ArticlePDF Available

Abstract

This paper presents a number of research initiatives related to innovative and cut-edge technologies for Cloud Computing. These are chiefly in the fields of (i) environment security, (ii) quality assurance , (iii) service composition, and (iv) system management. We present technologies for intrusion detection; a SLA perspective in security management; customer security concerns; a Cloud- based solution for eHealth; experimental assessment of routing for grid and cloud; simulator improvements to validate the green cloud computing approach, and; a framework to radio layer operation in cognitive networks.
!"#"$%&%#'("#)(*%+,-.'/(01-(
2-.)3(451,)("#)(
41$#.67%(8%'91-:;(
<%"#(=",51()"(*.57%.-"(
>5%?"#)-%(@%#-.A,%(
B%1#"-)1(C-%.'";(
(
(
>D!E8E*FG>FEH8(>8D(!>8>2I!I8F(HC(4H!=JFIG((
8IFKHGL*(M(E8INOPQ(
C%)%-"5(J#.7%-;.'/(10(*"#'"(4"'"-.#"(
DI4I!RIG(ST3(SUPS(M(RG>VEB(
E8FGHDJ4FEH8(
451,)(+1&W,6#$(W1;%;(#%9(+X"55%#$%;(01-('X%(
)%7%51W&%#'( "#)( &"#"$%&%#'( 10( 'X%.-(
;%-7.+%;Y(
FX.;(W"W%-(W-%;%#';("(;%-.%;(10(-%;%"-+X(Z%.#$(
+1#),+'%)( 01-( 'X.;( '%+X#151$/Y( I;W%+."55/( .#(
;"0%'/3( %#7.-1#&%#'3( A,"5.'/( ";;,-"#+%3(
;%-7.+%(+1&W1;.61#("#)(&"#"$%&%#'(;/;'%&Y(
4H8FI8F(
*%+,-.'/(0-"&%91-:(01-(.#W,'(7"5.)"61#[(
E#'-,;.1#()%'%+61#(01-(+1&W,'"61#($-.);[(
E#'-,;.1#()%'%+61#(01-($-.)("#)(+51,)[(
*B>(.#(;%+,-.'/(&"#"$%&%#'(01-(+51,)(+1&W,6#$[(
41;',&%-(;%+,-.'/(.#(+51,)(+1&W,6#$[(
451,)(+1&W,6#$(01-(X%"5'X(+"-%[(
G1,6#$(01-($-.)("#)(+51,)(+1&W,6#$[(
!"#"$%&%#'(01-($-%%#(+51,)(+1&W,6#$[(
G").1(5"/%-(1W%-"61#(.#(+1$#.67%(#%'91-:;[(
41#+5,;.1#[(
S(M(*I4JGEF\(CG>!IKHGL(CHG(E8=JF(
]>BED>FEH8(
!"#.W,5"61#( "^"+:;( %#'-.%;( "-%( +1&&1#( .#(
9%Z("WW5.+"61#;("#)(;%+,-.'/Y(
E'( .;( W-1W1;%)( '1( ,;%( "#( _!B( ;+X%&"( 'X"'(
+1#'".#;( 'X%( W"-"&%'%-;( 01-( ;W%+.0/.#$(
;%+,-.'/Y(
FX%( W"W%-( W-1W1;%;( "( 0-"&%91-:( 01-(
"WW5.+"61#;( &1,#6#$( "$".#;'( .#$-%;;( 10(
&"#.W,5"61#("^"+:;Y(
S(M(*I4JGEF\(CG>!IKHGL(CHG(E8=JF(
]>BED>FEH8(
>^"+:;(0-1&(5"+:(10(.#W,'(7"5.)"61#`(
81'(+1--%+'(1W%-"61#(10(7"5.)"61#(a%5);(1-(JGB[(
G,##.#$(*bB('1(&"#.W,5"'%(1-(JGB(a%5);[(
@.))%#(a%5)(&"#.W,5"61#[(
*%#).#$( &%;;"$%;( 5"-$%-( 'X"#( 'X%( &"?.&,&(
W%-&.^%)('1(%?%+,'%("-Z.'-"-/(+1&&"#);Y(
\1,( ;X1,5)( 7"5.)"'%( ,;%-( .#W,'( Z%01-%(
"WW5.+"61#(Z%$.#;(%?%+,6#$Y(
S(M(*I4JGEF\(CG>!IKHGL(CHG(E8=JF(
]>BED>FEH8(
!%+X"#.;&(.#W,'(7"5.)"61#("#)("WW5.+"61#`(
FX%(_!B(*+X%&"(;W%+.a+"61#()%a#%;('X%(7"5.)(
_!B(01-('"Z5%[(
FX%(_!B(a5%()%a#%;('X%(7"5.)(%#'-.%;[(
FX%(&%+X"#.;&(.;(+"55%)(;%-7%-('1(7"5.)"'%('X%(
,;%-("++1-).#$('1('X%(_!B(;W%+.a+"61#[(
]%-.a+"61#('":%;(W5"+%("++1-).#$('1("#/(
.#+1#;.;'%#+/(_!B(.#W,'[(
