ArticlePDF Available

New threats to endangered Cook's scurvy grass (Lepidium oleraceum; Brassicaceae): Introduced crop viruses and the extent of their spread


Abstract and Figures

To date, most research conducted on plant viruses has centred on agricultural systems where viruses greatly reduce economic output. Introduced viruses are globally common and there is a lack of knowledge around how they might affect natural populations. Although it has been suggested that infectious disease may have played an underestimated role in past species extinctions, there is little empirical evidence. Cook's scurvy grass (Lepidium oleraceum Sparrm. ex G.Forst; Brassicaceae) is a threatened coastal plant endemic to New Zealand. Following the discovery of Turnip mosaic virus (TuMV) in some glasshouse cultivated specimens, we surveyed wild extant Lepidium populations on the Otago coast for TuMV while screening for two other common crop viruses. We show that TuMV is almost ubiquitous among remaining wild L. oleraceum populations on the South Island's east coast and report the first record of L. oleraceum as a host for both Cauliflower mosaic virus and Turnip yellows virus. The high incidence of virus infection throughout the study populations may make this system one of the first examples of introduced viruses affecting the conservation of a threatened plant species.
Content may be subject to copyright.
New threats to endangered Cooks scurvy grass
(Lepidium oleraceum; Brassicaceae): introduced crop
viruses and the extent of their spread
Josh C. C. M. Van Vianen
, Gary J. Houliston
, John D. Fletcher
, Peter B. Heenan
and Hazel M. Chapman
School of Biological Sciences, University of Canterbury, Private Bag 4800, Christchurch 8140, New Zealand.
Manaaki Whenua-Landcare Research, PO Box 40, Lincoln 7640, New Zealand.
The New Zealand Institute for Plant & Food Research Ltd, Private Bag 4704, Christchurch, New Zealand.
Corresponding author. Email:
Abstract. To date, most research conducted on plant viruses has centred on agricultural systems where viruses greatly
reduce economic output. Introduced viruses are globally common and there is a lack of knowledge around how they might
affect natural populations. Although it has been suggested that infectious disease may have played an underestimated role
in past species extinctions, there is little empirical evidence. Cooks scurvy grass (Lepidium oleraceum Sparrm. ex G.Forst;
Brassicaceae) is a threatened coastal plant endemic to New Zealand. Following the discovery of Turnip mosaic virus
(TuMV) in some glasshouse cultivated specimens, we surveyed wild extant Lepidium populations on the Otago coast for
TuMV while screening for two other common crop viruses. We show that TuMV is almost ubiquitous among remaining
wild L. oleraceum populations on the South Islands east coast and report the rst record of L. oleraceum as a host for both
Cauliower mosaic virus and Turnip yellows virus. The high incidence of virus infection throughout the study populations
may make this system one of the rst examples of introduced viruses affecting the conservation of a threatened plant species.
Additional keywords: biological invasions, CaMV, Lepidium oleraceum, New Zealand, plant conservation, TuMV, TuYV.
Received 17 October 2012, accepted 15 February 2013, published online 5 April 2013
Cooks scurvy grass, Lepidium oleraceum Sparrm. ex G.Forst;
Brassicaceae, named for its use by Captain James Cook as an
antiscorbutic for his crew during his voyages to New Zealand in
the 18th century (de Lange and Norton 1996), is one of six species
of coastal cress indigenous to New Zealand (Garnock-Jones
and Norton 1995; Norton and de Lange 1999). Five of these
are endemic, including L. oleraceum, and one is shared with
Tasmania (L. exicaule; Hewson 1981). There has been a large
decline in both the range and distribution of coastal cress
populations, with all species being classied as extinct,
threatened with extinction or at risk under the revised New
Zealand Threat Classication System (de Lange et al. 2009).
The conservation status of these plants is of particular
signicance to New Zealand plant conservation because of
historical records dating back to the rst European explorers
who described the plants as being abundant and widely
distributed (Norton and de Lange 1999).
Lepidium oleraceum (threatened/nationally vulnerable) is
now estimated to be restricted to between 90 and 100 small,
isolated populations with many comprising less than 20
individuals. The total number of individuals is estimated to be
between 2000 and 5000 (Norton and de Lange 1999) and the
survival of the species is fully dependent on intensive
conservation management (de Lange et al. 2009).
Reasons for their decline include habitat degradation, the
loss of associated seabird and seal colonies, insect and fungal
pests, and browsing by introduced mammals (Norton and de
Lange 1999;
Hasenbank et
al. 2011). The discovery of Turnip
mosaic virus (TuMV; Family: Potyviridae Genus: Potyvirus)
in glasshouse specimens and in a replanted individual of
L. oleraceum from Banks Peninsula, Canterbury, New
Zealand, were the rst records of any virus infecting this
species (Fletcher et al. 2009). This highlighted a potential new
threat to L. oleraceum.
TuMV is a common aphid-vectored virus of brassica and
other plant species in New Zealand, including: Armoracia
rusticana, Brassica napus, B. pekinensis, B. rapa, Erysimum
cheiri, Lunaria annua, Matthiola incana, Sinapis alba,
Sisymbrium ofcinale (Pearson et al. 2006), Rorippa
nasturtium-aquaticum (Anonymous 2004), Crocus sativus,
Erodium moschatum, Lobelia speciosa, Nasturtium ofcinale
and Tropaeolum majus (Ochoa Corona et al. 2007). TuMV
can cause symptoms of leaf mosaic, necrosis, chlorotic mottle
Australian Journal of Botany, 2013, 61, 161166
Journal compilation CSIRO 2013
and severe distortion as well as reductions in plant biomass
in important crop brassicas (Spence et al. 2007). In addition
TuMV has been known to reduce the tness of wild brassicas
by reducing biomass, fecundity and survival (Maskell et al.
Most of the L. oleraceum individuals found to be infected
with TuMV in Fletcher et al.(2009) were either glasshouse-
grown research specimens or plants temporarily grown under
glasshouse conditions for replanting or conservation purposes. It
is possible that the plants were infected while under glasshouse
conditions where aphid infestations were common. These plants
were growing in close proximity to other TuMV host plants,
either in the glasshouses themselves (Fletcher et al. 2010)orin
the surrounding farming landscape. The Canterbury region is
dominated by agricultural land where brassica crops, grown in
abundance for human consumption and for sheep/cow fodder
provide a potential virus reservoir.
