Conference PaperPDF Available

Discontinuity layout optimization: A new numerical procedure for upper bound limit analysis

Authors:

Abstract

Discontinuity Layout Optimization (DLO) is a recently developed and extremely promising alternative to more well established numerical limit analysis procedures (e.g. finite element limit analysis). With DLO a comparatively simple discontinuum problem formulation is considered: a given planar body is discretised using a suitably large number of nodes laid out on a grid and the failure mechanism is deemed to comprise the most critical sub-set of potential discontinuities inter-connecting these nodes, identified using mathematical programming techniques. Here the procedure is outlined and its promise is demonstrated by applying it to various standard limit analysis problems.
IX Internatinal Conference on Computational Plasticity
COMPLAS IX
E. O˜nate and D.R.J. Owen (Eds)
c
°CIMNE, Barcelona, 2007
DISCONTINUITY LAYOUT OPTIMIZATION: A NEW
NUMERICAL PROCEDURE FOR UPPER BOUND LIMIT
ANALYSIS
Matthew Gilbertand Colin C. Smith
Computational Limit Analysis & Design Unit
Department of Civil & Structural Engineering
University of Sheffield, Mappin Street, Sheffield S1 3JD, UK
e-mail: m.gilbert@sheffield.ac.uk c.c.smith@sheffield.ac.uk
web page: http://www.cladu.shef.ac.uk/
Key words: Computational Plasticity, Limit Analysis
Summary. Discontinuity Layout Optimization (DLO) is a recently developed and extremely
promising alternative to more well established numerical limit analysis procedures (e.g. finite
element limit analysis). With DLO a comparatively simple discontinuum problem formulation
is considered: a given planar body is discretised using a suitably large number of nodes laid out
on a grid and the failure mechanism is deemed to comprise the most critical sub-set of potential
discontinuities inter-connecting these nodes, identified using mathematical programming tech-
niques. Here the procedure is outlined and its promise is demonstrated by applying it to various
standard limit analysis problems.
1 INTRODUCTION
When an estimate of the ultimate load carrying capacity of a body or component is required,
computational limit analysis tools have the potential to play an invaluable role in bridging
the gap between existing hand-type calculations and highly complex non-linear modelling tech-
niques. One such tool which has been investigated by academic researchers over a period of
several decades is finite element limit analysis. However, despite its promise, for a variety of
reasons this method has not yet found its way into general engineering practice.
Discontinuity Layout Optimization (DLO) is a recently developed alternative to finite element
limit analysis which shows significant promise. Though there are certain similarities between
DLO and previously proposed numerical formulations (e.g. as with the formulation of Munro
& da Fonseca1, the zones lying between potential discontinuities are simply assumed to be
rigid), a key differentiator is that the DLO problem is formulated entirely in terms of potential
discontinuities interconnecting nodes, rather than in terms of (solid) elements. This means that
discontinuities can be allowed to freely cross-over one another, considerably increasing the search
space and hence the ability of the procedure to identify complex failure mechanisms. Benefits of
the procedure are that singularities are identified without difficulty and, as failure mechanisms
are explicitly identified, output is easy to interpret (e.g. see Fig. 1).
1
Matthew Gilbert and Colin C. Smith
(a)
(b) (c) (d)
Figure 1: Sample DLO output, showing discontinuities at failure: (a) bearing capacity problem (weight-
less sand with φ= 25oand uniform surcharge, also showing nodal discretization); (b) max. height of
vertical cut in clay problem (translational mechanism); (c) horizontal anchor in clay pullout problem; (d)
uniformly loaded square concrete slab problem (fixed supports)
2 BRIEF OUTLINE OF THE DLO PROCEDURE
The Discontinuity Layout Optimization (DLO) procedure was devised following (re)discovery
by the authors of the similarity in the forms of optimum trussesand critical arrangements of
lines of failure (i.e. discontinuities) in limit analysis problems (e.g. see Fig. 2). In fact the
analogy was formally identified almost half a century ago3,4,5, but, apart from leading to a
realization that established analytical solution methods used in limit analysis could be applied
to the then emerging field of truss layout optimization, little use appears to have been made of
the analogy in the intervening years. However, with DLO well developed approximate-discretized
truss layout optimization techniques are effectively being transferred back to the field of limit
analysis. Consider for example a plane strain problem involving a Tresca (cohesive) material:
slip displacements along discontinuities correspond to bar forces (Fig. 2), and the objectives of
finding the minimum (slip) energy dissipation and minimum (truss) volume solutions are also
found to be analogous. Full details are provided in a forthcoming publication6.