E0("++%;;(.;(7"5.)"'%)(.;(-%5%";%)3(1'X%-9.;%(
).;W5"/;('X%(%--1-(&%;;"$%Y(
S(M(*I4JGEF\(CG>!IKHGL(CHG(E8=JF(
]>BED>FEH8(
>)7"#'"$%;("#)(+1#+5,;.1#;`(
E'( 91-:;( 1#( 'X%( ;%-7%-( ;.)%( M( &%"#.#$( 'X"'( "#/(
+,;'1&%-(.#W,'(.;(7"5.)"'%)(Z%01-%(Z%.#$(W-1+%;;%)[(
J;%;( "( ;.#$5%( 7"5.)"61#( &%+X"#.;&( 01-( 'X%( %#6-%(
;/;'%&[(
=-1&1'%;(-%,;%("#)(;'"#)"-).c"61#(10(;/;'%&;[(
>#( .#)%W%#)%#'( ;%+,-.'/( ;W%+.a+"61#( 01-( .#W,'(
7"5.)"61#Y(
>-+X.'%+',-%('X"'(+"#(Z%(,;%)(01-(K%Z("WW5.+"61#;(1-(
K%Z(;%-7.+%;Y(
d(M(E8FGJ*EH8(DIFI4FEH8(CHG(
4H!=JF>FEH8(2GED*(
FX%( .#'-,;.1#( )%'%+61#( '%+X#151$/( .;( +,--%#'(
5.&.'%)Y(
2-.)( +1&W,6#$( .;( %&%-$.#$( ";( '115;( '1( 0"+.5.'"'%(
'X%( ;%+,-%( ;X"-.#$( 10( X%'%-1$%#%1,;( -%;1,-+%;(
%#7.-1#&%#';Y(
E#'-,;.1#( )%'%+61#( ;/;'%&;( eED*f( X"7%( "#(
.&W1-'"#'(-15%(.#('X%(&"#"$%&%#'(10(;%+,-.'/(10(
#%'91-:Y(
ED*;(+"#(#1'(W-1W%-5/()%'%+'(#%'91-:(.#'-,;.1#Y(
d(M(E8FGJ*EH8(DIFI4FEH8(CHG(
4H!=JF>FEH8(2GED*(
=-1W1;"5;("#)(*15,61#;`(
J;%( 10( "( &%'X1)( 9X.+X( ,65.c%;( X.$XM5%7%5( 519M5%7%5(
0,#+61#"5.'/(10('X%(ED*('X-1,$X(+1&&,#.+"61#(Z/(-%,;.#$(
'X%("5-%")/("7".5"Z5%(;1g9"-%(.#'-,;.1#("71.).#$(),W5.+"'%(
0,#+61#"5.'/[(
>-%( .#;'"55%)( .#( ;W%+.a+( #%'91-:( #1)%;( "#)( #%'91-:(
)1&".#;( "#)( 91-:( .#'%$-"'%)( 9.'X( .#'-,;.1#( )%'%+61#(
;/;'%&;[(
E#( 1-)%-( '1( "+X.%7%( 'X%( &"?.&,&( 5%7%5( 10( ;%+,-.'/3( %"+X(
$-.)( #1)%( "#)( $-.)( #%'91-:( )1&".#( ;X1,5)( X"7%( "( 519%-(
5%7%5(ED*(.#;'"55%)Y(
>,).';( ;%%:.#$( "#1&"5.%;( 1-( "^"+:;( 1#( 'X%( #%'91-:3(
9X%-%( %"+X( #1)%( .;( +155%+'%)( "#)( "#"5/c%)( 'X%( )"'"(
.)%#60/.#$('X%(%7.)%#+%(10("^"+:Y(
d(M(E8FGJ*EH8(DIFI4FEH8(CHG(
4H!=JF>FEH8(2GED*(
8%'91-:( ;%+,-.'/( &"#"$%-( .;( "5%-'%)(
9X%#%7%-( "#( .#'-,;.1#( .;( )%'%+'%)( Z/( $-.)(
.#'-,;.1#()%'%+61#(;/;'%&;(1-("#("5%-'(.;(;%#'(
Z/('X%(519%-M5%7%5(ED*;Y(
>$%#';( "-%( ;'1-%)( .#( )"'"Z";%;3( 9X%-%( 'X%/(
%?+X"#$%( )"'"( 9.'X( 'X%( )"'"Z";%( .#( 1-)%-( '1(
"#"5/c%(,;%-(Z%X"7.1-("#)(,W)"'%('X%(W-1a5%;Y(
d(M(E8FGJ*EH8(DIFI4FEH8(CHG(
4H!=JF>FEH8(2GED*(
Conclusions:*
FX%( 1Zh%+67%( 10( 'X.;( W"W%-( .;( '1( )%;+-.Z%( 'X%(
;X1-'+1&.#$;( 10( "7".5"Z5%( ;15,61#;( 01-( $-.)( .#'-,;.1#(
)%'%+61#(W-1Z5%&3(9X%-%('%+X#151$/(.;(5.&.'%)Y(
K";(5.;'%)(Z";.+(-%A,.-%&%#';('X"'(&,;'(Z%(&%'(Z/("(
$-.)(.#'-,;.1#()%'%+61#(;/;'%&;`(
417%-"$%[(
*+"5"Z.5.'/[(
41&W"6Z.5.'/($-.)Y(
E'( 9";( ";;,&%)( 'X"'( 'X%( .#'%$-"61#( 10( ED*( 9";(
0%";.Z5%Y(
i(M(E8FGJ*EH8(DIFI4FEH8(CHG(2GED(>8D(
4BHJD(
=-17.).#$( ;%+,-.'/( .#( "( ).;'-.Z,'%)( ;/;'%&(
-%A,.-%;`(
!1-%('X"#(,;%-(",'X%#6+"61#(9.'X(W";;91-);(1-(
).$.'"5(+%-6a+"'%;[(
41#a)%#6"5.'/(10()"'"('-"#;&.;;.1#[(
