ArticlePDF Available

The importance of economies of scale for reductions in greenhouse gas emissions from shipping

Authors:
Elizabeth Lindstad at SINTEF Ocean AS
Elizabeth Lindstad
  • SINTEF Ocean AS
Bjørn Egil Asbjørnslett at Norwegian University of Science and Technology
Bjørn Egil Asbjørnslett
Anders Hammer Strømman at Norwegian University of Science and Technology
Anders Hammer Strømman
Download full-text PDFDownload full-text PDF
Read full-text
Download citation

Abstract and Figures

CO2 emissions from maritime transport represent 3.3% of the world's total CO2 emissions and are forecast to increase by 150%–250% by 2050, due to increased freight volumes (Second IMO GHG study, 2009). Fulfilling anticipated climate requirements (IPCC, 2007) could require the sector to reduce emissions per freight unit by a factor of five or six. The International Maritime Organization (IMO) is currently debating technical, operational and market-based measures for reducing greenhouse gas emissions from shipping. This paper also investigates the effects of economies of scale on the direct emissions and costs of maritime transport. We compared emissions from the current fleet (2007), with what can be achieved by increasing average vessel size. The comparison is based on the 2007 levels of trade and predictions for 2050. The results show that emissions can be reduced by up to 30% at a negative abatement cost per ton of CO2 by replacing the existing fleet with larger vessels. Replacing the whole fleet might take as long as 25 years, so the reduction in emissions will be achieved gradually as the current fleet is renewed.
Figures - uploaded by Elizabeth Lindstad
Author content
All figure content in this area was uploaded by Elizabeth Lindstad
Content may be subject to copyright.
5478564b0cf293e2da28df
a2.pdf
Content uploaded by Elizabeth Lindstad
Author content
All content in this area was uploaded by Elizabeth Lindstad on Nov 28, 2014
Content may be subject to copyright.
The importance of economies of scale for reductions in greenhouse gas emissions from shippi
ng.pdf
Available via license: CC BY-NC-ND 3.0
Content may be subject to copyright.
A preview of the PDF is not available
... For those product, there are many type of fishing vessel who specialize on catching and processing those. [16], who forbids a certain type of fishing vessel to operate within Indonesia waterways, currently the Pole and Line ships is the most dominant and mostly used to catch Tuna Fish. From those problem and explanation, it became clear that energy measurement is very important and we could analyze those things on one of the most needed vessel in Fisheries process, which is Pole and Line Type. ...
Carbon Footprint Estimation for Pole and Line Fishing Vessel According to Its Operation Mode -Study Case at Papua Fisheries-
Article
  • Apr 2016
Carbon Footprint is one of the newest issue that people are concerned about especially on Fisheries business in Indonesia. The ships are growing bigger in terms of number and it makes the environment issue also became more concern for the people’s life and wellbeing. In this experiment, those issues will be analyzed with Carbon Footprint on Fishing Ships in Sorong. This experiment will be analyzed using mathematical analysis based on literature that used in order to get the emission factor and also to calculate the carbon footprint emission on site. Those calculations will be used as basic logic calculation using the emission factor multiplied by fuel consumption. The purpose of this experiment is to understanding the Mode of the operation of the fishing ships in order to calculate the emissions. This experiment purpose is to get estimation of the amount of exhaust gas from fishing ships emission and also to get the constant value for each fuel that used for the fishing ships on the experiment site.
View
... For comparison of ERM and VCRM, it was assumed that they are installed on a 0-1000 TEU container ship with average distance per voyage l voyage =650 nm, the average duration of cargo voyage τ voyage =6 days, the annual number of cargo voyages 49 [29]. The average time of stay in port τ port =1 day. ...
