ArticlePDF Available

TRAINING FOR THE BIKE TO RUN TRANSITION IN TRIATHLON

Authors:

Abstract

The purpose of this study was to examine the effect of a practice regimen that targets the bike-to-run transition for triathlons; known as brick workouts. The principle of specificity suggests that since this skill is a critical transition in a triathlon, having further impact on the subsequent running section, practicing this skill is vital for success. Moreover, the identification of performance parameters that quantify a successful transition will serve to maximize practice efficiency. Subjects (N=12) performed either brick workouts or single event training, to examine their effects on the bike-run transition. Our results indicate that the brick workouts had a positive effect by eliciting an increased adaptability in knee behavior in response to the transition from cycling to running. Quicker adoption of efficient running mechanics may ensue, leading to less fatigue and greater performance. INTRODUCTION: Transitioning from biking to running during a triathlon can be a difficult endeavor for a novice, or even a professional triathlete. The difficulty in this transition is highlighted by the retention of the movement pattern characteristic of biking, well into the initiation of the running segment. At minimum, easing this transition can bring added comfort to the athlete, and at maximum it could mean the energetic difference between victory and defeat. As known in the triathlete community as the "brick" workout, this type of transition training focuses on the repeated alternation of bike and run training during a single practice session. This is in stark contrast to the traditional training approach of single skill training during separate practice sessions, where the transition phase receives little attention. Brick training brings specific practice efforts to the optimization of the transition phase, in order to alleviate the carry-over detrimental effects of distance cycling on the subsequent running performance. However, even though brick training is developing wide spread use in the triathlon community, and is strongly purported by the principle of specificity, no definitive research could be found to support the use of brick workouts and its effects on running performance following the bike-run transition. Thus, the purpose of this research was to document the effectiveness of brick workouts, while concurrently presenting a novel measure of performance which could continue to benefit the analysis of triathletes' performance. METHOD: Participants and Grouping: Seven male and five female college-aged triathletes were split randomly into two groups (experimental brick training group & control training group). Maximal oxygen uptake (VO 2Max
TRAINING FOR THE BIKE TO RUN TRANSITION IN TRIATHLON
Josh Haworth, Mark Walsh, Adam Strang, Jeff Hohl, Sarah Spraets, Michelle Wilson,
Cory Brown
Department of Kinesiology and Health
Miami University, Oxford, OH, USA
The purpose of this study was to examine the effect of a practice regimen that targets the
bike-to-run transition for triathlons; known as brick workouts. The principle of specificity
suggests that since this skill is a critical transition in a triathlon, having further impact on
the subsequent running section, practicing this skill is vital for success. Moreover, the
identification of performance parameters that quantify a successful transition will serve to
maximize practice efficiency. Subjects (N=12) performed either brick workouts or single
event training, to examine their effects on the bike-run transition. Our results indicate that
the brick workouts had a positive effect by eliciting an increased adaptability in knee
behavior in response to the transition from cycling to running. Quicker adoption of
efficient running mechanics may ensue, leading to less fatigue and greater performance.
KEY WORDS: approximate entropy, transition, brick, movement, training, triathlon.
INTRODUCTION:
Transitioning from biking to running during a triathlon can be a difficult endeavor for a novice,
or even a professional triathlete. The difficulty in this transition is highlighted by the retention
of the movement pattern characteristic of biking, well into the initiation of the running
segment. At minimum, easing this transition can bring added comfort to the athlete, and at
maximum it could mean the energetic difference between victory and defeat. As known in the
triathlete community as the “brick” workout, this type of transition training focuses on the
repeated alternation of bike and run training during a single practice session. This is in stark
contrast to the traditional training approach of single skill training during separate practice
sessions, where the transition phase receives little attention. Brick training brings specific
practice efforts to the optimization of the transition phase, in order to alleviate the carry-over
detrimental effects of distance cycling on the subsequent running performance. However,
even though brick training is developing wide spread use in the triathlon community, and is
strongly purported by the principle of specificity, no definitive research could be found to
support the use of brick workouts and its effects on running performance following the bike-
run transition. Thus, the purpose of this research was to document the effectiveness of brick
workouts, while concurrently presenting a novel measure of performance which could
continue to benefit the analysis of triathletes' performance.
METHOD:
Participants and Grouping:
Seven male and five female college-aged triathletes were split randomly into two groups
(experimental brick training group & control training group). Maximal oxygen uptake (VO2Max
Procedures: Triathletes in both groups engaged in 6 weeks of triathlon preparation using
one of two training methods; brick or traditional. Relative practice intensity was maintained
between the groups by providing similar training volumes during specific practice (2 hours
per week), documentation of miles and minutes of training outside of the specific practice
(both cycling and running), and the instructed regulation of 80% heart rate max during
specific practice.