*'-.+'(+1#'-15(10('X%('";:;(W%-01-&%)[(
=-%7%#'(&"5.+.1,;(,;%-;[(
G"W.)()%'%+61#(10(:#19#("^"+:;Y(
i(M(E8FGJ*EH8(DIFI4FEH8(CHG(2GED(
>8D(4BHJD(
=-1W1;"5;("#)(*15,61#;(:*
D"'"(+155%+61#(&.))5%9"-%("#)()%'%+61#(
'%+X#.A,%;("-%("WW5.%)(.#'-,;.1#[(
>#"5/;.;(01-("#1&"5/()%'%+61#(01-(7%-.0/.#$('X%(
"+61#;(10(,;%-;[(
>#"5/c%(,;%-(Z%X"7.1-("#)(:#195%)$%[(
]%-.a+"61#(10(7.15"61#;(10(;%+,-.'/(W15.+.%;("#)(
;'"#)"-);(10(:#19#("^"+:;Y(
i(M(E8FGJ*EH8(DIFI4FEH8(CHG(2GED(
>8D(4BHJD(
R%+",;%( 10( .';( ).;'-.Z,'%)( #"',-%3( +51,)( +1&W,6#$(
%#7.-1#&%#';("-%("(Z.$('"-$%'(01-(.#'-,)%-;Y(
>#( ED*( ;X1,5)( Z%( )%W51/%)( '1( 91-:( .#( "( +51,)( +1&W,6#$(
%#7.-1#&%#'Y(FX,;3(%"+X(#1)%(.;(&1#.'1-%)(Z/("(W1-61#(10(
.#'-,;.1#M)%'%+61#( ;/;'%&( "#)( 9X%#( "#( "^"+:( 1++,-;3( "#(
"5%-'(.;(;%#'('1('X%(1'X%-(#1)%;(10('X%(%#7.-1#&%#'Y(
>#( "^"+:( 1#( "( ;/;'%&( 10( +51,)( +1&W,6#$( +"#( Z%( ;.5%#'(
;.#+%( +1&&,#.+"61#( .;( ,;,"55/( %#+-/W'%)( "#)( .#7.;.Z5%(
#1)%Y(
FX%( )%;+-.Z%)( 91-:( W-%;%#';( "#( "-+X.'%+',-%( +"55%)( ED*(
+51,)(44ED*(j(41,5)(41&W,6#$(E#'-,;.1#(D%'%+61#(*/;'%&(
9X.+X(&":%;('X%()%'%+61#(10(#%'91-:("#)(X1;'("^"+:;('1(
.)%#60/('X%(%#7.-1#&%#'Y(
i(M(E8FGJ*EH8(DIFI4FEH8(CHG(2GED(
>8D(4BHJD(
=-1W1;"5;("#)(*15,61#;`(
81)%(.;("#(%#6'/('X"'(+1#'".#;($-.)(-%;1,-+%;[(
C,#+61#"5.'/( .#'1( 'X%( %#7.-1#&%#'( 'X-1,$X( 'X%(
&.))5%9"-%[(
>,).'1-( .;( -%;W1#;.Z5%( 01-( +"W',-.#$( )"'"( 0-1&(
&,56W5%( ;1,-+%;3( ;,+X( ";( &%;;"$%;( 'X"'( 'X%( ;/;'%&(
-%$.;'-/(;%-7.+%("#)(#1)%[(
ED*(;%-7.+%('X"'("#"5/c%;()"'"(+"W',-%)(9.'X()%'%+61#(
'%+X#.A,%;( Z";%)( 1#( ,;%-( Z%X"7.1-( :#195%)$%( 10(
W-%7.1,;("^"+:;[(
*'1-"$%( *%-7.+%( &".#'".#;( 'X%( )"'"( -%A,.-%)( Z/( 'X%(
ED*(;%-7.+%('1(W%-01-&('X%("#"5/;.;[(
i(M(E8FGJ*EH8(DIFI4FEH8(CHG(2GED(
>8D(4BHJD(
41#+5,;.1#;`(
H#%( 9";( )%;+-.Z%)( +51,)( +1&W,6#$( .#'-,;.1#( )%'%+61#(
;/;'%&(+"W"Z5%(10(.)%#60/.#$(,#:#19#("^"+:;[(
FX%( ;15,61#( .;( "( ;%-7.+%( 10( D@*( 'X"'( +"W',-%;( ",).'( )"'"(
0-1&(1#%(W"-'(10(-%$.;'-/('1(.#+-%";%('X%( ;%+,-.'/(5%7%5(1#(
%"+X(#1)%[(
F91('%+X#.A,%;(9%-%("WW5.%)`(
@%(9";(&")%(kk"#("-6a+."5(#%,-"5(#%'91-:('1(-%+1$#.c%(W"^%-#;(10(
,;%-(Z%X"7.1-("#)(.#).+"'%("Z#1-&"5("+67.'/[(
E)%#6a+"61#(10('-"+:;("5-%")/( :#19#("^"+:;(0-1&("(;%'( 10(-,5%;3(
9X%-%(9%()%;+-.Z%("(;/;'%&(01-(+"W',-.#$()"'"(0-1&(;/;'%&(",).'(
51$("#)(&%;;"$%(%?+X"#$%(Z%'9%%#(#%'91-:(#1)%;Y(
=-1+%;;.#$(+1;'(.;(519("#)('X%(/.%5)(.;(;"6;0"+'1-/(01-("(-%"5(
6&%(.&W5%&%#'"61#Y(
N(M(*B>(E8(*I4JGEF\(!>8>2I!I8F(
CHG(4BHJD(4H!=JFE82(
NYPY(*%-7.+%(B%7%5(>$-%%&%#';(01-(*%+,-.'/(e*%+M
*B>f`(
M=-%7%#6#$( "^"+:;( "#)( ,;.#$( +1&W,'"61#"5(
&%+X"#.;&;( 'X"'( .#7157%( 5%7%5;( 10( ;%+,-.'/(
