Content uploaded by Carlos Becker Westphall
Author content
All content in this area was uploaded by Carlos Becker Westphall
Content may be subject to copyright.
Management(in(legacy(network(
equipment(to(op4mize(green(clouds(
!
!
Sergio(Roberto(Villarreal(and(Carlos(Becker(Westphall(
!
Networks(and(Management(Laboratory(
Federal(University(of(Santa(Catarina(
JANUARY(28TH,(SEVILLE,(SPAIN(( ICN(2013(PANEL:(CHALLENGES(IN(MODERN(NETWORKING( "!
Summary!
"!#!$%&'()*+,(%!
-!.!/012&0)!3('45!
6!.!7'(8(521!
9!.!:250!;&*)<!
=!.!:(%+1*5>(%5!!
?!#!@*&*'0!3('45!
A!#!;(B0!/0C0'0%+05!
DEFGE/H!-IJKL!;MN$OOML!;7E$F!! $:F!-P"6!7EFMOQ!:KEOOMFRM;!$F!STUM/F!FMJ3T/V$FR! -!
"W!$%&'()*+,(%!
#!;&'2&0X>05!&(!>B8'(Y0!)2&2!+0%&0'!0Z+>0%+<!2'0!
*5*211<! [250)! (%! 50'Y0'5L! 8(\0'! 5<5&0B! 2%)!
+((1>%XW!
#! J]0! 010+&'>+21! +(%5*B8,(%! (C! >%&0'+(%%0+,(%!
%0&\('4!]25!%(&!'0+0>Y0)!B*+]!2^0%,(%W!
#!E5!&]0!0Z+>0%+<!(C!8]<5>+21!50'Y0'5!2%)!Y>'&*21!
B2+]>%05! >B8'(Y05L! &]0! 82',+>82,(%! (C! &]0!
%0&\('4![0+(B05!B('0!>B8('&2%&W!
#! ;0 ' Y 0' 5! + ( % 5( 1 > ) 2 ,( %! 2 1 X (' > & ] B 5! X0 % 0 ' 21 1 <!
)>5'0X2')!&]0!+(%5(1>)2,(%!(C!%0&\('4!&'2Z+W!
"!$%&'()*+,(%!
#! 3 ] > 1 0! &] 0! R ' 0 0 %! F 0 & \ ( ' 4> % X! ] 2 5! 8 ' ( 8 ( 5 0 )!
8'>%+>8105!2%)!&0+]%>_*05!&]2&!2'0!&]0! [25 >+!8'>%+>8105!8'(8(50)!
>%! '0+0%&! \('45! C('! 8(\0'! B2%2X0B0%&! >%! 10X2+<!
%0&\('4! 0_*>8B0%&L! 2%)! 8'(8(50)! >&5! 2881> +2,(%! &(!
(8,B>`0!(*'!288'(2+]!&(!X'00%!+1(*)W!
DEFGE/H!-IJKL!;MN$OOML!;7E$F!! $:F!-P"6!7EFMOQ!:KEOOMFRM;!$F!STUM/F!FMJ3T/V$FR! 9!
-!/012&0)!3('45!
#! S2]2)0Y2%! 0&! 21! b-PPcd! 8'050%&! &]0! '05*1&5! (C! 2!
+(B8'0]0%5>Y0! '0502'+]! &(! )0&0'B>%0! &]0!
+(%5*B8,(%! (C! B2e('! %0&\('4! 0_*>8B0%&! >%!
)>f0'0%&!+(%)>,(%5W!!
#!J]0!'0502'+]!)0&0'B>%0)!&]2&!&]0!0%0'X<!+(%5*B0)!
[<! %0&\('4! 0_*>8B0%&! >5! '012,Y01<! >%)080%)0%&! (C!
&]0!Y(1*B0!(C! &'2Z+! 2%)! &]0! 5>`0! (C! &'2%5B>^0)!
82+40&5L! 2%)! )080%)0%&! (%! &]0! 2B(*%&! (C! 2+,Y0!
8('&5!2%)!&]0!5800)!(C!&]050!8('&5!+(%gX*'0)W!
DEFGE/H!-IJKL!;MN$OOML!;7E$F!! $:F!-P"6!7EFMOQ!:KEOOMFRM;!$F!STUM/F!FMJ3T/V$FR! =!
-!/012&0)!3('45!
