Article

Trust during retail encounters: A touchy proposition

Authors:
To read the full-text of this research, you can request a copy directly from the authors.

Abstract

Adopting an interpersonal communication perspective, this study examines the propositions that a salesperson's touch increases trust, which increases product evaluations and purchase intention. These relationships are evaluated in a contact and non-contact culture, with need for touch (NFT) examined as an additional moderator. An exploratory series of in-depth interviews provides an initial understanding of these relationships, followed by a 2 (touch/no touch condition) × 2 (consumers in France/Germany) experiment with wine serving as the example category. The findings indicate that touch does not uniformly instill trust in customers. Instead a salesperson's touch relates to greater trust only when consumers have an inherent NFT or when they are from a culture where personal touching behavior is less prevalent. Trust, in turn, relates positively to evaluations of product attractiveness, quality, and to purchase intention.

No full-text available

Request Full-text Paper PDF

To read the full-text of this research,
you can request a copy directly from the authors.

... Bitner (1992) personas que puntúan más alto en la escala de tacto interpersonal también puntúan más alto en la escala de tacto con productos. En esta misma línea, Orth et al. (2013) asocian las bajas puntuaciones en escala NFT con la aversión al tacto interpersonal. ...
... La segunda cuestión que podemos mencionar es que en varias de las investigaciones más recientes en la literatura del tacto durante el encuentro de servicio (e.g., Guéguen y Fisher-Lokou, 2003b;Guéguen y Vion, 2009;Orth et al., 2013) En investigaciones sobre el efecto del sexo en otros campos de investigación, el sexo del emisor del tacto tampoco es relevante (e.g., Hertenstein et al., 2006aHertenstein et al., , 2009Thompson y Hampton, 2011). ...
... H1b: Una sonrisa "Duchenne" por parte del vendedor provocará una mejor evaluación de la competencia del vendedor por parte del cliente.Así mismo, como hemos comentado en el apartado 1.4.3, las escasas investigaciones que encontramos sobre el efecto del tacto del vendedor al cliente en el encuentro de servicio apuntan a conclusiones similares: el leve toque que el vendedor hace al cliente se asocia con mejores evaluaciones del cliente (e.g., Erceau y Guéguen, 2007;Orth et al., 2013;Saleh et al., 2023). Por tanto, vamos a asumir en nuestras siguientes hipótesis que esto es así también para nuestro estudio, tanto en lo referente a la evaluación de la competencia como de la calidez del vendedor. ...
Thesis
Full-text available
¿Puede una simple acción no verbal cambiar las percepciones que el cliente tiene acerca del vendedor en un encuentro de servicio? En esta tesis hemos examinado, por primera vez en una muestra española y a través de tres estudios, cómo un leve toque del vendedor en el hombro o en el brazo del cliente y/o una sonrisa “Duchenne” del vendedor al cliente influyen en las evaluaciones que el cliente hace de la calidez y de la competencia del vendedor, utilizando para ello el Modelo de Contenido de Estereotipos (Fiske et al., 2002). En el primer estudio (con datos de 2018), estudiamos el efecto del leve toque y de la sonrisa del vendedor sobre las evaluaciones que el cliente hace de su calidez y su competencia, así como la interacción de la sonrisa sobre los efectos del leve toque del vendedor en las evaluaciones del cliente (estudiada por primera vez en un encuentro de servicio). En el segundo estudio, replicamos el primero, pero con datos tomados en 2022, para analizar el efecto pandemia. Y en el tercer estudio, con datos de 2023, estudiamos si el sexo del vendedor y del comprador modula el efecto del leve toque del vendedor en las evaluaciones que el cliente hace de su competencia y su calidez. Además, introducimos la extraversión de cliente (estudios 1 y 2) y el Confort con el Tacto Interpersonal del cliente (estudio 3) como variables moduladoras. Los resultados encontrados muestran que, tanto la sonrisa como el leve toque del vendedor tienen un efecto positivo sobre la evaluación que el cliente hace de su calidez, a lo largo de los 3 estudios. Cuando el vendedor, además, de tocar al cliente, le sonríe, el efecto positivo del tacto sobre la evaluación de la calidez del vendedor es menos intenso, tanto antes como después de la pandemia. En cuanto a la percepción de la competencia, la sonrisa “Duchenne” del vendedor también provoca un efecto positivo sobre el efecto que el tacto del vendedor en las percepciones del cliente, sin efecto pandemia. Sin embargo, el leve toque del vendedor sufre una evolución a lo largo de nuestros tres estudios en cuanto a su efecto sobre la evaluación de su competencia, pasando de ser positivo en 2018, a no ser significativo en 2022 y a tener un efecto negativo en 2023. Así mismo, la interacción de la sonrisa sobre el efecto que el tacto del vendedor tiene sobre la evaluación que el cliente hace de su calidez no es significativa, ni antes ni después de la pandemia. En cuanto a la modulación del sexo del vendedor y del comprador sobre el efecto del leve toque del vendedor en las evaluaciones de los clientes, encontramos que las evaluaciones de los clientes no están influidas por el sexo de los vendedores, sean hombres o mujeres; mientras que el sexo del comprador sí influye, siendo los compradores hombres los que mejor evalúan a los vendedores, en comparación con las clientes mujeres. Se discuten los resultados encontrados y se exponen las implicaciones gerenciales.
... All papers included in the present review investigated the effect of social touch on trust. Six papers explored this in the context of unmediated human-human interactions (Brummelman et al., 2019;Burgoon, 1991;Orth et al., 2013;Petit, 2023;Phillips & Kassinove, 1987;Rosenberger et al., 2018), 2 studies used mediated human touch (Erk et al., 2015;Takahashi et al., 2017), 1 compared human and robot touch (Bevan & Stanton Fraser, 2015), 5 papers used a robot partner (Arnold & Scheutz, 2018;Giorgi et al., 2022;Law et al., 2021;Mazursky et al., 2022;Nie et al., 2012), and 1 employed virtual agents on a tablet with haptic device for tactile feedback (Huisman et al., 2014). Table 1 summarises the main information of the included papers, which are first ordered based on the type of partner (from humans to robots and virtual agents), then alphabetically by first authors' last name. ...
... Within social interactions between humans, social touch was found to improve perceived trustworthiness of a salesperson during a retail encounter (Orth et al., 2013). However, social touch failed to improve perceived trustworthiness of a psychologist during a counselling session on mental health (Phillips & Kassinove, 1987). ...
... Evidence on the role of social touch in building up trust towards other people is mixed and seemingly contradictory. While some authors found that social touch can indeed facilitate the partner's perceived trustworthiness (Burgoon, 1991;Orth et al., 2013;Petit, 2023), others failed to support this hypothesis (Phillips & Kassinove, 1987), also when looking at trust behaviours (Rosenberger et al., 2018). Results are even less promising in the case of mediated interactions and telecommunication, whereby there is no clear evidence of digital social touch affecting perceived trustworthiness of a remote partner (Bevan & Stanton Fraser, 2015;Erk et al., 2015;Takahashi et al., 2017). ...
... But, since the covid-19 pandemic, this positive effect could be hampered by the new social distancing rules that have been put in place. Indeed, increasing physical distance with frontline employees may reduce relational closeness, trust, and perceived quality of the service experience (Martin and Nuttall 2017;Orth, Bouzdine-Chameeva, and Brand 2013). The customer's comfort, and subsequently the perceived quality of the product and service, must be considered in a global way, considering all the elements of the sensory context that could impact it. ...
... Therefore, we assume that a pleasant ambient scent tends to reduce stress and anxiety that may feel consumers when they maintain a low physical distance with frontline employees maintaining. To take it a step further, in the presence of an ambient scent, physical proximity to frontline employees can even be felt as evidence of their relational closeness, trust and empathy in their relationship (Erceau and Guéguen 2007;Gallace and Spence 2010;Orth, Bouzdine-Chameeva, and Brand 2013). ...
... In the low physical distance condition, the saleswoman approaches the consumer and furtively touches the consumer on the arm. This manipulation of interpersonal physical distance is frequently used in the literature (Fischer-Lokou and Guéguen 2004;Fisher, Rytting, and Heslin 1976;Guéguen 2001;Hornik 1992aHornik , 1992bOrth, Bouzdine-Chameeva, and Brand 2013). In the high physical distance condition, the saleswoman maintains a distance of 1 m to 1.5 m from the consumer. ...
Article
Full-text available
Many sales and service interactions with frontline employees take place in scented places. This research focuses on the effect of ambient scents on consumer comfort with frontline employees and subsequently on the perceived quality of product and service offers. Two experimental studies carried out in actual setting in Paris, in taxis (242 respondents interacting with drivers) and in a small shop (120 respondents interacting with advisors), show that consumer comfort with frontline employees and perceived quality are higher (lower) in the presence of an ambient scent when the frontline employees maintain strong (low) physical proximity with consumers. This study shows the impact of ambient scents in consumers-employee’s relationships and questions their relevance when social interactions are constrained by distancing rules.
... 712). Offering a more nuanced view on the relevance of trust in a retailing context, Orth et al. (2013) identify benevolence and integrity as two factors of particular importance for constituting trust toward the retailer. Benevolence describes an organization's concern for consumers' interests as expressed through activities and sacrifices that do not solely pursue profit motives (Ganesan & Hess, 1997;Singh & Sirdeshmukh, 2000). ...
... The results of three studies confirm that a decentralized blockchain-based traceability system positively impacts retailer choice. This effect is mediated by trust in the retailer, which is ensured by the technology itself and not dependent on interpersonal interaction in a blockchain-based environment (Orth et al., 2013). We include retailer familiarity and blockchain benefit disclosure as mediators and also account for control variables, such as consumer confidence in food safety, blockchain knowledge, age, and gender. ...
... Trust in the retailer (Mayer & Davis, 1999;Orth et al., 2013). Rating scale (3 = Retailer A -− 3 = Retailer B). ...
Article
Full-text available
In the last decades, numerous food scandals have attracted policy makers’ interest and subsequently induced retailers to actively improve food safety. Blockchain technology allows consumers to track the flow of food products and reduce food fraud, such as counterfeiting, dilution, or adulteration. Using three experiments conducted with Austrian business students as well as an online convenience sample, we investigate how the traceability of food products impacts consumers’ trust in the retailer and subsequently influences consumers’ retailer choice. Our model further considers retailer familiarity and the disclosure of blockchain benefits as important moderators of the impact of blockchain-based traceability systems on trust in the retailer. The model was tested using ANOVA, ANCOVA, and Hayes’ PROCESS models. In terms of fostering consumer trust, the findings show that retailers who are unfamiliar to consumers profit more from the use of blockchain technology than do better-known retailers. Moreover, informing consumers about specific blockchain benefits strengthens the positive effects of a blockchain-based traceability system.
... The intangibility of the online purchase process leads consumer to focus on other indicators that tend to be more subjective or personal, such as subjective norms. As prior research shows, this intangibility prompts consumers to behave in different ways in offline vs online channels (Orth et al., 2013;Xiang et al., 2015). Workman and Cho (2013) cite several variables that affect product evaluations in different shopping channels, such as personal (e.g. consumer personality), social (influence of family and friends) and epistemic (curiosity, knowledge) variables. ...
... Some authors thus emphasise the relevance of perceived service quality (Kim et al., 2011), website quality Lee and Wu, 2011), e-tailer perceived quality (Das, 2016) and perceived shopping quality (Lo and Qu, 2015) in a particular channel. Orth et al. (2013) relate product quality evaluations to interpersonal (salesperson-consumer) forms of touch, though not to product touch. ...
... Physical contact with products can be a key source of information for consumers, especially prior to the purchase decision. This contact may prove vital for weighing alternatives, establishing preferences and making choices (Childers and Peck, 2010;Orth et al., 2013;Park et al., 2012;Yazdanparast and Spears, 2013). Information gleaned from handling the product directly is more reliable and revealing than indirect experiences, because it is generated and obtained by the purchasers themselves. ...