;%-7.+%('X"'(.;()%5.7%-%)Y(
ME;("(01-&"5(#%$16"'%)()1+,&%#'('X"'()%a#%;(
.#3( ;W%+."55/3( "( A,"#6'"67%( 9"/( 9X"'( ;%-7.+%(
5%7%5;( 9.55( Z%( )%5.7%-%)( 0-1&( 'X%( W-17.)%-( '1(
'X%(+,;'1&%-Y((
N(M(*B>(E8(*I4JGEF\(!>8>2I!I8F(
CHG(4BHJD(4H!=JFE82(
NYPY(*%-7.+%(B%7%5(>$-%%&%#';(01-(*%+,-.'/(e*%+M
*B>f`(
M*%-7.+%( 5%7%5( ;%+,-.'/( -%A,.-%&%#';( .#+5,)%`(
+-/W'1$-"WX/3( )"'"( W"+:%'( a5'%-.#$3(
-%),#)"#+/(10((X"-)9"-%("#)(;1g9"-%("#)(;1(
1#Y(
M!1#.'1-.#$( "#)( +1#'-15( 10( 'X%( "$-%%&%#';(
e*%+M!1#f`( &1#.'1-.#$( 9X%'X%-( 'X%( "$-%%)(
&%'-.+;( "-%( Z%.#$( &%'Y( FX%( "-+X.'%+',-%( *%+M
!1#(.;(.#)%W%#)%#'(10("(;W%+.a+('%+X#151$/Y(
N(M(*B>(E8(*I4JGEF\(!>8>2I!I8F(
CHG(4BHJD(4H!=JFE82(
NYSY(H7%-7.%9(1#('X%(;,Zh%+'(
M451,)( +1&W,6#$3( #%9( ).;'-.Z,'%)( +1&W,6#$(
"#)( Z,;.#%;;( W"-").$&3( 'X"'( W-17.)%;(
+1&W,6#$( W19%-3( ;1g9"-%( "#)( ;'1-"$%( "#)((
%7%#( "( ).;'-.Z,'%)( )"'"( +%#'%-( .#0-";'-,+',-%(
1#()%&"#)3()%5.7%-%)(17%-('X%(E#'%-#%'Y(
M>#(")7"#'"$%(10("(*B>M*%+(.;('X%(W1;;.Z.5.'/(10(
"( Z%^%-( ,#)%-;'"#).#$( 10( X19( ;%+,-.'/( .;(
Z%.#$(W%-01-&%)Y(
N(M(*B>(E8(*I4JGEF\(!>8>2I!I8F(
CHG(4BHJD(4H!=JFE82(
NYdY(D.l+,56%;('1()%a#%(;%+,-.'/(&%'-.+;('1(Z%(,;%)(
.#(*B>`(
MFX%( W"-").$&( .;( ;655( %7157.#$3( ";( 9%55( ";( 'X%(
,#)%-;'"#).#$( 10( 9X"'( "-%( 'X%( ;%+,-.'/(
+X"55%#$%;( 'X"'( .'( Z-.#$;Y( ( *%-7.+%;( )%5.7%-%)( .#(
;,+X( +1#).61#;( )%&"#)( +1#;.)%-"Z5%( %m1-'( .#(
'X%(W-1+%;;(10()%a#.#$(;%+,-.'/(;%-7.+%(5%7%5;Y(
MFX%(#%$16"61#( 10( 'X%( *B>( 9.55(X"7%( '1( Z%( "$.5%3(
.#( 1-)%-( '1( #1'( "m%+'( 'X%( X.-.#$( 10( ;%-7.+%;3( '1(
"5519()%&"#);('1(Z%(&%'(&1-%(A,.+:5/Y(
OY((4H*FJ!IG(*I4JGEF\(E8(4BHJD(
4H!=JFE82(
OYPY(D%a#.61#(10(+51,)(+1&W,6#$`(
ME'(.;("(#%9().;'-.Z,'%)(+1&W,6#$("#)(Z,;.#%;;(
W"-").$&Y( E'( W-17.)%;( +1&W,6#$( W19%-3(
;1g9"-%( "#)( ;'1-"$%( "#)( %7%#( "( ).;'-.Z,'%)(
)"'"(+%#'%-(.#0-";'-,+',-%(1#()%&"#)Y((
M( 451,)( +1&W,6#$( &":%;( ,;%( 10( %?.;6#$(
'%+X#151$.%;3( ;,+X( ( ";( 7.-',"5.c"61#3(
).;'-.Z,'%)( +1&W,6#$3( $-.)( +1&W,6#$3( ,65.'/(
+1&W,6#$("#)(E#'%-#%'Y((
OY((4H*FJ!IG(*I4JGEF\(E8(4BHJD(
4H!=JFE82(
OYSY(!".#(*%+,-.'/(=-1Z5%&;(=1.#'%)(01-(451,)((
41&W,6#$(*%+,-.'/`(
MFX-%%(&".#(+1#+%-#;(10(+,;'1&%-;`((
M],5#%-"Z.5.'/('1("^"+:[(
M*'"#)"-)(;%+,-.'/(W-"+6+%;[(
MR%.#$( ;,Zh%+'( '1( ;'"'%( 1-( #"61#"5( )"'"M;'1-"$%(
5"9;(-%5"'%)('1(W-.7"+/(1-(-%+1-)(:%%W.#$(
OY((4H*FJ!IG(*I4JGEF\(E8(4BHJD(
4H!=JFE82(
OYdY( J#.A,%( ;%+,-.'/( -.;:;3( +1#;.)%-.#$( ;%+,-.'/(
+1#).61#;( ),-.#$( 'X%( W-1+%;;( 10( +X11;.#$( ( "(
+51,)(W-17.)%-`(
M=-.7.5%$%)(,;%-("++%;;[(
MG%$,5"'1-/(41&W5."#+%[(
MD"'"(51+"61#[(
MD"'"(;%$-%$"61#[(
MG%+17%-/[(
ME#7%;6$"67%(;,WW1-'[(
MB1#$M'%-&(7."Z.5.'/(