Marine Heat-driven Ejector Refrigeration Machine for Air-conditioning System with Thermal Energy Storage Unit
Article
Full-text available
  • Nov 2024
A novel heat-driven ejector refrigeration machine for an onboard air-conditioning system of a merchant ship was conceptualized and analyzed. The source of waste heat is low-pressure steam from the exhaust gas boiler (0.5-0.7 MPa). However, the steam from auxiliary boilers is used in port. It was proposed to include a thermal energy storage unit in the ejector refrigeration machine design to reduce fuel consumption by auxiliary boilers in the port. A phase change material with a melting point of 142 °C was proposed for use as thermal energy storage material. It was admitted for the TES unit to replace half of the generator load for 1 day of operation. For such conditions the volume and mass of the thermal energy storage unit were 16.5 tons and 125 m3 at an ejector refrigeration machine cooling capacity of 174 kW. It was shown that ejector refrigeration machine with thermal energy storage unit inherent the lower fuel consumption for its operation compared to the vapor-compression refrigeration machine: 53916 vs. 80567 kg of fuel per year. It is advisable to use the proposed ejector refrigeration machine with a thermal energy storage unit on ships that have short voyages and frequent stays in port. The problems in the TES unit design that need to be studied further have been noted in the paper.
View
... Greenhouse gas emissions from maritime transport contribute to air and water pollution, with negative effects on ecosystems and human health. Furthermore, these emissions are a significant driver of global warming, with the potential to disrupt weather patterns, rise sea levels, and cause other severe climate-related events [2]. ...
A Data-Driven Model for Rapid CII Prediction
Article
Full-text available
  • Nov 2024
The shipping industry plays a crucial role in global trade, but it also contributes significantly to environmental pollution, particularly in regard to carbon emissions. The Carbon Intensity Indicator (CII) was introduced with the objective of reducing emissions in the shipping sector. The lack of familiarity with the carbon performance is a common issue among vessel operator. To address this aspect, the development of methods that can accurately predict the CII for ships is of paramount importance. This paper presents a novel and simplified approach to predicting the CII for ships, which makes use of data-driven modelling techniques. The proposed method considers a restricted set of parameters, including operational data (draft and speed) and environmental conditions, such as wind speed and direction, to provide an accurate prediction of the CII factor. This approach extends the state of research by applying Deep Neural Networks (DNNs) to provide an accurate CII prediction with a deviation of less than 6% over a considered time frame consisting of different operating states (cruising and maneuvering mode). The result is achieved by using a limited amount of training data, which enables ship owners to obtain a rapid estimation of their yearly rating prior to receiving the annual CII evaluation.
View
... Emissions from large-scale shipping methods based on net payload capacity(Lindstad et al., 2012). ...
AgRefine D2.8: Life Cycle Assessment Framework and Report
Technical Report
Full-text available
  • Mar 2024
Biorefinery concepts, which aim to convert bio-based resources or waste streams into multiple value-added products, are a key focus for the developing sustainable and circular bioeconomy. To understand and compare the sustainability of different biorefinery concepts, life cycle assessment (LCA) is a useful methodology. However, the utilization of this methodology still has some challenges, particularly when it comes to quantifying the impacts of emerging biotechnologies. These challenges are apparent within the AgRefine project, where several biorefinery processes and technologies of different technological readiness levels (TRLs) are being developed from multiple European partners. This deliverable reports on the life cycle inventory inputs and scale up methodologies which could be useful for life cycle assessments (including environmental LCAs, life cycle costings, social LCAs, and life cycle sustainability assessments) in future biorefinery projects. This deliverable as well as all other AgRefine deliverables can be accessed from: https://doi.org/10.3030/860477
View
... One way to reduce fuel consumption per volume of cargo transported is to increase the size of the vessels. It has been proven that larger ships, when compared to smaller ones, have an increase in fuel consumption that is lower than the corresponding increase in cargo capacity (Panagakos et al., 2019;Lindstad et al., 2012;Chang and Jhang, 2016). Indeed, meeting the needs of vessels of such considerable size requires, on the one hand, a compatible water depth for operation and maneuver and, on the other hand, berths-ship docking area for accommodating large ships, and terminals capable of handling enormous quantities of goods, including hundreds of hectares of land with infrastructure for roads and railways and warehouses (Notteboom et al., 2022). ...