Article
Purpose The purpose of this paper is to address the potential impact of need for touch (NFT) on perceived product quality and the possible roles of purchasers’ social (subjective norms), personal (buying impulsiveness) and epistemic (e-commerce orientation) factors, as well as the likely interaction effect of the shopping channel. Design/methodology/approach The empirical study is based on 540 observations, analysed in a partial least squares structural equation model. Findings The link between the NFT and perceived quality tends to be negative, especially for online purchases. E-commerce orientation reduces the need to touch products, but subjective norms and buying impulsiveness have no significant effects. Research limitations/implications The NFT scale might be improved by adding more items. Some of the structural model coefficients indicate a low effect size. Finally, the results are limited to Spanish purchasers of the focal product. Practical implications Firms should appeal to purchasers’ e-commerce orientation to reduce the negative implications of a need to touch products among consumers shopping online. Originality/value The need to touch a product may be an obstacle to online purchases, yet few studies deal with its impact in online, relative to offline, contexts to evaluate product quality. This study also integrates personal, social and epistemic factors.
... Interpersonal touch refers to non-verbal behavior that is often considered to be an expression of attachment, emphasizing a social proximity between individuals (Knapp, 1978). This tactile contact increases trust (Orth et al., 2013), and acts of generosity (Crusco and Wetzel, 1984). This positive effect of touch on prosocial behavior is called the Midas Touch Effect (Crusco and Wetzel, 1984). ...
... In line with the aforementioned positive effect of touch on trust (Orth et al., 2013), Morhenn et al. (2008) found that interpersonal touch, when followed by an act of trust, leads people to sacrifice money for others. Thus, trust might play an important role in the effect of interpersonal touch on donations to homeless people. ...
Article
Full-text available
Getting help is often difficult for people who trigger disgust (e.g., homeless, sick, or disabled people) as well as the charities representing them because of low trust in these groups. Prior research has demonstrated that physical contact can help increase generosity. However, it is difficult to trigger this phenomenon—called Midas Touch Effect—when people feel disgust and are uncomfortable with interpersonal touch. This research examines touch-related vocabulary (e.g., “I would be touched,” “anyone who I can contact”) as an alternative, non-physical way for prompting the Midas Touch Effect. This research examines if such a vocabulary may reduce the negative effects of disgust on trust, and thus increase the willingness to donate. Across two studies, it is shown that while disgust has a negative effect on trust and willingness to donate to a homeless person when no touch-related vocabulary is used, no such negative effect is observed when the message includes touch-related vocabulary.
... Research on the need for tactile experiences (Citrin et al., 2003) reveals that consumers who rely heavily on tactile input (i.e., high NFT) are reluctant to depend solely on other sensory inputs (e.g., sight, hearing) when making a purchase decision. Orth et al. (2013) show that the positive effect of touch on product evaluation is mediated by trust only for consumers with high NFT, not for those with low NFT. However, research also identifies a boundary condition for NFT such that environmental encouragement through a "feelthe-freshness" point-of-purchase sign works for all consumers, regardless of their NFT level (Peck & Childers, 2006). ...
... 16 Orth et al. (2013) examine interpersonal touch from a cross-cultural perspective. In general, consumers trust a salesperson more in touch than no-touch conditions, but the positive impact of touch on product evaluations is significant only for consumers from a non-contact culture (e.g., Germany), not those from a contact culture (e.g., France). ...
Chapter
Consumers use their sense of touch to interact with products and salespeople in direct marketing; they use touchscreen devices to interact with products and others on e-commerce and mobile commerce platforms. Understanding the role of touch in consumers’ experiences in both physical and digital realms is essential for businesses to implement effective haptic strategies and for scholars to advance knowledge in touch literature. This chapter offers an initial review of the role of touch, touchscreens, and haptic technology through an interactive marketing lens. Specifically, it proposes a conceptual framework for continued research by situating current haptic and tactile research within an interactive marketing frame. It summarizes new knowledge of three important topics in interactive marketing: technology adoption, customer behavior, and multichannel marketing. It also draws readers’ attention to the multifaceted research of touch from psychology and neuroscience perspectives. The first half of the chapter summarizes the most up-to-date research findings and theories (e.g., psychological ownership) on haptic and tactile effects that substantially affect interactions between consumers and products and between consumers and service providers. Then a summary of recent research outlines how touchscreen devices (e.g., smartphones, tablets) and haptic technology (e.g., smart wearables) influence consumers’ experiences in the digital world.
... Adicionalmente, para recopilar los datos se aplicó una encuesta personal en cada uno de los museos. El diseño del instrumento se basó en el modelo de resonancia de marca evaluando atractivo y percepción a través de la propuesta de (Malhotra, 1981;Orth et al., 2013) (Véase Tabla 1). Ambas variables se manejaron de manera complementaria más no sustitutiva. ...
... Finalmente, el instrumento constó de 22 ítemes autoadministrados y 4 ítemes de control. (Orth et al., 2013) Mide cual atractivo puede ser la marca y con ello aumentar la intención de compra. ...
Article
Literature on the impacts of COVID 19 reveals thathow the effects of the pandemic may be experienced at destinations in different stages of their development has not been studied. This paper discusses the impact of a break in tourism visitation to destinations caused by COVID 19 and uses the Tourism Area Life Cycle model as a framework from which to argue that the scale and importance of the impacts on destinations will vary depending on the stage of the development cycle reached by any specific destination. Such impacts may range from a short term and temporary loss of tourists to a permanent departure of the destination from tourism. It is argued that the nature and degree of recovery of the tourism market at any specific destination will vary in speed and level of recovery, the degree of permanence of impacts, and the likelihood of destinations retaining their overall appeal after the pandemic has ended, depending on their stage of development. The paper concludes with a discussion of the possibility of destinations using the pandemic to reposition themselves in terms of their markets, and attempting to modify the tourism industry itself.
... One more important variable that affects the channel choice is the need for touch and feel, the desire to interact physically with a product (Jin and Phua, 2015). Many purchase contexts demand a higher need for touch and feel while evaluating products, which are hindered in online channels due to the absence of physical contact (Kim and Kim, 2004;Orth et al., 2013;Kim and Peterson, 2017). In such scenarios, consumers prefer searching for products offline (Kim and Peterson, 2017); however, such needs alone does not affect the actual purchase process. ...
... Various products require touch and feel during the information search period, including apparel, vegetables, groceries etc. For such products, the need for touch and feel would lead to higher online search(Kim and Kim, 2004;Orth et al., 2013; Kim and Peterson, 2017). However, touch-and-feel is only required during information search and would have no impact on actual purchase channel choice, as shown in our study. ...
Article
Full-text available
Purpose The purpose of this research is to propose and validate a theoretical framework explaining web-rooming and showrooming as a multi-stage decision-making process. The authors have used consumer purchase decision-making theories to propose a model that identifies showrooming and webrooming as a combination of two decisions, channel choice during information search and channel choice during actual purchase. Further, the authors explored how various antecedents of showrooming and webrooming have differential effects on various stages of a purchase decision-making process and how product type moderates the relationships. Design/methodology/approach The authors have conducted empirical research, whereby 243 responses were obtained from a cross-sectional survey. The authors have used structural equation modeling and multiple regression analysis to validate our theoretical model. Findings Webrooming or showrooming is a multi-stage decision-making process for the consumers. First, consumers decide whether to search online or offline and then whether to buy online and offline. Different individual, purchase context-related and channel related factors impact these decisions. Product type governs which variables will be more important than others. Originality/value The research looks to enhance the understanding of the consumer's decision-making process during showrooming and webrooming while also helping retailers design and implement appropriate strategies that could affect consumers during information search and actual purchase.
... As for interpersonal trust, during a product-purchasing process, interpersonal trust is created when the buyer and the seller communicate face-to-face about the production process, value, and concepts underlying the product [41,42]. Farmers' markets emphasize a buyer-seller relationship. ...
... This shows that interpersonal trust and institutional trust complement each other, which was similar to a previous study [38]. In addition, the simultaneous influence of institutional and interpersonal trust on purchase intention was validated, consistent with previous studies [39][40][41][42][43]. Furthermore, consistent with numerous studies [23,29,53], the consumers' purchase intentions significantly affected their actual purchase behaviors. ...
Article
Full-text available
Farmers’ markets in Taiwan advocate for the sustainable consumption of locally produced food to support sustainability and social justice goals. Institutional trust and interpersonal trust are critical determinative factors in sustaining farmers’ farm-to-consumer venues for the long-run. The purpose of this research was to investigate determinants of customers’ actual purchase behaviors, and the relationships between trust, purchase intention, and actual purchase behavior in the context of farmers’ markets. A questionnaire approach with closed-ended survey questions was conducted with customers in farmers’ markets in different parts of Taiwan. The results revealed that both institutional and interpersonal trust could serve as driving forces influencing a consumer’s purchase intentions, which in turn reinforces their actual purchase behavior. Specifically, the interpersonal trust between consumers and producers includes positive interactions and sufficient communication, enabling producers to share the value and concepts underlying their production processes with the consumers, enhancing customers’ purchase intentions and intensity. Institutional trust generated from a producer’s endeavor to improve the quality of their own products by meeting market standards would impress consumers and build loyalty. It is recommended that farmers’ market farmers or managers continually examine both the institutional and interpersonal needs of customers (e.g., food safety, face-to-face interactions between farmers and consumers) to earn customers’ trust, and to accommodate their expectations by providing sufficient products and services.
... Long before the existence of mass digital markets, marketers in different product categories had been building expertise in constructs rooted in human physiology, reaching out to consumers through the senses (Dauce and Rieunier 2002;Krishna 2012;Lindstrom 2005). Studies of sensory experience in offline environments have looked at interpersonal touch and compliance (Hornik 1992;Patterson, Powell, and Lenihan 1986), product evaluation (Krishna and Morrin 2008), perceived ownership (Peck, Barger, and Webb 2013), touch avoidance and contamination (Argo, Dahl Darren, and Morales 2006), trust (Orth, Bouzdine-Chameeva, and Brand 2013) and a variety of related topics. ...
... These studies explored the tactile stimulation provided by interfaces, demonstrating that the more an interface provides a "direct-touch" interaction (i.e., touchscreen compared to a mouse or pad), the more it influences consumer attitudes and behavior. Similarly, previous studies conducted in offline environments have shown that tactile interaction during consumption or purchasing stages modifies consumers' evaluations of a brand; specifically, touch increases brand trust (Crusco and Wetzel 1984;Morhenn et al. 2008;Orth, Bouzdine-Chameeva, and Brand 2013). ...
Article
Full-text available
Consumers can use alternative methods to interact with or access a brand through their mobile devices. They can type a response using a touchscreen keyboard (touch interaction) or use voice response while holding a mobile device (combined voice and touch interaction). In this study, we look at the impact of these different types of interaction on personal engagement and the effect on brand trust as relevant concerns to managers in the digital, mediated context. Using a framework based on sensory marketing and Dual Coding Theory, we conducted 2 one-way between-subjects experiments with a two-level interface interaction considering a hedonic product (Experiment 1) and utilitarian product (Experiment 2). Findings confirm a three-way interaction such that the impact of privacy concern on the relationship between personal engagement and trust depends on the nature of the platform interaction; touch vs. combined touch and voice. We also find that adding voice to the platform interface has the counterintuitive effect of reducing engagement with that platform. All in all, our results provide novel insights into the role of touch and voice in the online context when it comes to consumers' decision-making.
... Yet very little attention has been paid to the subject of interpersonal touch in service encounters. One study found a positive impact of touch on product evaluations (Orth, Bouzdine-Chameeva, & Brand, 2013), while another finds touch increased the consumer's liking of the service employee, service provider, and service evaluation (Wycoff & Holley, 1990). Relatedly, in a consumer behavior context, researchers have investigated tipping behavior, known as the "Midas touch" (Crusco & Wetzel, 1984), and whether touch by the server increases compliance with a marketing request (Hornik, 1992b). ...
... A few studies have noted that touch has a positive effect on consumer's evaluation of a store (Hornik, 1992a) or of a restaurant (Crusco & Wetzel, 1984;Hornik, 1992b). In a service encounter context specifically, Orth et al. (2013) found a fleeting touch on a customer's shoulder by a salesperson enhanced trust towards the salesperson and increased favorable product evaluations. Wycoff and Holley (1990) found touch on the shoulder or forearm by an airline flight attendant increased passengers' liking of the attendant, the airline, and their perceived flight safety. ...
