Article

Multi-valued versus single-valued large-amplitude bending-torsional–rotational coordinate systems for simultaneously treating trans-bent and cis-bent acetylene in its S1 state

Authors:
To read the full-text of this research, you can request a copy directly from the author.

Abstract

There are now a large number of papers in the spectroscopic literature which make use of multiple-valued (frequently double-valued) coordinate systems and the associated multiple-groups of the permutation-inversion group to deal with the symmetry properties of large-amplitude motions in molecules of high symmetry. The use of multiple-valued coordinate systems, and the resultant appearance of more minima on the potential surface than would be found on the surface for a single-valued coordinate system, can lead to conceptual confusion and questions of mathematical legitimacy. In the present paper we demonstrate that treatments using multiple-valued coordinate systems simply represent one scheme for applying the appropriate quantum mechanical boundary conditions to Schrödinger’s partial differential equation defined in a single-valued coordinate system. The demonstration is not general, but rather focuses on the specific example of the S1 electronic state of C2H2, which has local minima only for nonlinear configurations, and on the twofold and eightfold extended permutation–inversion groups recently introduced to simultaneously treat symmetry questions in trans-bent and cis-bent acetylene. Some discussion of the mathematical convenience lost by using a single-valued coordinate system is also presented.

No full-text available

Request Full-text Paper PDF

To read the full-text of this research,
you can request a copy directly from the author.