There is increasing interest in the role plant pathogens play
in regulating communities and ecosystem processes, with an
emphasis on the way in which anthropogenic climate change
may interact with plant-pathogen dynamics (Anderson and May
1986; Anderson et al. 2004; Garrett et al. 2006; Lafferty 2009).
In the case of viral pathogens, the bulk of the literature is
dominated by agricultural viruses and crop research where
viruses can have large impacts on economic outputs, with the
effects of plant viruses on natural systems rarely investigated
(Gilbert 2002). Nevertheless, there are examples of native
plants acting as hosts for introduced viruses (Pearson et al.
2006). Recent examples from New Zealand include the
infection of native grasses (Graminacae) with introduced
cereal and pasture grass viruses, namely, Cocksfoot mottle
virus, Barley yellow dwarf virus and Cereal yellow virus
(Davis and Guy 2001; Delmiglio et al. 2010 ) and Pachycladon
spp. with TuMV in glasshouse specimens (Fletcher et al. 2010).
Additionally, several broader-scale ecosystem level studies
have been carried out on the effect of viruses in natural
ecosystems in California (Malmstrom et al. 2005a, 2005b,
2006) and Australia (Webster et al. 2007). Despite some
research suggesting that pathogens may be an underestimated
factor contributing to global biodiversity loss (De Castro and
Bolker 2005; Smith
et al. 2006),
studies empirically stating
the effects introduced viruses may have on plant conservation
are scarce.
We surveyed the known remaining wild populations of
L. oleraceum on the South Islands mainland east coast and
also tested one coastal population of L. tenuicaule Kirk, which
is currently classied as being at risk and declining (de Lange
et al. 2009). Because there is a plethora of introduced crop
viruses recorded in New Zealand (Pearson et al. 2006), we
have taken a targeted approach and surveyed two other
common brassica viruses; Cauliower mosaic virus (CaMV;
Family: Caulimoviridae Genus: Caulimovirus), recorded in
New Zealand infecting six common crop brassicas including:
B. napus, B. napus var. napobrassica, B. oleracea var. botrytis,
B. oleracea var. capitata, B. oleracea var. ramosa, and B. rapa
(Pearson et al. 2006) and Turnip yellows virus (TuYV; Family:
Luteoviridae Genus: Polerovirus), with over 30 known hosts
in many plant genera including Brassicaceae (Pearson et al.
2006). Both of which we felt may also infect native Lepidium
hosts because of their wide host ranges, their common occurrence
in agricultural landscapes and a shared transmission pathway.
Materials and methods
Sample populations and species
Six populations of L. oleraceum were sampled, representing the
remaining known distribution of the species on the mainland
east coast of the South Island. These sites were Eye Tallus,
Highcliff, Long Beach and Aramoana in the vicinity of the
Otago Peninsula and Bridge Point and Tavora in North Otago.
Also sampled was one population of L. tenuicaule from Shag
Point, North Otago (Fig. 1). Although L. tenuicaule is currently
not a conrmed host for any viruses, being the same genus as
L. oleraceum it was included for testing as it may also be
susceptible to infection. Although there are other known
populations of Lepidium spp. distributed on offshore rock-
stacks such as Motunau Island off the Canterbury coast,
cult access prevented these populations being sampled.
of plant samples and storage
Sampling was conducted in March 2010. Because populations
were small, samples were collected from every individual adult
plant at each site except for L. tenuicaule at Shag Point where
a random subsample was taken so as to minimise impact on
the population. Virus symptoms often manifest visually as leaf
mosaic, necrosis, chlorotic mottle, leaf distortion and a reduced
plant biomass. Samples of between 3 and 5 leaves per plant
(510 g) were collected in equal proportions from both
symptomatic and asymptomatic stems and leaves. The
exception was L. tenuicaule, where because of their small size
and woody stems with small leaves, a larger number of leaves
were required. Leaves were stored in sealed plastic bags with a
small piece of moist tissue paper and kept cool with ice packs
then transferred to a 4
C fridge until processed.
Virus detection
Double antibody sandwich enzyme-linked immunosorbent
assay serological tests were conducted according to the
manufacturers protocols using two commercially available
kits and one prepared at Plant and Food Research: TuMV
(AS0132; DSMZ, Braunschweig, Germany), CaMV (AS0206;
DSMZ) and TuYV (Plant & Food Research g 048 coat and
conjugate). Duplicate samples of crushed leaf sap were tested,
with three negative and one positive control. Both positive and
negative control samples were obtained from B. napus (rape
seed), B. rapa var. rapa (turnip) or B. pekinensis (Bok Choi).
These were grown in glasshouse conditions at 1822
C at Plant
& Food Research, Lincoln. Enzyme-linked immunosorbent
assay plates were coated with each antibody at appropriate
dilutions and incubated at 4
C overnight. Sample tissue was
crushed using a mechanised leaf roller then diluted with PBS-
Tween-PVP buffer (0.15 M phosphate-buffered saline, 0.05%
Tween 20, 2% polyvinylpyrrolidone 40) at a ratio of 1 : 10,
loaded on coated plates, then incubated. Conjugates were
diluted in PBS-Tween-PVP ovalbumen (0.2%): 1 mL/mL
(TuMV), 2 mL/mL (CaMV) and 2 mL/mL (TuYV). Plates were
washed 3 times for 3 min with PBS Tween buffer between
treatments. All incubations were carried out at 4
C overnight.
162 Australian Journal of Botany J. C. C. M. Van Vianen et al.
After incubation with the alkaline phosphatase conjugate, plates
were developed with 2,4 DNPP substrate (2,4 dinitrophenyl
phosphate; 0.5 mg/mL) and spectrometer readings were taken
at OD 405 nm at 30- and 60-min intervals. The threshold level
for a sample to be considered positive was when the A
reading from the spectrometer was greater than the mean value
of the negative controls plus 3 times the standard deviation.