Article
Interpersonal touch has been shown to affect consumer behaviors such as compliance with a request, impulse buying, and tipping behavior. In this study, we examine if the impact of touch on purchase behavior is gender specific, and if it depends on how much the individual likes the product. Findings indicate male consumers are more likely to purchase a product at low to moderate levels of perceived tastiness when they are touched by a female server, whereas females are less likely to purchase. However, the touch encounter doesn’t matter for either gender when a consumer really likes the product.
... The study also makes a contribution to the sales and retailing literature, as it is one of the few that has considered trust in the salesperson in a retailing context. Indeed, only three previously published works were found that investigated the construct in a retail store setting (Bateman & Valentine, 2015;Orth, Bouzdine-Chameeva, & Brand, 2013;Sirdeshmukh, Singh, & Sabol, 2002). Traditionally, trust has been explored in field sales. ...
... This construct was investigated because of its long tradition in the marketing and sales literature (e.g., Hawes, Mast, & Swan, 1989;Morgan & Hunt, 1994;Swan, Bowers, & Richardson, 1999;Wilson, 1995) and its relative paucity of studies in retail selling (for exceptions, see Bateman & Valentine, 2015;Orth et al., 2013). Trust is requisite for generating interaction with others (e.g., Czepiel, 1990) and a key component in establishing solid relationships in the buyer-seller dyad (e.g., Hawes et al., 1989;Kumar, 1996;Morgan & Hunt, 1994;Wilson, 1995). ...
Article
Store-based retailers face constant challenges in trying to lure shoppers, extend shopping visits, and convert patrons. With shopping options galore (e.g., native online sellers, mobile commerce, automatic replenishment), experts might inquire whether store-based retailers still offer enough value for today's consumers. Some stores have found success through format diversification, self-checkout, in-store pickup, and so on. In this study, we assert that store-based retailers could find success via in-store salespersons capable of satisfying the social needs of consumers experiencing loneliness. Despite purported “connections” to friends, followers, and devices, consumers of all demographics feel undesirable shortcomings in their personal relationships. Delving into this largely unexplored area, we find that two varieties of loneliness—social and emotional—influence the degree to which consumers use in-store sales personnel for social interaction. We also ascertain that consumers’ predisposition to comply with salesperson input affects their trust in the salesperson, purchase intention, and retail store patronage.
... These factors were also instrumental in building trust in food retailers (Wang and Tsai, 2014). The importance of trust and risk perceptions were reported to be relevant in context of brick and mortar as well as online shopping formats (Hongyoun Hahn and Kim, 2009;Chiu et al., 2012;Twing-Kwong et al., 2013;Orth et al., 2013); however, they have been studied sparingly in context of organic food retailers. The growth of organic food market has presented several challenges for food retailers as they are required to envisage promotions to nurture trust towards organic food products (Borin et al., 2011). ...
... In the context of retailing, Orth et al. (2013) posit that salespersons' behaviour can improve trust perceptions towards retailers. Salespersons' touch and non-touch behaviour were examined in "contact" and "non-contact" cultures. ...
Article
Purpose The purpose of this paper is to examine the role of green self-identity, green peer influence, service and product quality of organic food retailers on Indian consumers’ perceived trust and transaction risk. Design/methodology/approach The sample consisted of consumers purchasing organic food products from organic food retailers. A mix of judgemental and convenience sampling was used. Findings Green peer influence, perceived organic food quality and service quality had a positive influence on perceived trust towards organic food retailer. Green self-identity had a negative influence on perceived transaction risk, and green peer influence had a positive effect on perceived transaction risk. Practical implications The findings can be used by organic food retailers to increase trust by improving organic food brands and service quality at the stores. The organic food market is in nascent stage and consumers’ trust towards organic food retailers is crucial in improving intention to purchase organic food. Peer influence should be used in cultivating trust towards products sold by organic food retailers. Originality/value The study adds to existing research by analysing the role of green self-identity, peer influence, organic food and service quality on perceived trust and transaction risk. The results can be used by retailers for marketing organic food brands.
... According to Jin and Dobry (2023), ChatGPT can improve travelers' insurance literacy by presenting such information simply, answering queries about travel insurance coverage, and recommending a suitable insurance plan. Accordingly, such features improve travelers' trust, further increasing the attractiveness of ChatGPT's travel insurance recommendations (Orth et al. 2013). Thus, the following hypothesis is proposed: ...
Article
Full-text available
This study employed dual‐process theory to examine the behavioral intention to follow ChatGPT's travel insurance recommendations. It investigated the moderating role of insurance literacy on the relationship between the attractiveness of ChatGPT's travel insurance recommendations and the behavioral intention to adopt these recommendations. In total, 378 usable questionnaires were collected through the Prolific platform in the United States. The findings showed that while perceived trust, accuracy, and customization were responsible for the attractiveness of ChatGPT's travel insurance recommendations, perceived convenience and perceived security had no significant effect. In addition, it was found that perceptions of both “coolness” and “creepiness” significantly affected the attractiveness of ChatGPT's recommendations. At the same time, the attractiveness of recommendations influenced the behavioral intention to adopt them. In contrast, insurance literacy did not moderate the relationship between recommendations' attractiveness and the behavioral intention to adopt such recommendations. This study is unique in that it is the first study to employ Dual‐process theory in this context. The findings enhance our understanding of which element (cognitive vs. affective) exerts the most substantial influence on the attractiveness of travel insurance based on ChatGPT's recommendations, providing valuable insights into the design and marketing of AI‐based travel insurance services.
... This pattern aligns with literature indicating that concerns about financial and performance risks lead to thorough cross-channel searches (Verhoef et al., 2007;Mohseni et al., 2018). The choice of search channel is further influenced by a desire for tactile experiences with certain products, like apparel and groceries, which drives more online searches (Young Kim et al., 2004;Orth et al., 2013;Kim et al., 2017). However, Yan et al. (2021) note that this need for a tactile experience only affects the information search phase, not the final purchasing decision. ...
Article
Full-text available
Webrooming is a two-part shopping process where consumers research online before purchasing in-store. Anchored in Icek Ajzen's Theory of Planned Behavior, this study explores the webrooming trend in the high-involvement appliance category, including items such as televisions, refrigerators, air-conditioning units, and washing machines. Building on Eugene et al.'s (2021) investigation into consumers' tactile preferences, this research adds High Involvement Appliances as a moderating factor. The study employs purposive sampling, collecting data from 100 respondents aged 26-45 (Millennials) residing in Bulacan, Laguna, Cavite, and Rizal who have previously engaged in webrooming. The findings indicate that high-involvement appliances do not significantly moderate the relationships between Attitude, Subjective Norms, and Perceived Behavioral Control with the Intention to Webroom. This insight is crucial for both online and physical retailers, as it highlights the importance of understanding millennials' unique preferences and behaviors regarding high-involvement appliances. It also examines factors affecting this trend, potentially reshaping marketing strategies in the sector. Additionally, the study underscores the significance of an omnichannel approach, integrating online and offline touchpoints to enhance the shopping experience. The study aims to provide actionable insights for small- and medium-sized enterprises in the appliance sector, focusing on how millennials in the neighboring provinces of Metro Manila are influenced by webrooming before making high-involvement appliance purchases.
... Our work examines how luxury-brand displays impact consumers' perceptions of employees who play a role in price setting (e.g., salespeople). As such, we answer calls for B2C research in negotiations ( Boyer & Jap, 2022 ) and contribute to existing research on consumer-salesperson relationships ( Argo & Dahl, 2020 ;Orth, Bouzdine-Chameeva & Brand, 2013 ). Second, we extend research that studies the impact of salesperson attire on consumer perceptions ( Barney, Jones & Farmer, 2020 ;Wood, Boles & Babin, 2008 ). ...
... When a verbal request is coupled with a light touch on the upper arm, people are much more likely to comply with that request. Effects on compliance can be seen in a number of consumer contexts such as requests to participate in a mall-intercept interviews (Hornik & Ellis, 1988), to try a product sample in a retail store (Smith et al., 1982), to buy a new product (Smith et al., 1982), and to negotiate a deal with a salesperson (Orth et al., 2013). This tactic also works on fellow shoppers. ...
Article
Full-text available
This article details the theoretical foundation of haptics in consumer research. We structure the review using a continuum from proximal touch‐based interactions to increasingly distal interactions through devices, imagery, or language use. We begin with a focus on product/object touch in marketing highlighting touch for haptic information, touch for haptic pleasure, and touch for nonhaptic functional reasons. We then elaborate on research considering work compensating for actual touch through various mechanisms including device‐mediated touch and imagery processing. Next, we examine interpersonal touch followed by a discussion on touch in sensory words and textual paralanguage. The authors note various avenues for future research in haptics with the aim to encourage research in consumer psychology and marketing.
... In consumer research, a smaller body of literature (Bashir & Rule, 2014) has focused on the impact of nonverbal communication on the perceptions consumers form of communicators and the implications of these impressions for their persuasiveness (Webster & Sundaram, 2009). These studies highlight the roles of body posture (Gurney et al., 2017), eye gaze (Leigh & Summers, 2002), touch (Orth et al., 2013), display of emotions (Mattila & Enz, 2002), listening (Ramsey & Sohi, 1997), and clothing (Bashir & Rule, 2014). Even brief exposures to nonverbal personal cues generally yield relatively accurate judgments (Naylor, 2007). ...
Article
Expressions of dominance present potentially powerful nonverbal means for interpersonal marketing communications. Yet, research on the persuasiveness of nonverbal dominance has generated seemingly contradictory results. To reconcile these and establish whether there is a meaningful link between nonverbal dominance and persuasive outcomes, our study integrates nonverbal communication research with the warmth-competence model of social cognition. A field study and five experiments demonstrate that communicators perceived as either low or high in nonverbal dominance will generally be less persuasive than communicators exuding intermediate levels. Underlying this overall bell-shaped influence of dominance on persuasion are two independent pathways: one channeling the effect through instrumental outcomes (competence) and the other through social outcomes (warmth). Consumer focus on instrumental over social outcomes and consumer-communicator homophily represent boundary conditions. These findings suggest that nonlinear relationships may have been overlooked in past research.
... Trust in traditional channels that use service employees received considerable attention from researchers (Orth, Bouzdine-Chameeva, and Brand 2013;Jin, Ueltschy Murfield, and Bock 2022). Additionally, trustworthiness in BOPIS pickup relies on cues based on the retailer's ability and the integrity of the employees (Wingreen et al. 2019). ...
Article
Full-text available
The purpose of this study is to identify consumer attitudes toward buy online pickup in-store (BOPIS). This study examines how value perceptions change as consumers progress in the online ordering and physical pickup processes within the BOPIS channel. We use a multivariate regression and two separate multiple regression analyses to examine the differential effects of multiple constructs on BOPIS customer satisfaction. As consumers start the process by engaging with the retailer online, perceived usefulness and hedonic value online play a critical role in customer satisfaction. Consumer attitudes change as they pick up their order at the store where the degree of ease and hedonic pickup in collecting their products increases in importance in customer satisfaction. Furthermore, the study findings suggest a halo-effect for trust on BOPIS customer satisfaction. As BOPIS continues to expand into various industries, understanding the complexity of consumer value will be of importance to improve the omni-channel experience.
... Haptic refers to the active searching and gathering of information received by the hands [74], while haptics refers mostly to the global environment using technologies to stimulate tactile sensations and transfer information between an individual and an interface [9,37,50]. Furthermore, the marketing literature has shown that haptics can provide both hedonic and utilitarian values to consumers [44,94] and drive customer confidence [23,69]. In addition, previous research has demonstrated how consumers use their sense of touch in physical stores either to obtain information about the product or just for fun, which relates to an individual trait for information processing known in marketing literature as the "need for touch" (NFT) [75], and this need can also be fulfilled online [82]. ...