An optimum truss (after Michell2) comprises an arrangement of bars of minimum total weight to support
specified applied loads without yielding.
2
Matthew Gilbert and Colin C. Smith
3
3
(a) Truss layout problem: loading & support con-
ditions; domain, nodal discretisation & ‘ground
structure’; optimal bar layout & pre-existing bars
along top of domain are highlighted
3
33
18
20 20
18
2
42
line of zero cohesion
(b) Discontinuity layout problem: imposed dis-
placement conditions; domain, nodal discretisation
& optimal slip-line layout (i.e. as (a)); labelled
slip line displacements (corresponding to truss bar
forces)
Figure 2: Analogy between (a) truss layout and (b) discontinuity layout optimization problems
The use of Linear Programming (LP) guarantees that a globally optimal solution is obtained
for a given nodal discretization. Increased accuracy can be obtained by increasing the nodal
density and by making use of an adaptive nodal connection procedure originally developed for
truss optimization7, allowing problems with up to 109potential discontinuities to be treated.
Although the simple truss analogy exists only for in-plane problems involving weightless cohesive
media, DLO can be applied to problems involving various constitutive relations and loading
regimes (e.g. a bearing capacity on sand problem with fine nodal refinement is shown on Fig.
1(a); a problem involving body forces is shown on Fig. 1(b); a concrete slab problem subjected
to distributed out-of-plane live loading is shown on Fig. 1(d)).
A selection of DLO results for standard problems are tabulated in Table 1. In all cases nodes
were laid out uniformly over the problem domains (i.e. no manual, problem specific, refinement
was undertaken). The close agreement with known exact analytical solutions using the basic
DLO procedure demonstrates its promise (solutions are within 1% in all but one case). For two
problems exact solutions were not available: (i) for the vertical cut problem a solution reasonably
close to that previously obtained using a carefully tailored finite element mesh geometry8was
obtained; (ii) for the horizontal anchor problem the DLO procedure produced a significantly
better upper bound solution than that previously obtained using finite element limit analysis9.
3 CONCLUDING REMARKS
Discontinuity Layout Optimization (DLO) is a powerful new numerical procedure which
shows considerable promise. In contrast with finite element limit analysis, no mesh is required
and the underlying formulation is simpler. Furthermore, stress / displacement singularities can
For the quoted DLO solution only translational displacements were permitted but the solution may have been
better still had rotations also been allowed.
3
Matthew Gilbert and Colin C. Smith
Literature DLO
Problem solution solution % diff.
Square concrete slab (simple supports) 24 24 0.00
Square concrete slab (fixed supports) - Fig. 1(d) 42.851 42.869 0.04
Compressed metal block (width / height = 3.64) 3.334 3.335 0.03
Smooth footing on sand (Nqwith φ= 25o) - Fig. 1(a) 10.662 10.684 0.21
Smooth footing on sand (Nγwith φ= 25o) 3.461 3.563 2.94
Maximum height of a vertical cut in clay - Fig. 1(b) 3.7823.7970.4
Horizontal anchor pullout in clay (embedment ratio = 8) - Fig. 1(c) 7.67.247 (-4.6)
Upper bound finite-element limit analysis solution
Assuming translational failure mechanism
Table 1: Comparison of literature and DLO solutions for various well known problems (solutions are
expressed in the form commonly used for each problem type, e.g. as a dimensionless load factor)
be handled automatically (i.e. without the need for tailored meshes) and failure mechanisms
are explicitly identified so output can be interpreted easily. For the same reason the method can
also be used as a tool for users wishing to identify new analytical solutions.
4 ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS
The first author acknowledges the support provided by EPSRC (grant ref: GR/S53329/01).
REFERENCES
[1] J. Munro and A. Da Fonseca. Yield line method by finite elements and linear programming.
The Structural Engineer,56B(2), 37-44, (1978).
[2] A.G.M. Michell. The limits of economy of material in frame-structures, Phil. Mag.,8, 589-
597, (1904)
[3] W.S. Hemp. Rep. 115: Theory of structural design, College Aeronautics, Cranfield, (1958).
