ArticlePDF Available

Abstract and Figures

There is a renewed interest amongst scholars in the practice of pilgrimage. Over the past two decades, pilgrim numbers have risen significantly, whilst forms of “implicit” or “alternative” spirituality have gained visibility and now coexist with organised religions, sometimes sharing the same ritualistic space. There is probably no better place to look at the coexistence of old and new forms of ritual expression than in the Camino to Santiago. To better understand the meanings attributed to this pilgrimage, we undertook a survey with over 470 pilgrims at various locations along the Camino. The findings confirm that individuals with various, often contrasting, motivations and expectations walk side by side on this pilgrimage route. We suggest that the results cannot be read simplistically as either confirming a “post-secularisation” trend or a religious revival.
Content may be subject to copyright.
1 23
Review of Religious Research
The Official Journal of the Religious
Research Association
ISSN 0034-673X
Rev Relig Res
DOI 10.1007/s13644-013-0131-4
Rise of Pilgrims on the Camino to Santiago:
Sign of Change or Religious Revival?
Lluis Oviedo, Scarlett de Courcier &
Miguel Farias
1 23
Your article is protected by copyright and
all rights are held exclusively by Religious
Research Association, Inc.. This e-offprint is
for personal use only and shall not be self-
archived in electronic repositories. If you wish
to self-archive your article, please use the
accepted manuscript version for posting on
your own website. You may further deposit
the accepted manuscript version in any
repository, provided it is only made publicly
available 12 months after official publication
or later and provided acknowledgement is
given to the original source of publication
and a link is inserted to the published article
on Springer's website. The link must be
accompanied by the following text: "The final
publication is available at link.springer.com”.
ORIGINAL PAPER
Rise of Pilgrims on the Camino to Santiago:
Sign of Change or Religious Revival?
Lluis Oviedo Scarlett de Courcier Miguel Farias
Received: 13 October 2012 / Accepted: 25 July 2013
Religious Research Association, Inc. 2013
Abstract There is a renewed interest amongst scholars in the practice of pil-
grimage. Over the past two decades, pilgrim numbers have risen significantly, whilst
forms of ‘‘implicit’’ or ‘‘alternative’’ spirituality have gained visibility and now
coexist with organised religions, sometimes sharing the same ritualistic space. There
is probably no better place to look at the coexistence of old and new forms of ritual
expression than in the Camino to Santiago. To better understand the meanings
attributed to this pilgrimage, we undertook a survey with over 470 pilgrims at
various locations along the Camino. The findings confirm that individuals with
various, often contrasting, motivations and expectations walk side by side on this
pilgrimage route. We suggest that the results cannot be read simplistically as either
confirming a ‘‘post-secularisation’’ trend or a religious revival.
Keywords Pilgrimage Religious revival Spirituality Religious
change
Introduction
A number of competing theories have been offered regarding why people go on
pilgrimages, focusing on bodily, emotional and social dimensions. Turner’s (1978)
L. Oviedo (&)
Theology Faculty, Pontifical University Antonianum, Rome, Italy
e-mail: loviedo@antonianum.eu
S. de Courcier
Ian Ramsey Center, Oxford University, Oxford, UK
e-mail: scarlettdecourcier@gmail.com
M. Farias
Department of Experimental Psychology, Oxford University, Oxford, UK
e-mail: miguel.farias@psy.ox.ac.uk
123
Rev Relig Res
DOI 10.1007/s13644-013-0131-4
Author's personal copy
framing of pilgrimage according to the categories of communitas and liminality has
been particularly influential. He suggests that the process of undertaking a sacred
journey creates new forms of social interaction and experiences that move beyond
the everyday world; this, he argues, can only be achieved by distancing oneself from
one’s familiar environment. More recently, other scholars have stressed the
‘contesting’ dimension of pilgrimage, that is, the ways in which this ritual is often
displaced to the margins of organised religion and institutional social structure
(Eade and Sallnow 1991; Coleman and Eade 2004).