nY(4BHJD(4H!=JFE82(CHG(@I>BF@(
4>GI(
nYPY(*15,61#('1((",'1&"'%(W-1+%;;%;(01-("6%#'o;(
7.'"5()"'"(+155%+61#(
MF%5%&%).+.#%( "5519;( -%&1'%( )."$#1;%;( "#)(
&1#.'1-.#$(10(W"6%#';Y(J;.#$(p;%#;1-;q("^"+X%)(
'1( %?.;6#$( &%).+"5( %A,.W&%#';('X"'("-%(
.#'%-+1##%+'%)('1(%?+X"#$%(;%-7.+%Y(
MFX%( W-1W1;"5( .;( Z";%)( 1#( 'X%( +1#+%W';( 10( ,65.'/(
+1&W,6#$( "#)( 9.-%5%;;( ;%#;1-( #%'91-:;Y( FX%(
.#01-&"61#( Z%+1&%;( "7".5"Z5%( .#( 'X%( p+51,)q(
0-1&( 9X%-%( .'( +"#( ( Z%( W-1+%;;%)( Z/( %?W%-'(
;/;'%&;("#)r1-().;'-.Z,'%)('1(&%).+"5(;'"mY((
(
nY(4BHJD(4H!=JFE82(CHG(@I>BF@(
4>GI(
nYSY(*%7%-"5(+X"55%#$%;(";;1+."'%)('1(",'1&"61#(
.#('X.;(;1-'(10(%#7.-1#&%#'`(
MX%'%-1$%#%.'/( 10( )%7.+%;3( W-1'1+15;3( "#)(
W-1$-"&&.#$( .#'%-0"+%;[( 'X%( -%A,.-%&%#'( 01-(
s%?.Z5%3( .&W"+'M0-%%( )%W51/&%#'[( 'X%(
-%A,.-%&%#'( 01-( %";/( '1( +1#a$,-%3( ( %";/( '1(
&"#"$%3( ;+"5"Z5%( "#)3( .0( W1;;.Z5%3( ;%50M
")h,;6#$(;/;'%&;3("#)(1'X%-;Y((
nY(4BHJD(4H!=JFE82(CHG(@I>BF@(
4>GI(
nYdY(*15,61#(=-%;%#'%)`(
MR";%)( 1#( +1#+%W';( 10( 9.-%5%;;( ;%#;1-( #%'91-:;(
"#)( ,65.'/( +1&W,6#$Y( p*%#;1-;q( "-%( "^"+X%)( '1(
%?.;6#$( &%).+"5( %A,.W&%#';( 'X"'( "-%( .#'%-M
+1##%+'%)( '1( %?+X"#$%( ;%-7.+%;[( 'X%;%( "-%(
.#'%$-"'%)('1('X%(.#;6',61#t;(+1&W,6#$(#%'91-:(
.#0-";'-,+',-%Y(
MFX%( .#01-&"61#( Z%+1&%;( "7".5"Z5%( .#( 'X%(
p+51,)q3( 0-1&( 9X%-%( .'( +"#( Z%( W-1+%;;%)( Z/(
%?W%-'( ;/;'%&;( "#)r1-( ).;'-.Z,'%)( '1( &%).+"5(
;'"m((01-("#"5/;.;Y(
nY(4BHJD(4H!=JFE82(CHG(@I>BF@(
4>GI(
nYiY( *%7%-"5( W-"+6+"5( ")7"#'"$%;( .#( 'X.;(
.&W5%&%#'"61#`(
M.'(W-17.)%;("59"/;(1#3(-%"5M6&%()"'"(+155%+6#$[(
M.'( %5.&.#"'%;( &"#,"5( +155%+6#$( 91-:( "#)( W1;;.Z.5.'/(
10('/W.#$(%--1-;[(
M(.'(0"+.5.'"'%)('X%()%W51/&%#'(W-1+%;;Y(
M( FX%( W-1W1;%)( "-+X.'%+',-%( +17%-;( 'X%( ;%7%-"5(
%5%&%#';(.#(+,--%#'(;/;'%&;Y(
T(M(GHJFE82(CHG(2GED(>8D(4BHJD(
4H!=JFE82(
TYPY(2-.)("#)(451,)(+1&W,6#$('%+X#151$.%;`(
MFX%;%( ;'-,+',-%;( ".&( '1( ;,WW1-'( ;%-7.+%(
"WW5.+"61#;( Z/( $-1,W.#$( )%7.+%;( "#)( ;X"-%)(
-%;1,-+%;(.#(1#%(5"-$%(+1&W,'"61#"5(,#.'Y(
MFX%( #%%)( '1( +1##%+'( &"#/( X%'%-1$%#%1,;(
;/;'%&;(.;(1#%(10('X%(&".#(#%+%;;.6%;(10($-.)(
"#)( +51,)( +1&W,6#$3( .#'-1),+.#$( #%9( 5%7%5;(
10(+1&W5%?.'/Y((
(
T(M(GHJFE82(CHG(2GED(>8D(4BHJD(
4H!=JFE82(
TYSY(=-1Z5%&;(10(!"#"$%&%#'`(
MFX%(+1#a$,-"61#("#)(&"#"$%&%#'(.;()1#%(Z/(
X,&"#;(&":.#$((;519("#)("(;,Zh%+'(10(
)%+.;.1#(&":.#$(W-1Z5%&;Y(
MFX%(;15,61#(91,5)(Z%(#1(X,&"#(.#'%-7%#61#(
.#( 'X%( &"#"$%&%#'Y( @19( '1( &"#"$%(
%l+.%#'5/( "#)( .#( "#( ",'1&"'%)( 9"/( "(
X%'%-1$%#%1,;("#)(+1&W5%?(%#7.-1#&%#'3(5.:%(
$-.)(1-(+51,)u(
(
T(M(GHJFE82(CHG(2GED(>8D(4BHJD(
4H!=JFE82(
TYdY(>#(%?W%-.&%#'"5(";;%;;&%#'(10(-1,6#$(01-((