The results of the enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay tests on
Lepidium spp. are summarised in Table 1 and Fig. 1. Viruses were
detected in ve of the seven populations. The L. oleraceum
population at Aramoana and the L. tenuicaule population at
Shag Point were virus-free. Of the 155 L. oleraceum plants
sampled, 75 (48.4%) were infected with viruses, of which 11
(14.6%) had multiple infections; one was co-infected with CaMV
and TuYV and the other 10 were co-infected with CaMV and
TuMV. Only two populations contained individuals displaying
obvious visual signs of viral infection with individuals at both
Long Beach and Tavora appearing to be symptomatic.
The most prevalent virus was CaMV, infecting 57 of the 155
(36.8%) L. oleraceum individuals sampled. TuMV was the next
most prevalent, infecting 28 of the 155 (18%) L. oleraceum
individuals sampled. In contrast, TuYV was only detected in
one individual L. oleraceum and it was a co-infection with
Long Beach
Bridge PointEye Tallus
Total Infected
Long Beach
Bridge Point
Shag Point
Eye Tallus
Virus Free
Fig. 1. Map of New Zealand, showing the distribution of extant South Island east coast Otago Lepidium species and virus infection rates within
populations. All populations are L. oleraceum, except Shag Point (L. tenuicaule Kirk; excluded from total). Pie graphs show the virus community
composition within each Lepidium population and the total virus incidence across all populations for Turnip mosaic virus (TuMV), Cauliower mosaic
virus (CaMV) and Turnip yellows virus (TuYV). Graphs for Shag Point and Aramoana are excluded because no viruses were detected.
Table 1. Virus population structure within Otago Lepidium populations
Data presented as counts of virus incidence including sum totals for each virus species and co-infections across all populations, the
proportion of infected individuals within each population and the presence of visual viral symptoms within each population. X, visual signs
of viral infection are present; TuMV, Turnip mosaic virus; CaMV, Cauliower mosaic virus; TuYV, Turnip yellows virus
Population Population
Visual signs
of infection
Eye Tallus
16 110 1 75%
77 X 10 35 7 68%
Bridge Point
6 1 –– 2 50%
Long Beach
31 X 6 1 ––23%
12 ––18%
13 ––
Shag Point
9 ––
155 18 46 10 1 48%
Lepidium oleraceum.
Lepidium tenuicaule Kirk (~10% of true population size).
Does not include Shag Point population.
New threats to endangered Cooks scurvy grass Australian Journal of Botany 163
CaMV. The A
reading for the TuYV was only just higher
than the threshold and so was determined as being only weakly
positive for TuYV.
Aramoana was the only L. oleraceum population where
virus was not detected. Across the other populations infection
rates ranged from 8% at Highcliff to 75% at Eye Tallus. All
infected L. oleraceum populations had at least two virus species
Virus distribution
This study has shown that three introduced viruses infecting
brassica crops are prevalent among New Zealands endemic
L. oleraceum populations on the Otago coast. Infection rates
ranged from 8 to 75% in all populations apart from Aramoana
where virus was not detected. These levels of infection are
similar to those of TuMV, CaMV and TuYV in natural
B. oleracea populations in southern England, where their
incidence is reported to range between 16 and 90% (Raybould
et al. 1999). The three virus species detected in this study had
varying levels of incidence across all the L. oleraceum
populations. Both the proportion of infected plants and the
structure of the virus community varied within each
population. For example, the virus community structure in the
Tavora population was dominated by CaMV infection (68%),
followed by TuMV (19%) and co-infection with both (13%).
In contrast, the structure of the virus community in the Long
Beach population was dominated by TuMV (86%), followed
by CaMV (14%) with no co-infections occurring (Table 1,
Fig. 1). Possible reasons for variation in virus incidence
between population sites and among individual plants may
include: genetic variation in host plant pathogen resistance
(Hammond-Kosack and Jones 1996; Parker and Gilbert 2004);
variation in vector density, herbivory and behaviour (Carmona
et al. 2011); the proximity of virus source populations, cultivated
or wild (De Castro and Bolker 2005; Malmstrom et al. 2005b);
the demographic structure of the host population (Raybould
et al. 1999); interactions between viruses (Power 1996); and a
wide range of climatic and environmental variables (Coakley
et al. 1999; Chakraborty et al. 2000; Garrett et al. 2006).
Among the surveyed populations, not all expressed virus
symptoms. For example, it was noted that the Long Beach and
Tavora populations were observed to have obvious and often
systemic virus symptoms. In contrast, the Bridge Point, Eye
Tallus and Highcliff populations were not noted as having
obvious visual symptoms, yet also tested positive for virus
infection. This could suggest that there may be some natural/
evolved tolerance or resistance to infection among some
Lepidium populations. The Aramoana population is
geographically similar and in close proximity (~6 km) to Long
Beach, where 23% of the population is infected, therefore one
would also expect to detect viruses at Aramoana. The complete
lack of virus infection at Aramoana might be explained by
harsher environmental conditions and the resulting changes in
plant morphology. This population inhabits a man-made break-
water where high winds and sea spray are constant features. This
is reected in the plant adaptations of thick waxy leaves and a
woody, prostrate habit. These characteristics, combined with
potentially suboptimal environmental conditions for aphid
vectors and other potential host plants, may be contributing
factors explaining why this population has remained virus-free.
While the Shag Point L. tenuicaule population shares the
same geographic and landscape characteristics as the other
populations, it also appears virus-free and elsewhere has not
been recorded as a virus host. There may be some biological
reasons for viruses not occurring in L. tenuicaule that relate to
its phylogenetic history. Lepidium in
New Zealand comprises
two lineages (Mitchell and Heenan 2000; Mummenhoff et al.
2004) with L. oleraceum in one lineage and L. tenuicaule in
another. Another reason could be a sampling effect. Unlike
the L. oleraceum populations, where every individual in each
population was sampled, at Shag Point only a random subsample
of nine plants representing ~10% of the population was taken so
as to minimise negative impacts on the population. Although
all sampled individual plants lacked any observable virus
symptoms and tested negative for virus in the laboratory, this
does not conclusively exclude the possibility that the three virus
species we tested for, or any other viruses, are present in the
population. A further observation was that large aphid colonies
were present in most L. oleraceum populations during sample
collection; however, no aphids were observed feeding on
L. tenuicaule. These observations may re ect differences in
the host preference of aphid vectors, related to morphological
differences between the species. In comparison to the erect
(>50 cm), bright green eshy-leafed L. oleraceum,
L. tenuicaule is a much smaller, prostrate species with small
pinnate leaves (Norton and de Lange 1999). This may be a
contributing factor to this population remaining virus-free.