A common criticism of both of these approaches is that not all pilgrimages
can be placed within the same framework; indeed many traditional pilgrimages
to religious shrines tend to confirm and re-enact forms of conventional
religiosity. Recent work has opened up the heuristic toolbox to a variety of
sacred journeys. These have included differentiating between institutional
religions and new spiritualities (Ivakhiv 2003; Reader 2007; Steil and de Sa
´
Carneiro 2008); community and individualism (Bilu 1988; Coleman 2002;
Ivakhiv 2003; Sean 2003); religious and secular aspects (Graham and Murray
1997; Santos 2002; Swatos 2009; Timothy and Olsen 2006; Frey 1998; Margry
2008); and between tradition and innovation (Swatos 2009; Pack 2010). Other
researchers have attempted to deconstruct the concept of pilgrimage by
highlighting its overlap with ‘tourism’—after all, what are these but forms of
travel? (Morinis 1992; Santos 2002; Swatos and Tomasi 2002; Badone and
Roseman 2004; Timothy and Olsen 2006).
Several theoretical frameworks may be applied to try to make sense of this
ritual activity. ‘Rational Choice theory’ suggests that actions are driven by cost-
benefit analysis; human ethology may explore ‘appetitive behaviours’ bringing
pilgrims to the ‘consummatory end act’ of prayer at the end of the long journey
(Feierman 2009); cognitive-adaptive religious theory may identify costly
religious practices prompting group cohesion and pro-social behaviours (Sosis
and Alcorta 2003; Nordin 2011; Kantner and Vaughn 2012). In a similar fashion,
cultural anthropology may perceive a long pilgrimage as an ‘‘in-group marker’
(McElreath et al. 2003).
The present work addresses the ongoing debate on whether the rise of pilgrims
represents a ‘religious revival’, a secular or ‘post-secular’ expression of nature
travel, or if it forms part of a wider movement of eclectic and ‘fuzzy’ spirituality
(Hill et al. 2000; Marler and Hadaway 2002; Heelas et al. 2005). The Santiago Way
is probably the most interesting pilgrimage route to test these three competing ideas.
Although historically this has been a penitential track used to fulfil religious
promises, the extraordinary rise of pilgrims in the last twenty years (see Fig. 1)
1
contradicts a general decline in religious practice (Hervieu-Leger 1997). Specif-
ically, the aim of the research was to assess pilgrims’ motivations to undertake this
journey, typically lasting two to four weeks, through a quantitative survey.
Additionally, we also collected qualitative data on personal narratives about the
pilgrimage.
1
See also: http://peregrinossantiago.es/eng/pilgrims-office/statistics/?anio=2012&mes=9.
Rev Relig Res
123
Author's personal copy
Method and Data Collection
The first section of the questionnaire included a list of 48 religious and secular items
describing motivations to be on the pilgrimage. Pilgrims ranked their levels of
agreement with these items on a Likert scale (1–6). This list of motivations was
developed taking into account the available literature (e.g. Graham and Murray
1997; Coleman 2002) as well as speaking to people who had done the Santiago way.
The questionnaire also included sections on demographics; duration and type of
pilgrimage (alone or part of a group); levels of religious practice and experience;
and two open-ended questions about ‘expectations’ and ‘religious or spiritual
experiences’ during the pilgrimage. The questionnaire was originally written in
English and then translated into four additional languages (Spanish, French,
Portuguese and German).
There are several pilgrim trails, though the Camino France´s or ‘French way’ is
the most popular. The Camino France´s forms the spine of the Camino de Santiago,
stretching 780 km from St Jean Pied du Port in France to Santiago de Compostela
in North-West Spain. An efficient infrastructure of refuges and hostels provides
cheap accommodation and most pilgrims use these facilities to rest. The surveys
were handed out to pilgrims at such places, usually after the daily walking time was
over.
A total of 470 questionnaires were collected along the Camino France´s during
August–September of 2009, and July 2010. Interviews were also conducted with
many pilgrims, as well as hospitaleros (those responsible for pilgrims’ accom-
modation) and Catholic priests who attended to pilgrims’ religious or spiritual
needs.
Fig. 1 Evolution of the number of pilgrims to Santiago. Filled diamond Holy Jacobean year. Source:
statistics archive Cathedral of Santiago
Rev Relig Res
123
Author's personal copy
Results: Religion and Personal Identity in Motion
The demographic data of the present sample describes a varied population of more
than 40 nationalities (including 30.4 % Spanish, 17.7 % German, 6.8 % American,
5.9 % Italian, 5.2 % French and 5 % Brazilian). The average age of pilgrims was
32.2 years, with a standard deviation of 14.5; 51.1 % were male. About one third
were students.