$-.)("#)(+51,)(`(
MFX%( ;/;'%&( X";( ;%50M&"#"$%&%#'( W-1W%-6%;3( "#)(
-%)%a#%;( 'X%( X,&"#( 1W%-"'1-v;( -%;W1#;.Z.5.6%;3( 9X%-%(
'X%.-(%?W%-.%#+%(.;(,;%)('1()%a#%($%#%-"5(1Zh%+67%;("#)(
W15.+%;('1(+1#'-15('X%(;/;'%&(.#;'%")(10(W5"+.#$('X%&(.#("(
)%+.;.1#(&":.#$(W1;.61#Y(
MFX%( ;/;'%&( W-1W1;%)( X%-%( .&W5%&%#';( '91( -1,6#$(
"5$1-.'X&;`(1#%(.;(Z";%)(1#('X%().-%+'(.#'%-+1##%+61#(9.'X("(
#%.$XZ1-(#1)%3("#)('X%(1'X%-(.;(Z";%)(1#('X%(.#'%-+1##%+61#(
"&1#$("55(#1)%;Y((
(
(
T(M(GHJFE82(CHG(2GED(>8D(4BHJD(
4H!=JFE82(
TYdY(>#(%?W%-.&%#'"5(";;%;;&%#'(10(-1,6#$(01-(($-.)(
"#)(+51,)(`(
MFX%(+1#7%-$%#+%(6&%(10('X%("5$1-.'X&(Z";%)(1#(
'X%( ).-%+'( .#'%-+1##%+61#( '1( 'X%( #%.$XZ1-( #1)%(
.;(-%"55/(;&"55("#)("5&1;'(+1#;'"#'Y(
MFX%( W-1W1;%)( ;15,61#( '1( ",'1&"6+"55/( &"#"$%(
'X%(+1&W5%?.'/(10($-.)(+1&W,6#$("#)(+51,)(.;(1#(
+-%"6#$( .#'%55.$%#'( "$%#';( "Z5%( '1( ;%#;%( 'X%.-(
%#7.-1#&%#'( "#)( "+6#$( .#( "++1-)"#+%( 9.'X( W-%M
)%a#%)(W15.+.%;Y(
Q(M(!>8>2I!I8F(CHG(2GII8(4BHJD(
4H!=JFE82(
>Y(*+1W%("#)(41#'%?'(
RY(=-1W1;"5;("#)(;15,61#;(
4Y(41#+5,;.1#("#)(0,',-%(91-:;(
Q(M(!>8>2I!I8F(CHG(2GII8(4BHJD(
4H!=JFE82(
*+1W%("#)(41#'%?'`(
=-1W1;%( "#( .#'%$-"'%)( ;15,61#( 01-( %#7.-1#&%#'3(
;%-7.+%;( "#)( #%'91-:( &"#"$%&%#'( Z";%)( 1#(
1-$"#.c"61#( &1)%5( 10( ",'1#1&1,;( "$%#'(
+1&W1#%#';Y(
FX%($1"5(10($-%%#(+1&W,6#$(
Q(M(!>8>2I!I8F(CHG(2GII8(4BHJD(
4H!=JFE82(
*+1W%("#)(41#'%?'`(
>WW-1"+X%;('1()%"5.#$(9.'X('X%(W-1Z5%&;(10(
51")(W-%).+61#(&1)%5;(.#+5,)%('X%(015519.#$`(((
>5519(01-("(&"-$.#(10(1#M5.#%(-%;1,-+%;(
F1(',-#(1#(.)5%(-%;1,-+%;[((
F1('%&W1-"-.5/(,;%(%?'%-#"5(-%;1,-+%;(1#()%&"#)(
Q(M(!>8>2I!I8F(CHG(2GII8(4BHJD(
4H!=JFE82(
*+1W%("#)(41#'%?'`(
=-1W1;%( "( ;15,61#( Z";%)( 1#( .#'%$-"'%)( %#7.-1#&%#'3(
;%-7.+%;("#)(#%'91-:(&"#"$%&%#'('X"'(W-1&1'%;`(
IA,.'"Z5%(51")().;'-.Z,61#( 'X-1,$X('%+X#.A,%;(5.:%(7.-',"5(
&"+X.#%;[((
=-%).+67%( -%;1,-+%( "551+"61#( &1)%5;( 'X-1,$X( X.;'1-.+"5(
51")("#"5/;.;("#)(W-1M"+67%("551+"61#(&%'X1);[((
>$$-%$"'%(%#%-$/(&"#"$%&%#'(10(#%'91-:()%7.+%;[((
E#'%$-"'%)( +1#'-15( 17%-( 'X%( %#7.-1#&%#'"5( ;,WW1-'( ,#.';3(
9X.+X(-%W-%;%#'('X%(5"-$%-(;X"-%(10(%#%-$/(+1#;,&W61#Y(
Q(M(!>8>2I!I8F(CHG(2GII8(4BHJD(
4H!=JFE82(
*+1W%("#)(41#'%?'`(
FX%(1Zh%+67%;("-%('X%(015519.#$`((
F1(W-17.)%(s%?.Z.5.'/(10('X%(;/;'%&(+1#a$,-"61#('X"'(
"5519;( 01-( 'X%( %";/( .#'-1),+61#( 10( #%9( %5%&%#';( .#(
'X%(&"#"$%)(%#7.-1#&%#'[(
F1(W-17.)%( "(5%7%5(10( "7".5"Z.5.'/('X"'(:%%W;( '1(X.$X%-(
;'"#)"-)(*B>(+1&W5."#+%(-"'%;("#)(9X.+X(+1#'-.Z,'%;(
'1(;/;'%&t;(;'"Z.5.'/("#)(;%+,-.'/[((
F1( -%),+%( +1;'( .#( Z1'X( +"W.'"5( "#)( 1W%-"61#"5( +1;';(
e4>=I_("#)(H=I_f('1(;,WW1-'('X%(Z,;.#%;;(W-%).+"'%;[(