... Regarding grower demographics, the less of householder head's academic educational years, the more likely a grower will choose to exchange products with wholesalers or agents. Given that trust between the exchangers may be a starting point for the development of key relationship outcomes (Orth et al. 2013), our empirical result reveals that growers having higher degree of trust in agents and lower degree of trust in cooperatives are more likely to trade with apple agents. The relative risk ratio estimation results reveal that a unit increase in the degree of trust in cooperatives of growers trading with agents would lead to 55.3 percent less likely to choose agents as their trading partners. ...
Article
Based on the mathematical analysis of dominant exchange partners in agriculture, we provide a methodology from the perspective of transaction cost that can be used to deal with the relevance of fixed and proportional transaction costs related characteristics to grower choice behavior on trading partner employing multinomial logit regression model consistent with a sample of 351 apple growers collected in field survey in northwestern China. The descriptive statistics results reveal strongly a relationship amongst geographical location of farm households, contractual relationships and grower’s choice on trading partner. The empirical findings indicate that proportional transaction costs related factors have significant correlation with choice behavior on trading partner in apple market. The findings call for a greater attention to establish the trust mechanism and to regulate contractual relationship between exchangers. Encouragement in cooperatives participation of small-scale growers is also highly recommended to mitigate the proportional transaction costs and thereafter to increase agricultural incomes of farm household.
... Thus, the need to touch and see the product is a variable that influences channel choice and represents the desire for physical interaction with the product (Jin & Phua, 2015). In the research conducted by Orth et al. (2013), it has been found that many purchase decisions require a higher need for touch and feel when evaluating products (this is impossible when using online channels). In such scenarios, consumers prefer to search for products offline, but these needs do not significantly influence the purchase process itself. ...
... This is in contrast to previous studies, which showed that more price-conscious customers engage in more showrooming (Burns et al., 2018). Our results may be explained by the fact that the need for touch and feel influences customers' channel selection during information searches, and our study considered fashion products that require touch and feel before a purchase decision is made (Orth et al., 2013). Customers with low price consciousness, especially for fashion products, may be involved in more shopping activities, and showrooming is one such process during the pre-purchase journey. ...
Article
Full-text available
Purpose This study aims to examine the positive impact of showrooming on the fashion retail business by examining the interrelationship between deal-seeking on mobile devices and digital coupon redemption intention on mobile shopping intention. Design/methodology/approach Purposive sampling was used to obtain data from 496 fashion apparel customers using the database of an online survey collection platform. Stimulus organism response (S-O-R) theory was used to examine the influence of showrooming on showroomers' mobile shopping intentions. Findings The findings suggest price consciousness is negatively related to showrooming and product involvement is positively related. In addition, showrooming affects the intention to redeem digital coupons and mobile deal-seeking. The intention to redeem digital coupons boosted mobile deal-seeking behavior. The impact of mobile deal-seeking on showroomers' mobile purchase intention is significant. Research limitations/implications This research focused on fashion product consumers and generalization of the findings may be limited. The literature on positive effect of showrooming phenomenon on brick-and-mortar stores are scarce further extensive research may provide substantial generalization. Practical implications This demonstrates how showroomers may be successfully enticed to make purchases on the Brick-and-Mortar (B&M) store's online channel. Originality/value This study provides insights on navigating the showroomers into online channel customers.
... Adicionalmente, para recopilar los datos se aplicó una encuesta personal en cada uno de los museos. El diseño del instrumento se basó en el modelo de resonancia de marca evaluando atractivo y percepción a través de la propuesta de (Malhotra, 1981;Orth et al., 2013) (Véase Tabla 1). Ambas variables se manejaron de manera complementaria más no sustitutiva. ...
Article
Full-text available
At present, among the problems faced by the museums in Mexico figure the need to increase visitor numbers, create new audiences, attract public and private funding, optimise their management models, and establish competitive differences between themselves while adopting new technologies. Thus, this study examines the evaluation given by the visitors of four museums affiliated to universities in Puebla, Mexico, rating their appeal. Hence, a quantitative descriptive research was carried out from a database of 1400 valid surveys, with 385 chosen for each museum, using individual sampling by quotas. The results show the potential of the attributes identified for each institution in that they are seen as “or‑ ganized”, “pleasant” and “enjoyable”. It likewise suggests that collaboration between these organisations may increase visitor numbers.
... Interpersonal communication among employees and external publics can increase publics' trust in organizations and their intentions to choose organizations' products or services (Lee & Tao, 2020;Orth et al., 2013). This trust toward employees can increase external publics' positive word-of-mouth (WOM) communication about an organization (Gremler et al., 2001). ...
Article
Effective internal risk and crisis communication can improve organizational functioning, which ultimately can improve community resilience to crises. However, little is known about communicative behaviors associated with effective internal risk and crisis communication. Microboundary spanning theory provides a fruitful framework for examining organizations’ internal risk and crisis communication. While most microboundary spanning work examines corporate communicative behaviors, our study extends this perspective by applying it to a non-corporate context. Specifically, this study explores U.S. National Weather Service (NWS) forecasters’ communicative behaviors through 32 in-depth face-to-face interviews. Findings reveal that NWS forecasters engage in megaphoning and scouting with organizational partners and community members. These communicative behaviors are strategic and spontaneous to mitigate the impact of threats on communities. Negative megaphoning seems to contribute to organizational partners’ trust in the NWS, and trust appears to be an integral factor in the success of positive megaphoning. Findings also uncover the need for additional cross-office information seeking. Ultimately, both megaphoning and scouting enhance the NWS’s capacity to save lives during severe weather.
... Therefore, we found the feature of lots of channels and conducted this study by classifying them into face-toface service channels and non-face-to-face service channels. According to Orth, Bouzdine-Chameeva and Brand (2013), contact between customer and service provider increases trust and leads to a positive attitude of customer. Service failure damaging truth, the customer wants to be rewarded with psychological dimension for recovery of truth in case of face-to-face service channels. ...
... Since Hornik (1992) introduced NFT to the consumer research literature and called for more studies on the effect of NFT on consumer behaviour (Peck and Childers, 2003a), ample evidence has been provided that information obtained through touching products often lies at the heart of purchase decisions, and serves an information search, perceptions of product quality, brand judgments, alternative preferences, attitudes, persuasion, purchase intentions, and satisfaction (e.g. Childers and Peck, 2010;Orth et al., 2013;Vieira, 2012). For example, the need to touch a product might represent a buyer's personality trait and thereby affect each consumer's multichannel purchase behavior differently (Dholakia et al., 2010). ...
Article
Purpose - With the growth of online shopping, during which consumers are not able to touch products, there is much for researchers and marketers to learn about the underlying role of the need for touch (NFT) in driving online shopping decisions. Consumers’ emotional state prior to purchase is considered a situational variable that affects their attitude and behaviour. This study explores the effects of consumers’ NFT and pre-purchase emotional states on their online decision-making behaviour, examining perceived quality, confidence in product judgment and intention to purchase. Design/methodology/approach - A field experiment was conducted using a scenario presenting buying a sweater as a real purchase opportunity available to participants. Two hundred ninety-eight university students at a university in the southeast of France who voluntarily choose to participate were used in this study. A 2 (NFT: high/low determined by a median split) x 2 (emotional states: high/low level) analysis of variance (ANOVA) was used to further examine the interaction of NFT and emotional states in consumer decision making. Findings - The results indicate that autotelic NFT and positive emotional states experienced before shopping have an impact on consumers’ decisions in relation to perceived quality, confidence in product judgment and intention to purchase. Furthermore, this study demonstrates that instrumental vs. autotelic NFT affects consumer decision making, with mixed support found for negative emotional states acting as possible moderators. Originality/value - This study advances the NFT field and leads to insights regarding online consumer purchase decision making by exploring instrumental vs. autotelic NFT and pre-purchase emotional states as antecedents of consumer decisions.
... Salesperson's actions and behaviour such as initial contacts, identifying customer's needs, providing information and offering the right solution help to build relationships. The salesperson's interpersonal communication increase customer trust (Orth, et al., 2013). Previous literature suggest that salesperson's behaviour determines the nature of relationships and behaviour can be classified as relational oriented or consultative task oriented (Crosby, et al., 1990;Morgan & Hunt, 1994, Liu & Leach, 2001. ...
Article
Full-text available
This study examines the impact of retail services quality and selling behavior on customers’ satisfaction, trust, and store loyalty in case of high involvement products such as consumer electronics/home appliances in the context of Pakistan. The data was collected from 377 customers who completed the survey online. Respondents were particularly asked if they had any experience of buying such items recently and keeping in mind the purchase experience, rate the scale items accordingly. Factor analysis and multiple regression analysis were used for model testing. The study results show that store service quality and selling orientation strategy both have a significant impact on customer satisfaction, trust and store loyalty intentions. The study also involves the mediation analysis, satisfaction‐trust serving as mediator factor between two IVs (service quality and selling behaviors) and DV (store loyalty intentions). Results show that services quality and selling behaviour both have significant influence on store loyalty intentions. Further, satisfaction‐trust mediates the relationship between variables. The indirect path is significant which proves that satisfaction‐trust mediate the relationship between store attributes and consumer buying behaviour. The study has significant implications for multiple retail channels that can incorporate retail service quality and selling behaviour strategy (relational selling & consultative selling) to differentiate the retail brand services. Retailers of high involvement products category heavily relying on the selling skills and behaviour of salesperson/employee, can benefit from the study to implement retail brand positioning strategy.
... According to Hao et al. (2012), satisfaction refers to the feeling or emotion of a person perceived by their expectations and wishes. It is essential for a company to create and maintain customers' trust [22] as it is a necessary ingredient for a long-term salesperson-customer relationship [23,24] and for the development of long-term business [25]. ...
... Hence, country image can be seen as the behavioral manifestation of the consumer's overall interpretation of a product's attributes stemming from the product's COO. As country image is used by consumers to determine perceived product quality, factors such as trust and safety play a pivotal role in product evaluation (Böcker and Hanf, 2000;Orth et al., 2013;Aprile et al., 2016). For example, in line with the above-mentioned findings of Lewis and Grebitus (2016), Loureiro and Umberger (2005) showed that U.S. consumers preferred beef from the U. S. as they perceived it as safer than foreign beef. ...
Article
With rising incomes and urbanization, diets across Sub-Saharan Africa (SSA) have diversified in source and form, encompassing more processed and packaged foods. While previous studies have identified ethnocentrism to be an influencing factor of purchase behavior, so far, no study has evaluated consumer ethnocentrism for food products in Nigeria. We conducted a study involving 2250 Nigerian consumers, using a widely validated consumer ethnocentric tendencies scale (CETSCALE). We aimed to answer the following questions: i) Are Nigerian consumers ethnocentric and how does this vary by socio-demographics? ii) Does consumer ethnocentrism affect their purchase frequency of imported food products? iii) What roles do country image and relatedly food safety concerns play in food purchasing behavior of imported food? We find that consumer ethnocentrism is indeed established in Nigeria among a large share of consumers. It is driven by key factors such as country image and food safety, and it tends to be strongly affected by socio-demographics such as income and education. We also find that ethnocentrism’s influence on purchase behavior varies across food categories. Our findings suggest that COO-labelling and a reliable formalization of product traceability with the support of the government could allow marketers to better capitalize on consumer ethnocentrism.
... Trust, a vital component in customer-firm relationships, is known to affect satisfaction, perceived product attractiveness/quality, purchase intentions, loyalty, and positive word of mouth (Kang & Hustvedt, 2014;Orth, Bouzdine-Chameeva, & Brand, 2013). Trust is associated with qualities of consistency, bias suppression, ethicality, respectfulness, supportiveness, and openness (Mayer, Davis, & Schoorman, 1995). ...
Article
In this study we explore the mediating role of managerial ability in the relationship between gender diversity and firm performance. Drawing on diversity, gender, and upper echelon theories, we propose that the addition of unique female perspectives and leadership styles will afford gender-diverse TMTs a managerial capability advantage over equally talented yet homogeneous male teams; and this link between gender diversity and managerial capability will be more pronounced in times of crisis. Our results confirm our hypotheses. Our key finding is that increasing female representation in TMTs has a substantial and direct influence on overall managerial capabilities and elicits positive performance effects both in times of stability and more so, in times of crisis. Notably, and unique to this study, we show that managerial ability completely (partially) mediates the gender diversity-performance link suggesting that feminine traits and transformational leadership styles are more efficacious in contemporary leadership contexts than generally believed.
