Content uploaded by Carlos Becker Westphall
Author content
All content in this area was uploaded by Carlos Becker Westphall
Content may be subject to copyright.
Toward'an'Architecture'for'
Monitoring'Private'Clouds'
!
!
!!
Shirlei'Aparecida'de'Chaves,'Rafael'Brundo'Uriarte,'
Carlos'Becker'Westphall'
!
Networks'and'Management'Laboratory'
Federal'University'of'Santa'Catarina'
DECEMBER'2011' IEEE'COMMUNICATIONS'MAGAZINE' "!
#$%&'()!
"* +,-./+0.!
1* 23./#450.2#3!!
6* ,+078/#534!
6*"*!0&9$:!09;<$=(>!-)?@'A)!B9:)&C!
6*1*!0&9$:!09;<$=(>!4)<&9D;)(%!B9:)&C!
6*6*!0&9$:!09;<$=(>!-%E(:E?:C!
!
!
!
!
!
4F0FB,F/!1G""! 2FFF!0#BB5320+.2#3-!B+8+H23F! 1!
#$%&'()!
I*!B#32.#/238!+/0J2.F0.5/F!+34!K0B#3-!
I*"*!+?AL'%)A%$?)!
I*1*!2;<&);E(%E=9(!
M*!0+-F!-.54N!
O*!/FP+.F4!Q#/7!
O*"*!8?':!B9('%9?'(>!
O*1*!0&9$:!B9('%9?'(>!
4F0FB,F/!1G""! 2FFF!0#BB5320+.2#3-!B+8+H23F! 6!
#$%&'()!
R*!7FN!PF--#3-!PF+/3F4!
R*"*!/)&E%):!%9!.)C%S,):!K?)<E?E=9(!
R*1*!4)C'>(!E(:!2;<&);)(%E=9(!
R*6*!-%E(:E?:'TE=9(!E(:!+@E'&EU&)!2;<&);)(%ES
=9(C!
V*!0#30P5-2#3-!+34!W5.5/F!Q#/7-!
X*!-#BF!/FWF/F30F-!
4F0FB,F/!1G""! 2FFF!0#BB5320+.2#3-!B+8+H23F! I!
"*!+,-./+0.!
.L'C!<?)C)(%E=9(!:)CA?'U)CY!
!S!9$?!)Z<)?')(A)!['%L!E!<?'@E%)!A&9$:\!!
S %L)!:)C'>(!E(:! ';<&);)(%E=9(! 9]! E! K?'@E%)!
0&9$:!B#3'%9?'(>!-DC%);!^K0B#3-_\!E(:!
S '%C! E<<&'AE=9(! @'E! E! AEC)! ! C%$:D!]9?!%L)!
<?9<9C):! E?AL'%)A%$?)`! $C'(>!9<)(!C9$?A)!
C9&$=9(C!E(:!'(%)>?E=(>!['%L!%?E:'=9(E&!%99&C!
&'a)!3E>'9C*!
4F0FB,F/!1G""! 2FFF!0#BB5320+.2#3-!B+8+H23F! M!
1*!23./#450.2#3!
S 0&9$:! A9;<$=(>! <?9@':)C! C)@)?E&! %)AL('AE&!
U)()b%C! '(A&$:'(>! c)Z'U&)!LE?:[E?)!E(:!
C9d[E?)! E&&9AE=9(`! )&EC=A'%D`! E(:!
<)?]9?;E(A)!'C9&E=9(*!
S 0&9$:! ;E(E>);)(%! ;ED! U)! @')[):! EC! E!
C<)A'E&'TE=9(! 9]! :'C%?'U$%):! A9;<$=(>!
;E(E>);)(%`! '(L)?'=(>! %)AL('e$)C! ]?9;!
%?E:'=9(E&!A9;<$%)?!()%[9?a!;E(E>);)(%*!
4F0FB,F/!1G""! 2FFF!0#BB5320+.2#3-!B+8+H23F! O!
1*!23./#450.2#3!
.L)!'(%)(%!9]!%L'C!<?)C)(%E=9(!'C!%9Y!