# ! J]0<! 215(! 8'(8(50! 2! B2&]0B2,+21! 0a8'055>(%! &(!
+21+*12&0! &]0! 0%0'X<! +(%5*B8,(%! >%! %0&\('4!
0_*>8B0%&!\>&]!2!-h!2++*'2+<W!
# ! J]> 5! 0a8'055>(%! ]25! 2! ga0)! +(B8(%0%&! \]>+]! >5! &]0!
+(%5*B8,(%! \>&]! 211! &]0! 8('&5! (f! 2%)! 2! Y2'>2[10!
+(B8(%0%&!&]2&!)080%)5! (%!&]0!2B(*%&!(C!2+,Y0!8('&5!
2%)!>&5!+(%gX*'0)!+282+>&<W!
#! J]0! 0%0'X<! 52Y0)! >5! X'02&0'! \]0%! &]0! 5800)! 51(\5!
)(\%!(C!"!R[85!&(!"PP!S[85L!&]2%!C'(B!"PP!S[85!&(!
"P!S[85W!
!
DEFGE/H!-IJKL!;MN$OOML!;7E$F!! $:F!-P"6!7EFMOQ!:KEOOMFRM;!$F!STUM/F!FMJ3T/V$FR! ?!
-!/012&0)!3('45!
# S2]2)0Y2B! 0&! 21! b-P""dL! +(%,%*>%X! &]0!
\('4! 8'050%&0)! 02'1>0'L! 8*&! &]0! >)02! &]2&!
+(%5*B8,(%! >%! 5\>&+]05! >)0211<! 5](*1) ! [0!
8'(8(',(%21! &(! &]0! &'2Z+! 1(2)L! [*&!C('!
10X2+<!)0Y>+05!>%!'021>&<!>5!_*>&0!)>f0'0%&W!
!
# J]0<! 8'(8(50! &0+]%>_*05! &(! B240! &]0!
+(%5*B8,(%! (C! &]0! %0&\('4! >%! X0%0'21! B('0!
8'(8(',(%21! 2881<>%X! 2Y2> 1 2[ 1 0! 5 0i% X5 ! > % !
10X2+<!)0Y>+05!
-!/012&0)!3('45!
J]0!'05*1&5!2'0!>11*5&'2&0)!>%!&]0!%0a&!gX*'0!
!
#! j7'(8(',(%21! M%0'X<kQ!5](\5!&]0!>)021![0]2Y>('!
>)0%,g0)! \]>+]! +(''058(%)5! &(! 2! %0&\('4! \>&]!
0_*>8B0%&5!&(&211<!jM%0'X<!E\2'0l!
#! j:*''0%&lQ! 5](\5! &]0! 2+&*21! +*'Y0! (C! B(5&! +*''0%&!
%0&\('45L! \]0'0! +(%5*B8,(%! >5! Y>'&*211<! >%)080%)0%&! (C!
1(2)W!
#! lT*'! &0+]%>_*05kQ! 5](\5! &]0! +(%5*B8,(%! +*'Y0!
([&2>%0)![<!2881<>%X!&]0!&0+]%>_*05!8'(8(50)!C('!&]0B!
DEFGE/H!-IJKL!;MN$OOML!;7E$F!! $:F!-P"6!7EFMOQ!:KEOOMFRM;!$F!STUM/F!FMJ3T/V$FR! I!
-!/012&0)!3('45!
DEFGE/H!-IJKL!;MN$OOML!;7E$F!! $:F!-P"6!7EFMOQ!:KEOOMFRM;!$F!STUM/F!FMJ3T/V$FR! c!
M%0'X<!8'(8(',(%21>&<!>%!%0&\('45!#!S2]2)0Y2B!0&!21L!-P""W!$MMM!:(BS2XW!
-!/012&0)!3('45!
• 7'(8(50)!;0i%X5!
– J( !/0)*+0!&]0!5800)!(C! 1(\!* 52X0!5\>&+]05!8('&5W!!
– J(!J*'%!(f!*%*50)!5\>&+]05!8('&5W!!
– J( !U>5+( %%0+&!B() *105!\> &]!21 1!&] 0>'!8('&5!(f W!
– J(!J*'%!(f!*%*50)!5\>&+]05W!
• /05*1 &5!
– 6=h!52Y> %XW!