... Trust, a vital component in customer-firm relationships, is known to affect satisfaction, perceived product attractiveness/quality, purchase intentions, loyalty, and positive word of mouth (Kang & Hustvedt, 2014;Orth, Bouzdine-Chameeva, & Brand, 2013). Trust is associated with qualities of consistency, bias suppression, ethicality, respectfulness, supportiveness, and openness (Mayer, Davis, & Schoorman, 1995). ...
Article
Firms often strive to delight their customers and build strong customer-firm relationships by providing favored benefits to their customers. Drawing from the organizational justice literature, we show that even when customers receive favorable outcomes from distributively fair firm actions, considerations of procedural unfairness may adversely affect their firm evaluations. Procedural fairness salience and customers’ perceived relationship with the firm determine the extent to which procedural fairness affects firm-evaluations. Customers in communal relationships, focused on social/relational factors, are more sensitive to procedural fairness, leading to improved (diminished) firm evaluations when the procedure is perceived as fair (unfair). Those in exchange relationships are unaffected by procedural fairness and evaluate the firm based largely on outcome favorability. Firm trustworthiness mediates the impact of procedural fairness on evaluations. Implications of procedural fairness being driven by relational and non-instrumental considerations are discussed.
... With few exceptions (Martin 2012;Orth, Bouzdine-Chameeva, and Brand 2013;Webb and Peck 2015), previous work in marketing has focused on product touch (Argo, Dahl and Morales 2006;Brasel and Gips 2014;Grohmann, Spangenberg, and Sprott 2007;Krishna and Morrin 2008;McCabe and Nowlis 2003;Peck, Barger, and Webb 2013;Peck and Shu 2009) in which understanding the effects of touch, the motivations to touch, and how to compensate for an inability to touch are important for understanding consumer purchase decisions. While there is theoretical overlap with literature on product touch (e.g., both rely on haptics, or touch with the hand), our work fits into a broader theoretical context of source effects of social influence in consumer experiences. ...
Article
Full-text available
Previous research has highlighted the effects of receiving interpersonal touch on persuasion. In contrast, we examine initiating touch. Individuals instructed to touch engage in egocentric projection in which they project their own affective reaction onto their expectations for how the recipient will feel (i.e., empathic forecast), how they appear to the recipient (i.e., metaperception), and the evaluation of the interaction itself (i.e., interaction awkwardness). Touch initiators expect that recipients will feel worse with touch, express concern for how they, themselves, will be perceived, and think interactions are more awkward. Interestingly, touch recipients do not evaluate these interactions more negatively and leave higher tips after having been touched; touch initiators do not expect this to be the case. As a result, instructed touch initiators (vs. volitional touch initiators) are less (more) likely to engage in subsequent interactions with customers, potentially undermining future service provided to customers. Across five studies, four of which involve actual dyadic interactions, we test the consequences of initiating touch with an inquiry into the effects of interpersonal touch on the initiator. We discuss theoretical and managerial implications.
... Many academic researchers recognize the relevance of in-store personnel in influencing consumers' offline store experiences (Bäckstrom & Johanson, 2006;Grewal, Baker, Levy, & Voss, 2003;Haas & Kenning, 2014;Naylor & Frank, 2000;Orth, Bouzdine-Chameeva, & Brand, 2013). By providing consumers with the needed information and acting in a social, friendly manner, in-store personnel are a driving force behind the generation of offline store revenues (Rutherford, 2012). ...
Article
Full-text available
In today’s multichannel retail environment, consumers’ experiences in one channel influence their perceptions of another channel. Specifically, consumer evaluations of a firm’s online store have been found to be influenced by consumer interactions with the firm’s in‐store personnel. This paper is among the first to address this assumption and test it empirically. Drawing upon the analogical transfer paradigm, we propose hypotheses and accordingly model in‐store personnel’s competence and friendliness as determinants of online store usefulness, online store enjoyment, and online store value. Using consumer data collected from two Dutch multichannel retailers, we test this model with partial least squares modeling. The results provide clear support for the model and confirm that consumers may use characteristics of in‐store personnel as analogies when evaluating a firm’s online store. Implications for research and retail managers are discussed.
... The presentation of facts intended to support a conclusion Arguments are not presented as stories Stories and metaphors in retail selling Campbell and Davis, 2006). Orth et al. (2013) also explored touch as interpersonal communication driving trust building. Note that ideas like affiliative or dominant communication styles consist of a set of behaviours rather than being linguistic communication tools and are thus substantially different (Webster and Sundaram, 2009). ...
Article
Purpose The purpose of this paper is to propose future directions for research into stories and metaphors as concise communication tools that are particularly salient for the fast pace of today’s retail sales environment. Design/methodology/approach A cross disciplinary approach is taken to propose new avenues for sales communication research. Findings This work highlights research possibilities into the contextually sensitive constructs of stories and metaphors with associated theoretical approaches. This could improve research into stories and metaphors as communication techniques for retail selling. Research limitations/implications The findings indicate that stories and metaphors are highly engaging sensemaking tools that salespeople can use in retail sales encounters. The lack of existing literature within the sales domain suggests a significant learning curve in demarcating the use of these tools. Practical implications Stories and metaphors are presently used by salespeople but without the benefit of extensive scientific understanding. This paper builds a foundation for research that could bring clarity to the use of these tools in retail selling. Originality/value Researchers will benefit from a finer grained conceptualization with which to examine sales communication. The proposed research should get sales practitioners a clearer understanding of using stories and metaphors in sales encounters.
... As for physical contact, some individuals see it as agreeable and for others not so much, as it varies according to the culture, subculture, and ethnicities that the individual is inserted (Hornik, 1992). The intensity of NFT can vary according to the cultural values of each country and that every society has its normative rules for touch (Orth, Chameeva & Brand, 2013). ...
Poster
Full-text available
Technological advances allow new points of contact, where the salesperson-consumer interaction can be in the digital, physical environment, or both. Guo and Main (2017) suggest that sellers should adjust their approach based on consumer characteristics such as mood and buying motivation, thus creating a better perception of the service and further memorable experiences (Bustamante & Rubio, 2017). Given the complexity of the effects of the human variable in the retail environment (Turley & Milliman, 2000) which presents itself as a rich empirical context for behavioral investigations (Penz & Hogg, 2011), the research is oriented by the following question: how do the interactions occur between salesperson and consumers in the surfwear retail?.
... Orth, Chameeva, and Brand (2013) France, Germany In a lab experiment, salespeople were significantly more trustable in a "touch" condition (i.e., the salesperson placing a hand on the buyer's shoulder for 1-2 seconds) than in a "no touch" condition. In turn, trust positively affected buyer evaluations of the salesperson's product. ...
Article
Full-text available
This research uses a combination of text mining, co-word analysis, and social network analysis (SNA) to review 132 international sales and sales management (ISSM) articles published between 1980 and 2017. The study provides a unique view of the past and future of ISSM research and provides three principal contributions. First, from a social network–analytic perspective, it offers a unique examination of the ways ISSM research topics are interconnected, as reflected by keyword network structure. Second, by conducting SNA across two periods (1980–1999 and 2000–2017) and examining the changes in network centrality measures, the study offers initial insights into the evolving nature of the ISSM literature. Third, the study reports keyword network disconnections (i.e., structural holes) to propose a fruitful agenda for future ISSM research. Taken together, this research offers a current perspective of the ISSM research domain's evolving nature.
... Salespersons' expertise and communicative power lead to higher customer trust (Doney & Cannon, 1997). Moreover, a salesperson's touch increases trust (Orth, Bouzdine-Chameeva, & Brand, 2013). ...
Thesis
Full-text available
How can be developed and impacted relationships in store? Many researches have studied in-store actions in a transactional perspective while relationship marketing has paid little attention to what happens in store. However, stores constitute a key point of contact between consumers and brands. Based on two qualitative studies and an experimental study, this research focuses on the impact of in-store actions on consumer-brand relationships. It differentiates relational and transactional actions and compares their effects. The empirical application involves ice cream brands distributed in the super-hypermarket channel. An online questionnaire is implemented to test fictitious actions that brands could implement. Our results show the interest for manufacturers brands to use relational in-store actions. Individuals exposed to relational in-store actions attribute more frequently the effort to the manufacturer. They perceive stronger efforts and brand expression, they identify more with the brand, and declare a higher loyalty to the latter. On the whole, in-store actions demonstrate the brand relational orientation and contribute to the relationship quality. The originality of the research lies in the consideration of in-store actions in a relational perspective. More generally, the conceptualization and the study of the impact of these kinds of actions highlight a more social way to consider interactions between consumers and brands in the marketplace.
... If this is indeed the case, heterosexual female customers should express a stronger favorable response to working with gay male sales associates than their straight male counterparts when purchasing. For example, sales associates and customers often engage in intimate touching during retail encounters, especially in the selling of cosmetics and apparel (Orth et al., 2013). ...
Article
Full-text available
This article explores an under-researched area in retailing; namely, straight female shoppers’ preferences for working with gay male sales associates. Study 1 employs qualitative methodology to show that female shoppers often prefer working with gay male sales associates when they are older or heavier than female sales associates. Study 2 employs experimental methodology to show that female shoppers desire to work with gay male associates more than their straight male counterparts when they are purchasing merchandise requiring non-sexual intimacy, such as apparel and cosmetics. The results should help retailers understand why many female shoppers willingly, and comfortably, work with gay male sales associates and the role of gay associates in various retail departments.
