 m distance. ...
Article
Full-text available
Hydrokinetic turbines, targeting the kinetic energy of fast-flowing currents, are under development with some turbines already deployed at ocean sites around the world. It remains virtually unknown as to how these technologies affect fish, and rotor collisions have been postulated as a major concern. In this study the effects of a vertical axis hydrokinetic rotor with rotational speeds up to 70 rpm were tested on the swimming patterns of naturally occurring fish in a subtropical tidal channel. Fish movements were recorded with and without the rotor in place. Results showed that no fish collided with the rotor and only a few specimens passed through rotor blades. Overall, fish reduced their movements through the area when the rotor was present. This deterrent effect on fish increased with current speed. Fish that passed the rotor avoided the near-field, about 0.3 m from the rotor for benthic reef fish. Large predatory fish were particularly cautious of the rotor and never moved closer than 1.7 m in current speeds above 0.6 ms(-1). The effects of the rotor differed among taxa and feeding guilds and it is suggested that fish boldness and body shape influenced responses. In conclusion, the tested hydrokinetic turbine rotor proved non-hazardous to fish during the investigated conditions. However, the results indicate that arrays comprising multiple turbines may restrict fish movements, particularly for large species, with possible effects on habitat connectivity if migration routes are exploited. Arrays of the investigated turbine type and comparable systems should therefore be designed with gaps of several metres width to allow large fish to pass through. In combination with further research the insights from this study can be used for guiding the design of hydrokinetic turbine arrays where needed, so preventing ecological impacts.
Article
Full-text available
A new generation of hydropower technologies, the kinetic hydro and wave energy conversion devices, offers the possibility of generating electricity from the movements of water, without the need for dams and diversions. The Energy Policy Act of 2005 encouraged the development of these sources of renewable energy in the United States, and there is growing interest in deploying them globally. The technologies that would extract electricity from free-flowing streams, estuaries, and oceans have not been widely tested. Consequently, the U.S. Department of Energy convened a workshop to (1) identify the varieties of hydrokinetic energy and wave energy conversion devices and their stages of development, (2) identify where these technologies can best operate, (3) identify the potential environmental issues associated with these technologies and possible mitigation measures, and (4) develop a list of research needs and/or practical solutions to address unresolved environmental issues. We review the results of that workshop, focusing on potential effects on freshwater, estuarine, and marine ecosystems, and we describe recent national and international developments.
Article
Full-text available
The in situ estimation of the length of marine biological specimens or features by Scuba divers is complicated by the magnifying properties of water and the underwater environment. In this paper we describe the development and preliminary testing of an underwater stereo-video system which is designed to make accurate and precise measurements of the lengths of marine subjects. The results of 640 measurements of 16 plastic silhouettes of fish are presented. The initial results demonstrate the ability of the system to make accurate and repeatable measurements of length when the orientation of the subject to the stereo-video cameras is less than 75 degrees.
Article
Full-text available
1. The evidence for anthropogenically induced climate change is overwhelming with the production of greenhouse gases from burning fossil fuels being a key driver. In response, many governments have initiated programmes of energy production from renewable sources. 2. The marine environment presents a relatively untapped energy source and offshore installations are likely to produce a significant proportion of future energy production. Wind power is the most advanced, with development of wave and tidal energy conversion devices expected to increase worldwide in the near future. 3. Concerns over the potential impacts on biodiversity of marine renewable energy installations (MREI) include: habitat loss, collision risks, noise and electromagnetic fields. These factors have been posited as having potentially important negative environmental impacts. 4. Conversely, we suggest that if appropriately managed and designed, MREI may increase local biodiversity and potentially benefit the wider marine environment. Installations have the capacity to act as both artificial reefs and fish aggregation devices, which have been used previously to facilitate restoration of damaged ecosystems, and de facto marine-protected areas, which have proven successful in enhancing both biodiversity and fisheries. 5. The deployment of MREI has the potential to cause conflict among interest groups including energy companies, the fishing sector and environmental groups. Conflicts should be minimized by integrating key stakeholders into the design, siting, construction and operational phases of the installations, and by providing clear evidence of their potential environmental benefits. 6. Synthesis and applications. MREI have the potential to be both detrimental and beneficial to the environment but the evidence base remains limited. To allow for full biodiversity impacts to be assessed, there exists an urgent need for additional multi and inter-disciplinary research in this area ranging from engineering to policy. Whilst there are a number of factors to be considered, one of the key decisions facing current policy makers is where installations should be sited, and, dependent upon site, whether they should be designed to either minimize negative environmental impacts or as facilitators of ecosystem restoration.