– A9h!52Y> %X!+(B[ > % 0)!\>&]!50'Y0'!1(2)!+(%5(1> )2,(% W!
-!/012&0)!3('45!
#!30'%0'!0&!21!b-P"-d!8'(8(50!2!5(1*,(%!C('!&]0!
>%&0X'2&0)! +(%&'(1! (C! 50'Y0'5! 2%)! 5<5&0B5! &(!
5*88('&! R'00%! :1(* )! [250)! (%! T'X2%>`2,(%!
J]0('<!S()01!#!TJSW!!
#! J]>5! 288'(2+]! )0g%05! 2! B()01! (C! 211(+2,(%!
2%)! )>5&'>[*,(%! (C! Y>'&*21! B2+]>%05L! Y21>)2&0)!
&]'(*X]! 5>B*12,(%5L! )0B(%5&'2&0)! &(! 2+]> 0Y0!
9Ph! 0%0'X<! 52Y>%X5! +(B82'0)! &(! &'2)>,(%21!
+1(*)!B()01W!
DEFGE/H!-IJKL!;MN$OOML!;7E$F!! $:F!-P"6!7EFMOQ!:KEOOMFRM;!$F!STUM/F!FMJ3T/V$FR! ""!
-!/012&0)!3('45!
#! J]0! 8'(8(50)! B()01! )0&0'B>%05! \]0%! &(!
&*'%! (fL! '05>`0! ('! B>X'2&0! Y>'&*21! B2+]>%0L!
2%)! \]0%! +(%%0+,%X! ('! )>5+(%%0+,%X!
8]<5>+21!B2+]>%05![250)!(%!\('41(2)!2%)!&]0!
'0_*>'0B0%&5!(C!&]0!;OEW!!
#! J]0! %0a&! gX*'0! 5](\5! &]0! 2'+]>&0+&*'0! (C!
&]0! 8'(8(50)! B2%2X0B0%&! 5<5&0BL! \]> +] ! >5!
[250)!(%!%('B5L!'(105L!'*105!2%)![01>0C5W!
!
DEFGE/H!-IJKL!;MN$OOML!;7E$F!! $:F!-P"6!7EFMOQ!:KEOOMFRM;!$F!STUM/F!FMJ3T/V$FR! "-!
-!/012&0)!3('45!
DEFGE/H!-IJKL!;MN$OOML!;7E$F!! $:F!-P"6!7EFMOQ!:KEOOMFRM;!$F!STUM/F!FMJ3T/V$FR! "6!
S2%2X0B0%&!S()01!#!DW!30'%0'L!!RW!EW!R0'(%>B(L!:W!mW!305&8]211!0&!21L!-P"-W!:OM$!MDW!
-!/012&0)!3('45!
@'0>&25!b-P""d!80'C('B0)!0a&0%5>(%5!(C!&]0!
5>B*12&('! :1(*);>B! )0Y01(80)! [<!
:EOKM$/T;! 0&! 21! b-P""dL! 2&! &]0! G%>Y0'5>&<!
(C! S01[(*'%0L! +'02,%X! &]0! %0+0552'<!
+125505!&(!5*88('&!&]0!T'X2%>`2,(%!J] 0('<!
S()01L! 211(\>%X! &(! +21+*12&0! 0%0'X<!
52Y>%X5! 2%)! ;OE! Y>(12,(%5! >%! Y2'>(*5!
5+0%2'>(5W!
DEFGE/H!-IJKL!;MN$OOML!;7E$F!! $:F!-P"6!7EFMOQ!:KEOOMFRM;!$F!STUM/F!FMJ3T/V$FR! "9!
6!7'(8(521!
#!J]0!8'(8(521!+( %5> )0'5!&]0!%0&\('4!&(8(1(X<!
(C! 2! &<8>+21! )2&2+0%&0'! 5](\%! >%! &]0! % 0a&!
gX*'0L! \]0'0! &]0! 5\>&+]05! 2'0! 2''2%X0)! >%! 2!
]>0'2'+]<! (C! &]'00! 12<0'5Q! l:('0kL!
lEXX'0X2,(%kL!2%)!lM)X0jW!!
#! $%! &]>5! +(%gX*'2,(%L! &]0'0! >5! '0)*%)2%+<! >%!
&]0! +(%%0+,(%5! [0&\00%! 12<0'5! 5*+]! &]2&! &]0!
