ArticlePDF Available

The Global Decline of Intercountry Adoption: What Lies Ahead?

Authors:

Abstract and Figures

This article examines the latest trends in intercountry adoption worldwide, based on data from twenty-three receiving countries. Trends in the number of children sent by states of origin are based on their returns to the Hague Special Commission or on estimates derived from country data provided by the receiving states. The analysis concentrates on the period from 2004 to 2010 when estimated annual global numbers declined from 45,000 to 29,000, fewer than those recorded in 1998. The article will also look at changes in the age – and other characteristics – of children sent. Discussion centres on changes in sending countries, exploring the declines in China, Russia and Guatemala, the rise in adoptions from Haiti after the earthquake of 2010 and the emergence of Africa – and in particular Ethiopia – as a significant source of children for adoption. The article concludes with a consideration of the implications of a continuing high demand from childless couples in developed countries on the intercountry adoption ‘market’; and the prediction of David Smolin that, unless truly reformed, intercountry adoption will eventually be abolished and labeled as a ‘neo-colonial mistake’.
Content may be subject to copyright.
A preview of the PDF is not available
... IDENTITY IN ADOLESCENTS ADOPTED FROM RUSSIA 3 experiences of discrimination, and birth culture exploration in adolescents adopted in Spain from Russia, one of the main countries of origin for international adoption worldwide in the last 25 years (Selman, 2012). ...
... Russia has been a major country of origin during the boom of international adoptions in the mid-90s and early 2000s, along with China (Selman, 2012). Most of the children adopted from Russia at the end of the 2000s and in the first decade of the 21 st century, mainly in the USA, Spain, Italy, France, and Canada, are reaching or have already reached adolescence and emerging adulthood. ...
Article
In this study, we examined identification and interest with birth country, perceived discrimination, and related issues through self-report in 69 adolescents adopted from Russia to Spain. The adolescents showed a high degree of interest in their birth country, and most of them considered that their birth country is a part of their identity. There were differences in birth-country related variables depending on how much adopted adolescents felt others perceived them as foreigners. Considering internationally adopted youth needs regarding their origins, even in traditionally considered “same-race” adoptions, is essential for supporting them in the path towards integrated identity development.
... I engage on adoption as a colonial industry, following various "adoptee activists" and researchers (Cawayu, 2020;Cawayu & De Graeve, 2022;De Graeve, 2014, 2015bDiemar & Wool-Rim, 2024a, 2024bIllescas Miranda, 2023;Sacré et al., 2023;Selman, 2012;Witheckx et al., n.d.). Industry as the movement of sectors across geographical dispersed spaces that accumulated wealth (Andersson, 2017, pp. ...
Thesis
Full-text available
This research examines the experiences of people that were adopted from Bolivia and raised in Belgium. The aim of this research is to assess the impact of their “looks” based on their life stories. Employing ethnographic fieldwork, informal interviews and active participation, this study engaged with 12 people between 27 and 45 years old related to The Network of Bolivian adoptees. The interlocutors were articulated into three friend groups from Belgium together with one from Sweden for triangulation purposes. The study found that their “looks” articulated a group categorized as foreigners in Belgium, while providing superficial inclusion in Bolivia. This embodied dissonance underscores the limitations of inclusion derived from socio-cultural learning in Belgium. This research pointed out the relevance of the geographical distance in adoption with a novel concept of “transcontinental adoption,” together with “existential hole” and “love” to elucidate its dynamics. Furthermore, it endorses the rooted child paradigm (De Graeve, 2014, 2015a) as a viable upbringing model and offers recommendations for enhancing transcontinental adoptions. Keywords: Transcontinental adoption, looks, family, Bolivia, Belgium.
... International adoption of children who spent their early years in orphanages or institutions has been widespread in Europe and North America in the last 30 years (Selman, 2012). Notwithstanding its challenges, international adoption has been broadly successful in providing a stimulating and nurturing family environment for children with early adversity, resulting in an impressive catch-up across most developmental domains (Palacios et al., 2019;van IJzendoorn & Juffer, 2006). ...
Article
Full-text available
Background: Internationally adopted children who suffered early institutionalization are at risk of a late onset of internalizing problems in adolescence. Both pre-adoption, adversity-related, and post-adoption factors predict variability in internalizing problems in this population. Previous studies have suggested different patterns of parent- adolescent informant discrepancies in adoptive dyads. Method: We analyzed internalizing problems among 66 adolescents internationally adopted from Russia to Spanish families using both the parent- and self-report version of the Strengths and Difficulties Questionnaire and comparing them with a low-risk, community group (n = 30). We assessed pre-adoption and post-adoption factors and evaluated cross-informant discrepancies. Results: Internationally adopted adolescents exhibited more internalizing problems by parent-report than community adolescents, but there were no differences by self-report. Adopted youth showed no discrepancies between parent and self-report, whereas community adolescents reported more internalizing symptoms than their parents. Pre-adoption adversity-related factors predicted parent-reported internalizing problems, while post-adoption factors predicted self-reported internalizing problems. Conclusions: Parent-adolescent informant discrepancies in adopted adolescents from Eastern Europe for internalizing symptoms were lower than in community adolescents. Both adversity-related factors and the lived experience of adoption may influence the development of internalizing symptoms in internationally adopted adolescents.