F1(W-17.)%( ;,;'".#"Z.5.'/(Z/( ,;.#$(&%'X1);('1(-%),+%(
%#%-$/(,65.c"61#("#)(+"-Z1#(%&.;;.1#(011'W-.#';Y(
Q(M(!>8>2I!I8F(CHG(2GII8(4BHJD(
4H!=JFE82(
=-1W1;"5("#)(;15,61#;`(
=-1W1;%( "#( 1-$"#.c"61#( 'X%1-/( &1)%5( 01-(
.#'%$-"'%)( &"#"$%&%#'( 10( "( $-%%#( +51,)(
+1&W,6#$(%#7.-1#&%#'Y(
Q(M(!>8>2I!I8F(CHG(2GII8(4BHJD(
4H!=JFE82(
=-1W1;"5("#)(;15,61#;`(
H,-( -%;%"-+X( ")7"#+%;( 'X%( ;'"'%( 10( 'X%( "-'( ";(
015519;`((
E'( .#'-1),+%;( "#( 1-$"#.c"61#( 'X%1-/( &1)%5( 01-(
.#'%$-"'%)(&"#"$%&%#'(10('X%($-%%#(+51,);(Z";%)(1#(
'X%( +1#+%W';( 10( 1-$"#.c"61#( &1)%5;3( #%'91-:(
&"#"$%&%#'3("#)().;'-.Z,'%)(+1&W,6#$[((
E'( "#"5/;%;( 'X%( #%'91-:( "#)( ;/;'%&t;( Z%X"7.1-( "#)(
1W%-"61#"5(W-.#+.W5%;[((
Q(M(!>8>2I!I8F(CHG(2GII8(4BHJD(
4H!=JFE82(
=-1W1;"5("#)(;15,61#;`(
E'( 7"5.)"'%;( 'X%( W-1W1;"5( )%&1#;'-"6#$( 'X%(
;/;'%&t;("))%)M7"5,%(.#("(+";%(;',)/(;+%#"-.1[((
E'(.&W-17%;("(;.&,5"'1-(e'X%(451,)*.&(0-"&%91-:f(
'1( 7"5.)"'%( 'X%( $-%%#( +51,)( +1&W,6#$(
&"#"$%&%#'("WW-1"+XY(
Q(M(!>8>2I!I8F(CHG(2GII8(4BHJD(
4H!=JFE82(
=-1W1;"5("#)(;15,61#;`(
K";(&1)%5%)('X%(;/;'%&(,;.#$(81-&;(e8!f3(R%5.%0;(
eRBf("#)(=5"#(G,5%;(e=Gf3(.#0%--.#$('X"'(9%(91,5)(#%%)(
e8!f('1(-%),+%(%#%-$/(+1#;,&W61#3(-%),+%('X%(+1;';(
10('X%(+51,)("#)(&".#'".#("(&.#.&"5.;'(;'-,+',-%Y(
Q(M(!>8>2I!I8F(CHG(2GII8(4BHJD(
4H!=JFE82(
41#+5,;.1#`(
FX%(H-$"#.c"61#('X%1-/(&1)%5(9";(W-1W1;%)[(
FX%(41#+%W';(-%5"'%)('1(+51,)(+1&W,6#$("#)($-%%#(
+51,)(+1&W,6#$(9%-%(W-%;%#'%)[(
F%;';(9%-%(-%"5.c%)('1(W-17%('X%(7"5.).'/(10('X%(;/;'%&(
Z/(,65.c.#$(451,)*.&(;.&,5"'1-Y(
PU(M(G>DEH(B>\IG(H=IG>FEH8(E8(
4H28EFE]I(8IFKHGL*(
>Y(*+1W%("#)(41#'%?'[(
RY(=-1W1;"5;("#)(;15,61#;[(
4Y(41#+5,;.1#("#)(0,',-%(91-:;Y(
PU(M(G>DEH(B>\IG(H=IG>FEH8(E8(
4H28EFE]I(8IFKHGL*(
*+1W%("#)(41#'%?'`(
*+X%&"('1(+5";;.0/('X%(;.$#"5(10(Z"#)(1+,W"61#[(
B.;'(10(0,#+61#"5.6%;(10(.#01-&"61#("#)(
1W%-"61#;[(
I7"5,"'%('X%(%?W-%;;.7.'/(10(W-1W1;%)(;+X%&"Y(
PU(M(G>DEH(B>\IG(H=IG>FEH8(E8(
4H28EFE]I(8IFKHGL*(
*+1W%("#)(41#'%?'`(
FX%( .#+-%";%( .#( ,;%( 10( 9.-%5%;;( #%'91-:;( 5%)( 'X%(
J*>(C44('1(W,Z5.;X("(-%W1-'(;X19.#$('X"'(W-1Z5%&(
10(;W%+'-,&(;X1-'"$%Y(
"#( %m1-'( X";( Z%%#( +1#),+'%)( .#( 1-)%-( '1( 'X"'(
,#5.+%#;%)( ,;%-;( +1,5)( ,;%( 'X%( ;W%+'-,&( "5-%")/(
";;.$#%)('1(5.+%#;%)(,;%-;Y(
PU(M(G>DEH(B>\IG(H=IG>FEH8(E8(
4H28EFE]I(8IFKHGL*(
*+1W%("#)(41#'%?'`(
K%(&,;'(";;,-%(+1$#.67%(+"W"Z.5.'/("#)(-%M
+1#a$,-"Z.5.'/Y(
FX%-%("-%('91('/W%;(10(;W%+'-,&("9"-%#%;;`((
=";;.7%[((
>+67%Y(
PU(M(G>DEH(B>\IG(H=IG>FEH8(E8(
4H28EFE]I(8IFKHGL*(
=-1W1;"5;("#)(;15,61#;`(
*W%+'-,&(;.$#"5(;%#;.#$(M('X%(+1$#.67%(-").1(&,;'(
Z%("Z5%('1(W%-01-&(=J()%'%+61#3( ;%#;.#$( +1#'-15(