S K?9@':)!'(C'>L%!'(%9!L9[!%?E:'=9(E&!%99&C!E(:!
;)%L9:C!]9?!;E(E>'(>!()%[9?a!E(:!
:'C%?'U$%):! CDC%);C! AE(! U)! ?)$C):!'(!A&9$:!
A9;<$=(>!;E(E>);)(%*!
S 2(%?9:$A)!E!K?'@E%)!0&9$:!B#3'%9?'(>!-DC%);!
^K0B#3-_! [)! :)@)&9<):! %9! @E&' :E%)! %L'C!
E?AL'%)A%$?)`![L'AL![)!'(%)(:!%9!9<)(!C9$?A)*!
4F0FB,F/!1G""! 2FFF!0#BB5320+.2#3-!B+8+H23F! R!
1*!23./#450.2#3!
S J)&<! ]$%$?)! E:9<%)?C! 9]! A9$&:! A9;<$=(>!
;Ea)! >99:! :)A'C'9(C! 9(! U$'&:'(>! %L)'?!
;9('%9?'(>!CDC%);!'(!%L)!A&9$:*!
S Q)! AL9C)! %9! E::?)CC! <?'@E%)! A&9$:C! U)AE$C)!
%L)D!)(EU&)!)(%)?<?'C)C!%9!?)E<!A&9$:!U)()b%C!
[L'&)! a))<'(>! %L)'?! ;'CC'9(SA?'=AE&! :E%E! E(:!
C9d[E?)! $(:)?! %L)'?! A9(%?9&! E(:! $(:)?! %L)!
>9@)?(E(A)!9]!%L)'?!C)A$?'%D!<9&'A')C*!
4F0FB,F/!1G""! 2FFF!0#BB5320+.2#3-!B+8+H23F! V!
6*!,+078/#534!!
6*"*!0&9$:!09;<$=(>!-)?@'A)!B9:)&C!
S -9d[E?)SECSES-)?@'A)! ^-EE-_Y! .L)! A9(C$;)?!
$C)C! %L)! <?9@':)?fC! E<<&'AE=9(C`! [L'AL! E?)!
L9C%):!'(!%L)!A&9$:*!
S K&Eg9?;SECSES-)?@'A)! ^KEE-_Y! 09(C$;)?C!
:)<&9D! %L)'?! 9[(! E<<&' AE=9( C! '(%9! %L)! A&9$:!
'(]?EC%?$A%$?)*! K?9>?E;;'(>! &E(>$E>)C! E(:!
E<<&'AE=9(C!:)@)&9<;)(%!%99&C!$C):!;$C%!U)!
C$<<9?%):!UD!%L)!<?9@':)?*!
4F0FB,F/!1G""! 2FFF!0#BB5320+.2#3-!B+8+H23F! X!
6*!,+078/#534!!
6*"*!0&9$:!09;<$=(>!-)?@'A)!B9:)&C!
S 2(]?EC%?$A%$?)SECSES-)?@'A)! ^2EE-_Y! 09(C$;)?C!
E?)! EU&)! %9! <?9@'C'9(! C%9?E>)`! () % [ 9 ? a `!
<?9A)CC'(>`! E(:! 9%L)?! ?)C9$?A)C`! E(:! :)<&9D!
E(:!9<)?E%)!E?U?'%?E?D!C9d[E?)`!?E(>'(>!]?9;!
E<<&'AE=9(C!%9!9<)?E=(>!CDC%);C*!
S .L'C!<?)C)%E=9(!]9A$C)C!9(!2EE-!;9:)&*!
4F0FB,F/!1G""! 2FFF!0#BB5320+.2#3-!B+8+H23F! "G!
6*!,+078/#534!!
6*1*!0&9$:!09;<$=(>!4)<&9D;)(%!B9:)&C!
S K$U&'AY!/)C9$?A)C!E?)!E@E'&EU&)!%9!%L)!>)()?E&!
<$U&'A!9@)?!%L)!2(%)?()%*!2(!%L'C!AEC)`!h<$U&'Ai!
ALE?EA%)?'T)C! %L)! CA9<)! 9]!'(%)?]EA)!