Further study is needed to determine if L. tenuicaule is indeed
a target species for known aphid vectors and thus potentially a
viable host for these viruses.
Virus establishment at the Tavora population may have a
different history to the other sites. This population has been
replanted as part of a wider coastal ecosystem restoration
project, with plants derived from seed collected on other parts
of the Otago coast. While the virus species detected in this
study are not known to be seed transmitted, it is possible that
infection occurred during propagation of seedlings in the
glasshouse or shade house. This may have inuenced the
infection rate in this population, as the majority of individuals
in the Tavora population are of the same or similar age and age
class structure has been shown to be a determinant of virus
infection rates (Raybould et al. 1999; Spence et al. 2007).
Multiple infections
Our data shows that multiple infections that is, individuals
infected with more than one virus species are common. In total,
14.6% of all infected individuals in this study were co-infected.
This is a typical phenomenon, which has been reported in several
other plant virus studies (Raybould et al. 1999; Davis and Guy
2001; Syller 2012). Multiple virus infections can lead to a variety
of intra-host virus-virus interactions, both antagonistic and
synergistic (García-Cano et al. 2006; Mukasa et al. 2006;
Spence et al. 2007; Syller 2012).
Different viruses can also exert differential forces on disease
transmission by altering vector preferences for hosts infected with
164 Australian Journal of Botany J. C. C. M. Van Vianen et al.
certain viruses over others. For example, aphids settling
preferentially on virus-infected host plants or producing more
offspring on infected hosts (Bosque-Pérez and Eigenbrode
2011). Understanding which factors are responsible for
determining the virus community structure and how the
viruses are affecting the persistence of L. oleraceum
populations is a matter for further research.
Future research and implications for management
The implications of this study are wide ranging in terms of
both the conservation of New Zealands coastal cresses and
the future direction of plant conservation in general. Although
these populations have high levels of viral infection, we do not
know how these viruses are affecting plant tness, ecology or
population survival. Lepidium oleraceum is a relatively short-
lived (510 years) perennial herb, which owers readily and
produces an abundance of small seed on which it is reliant
for propagation (Norton and de Lange 1999). Historically
L. oleraceum has been associated with the high soil fertility of
sea bird colonies (Norton et al. 1997). The loss of such habitat,
coupled with high natural variation in population size (Norton
and de Lange 1999; de Lange et al. 2009) makes this species
especially vulnerable to loss of tness through reduced seed
production or increased mortality rates from viral infection.
Such negative inuences will have large implications for its
conservation. While this is a preliminary study and we are yet
to measure the direct effect of viral infection in L. oleraceum,
we can surmise that because effects such as reduced biomass,
reduced seed output and increased mortality are common
responses in other brassicas infected with the same virus
species (Maskell et al. 1999; Spence et al. 2007), there is a
high likelihood L. oleraceum populations on the Otago coastline
are suffering from similarly negative effects associated with
virus infection. With this in mind, steps have been taken to
ensure conservation nursery staff are now aware of the risks of
introducing virus-infected plants (Fletcher et al. 2009). Though
there are other examples of introduced plants acting as reservoirs
for common viruses leading to the infection of natives, such as
the discovery of the Barley yellow dwarf virus, Cereal yellow
dwarf virus and Cocksfoot mottle virus infections in several native
New Zealand grasses (Delmiglio et al. 2010), virus infections in
Lepidium may be the rst example of introduced viruses directly
affecting the conservation of an endangered species.
Understanding the role of infectious diseases in species
extinction is a growing eld of research. Global change has
already been shown to increase the transmission of infectious
diseases worldwide (Garrett et al. 2006
), with potential
for native plant populations (Jones 2009). Smith
et al.(2006) state that it is critical that we combine evidence
with theory to discern the circumstances under which infectious
disease is most likely to serve as an agent of extinction.
Unfortunately, in the case of L. oleraceum, theory predicts that
a combination of small population sizes, potential inbreeding
depression, the presence of virus reservoirs and the vector-
transmitted nature of the viruses are all potential contributing
factors leading to disease-induced extinction (De Castro and
Bolker 2005). Following the Smith et al.(2006) call for
combining theory and evidence, and given the conservation
status of these endemic New Zealand plants, it is imperative
that future research concentrates on quantifying the effects that
these viruses are having on both individual plant tness and
population persistence. This survey is important in that it
demonstrates for the rst time that infection from introduced
viruses is a threat to the survival of New Zealands coastal
cresses. Future studies should incorporate viral molecular
systematics to elucidate evolutionary processes which may be
affecting the pathogenicity of these viruses of Lepidium.In
addition, as all three common crop viruses we tested for infect
native hosts, it is important to carry out wider surveys to
understand the scale of viral threats to native New Zealand
plant species. The cosmopolitan nature of crop viruses of the
type discussed in this study may also warrant further
investigation into declines of native Lepidium species in other
countries. For example, there are six species of Lepidium in
Australia listed as being endangered, vulnerable or poorly
known (Briggs and Leigh 1996). These species may also be
suffering from and/or be at risk of viral infection, especially if
they are restricted to landscapes with historical and widespread
agricultural land conversion such as those dominating the South
Island of New Zealand.
This work was supported by the MBIE-funded research program C09X0503
to Landcare Research and The Better Border Biosecurity(B3) program funded
by MSI (JF). We would also like to thank Graeme Loh, John Barkla and the
Department of Conservation for sampling permission and the guided tour of
Otago Peninsula.