Religiosity Indicators
Two thirds of the sample group were Christian (66 %), while 22.6 % were atheists.
Those describing themselves as spiritual or New Agers had a marginal represen-
tation (2.3 %). The remaining participants either belonged to ‘other’ religions or did
not indicate their religious or secular affiliation.
One of the main aims of the research was to assess levels of secularisation on the
Camino. Many voices, especiallythose of Catholic authorities, have expressed concern
about the decline of religious practice and the ever-increasing secular profile of
pilgrims who, generally, lack interest in the specifically Catholic elements of the
pilgrimage. A number of items in the survey were used to assess religious practice
throughout the journey. When asked which religious aspects of the Camino pilgrims
were most drawn to, the main answers were: ‘Private prayer or contemplation’
(31.8 %); ‘Prayer/reflection with others’ (14.8 %); and ‘Religious rituals/sites’ (15 %).
Concerning other religious indicators, 24.7 % of pilgrims pray at least once a
day, and 23.4 % attend religious services at least once a week. Comparing these
figures for the Spanish pilgrims (N =134) with the latest data provided by
European Surveys regarding Spain (ESS 2010), 18.4 % of pilgrims pray daily,
against 20.9 % of the general population surveyed in ESS; 20 % of pilgrims attend
weekly religious services, while the general sample from the ESS gives a figure of
14.4 %. These results seem to suggest that there is not a vast difference between the
general population and pilgrims. From this perspective it seems that the Camino
does not draw a specific type of person from the general population—the most
religious, for example—but rather a representative subset of the general population;
no more, and no less, religious than average. Although religious practice during the
pilgrimage may seem low, these results are in line with the current statistics of
religiosity in most European societies.
Observing reported levels of religiosity and spirituality sheds some light on the
impact of secularisation. The mean religiosity level (on a scale from 0 to 10) was
3.97 (SD =2.93), whilst the mean for spirituality (‘How spiritual are you?’) was
5.9 (SD =2.85). This suggests that pilgrims tend to identify themselves more with
spirituality than religiosity.
The questionnaire included seven items concerning religious experiences, e.g. ‘I
have felt very close to God/the divine in prayer or meditation’ or ‘I have been aware
of God’s/the divine’s presence’. Only the latter item reaches a mean of 3
(SD =1.9) (on a six-point scale), while the remaining items score between 2 and 3
points. The impression arising from these results is that pilgrims, on average, do not
report a high frequency of religious experiences.
Rev Relig Res
123
Author's personal copy
Thus far the results suggest that pilgrims on the Santiago Way are not any more
or less religious than non-pilgrims. We now turn to the analysis of motivations.
Analysing the Motivations
The survey listed 48 possible motivations to go on pilgrimage that participants were
asked to rank in order of importance. Using exploratory factor analysis with
Varimax rotation, we extracted six factors which explained 54 % of the total
variance. The factors were: religious growth, spiritual growth, sensation seeking,
seeking life direction, community, and religious devotion (see Tables 1,2).
The factor analysis distinguishes between dimensions that are very often
entrenched, as in the case of religiosity and spirituality motivations. Religious Growth
clusters items that are fitting of a traditional religious mentality (e.g. ‘Grow in faith’, ‘Be
closer to God’). The overall mean for this type of motivation was not high: 3.09
(SD =1.37) on a scale of 1 to 6. This result draws doubts regarding a religious revival in
the Camino. The second factor, Spiritual Growth, also consisted of six items thatdirectly
tapped into a more secular and vagueform of religiosity (e.g. ‘Expand my consciousness
or ‘Find my deeper self’). This factor had the highest average of all motivations (4.03,
SD =1.19). This reveals a greater interest in a secular spirituality and confirms the
scores of religious and spiritual self-assessment. Further, the low score (1.88,
SD =1.11) on the sixth factor, labelled Religious Devotion, which describes traditional
pilgrimage motivations (e.g. ‘Fulfilling a promise’ or ‘Repentance’), indicates that what
moves mo dern pilgrims to the Camino is quite different fromtheir pre-modern ancestors.