)
was recorded pre-post training in order to ensure standardized fitness between groups.
The brick training group practiced the run-bike transition by performing transition training,
alternating 10 minute bike with 10 minute run, for one hour twice each week. The traditional
training group practiced bike and run workouts for one hour each week, on separate days.
SIMI motion analysis was used to record lower extremity kinematics (at 60 Hz) during each
triathlete's initial running performance after the bike-run transition, both pre and post 6 weeks
of training. For both tests, participants cycled for 40 minutes at 90% max heart rate (to
simulate true race conditions), and were then filmed for the first minute of the following run.
To aid in digitizing, retroreflective markers were fixed to known body landmarks of the lower
extremity (greater trochanter, lateral epichondyle, and lateral maleolus). SIMI was also used
for manual digitization and calculation of knee angle; used for subsequent analysis.
Design: The current investigation utilized a 2 X 2 design (time X training), with a
corresponding ANOVA used to test for differences across three dependant variables. Time
(the within subjects factor) had two levels, pre and post training. Training type (the between
subjects factor) also had two levels, traditional and brick training. Three dependent variables
were calculated from the knee angle data collected during the first minute of running
following the transistion phase from a 40 minute bout of cycling. Dependent variables
included 1) knee angle range (max min knee angle position), 2) knee angle coefficient of
variability (standard deviation of position/mean position), and 3) approximate entropy (ApEn;
a nonlinear measure of knee angle temporal predictability, i.e. consistency of position during
recurrent cycles).
Approximate Entropy (ApEn)
ApEn has been used to examine heart rate complexity proceeding atrial fibrillation showing
that a period of very low ApEn precedes atrial fibrillation (Tuzcu, 2006). Studies of postural
control have found that after cerebral concussion an athlete’s center of pressure oscillations,
measured by ApEn, are significantly more rigid up to 96 hours post-injury, even when the
athlete appears steady (Cavanaugh, 2006).
: This value characterizes the complexity of variability within the
signal; the degree to which a signal remains self-similar through time (Vaillancourt, Newell,
2000). Higher values indicate that the behavior is irregular and lower values indicate
maintained consistency. ApEn is computed using algorithms by Pincus (1994), implemented
in MATLAB. Stergiou (2004) report that ApEn is useful for characterizing the health and
optimal performance of a biological system including heart rhythm, standing posture, and
gait.
Analysis: Linear analysis of knee angle was performed by calculating the average of both
range and coefficient of variability for each group during the first minute of running after 40
minutes of cycling, both pre and post training. Non-linear analysis was calculated across the
whole of the first minute of running after the transition phase.
RESULTS:
No overall group changes in VO2Max
were observed. In addition, exercise outside of the
training protocol did not vary between groups. Linear analysis of knee angle range and
coefficient of variability showed no measureable difference for the two conditions within
groups (Figures 1 & 2), indicating that the knee moved within the same volume of space
regardless of the training. However, the non-linear measurement of ApEn (Figure 3) showed
a difference between pre and post training within the brick training group, t (5) = -3.49,
p=0.017, but not for the traditional training group, t (5) = 0.49, p=0.640. The change in ApEn
value indicated that the brick training group experienced changes to the temporal
organization of knee movement, decreased rigidity, as a result of training. Although pre-test
values exhibit differences between the two groups, the study participants were quite similar
in terms of age, experience, and anthropometrics and were placed randomly into the groups.
Moreover, the goal of this study is to focus on changes in performance due to training type.
Further investigation and analysis may be needed to uncover the source of an athlete's
specific a priori mechanical approach to running.
0
20
40
60
80
100
120
Brick Training Gro up
Traditional Training Group
Range of Knee Angle (degrees)
Pre-Tes t
Post-Test
Figure 1: Knee Angle Range
0
0.05
0.1
0.15
0.2
0.25
Traditional Training Group
Coefficie nt of Variability
Pre-Tes t
Post-Test
Figure 2: Knee Angle Coefficient of Variability
0.15
0.2
0.25
0.3
0.35
0.4
Brick Training Group
Traditional Training Group
ApEn
Pre-Tes t
Post-Test
p= 0.640
p= 0.017
Figure 3: Knee Angle ApEn
DISCUSSION: Approximate entropy characterizes the regularity, or predictability, of a
behavior. Lower values of ApEn indicate a system that is highly recurrent, repeating nearly
the identical behavior throughout subsequent iterations. What this means in terms of running
mechanics, is that lower ApEn values indicate rigid, non-adaptive strategies. Specifically in
the context of the bike-run transition phase of the triathlon, this rigidity indicates a reduced
ability of the neuromuscular system to transition from cycling mechanics to running
mechanics, due to being "stuck" in the repeated engagement of cycling behavior. Slowed,
inefficient transitions between these performance mechanics cause drastic deficits to
performance, serving as a source of pain and discomfort and increasing propensity for injury.