C2>1*'0!(C!(%0!*%>&!)(05!%(&!2f0+&!+(%%0+,Y>&<W!
DEFGE/H!-IJKL!;MN$OOML!;7E$F!! $:F!-P"6!7EFMOQ!:KEOOMFRM;!$F!STUM/F!FMJ3T/V$FR! "=!
6!7'(8(521!
DEFGE/H!-IJKL!;MN$OOML!;7E$F!! $:F!-P"6!7EFMOQ!:KEOOMFRM;!$F!STUM/F!FMJ3T/V$FR! "?!
E!&<8>+21!)2&2+0%&0'!&(8(1(X<!#!S2]2)0Y2B!0&!21L!-P""W!$MMM!:(BS2XW!
6!7'(8(521!
• J (!+'02&0!(*'!B()01!\0!+(%5> )0'0)!&]0!
C(11(\>%X!'*105Q!
!
– M2+] !'2+4!2++(BB()2&05!9P!l"Gk!50'Y0'5!!2%)!
&\(!2++055!12<0'!5\>&+]05!\>&]!9I!"R[85!8('&5!
2%)!&\(!"PR[85!*81>%4!8('&5W!
– M2+] !50'Y0'!]25!&\(!"R[85!%0&\('4!+2')5L!02+]!
+(%%0+&0)!&(!2!)>f0'0%&!5\>&+]!>%!>&5!'2+4W!
6!7'(8(521!
• 30!21 5(!+(%5>)0'0)!&]2&Q!
!
– G8!&(!"-!'2+45!+2%![0!B0&![<!&\(!2XX'0X2,(%!
12<0'!5\>&+]05!\>&]!-9!!"PR[85!8('&5W!
– 3>&]! 1055!&]2% !"-!'2+45!+('0!12<0'!5\>&+]05!2'0!%(&!
%0+0552'<W!
– G8 !&(! "99!'2+45!+2%![0!B0&![<!&\(!+('0!12<0'!
5\>&+]05W!
6!7'(8(521!
/(105! S2%2X0B0%&! #! E))! &(! &]0! +(B8(%0%&!
j;<5&0B!T8 0'2,(%5k!&]0!'(105!jS2%2X0B0%&!
F0&\('4! M_*>8B0%&jL!\]>+]!2+&5!25!2%!
>%&0'C2+0! [0&\00%! &]0! B()01! 2%)! &]0!
%0&\('4! 0_*>8B0%&! [0>%X! '058(%5>[10! C('!
2+,(%5! 80'C('B0)! (%! &]050! )0Y>+05! 5*+]! 25Q!
0%2[10! ('! )>52[10! 8('&5! 2%)! 2+,Y2&0! ('!
)02+,Y2&0!0_*>8B0%&W!
DEFGE/H!-IJKL!;MN$OOML!;7E$F!! $:F!-P"6!7EFMOQ!:KEOOMFRM;!$F!STUM/F!FMJ3T/V$FR! "c!
6!7'(8(521!
712%%>%X!/*105!#!J]050!'*105!2'0!*50)!2&!,B05!
\]0%!)0+>5>(%5!B*5&![0!B2)0L!2%)!&]0'0C('0!
5](*1)! [0! 2))0)! '*105! &(! +(%gX*'0! %0&\('4!
0_*>8B0%&!>%!2++(')2%+0!\>&]!&]0!2+,Y2,(%!
2%)! )02+,Y2,(%! (C! 7]<5>+21! S2+]>%05W! J(!
>B810B0%&! &]0! 8'(8(50)! 50i%X5! C('!
SEKEUMNES!b-P""dL!21'02)<!8'050%&0)L!&]0!
C(11(\>%X!'*105!2'0!8'(8(50)Q!
!
DEFGE/H!-IJKL!;MN$OOML!;7E$F!! $:F!-P"6!7EFMOQ!:KEOOMFRM;!$F!STUM/F!FMJ3T/V$FR! -P!
6!7'(8(521!
#! $C! 2! 7S! >5! 5\>&+]0)! (fL! &]0! +(''058(%)>%X!
8('&5! (C! 2++055! 12<0'! 5\>&+]05! 5] (*1 )! [0!
&*'%0)!(fW!
#!$C!2%!2++055!12<0'!5\>&+]!]25!B('0!&]2%!]21C!