Anderson RM, May RM (1986) The invasion, persistence and spread of
infectious diseases within animal and plant communities. Philosophical
Transactions of the Royal Societyof London. Series B, Biological Sciences
314(1167), 533570. doi:10.1098/rstb.1986.0072
Anderson PK, Cunningham AA, Patel NG, Morales FJ, Epstein PR, Daszak P
(2004) Emerging infectious diseases of plants: pathogen pollution,
climate change and agrotechnology drivers. Trends in Ecology &
Evolution 19(10), 535544. doi:10.1016/j.tree.2004.07.021
Anonymous (2004) Plants biosecurity records 07/08/200417/09/2004.
(Biosecurity New Zealand: Wellington, New Zealand)
Bosque-Pérez NA, Eigenbrode SD (2011) The inuence of virus-induced
changes in plants on aphid vectors: insights from luteovirus
pathosystems. Virus Research 159(2), 201205.
Briggs JD, Leigh JH (1996) Rare or threatened Australian plants. 1995 rev.
edn. (CSIRO Publishing: Melbourne)
Carmona D, Lajeunesse MJ, Johnson MT (2011) Plant traits that predict
resistance to herbivores. Functional Ecology 25(2), 358367.
Chakraborty S, Tiedemann AV, Teng PS (2000) Climate change: potential
impact on plant diseases. Environmental Pollution 108(3), 317326.
Coakley SM, Scherm H, Chakraborty S (1999) Climate change and plant
disease management. Annual Review of Phytopathology 37, 399426.
Davis LT, Guy PL (2001) Introduced plant viruses and the invasion of a
native grass ora. Biological Invasions 3(1), 8995.
De Castro F, Bolker B (2005) Mechanisms of disease-induced extinction.
Ecology Letters 8(1), 117126. doi:10.1111/j.1461-0248.2004.00693.x
New threats to endangered Cooks scurvy grass Australian Journal of Botany 165
de Lange PJ, Norton DA (1996) To what New Zealand plant does the
vernacular scurvy grass refer? New Zealand Journal of Botany 34(3),
417420. doi:10.1080/0028825X.1996.10410705
de Lange PJ, Norton DA, Courtney SP, Heenan PB, Barkla JW, Cameron EK,
Hitchmough R, Townsend AJ (2009) Threatened and uncommon plants
of New Zealand (2008 revision). New Zealand Journal of Botany 47(1),
6196. doi:10.1080/00288250909509794
Delmiglio C, Pearson MN, Lister RA, Guy PL (2010) Incidence of cereal
and pasture viruses in New Zealands native grasses. Annals of Applied
Biology 157(1), 2536. doi:10.1111/j.1744-7348.2010.00406.x
Fletcher JD, Bulman S, Fletcher PJ, Houliston GJ (2009) First record of
Turnip mosaic virus in Cooks scurvy grass (Lepidium oleraceum agg.)
an endangered native plant in New Zealand. Australasian Plant Disease
Notes 4(1), 911.
Fletcher JD, Lister RA, Bulman SR, Heenan PB (2010) First record of
Turnip mosaic virus in Pachycladon spp. (Brassicaceae): an
endangered native plant species in New Zealand. Australasian Plant
Disease Notes 5(1), 910. doi:10.1071/DN10004
García-Cano E, Resende RO, Fernández-Muñoz R, Moriones E (2006)
Synergistic interaction between Tomato chlorosis virus and Tomato
spotted wilt virus results in breakdown of resistance in tomato.
Phytopathology 96(11), 12631269. doi:10.1094/PHYTO-96-1263
Garnock-Jones PJ, Norton DA (1995) Lepidium naufragorum (Brassicaceae),
a new species from Westland, and notes on other New Zealand coastal
species of Lepidium. New Zealand Journal of Botany 33(1), 4351.
Garrett KA, Dendy SP, Frank EE, Rouse MN, Travers SE (2006) Climate
change effects on plant disease: genomes to ecosystems. Annual Review
of Phytopathology 44, 489509.
Gilbert GS (2002) Evolutionary ecology of plant diseases in natural
ecosystems. Annual Review of Phytopathology 40,1343.
Hammond-Kosack KE, Jones JDG (1996) Resistance gene-dependent plant
defense responses. The Plant Cell 8(10), 17731791.
Hasenbank M, Brandon A, Hartley S (2011) White buttery(Pieris
and the white rust Albugo candida on Cooks scurvy grass (Lepidium
oleraceum). New Zealand Journal of Ecology 35(1), 6975.
Hewson HJ (1981) The genus Lepidium L. (Brassicaceae) in Australia.
Australian Systematic Botany 4(2), 217308. doi:10.1071/BRU9810217
Jones RAC (2009) Plant virus emergence and evolution: origins, new
encounter scenarios, factors driving emergence, effects of changing
world conditions, and prospects for control. Virus Research 141(2),
113130. doi:10.1016/j.virusres.2008.07.028
Lafferty KD (2009) Calling for an ecological approach to studying climate
change and infectious diseases. Ecology 90(4), 932933.
Malmstrom CM, Hughes CC, Newton LA, Stoner CJ (2005a) Virus infection
in remnant native bunchgrasses from invaded California grasslands. New
Phytologist 168(1), 217230. doi:10.1111/j.1469-8137.2005.01479.x
Malmstrom CM, McCullough AJ, Johnson HA, Newton LA, Borer ET
(2005b) Invasive annual grasses indirectly increase virus incidence in
California native perennial bunchgrasses. Oecologia 145(1), 153164.
Malmstrom CM, Stoner CJ, Brandenburg S, Newton LA (2006) Virus
infection and grazing exert counteracting inuences on survivorship of
native bunchgrass seedlings competing with invasive exotics. Journal
of Ecology 94(2), 264275. doi:10.1111/j.1365-2745.2006.01101.x
Maskell LC, Raybould AF, Cooper JI, Edwards ML, Gray AJ (1999)
Effects of turnip mosaic virus and turnip yellow mosaic virus on the
survival, growth and reproduction of wild cabbage (Brassica oleracea).
Annals of Applied Biology 135(1), 401407.
Mitchell AD, Heenan PB (2000) Systematic relationships of New Zealand
endemic Brassicaceae inferred from nrDNA ITS sequence data.
Systematic Botany 25(1), 98105. doi:10.2307/2666676
Mukasa SB, Rubaihayo PR, Valkonen JPT (2006) Interactions between a
crinivirus, an ipomovirus and a potyvirus in coinfected sweetpotato
plants. Plant Pathology 55(
3), 458 467.