[4] M.P. Neilson. Plasticitetsteorien for jernbetonplader (Theory of plasticity for reinforced con-
crete slabs): Licentiatafhandling, Danmarks Tekniske Hojskole, Copenhagen, (1962).
[5] W. Prager. On a problem of optimal design, Proc. IUTAM Symposium on non-homogeneity
in elasticity and plasticity, Warsaw, London: Pergamon, 125-132, (1959).
[6] C.C. Smith and M. Gilbert. Application of discontinuity layout optimization to plane plas-
ticity problems, accepted for publication in Proc. R. Soc. A, (2007)
[7] M. Gilbert and A. Tyas. Layout optimization of large-scale pin-jointed frames, Engineering
Computations,20 (8), 1044-1064, (2003).
[8] J. Pastor, T.H. Thai, and P. Fracescato. Interior point optimization and limit analysis: an
application, Commun. Numer. Meth. Engng.,19, 779-785, (2003).
[9] R. Merifield, S.W. Sloan and H. Yu, Stability of plate anchors in undrained clay, Geotech-
nique,51(2), 141-153, (2001).
4
... The information obtained through a numerical analysis should always be complemented A numerical modelling approach is presented in Figure 2. 7. On a first step, the information (inputs) collected during the geometrical survey, historical research, inspection, experimental tests and monitoring of the structure is used to provide the basic information necessary to create the model. Structural analysis can be performed by using different methods: Limit analysis (Heyman, 1982(Heyman, , 1995, generalized matrix formulations (Lagomarsino et al., 2013, Siano et al., 2017, FEM (Zienkiewicz, 2013), Discrete Element Method (DEM) (Cundall and Strack, 1979), Discontinuity Layout Optimization (DLO) (Gilbert and Smith, 2007), ...
... Non-linear models also hold the promise of potentially describing the behaviour of cob structures under the action of earthquakes or other extreme loading events. Hence, the importance of finding a numerical constitutive material to describe cob's non-linear structural response.Furthermore, an alternative simulation tool known as DLO(Gilbert and Smith, 2007) has been explored to try to simulate cob's structural behaviour. This method started to be developed in 2007, and has been further developed since, at the University ofSheffield by Matthew Gilbert and Colin Smith and is presented as a promising alternativeto other analysis methods such as FEM. ...
Thesis
Full-text available
Cultural heritage is increasingly threatened not only by traditional causes of decay, but also by changing social, economic and environmental conditions. The deterioration or disappearance of any cultural item constitutes a harmful impoverishment of our heritage. Besides, culture has been recognized as an enabler and driver of sustainable development, peace and economic progress, which highlights the necessity of fostering its documentation, protection, and promotion. For all these reasons, working in the conservation of our cultural heritage should not only be justified but encouraged. The general objective of this PhD thesis is to contribute with the efforts to achieve Target 11.4 of the Sustainable Development Goals (SDG), adopted by the United Nations (UN) in 2015, by strengthening the efforts to protect and safeguard the world’s cultural and natural heritage. The aim of the research is to increase awareness regarding the importance of vernacular architecture and its intrinsic values, as identified on the International Council of Monuments and Sites (ICOMOS) Action Plan for the Future. It specifically focuses on the improvement of earthen architectural heritage conservation, as this group of structures is particularly vulnerable to environmental and anthropologic threats. The thesis presents a summarized and concise picture of the present situation of the remaining earthen buildings in Ireland, identifies their main characteristics, the values that make such buildings important, evaluates their vulnerability as vernacular architectural style and therefore, allows to understand and better approach any future intervention on such kinds of structures. Within the context of current conservation practice, which is based on a scientific approach and implements a cyclic method of research, diagnosis, intervention and control activities, the thesis contributes to the development of quantitative research methods. A first contribution is presented on the structural analysis of cob by evaluating the suitability of available constitutive material to model its non-linear structural behaviour using two of the most commonly used Finite Element Method (FEM) software in the market, ANSYS and ABAQUS. A second contribution is concerned with the experimental testing of cob. A Minor Destructive Test (MDT) known as the flat jack test, has been experimentally validated by testing it in a series of cob wallettes built in the laboratory of Civil, Structural and Environmental Engineering (CSEE) at Trinity College Dublin (TCD). The purpose of the experimental campaign was to assess the feasibility of the technique to measure the average compressive levels of stress in existent cob walls and estimate their mechanical properties. The principal results show that effectively the test can be applied in cob walls but it tends to overestimate the stress values by a factor of approximately two. As conclusion, it is advised to correct the average compressive stress, fm, by using a value for the dimensionless geometrical efficiency constant, Ke, of 0.51. The use of a more realistic value would prevent the design and application of over invasive interventions that may place in danger the value of the historical fabric. The double flat jack tests allowed to estimate the mechanical parameters of the material to a good degree of certainty. Finally, a parametric analysis of cob walls is presented with the aim of providing conservation practitioners with rule of thumb guidance to assess the safety of existent cob buildings under seismic actions. The methodology presented in this regard is not limited to the Irish context but could as well be implemented in different countries where the seismic hazard represents an actual threat for the structural safety of remaining vernacular cob buildings.