Chapter
Full-text available
Dijital dünyanın hızlı bir şekilde gelişmesi sayesinde tüketicilerin internet üzerinden alışveriş yapma sıklığı artmıştır. Önceleri sadece fiziksel mağazalardan alışveriş yapan tüketiciler dijitalleşmenin hayatlarına girmesi ile çok kanallı alışveriş olanağı ile karşı karşıya kalmıştır. Çok kanallı alışveriş olanağı sayesinde tüketiciler bazı kanallarda ürünü veya ürünün fiyatını araştırmakta, ürünü denemekte, diğer kanallardan ise satın almayı gerçekleştirmektedir. Bu durum da çok kanallı alışveriş türlerinden biri olan showrooming davranışına daha fazla başvurulmasına neden olmuştur. Showrooming tüketicilerin mağazaya gidip ürün ve fiyat incelemesi yaparak beğendikleri ve uygun fiyatlı olduğunu düşündükleri ürünleri internet üzerinden satın alma davranışlarıdır. Özellikle kozmetik ürünlerde tüketicilerin mağazada inceleme yapıp daha sonra aynı ürünü uygun fiyata internetten satın aldığı görülmektedir. Ürün reklamlarında kullanılan ünlülerin çekicilik, dürüstlük ve uzmanlık özelliklerine vurgu yapılması da tüketicileri etkileyebilmekte, böylelikle tüketiciler internet üzerinden daha kolay alışveriş yapabilmektedir. Tüketicilerin kozmetik ürünleri satın almasını sağlamak için kozmetik ürünlerin reklamlarında genellikle ünlü kişiler kullanılmaktadır. Reklamlarda kullanılan ünlüler tüketicilerin markaya güven duymasını da sağlamaktadır. Ek olarak tüketicilerin markaya güvenduymaları internetten ürün alma olasılığını da artırmaktadır. Bu nedenle bu araştırmanın amacı kozmetik ürün satın alan tüketicilerde reklamlarda ünlü kullanımının showrooming davranışı ve marka güveni üzerindeki etkisini ortaya çıkartmaktır. Araştırmanın örneklemini Türkiye’de yaşayan 18 yaş ve üstü 399 tüketici oluşturmaktadır. Katılımcılara kolayda örnekleme yöntemi vasıtasıyla ulaşılmıştır. Veriler çevrim içi anket yöntemi ile toplanmıştır. Reklamlarda Ünlü Kullanımı Ölçeği çekicilik, dürüstlük ve uzmanlık olmak üzere üç alt faktörden, Marka Güveni Ölçeği güvenirlik ve niyet boyutlarından ve son olarak Showrooming Ölçeği de tek faktör 5 ifadeden meydana gelmektedir. Öncelikle verilere doğrulayıcı faktör analizi yapılmış, daha sonra da hipotezleri test edebilmek için yapısal eşitlik modeli kullanılmıştır. Doğrulayıcı faktör analizi sonucuna göre reklamda ünlü kullanımı çekicilik, dürüstlük ve uzmanlık olmak üzere üç alt boyuttan, marka güveni güvenirlik ve niyet boyutlarından, showrooming davranışı ise tek alt boyuttan meydana gelmektedir. Araştırma sonuçlarına göre reklamlarda kullanılan ünlünün uzmanlığı showrooming davranışını, çekiciliği marka güvenirliğini ve son olarak showrooming davranışı marka güvenirlik ve niyetini etkilemektedir
Article
Full-text available
Human resources in any organization have a significant impact on how one organization excels in competition with others, which in some areas, such as face-to-face sales, this role is more important. The purpose of this study is evaluation of the effect of salesperson gender and age (demographic characteristics), salesperson height and weight on buyer trust to a salesperson, using conjoint analysis approach and Based on Homophily theory. Data were collected from clothing buyers in Tehran through 194 questionnaires using in hand sampling. Results show the main factor affecting buyer’s confidence to a salesperson is his/her weight with the average importance of 28.5%. Salesperson’s age, height, and gender are located in the next priorities with average importance of 27/7, 23/9 and 19/9% respectively. Based on results effect of different surface of salesperson characteristics on buyer’s trust shows the same gender, weight and height of salesperson and buyer led to more confidence of buyer. Also, the difference in age between salesperson and buyer, decrease buyer’s trust. The results of ranking 12 types of salespersons according to the utility average shows the first rank allocates to a salesperson with these characteristics: different gender from a buyer, older than a buyer, similar weight and taller than the buyer. Also, the last rank allocated to a salesperson includes characteristics as the similar gender with the buyer, same age as the buyer, different weight with the buyer and taller than him/her
Article
Full-text available
Purpose The purpose of this paper is twofold. First, it seeks to extend service and retailers understanding of how the inclusion of haptics can gamify digital service experiences. Second, it seeks to understand the moderating role of consumers orientation towards adventure in service experiences. Design/methodology/approach This research adopts a two-study, 2 (haptic technology: present vs absent) × 2 (adventure orientation: high vs low) to test the proposed hypotheses (Study 1 n = 210, Study 2 n = 452). The data are tested using ANCOVA's and Hayes PROCESS Macro to investigate mean differences and the potential presence of two different moderated mediated relationships. Findings The results are consistent across the two experimental studies evidencing that the inclusion of haptics to gamify the service experience leads to significantly improved outcomes for service brands and channels. Further, the results demonstrate that the impact of haptics is greater for consumers with a lower, compared to higher, sense of adventure. Thus, the results demonstrate that whilst haptics improves consumers experiences with technological services overall, this is more prevalent for those who have “less sense of adventure”. Originality/value This paper sheds insight into the emerging area of haptic technology and is one of the first to specifically examine the impact of consumers “sense of adventure.”
Article
Trust has an imperative role in online advertising because the effectiveness of the adverts will be greatly affected when consumers distrust online adverts. Currently, the level of consumers' trust in online advertising remains low. The current study will assess the drivers of trust by integrating the Trust Building Model and the ADTRUST scale. Unlike present literature that utilized linear models, a Structural Equation Modelling-Artificial Neural Network (SEM-ANN) approach was used. This is because consumers’ trust-building is a complex process and linear models will over-simplify the complexity in the decision-making processes. Thus, the outcomes from linear models are inadequate and inaccurate to explicate the mechanism of trust creation in online advertising. Data were gathered from 500 online consumers using a mall intercept technique. The outcomes from the sensitivity analysis show that reliability is the most imperative antecedent of trust followed by website quality, willingness to rely on, reputation, and hours spent. The model predicts 76.14% trust in online advertising. The theoretical implication is the integration of the ADTRUST scale with the Trust Building Model. The methodological implication is the use of the SEM-ANN approach that captured both linear-nonlinear and compensatory-non-compensatory associations. The findings provide some useful practical implications for online advertisers, service providers, and retailers. The study has contributed useful theoretical and practical implications to the online marketing literature.
Article
This research aims to examine and contrast trust in consumer-salesperson/organization relationships in direct selling and Internet (online) marketing in China, a large and fast-growing market for both approaches in B2C marketing. A personal interview survey involving two different measures of trust (i.e., cognitive trust and organization trust) was conducted. Two sample groups were obtained independently from southern and northern cities in China. For cognitive trust, there is a significant difference between the two shopping approaches (Internet marketing vs. direct selling), with the value of trust generally being greater for direct selling. In contrast, for organization trust, the value is greater for Internet marketing. However, the overall results show that neither the measure of cognitive trust nor the measure of organization trust is a good predictor of consumer behavior. Managerial implications and recommendations for future research directions are discussed.
Article
Full-text available
Purpose The purpose of this paper is to investigate how social loneliness, emotional loneliness and social isolation relate to Indian consumers’ enjoyment of social interaction with an in-store salesperson. Design/methodology/approach Over 300 Indian respondents are surveyed about personal disposition, shopping experiences and other factors. The research model and hypotheses are evaluated utilizing partial least squares structural equation modeling. Findings As posited, Indian consumers dealing with loneliness and social isolation tend to enjoy in-store shopping experiences involving personal interactions with salespersons. Further, salespersons’ adaptive selling relates positively to consumers’ predisposition to comply with salesperson input and three outcomes (i.e. trust in salesperson, purchase intention and retail patronage). Originality/value This study fills a void in current marketing and retailing literature, providing one of the first known empirical investigations of consumers’ experiences with loneliness and social isolation. Overall, the study shows that store-based retailers within culturally collectivistic emerging markets can capitalize on their unique ability to attract and retain shoppers through in-store salesperson interactions.
Article
Today, with the fierce competition, the importance of effective sales capabilities in differentiated core competencies has been more emphasized. Businesses are getting through strengthened sales capabilities and generate sustainable performance over this very important relationships with existing customers. In this situation, important effective selling behaviors are adaptive selling behavior and relationship-oriented selling behavior in this respect. Adaptive selling behavior has been a lot of studies by the Weits and his colleagues in the 1990s. After that, it has been a lot of studies on customer-oriented selling behavior and relationship-oriented selling behavior in the 2000s. In this study, we tried to establish a theoretical concept through the review of existing research on relationshp oriented selling behavior which has been studied most actively in effective selling behavior research. Based on this review process, we clarify the deficiencies in the existing research and try to establish the Korean concept of relationship-oriented selling behavior through qualitative research. To achieve this goal, in the interviews with the salespersons of a Korean finance company (Aju Capital), wey derive the concept of nation relationship-oriented selling behavior and evaluate the configuration of factors. Interview results are sorted and analyzed according to the contents of Grounded theory which is most commonly used in qualitative methods. As grounded theory suggested, Interview process was recorded and the transcripts of the interview records were made. By a total of four researchers, including the two research assistant, analysis of the transcripts was done. At first, each researcher organized each concept and specific factors mentioned by the salesperson and if there is a difference in opinion of all researchers in the classification process, it was adjusted through discussion. Based on the results of the analysis derive a conceptual model of the Korea relationship-oriented selling process and proposed a six research propositions. Research proposition 1 are intended to present the relationships between salesperson’s intention to make a relationship with customer and factors which influence the relationship making intention. Those factors are leadership, relevance, interactivity, performance, integrity, and similarities. Research Proposition 2 has set a positive relationship between the intention and the formation of relationship. Proposition 3 presents the three factors that affect the trust of the public relations with the customer (comfort, integrity, and altruism (care)). Research Proposition 4 is presented two factors (sincerity and sharing of information) which influence trust and informal relationship and a factor (personal meeting) that affect informal relationship. Research proposition 5 emphasizes the importance of trust in both formal and informal relationships and suggested that public relations are proposed to have a positive impact on informal relationship. Finally, the study proposes expected performances through relationship with customers which are financial performance, collaboration and referral behaviors. Those performance are all long term oriented performances in customer perspective. This paper presents a theoretical contributions and practical implications in the following ways: First, this study suggested the process of relationship-oriented selling behavior and proposed the elements of relationship orientation in Korea. Second we proposed that the process of relationship oriented selling behavior is divided into relationship intentions, relationship forming and expected performance from relationship making process. In practice, we suggested relationship-oriented outcomes in assessment portion of the sales people (financial performance, collaboration and referral act) and the relationship-oriented selling is very important to generate revenue in the long term of the company.
Article
Purpose The purpose of this paper is to examine the dimensions of interpersonal trust which would affect the buyer-salesperson relationship in a direct selling situation. It also investigates consumers’ perceived risk and advantages of direct selling. Design/methodology/approach A questionnaire survey of consumers (and also non-consumers) of direct selling companies in Hong Kong was performed by means of mall-intercept interview. The major measurements were perceived risk, perceived advantages, trust dimensions, and repurchase intention. Findings The results show that there are six dimensions of interpersonal trust in the buyer-seller relationship in direct selling, but only one dimension (i.e. honesty) has a significant relationship with repurchase intention. The ability to shop at home is found to have the highest advantage rating of direct selling. In addition, direct selling is perceived to have a lower level of risk than unsolicited telephone call such as telemarketing. Originality/value This is the first study to investigate the effects of different dimensions of interpersonal trust on consumer buying behavior under a direct selling situation in Asia. The study also serves as a foundation for studying the applicability and usefulness of all trust measures in other western or non-western cultures/nations.
Article
Full-text available
Airline flight attendants' touching of 158 passengers on the shoulder or forearm increased their liking of the 4 attendants and the airline in general and also their perceived flight safety.
Article
Full-text available
The most commonly used method to test an indirect effect is to divide the estimate of the indirect effect by its standard error and compare the resulting z statistic with a critical value from the standard normal distribution. Confidence limits for the indirect effect are also typically based on critical values from the standard normal distribution. This article uses a simulation study to demonstrate that confidence limits are imbalanced because the distribution of the indirect effect is normal only in special cases. Two alternatives for improving the performance of confidence limits for the indirect effect are evaluated: (a) a method based on the distribution of the product of two normal random variables, and (b) resampling methods. In Study 1, confidence limits based on the distribution of the product are more accurate than methods based on an assumed normal distribution but confidence limits are still imbalanced. Study 2 demonstrates that more accurate confidence limits are obtained using resampling methods, with the bias-corrected bootstrap the best method overall.
Article
Full-text available
Studies that combine moderation and mediation are prevalent in basic and applied psychology research. Typically, these studies are framed in terms of moderated mediation or mediated moderation, both of which involve similar analytical approaches. Unfortunately, these approaches have important shortcomings that conceal the nature of the moderated and the mediated effects under investigation. This article presents a general analytical framework for combining moderation and mediation that integrates moderated regression analysis and path analysis. This framework clarifies how moderator variables influence the paths that constitute the direct, indirect, and total effects of mediated models. The authors empirically illustrate this framework and give step-by-step instructions for estimation and interpretation. They summarize the advantages of their framework over current approaches, explain how it subsumes moderated mediation and mediated moderation, and describe how it can accommodate additional moderator and mediator variables, curvilinear relationships, and structural equation models with latent variables.
Article
Full-text available
It has previously been suggested that consumers' product evaluations are positively affected by tactile interaction. However, it is not known if it is applicable to products that people usually touch for brief periods of time. This study sets out to explore whether it is possible to influence consumers' tactile perception of fast-moving consumer goods by altering the surface texture. In this study individual tactile sensing and visual appreciation were compared with the combined visual and tactile sensing of surface textures for two types of products (soap and biscuits). Three types of textures on the outside of either a soap or biscuit box and three separate sample swatches of the textures used on the boxes were used in the study. The three soap or biscuit boxes were visually presented to the participants. This was followed by a blind haptic evaluation of the three textures, and then by a combined visual and tactile evaluation of three differently textured boxes (either soap or biscuit boxes). The results suggest that a consumer's perception of the packaging of fast-moving consumer goods is affected more by vision than by touch, which raises some questions with regard to when marketers should encourage consumers to engage in extensive tactile interaction prior to purchase. © 2011 Wiley Periodicals, Inc.
