ArticlePDF Available

Gender and climate change-induced migration: Proposing a framework for analysis

IOP Publishing
Environmental Research Letters
Authors:

Abstract and Figures

This paper proposes frameworks to analyze the gender dimensions of climate change-induced migration. The experiences, needs and priorities of climate migrants will vary by gender and these differences need to be accounted for if policies are to be inclusive. Among the vulnerable groups, women are likely to be disproportionately affected due to climate change because on average women tend to be poorer, less educated, have a lower health status and have limited direct access to or ownership of natural resources. Both the process (actual movement) and the outcomes (rural–rural or rural–urban migration, out-migration mainly of men) of climate change-induced migration are also likely to be highly gendered.
This content is subject to copyright. Terms and conditions apply.
IOP PUBLISHING ENVIRONMENTAL RESEARCH LETTERS
Environ. Res. Lett. 7(2012) 025601 (7pp) doi:10.1088/1748-9326/7/2/025601
Gender and climate change-induced
migration: proposing a framework for
analysis
Namrata Chindarkar
School of Public Policy, University of Maryland, College Park, USA
E-mail: namrata.chindarkar@gmail.com
Received 28 March 2012
Accepted for publication 29 May 2012
Published 22 June 2012
Online at stacks.iop.org/ERL/7/025601
Abstract
This paper proposes frameworks to analyze the gender dimensions of climate change-induced
migration. The experiences, needs and priorities of climate migrants will vary by gender and
these differences need to be accounted for if policies are to be inclusive. Among the
vulnerable groups, women are likely to be disproportionately affected due to climate change
because on average women tend to be poorer, less educated, have a lower health status and
have limited direct access to or ownership of natural resources. Both the process (actual
movement) and the outcomes (rural–rural or rural–urban migration, out-migration mainly of
men) of climate change-induced migration are also likely to be highly gendered.
Keywords: climate change, migration, gender, vulnerability assessment
1. Introduction
The Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (Parry
et al 2007) argues that climate change will affect human
settlements through its impacts on human health, food
security and decrease in the viability of natural resource-
based economic activity. Realizing the gravity of this
phenomenon, the United Nations Framework Convention on
Climate Change (UNFCCC) included climate change-induced
displacement, migration, and planned relocation in the 2010
and 2011 Conference of the Parties. In fact, paragraph
14(f) of the Cancun Adaptation Framework calls for deeper
examination of human impacts of climate change and
incorporation of migration policies and measures to address
displacement in national adaptation strategies.
It is believed that the effects of climate change
on population movements are likely to adversely and
Content from this work may be used under the terms
of the Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-
ShareAlike 3.0 licence. Any further distribution of this work must maintain
attribution to the author(s) and the title of the work, journal citation and DOI.
disproportionately impact poor and vulnerable population
groups, especially women (CIDA 2002, Hunter and David
2009). While research on climate change-induced migration
in itself is scarce, its impact on women is under-explored.
Climate change may not only directly impact women through
environmental changes such as rise in sea level or increases
in temperature, but also make them more vulnerable because
of its interaction with socio-cultural factors (The Government
Office for Science 2011). For instance, unequal gender
relations and access to resources may make women more
vulnerable to climate change than men (Masika 2002, p 4).
Furthermore, adaptation, that is, the ability to adapt to and
cope with changes due to climate change, is also gendered.
Adaptive capacities of individuals greatly depend on income,
education, health and access to natural resources. Given that
women tend to be poorer, less educated, have a lower health
status and have limited direct access to or ownership of
natural resources, they will be disproportionately affected
by climate change (Masika 2002, p 5, Demetriades and
Esplen 2010). For instance, it is predicted that climate change
will negatively impact food production and availability of
natural resources such as water. Scarcity of food can worsen
11748-9326/12/025601+07$33.00 c
2012 IOP Publishing Ltd Printed in the UK
Environ. Res. Lett. 7(2012) 025601 N Chindarkar
women’s nutritional status due to their marginalization within
households. Also, as women are mainly responsible for
gathering water for the household, paucity of water might
increase the burden on women. The impact on women is likely
to be worse in developing countries because of the deeper
economic and social gender divide.
One aspect of gender and climate change that remains
a huge gap and requires attention is that of climate
change-induced migration. A United Nations Population Fund
UNFPA (2009, p 35) report argues that migration requires
economic and physical capacities that are not available
to everyone. Due to issues pertaining to opportunities,
capabilities as well as security, women, children and elderly
are usually the ones left behind in the face of an environmental
crisis. However, a more thorough analysis of women’s
vulnerability to climate change-induced migration is required
to understand the gender dimensions of factors that lead to
climate change-induced migration and the differential impacts
that the process and outcomes of climate change-induced
migration have on women. The questions that need to be
examined are:
(i) How does gender influence the vulnerabilities that
increase the probability of or lead to climate change-
induced migration?