... More capacities were estimated through usages of other trial mechanisms, and the lowest collapse load found was taken as final upper bounded solution. The last updates on automated upper bound methods are provided by Gilbert [25] who proposed a meshless technique based on a discontinuity layout optimisation procedure [26]. ...
Article
Full-text available
Nowadays, large part of the technical knowledge associated with collapses of slabs is based on past failures of bridges, floors, flat roofs and balconies. Collapse mechanisms tend to often differ from each other due to unique features which make it difficult to derive a generalised technique that can predict the right mechanism. This paper proposes a novel algorithm for tackling the problem of detection of collapse mechanisms, which is part of a pseudo-lower bound method for assessing concrete slabs in bridges and buildings. The problem is generalised to a combinatorial one, and the solution is based on a set of well-known combinatorial optimization algorithms. The proposed approach enables an identification of the domain of existence of yield-lines potentially leading to collapse. The output provides an estimation of a hampered domain of feasible yield-lines through which engineers can quickly identify zones of the slab and directions in which yield-lines leading to collapse are more likely to occur. Numerical applications of the algorithm are presented herein.
... Alternative numerical techniques are also available and could provide interesting results if implemented to describe the structural response of cob walls. Examples of such techniques include DEM (Cundall & Strack 1979), DLO (Gilbert & Smith 2007) and SPH (Lucy 1977). ...
Preprint
Full-text available
Even though Irish meteorological conditions are adverse for the development of earthen constructions, earth has been used as a construction material in Ireland for more than 4000 years. The objective of this paper is to present a summarized and concise picture of the present situation of the remaining earthen buildings in the country, identify their main characteristics, the values that make such buildings important, evaluate their vulnerability as vernacular architectural style and therefore, understand and better approach any future intervention on such kinds of structures. In particular, the paper highlights the lack of a detailed description of traditional construction techniques and of recommended procedures for the conservation of existing earthen structures. The paper identifies the pertinent Irish texts and suggests how recent research on the mechanical properties of cob and state-of-the-art numerical analysis techniques and constitutive models can be used to assess the strength and stability of existing historic structures.
... It is characterized by great efficiency and robustness. Besides, in comparison with element-based limit analysis methods [41,42], the DLO is a nodebased method [43,44], without mesh bias. The factor of safety, λ, is defined as the increasing load factor [32], which is directly obtained for evaluating the stability of the fire-loaded shallow tunnel. ...
Article
Full-text available
When subjected to fire loading, shallow tunnels may experience loss of stability. This may result in large deformations and ultimately in local collapse of such structures. High temperature has a great negative influence on tunnels, not only because of thermal‐induced mechanical degradation of the heated lining but also because of thermal spalling in consequence of the build‐up of pore pressure. Thermal spalling causes quick loss of lining sections. Mechanical degradation sole can be simulated by thermo‐mechanical models, while consideration of mechanical degradation and spalling requires thermo‐hydro‐chemo‐mechanical (THCM) models and a spalling criterion. After simulation of both processes, the stability of a tunnel structure can be assessed by means of limit analysis. In this work, at first, a fully coupled THCM model is developed. Then, by using a “stress vs strength” criterion and a boundary shifting strategy, the coupled mechanical degradation and thermal spalling processes are captured, providing time‐dependent and space‐dependent information of the heated lining. Finally, a novel numerical approach, termed discontinuity layout optimization (DLO), is applied to quantify the stability of the tunnel structure with the help of a factor of safety. The proposed numerical procedure is used to conduct numerical studies with, as well as without, consideration of spalling. The results show that spalling has a great impact on the stability of the tunnel. It reduces the thickness of the lining section and accelerates the heating process of the inner concrete.