Environmental performance of Brazilian ports with capacity for modernization to receive and operate post-panamax ships
Conference Paper
Full-text available
  • Jun 2024
It is widely known that ports are important infrastructures for the economic development, serving as pivotal entry points for commerce and having, significant strategic importance for countries. The Brazilian maritime sector comprises 35 public ports and 174 Private Use Terminals, and exist a pressing requirement for their modernization and adaptation, especially in view of the increasing size of post-Panamax ships. Out of these 209 ports, just a few have channel depths conducive for accommodating ships with drafts exceeding 15 meters. This highlights the imperative for upgrades to meet the evolving demands of the maritime industry. The objective of this study is to analyze the environmental performance of ports deemed suitable for the development to facilitate the reception and operation of post-Panamax ships. Consequently, emphasis was placed on ports located along the coastal region or major rivers. As a result, as part of this research a selection of 38 ports were scrutinized. The analysis of the selected ports was carried out through the Índice de Desempenho Ambiental (IDA), the most notorious environmental performance indicator used by the Brazilian Government to evaluate the environmental performance of ports, comprising 38 indicators into 4 categories: economic-operational, socio-cultural, physical-chemical and biological-ecological. The results confirm that there are some indicators that are very positive such as the existence of environmental licensing or the provision of qualified environmental professionals. However, there are some indicators with a low performance that should be addressed such as the implementation of emergency response plans and the provision of onshore power supply.
View
Unlocking Brazil’s Maritime Potential: Expanding Ports for Post-Panamax Operations
Article
  • May 2025
The Brazilian port sector faces an urgent need for modernization to meet the demands of the contemporary global economy. A significant challenge lies in the shallow depth of access channels, which hinders the navigation of larger ships with deeper drafts, and the fact that many ports are constrained by the proximity of large cities, limiting their expansion. This study aims to identify Brazilian ports with the potential to accommodate post-Panamax ships, a critical component of modern maritime trade. Using a multi-criteria evaluation system, five key criteria were selected: water depth, land capacity for expansion, dredging requirements, water accessibility, and transport infrastructure. These criteria were systematically applied to 210 Brazilian port facilities, analyzed through QGIS 3.38.3 software using satellite imagery and literature sources. To prioritize the most suitable ports, Pareto analysis and quartile analysis were employed, resulting in the identification of 58 port facilities as prime candidates for expansion. This research provides a data-driven framework to guide the modernization of Brazilian ports, positioning them to better serve the growing demands of the global maritime industry.
View
View
View
View
View
View
View
The effectiveness and costs of speed reductions on emissions from international shipping
Article
Full-text available
  • Dec 2009
  • TRANSPORT RES D-TR E
Greenhouse gas emissions from international shipping are an increasing concern. The paper evaluates whether vessel speed reduction can be a potentially cost-effective CO2 mitigation option for ships calling on US ports. By applying a profit-maximizing equation to estimate route-specific, economically-efficient speeds, we explore policy impacts of a fuel tax and a speed reduction mandate on CO2 emissions. The profit-maximizing function incorporates opportunity costs associated with speed reduction that go unobserved in more traditional marginal abatement cost analyses. We find that a fuel tax of about 150/tonfuelwillleadtoaveragespeed−relatedCO2reductionsofabout20–30150/ton fuel will lead to average speed-related CO2 reductions of about 20–30%. Moreover, a speed reduction mandate targeted to achieve 20% CO2 reduction in the container fleet costs between 30 and $200 per ton CO2 abated, depending on how the fleet responds to a speed reduction mandate.
View
View
Globalisation, Transport and the Environment
Book
  • Feb 2010
The results of an OECD analysis on the impacts of globalisation on transport levels, the consequences for the environment, and the policy instruments that can be used to limit any negative impacts for the environment are described below.
View
Determining a required energy efficiency design index level for new ships based on a cost-effectiveness criterion
Article
  • Mar 2010
The maritime industry is expected to contribute to Greenhouse Gas (GHG) emission reductions, and the International Maritime Organisation (IMO) is working on possible ways of regulating shipping's GHG emissions. One possible instrument is the Energy Efficiency Design Index (EEDI). However, there is no agreement on a mandatory application or how to set the required targets. This article presents an approach where a required index level (IR) can be determined through a cost-effectiveness assessment of the available reduction measures. A decision criterion of 50 USD per tonne CO2-eq. averted is used, based on a 2°C stabilisation level target. For illustration purposes, eleven emission reduction measures are analysed for implementation on a representative ship, and the IR is reached after applying the measures fulfilling the decision criterion. Using the same principles, other regulatory requirements such as a cap on emissions from shipping, e.g. for use in a shipping emissions trading scheme, can be developed. Using a cost-effectiveness approach in setting a IR or determining a cap will avoid prescriptive regulations detailing specific measures to be implemented, and the costs imposed by new requirements may be justified on the basis of the achievable emission reductions and cross-sector potential for achieving a global reduction target.