The Sensation Seeking factor, which overall score was the second highest (3.17,
SD =1.18), reflects a clearly secularised pattern, potentially associated with
qualities of ‘personal expressivism’ (Taylor 2007), such as ‘Testing my limits’ or
‘Proving myself’; ‘Search of adventure’; ‘Enjoying myself’. Likewise, Seeking life
direction captures a similar individualistic dimension. On the other hand, Community
includes three items, which partially overlap with a sense of religious collectiveness
and duty of helping others (e.g. ‘Doing something on behalf of someone’).
These results show that overall pilgrims gravitate towards a spiritual sensitivity,
though there is also space for more traditional religious motivations. The analysis of
correlations between the various factors, age and religious practice confirms the
differences between religious and spiritual motivations (see Table 3). As expected,
frequency of religious practice is strongly correlated with ‘‘religious growth’’ but
only weakly with ‘‘spiritual growth’’. Further, the expressivistic motivations of
‘sensations seeking’’ is negatively correlated with ‘‘religious growth’’ but positively
correlated with ‘‘spiritual growth’’. Further, we also notice that ‘‘religious growth’
and religious practice are positively correlated with age, showing that the older
pilgrims tend to be more traditionally religious. Older people are also less interested
in seeking new experiences and in ‘‘looking for life direction’’.
Constructing Personal Narratives
The survey data can be further explored by looking at the relevance of individual
items. For example, the ‘Hope of meeting a partner’ (M =1.63; SD =1.1)
Rev Relig Res
123
Author's personal copy
Table 1 Santiago pilgrims
survey-factor description Factor 1 Religious growth (Cronbach’s alpha =.921)
Be closer to God
Strengthen my religious/spiritual beliefs
Learning about God by being with other people
Having more time for prayer
Grow in faith
Find out more about my religion/spirituality
Drawing strength from a sacred place
Pray for the healing of others
Paying reverence to a saint or sacred space
Factor 2 Spiritual growth (Cronbach’s alpha =.862)
Find myself
Expand my consciousness
Find my deeper self
Being close to nature
Find peace
Purifying my spirit
Yearning for a simple life
Seeking unity with the universe
Factor 3 Sensation seeking (Cronbach’s alpha =.871)
Curiousity
Testing my limits
Doing something different
Proving myself
Search for adventure
Enjoying myself
See interesting sights
Getting to know people
Factor 4 Seeking life direction (Cronbach’s alpha =.824)
Trying to know the future
Coming to terms with a decision
Seek guidance for the future
To look for a sign or direction in my life
Factor 5 Community (Cronbach’s alpha =.702)
Doing something on behalf of someone
Helping sick people
Being with my community
Factor 6 Religious devotion (Cronbach’s alpha =.726)
Fulfilling a promise
Fulfilling a religious duty
Repentance
Rev Relig Res
123
Author's personal copy
revealed that this was a very low priority to go on pilgrimage. On the other hand,
other seemingly frivolous motives such as ‘Enjoying myself’, were a high
motivation (M =4.3; SD =1.51).
Despite the high scores for secular and individualistic motivations, many of the
results reveal the appeal of moving away from an ordinary experience of life. The
items with the highest scores highlight this: ‘To be close to nature’ (M =4.89;
SD =1.23) and ‘To find my deeper self’ (M =4.80; SD =1.37). In both cases, the
meaning of the pilgrimage seems related to an almost mystical sense of nature—a
desire to recover a sense of identity through a detachment from everyday life and
relationships. In this sense, the secularisation of the Camino cannot be framed as a
straightforward ‘desacralisation’ or ‘disenchantment’ of the world. Being in nature
allows for a deeper sense of connection with the self—the self which the pilgrim is
wrestling with, either in search of a new direction or of finding a deeper, more
connected and peaceful structure. Thus, nature could be perceived as a conduit to a
‘re-routing of the self’, a dimension in which the personal self might be lived in its
most pristine form and rescued from estrangement (Taylor 1992).