Mummenhoff K, Linder P, Friesen N, Bowman JL, Lee JY, Franzke A
(2004) Molecular evidence for bicontinental hybridogenous genomic
constitution in Lepidium sensu stricto (Brassicaceae) species from
Australia and New Zealand. American Journal of Botany 91(2),
254261. doi:10.3732/ajb.91.2.254
Norton DA, de Lange PJ (1999) Coastal Cresses (Nau) Recovery Plan.
Threatened Species Recovery Plan 26. (Department of Conservation:
Norton DA, de Lange PJ, Garnock-Jones PJ, Given DR (1997) The role of
seabirds and seals in the survival of coastal plants: lessons from New
Zealand Lepidium (Brassicaceae). Biodiversity and Conservation 6(6),
765785. doi:10.1023/B:BIOC.0000010401.93153.29
Ochoa Corona F, Lebas B, Elliott D, Tang J, Alexander B (2007) New
host records and new host family range for Turnip mosaic virus in New
Zealand. Australasian Plant Disease Notes 2(1), 127130.
Parker IM, Gilbert GS (2004) The evolutionary ecology of novel plant-
pathogen interactions. Annual Review of Ecology, Evolution, and
Systematics 35, 675700.
Pearson MN, Clover GRG, Guy PL, Fletcher JD, Beever RE (2006) A review
of the plant virus, viroid and mollicute records for New Zealand.
Australasian Plant Pathology 35(2), 217252. doi:10.1071/AP06016
Power AG (1996) Competition between viruses in a complex plant-pathogen
system. Ecology 77(4), 10041010. doi:10.2307/2265571
Raybould AF, Maskell LC, Edwards ML, Cooper JI, Gray AJ (1999) The
prevalence and spatial distribution of viruses in natural populations of
Brassica oleracea. New Phytologist 141(2), 265275.
Smith KF, Sax DF, Lafferty KD (2006) Evidence for the role of infectious
disease in species extinction and endangerment. Conservation Biology 20
(5), 13491357. doi:10.1111/j.1523-1739.2006.00524.x
Spence NJ, Phiri NA, Hughes SL, Mwaniki A, Simons S, Oduor G, Chacha D,
Kuria A, Ndirangu S, Kibata GN, Marris GC (2007) Economic impact
of Turnip mosaic virus, Cauliower mosaic virus and Beet mosaic virus
in three Kenyan vegetables. Plant Pathology 56(2), 317323.
Syller J (2012) Facilitative and antagonistic interactions between plant
viruses in mixed infections. Molecular Plant Pathology 13(2), 204216.
Webster CG, Coutts BA, Jones RAC, Jones MGK, Wylie SJ (2007) Virus
impact at the interface of an ancient ecosystem and a recent
agroecosystem: studies on three legume-infecting potyviruses in the
southwest Australian oristic region. Plant Pathology 56(5), 729742.
166 Australian Journal of Botany J. C. C. M. Van Vianen et al.
... Collectively, the genetic consequences of small population size and pathogen infection on population fitness present a complex problem for conservation. The discovery of an introduced crop virus infecting endangered New Zealand plant species (Van Vianen et al. 2013) provides a study system in which to investigate the conservation implications of disease and the associated genetic consequences of small population size. ...
... Of serious concern for the conservation management of coastal cress, we recently discovered a high incidence of introduced common crop viruses infecting several extant populations of L. crassum and L. juvencum, including Turnip mosaic virus (TuMV), Cauliflower mosaic virus and Turnip yellows virus (Van Vianen et al. 2013), with many plants showing severe disease symptoms. Disease has been identified as a key driver of extinction, although the role it plays has been difficult to quantify and may have been underestimated in many cases (Smith et al. 2006); nevertheless, there are several instances of endangered animal species being severely impacted or going extinct as a direct result of disease (e.g. ...
... Lepidium species endemic to New Zealand are ideal candidates for investigating genetic rescue. The species are closely related; their populations are small, isolated and likely to suffer the effects of inbreeding depression; and they are among the first threatened plant species to be affected by introduced viruses (de Lange et al. 2013;Van Vianen et al. 2013). One such virus is TuMV, a common aphid vectored virus that can cause symptoms of leaf mosaic, necrosis, chlorotic mottle and severe distortion, as well as reductions in plant biomass (Spence et al. 2007). ...
Lepidium castellanum, L. juvencum and L. oleraceum are threatened coastal cresses endemic to New Zealand. These three species were selfed and interspecific hybrids generated for examination of hybrid fitness and inbreeding depression. In controlled glasshouse experiments, the interspecific hybrids and selfed progeny were inoculated with a strain of the introduced Turnip mosaic virus (TuMV) previously isolated from wild populations of L. aegrum. Experiments tested the hypothesis that heterosis in the interspecific hybrids provides a gain in TuMV resistance in comparison to selfed plants. We show that interspecific hybrids of three genetically distinct species of Lepidium increased plant performance and reduced susceptibility to the effects of the TuMV. We suggest that interspecific hybridization could be implemented as a conservation management strategy and that a broader outlook may be required to mitigate the negative impacts of introduced pathogens on threatened species.
... cabbage white butterfly Pieris rapae), and/or infections of pathogens (as detected in coastal Lepidium; e.g. Armstrong 2007;van Vianen et al. 2013). Lesions of white blister rust (Albugo, Chromista), and associated stunted and distorted growth, have been observed on all three inland Lepidium species in parts of their remaining geographical ranges. ...
... A further threat to CWR is the onslaught of diseases. It has been documented by Van Vianen et al. (2013). Lepidium oleraceum Sparrm. ...