Article
Full-text available
Introduction There is a gap in the literature on the romantic relationships of adopted adolescents. To address this issue, the present study has three aims: (1) to explore differences between adopted and non‐adopted adolescents in terms of their involvement in and the length of their romantic relationships; (2) to explore the quality of these relationships; and (3) to analyze associations between affective relationships and well‐being in both groups. Method The sample comprised 276 adopted (64.5% girls; mean age 16.3 years, 73.9% international adoptees) and 276 non‐adopted (48.3% girls; mean age 16.3 years) adolescents, all of whom participated in the Spanish Health Behaviour in School‐aged Children survey. Results Similar romantic relationship rates and lengths were found among adoptees and non‐adoptees, as well as between international and domestic adoptees. Adoptees reported more emotional support and conflicts in their romantic relationships than their non‐adopted peers. Finally, associations between the quality of the romantic relationships and well‐being were similar for both groups, with more conflicts being linked to lower levels of well‐being, and more emotional support and affection correlating with higher levels of well‐being. Discussion The data suggest more similarities than differences between adopted and non‐adopted adolescents. However, although this indicates that romantic relationships are yet another example of recovery for adopted boys and girls, further research is required, with larger and more diverse samples from multiple countries, to explore the differences observed in more detail.
Article
The invasion of Ukraine paints a complex picture for children. Russia has been accused of kidnapping and genocide, violating international rights and humanitarian laws. Some children taken by Russia will be adopted, all will be Russified, and the fate of others is unknown. Children of all ages taken from families or institutions have become weapons of war. Attempts at ‘rescues’ for the purpose of adoption mean children are also at risk from other actors. Social workers and NGOs play important roles in work with these children and their families. The Taken Children of Ukraine is the focus of this article.
Article
Ces dernières années, le domaine de l’adoption en Belgique a connu une formalisation juridique croissante, à l’instar d’un mouvement international consacrant comme pilier légal la notion d’« intérêt supérieur de l’enfant ». La procédure d’adoption est désormais un processus balisé, sélectif, tandis qu’elle est gérée par un milieu associatif qui s’est professionnalisé. Cet article, au travers d’entretiens menés avec des professionnel·les, des candidat·es et des parents adoptants, tend à observer cette procédure comme un prisme privilégié permettant d’analyser non seulement les mutations des définitions de la parentalité et des configurations familiales mais aussi le rôle des acteur·ices de terrain dans l’établissement et le renforcement de ces notions. Ainsi se dégage de cette entreprise « psycho-technocratique » un modèle normatif de « bonne » parentalité, défendu au nom d’une charge émotionnelle liée à l’intérêt supérieur de l’enfant. Ce modèle est soutenu et renforcé par des outils administratifs et psychologiques de gouvernement des individus, reposant d’une part sur un système de production narrative qui vise au développement de soi et, d’autre part, sur des normes familiales essentialistes et parfois hétéronormatives.
Article
Full-text available
Introduction The Growth of Intercountry Adoption in the Twentieth Century The Rise and Fall of Sending Countries Age and Gender in International Adoption Sending Countries 1948 to 1989 Intercountry Adoption Since 1990 How are Internationally Adopted Children Faring? Africa-A New Untapped Source with Huge Capacity? The Future of Intercountry Adoption
Book
This book explores the economic, religious, political and personal forces that led to some 80,000 British children being sent to Canada between 1867 and 1915. How did this come about? What were the motives and methods of the people involved? Why did it come to an end? What effects did it have on the children involved and what eventually became of them? These are the questions Roy Parker explores in this meticulously researched work. His book - humane and highly professional - will capture and hold the interest of many: the academic, the practitioner and the general reader.
Book
Discover the roots of international transracial adoption
Article
Introduction North America Intercountry Adoptions: Experiences of Families in the United States Adoption of Native Children in Canada: A Policy Analysis and a Research Report Western Europe Norway: Intercountry Adoptions in a Homogeneous Country Barbro Saetersdal and Monica Dalen International Adoption in West Germany: A Private Affair The Conditions of 18-25-Year-Old Foreign-Born Adoptees in Denmark Intercountry Adoption Coming of Age in The Netherlands: Basic Issues, Trends, and Developments The Middle East Foreign Adoptions in Israel: Private Paths to Parenthood Selected Bibliography Index