>&5! 8('&5! (fL! >&5! *81>%4! 8('&5! B*5&! ]2Y0! &]0>'!
5800)!'0)*+0)!&(!"!R[85W!
#! $C! 2%! 2++055! 1 2<0'! 5\> &+]! ]25! &*'%0)! (f! 211!
&]0>'!8('&5L!>&!B*5&![0!5]*&!)(\%W!!
!
DEFGE/H!-IJKL!;MN$OOML!;7E$F!! $:F!-P"6!7EFMOQ!:KEOOMFRM;!$F!STUM/F!FMJ3T/V$FR! -"!
6!7'(8(521!
#! $C! 2%! 2+ + 0 55! 1 2 <0 '! 5\ > & +]! > 5! (f L! &] 0!
+(''058(%)>%X! 8('&5! >%! &]0! 2XX'0X2,(%! 12<0'!
5\>&+]!5](*1)![0!&*'%0)!(fW!
#!$C!2%!2XX'0X2,(%!12<0'!5\>&+]!]25!&*'%0)!(f!
211!&]0>'!8('&5L!>&!B*5&![0!5]*&!)(\%W!
#! $C! 2%! 2XX'0X2,(%! 1 2<0'! 5\>&+]! >5! (fL! &]0!
+(''058(%)>%X! 8('&5! (C! &]0! +('0! 12<0'! 5\>&+]!
5](*1)![0!&*'%0)!(fW!
DEFGE/H!-IJKL!;MN$OOML!;7E$F!! $:F!-P"6!7EFMOQ!:KEOOMFRM;!$F!STUM/F!FMJ3T/V$FR! --!
6!7'(8(521!
@('! 02+]! (C! &]0! '*105! 1>5&0)! 2[(Y0L! >&! 5](*1)!
C('B*12&0! 2! [01>0C!'012&0)!8(\0'!
+(%5*B8,(%W! $C! \0! +(%5>)0'! :K/$;JF;MF! 0&!
21!b-P"PdL!\0!+2%!+>&0!25!2%!0a2B810Q!
! #! U>5+(%%0+,%X! 2! 8('&! (%! 2! 5\>&+]!
2++055!12<0'!X0%0'2&05!2!52Y>%X!(C!=PP!B3]W!
! #! U0+'0250! &]0! 5 800)! (C! 2! "P! R[8 5! 1>%4!
&(!"!R[85!X0%0'2&05!2!52Y>%X!(C!9W=!3]W!
!
DEFGE/H!-IJKL!;MN$OOML!;7E$F!! $:F!-P"6!7EFMOQ!:KEOOMFRM;!$F!STUM/F!FMJ3T/V$FR! -6!
6!7'(8(521!
;$SGOEJ$TF!
! !J]0!)2&2+0%&0'! )0C2*1&! %0&\('4!
&(8(1(X<L! '*105! 2%)! [01>0C5! 8'(8(5215! C( 'B!
&]0! [25>5! C('! +'02,%X! 2! 5>B*12,(%! B() 01! &(!
Y21>)2&0! )>f0'0%&! 5&'2&0X>05! 2%)! '*105! >%!
580+>g+!50i%X5!2%)!\>&]!)>f0'0%&!\('41(2)5W!!
DEFGE/H!-IJKL!;MN$OOML!;7E$F!! $:F!-P"6!7EFMOQ!:KEOOMFRM;!$F!STUM/F!FMJ3T/V$FR! -9!
6!7'(8(521!
• J]0!5>B*12&('!B*5&Q!
!
– :21+*12&0! &]0! >%>,21! +(%gX*'2,(%! C'(B! &]0! >%C('B0)!
2B(*%&! (C! 8]<5>+21! 50'Y0'5L! )0&0'B>%>%X! &]0! 2B(*%&! (C!
'2+45! 2%)! 5\>&+]05! (C! 02+]! &<80! 2%) ! &*'%>%X! (f! *%*50)!
8('&5W!
– :21+*12&0! &]0! >%>,21! +(%5*B8,(%! \>&]! 211! 8]<5>+21!
B2+]>%05!+(%%0+&0)!*5>%X!&]0!C('B*12!5] (\%!(%!&]0!%0a&!
51>)0W!
– /0+21+*12&0!&]0!+(%5*B8,(%!02+]!,B0!8]<5>+21!B2+]>%05!