Full-text available
Viruses are important constituents of ecosystems, with the capacity to alter host phenotype and performance. However, virus discovery cued by disease symptoms overlooks latent or beneficial viruses, which are best detected using targeted virus detection or discovered by non-targeted methods, e.g., high-throughput sequencing (HTS). To date, in 64 publications, 701 viruses have been described associated with indigenous species of Aotearoa New Zealand. Viruses were identified in indigenous birds (189 viruses), bats (13 viruses), starfish (4 viruses), insects (280 viruses), and plants (126 viruses). HTS gave rise to a 21.9-fold increase in virus discovery rate over the targeted methods, and 72.7-fold over symptom-based methods. The average number of viruses reported per publication has also increased proportionally over time. The use of HTS has driven the described national virome recently by 549 new-to-science viruses; all are indigenous. This report represents the first catalogue of viruses associated with indigenous species of a country. We provide evidence that the application of HTS to samples of Aotearoa New Zealand’s unique fauna and flora has driven indigenous virus discovery, a key step in the process to understand the role of viruses in the biological diversity and ecology of the land, sea, and air environments of a country.
Full-text available
More than 200 plant viruses and many of their invertebrate vectors have invaded New Zealand (NZ) in the last two centuries. All of these invaders are associated with introduced agricultural, horticultural and/or weed species. At least 16 of the viruses have invaded the native flora, including some rare and critically endangered species. Patterns are emerging: aphid transmitted viruses which are able to infect species from a number of families are prominent. For example, cucumber mosaic virus infects native species from seven families. There are also examples of viruses with more restricted host ranges invading individual families, particularly the native grasses. The yellow dwarf viruses have escaped from cereals and pasture into native grasses. Some of the species are also native to Australia and the Pacific Islands and the review and its literature should be of interest to those working further afield. Prospects for controlling or mitigating the effects of the viruses in agricultural systems have limited application in the native flora but they are relevant to propagation and rescue strategies. Biosecurity measures are not only the first line of defence against threats to agriculture but also to the conservation estate. The protection of native floras from virus invasion is another justification for the control measures and legislative procedures already in place to protect agriculture. High throughput sequencing to detect all viruses at the border, and genetic engineering and RNAi technologies to mitigate the effects of invasions are promising developments for the protection of the native flora.
In addition to climate change, there are several other threats to CWRs, such as, their loss, degradation, and fragmentation of their natural habitats, deforestation, logging, plantation and industrialized agriculture, forestry, dryland destruction and desertification, fire, urbanization, mining and quarrying, and, massive invasive species.
Global warming is a reality man has to live with. Future food security will be dependent on a combination of the stresses, both biotic and abiotic, imposed by climate change, variability of weather within the growing season, development of cultivars more suited to different ambient conditions, and the ability to develop effective adaptation strategies which allow these cultivars to express their genetic potential under the changing climate conditions. Those plant species which are very closely related to field crops, including their progenitors, having the potential to contribute beneficial traits for crop improvement, such as, resistance to an array of biotic and abiotic stresses, enriching the gene pool, leading ultimately to enhanced plant yield, thereby aiding humanity's relentless search for production of more food to meet the ever growing needs of a burgeoning world population, are Called the “Crop Wild Relatives”(CWRs). In fact, CWRs are known to have tremendous potential to sustain and enhance global food security, thereby contributing enormously to humanity's well-being. Therefore, their search, characterization and conservation in crop breeding programs assume great importance. Viewed against the recent upheavals in global climate change, the task becomes all the more important. Against the background of the disastrous after effects, especially the alarming environmental hazards of the highly soil extractive farming, euphemistically known as the “green revolution,” of the 1960s, the task assumes much cruciality. This chapter discusses, at length, the role of CWRs and how they can be tapped to enable mankind to ensure sustainability of food production.
This chapter discusses the challenges of conserving and using Crop Wild Relatives (CWR), reviews briefly the diversity of CWR and their distribution, and identifies some research priorities in the ex situ and in situ conservation and use of CWR. The main general objective and long-term goal of in situ conservation of species is to protect, manage, and monitor the populations in their natural habitats. In ex situ conservation, CWRs require adequate isolation from related species during regeneration to avoid gene flow between species. The genes that come from CWR can make a direct contribution to human well-being and poverty alleviation, by increasing food production and quality and ensuring long-term food security. A key research area for CWR and climate change is the identification of adaptive traits contained in CWR that could be used by breeders for developing crop varieties that can adapt to specific environments.
Full-text available
Recent theoretical and empirical studies of the population biology of infectious diseases have helped to improve our understanding of the major factors that influence the three phases of a successful invasion, namely initial establishment, persistence in the longer term and spread to other host communities. Of central importance in all three phases is the magnitude of the basic reproductive rate or transmission potential of the parasite. The value of this parameter is determined by a variety of biological properties of the association between an individual parasite and its host and the interaction between their populations. The recent epidemic of acquired immunodeficiency syndrome (AIDS) in North America and Europe is employed to illustrate the factors that promote disease establishment and spread. The frequency distribution of the number of different sexual partners per unit of time within homosexual communities is shown to be of central importance with respect to future trends in the incidence of AIDS. Broader aspects of pathogen invasion are examined by reference to simple mathematical models of three species associations, which mirror parasite introduction into resident predator-prey, host-parasite and competitive interactions. Many outcomes are possible, depending on the values of the numerous parameters that influence multi-species population interactions. Pathogen invasion is shown to have far-reaching implications for the structure and stability of ecological communities.
Full-text available
Screenhouse experiments conducted in Kenya showed that inoculation of cabbage seedlings with Turnip mosaic virus (TuMV), either alone, or in combination with Cauliflower mosaic virus (CaMV), reduced the number and weight of marketable harvested heads. When viruses were inoculated simultaneously, 25% of cabbage heads were non-marketable, representing 20-fold loss compared with control. By contrast, inoculation with CaMV alone had insignificant effects on cabbage yield. This suggests that TuMV is the more detrimental of these pathogens, and its management should be a priority. Early exposure to TuMV produced cabbages that were 50% lighter than non-infected plants, but later infection was less damaging suggesting that controlling virus infection at the seedling stage is more important. TuMV was far less damaging to kale than it was to cabbage; although high proportions of TuMV-inoculated kale plants showed symptoms (>90%), the marketability and quality of leaves were not significantly reduced, and no clear relationship existed between timing of infection and subsequent crop losses. Early inoculation of Swiss chard with Beet mosaic virus (BtMV) significantly impaired leaf quality (∼50% reduction in marketable leaf production), but the impact of disease was greatest in plants that had been inoculated at maturity, where average leaf losses were two and a half times those recorded in virus-free plants. Disease-management of BtMV in Swiss chard is important, therefore, not only at the seedling stage, but particularly when plants are transplanted from nursery to field.