We now turn to the testimonies. Two questions invited pilgrims to write about
their expectation of the Camino, and their religious or spiritual experiences, and
reactions, to the pilgrimage. These were some of the accounts, which highlight the
coexistence of religious, spiritual and secular themes:
Table 3 Pearson correlation coefficients between factors, age, and religious practice (N=453)
Variables f1 f2 f3 f4 f5 f6 Age
f1 Religious growth
f2 Spiritual growth .538**
f3 Sensations seek. -.166** .139*
f4 Life direction .339** .607** .229**
f5 Community .393** .207** .183** .130*
f6 Devotion .485** .311** .101* .302** .388** –
Age .149* -.047 -.339** -.219** .106* .047
Religious practice .649** .187* -.376** .045 .132* .179* .228**
*p\.05; ** p\.001
Table 2 Means of six main factors (1–6)
N Mean SD
f1 Religious growth 435 3.0907 1.37899
f2 Spiritual growth 442 4.0326 1.19760
f3 Sensations seeking 451 3.9092 1.18769
f4 Seeking life direction 453 3.1720 1.41581
f5 Community 446 2.7443 1.28367
f6 Devotion 422 1.8832 1.11898
Rev Relig Res
123
Author's personal copy
My expectations are to dialogue with God, to ask for help; to take part in mass;
praying for other people. My experiences: sadness, weeping in a Church;
‘feeling supported by God’’.
I have had some incredible dreams and beautiful experiences. I’ve felt energy,
smelt incense in the desert, felt connections with others.
I walk in surrender and strengthen my belief that the universe is always there to
support me. People are like angels to each other in life, we are being used by ‘the
force’. Everything happens ‘through’ us. In stillness, I feel that everything is
united and connected. The universe speaks to me in symbols. I feel humble and
so grateful to be here.
Being in nature and getting regular exercise makes me feel very happy and
emotionally very positive.
After 12 years in a relationship, my partner dropped me a month ago. I thought
it was the end of my life. The only solution I found was the Camino. I wanted to
heal the pain in my soul. I wanted to close the gate in my relationship and to stop
loving him. Several times a day, I’ve visited church and prayed. And I cried
most of the time I was in churches. Slowly, I found myself full of grace and
peace. My vision is now clear; I reckon I am over him.
My expectations are to get on with others. Sharing and listening to their stories
and life events. Supporting and helping them by being attentive. Having fun,
chatting and enjoying the company of others.
I want to show God and the Apostle Santiago my love and devotion for them
and, in this way, by doing the Camino, to thank them for the family they gave
me, the health we enjoy, and to ask to keep blessing us.
In these accounts, the experience of pilgrimage is eminently plural. The Camino
allows for the construct of narratives that follow particular motivations.
Drawing Conclusions
Returning to our major question—is the rise of pilgrims on the Camino a ‘religious
revival’, a secular or ‘post-secular’ expression of nature travel, or if it forms part of
a wider movement of eclectic and ‘fuzzy’ spirituality? It is safe to exclude the first
one. Our data clearly indicate that the majority of pilgrims are not particularly
interested in traditional religiosity. However, it is difficult to read the results as a
clear sign of spiritual change. There are clear signs of the presence of eclectic forms
of spirituality, but this is associated with a desire or search for new sensations. We
suggest framing the results by considering two major types of pilgrims, roughly
corresponding to what Taylor (2007) described as the ‘porous’ and the ‘buffered’
self. While the first refers to the individual integrated into a cosmos of religious
meanings and values, the ‘buffered self’ corresponds to the modern person, flexible
and adaptive to every context, without being integrated or subsumed into a greater
cosmos of meaning. The Camino provides a context in which both types coexist:
one integrated into a religious universe of symbols, and the second constructing her
own universe of meaning and references, not immediately connected with a
Rev Relig Res
123
Author's personal copy
predetermined framework, but vaguely or fuzzily attaching itself to experiences and
feelings. The second kind of pilgrim is predominant in our sample.
Many pilgrims seem to be looking for an experience outside the margins of
material interest and the simplistic pursuit of gain. In this sense, pilgrimage offers
something almost unique in the context of advanced societies and their logic of
consumerism. In Weberian terms, it offers an ‘escape from the iron cage’, or an
avoidance of the impoverishing logic of disenchantment. Following Taylor (2007),
we suggest that the pilgrimage experience forms part of the process through which
individuals in advanced societies try to redefine their flexible identities.