2'0!&*'%0)!(%!('!(fW!
6!7'(8(521!
!!J]0!C('B*12!C('!+21+*12,%X!&]0!+(%5*B8,(%!
b:d!>%!32^!b3d!(C!5\>&+]05!>5Q!
!
:!n!:m!o!=Fp7"PR>X2!o!PW=Fp7R>X2!o!PW6Fp7@25&!
!
! ! !$%!&]>5!0a8'055>(%L!&]0!+(%5*B8,(% !:!>%!3!>5!
+21+*12&0)! [ <! 5*BB>%X! &]0! +(%5*B8,(%! [250!
b:mdL! \]>+]! >5! 2! ga0)! Y21 *0! (C! 02+]! )0Y>+0L! 2%)!
&]0!+(%5*B8,(% ! (C! 2+,Y0! 8('&5!2&! 02+]! 5800)L!
\]>+]!>5!&]0!Y2'>2[10!+(B8(%0%&W!
DEFGE/H!-IJKL!;MN$OOML!;7E$F!! $:F!-P"6!7EFMOQ!:KEOOMFRM;!$F!STUM/F!FMJ3T/V$FR! -?!
6!7'(8(521!
:E;M!;JGUH!
! J(! Y21>)2&0! &]0! 8'(8(521L! >&! >5! 28 81> 0)! (%! 2!
]<8(&]0,+21! +250! (C! 2! +1(*)! \>&]! -PP! 8]<5>+21!
50'Y0'5L! +'02,%X! &]0! &(8(1(X<L! +21+*12,%X! >&5!
+(%5*B8,(%! \>&](*&! B2%2X0B0%&! (C! %0&\('4!
0_*>8B0%&!2%)!>11*5&'2,%X!&\(!8(55>[10!5>&*2,(% 5!
>%!5<5&0B!(80'2,(%!!
!!!!!!!!!$&!\25!+(%5>)0'0)!C('!&]>5!5+0%2'>(!&]2&!&]0!
2++055!12<0'!5\>&+]05!]2Y0!2!+(%5*B8,(%![250!(C!
?P!3!2%)!&]0!2XX'0X2,(%!12<0'!(C!"9P!3W!
DEFGE/H!-IJKL!;MN$OOML!;7E$F!! $:F!-P"6!7EFMOQ!:KEOOMFRM;!$F!STUM/F!FMJ3T/V$FR! -A!
6!7'(8(521!
• E88 1<>% X!&]0!8'(8(50)!'*105!\0!\>11!]2Y0!!&]0!
C(11(\>%X!J(8(1(X<Q!
– =!'2+45!](*5> %X!2!+1 *5&0'!(C!9P!50'Y0'5!02+]W!
– "P!2++055!12<0'!5\>&+]05!\>&]!9P!"R[85!8('&5!2%)!
&\(!"PR[85!8('&5!+(%0+&0)W!
– P-! 2XX'0X2,(%! 12<0'! 5\>&+]05! \>&]!"-!"PR[85!
8('&5!+(%0+&0)W!
6!7'(8(521!
;+0%2'>(!"Q!E11!0_*>8B0%&!+(%%0+&0)!\>&]!211!>&5!
8('&5W!J]0!+(%5*B8,(%!(C!&]0!%0&\('4!\>11![0Q!
!
# E++055!12<0'!5\>&+]05!n!!
!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!"P!a!b?P!o!=a-!o!PW=a9Id!n!c9P!3!
#!EXX'0X2,(%!12<0'!5\>&+]05!n!!!
!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!-!a!b"9P!o!=a-9d!n!=-P!3!
#!J(&21!+(%5*B8,(%!(C!%0&\('4!n!"9?P!3!
!
DEFGE/H!-IJKL!;MN$OOML!;7E$F!! $:F!-P"6!7EFMOQ!:KEOOMFRM;!$F!STUM/F!FMJ3T/V$FR! -c!
6!7'(8(521!
;+0%2'>(!-Q!$%>,21!+(%gX*'2,(%!\>&]!*%*50)!8('&5!
)>52[10)W!J]0!+(%5*B8,(%!(C!&]0!%0&\('4!\>11![0Q!
!
# E++055!12<0'!5\>&+]05!n!!
!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!"P!a!b?P!o!=a-!o!PW=a9Pd!n!cPP!3!