Article
Full-text available
Success in selling demands effective trust earning behavior. This article examines and compares the perceptions of manufacturers' reps and purchasing executives in relation to this process of earning the buyer's trust. The results indicate statistically significant differences over the two groups in their perceptions of how various trust earning components contribute to the development of buyer trust. Manufacturers' reps overestimated the trust earning potential of the “likeable,” “competent,” and “dependable” constructs. Manufacturers' reps also held an inflated view of the overall extent to which they were trusted by purchasing executives.
Article
Full-text available
Whereas most research has focused on the negative aspects of touch in the workplace (i.e. sexual harassment), this study focuses upon the positive use of touch. In an effort to explain individual differences in the use of workplace touch, three sequential studies are used to introduce the concepts of workplace touch self-efficacy and workplace touch initiation anxiety. In Study 1 we develop scales to assess the constructs. Study 2 provides an initial examination of the construct validity of the measures developed in Study 1. Results of Study 3 indicate that supervisor reports of touch self-efficacy and physiological touch anxiety are related to subordinate reports of supervisor touch. Additionally, results show that supervisor use of touch is related to several indicators of supervisor social effectiveness. Finally, sex of the supervisor appears to play a role in workplace touch as female supervisors report less touch anxiety, greater touch self-efficacy and more use of touch than male supervisors.
Article
Full-text available
Scholars have paid increasing attention to the role of non-verbal communication within intimate relationships. Reportedly, immediate behaviors such as touch escalate opposite-sex relationships by promoting increased intimacy and psychological closeness. This study examined the effects of relational stage, gender and touch avoidance on unobtrusively coded public touch behavior. An ANOVA indicated that relational stage was curvilinearly related to public interpersonal touch such that the level of touch was higher in intermediate stage of relationships than in either initial or stable stages. Gender had no effect on touch. Instead, a high correlation was found between the amount of touch used by males and the amount of touch used by their female partners. Touch avoidance was found to be linearly related to the amount of touch displayed, with low touch avoiders touching the most and high touch avoiders touching the least. There was a strong additive effect for touch avoidance, with all three touch avoidance groups following a curvilinear pattern for relational stage. x² tests found that touch increased primarily in the hand and waist areas during the intermediate stage. Implications for the study of reciprocity, immediacy, intimacy and stage theory are discussed.
Article
Full-text available
The authors report a study of the effects of price, brand, and store information on buyers' perceptions of product quality and value, as well as their willingness to buy. Hypotheses are derived from a conceptual model positing the effects of extrinsic cues (price, brand name, and store name) on buyers' perceptions and purchase intentions. Moreover, the design of the experiment allows additional analyses on the relative differential effects of price, brand name, and store name on the three dependent variables. Results indicate that price had a positive effect on perceived quality, but a negative effect on perceived value and willingness to buy. Favorable brand and store information positively influenced perceptions of quality and value, and subjects' willingness to buy. The major findings are discussed and directions for future research are suggested.
Article
Full-text available
Attitudes toward same sex touching is an area of considerable importance to understanding sex‐role rigidity and heterosexual intimacy, and are thought to be significant to sexual adjustment and well‐being. A reliable and valid scale is needed for research on same sex touching. In this article, seven phases in the development of a Likert‐type scale measuring attitudes toward same sex touching (SSTS) are described. Phase 1 of the study was an item analysis producing part‐whole correlations ranging from .72 to .82, alpha = .98, and reproducibility = .93. Further, in Phase 2, the SSTS was shown to have moderate relationships to authoritarianism (r = ‐.38, p ≤ .01), rigidity (r = ‐.48, p ≤ .01), and socially desirable conceptions of femininity for both males (r = .46, p ≤ .01), and females (r = .31, p ≤ .01). In Phase 3 the construct validity correlations of Phase 2 were generally replicated. In Phases 4 and 5 significant correlations were found between the SSTS and Machiavellianism (r = ‐.25, p ≤ .05), religious orthodoxy (r = ‐.29, p ≤ .05), and locus of control (r = .35, p ≤ .05) for males and with radicalism—conservatism (r = .36, p ≤ .05) and self‐esteem (r = ‐.33, p ≤ .05) for females. Phase 5 yielded a ‐.77 (p ≤ .01) correlation between SSTS and the criterion touch‐avoidance measure. Finally, results from Phases 6 and 7 demonstrated promising SSTS discriminant validity. In particular, more positive attitudes were found for counseling as compared to science students. Furthermore, students working in task groups under cooperative conditions discriminate effectively on the SSTS for both self‐ and peer rankings on ease of same sex touching behavior.
Article
Full-text available
Purpose The purpose of this paper is to develop and test a comprehensive model of customer trust in a retail service setting. Three levels of the customer‐to‐store relationship are simultaneously taken into account: customer to sales associates, customer to store branded products, and customer to the store itself. Design/methodology/approach Using partial least square (PLS) on a sample of 393 customers of an Italian supermarket retailer, a model linking customer trust (in the store, in store branded products and in sales associates) to overall perceived value and store loyalty intentions and behaviors is tested. Subsequently an expanded model to determine the influence of managerially controlled antecedent variables (salespeople's trustworthiness, store environment, store assortment, and communications) is estimated on the various trust levels. Findings Trust in the salesperson and trust in store branded products have positive effects on overall store trust. Store trust, in turn, increases perceived value and loyalty intentions. Looking at the drivers of the three levels of customer trust, salesperson trustworthiness positively affects only trust in the salesperson. Store environment has a positive impact only on overall trust in the store. Store communication fosters all three levels of customer trust, while store assortment increases both overall trust and trust in store branded products. Practical implications Findings of the study suggest an alternative perspective to the dominant strategies in grocery retailing services. To foster store patronage, retailers have typically invested in price cuts, promotions and loyalty schemes. Store managers may rather use sales associates, the store environment, store assortment, store branded products, and communication to foster customer trust and increase customer loyalty. Managing store brands with the goal to build trust, as opposed to increase immediate profit margins, may call for a completely different approach to private labels. Similarly, the potential relevance of interpersonal trust may suggest retailers to devote more resources to selection, recruitment and training of sales associates, and may stimulate changes in evaluation criteria, incentive schemes and reward systems. Originality/value The study aims at filling two important gaps in the literature: the scarcity of comprehensive store patronage models and the lack of exploration of the operational means of improving customer trust in retail services.
Article
Full-text available
My purpose in this article is to introduce studying cultural variability in communication in general and this special issue in particular. I begin by examining the nature of culture. Next, I review the emic and etic approaches to studying communication and culture with a focus on the major dimensions of cultural variability used to explain communication across cultures. Following this, I examine individual-level processes that mediate the influence of culture on communication. I conclude by overviewing the articles included in this issue and discussing how they are consistent with current trends in the study of cultural variability in communication.
Article
Full-text available
Examines distance, axis, and tactility patterns of people engaged in dyadic communication in Germany, Italy, and the United States and concludes that contrary to Edward Hall's position, the cultures studied are too behaviorally diverse to be classified as strictly contact or noncontact cultures. (MH)
Article
Full-text available
Examined how adult attachment styles moderate spontaneous behavior between dating couples when 1 member of the dyad is confronted with an anxiety-provoking situation. 83 dating couples were unobtrusively videotaped for 5 min in a waiting room while the woman waited to participate in an "activity" known to provoke anxiety in most people. Independent observers then evaluated each partner's behavior on several dimensions. Results revealed that persons with more secure attachment styles behaved differently than persons with more avoidant styles in terms of physical contact, supportive comments, and efforts to seek and give emotional support. Findings are discussed in the context of theory and research on attachment. (PsycINFO Database Record (c) 2012 APA, all rights reserved)
Article
Full-text available
The effect on the impact of a message of explicitly stating a desire to persuade can depend on the communicator's physical attractiveness. Experiment 1 confirmed this possibility. Attractive male and female salespersons induced more positive attitudes and stronger intentions to purchase a product when they explicitly stated their desire to influence potential buyers. In contrast, unattractive salespersons were less likely to induce a favorable attitude toward the product under these conditions. Experiment 2 replicated these effects and provided evidence that they are mediated by the attribution of self-serving motives to the salesperson. A 2-step process of impression formation and attribution was used to describe the mechanisms underlying these effects. (PsycINFO Database Record (c) 2012 APA, all rights reserved)
Article
Full-text available
To describe sex differences in interpersonal touch, observation was made of 4,500 dyads in their teens and older in public places. The principal analyses addressed the issue of asymmetry in the initiation of touch in mixed sex dyads. Over all ages and initiating body parts, males touched females (MF touch) with the same frequency that females touched males (FM touch). However, among younger dyads, MF touch prevailed, whereas the reverse was true for older dyads. Though there was a tendency for MF touch with the hand to exceed FM touch with the hand, significant sex differences appeared only for "arm around," in which MF touch prevailed, and "arms linked," in which FM touch was more common. Analyses also addressed main effects of toucher sex and recipient sex, male–male vs female–female touch, and same- vs opposite-sex touch. (PsycINFO Database Record (c) 2012 APA, all rights reserved)
Article
Advertisements containing product endorsements by a third-party organization (TPO), product endorsements by a celebrity, or no endorsement were compared for their ability to affect the dependent variables of perceived product quality, attitude toward the manufacturer, purchase risk, and information value of the ad. In addition, prior brand evaluation and source (endorser) trustworthiness were tested as moderators of the endorsement effect. In two factorial experiments, one for a desktop computer and one for auto insurance, significant main effects were found for endorsement and brand but not for trustworthiness. Brand interacted with endorsement in the quality perception of computers. In both experiments, TPO endorsement was particularly effective in enhancing respondent perceptions of product quality. It is concluded that TPO endorsement may function as an extrinsic quality cue in advertising.
Article
The authors integrate theory developed in several disciplines to determine five cognitive processes through which industrial buyers can develop trust of a supplier firm and its salesperson. These processes provide a theoretical framework used to identify antecedents of trust. The authors also examine the impact of supplier firm and salesperson trust on a buying firm's current supplier choice and future purchase intentions. The theoretical model is tested on data collected from more than 200 purchasing managers. The authors find that several variables influence the development of supplier firm and salesperson trust. Trust of the supplier firm and trust of the salesperson (operating indirectly through supplier firm trust) influence a buyer's anticipated future interaction with the supplier. However, after controlling for previous experience and supplier performance, neither trust of the selling firm nor its salesperson influence the current supplier selection decision.
Article
This study examined how adult attachment styles moderate spontaneous behavior between dating couples when 1 member of the dyad is confronted with an anxiety-provoking situation. Eighty-three dating couples were unobtrusively videotaped for 5 min in a waiting room while the woman waited to participate in an "activity" known to provoke anxiety in most people. Independent observers then evaluated each partner's behavior on several dimensions. Results revealed that persons with more secure attachment styles behaved differently than persons with more avoidant styles in terms of physical contact, supportive comments, and efforts to seek and give emotional support. Findings are discussed in the context of theory and research on attachment.
Article
Interpersonal communication in marketing is approached from a perspective that focuses on communication signs. A classification scheme is presented and relevant literature surveyed. Directions for future research are suggested.
Article
Marketing universals are defined as consumer behaviors within a segment and toward a particular product category that are invariant across cultures. Using several definitions of culture and three different criteria for universality, the authors evaluate whether the use of brand, price, retailer reputation, and physical product appearance as signals of quality are marketing universals for consumer electronics products. Using a sample representing 38 nationalities, they find that there are few differences in the use of quality signals across cultures for a high priority segment of consumers. They draw conclusions for the adaptation versus standardization debate and argue that certain behaviors are likely to be universal, whereas others are not. Understanding such differences is essential to designing international marketing strategies.