References
Badone, Ellen, and Sharon R. Roseman. 2004. Intersecting journeys: The anthropology of pilgrimage and
tourism. Chicago: University of Illinois Press.
Bilu, Yoram. 1988. The inner limits of communitas: A covert dimension of pilgrimage experience. Ethos
16(3): 302–325.
Coleman, Simon. 2002. Do you believe in pilgrimage? Communitas, contestation and beyond.
Anthropological Theory 2(3): 355–368.
Coleman, Simon, and John Eade (eds.). 2004. Reframing pilgrimage: Cultures in motion. London:
Routledge.
Eade, John, and Michael J. Sallnow (eds.). 1991. Contesting the sacred: The anthropology of christian
pilgrimage. London and New York: Routledge.
Feierman, Jay R. 2009. Conclusion. In The Biology of religious behavior: The evolutionary origins of
faith and religion, ed. Jay R. Feierman, 243–264. Santa Barbara, CA: Praeger/ABC-CLIO.
Frey, Nancy Louise. 1998. Pilgrim stories: On and off the road to Santiago. Berkeley: University of
California Press.
Graham, Brian, and Michael Murray. 1997. The spiritual and the profane: the pilgrimage to Santiago De
Compostela. Cultural Geographies 4(4): 389–409.
Heelas, P., L. Woodhead, B. Seel, B. Szerszynski, and K. Tusting. 2005. The Spiritual revolution: Why
religion is giving way to spirituality. Malden MA, Oxford: Wiley, Blackwell.
Hervieu-Leger, Danie
`le. 1997. Le pe`lerin et le converti La religion en mouvement. Paris: Flammarion.
Hill, P.C., K.I. Pargament, R.W. Hood, M.E. McCullough Jr, J.P. Swyers, D.B. Larson, and B.J.
Zinnbauer. 2000. Conceptualizing religion and spirituality: Points of commonality, points of
departure. Journal for the Theory of Social Behaviour 30: 51–77.
Ivakhiv, Adrian. 2003. Nature and self in New Age pilgrimage. Culture and Religion 4(1): 93–118.
Kantner, John, and K.J. Vaughn. 2012. Pilgrimage as costly signal: Religiously motivated cooperation in
Chaco and Nasca. Journal of Anthropological Archaeology 31(1): 66–82.
Margry, Peter Jan. 2008. Shrines and pilgrimage in the modern world: New itineraries into the sacred.
Amsterdam: Amsterdam University Press.
Marler, P.L., and C.K. Hadaway. 2002. ‘‘Being religious’’ or ‘‘being spiritual’’ in America: A zero-sum
proposition? Journal for the Scientific Study of Religion 41: 289–300.
McElreath, Richard, Robert Boyd, and Peter J. Richerson. 2003. Shared norms and the evolution of ethnic
markers. Current Anthropology 44(1): 122–130.
Morinis, Alan. 1992. Sacred journeys: The anthropology of pilgrimage. Westport, London: Greenwood.
Nordin, Andreas. 2011. The cognition of hardship experience in Himalayan pilgrimage. Numen 58:
632–673.
Pack, Sasha D. 2010. Revival of the pilgrimage to Santiago de Compostela: The politics of religious,
national, and European patrimony, 1879–1988. The Journal of Modern History 82(2): 335–367.
Reader, Ian. 2007. Pilgrimage growth in the modern world: Meanings and implications. Religion 37(3):
210–229.
Santos, Xose M. 2002. Pilgrimage and tourism at Santiago de Compostela. Tourism Recreation Research
27(2): 41–50.
Sean, Slavin. 2003. Walking as spiritual practice: The pilgrimage to Santiago de Compostela. Body &
Society 9(3): 1–18.
Rev Relig Res
123
Author's personal copy
Sosis, Richard, and Candace Alcorta. 2003. Signaling solidarity and the sacred: The evolution of religious
behavior. Evolutionary Anthropology 12: 264–274.
Steil, Carlos Alberto, and Sandra de Sa
´Carneiro. 2008. Peregrinac¸a
˜o, turismo e Nova Era: Caminhos de
Santiago de Compostela no Brasil. Religia˜o e Sociedade, Rio de Janeiro 28(1): 105–124.
Swatos, William H. 2009. Pilgrimage and conversion. Religion and the Social Order 17: 115–130.