EAA)CC'U'&'%D*!
S K?'@E%)Y! /)C9$?A)C! E?)! EAA)CC'U&)! ['%L'(! E!
<?'@E%)! 9?>E('TE=9(*! .L'C! )(@'?9(;)(%!
);<LEC'T)C! %L)! U)()b%C! 9]!LE?:[E?)!
'(@)C%;)(%C*!
4F0FB,F/!1G""! 2FFF!0#BB5320+.2#3-!B+8+H23F! ""!
6*!,+078/#534!!
6*1*!0&9$:!09;<$=(>!4)<&9D;)(%!B9:)&C!
S 09;;$('%DY! /)C9$?A)C! 9(! %L'C! ;9:)&! E?)!
CLE?):! UD! C)@)?E&! 9?>E('TE=9(C! ['%L! E!
A9;;9(!;'CC'9(*!!
S JDU?':Y!.L'C!;9 : )&!;'Z)C!%L)!%)AL('e$)C!]?9;!
<$U&'A!E(:!<?'@E%)!A&9$:C*!+!<?'@E%)!A&9$:!AE(!
LE@)! '%C! &9AE&! '(]?EC%?$A%$?)! C$<<&);)(%):! UD!
A9;<$%)?!AE<EA'%D!]?9;!<$U&'A!A&9$:*!
4F0FB,F/!1G""! 2FFF!0#BB5320+.2#3-!B+8+H23F! "1!
6*!,+078/#534!!
6*6*!0&9$:!09;<$=(>!-%E(:E?:C!
S #<)(! 0&9$:! 09;<$=(>! 2(%)?]EA)Y! .L'C!#<)(!
8?':! W9?$;! >?9$<! LEC!E!]9A$C! 9(!
C<)A'bAE=9(C!]9?!'(%)?]EA'(>!hjEE-i! A&9$:!
A9;<$=(>!]EA'&'=)C*!
S !#002!'(!F$AE&D<%$C`!#002!'(!#<)(-%EAa`!#002!
'(!#<)(3)U$&E***!
4F0FB,F/!1G""! 2FFF!0#BB5320+.2#3-!B+8+H23F! "6!
6*!,+078/#534!!
6*6*!0&9$:!09;<$=(>!-%E(:E?:C!
S #<)(! 0&9$:!-%E(:E?:C!2(A$UE%9?Y! .L'C!
'('=E=@)`! ]?9;! 4'C%?'U$%):! BE(E>);)(%! .ECa!
W9?A)! ^4B.W_`! ]9A$C)C! 9(! '(%)?EA=9(C!
U)%[))(! A&9$:! )(@'?9(;)(%C`! %L)'?!
A9(C$;)?C`!E(:!:)@)&9<)?C*!
S FZE;<&)! 9]! :9A$;)(%Y! h5C)! AEC)C! E(:!
2(%)?EA=9(C!]9?!BE(E>'(>!0&9$:Ci*!
!
4F0FB,F/!1G""! 2FFF!0#BB5320+.2#3-!B+8+H23F! "I!
I*!B#32.#/238!+/0J2.F0.5/F!+34!K0B#3-!!
4F0FB,F/!1G""! 2FFF!0#BB5320+.2#3-!B+8+H23F! "M!
I*!B#32.#/238!+/0J2.F0.5/F!+34!K0B#3-!!
I*"*!+?AL'%)A%$?)!
S!.L?))!&ED)?C!E::?)CC!%L)!;9('%9?'(>!()):C!9]!E!
<?'@E%)!A&9$:*!!
2(]?EC%?$A%$?)!&ED)?Y!
S ,EC'A!]EA'&'=)C`!C)?@'A)C`!E(:!'(C%E&&E=9(C`!C$AL!
EC!LE?:[E?)!E(:!()%[9?aC\!
S +@E'&EU&)!C9d[E?)Y!9<)?E=(>!CDC%);`!
E<<&'AE=9(C`!&'A)(C)C`!LD<)?@'C9?C`!E(:!C9!9(***!
4F0FB,F/!1G""! 2FFF!0#BB5320+.2#3-!B+8+H23F! "O!