Additionally, the perseverance of cycling mechanics into the running section is quite
expensive, leading to large consumptions of oxygen and energy that could instead be used
to heighten the athlete's performance.
The increased values of ApEn found following brick training suggest that individuals in this
group have acquired a new, transition-specific flexibility in knee angle behavior. Reduced
rigidity following the cycling section of the race will allow for a quicker, smoother, and more
efficient transition into steady state running mechanics. Coupled with the observation of
unchanged range and coefficient of variation, these results suggest that it is the temporal
organization of knee joint behavior which differs after training, with the opportunity to
influence performance.
CONCLUSION: The decreased rigidity in knee movement behavior found after training for
the transition through brick workouts reflects an increase in fluidity and flexibility of
movement. Increasing knee angle ApEn indicates greater adaptability during the run after the
transition, indicating the potential for quicker, more efficient transitions into steady state
running mechanics. It is important to mention that linear analysis was unable to detect these
subtle changes that occur resulting from brick training. Non-linear analysis may detect this
information readily and help to explain why so many triathletes participate in brick training.
Upon further investigation, ApEn may become a critical evaluative measure of performance
for triathletes.
REFERENCES:
Cavanaugh, J.T., Guskiewicz, K.M., Giuliani, C.G., Marshall, S.M., Mercer, V.S., & Stergiou, N. (2006).
Recovery of Postural Control After Cerebral Concussion: New Insights Using Approximate Entropy.
41, 305-313.
Pincus, S.M., & Goldberger, A.L. (1994). Physiological Time-Series Analysis: What Does Regularity
Quantify?. American Journal of Physiology. 266, 1643-1656.
Stergiou, N., Buzzi, U.H., Kurz, M.J., & Heidel, J (2004). Innovative Analyses of Human Movement:
Analytical Tools of Human Movement Research. Champaign, IL: Human Kinetics.
Tuzcu, V, Nas, S, Borklu, T, & Ugur, A (2006). Decrease in the Heart Rate Complexity Prior to the
Onset of Atrial Fibrillation. Europace, 8, 398-402.
Vaillancourt, Newell (2000) The dynamics of resting and postural tremor in Parkinson's disease.
Clinical Neurophysiology, 111(11), 2046-2056.
Acknowledgement
This research was funded in part by the Undergraduate Research Award from Miami University,
Oxford, OH, 45056. USA.
... Nor, although the principle of specificity indicates that brick workouts make sense, has much research to support them been conducted (34)(35)(36). While assessment of the ability to run after cycling within a triathlon specific test protocol (37), as well as on its own, is important, neither task has been easy to conduct under ecologically valid conditions (2). ...
... For the calculation of both, the research group provided an open access application (available online http:// www.uni-konstanz.de/FuF/SportWiss/vieten/CyclicMove/). In the present study, based on previous work (for an overview see 34), dM and dD values equal to or below 5 m/s 2 represented a very high similarity of the compared running motion and the movement precision respectively. ...
... Frontiers in Sports and Active living marginal gains, this finding could open another perspective both to examine and improve the final discipline, and to be able to do so under ecologically valid conditions. "At minimum, easing (the cycle-run) transition can bring added comfort to the athlete, and at maximum it could mean the (…) difference between victory and defeat" (34). ...
Article
Full-text available
Running in a triathlon, a so-called brick run, is uniquely influenced by accumulated load from its preceding disciplines. Crucially, however, and irrespective of race type, the demands of a triathlon always exceed the sum of its parts. Triathletes of all levels commonly report subjectively perceived incoordination within the initial stages of the cycle run transition (T2). Although minimizing it, and its influence on running kinematics, can positively impact running and overall triathlon performance, the mechanisms behind the T2 effect remain unclear. In the present study, we assessed the influence of the pre-load exercise mode focusing on the biomechanical perspective. To analyze inertial sensor-based raw data from both legs, the so-called Attractor Method was applied. The latter represents a sensitive approach, allowing to quantify subtle changes of cyclic motions to uncover the transient effect, a potentially detrimental transient phase at the beginning of a run. The purpose was to analyze the impact of a pre-load on the biomechanics of a brick run during a simulated Olympic Distance triathlon (without the swimming section). Therefore, we assessed the influence of pre-load exercise mode on running pattern ( δ M) and precision ( δ D), and on the length of the transient effect (t T ) within a 10 km field-based run in 22 well-trained triathletes. We found that δ D, but not δ M, differed significantly between an isolated run (I Run ) and when it was preceded by a 40 km cycle (T Run ) or an energetically matched run (R Run ). The average distance ran until overcoming the transient phase (t T ) was 679 m for T Run , 450 m for R Run , and 29 4 m for I Run . The results demonstrated that especially the first kilometer of a triathlon run is prone to an uncoordinated running sensation, which is also commonly reported by athletes. That is, i) the T2 effect appeared more linked to variability in running style than to running style per se ii) run t T distance was influenced by preceding exercise load mode, being greater for a T Run than for the R Run condition, and iii) the Attractor Method seemed to be a potentially promising method of sensitively monitoring T2 adaptation under ecologically valid conditions.