Swatos, William H., and Luigi Tomasi (eds.). 2002. From medieval pilgrimage to religious tourism: The
social and cultural economics of piety. Santa Barbara, CA, Denver, CO: Praeger.
Taylor, Charles. 1992. The ethics of authenticity. Cambridge, MA.: Harvard University Press.
Taylor, Charles. 2007. A secular age. Cambridge, MA.: Harvard University Press.
Timothy, Dallen J., and Daniel H. Olsen. 2006. Tourism, religion and spiritual journeys. London, New
York: Routledge.
Turner, Victor, Edith Turner, Deborah Ross (1978) 2011. Image and pilgrimage in christian culture, New
York: Columbia University Press.
Rev Relig Res
123
Author's personal copy
... Motivation is the process that influences the orientation and efforts of an individual to achieve a goal [3,9,26], while tourist motivation reflects the internal needs of tourists, also referred to as push and pull factors [27]. Some authors have indicated that tourist motivations are a multifaceted construct [3] that originates from the intrinsic reasons for the trip and the forces that drive the tourist to choose a particular destination [28]; they are also the specific desires of tourists that lead them to travel [29]. ...
... It should be noted that they have also been referred to as motivational factors that originate from individual commitments to the sacred, which can arise unexpectedly [7]. Other authors have indicated a great diversity of religious motivations among tourists or pilgrims [3,26]. As Belhassen & Bowler [32] pointed out, religious tourism can transform and open up the possibility of seeing things differently. ...
Article
Full-text available
The present study, focused on pilgrimages as part of religious tourism, aimed to achieve the following objectives: Identify the motivations of the demand for religious tourism focused on pilgrimages; analyze the segmentation of the demand; identify the relationship between demand segments with satisfaction and loyalty; and establish the sociodemographic aspects that characterize demand segments. The study was conducted during the Pilgrimage of the Christ of Miracles in Lima, Peru. The sample was taken on-site from 384 tourists. The statistical techniques used were factor analysis and the k-means clustering method. The results reveal five motivational dimensions: Religious Experience, Belief Experience, Escape, Touristic Experience, and Shopping. Three attendee segments were also identified: Believers, related to belief experience; Religious, related to religious experience; and Passive, tourists with low motivations. The Religious segment had the highest satisfaction and loyalty levels among these groups. Sociodemographic differences were also found in the demand segments. The findings will contribute to management guidelines for destination administrators with religious events and provide insights into academic literature.
... To date, there has been a lot of research on the experiences of pilgrimage to holy places, such as the studies of Gross (1971) on the pilgrimage centre of Bom Jesus de Lapa, in Bahia, Brazil; Dubisch (1995Dubisch ( , 2000 on the pilgrimage to the Greek island of Tinos; Abbate and Di Nuovo (2013) on the pilgrimage in Medjugorje, Bosnia and Herzegovina; Lopez (2013), Oviedo et al. (2014) and Lois-González and Santos (2015) on the pilgrimage to Santiago de Compostela; Shackley (1998) on Saint Catherine's Monastery on Mount Sinai, Egypt; etc. Other research focuses on the study of religious tourism and pilgrimages and on issues of pilgrimage authenticity (Belhassen et al., 2008). ...
Chapter
Emotion-based motivation is a concept that bridges the realms of psychology and neuroscience, examining how emotional states influence motivational processes. Emotions are complex psychological states that involve physiological arousal, expressive behaviors, and conscious experience. They play a critical role in shaping our motivations, guiding us towards goals, and influencing our actions.
Article
In the field of social robotics, there is a growing interest in robotic assistants for culture and tourism, and recent advances in 5G cellular communications, radically improving end-to-end latency and throughput, are key enablers in this regard. The Saint James Way (the Way) to Santiago de Compostela, Spain, is one of the main pilgrimage routes in Christianity. Over 430,000 pilgrims traveled to Santiago in 2022. Many of them cited motivations for travel other than religion, making the Way a major European touristic attraction linking many historical landmarks in Spain. In this article, we present and describe our experience in this scenario with a robotic walking avatar that was teleoperated from Italy (2,000 km away). To the best of our knowledge, this is the first time the feasibility of such an avatar has been quantitatively assessed in terms of teleoperation performance, terrain crossing capacity, and autonomy.