I*!B#32.#/238!+/0J2.F0.5/F!+34!K0B#3-!!
I*"*!+?AL'%)A%$?)!
2(%)>?E=9(!&ED)?Y!
S .L)!;9('%9?'(>!EA=9(C!%9!U)!<)?]9?;):!'(!%L)!
'(]?EC%?$A%$?)! &ED)?!;$C%!U)! CDC%);E=T):!
U)]9?)! <ECC):! %9! %L)! E<<?9<?'E%)! C)?@'A)!
?$(('(>!'(!%L)!'(%)>?E=9(!&ED)?*!
S .L)! '(%)>?E=9(! &ED)?! 'C! ?)C<9(C'U&)!]9?!
EUC%?EA=(>!E(D!'(]?EC%?$A%$?)!:)%E'&C*!
4F0FB,F/!1G""! 2FFF!0#BB5320+.2#3-!B+8+H23F! "R!
I*!B#32.#/238!+/0J2.F0.5/F!+34!K0B#3-!!
I*"*!+?AL'%)A%$?)!
k')[!&ED)?Y!
S .L'C!&ED)?!<?)C)(%C!EC!%L)!;9('%9?'(>!'(%)?]EA)!
%L?9$>L! [L'AL! '(]9?;E=9(`! C$AL!EC!%L)!
]$&b&&;)(%! 9]! 9?>E('TE=9(E&!<9&'A')C!E(:!
C)?@'A)!&)@)&!E>?));)(%C`!AE(!U)!E(E&DT):*!
S 5C)?C! 9]! %L'C! &ED)?! E?)! ;E'(&D! '(%)?)C%):!'(!
AL)Aa'(>! kB! ';E>)C! E(: ! E@E'&EU& )! C)?@'A)!
&)@)&C*!!
4F0FB,F/!1G""! 2FFF!0#BB5320+.2#3-!B+8+H23F! "V!
I*!B#32.#/238!+/0J2.F0.5/F!+34!K0B#3-!!
I*1*!2;<&);)(%E=9(!!
S .L)! A$??)(%! K0B#3-! @)?C'9(! EA%C! <?'(A'<E&D!
9(! %L)! '(%)>?E=9(! &ED)?`! UD! ?)%?')@'(>`!
>E%L)?'(>`!E(:!<?)<E?'(>!?)&)@E(%!'(]9?;E=9( !
]9?!%L)!@'C$E&'TE=9(!&ED)?*!
S .L)! CDC%);! 'C! :'@':):! '(%9! %L)!;9:$&)C!
<?)C)(%):!'(!%L)! ()Z%!b>$?)!E( :! :)CA?'U):!
U)&9[*!
4F0FB,F/!1G""! 2FFF!0#BB5320+.2#3-!B+8+H23F! "X!
+!%D<'AE&!:)<&9D;)(%!CA)(E?'9!]9?!K0B#3-!!
4F0FB,F/!1G""! 2FFF!0#BB5320+.2#3-!B+8+H23F! 1G!
I*!B#32.#/238!+/0J2.F0.5/F!+34!K0B#3-!!!
I*1!2;<&);)(%E=9(!
S 39:)! 2(]9?;E=9(! 8E%L)?)?Y! .L'C!;9:$&)!'C!
?)C<9(C'U& )!]9?!>E%L)?'(>!&9AE&!'(]9?;E=9(!9(!
E! A&9$:!(9:)*!2%! >E%L)?C! '(]9?;E=9(! EU9$%!
&9AE&! kBC! E(:! C)(:C! ' %! %9! %L)! 0&$C%)?! 4E%E!
2(%)>?E%9?*!
S 0&$C%)?! 4E%E! 2(%)>?E%9?Y! 2%! 'C! E! C<)A'bA! E>)(%!!
%LE%! >)%L)?C! E(:! <?)<E?)C! %L)! :E%E! ]9?! %L)!
()Z%!&)@)&*!!!!!
!
4F0FB,F/!1G""! 2FFF!0#BB5320+.2#3-!B+8+H23F! 1"!