... Alternative numerical techniques are also available and could provide interesting results if implemented to describe the structural response of cob walls. Examples of such techniques include DEM (Cundall & Strack 1979), DLO (Gilbert & Smith 2007) and SPH (Lucy 1977). ...
... Alternative numerical techniques are also available and could provide interesting results if implemented to describe the structural response of cob walls. Examples of such techniques include DEM (Cundall & Strack 1979), DLO (Gilbert & Smith 2007) and SPH (Lucy 1977). ...
Conference Paper
Even though Irish meteorological conditions are adverse for the development of earthen con-structions, earth has been used as a construction material in Ireland for more than 4000 years. The objective of this paper is to present a summarized and concise picture of the present situation of the remaining earthen buildings in the country, identify their main characteristics, the values that make such buildings important, evaluate their vulnerability as vernacular architectural style and therefore, understand and better approach any future intervention on such kinds of structures. In particular, the paper highlights the lack of a detailed description of traditional construction techniques and of recommended procedures for the conservation of existing earthen structures. The paper identifies the pertinent Irish texts and suggests how recent research on the mechanical properties of cob and state-of-the-art numerical analysis techniques and constitutive models can be used to assess the strength and stability of existing historic structures.
... Recently, an innovative type of topology optimization method [22][23][24][25][26] coined "Discontinuity Layout Optimization (DLO)" was presented in [27], which determines the critical layout of discontinuities and associated upper-bound limit load [28] for the plane (2D) [27,29] and three-dimensional (3D) [30-32] plasticity problems. By introducing a great amount of potential discontinuities, the layout of activated discontinuity will be automatically obtained by solving the corresponding Linear Programming (LP) and Second Order Cone Programming (SOCP) problem. ...
Article
Full-text available
For tunnel constructed by New Austrian Tunnelling Method (NATM), the crown is the upper part of tunnel section, constructed during excavation process and supported by shotcrete. The stability of the crown has great influence on the safety of tunnel itself and the buildings above, which correlates, amongst others, with geometrical set-up of tunnel and material properties of shotcrete and soil/rock. In this paper, aiming at analyzing the stability of shotcrete supported crown, a recently presented numerical method Discontinuity Layout Optimization (DLO) is adopted, which introduces a great amount of potential discontinuities crossover one another and provides a wide search space for efficient upper limit analysis. In the analysis, a well-established hydration model of cementitious material is implemented for accounting the hydration of shotcrete. Then assumptions based on convergence-confinement method are used for accounting the three-dimensional effect in two-dimensional analysis, finally providing time-space-dependent assessments of stability of shotcrete supported crown.
... Belonging to the family of topology optimization, discontinuity layout optimization (DLO) is a recently presented, elegant and promising numerical method for determining (i) the critical layout of discontinuities in a body at failure and (ii) the associated upper bound limit load [5] for plasticity problems [6][7][8][9]. Introducing large numbers of potential discontinuities permitted to crossover one another in a given domain and specifying the loading and boundary conditions (live loads, dead loads and supports), DLO can automatically generate a set of activated discontinuities corresponding to the upper bound limit load. ...
Article
Full-text available
Discontinuity layout optimization (DLO) is a recently presented topology optimization method for determining the critical layout of discontinuities and the associated upper bound limit load for plane and three-dimensional (3D) problems. The modelling process (pre-processing) for DLO includes defining the discontinuities inside a specified domain and building the target function and the global constraint matrix for the optimization solver, which has great influence on the efficiency of the computation processes and the reliability of the final results. This paper focuses on efficient and reliable pre-processing of the discontinuities within the 3D DLO and presents a multi-slicing strategy, which naturally avoids the overlapping and crossing of different discontinuities. Furthermore, the formulation of the 3D discontinuity considering a shape of an arbitrary convex polygon is introduced, permitting the efficient assembly of the global constraint matrix. The proposed method eliminates unnecessary discontinuities in 3D DLO, making it possible to apply 3D DLO for solving large-scale engineering problems such as those involving landslides. Numerical examples including a footing test, a 3D landslide and a punch indentation are considered, illustrating the effectiveness of the presented method.