(ii) What are the gender dimensions of the process of climate
change-induced migration, that is, actual movement
of people; and outcomes of climate change-induced
migration, such as rural–rural or rural–urban migration,
out-migration mainly of men?
Although studies on gender and climate change-induced
migration are scarce, I draw upon literature and studies on
gender and climate change, gender and forced migration,
and gender and disasters from developing and developed
countries to propose a framework. Most literature deals
with the impact of sudden climate disasters such as floods,
cyclones and hurricanes, and not with the gradual effects of
climate change. However, as the frequency and severity of
sudden climate disasters is expected to increase, the findings
from these studies are pertinent. It should be emphasized
that the frameworks are intended to mainly examine
the gendered nature of internal climate change-induced
migration. However, it may be applicable to cross-border
climate change-induced migration such as Nepal–India or
Bangladesh–India, though there would be additional legal and
institutional constraints.
First, this paper reviews literature on how gender
influences peoples’ vulnerability to climate change and
subsequent migration, and proposes a framework which
can be used to conduct a gender-sensitive vulnerability
assessment. Second, the paper reviews literature to understand
the gender dimensions of the actual process of climate
change-induced migration and specific migration outcomes,
and proposes a framework to examine gender and climate
change-induced migration outcomes.
2. Gender and vulnerability to climate
change-induced migration
2.1. Review of literature
Recently, a few studies have examined the linkages between
climate change, migration, and gender using empirical
evidence. Besides empirically supporting the theories, these
studies are also methodologically relevant.
A series of studies were conducted using a monthly panel
data collected in the Chitwan Valley of Nepal that covers a
period of ten years. (Shrestha and Bhandari 2007, Massey et al
2007, Bohra-Mishra and Massey 2010). Though the primary
objective was only to study the effects of environmental
degradation on out-migration, all the studies disaggregate the
effect by gender. The methods and results of these studies
somewhat differ. However, a common conclusion is that for
women in the Chitwan Valley, an increase in the collection
time for fodder and firewood, and decline in agricultural
productivity increases the probability of local (within district)
out-migration. Climate change-induced migration for women
is therefore closely linked with deterioration of natural
resources as they are both the primary collectors and users.
In addition to environmental degradation and reduced
access to natural resources, climate variability and natural
disasters also have an impact on women’s likelihood of
migration. Using a cross-sectional survey of North Carolina
coastal residents conducted in 1999 following the disastrous
Hurricane Bonnie, Bateman and Edwards (2002) argue that
women are more likely than men to evacuate in the wake of a
natural disaster. Their findings indicate that women are more
likely to evacuate than men because of socially constructed
gender differences such as family obligations and caregiving;
greater response to evacuation incentives such as availability
of a vehicle and neighbor evacuation; higher exposure to risk
due to their low economic status and special medical needs;
and higher perceived risk due to caregiving responsibilities
(Bateman and Edwards 2002 p 107). In contrast however,
in developing countries where women’s mobility is highly
restricted such as Bangladesh, women are more likely to not
evacuate and die due to natural disasters (Fothergill 1996,
p 41). Therefore, even voluntary migration of women due to
climate change is highly correlated to social contexts.
Women’s ability to cope is another aspect of their
vulnerability to climate change-induced migration. Lambrou
and Piana (2006) argue that women’s ability to adapt to
climate change depends on their control over land and money;
access to credit and safeguards; low dependency ratios; good
health; personal mobility; and household entitlements. These
arguments are supported by ethnographic evidence which was
collected by ActionAid and the Institute for Development
Studies (IDS) in a report on the impacts of climate change
on poor South Asian women (India, Bangladesh and Nepal)
and their adaptation needs and priorities (Mitchell et al 2007).
The study, which was conducted in the Ganga river basin in
the aftermath of massive riparian flooding, also finds that poor
women particularly from Nepal were forced to migrate locally
due to their low adaptive capacity (Mitchell et al 2007, p 16).
2
Environ. Res. Lett. 7(2012) 025601 N Chindarkar
Furthermore, studies and surveys conducted in post-Hurricane
Katrina New Orleans find that poor women who lacked home
or renter’s insurance were the ones who not only lost their
shelter but also were not re-housed during the post-disaster
reconstruction process thus making it difficult for them to
return (Enarson 2006).