#!EXX'0X2,(%!12<0'!5\>&+]05!n!!!
!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!-!a!b"9P!o!=a"-d!n!9PP!3!
#!J(&21!+(%5*B8,(%!(C!%0&\('4!n!"6PP!3!
""!h!52Y>%X!!
DEFGE/H!-IJKL!;MN$OOML!;7E$F!! $:F!-P"6!7EFMOQ!:KEOOMFRM;!$F!STUM/F!FMJ3T/V$FR! 6P!
6!7'(8(521!
;+0%2'>(!6Q!!!cP!8]<5>+21!50'Y0'5!+(%%0+&0)Q!
!
# E++055!12<0'!5\>&+]05!+(B810&0!n!!
!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!9!a!b?P!o!=a-!o!PW=a9Pd!n!6?P!3!
# E++055!12<0'!5\>&+]05!82',21n!!
!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!-!a!b?P!o!PW=a"-d!n!"6-!3!
#!EXX'0X2,(%!12<0'!5\>&+]05!n!!!
!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!-!a!b"9P!o!=a9!o!PW=a-d!n!6--!3!
# J(&21!+(%5*B8,(%!(C!%0&\('4!n!I"9!3!
9=!h!52Y>%X!
9!:(%+1*5>(%5!!
30! 8'050%&0)! &]0! B()01! (C! X'00%! +1(*)!
B2%2X0B0%&![250)!(%!&]0!T'X2%>`2,(%!J]0('<!
S()01! 2%)! +(%+08&5! (C! %0&\('4>%X! 0_*>8B0%&!
B2%2X0B0%&! 8'(80'1<! 2881>0)! &]2&! +2*505! &]0!
[0]2Y>('! (C! &]0! &(&21! +(%5*B8,(%! (C! &]0!
%0&\('4! >5! '(*X]1<! 8'(8(',(%21! &(! &]0! &'2Z+!
1(2)W!
DEFGE/H!-IJKL!;MN$OOML!;7E$F!! $:F!-P"6!7EFMOQ!:KEOOMFRM;!$F!STUM/F!FMJ3T/V$FR! 6-!
9!:(%+1*5>(%5!
J]0%!\0!)05+'>[0)!&]0!010B0%&5!&]2&!5](*1) ![0!
2))0)! &(! &]0! 2'+]>&0+&*'0! (C! &]0! B2%2X0B0%&!
B()01![250)!(%!&]0!T'X2%>`2,(%!S()01!J]0('<L!
'*105! 2% )! [01>0C5! %0+0552'<! C('! &]0! +(''0+&!
%0&\('4! +(%gX*'2,(%! )* 0! &(! &]0! +(%5(1>)2,(%!
(C!1(2)!(%!50'Y0'5W!
DEFGE/H!-IJKL!;MN$OOML!;7E$F!! $:F!-P"6!7EFMOQ!:KEOOMFRM;!$F!STUM/F!FMJ3T/V$FR! 66!
9!:(%+1*5>(%5!
E15(! 2! B()01! \25! 8'(8(50)! &(! )0&0'B>%0! &]0!
%0&\('4! &(8(1(X<! (C! &]0! )2&2+0%&0'! )080%)>%X!
(%!&]0!%*B[0'!(C!8]<5>+21!50'Y0'5L!2%)!&]0!'*105!
2%)!C('B*125!C('!+21+*12,%X!&]0!+(%5* B8,(% !(C!
%0&\('4!5\>&+]05W!
DEFGE/H!-IJKL!;MN$OOML!;7E$F!! $:F!-P"6!7EFMOQ!:KEOOMFRM;!$F!STUM/F!FMJ3T/V$FR! 69!
9!@*&*'0!3('45!
$&! > 5! 8'(8(50)! &(! +(%,%*0! &]>5! '0502'+]! [<!
80'C('B>%X! &]0! %0+0552'<! 0a&0%5>(%5! &(!
:1(*);>B! ('! J02+]:1(*)! &(! >B810B0%&! &]0!
B()01! 2%)! 80'C('B! 0a80'>B0%&5! &( ! )0&0'B>%0!
&]0!B(5&!0f0+,Y0!'*105W!
DEFGE/H!-IJKL!;MN$OOML!;7E$F!! $:F!-P"6!7EFMOQ!:KEOOMFRM;!$F!STUM/F!FMJ3T/V$FR! 6=!