I*!B#32.#/238!+/0J2.F0.5/F!+34!K0B#3-!!!
I*1!2;<&);)(%E=9(!
S B9(' %9?'(>!4E%E!2(%)>?E%9?Y! 8E%L)?C! E(:!
C%9?)C!A&9$:!:E%E!'(!%L )!: E%EUEC)!]9?!L'C%9?'AE&!
<$?<9C)C`! E(:! <?9@':)C! C$AL! :E%E! %9! %L)!
09(b>$?E=9(!8)()?E%9?*!
S kB! B9('%9?Y! .L'C!;9:$&)!'(l)A%C! CA?'<%C! '(%9!
%L)!kBC!%LE%!C)(:!$C)]$&!:E%E!]?9;!%L)!kB!%9!
%L)!;9('%9?'(>!CDC%);*!!!!!
!
4F0FB,F/!1G""! 2FFF!0#BB5320+.2#3-!B+8+H23F! 11!
I*!B#32.#/238!+/0J2.F0.5/F!+34!K0B#3-!!!
I*1!2;<&);)(%E=9(!
S 09(b>$?E=9(! 8)()?E%9?Y! /)%?')@)C!
'(]9?;E=9(! ]?9;! %L)! :E%EUEC)! %9! >)()?E%)!
A9(b>$?E=9(!b&)C!]9?!@'C$E&'TE=9(!%99&C*!
S B9('%9?'(>!.99&!-)?@)?Y!2%C! <$?<9C)! 'C! %9!
?)A)'@)! ;9('%9?'(>! '(]9?;E=9(! E(:! %Ea)!
EA=9(C! C$AL! EC! C%9?'(>! '%! '(! %L)! :E%EUEC)!
;9:$&)!]9?!L'C%9?'AE&!<$?<9C)C*!!!!!
!
4F0FB,F/!1G""! 2FFF!0#BB5320+.2#3-!B+8+H23F! 16!
I*!B#32.#/238!+/0J2.F0.5/F!+34!K0B#3-!!!
I*1!2;<&);)(%E=9(!
S .L)! B9(' %9=(>!.99&!-)?@)?! >)()?)%)C! E!
A9(b>$?E=9(!b&)!%LE%! E&&9[C! 3E>'9(C! %9!
;9('%9?! E(:!:'C<&ED!%L)! ;9('%9?'(>!
'(]9?;E=9(!'(!'%C!C%E(:E?:!'(%)?]EA)*!
S F$AE&D<%$C!<?9@':)C!E!C';<&)!3E>'9C!CA?'<%!]9?!
UEC'A!;9('%9?'(>!9]!F$AE&D<%$C!A9;<9()(%C*!!!
!
4F0FB,F/!1G""! 2FFF!0#BB5320+.2#3-!B+8+H23F! 1I!
I*!B#32.#/238!+/0J2.F0.5/F!+34!K0B#3-!!!
I*1!2;<&);)(%E=9(!
S 5C)?! 2(%)?]EA)Y! B9C%! ;9('%9?'(>! %99&C! LE@)!
%L)'?!9[(!$C)?!'(%)?]EA)*!-<)A'bA!9()C!AE(!U)!
:)@)&9<):! :)<)(:'(>! 9(! ()):C`! U$%!'(!9$?!
AEC)!%L)!3E>'9C!'(%)?]EA)!'C!C$mA')(%*!
S 4E%EUEC)Y! -%9?)C! :E%E! ()):):! UD!
09(b>$?E=9(! 8)()?E%9?! E(:! %L)! B9('%9?'(>!
4E%E!2(%)>?E%9?*!!!!!
!
4F0FB,F/!1G""! 2FFF!0#BB5320+.2#3-!B+8+H23F! 1M!
M*!0+-F!-.54N !!
S Q)!U$'&%!E(!)(@'?9(;)(%![L)?)!kB!';E>)C!
E?)!E@E'&EU&)!]9?!$C)?C!%LE%!'(C%E(=E%)!E![)U!
C)?@)?`!%L$C!C';$&E=(>![)U!L9C=(>!C)?@'A)!
<?9@'C'9(*!