Article
Full-text available
Soil anchors are commonly used as foundation systems for structures requiring uplift resistance, such as transmission towers, or for structures requiring lateral resistance, such as sheet pile walls. To date, the design of these anchors has been largely based on empiricism. This paper applies numerical limit analysis to rigorously evaluate the stability of vertical and horizontal strip anchors in undrained clay. Rigorous bounds on the ultimate pull-out capacity are obtained by using two numerical procedures that are based on finite element formulations of the upper and lower bound theorems of limit analysis. These formulations follow standard procedure by assuming a rigid perfectly plastic clay model with a Tresca yield criterion, and generate large linear programming problems. By obtaining both upper and lower bound estimates of the pull-out capacity, the true pull-out resistance can be bracketed from above and below. Results are presented in the familiar form of break-out factors based on various soil strength profiles and geometries, and are compared with existing numerical and empirical solutions.
Article
Full-text available
Computerized layout (or “topology”) optimization was pioneered almost four decades back. However, despite dramatic increases in available computer power and the application of increasingly efficient optimization algorithms, even now only relatively modest sized problems can be tackled using the traditional “ground structure” approach. This is because of the need, in general, for the latter to contain every conceivable member connecting together the nodes in a problem. A simple, but effective solution method capable of tackling problems with large numbers of potential members (e.g. >100,000,000) is presented. Though the method draws on the linear programming technique of “column generation”, since layout optimization specific heuristics are employed it is presented as an iterative “member adding” method. The method requires a ground structure with minimal connectivity to be used in the first iteration; members are then added as required in subsequent iterations until the (provably) optimal solution is found.
Article
Full-text available
The well-known problem of the height limit of a Tresca or von Mises vertical slope of height h, subjected to the action of gravity stems naturally from Limit Analysis theory under the plane strain condition. Although the exact solution to this problem remains unknown, this paper aims to give new precise bounds using both the static and kinematic approaches and an Interior Point optimizer code. The constituent material is a homogeneous isotropic soil of weight per unit volume γ. It obeys the Tresca or von Mises criterion characterized by C cohesion. We show that the loading parameter to be optimized, γh/C, is found to be between 3.767 and 3.782, and finally, using a recent result of Lyamin and Sloan (Int. J. Numer. Meth. Engng. 2002; 55: 573), between 3.772 and 3.782. The proposed methods, combined with an Interior Point optimization code, prove that linearizing the problem remains efficient, and both rigorous and global: this point is the main objective of the present paper. Copyright © 2003 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd.
Article
Full-text available
A new and potentially widely applicable numerical analysis procedure for continuum mechanics problems is described. The procedure is used here to determine the critical layout of discontinuities and associated upper-bound limit load for plane plasticity problems. Potential discontinuities, which interlink nodes laid out over the body under consideration, are permitted to crossover one another giving a much wider search space than when such discontinuities are located only at the edges of finite elements of fixed topology. Highly efficient linear programming solvers can be employed when certain popular failure criteria are specified (e. g. Tresca or Mohr Coulomb in plane strain). Stress/velocity singularities are automatically identified and visual interpretation of the output is straightforward. The procedure, coined 'discontinuity layout optimization' (DLO), is related to that used to identify the optimum layout of bars in trusses, with discontinuities (e. g. slip-lines) in a translational failure mechanism corresponding to bars in an optimum truss. Hence, a recently developed adaptive nodal connection strategy developed for truss layout optimization problems can advantageously be applied here. The procedure is used to identify critical translational failure mechanisms for selected metal forming and soil mechanics problems. Close agreement with the exact analytical solutions is obtained.
Plasticitetsteorien for jernbetonplader (Theory of plasticity for reinforced concrete slabs): Licentiatafhandling, Danmarks Tekniske Hojskole
  • M P Neilson
M.P. Neilson. Plasticitetsteorien for jernbetonplader (Theory of plasticity for reinforced concrete slabs): Licentiatafhandling, Danmarks Tekniske Hojskole, Copenhagen, (1962).
Interior point optimization and limit analysis: an application
  • J Pastor
  • T H Thai
  • P Fracescato
J. Pastor, T.H. Thai, and P. Fracescato. Interior point optimization and limit analysis: an application, Commun. Numer. Meth. Engng., 19, 779-785, (2003).