"#)3(.#(+11W%-"67%(&1)%3(+11W%-"61#Y(
*W%+'-,&( &"#"$%&%#'( M( -%A,.-%;( 'X-%%( &".#(
";W%+';('1(Z%(;,++%;;0,5(`((
;W%+'-,&(4X"-"+'%-.c"61#[(
;W%+'-,&(;%5%+61#([(
G%+1#a$,-"61#Y(
PU(M(G>DEH(B>\IG(H=IG>FEH8(E8(
4H28EFE]I(8IFKHGL*(
=-1W1;"5;("#)(;15,61#;`(
*W%+'-,&( ;X"-.#$(M(;'%&;( 0-1&( 'X%( #%%)( .#( W-%7%#6#$3(
&,56W5%( 4G( #%'91-:;( +155.).#$( .#( ;W%+'-,&( 17%-5"WW.#$(
W1-61#Y( FX.;( +1#+%W'( .;( )%'".5%)( "#)( ;,Z).7.)%)( .#( .#'-"M
#%'91-:(;W%+'-,&(;X"-.#$("#)(.#'%-#%'91-:Y(
*W%+'-,&(&1Z.5.'/(M(($.7%;(-.;%("(#%9('/W%(10(X"#)1m(.#(4G(
#%'91-:3( 'X%( ;1M+"55%)( ;W%+'-,&( X"#)1mY( FX.;( '-"#;0%-(
1++,-;(.#('X-%%( ;.',"61#;`( =J( )%'%+61#3( +1##%+61#( 51;'(
),%( '1( &1Z.5.'/( 10( ,;%-;( .#7157%)( .#( +1&&,#.+"61#( 1-(
;W%+'-,&(Z"#)(+"#(#1'(&%%'(b1*(-%A,.-%&%#';Y(
PU(M(G>DEH(B>\IG(H=IG>FEH8(E8(
4H28EFE]I(8IFKHGL*(
=-1W1;"5;("#)(;15,61#;`(
FX%( W-1W1;%)( 0-"&%91-:( &,;'( Z%( "Z5%( '1( 1m%-(
'X%( 015519.#$( 0%"',-%;`( =J( )%'%+61#3( +X"##%5(
+5";;.a+"61#3( +X"##%5( ;%5%+61#( r( Z"#)9.)'X(
;%w#$3( &1),5"61#( ;%5%+61#3( 1Z;%-7"61#( 6&%(
;%w#$3( '-"#;&.;;.1#( 6&%( ;%w#$3( W19%-( ;%w#$3(
%;'"Z5.;X( "( ;%#;.#$( 'X-%;X15)3( ;.$#"5M'1M#1.;%(
"9"-%#%;;3( A,"5.'/( 10( )%'%+61#( "9"-%#%;;( "#)(
Z"#)9.)'X("9"-%#%;;Y(
PU(M(G>DEH(B>\IG(H=IG>FEH8(E8(
4H28EFE]I(8IFKHGL*(
41#+5,;.1#("#)(0,',-%(91-:;`(
I715,61#(10(+1$#.67%(-").1;("#)(#%'91-:;(
( 0-"&%91-:( +1&W1;%)( Z/( "( ;+X%&"( 01-( ;%#;.#$( ;.$#"5(
"#)(+5";;.0/('X%(;W%+'-,&Y(
C1-(0,',-%(91-:;3(9%(9.55(01+,;(1,-(%m1-';(1#('X%(
-%;%"-+X( +X"55%#$%;( '1( )%;+-.Z%;( 1W6&.c"61#( 10(
+11W%-"67%(;%#;.#$(";("(#%%)(01-(.&W-17%&%#'(10(
'X%(+1$#.67%(#%'91-:;Y(
PP(M(41#+5,;.1#;(
K";( W-%;%#'%)( ;1&%( 10( 'X%( &"h1-(
+1#'-.Z,61#;( 1,-( 91-:( $-1,W( X";( 1m%-%)( .#(
'X%(5";'(0%9(/%"-;(5.:%Y(>-%('X%;%`(
FX%( 91-:( p>( *%+,-.'/( C-"&%91-:( 01-( E#W,'(
]"5.)"61#q[(
FX%( 91-:( pE#'-,;.1#( D%'%+61#( 01-( 41&W,'"61#"5(
2-.);q[(
FX%(91-:(pE#'-,;.1#(D%'%+61#(01-(2-.)("#)(451,)[(
41&W,6#$qY(
PP(M(41#+5,;.1#;(
FX%( 91-:( p>( *B>( =%-;W%+67%( .#( *%+,-.'/(
!"#"$%&%#'(01-(451,)(41&W,6#$q[(
FX%( 91-:( p4,;'1&%-( *%+,-.'/( 41#+%-#;( .#( 451,)(
41&W,6#$q[(
FX%( 91-:( p>( 451,)( 41&W,6#$( *15,61#( 01-(
="6%#'v;( D"'"( 4155%+61#( .#( @%"5'X( 4"-%(
E#;6',61#;qY(
PP(M(41#+5,;.1#;(
FX%( 91-:( pI?W%-.&%#'"5( >;;%;;&%#'( 10( G1,6#$(
01-(2-.)("#)(451,)q[(
FX%( 91-:( p*.&,5"'1-( E&W-17%&%#';( '1( ]"5.)"'%(
'X%(2-%%#(451,)(41&W,6#$(>WW-1"+Xq[(
FX%(91-:(p>(0-"&%91-:('1(G").1(B"/%-(HW%-"61#(
.#(41$#.67%(8%'91-:;qY(
ResearchGate has not been able to resolve any citations for this publication.
ResearchGate has not been able to resolve any references for this publication.