Full-text available
Considering New Zealand’s small size and remoteness, a remarkable number of plant pathogens have been recorded. A complete review of the records of plant viruses, viroids and mollicutes in New Zealand found good documentary evidence for 186 viral diseases, 5 viroids and 6 mollicutes, of which 59 viruses, 3 viroids, and 4 mollicutes have been recorded since publication of the previous complete review in 1989. Based on a lack of sufficient documented evidence, a further 27 viruses, 5 viroid and 3 mollicute records were considered unconfirmed. The confirmed pathogens not only infect agricultural and horticultural crops but some also affect the native flora.
Full-text available
Pachycladon comprises nine native species from the South Island, New Zealand, including several threatened species. Virus-like disease symptoms were observed in a Pachycladon species collection. This is the first record of a virus in Pachycladon and a further report of Turnip mosaic virus (TuMV) infections in New Zealand native hosts. This may be the first record of association between the aphid species Aulacorthum solani and Pachycladon.
Full-text available
indigenous New Zealand vascular plant flora is presented using the 2008 version of the threat classification system developed for the New Zealand Department of Conservation. The list comprises 897 taxa (38% of New Zealand’s total indigenous vascular flora) in the following categories: Extinct—6 taxa, Threatened—180 taxa (comprising 91 Nationally Critical taxa, 45 Nationally Endangered, and 44 Nationally Vulnerable), At Risk—651 taxa (comprising 83 Declining, 6 Recovering, 20 Relict, and 542 Naturally Uncommon taxa), 25 taxa listed as either Vagrant (12) or Coloniser (13), and 35 as Data Deficient. A further 171 plants are listed as taxonomically indeterminate, being those which might warrant further conservation attention once their taxonomic status is clarified. Forty-four recognised taxa and 26 plants rated as taxonomically indeterminate, and previously considered to be threatened and/or uncommon, are removed from this updated listing. A brief analysis of the patterns of rarity exhibited by the listed taxa is presented. Overall, the conservation status of the New Zealand indigenous vascular plant flora is worsening, with 7.6% of this flora now regarded as threatened with extinction. A concordance of plants names from the 2004 listing is provided.
Once widespread, Cook's scurvy grass (or nau, Lepidium oleraceum) is now confined to a few offshore populations. Classed as nationally endangered by the New Zealand Department of Conservation, populations of Cook's scurvy grass are threatened by a number of factors, including introduced herbivorous insect species such as the white butterfly (Pieris rapae) and white rust infection caused by the oomycete Albugo candida. In this paper, we investigate the occurrence of white butterfly on Cook's scurvy grass and possible interactions with the white rust infection on the northernmost of the Matariki Islands in the Firth of Thames, New Zealand. We found that larger host plants were more likely to be infested with white butterfly. The occurrence of white butterfly eggs and larvae also decreased as levels of white rust increased. Twenty-eight percent of the white butterfly larvae collected and reared in the laboratory were parasitised by the braconid wasp species Cotesia rubecula. We also reared a hyperparasitoid belonging to the super-family Chalcidoidea from one of the parasitoid cocoons. Further studies on the trophic interactions between Cook's scurvy grass, Albugo candida and white butterfly and its parasitoids could improve the understanding of the threats posed by plant pathogens and insect herbivores to populations of Cook's scurvy grass, which in turn may lead to new management strategies for conservation.
Interactions among viruses, vectors, and host plants may influence the spread and success of plant viruses. Major factors include direct competition within host plants, direct competition within vectors, differences in transmission rates, and virus influences on vector behavior and population dynamics. The aphid-transmitted barley yellow dwarf viruses (BYDVs), which infect a broad range of grasses worldwide, represent a model system for addressing questions about the outcome of direct and indirect competition between viruses. Historical shifts in the relative prevalence of BYDV strains document the apparent displacement of one virus strain (PAV) by another (MAV) over 20 yr. In the barley yellow dwarf system, transmission rate appears to play an important role in determining the outcome of competition between viruses. Moreover, the interaction between transmission rate and vector behavior may be particularly important. PAV is the stronger competitor within hosts, where double infections occur more often than in insect vectors. PAV also has significant advantages due to higher overall transmission rates than MAV. In addition, vector aphids show a strong nonpreference for PAV that may lead to greater rates of virus spread.
A taxonomic revision of the genus Lepidium L. in Australia is presented; 116 names have been accounted for and a key is provided to the recognized 34 endemic or native species and 8 naturalized introductions. Nine new species are described and illustrated: L. biplicatum, L. catapycnon, L. genistoides, L. hypenantion, L. lyratogynum, L. platypetalum, L. pseudo-hyssopifolium, L. scandens and L. xylodes. An attempt to analyse the subgeneric classification is made and two new sections and one new subsection are described: sect. Oleracea, sect. Papillosa and subsect. Diploploca.
Phylogenetic relationships of New Zealand species of Brassicaceae belonging to the South Island endemic Ischnocarpus, Iti, Notothlaspi, and Pachycladon, and the indigenous Cardamine, Cheesemania, Lep- idium, and Rorippa were studied using nuclear ribosomal internal transcribed spacer sequences. Results sup- port a monophyletic Notothlaspi and suggest that species of this genus are not closely related to Thlaspi, the genus to which Hooker provisionally assigned N. australe. The cosmopolitan genus Cardamine is paraphyletic by the inclusion of the monotypic genus Iti. The association of Iti with New Zealand Cardamine is of particular significance, as the relationships of this monotypic genus have historically proven elusive. Cheesemania species, Ischnocarpus novae-zelandiae, and Pachycladon novae-zelandiae form a closely related monophyletic group. The species of Lepidium form a monophyletic group, but the New Zealand species are not monophyletic indicating two possible dispersal events to New Zealand. Additionally, the tribes Arabidieae, Lepidieae, and Sisymbrieae are polyphyletic. This study highlights the difficulty of using traditional characters such as fruit type and cotyledon arrangement to define the tribes of the Brassicaceae.