2.2. Conceptualizing climate change-induced migration
Climate change-induced migration, both voluntary and
forced, is a gendered and socially embedded process. To
examine the linkages between climate change, migration
and gender more formally I propose a gender-sensitive
vulnerability assessment framework. Drawing upon previous
literature on vulnerability to climate change, I define
vulnerability to climate change-induced migration as the
exposure and sensitivity of groups or individuals to stress as a
result of the impacts of climate change which in turn make
them susceptible to migration due to their low levels of or
absence of capacity to adapt (Adger 1999, IPCC 2001, Brooks
et al 2005, Adger 2006, Chambers 2006, O’Brien et al 2008).
In terms of exposure the value attributes of the hazard,
that is, its magnitude, frequency, duration and areal extent will
be important determinants of who will be affected and thus,
who will most likely be confronted with migration choices,
when and for how long. For instance, if the climatic disaster is
sudden and high in magnitude, there might be a sudden spike
in climate change-induced migration from that particular
affected region, but it may only be temporary. However, if
the climate change impact is gradual and irreversible such as
rising temperatures or sea levels over a relatively large area,
then migration might occur over a period of time and may be
permanent, with those having the capacity moving first and
the poorest being left behind.
Similarly, in terms of sensitivity, certain regions and
communities would be more sensitive to climate change-
induced migration as compared to others. For instance,
communities settled around river banks might be less sensitive
to climate change-induced migration as compared to those
settled in low-elevation coastal zones (LECZs). And in terms
of adaptive capacity, communities, which have traditionally
devised ways and methods to adapt to climate change, or
which are constantly and proactively adapting themselves,
might be less likely to migrate.
2.3. Framework to examine gender and vulnerability to
climate change-induced migration
Previous studies have used the indicator approach to
operationalize the three dimensions of vulnerability to
climate change (Yohe and Tol 2002, Brenkert and Malone
2005, Brooks et al 2005, Hanh et al 2009). I follow
a similar approach and draw upon the literature to
propose a framework to operationalize and examine gender
and vulnerability to climate change-induced migration.
Figure 1lists these indicators and potential gendered
impact. A crucial advantage of the indicator approach is
that it takes into account the multi-dimensional nature
of vulnerability. The framework also specifies the phase
during which women are most likely to be vulnerable.
For instance, when a high-intensity environmental disaster
strikes, women in culturally conservative societies could
be more vulnerable before or during migration because
they might feel ashamed to leave the house or are less
likely than men to know how to swim (Nelson et al
2002). Further, women might be more vulnerable post-
migration due to lack of education or livelihood-generating
skills.
3. Gender dimensions of the process of climate
change-induced migration
There is very little research done on how women are
affected during the actual process of climate change-induced
migration. However, some understanding can be gained from
the limited literature and research conducted in developed
countries. The main issues facing women during climate-
induced displacement are security and adequate emergency
relief (Gururaja 2000, Enarson 2006, Mitchell et al 2007,
Brown 2008, Brody et al 2008).
Brown (2008, p 34) states that just like other internally
displaced women, climate-induced women migrants are at a
greater risk of sexual and gender-based violence. Evidence on
this can be found in the ActionAid and IDS report (Mitchell
et al 2007 p 10), where many women state lack of safe
shelters upon being evacuated or forced to migrate as one
of their primary concerns. There are also other issues of
safety and security arising from women’s health status and
disintegration of social networks. Mitchell et al (2007, p 10)
observe that women suffer from psychosocial impacts of
natural disasters to a greater degree as compared to men.
The extra burden of looking after their family members
even when they themselves were in great distress resulted
in many women to suffer from anxiety and post-traumatic
stress. Further, the breaking of social ties and separation of
families also had a severe impact on these women. Similar
signs of stress were also observed among the women who
were displaced by Hurricane Katrina in New Orleans (Enarson
2006). In addition to these, often women are not allowed direct
access to relief aid because they are not the ‘head of the
household’ (Spring 2008). Such exclusion is likely to make
them more vulnerable.
A related issue is that of providing timely and adequate
emergency relief to women who have been displaced due
to climate change. A study by Enarson (1999) conducted
in-depth interviews and focus groups sessions with women
who were displaced due to two major natural disasters in
the US—Hurricane Andrew that hit Miami in 1992, and
the 1997 Red River Valley flood. She found that temporary
trailer camps provided by emergency relief workers were not
designed for the needs of women and children. There were
no provisions for their safety, and mental and reproductive
health (Enarson 1999, p 16). Another qualitative survey of
African American women displaced by Hurricane Katrina
found that they had difficulties in receiving timely emergency
3
Environ. Res. Lett. 7(2012) 025601 N Chindarkar
Figure 1. Framework to operationalize and examine vulnerability to climate change-induced migration and their gender dimensions.
aid suggesting that gender interacts with race to make some
women even worse off (Murakami-Ramalho and Durodoye
2008, as cited in Hunter and David 2009).