Article
Full-text available
This research concentrated on pilgrimages within the context of religious tourism. It sought to accomplish the following goals: establish the main motivational factors in religious tourism, identify the relationship between sociodemographic aspects and motivations, and determine the relationship between the sociodemographic aspects of pilgrims with their satisfaction and loyalty. The study was conducted during the Christ of Miracles Pilgrimage in Lima, Peru. The sample consisted of 384 tourists who were surveyed on-site. The statistical techniques used included factorial and multiple regression analysis. The findings uncovered five motivational dimensions: religious experience, belief experience, escape experience, tourist experience, and shopping. The sociodemographic variables were correlated with the motivation for the escape experience, thus younger attendees, with higher educational levels or who attended the event fewer times had higher levels of motivation for the Escape. Age was correlated with satisfaction, older attendees were more satisfied and the number of attendees at the event was correlated with loyalty. The results will offer management recommendations for organizers of religious events and add valuable insights to the academic literature.
Article
Full-text available
This study focused on pilgrimages as part of religious tourism and aimed to achieve the following objectives: identify the main motivational factors of religious tourism focused on pilgrimages; analyze the motivational dimensions that predict satisfaction in religious tourism focused on pilgrimages; analyze the motivational dimensions that predict loyalty in religious tourism focused on pilgrimages. The study was conducted during the pilgrimage to the Virgin of Chaguaya in Bolivia. The sample consisted of 384 tourists who were surveyed on-site. The statistical techniques used included factor analysis and multiple regression. The results revealed four motivational dimensions: Tourism and Escape, Religious Experience, Belief Experience, and Shopping. Additionally, specific motivations that influence the satisfaction and loyalty of attendees at religious events such as pilgrimages have been identified, among them the "Religious Experience" and the "Belief Experience" motivational dimensions. The findings will contribute to planning and management guidelines for religious event administrators and provide information to academic literature.
Article
Full-text available
Reframing Pilgrimage argues that sacred travel is just one of the twenty-first century's many forms of cultural mobility. The contributors consider the meanings of pilgrimage in Christian, Mormon, Hindu, Islamic and Sufi traditions, as well as in secular contexts, and they create a new theory of pilgrimage as a form of voluntary displacement. This voluntary displacement helps to constitute cultural meaning in a world constantly 'en route'. Pilgrimage, which works both on global economic and individual levels, is recognised as a highly creative and politically charged force intimately bound up in economic and cultural systems. © 2004 Selection and editorial matter EASA. All rights reserved.
Chapter
Offers a fresh and detailed take on the evolution of religious behavior from a biobehavioral perspective, promoting a new understanding that may help build bridges across the religious divide. There has been much recent interest in the study of religion from the perspective of Darwinian evolution. The Biology of Religious Behavior: The Evolutionary Origins of Faith and Religion offers a broad overview of the topic, written by internationally recognized experts. In addition to its primary focus on religious behavior, the book addresses other important aspects of religion, such as values, beliefs, and emotions as they affect behavior. The contributors approach the evolution of religion by examining the behavior of individuals in their everyday lives. After describing various religious behaviors, the contributors consider the behaviors with reference to their evolutionary history, development during the lifetime of the individual, proximate causes, and adaptive value. Happily, this foray into understanding religion from a biobehavioral perspective demonstrates that, at the biological and behavioral levels, what unites the different religions of the world is far greater than what divides them.
Chapter
1. Tourism and Religious Journeys 2. Sacred Spaces and Tourist Places 3. Religious and Secular Pilgrimage 4. Paradigms of Travel 5. Travel and Journeying on the Sea of Faith 6. Religious Tourism as an Educational Experience 7. Empty Bottles at Sacred Sites 8. Management Issues for Religious Heritage Attractions 9. Tourism and the Spiritual Philosophies of the 'Orient' 10. Nature Religion, Self Spirituality and New Age Tourism 11. Global Jewish Tourism 12. Buddhism, Tourism and the Middle Way 13. Tourism and Islam 14. Pilgrimage in Sikh Tradition 15. Pilgrimage in Hinduism 16. Sacred Places and Tourism in the Roman Catholic Tradition 17. Tourism and Informal Pilgrimage among the Latter-Day Saints 18. Conclusion