View
A historical reconstruction of ships' fuel consumption and emissions
Article
  • Jun 2007
Shipping activity has increased considerably over the last century and currently represents a significant contribution to the global emissions of pollutants and greenhouse gases. Despite this, information about the historical development of fuel consumption and emissions is generally limited, with little data published pre-1950 and large deviations reported for estimates covering the last 3 decades. To better understand the historical development in ship emissions and the uncertainties associated with the estimates, we present fuel-based CO2 and SO2 emission inventories from 1925 up to 2002 and activity-based estimates from 1970 up to 2000. The global CO2 emissions from ships in 1925 have been estimated to 229 Tg (CO2), growing to about 634 Tg (CO2) in 2002. The corresponding SO2 emissions are about 2.5 Tg (SO2) and 8.5 Tg (SO2), respectively. Our activity-based estimates of fuel consumption from 1970 to 2000, covering all oceangoing civil ships above or equal to 100 gross tonnage (GT), are lower compared to previous activity-based studies. We have applied a more detailed model approach, which includes variation in the demand for sea transport, as well as operational and technological changes of the past. This study concludes that the main reason for the large deviations found in reported inventories is the applied number of days at sea. Moreover, our modeling indicates that the ship size and the degree of utilization of the fleet, combined with the shift to diesel engines, have been the major factors determining yearly fuel consumption. Interestingly, the model results from around 1973 suggest that the fleet growth is not necessarily followed by increased fuel consumption, as technical and operational characteristics have changed. Results from this study indicate that reported sales over the last 3 decades seems not to be significantly underreported as previous simplified activity-based studies have suggested. The results confirm our previously reported modeling estimates for year 2000. Previous activity-based studies have not considered ships less than 100 GT (e.g., today some 1.3 million fishing vessels), and we suggest that this fleet could account for an important part of the total fuel consumption (˜10%).
View
View
View
Transport impacts on atmosphere and climate: Shipping
Article
  • Dec 2010
  • ATMOS ENVIRON
Emissions of exhaust gases and particles from oceangoing ships are a significant and growing contributor to the total emissions from the transportation sector. We present an assessment of the contribution of gaseous and particulate emissions from oceangoing shipping to anthropogenic emissions and air quality. We also assess the degradation in human health and climate change created by these emissions. Regulating ship emissions requires comprehensive knowledge of current fuel consumption and emissions, understanding of their impact on atmospheric composition and climate, and projections of potential future evolutions and mitigation options. Nearly 70% of ship emissions occur within 400 km of coastlines, causing air quality problems through the formation of ground-level ozone, sulphur emissions and particulate matter in coastal areas and harbours with heavy traffic. Furthermore, ozone and aerosol precursor emissions as well as their derivative species from ships may be transported in the atmosphere over several hundreds of kilometres, and thus contribute to air quality problems further inland, even though they are emitted at sea. In addition, ship emissions impact climate. Recent studies indicate that the cooling due to altered clouds far outweighs the warming effects from greenhouse gases such as Carbon dioxide (CO2) or ozone from shipping, overall causing a negative present-day radiative forcing (RF). Current efforts to reduce sulphur and other pollutants from shipping may modify this. However, given the short residence time of sulphate compared to CO2, the climate response from sulphate is of the order decades while that of CO2 is centuries. The climatic trade-off between positive and negative radiative forcing is still a topic of scientific research, but from what is currently known, a simple cancellation of global mean forcing components is potentially inappropriate and a more comprehensive assessment metric is required. The CO2 equivalent emissions using the Global Temperature Change Potential (GTP) metric indicate that after 50 years the net global mean effect of current emissions is close to zero through cancellation of warming by CO2 and cooling by sulphate and nitrogen oxides.
View