S 2(C%E(=E%):!kBC!E?)!P'($Z!C)?@)?C!<?9@':'(>!E!
UEC'A!C)%!9]!%99&C`!EA=(>!EC![)U!L9C=(>!
C)?@)?C*!
S +<EAL)!Q)U!-)?@)?`!KJK!&E(>$E>)`!-nP'%)*!
4F0FB,F/!1G""! 2FFF!0#BB5320+.2#3-!B+8+H23F! 1O!
.)C%U):!)(@'?9(;)(%!!
4F0FB,F/!1G""! 2FFF!0#BB5320+.2#3-!B+8+H23F! 1R!
M*!0+-F!-.54N !!!
S #<)(! -5-F! [EC! AL9C)(! EC! %L)! 9<)?E=(>!
CDC%);! 9]! %L)! <LDC'AE&! ;EAL'()C!^o)(! E(:!
NE-._*!
S F$AE&D<%$C!^'(%)?]EA)!A9;<E=U&)! ['%L!
+;ET9(fC!F01_*!kB!';E>)C![)?)!:9[(& 9E: ):!
]?9;!%L)!F$AE&D<%$C![)UC'%)*!
S kB! B9('%9?! ;9:$&)! 'C! '(l)A%)A! '(%9! %L)! kB!
:$?'(>!U99%`!E&&9['(>!:E%E!;9('%9?'(>*!
!
4F0FB,F/!1G""! 2FFF!0#BB5320+.2#3-!B+8+H23F! 1V!
/)<?)C)(%E=@)!3E>'9C!'(%)?]EA)!!
9]!%L)!;9('%9?):!A&9$:!C)?@'A)C!!
4F0FB,F/!1G""! 2FFF!0#BB5320+.2#3-!B+8+H23F! 1X!
M*!0+-F!-.54N !!!
S W'?C%!A9&$;(!CL9[C!9Ul)A%!(E;)C!^kB`!KB`!
/#5.F/-***_*!kB!(E;)C!E?)!E(!E>>?)>E=9(!9]!
$C)?!(E;)`!kB!24`!E(:!(E;)!9]!KB![L)?)!%L)!
kB!'C!?$(('(>*!
S .L)!9%L)?!%[9!A9&$;(C!CL9[!C)?@'A)!(E;)C!
E(:!%L)'?!C%E%$C!^#7`!QE?('(>`!0?'=AE&_*!
S 2%!CL9[C!L9C%!>?9$<!A?)E%):!UD!K0B#3-!E(:!
kBpkK!;E<<'(>*!!
!
4F0FB,F/!1G""! 2FFF!0#BB5320+.2#3-!B+8+H23F! 6G!
O*!/FP+.F4!Q#/7!!!
O*"*!8?':!B9('%9?'(>!
S /)])?)(A)!qRr!'(%?9:$A)C!%L)!!%L?))S&ED)?!8?':!
/)C9$?A)!2(]9?;E=9(!B9('%9?'(>!^8/2B_*!
S -)@)?E&!:)C'>(!'CC$)C! %LE%! CL9$&:! U)!
A9(C':)?):! [L)(! A9(C%?$A=(>!E!8?':!
B9('%9?'(>!-DC%);!^8B-_!E?)!<?))(%):!'(!qVr*!
Q)! LE@)! C)&)A%):!C9;)!E(:! A9??)&E%):! %L);!
['%L!K0B#B-*!
!
4F0FB,F/!1G""! 2FFF!0#BB5320+.2#3-!B+8+H23F! 6"!
O*!/FP+.F4!Q#/7!!!
O*"*!8?':!B9('%9?'(>!
S /)])?)(A)!qXr!':)(=b)C!C9;)!:'s)?)(A)C!
U)%[))(! A&9$:! ;9('%9?'(>! E(:!>?':!
;9('%9?'(>`! )C<)A'E&&D!'(!%)?;)C! 9]! '(%)?]EA)C!
E(:!C)?@'A)!<?9@'C'9('(>*!
S +(9%L)?!:'])?)(A)!'C!%LE%!A&9$:C!E?)!;E(E>):!