Article
3-Ethynylquinoline was subjected to a Sonogashira-Hagihara reaction with methyl 2-, 3-, and 4-bromobenzoates, respectively, and then N-methylated to give 3-[(-(methoxycarbonyl)phenyl)ethynyl]-1-methylquinolinium salts (two X-ray analyses). On saponification of the 3- and 4-substituted benzoates, the mesomeric betaines 3- and 4-[(1-methylquinolinium-3-yl)ethynyl] benzoates were formed. By contrast, the 2-benzoate derivative gave either the corresponding (1-oxo-1H-isochromen-3-yl)quinolinium derivative, or the mesomeric betaine 2-(1-methylquinolinium-3-yl)-1,3-dioxo-2,3-dihydro-1H-inden-2-ide depending on the reaction conditions. A DFT calculation predicts a transoid conformation of the acetylene bond in the intermediate 2-[(1-methylquinolinium-3-yl)ethynyl]benzoate which is due to a strong hydrogen bond between the carboxylate group and 2-H of the quinolinium ring, in addition to a 1,5-interaction between the carboxylate group and the CC triple bond. The bond angles of the transoid CC triple bond were calculated to be 211.6 degrees and -175.1 degrees in vacuo. The corresponding linear triple bond is 50.4 kJ/mol less stable in vacuo according to the calculation, and the N-heterocyclic carbene quinoline-2-ylidene is not formed as a tautomer.
Article
The bending and torsional degrees of freedom in S1 acetylene, C2H2, are subject to strong vibrational resonances and rovibrational interactions, which create complex vibrational polyad structures even at low energy. As the internal energy approaches that of the barrier to cis-trans isomerization, these energy level patterns undergo further large-scale reorganization that cannot be satisfactorily treated by traditional models tied to local minima of the potential energy surface for nuclear motion. Experimental spectra in the region near the cis-trans transition state have revealed these complicated new patterns. In order to understand near-barrier spectroscopic observations and to predict the detailed effects of cis-trans isomerization on the rovibrational energy level structure, we have performed reduced dimension rovibrational variational calculations of the S1 state. In this paper, we present the methodological details, several of which require special care. Our calculation uses a high accuracy ab initio potential surface and a fully symmetrized extended complete nuclear permutation inversion group theoretical treatment of a multivalued internal coordinate system that is appropriate for large amplitude bending and torsional motions. We also discuss the details of the rovibrational basis functions and their symmetrization, as well as the use of a constrained reduced dimension rovibrational kinetic energy operator.
Article
Recent theoretical developments that facilitate characterization of excited‐state potential energy surfaces are applied to study five stationary points on the S1 surface of C2H2. Although previous calculations have focused on the acetylenic trans and cis forms, the present research predicts that the vinylidene isomer is the global minimum on the potential surface. However, a high activation barrier calculated for rearrangement to the trans isomer suggests that S1 vinylidene is not likely to be formed via photoexcitation of ground‐state acetylene. The trans and cis acetylenic forms of the S1 state are shown to interconvert along an in‐plane reaction coordinate with an activation energy of ∼4000 cm−1, a value which is significantly lower than usually assumed in spectroscopic analyses.
Article
The electronic ground state potential surface of acetylene (HCCH) has a minimum at the linear conformation, but the excited electronic states may have potential minima at a variety of nonlinear equilibrium shapes. This work is concerned with the group theoretical ideas necessary to treat simultaneously the symmetry properties of rovibronic states associated with three different planar acetylene equilibrium configurations, namely trans bent acetylene, cis bent acetylene, and vinylidene (H2CC). We make use of three different kinds of groups: (i) point groups, (ii) permutation-inversion (PI) groups, and (iii) extended PI groups. The PI group is G4 or G8, depending on whether CH bond breaking is impossible (no bent acetylene vinylidene interconversion) or possible. The extended PI groups are G4(2) and G8(2), respectively, when the only large amplitude motions are the CCH bends at each end of the molecule, and G4(8) and G8(8), respectively, when internal rotation is added as a third large amplitude motion. Applied to acetylene, the results indicate that there will be no splittings of the rovibronic levels unless CH bond breaking occurs. Even without bond breaking, however, states of the cis and trans isomers just below their interconversion barrier will show "staggerings" in their K-structures, i.e., a given vibrational level will have three tunneling components at slightly different energies: one component will have levels with K = 4n only (where n is an integer), a second component will have levels with K = 4n + 2 only, and the third will have only odd-K levels. New experimental results for the S1-cis electronic state of acetylene [21] are reviewed, and are found to be consistent with the group theory in so far as comparison is possible.
Article
This article presents permutation–inversion group-theoretical strategies and recipes aimed at helping a high-resolution molecular spectroscopist use the existing pedagogical literature to carry out their own treatment of the basic symmetry questions in rotating molecules with large-amplitude vibrational motions. Topics addressed include: determination of the feasible permutation-inversion group and its symmetry species and character table; a general equation defining coordinates that can describe translation, overall rotation, large-amplitude vibrations and small-amplitude vibrations for a large class of floppy molecules; and the determination of symmetry species for basis functions and selection rules for operators written in these coordinates. The article is intended to be more advanced than existing pedagogical works, but it still leaves many important topics untreated.
Article
Valence-excited singlet (S1,S2) and triplet (T1–T4) states of acetylene have been studied by means of extended multireference electron correlation techniques (MR-CISD, MR-CISD+Q, and MR-AQCC). Extrapolations to the basis set limit have been performed. Minima and saddle points have been calculated using a recently developed analytic gradient method for excited states. Planar as well as nonplanar structures have been considered. In particular, the existence of an asymmetric, planar cis-type minimum on the S2 surface has been confirmed conclusively. Moreover, an intersection S1/S2 has been located close to this minimum. This situation will most probably affect the interpretation of the absorption bands attributed to the trans 1 1Bu state. In-plane and out-of-plane saddle points for cis–trans isomerization have been determined and characterized by harmonic vibrational analysis. Several interesting surface crossings for different electronic states (S1/S2, T2/T3, and S1/T3) have been characterized. Implications of the flatness of the T3 surface around linear structures and the location of the S1/T3 crossing seam on the anomalities observed in the ZAC spectrum of the 1Au state are discussed. © 2003 American Institute of Physics.
Article
The theory of the symmetry properties of the rotational and torsional levels is developed for molecules consisting of two identical XY2 groups connected by a symmetrical linear chain of atoms, with an arbitrary barrier to internal rotation. The levels are classified according to the representations of the double group of the Longuet-Higgins permutation-inversion group, and selection rules for electric dipole transitions are derived. It is shown that the symmetries of the normal coordinates of ethylene-like molecules can be different from those given recently by Papoušek, Sarka, Špirko and Jordanov. The results are applicable to the vibrational spectra of molecules like B2F4 and B2Cl4, which have low barriers to internal rotation in their ground states, and to the vibrational and rotational structure of electronic transitions of C2H4, where the combining electronic states may have very different torsional potential functions.
Article
Isomerization between the cis and trans conformers of the S(1) state of acetylene is studied using a reduced dimension discrete variable representation (DVR) calculation. Existing DVR techniques are combined with a high accuracy potential energy surface and a kinetic energy operator derived from FG theory to yield an effective but simple Hamiltonian for treating large amplitude motions. The spectroscopic signatures of the S(1) isomerization are discussed, with emphasis on the vibrational aspects. The presence of a low barrier to isomerization causes distortion of the trans vibrational level structure and the appearance of nominally electronically forbidden à (1)A(2)←X̃ (1)Σ(g)(+) transitions to vibrational levels of the cis conformer. Both of these effects are modeled in agreement with experimental results, and the underlying mechanisms of tunneling and state mixing are elucidated by use of the calculated vibrational wavefunctions.