Article
Artificial coastal reefs were initially installed off Reunion Island (SW Indian Ocean) in order to attract and catch small pelagic fish of economic importance for the local fishery. These artificial reefs also attract a high density of juvenile coral reef fish, especially after recruitment. Because of high species richness and density, a suitable method of evaluating diversity and abundance in such assemblages is needed. An experiment was conducted in situ for 1 year in order to test which of the two visual techniques, slate or video recording, would be the most suitable for sampling artificial reefs. For the quantitative study, a rope framework (four belt transects each measuring 24×3 m) was used to ease the movement of the divers. To avoid bias due to time variations, the study was conducted under limited time in situ. The advantages and disadvantages of the two techniques regarding the accuracy of qualitative and quantitative results are discussed. The qualitative study results show that the slate technique is the most accurate one for determining species richness. In the quantitative study, factors such as species characteristics (ecological type), attractiveness (relationship between fish and diver) and abundance of fish communities around the artificial reefs appear to influence our results on the comparison of the two techniques. Of 13 ‘permanent’ (observed in more than 75% of dives) species, 6 returned a similar frequency of detection by slate and video (Lutjanus kasmira, Lutjanus bengalensis, Priacanthus hamrur, Chaetodon kleinii, Heniochus diphreutes, Mulloides vanicolensis); these were then selected for comparison of the techniques using quantitative data. The correlation between video and slate census results is high, but, in comparison with the slate census, the video census underestimates abundance, especially for low values. A corrected index is proposed to remedy this underestimation; it could be used for video surveys conducted on species responding well to video detection (as below).
Article
An emerging class of renewable energy technology, the hydrokinetic conversion device (HCD), offers ways to capture the energy of flowing water without the impoundment or diversion of the conventional hydroelectric facilities based on dams and penstocks. Hydrokinetic technologies are designed for deployment in natural streams, like rivers, tidal estuaries, ocean currents, and also in some constructed waterways (e.g. canals). In ocean-energy deployment, hydrokinetic conversion devices can be flexibly arranged into multi-unit arrays, which would extract energy from tidal and marine currents basically in the same way as a wind farm.This article focuses on recent advances and trends in hydrokinetic system development that may lead to a feasible future scenario for hydrokinetic power. The basic principles of HCDs are explained, and early experiences in the field described. With the help of technical reports, papers, proceedings and websites, we then review existing and emerging technologies in the HCD field. Innovation in mooring, and power transmission systems are also covered.
Article
Article
Baited remote underwater stereo-video (stereo-BRUV) stations and diver operated stereo-video (stereo-DOV) transects are increasingly used to sample both tropical and temperate fish assemblages. Compared to in situ visual census methods, the use of stereo-video reduces inter-observer variability, improves definition of the sample unit area, increases accuracy of fish length estimates and provides a permanent record of the assemblage that can be validated where required or independently reanalysed. Previous studies have suggested that stereo-BRUV collects representative data on both carnivorous and herbivorous species and can be more cost-efficient than diver-based survey methods. This study compares estimates of common fish assemblage metrics obtained with stereo-BRUV stations and stereo-DOV transects across 3 biogeographic regions, and uses a cost-optimization procedure to compare the efficiency of these 2 methods. Stereo-BRUV stations were found to sample greater species richness and obtain greater estimates of relative biomass of generalist carnivores, but no differences occurred in the biomass of herbivores sampled by the 2 techniques. Stereo-BRUV stations generally obtained estimates of assemblage metrics with less variance, resulting in greater power to detect spatial and temporal changes in the fish assemblage metrics. Cost benefit analyses found that stereo-BRUV was generally more time efficient than stereo-DOV transects in terms of smaller standard error around the mean of the various metrics considered. However, across the 3 biogeographic regions sampled there was considerable variation in the magnitude of these differences. Results suggest that stereo-BRUV stations are, in general, a more cost-effective method for monitoring fish assemblages than stereo-DOV transects.