UD!C'(>&)!)(==)C!q"Gr`![L)?)EC!>?':C!;ED!(9%!
LE@)!E(D!A)(%?E&!;E(E>);)(%!)(=%D*!
!
4F0FB,F/!1G""! 2FFF!0#BB5320+.2#3-!B+8+H23F! 61!
O*!/FP+.F4!Q#/7!!!
O*1*!0&9$:!B9('%9?'(>!
S /)])?)(A)!q""r!:)b()C!>)()?E&! ?)e$'?);)(%C!
]9?! A&9$:! ;9('%9?'(>! E(:! <?9<9C)C! E! A&9$:!
;9('%9?'(>!]?E;)[9?a*!
S K0B#3-!!C$< <9?%C!%[9!E<<?9AL)C`!E>)(%C!E(:!
A)(%?E&! ;9('%9?'(>`! E(:! 'C! L'>L&D! E:E<%EU&)`!
;Ea'(>! %L)! ;'>?E=9(! %9!E!<?'@'%)! A&9$:!
C%?E'>L]9?[E?:*!
!
4F0FB,F/!1G""! 2FFF!0#BB5320+.2#3-!B+8+H23F! 66!
R*!7FN!PF--#3-!PF+/3F4!!!
R*"*!/)&E%):!%9!.)C%S,):!K?)<E?E=9(!
S -9d[E?)!<&Eg9?;C!]9?!A&9$:!A9;<$=(>`!C$AL!
EC! F$AE&D<%$C! E(:! #<)(3)U$&E`! C$<<9?%! E!
($;U)?!9]!:'s)?)(%!LD<)?@'C9?C`!)EAL!['%L!'%C!
9[(!ALE?EA%)?'C=AC*!
S +(!)ZE;<&)!'C!%L )!7kB!LD<)?@'C9?Y!'%!LEC!>?)E%!
<)?]9?;E(A)! U$%! ?)e$'?)C!LE?:[E?)!
@'?%$E&'TE=9(!%LE%!(9%!E&&!<?9A)CC9?C!<?9@':)*!!
!
4F0FB,F/!1G""! 2FFF!0#BB5320+.2#3-!B+8+H23F! 6I!
R*!7FN!PF--#3-!PF+/3F4!!!
R*1*!4)C'>(!E(:!2;<&);)(%E=9(!
S Q)!9<%):!]9?!C9&$=9(C![)&&!)C%EU&' CL):!'(!%L)!
;E?a)%!%9!]EA'&E%E%)!%L)!$C)!9]!K0B#3-!'(!%L )!
?$(('(>! C%?$A%$?)C! ['%L! &'t&)! )s9?%! E(:!
<?'9?'=T):! E(! E:E<%EU&)! E(:! )Z%)(C'U&)!
C9&$=9(*!
S Q)! <&E(():! %9!:)b()!C9;)!UEC'A!A9;;9(!
;)%?'AC!]9?!<?'@E%)!A&9$:C`!U$%!&E%)?!]9$(:!%LE%!
;)%?'AC!E?)!9d)(!C<)A'bA!%9!)EAL!AEC)*!!
!
4F0FB,F/!1G""! 2FFF!0#BB5320+.2#3-!B+8+H23F! 6M!
R*!7FN!PF--#3-!PF+/3F4!!!
R*6*!-%E(:E?:'TE=9(!E(:!+@E'&EU&)!2;<&);)(%ES
=9(C!
S ,)]9?)! AL99C'(>! E! C<)A'bA! %99&! ]9?! <?'@E%)!
A&9$:C`!'%!'C!';<9?%E(%!%9!@)?']D!%9![LE%!)Z%)(%!
A&9$:!C%E(:E?:C!E?)!';<&);)(%):!UD!%L)!%99&*!
S -9;)!%99&C`!C$AL!EC!#<)(3)U$&E`!LE@)!U)>$(!
';<&);)(=(>! C%E(:E?:'TE=9(! )s9?%C`!
'(A&$:'(>!%L)!#002!+K2*!
!
4F0FB,F/!1G""! 2FFF!0#BB5320+.2#3-!B+8+H23F! 6O!