Article
Only recently has research interest in relationship marketing and customer loyalty converged in the retail context. Although this research shows that relationship customers maintain their primary loyalty to the salesperson, which then “spills over” and affects loyalty to the store, other research suggests that salesperson loyalty has direct effects on store-level outcomes, such as spending and word of mouth. However, this has not been comprehensively investigated, and relationship researchers have specifically called for research examining the effects of salesperson and store loyalty on store-level outcomes. Our research addresses this call, and shows that in an upscale retail context a relationship customer's loyalty to the salesperson is significantly related to store loyalty as well as the important store-level outcomes of share of purchases, word of mouth and competitive resistance.
Article
There has been extensive research on the effect of source credibility on persuasion in social psychology. This paper suggests that some of the research on source credibility in social psychology may not be valid in a personal selling situation. Thus, in a personal selling situation, relationships between buyer's prior expectations and effect of salesperson credibility are proposed and tested experimentally. Some direct effects of salesperson credibility were observed which were as suggested by social psychology research. However, inverse persuasive effects of salesperson credibility predicted by social psychology research were not observed. Managerial implications of the research are suggested and directions for future research proposed.
Article
This article applies what the behavioral sciences know about trust to industrial sales situations. Trust between an industrial buyer and salesperson is defined cognitively and behaviorally. A model of this trust-building process is presented and appropriate behaviors for sales representatives who wish to build trust are discussed. The interactions between experience, general knowledge, and trust building are examined in light of possible situations a sales representative might encounter. The findings suggest that both firm and salesperson can act positively to build and maintain trust with their clients.
Article
Although personal selling and organizational buying are recognized as critical elements in the success of most industrial firms, research progress in this area has been hindered by the lack of a comprehensive and integrative conceptual model of the customer-salesperson interaction. This paper proposes such a model which focuses on the critical element of the buyer-seller interaction, communication.
Article
Advertisements containing product endorsements, by a third-party organization (TPO), product endorsements by a celebrity, or no endorsement were compared for their ability to affect the dependent variables of perceived product quality, attitude toward the manufacturer, purchase risk, and information value of the ad. In addition, prior brand evaluation and source (endorser) trustworthiness were tested as moderators of the endorsement effect. In two factorial experiments, one for a desktop computer and one for auto insurance, significant main effects were found for endorsement and brand but not for trustworthiness. Brand interacted with endorsement in the quality perception of computers. In both experiments, TPO endorsement was particularly effective in enhancing respondent perceptions of product quality. It is concluded that TPO endorsement may function as an extrinsic quality cue in advertising.
Article
While a few researchers have started to chip away at the notion that retail density is always negative, extant studies do not empirically address the question of why some shoppers respond negatively to a specific level of density while others respond positively. We examine this issue by drawing upon field theory (Lewin 1939) to shed light on how shoppers vary in terms of deeper motives (McClelland 1953) to seek control or intimacy with others in retail mall settings, and whether these motives influence shopping orientations. Shopping orientation is then hypothesized to affect perceptions of crowding, and, in turn, subsequent affective responses to the mall shopping experience. Moreover, we examine whether individual differences (gender and age) can help retailers segment those with different shopping orientations and the motives that influence these orientations. We found that task and social shopping orientations were influenced by deeper motives for control and intimacy. The causal relationships between shopping motive, shopping orientation, and consumers’ affective responses of stress and excitement were also discovered. Finally, we address theoretical and managerial implications of our results.
Article
Subjects in a shopping mall were approached with a request to participate in a survey. Half the subjects were touched and gazed at by interviewers and the other half were not. These nonverbal techniques increased compliance to participate in the interviewing task and somewhat decreased respondents' perceived burden. The touch and no-touch groups did not differ in response quality, apparent response bias, or volunteer bias. Compliance was related to the gender of the interviewer but not related to that of the respondent. Implications for mall intercept surveys are discussed.
Article
The service encounter frequently is the service from the customer's point of view. Using the critical incident method, the authors collected 700 incidents from customers of airlines, hotels, and restaurants. The incidents were categorized to isolate the particular events and related behaviors of contact employees that cause customers to distinguish very satisfactory service encounters from very dissatisfactory ones. Key implications for managers and researchers are highlighted.
Article
The persuasive impact of source credibility is examined in two situations, A highly credible source was more effective than a moderately credible source when the communication recommended buying a product, an advocacy which message recipients viewed unfavorably. The moderately credible source was more persuasive when the message advocated leasing the product, a position subjects generally supported. These findings are interpreted in terms of cognitive response theory. Practical implications of the research are suggested.
Article
Airline flight attendants' touching of 158 passengers on the shoulder or forearm increased their liking of the 4 attendants and the airline in general and also their perceived flight safety.
Article
The importance and complexity of tactile communication in a variety of interpersonal contexts is underscored in the nonverbal communication literature. However, whether touch produces positive or negative effects on interpersonal relationships may depend upon the coactants’ levels of touch avoidance. The present experimental study examined the interactive effects of touch and touch avoidance on interpersonal attraction and perceived homophily. The results of a MANOVA and follow‐up univariate tests demonstrated that interpersonal attraction and perceived homophily are dependent, in part, on the receiver's level of touch avoidance. Touch avoiders rated confederates who touched them lower in attraction and homophily than did touch approachers who were touched. A gender of confederate effect was also observed. These findings are consistent with the extant literature.
Article
The goal of relationship marketing is to build and maintain a committed, loyal relationship between a customer and an organization. Although studies have discussed the types of relational bonds that enhance customer loyalty, empirical research that focuses on the application of relational bonds in a virtual environment is relatively sparse. In response, this study investigates the effects of various relational bonds on customer commitment across search-experience-credence goods/services on Internet. The results suggest that financial, social, and structural bonds have positive impacts on customer commitment. In addition, financial bonds are more successful in strengthening customer commitment for search goods/services than for experience or credence goods/services. Structural bonds are more important for credence and experience goods/services than for search goods, and social bonds are almost equally important for all three types of goods/service.
Article
Ethological attachment theory is a landmark of 20th century social and behavioral sciences theory and research. This new paradigm for understanding primary relationships across the lifespan evolved from John Bowlby's critique of psychoanalytic drive theory and his own clinical observations, supplemented by his knowledge of fields as diverse as primate ethology, control systems theory, and cognitive psychology. By the time he had written the first volume of his classic Attachment and Loss trilogy, Mary D. Salter Ainsworth's naturalistic observations in Uganda and Baltimore, and her theoretical and descriptive insights about maternal care and the secure base phenomenon had become integral to attachment theory. Patterns of Attachment reports the methods and key results of Ainsworth's landmark Baltimore Longitudinal Study. Following upon her naturalistic home observations in Uganda, the Baltimore project yielded a wealth of enduring, benchmark results on the nature of the child's tie to its primary caregiver and the importance of early experience. It also addressed a wide range of conceptual and methodological issues common to many developmental and longitudinal projects, especially issues of age appropriate assessment, quantifying behavior, and comprehending individual differences. In addition, Ainsworth and her students broke new ground, clarifying and defining new concepts, demonstrating the value of the ethological methods and insights about behavior. Today, as we enter the fourth generation of attachment study, we have a rich and growing catalogue of behavioral and narrative approaches to measuring attachment from infancy to adulthood. Each of them has roots in the Strange Situation and the secure base concept presented in Patterns of Attachment. It inclusion in the Psychology Press Classic Editions series reflects Patterns of Attachment's continuing significance and insures its availability to new generations of students, researchers, and clinicians.
Article
The development of trust between salespeople and their customers has traditionally been considered a critical element in developing and maintaining a successful sales relationship. This article presents the first comprehensive literature review and meta-analysis of the antecedents of trust and consequences of trust in a sales context. A summary conclusion is that trust has a moderate but beneficial influence on the development of positive customer attitudes, intentions, and behavior. Another conclusion is that salespeople have modest influence over the development of trust between themselves and their customers. A comprehensive model of the role of trust in sales is presented. Directions for future research are identified.
Article
Although the verbal components of service encounters have been investigated, the nonverbal aspects of employee-customer interactions have remained virtually unexplored in the marketing literature. Thus, the purpose of this paper is to explore the importance of service employees’ nonverbal communication during service interactions. Specifically, a conceptual model is presented that links nonverbal communication (kinesics, paralanguage, proxemics, and physical appearance), customer affect, and consumers’ evaluations of service providers (with respect to credibility, friendliness, competence, empathy, courtesy, and trustworthiness). Further, the importance of nonverbal elements is discussed and managerial implications are given.
Article
This article examines an unexplored area of consumer research——the effect of accidental interpersonal touch (AIT) from a stranger on consumer evaluations and shopping times. The research presents a field experiment in a retail setting. This study shows that men and women who have been touched by another consumer when examining products report more negative brand evaluations, negative product beliefs, less willingness to pay, and spend less time in-store than their control (no-touch) counterparts. Our findings indicate that the AIT effect is especially negative for touch from a male stranger for both men (same-sex touch) and women (opposite-sex touch). Directions are provided for future study that highlight potential moderators and process explanations underlying the AIT effect.
Article
This paper defines hedonic consumption as those facets of consumer behavior that relate to the multisensory, fantasy and emotive aspects of product usage experience. After delineating these concepts, their theoretical antecedents are traced, followed by a discussion of differences between the traditional and hedonic views, methodological implications of the latter approach, and behavioral propositions in four substantive areas relevant to hedonic consumption-mental constructs, product classes, product usage and individual differences. Conclusions concern the usefulness of the hedonic perspective in supplementing and extending marketing research on consumer behavior.
Article
Examines personal meanings ascribed to the experience of touch in the context of forgiveness. Data from in-depth interviews with six self-reported Christians were analyzed to determine themes in the meanings participants assigned to a forgiving touch. (Contains 54 references.) (Author)
Article
Scholars in various disciplines have considered the causes, nature, and effects of trust. Prior approaches to studying trust are considered, including characteristics of the trustor, the trustee, and the role of risk. A definition of trust and a model of its antecedents and outcomes are presented, which integrate research from multiple disciplines and differentiate trust from similar constructs. Several research propositions based on the model are presented.
Article
Shoppers in a supermarket were approached with a request to sample a new food product. Half the shoppers were touched during the request and the other half were not. Touch increased the probability of both trying the food sample and buying the product. The touch and no-touch groups did not differ in their taste rating of the product. The probability of sampling or buying the product was not related to the gender of the shopper or the experimenter.
Article
Examined the use of celebrity spokespeople in advertising, focusing on 3 dimensions of source credibility: attractiveness, trustworthiness, and expertise. Two pilot studies were conducted with 78 college students to compile a list of 4 celebrities and products that would be appropriate for them to endorse. From this information, 4 questionnaires were developed. 542 respondents (aged 18–73 yrs) completed 1 questionnaire. In each case, Ss evaluated celebrities to be significantly different from each other with respect to the 3 dimensions studied. Ss' gender and age had no significant effect on their intention to purchase or on how they evaluated celebrities' credibility. Only the perceived expertise of celebrities significantly explained Ss' intentions to purchase, regardless of whether the product was for personal use or for gift-giving. (PsycINFO Database Record (c) 2012 APA, all rights reserved)
Article
Tested the effect on tipping of a female waitress touching the male patron, the female patron, or neither patron, using 112 pairs of restaurant customers. Results show the average tip in the female condition was 15%, the average tip in the male condition was 13%, and the average tip in the no-touch condition was 11%. (PsycINFO Database Record (c) 2012 APA, all rights reserved)
Article
Most of the research dealing with consumer–consumer interactions emphasizes the negative consequences of sharing the service experience with other consumers. Crowding, in particular, represents one of the important environmental factors affecting consumers' retail experience. However, recent studies in the context of hedonic services (e.g., amusement parks, concerts, etc.) have mentioned that crowds may potentially enhance consumers' service experience. The present study aims at demonstrating the presence of these positive consumer responses in a crowded hedonic situation, while investigating the influence of cultural differences in crowd-related issues. With the use of consumers from different cultures (North America and the Middle East), reactions to similarly crowded situations in a hedonic situation are compared. Results suggest that Middle Eastern respondents perceive both a lower level of density and appreciate crowded situations more than their North American counterparts. Potential explanations are discussed. © 2006 Wiley Periodicals, Inc.