... All these data parameters were also used to explain and enhance the process of transition in duathlon and triathlon events. The main outcome of these studies was the training method called 'brick workout' (Friel & Vance, 2013, p. 441;Walsh, Hohl, Strang, & Haworth, 2014), a session where the athletes combine the different disciplines one after the other, mainly focusing on cycling and running. To improve and develop the quantification of cyclic motion (as running, walking, swimming, cycling, etc.), especially human gait and the walking movement, we introduced a new approach in the field of cyclic motion analysis named 'attractor method' (Vieten, Sehle, & Jensen, 2013;Vieten & Jensen, 2015). ...
Article
Full-text available
Various publications discuss the discrepancies of running in triathlons and stand-alone runs. However, those methods, such as analysing step-characteristics or ground-contact time, lack the ability to quantitatively discriminate between subtle running differences. The attractor method can be applied to overcome those shortcomings. The purpose was to detect differences in athletes’ running patterns (δM) and movement precision (δD) by comparing a 5,000 m run after a prior cycling session (TRun) with an isolated run over the same distance (IRun). Participants completed the conditions on a track and a stationary trainer, allowing the use of their personal bike to simulate an Olympic triathlon. During each run, three-dimensional acceleration data, using sensors attached to the ankles, were collected. Results showed that both conditions lead to elevated attractor parameters (δM and δD) over the initial five minutes before the athletes found their rhythm. This generates a new perspective because independent of running after a bike session or without preload, an athlete needs certain time to adjust to the running movement. Coaches must consider this factor as another tool to fine-tune pacing and performance. Moreover, the attractor method is a novel approach to gain deeper insight into human cyclic motions in athletic contexts.
Article
Full-text available
The study examines the time and frequency structure of Parkinson's disease tremor in patients that exhibit no clinical signs of tremor. Eight mild to moderate Parkinson's disease and 8 matched control subjects maintained their limb in a constant position (30 s) under a postural finger, postural hand and resting tremor condition. Finger acceleration from the middle phalange, electromyographic (EMG) activity from extensor digitorum communis and flexor digitorum superficialis (FDS) were recorded. The data confirmed that there were no differences in the amount of limb motion and the modal frequency was around 9 Hz for each subject group. The time-dependent organization of tremor was more regular (lower approximate entropy [ApEn]) in Parkinson's disease. Both time and frequency analyses between the acceleration and extensor EMG signals demonstrate a reduction in the 20-25 Hz tremor component and an increase in the 8-12 Hz region of tremor. The results are discussed in relation to the proposal that increased regularity results from an increase in motor unit synchronization at 8-12 Hz and a reduction in the amplitude of the 20-25 Hz tremor component. The time and frequency structure of tremor may be useful in assessing individuals with Parkinson's disease.
Article
Approximate entropy (ApEn) is a recently developed statistic quantifying regularity and complexity that appears to have potential application to a wide variety of physiological and clinical time-series data. The focus here is to provide a better understanding of ApEn to facilitate its proper utilization, application, and interpretation. After giving the formal mathematical description of ApEn, we provide a multistep description of the algorithm as applied to two contrasting clinical heart rate data sets. We discuss algorithm implementation and interpretation and introduce a general mathematical hypothesis of the dynamics of a wide class of diseases, indicating the utility of ApEn to test this hypothesis. We indicate the relationship of ApEn to variability measures, the Fourier spectrum, and algorithms motivated by study of chaotic dynamics. We discuss further mathematical properties of ApEn, including the choice of input parameters, statistical issues, and modeling considerations, and we conclude with a section on caveats to ensure correct ApEn utilization.
Innovative Analyses of Human Movement: Analytical Tools of Human Movement Research
  • N Stergiou
  • U H Buzzi
  • M J Kurz
Stergiou, N., Buzzi, U.H., Kurz, M.J., & Heidel, J (2004). Innovative Analyses of Human Movement: Analytical Tools of Human Movement Research. Champaign, IL: Human Kinetics.