V*!0#30P5-2#3!+34!!W5.5/F!Q#/7!!
S .L'C! <?)C)(%E=9(! C$;;E?'T)C!C9;)!A&9$:!
A9;<$=(>! A9(A)<%C! E(:! 9$?! <)?C9(E&!
)Z<)?')(A)!['%L!%L'C!()[!<E?E:'>;*!
S .L)!A$??)(%!<9?g9&'9!9]!9<)(!%99&C!&EAaC!9<)(!
C9$?A)`! '(%)?9<)?EU&)!;E(E>);)(%!E(:!
;9('%9?'(>! %99&C*! .9! E::?)CC! %L'C! A?'=AE&! >E<`!
[)! :)C'>():! E! ;9('%9?'(>! E?AL'%)A%$?)`! E(:!
@E&':E:)! %L)! E?AL'%)A%$?)! UD! :)@)&9<'(>!
K0B#3-*!
4F0FB,F/!1G""! 2FFF!0#BB5320+.2#3-!B+8+H23F! 6R!
V*!0#30P5-2#3!+34!!W5.5/F!Q#/7!!
S .9! ;9('%9?! C<)A'bA! ;)%?'AC`! )C<)A'E&&D!'(!E(!
'(%)?]EA)S'(:)<)(:)(%! ;E(()?`! E! C ) % ! 9]!
<?)A9(b>$?):! ;9('%9?'(>! <&$>S' (C! ;$C%! U)!
:)@)&9<):*!
S W9?! ]$%$?)! [9?a`! [)! '(%)(:! %9!';<?9@)!
K0B#3-!%9!!;9('%9?!9%L)?!;)%?'AC!E(:!C$<9?%!
9%L)?!9<)(!C9$?A)! %99&C! &'a)! #<)(3)U$&E`!
#<)(-%EAa***!
!!
!
4F0FB,F/!1G""! 2FFF!0#BB5320+.2#3-!B+8+H23F! 6V!
X*!/FWF/F30F-!!
/)])?)(A)C!'(:'AE%):!'(!%L'C!<?)C)(%E=9(Y!
S qRr!Q*!0L$(>!E(:!/*!0LE(>`!h +!3)[!B)ALE('C;!]9?!
/)C9$?A)! B9('%9?'(>! '(! 8?':! 09;<$=(>`i! W$%$?)!
8)(*!09;<*!-DC*!uE(*!1GGX*!
S qVr! B*! N':$9!)%!E&*`!h/E<':! E(:! +$%9;E%):!
4)<&9D;)(%! 9]! B9('%9?'(>! -)?@'A)C! '(! 8?':!
F(@'?9(;)(%C`i!+K-00`!1GGR*!
S qXr!P*!QE(>!)%!E&*`!h-A')(=bA!0&9$:!09;<$=(>Y!FE?&D!
4)b('=9(! E(:! FZ<)?')(A)`i! 2FFF! 2(%f&*! 09(]*! J'>L!
K)?]*!09;<$=(>!E(:!09;;$(*`!1GGV*!!
!
4F0FB,F/!1G""! 2FFF!0#BB5320+.2#3-!B+8+H23F! 6X!
X*!/FWF/F30F-!!
/)])?)(A)C!'(:'AE%):!'(!%L'C!<?)C)(%E=9(Y!
S q"Gr! B*! ,?9Aa! E(:! +*! 89CA'(Ca'`! h8?':C! @C*! 0&9$:C`i!
2FFF!1G"G!M%L!2(%f&*!09(]*!W$%$?)!2(]9*!.)AL*`!1G"G*!
S q""r! K* ! JECC)&;)D)?! E(:! 3*! :fJ)$?)$C)`! h.9[E?:C!
J9&'C=A! B$&=S.)(E(%! B9('%9?'(>! ]9?! k'?%$E&! 4E%E!
0)(%)?C`i!2FFFp2W2K!3#B-!QaC<C*`!1G"G*!
!
4F0FB,F/!1G""! 2FFF!0#BB5320+.2#3-!B+8+H23F! IG!