9!@*&*'0!3('45!
$&! >5! 215(! 8'(8(50)! &(! 5&*)<! &]0! C02&*'05! (C!
R'00%! F0&\('4>%X! 2%)! %0\! %0&\('4>%X!
5&2%)2')5! 8'(8(50)! C('! )2&2+0%&0'5! 25! J/$OO!
bJ'2%582'0%&! $%&0'+(%%0+,(%! (C! O(&! (C! O>%45dL!
%0&\('45!)0g%0)![<!5(q\2'0!2%)!T80%@1(\L!>%!
(')0'! &(! )0&0'B>%0! &]0>'! >%r*0%+0! (%! ! (*'!
B2%2X0B0%&!B()01W!
DEFGE/H!-IJKL!;MN$OOML!;7E$F!! $:F!-P"6!7EFMOQ!:KEOOMFRM;!$F!STUM/F!FMJ3T/V$FR! 6?!
=!;(B0!/0C0'0%+05!
#!:EOKM$/T;L!/WL!/EFDEFL!/WL!mMOTROEsTNL!EWL!UM!/T;ML!:W!
0! mGH H EL! / W! :1(*);>BQ! E! J( ( 1 4 > &! C ( '! S ( ) 01 > %X! 2%)!
;>B*12,(%! (C! :1(*)! :(B8*,%X! M%Y>'(%B0%&5! 2%)!
MY21*2,(%!(C!/05(*'+05!7'(Y>5>(%>%X!E1X('>&]B5W!;7M!3>10<!
7'055W!-P""!!
#!3MFM/L!DWL!RM/TF$STL!RWEWL!3M;J7KEOOL!:WmWL!VT:KL!@WOWL!
@/M$JE;L!/W/WL!3M;J7KEOOL!:W SW!M%Y>'(%B0%&L!;0'Y>+05!2%)!
F0&\('4!S2%2X0B0%&! C('!R'00%!:1(*)5W! :OM$! MOM:J/TF$:!
DTG/FEOL!-P"-W!!
#!DE/E/3MKL!HWL!VKE/mGJO$L!SW!0! EO; EOMKL!SW!J02+]:1( *)Q!
E! : 1 ( * )! : ( B 8 * , % X! M ) * + 2 , ( % 2 1! J ( ( 1 4 > & W! J]0! "5&!
$%&0'%2,(%21! $mS! :1(*)! E+2)0B<! :(%C0'0%+0W! G;EW! E['>1!
-P"-W!!
!
DEFGE/H!-IJKL!;MN$OOML!;7E$F!! $:F!-P"6!7EFMOQ!:KEOOMFRM;!$F!STUM/F!FMJ3T/V$FR! 6A!
=!;(B0!/0C0'0%+05!
#! S E K E U M N E FL! 7W L! ;K E / S E L! 7 W L! mE F M / D M M L! ; W! M!
/EFREFEJKEFL! 7W! E! 7(\0'! m0%+]B2'4>%X! @'2B0\('4!
C('!F0&\('4!U0Y>+05W!FMJ3T/V$FRL!-PPcW!;8'>%X0'W!
#!SEKEUMNEFL!7WL!mEFM/DMML!; WL!;KE/SEL!7WL!;KEKL!EW!0!
/EFREFEJKEFL! 7W! T%! M%0'X<! MZ+>0%+<! C('! M%&0'8'>50!
2%)! U2&2! :0%&0'! F0&\('45W! $MMM! :(BB*%>+2,(%!
S2X2`>%0W!E*XW!-P""W!!
#! ;KM/! UM! :G;EJ$;L! :WDWL! :E//EFsEL! EW! 0! UM:G;EJ$;L! : W!
SW! :(B*%>+2,(%! 3>&]>%! :1(*)5Q! T80%! ;&2%)2')5! 2%)!
7'(8'>0&2'<! 7'(&(+(15! C('! U2&2! :0%&0'! F0&\('4>%XW! $MMM!
:(BB*%>+2,(%!S2X2`>%0W!;08&W!-P"-W!!
!
DEFGE/H!-IJKL!;MN$OOML!;7E$F!! $:F!-P"6!7EFMOQ!:KEOOMFRM;!$F!STUM/F!FMJ3T/V$FR! 6I!