Though there is yet no research on this, a potential
problem pertaining to security and emergency relief is
international climate change-induced migration and the
debate over whether climate migrants need to be given
‘refugee’ status. There is a clear division amongst the
development and human rights community. One side favors
the inclusion of climate migrants in the 1951 Refugee
4
Environ. Res. Lett. 7(2012) 025601 N Chindarkar
Convention in order to provide them with protection similar
to that provided to refugees. While the other side argues that
the existence of ‘environmental migrants’ itself is exaggerated
and their need for refugee-like protection is politically
motivated (Stavropoulou 2008, p 11). This debate can have
serious repercussions for women who are already facing the
adverse consequences of climate change-induced migration
and not receiving enough relief aid.
To understand the potential gravity of the problem let
us take the example of the India–Bangladesh migration
corridor. A report by the US National Intelligence Council on
climate change and cross-border migration (US Office of the
Director of National Intelligence 2009) predicts that people
affected by climate change in Bangladesh will most likely
migrate to India. Currently, there are about 15–20 million
people who have migrated to India from Bangladesh, most
of them being illegal immigrants. India’s anti-immigration
position and the fact that it has not ratified the 1951 Refugee
Convention, exposes the entire climate migrant population
and particularly the women to high personal security risks.
There are numerous cases where illegal women migrants from
Bangladesh have been ‘sold’ as wives or trafficked because
they were not provided any protection due to their illegal
status (Ramachandran 2005, p 7–8).
Thus, women are differentially impacted during the
process of climate change-induced migration. There are
safety and security issues pertaining to internal as well
as international migration. Climate change policy aimed at
climate migrants needs to be sensitive to these issues and also
incorporate legal and human rights frameworks necessary to
assist women climate migrants.
4. Gender dimensions of the outcomes of climate
change-induced migration
Climate change will result in different migration outcomes
depending on the degree of vulnerability. Specifically,
there would be temporary versus permanent climate
change-induced migration. Even within these there are
variations in adaptive strategies such as internal (local)
versus international, and rural–rural versus rural–urban.
An important sub-component of these from a gendered
perspective is out-migration of men. Less is known about
climate change as a push factor for these migration outcomes,
and even less is known about their gender dimensions. Again
however, we can draw upon the limited literature, case studies,
and experiences of countries in other regions.
Hunter and David (2009, p 21) argue that migration
outcomes are not uniform across men and women. This
is especially true when the effects of climate change are
felt gradually and a member of the family, usually a male
member, migrates in search of alternative livelihoods. Even
when women are not the ones who are forced to migrate
in search of livelihoods, climate change-induced migration
has an impact on them. In a study conducted in the Sonora
state of Mexico, where many communities are engaged in
processing fruits and vegetables, it was found that declines in
water availability due to climate change reduced the prospects
in the food processing industry forcing a lot of men in the
community to migrate. However, this increased the workload
of women, as many of them had to care for their families
in addition to working part time in the food processing
industry (Buechler 2009, p 51). Similarly, in Nepal, as more
and more males migrate from mountainous regions and rural
areas to newly developed cities, more and more women are
becoming heads of households, remaining in areas prone to
flooding and are therefore most vulnerable to climate-related
disasters (UNFPA 2009, p 33). A study on climate change and
migration in Somalia and Burundi by Kolmannskog (2009)
found that men in many pastoral families migrated in search of
work due to severe drought conditions. Consequently, women
who were left behind faced increasing risks of expulsion
from their families and communities, and sexual violence.
In contrast, drawing upon the literature on gender and
migration, Brown (2008, p 34) posits that male out-migration
due to climate change can also have positive impacts such
as increased autonomy and decision-making power for the
female members of the family.
Women who are forced to migrate due to climate
change with their families or by themselves also face unique
problems. It was found that women from poor families in rural
Bangladesh, who migrate to cities such as Dhaka are often
forced into long hours and low-paying jobs such as domestic
servants and sweatshops due to their lack of education and
skills (Kakissis 2010). Similar observations were made in the
Philippines where women from the fishing communities, who
were grappling with the harsh impacts of climate change,
migrated locally to work as domestic helps for affluent
families (UNFPA 2009, p 3). In a report titled Katrina and
the Women of New Orleans, Willinger (2008) combined data
from the US Census and the American Community Survey to
find that post-Katrina there was a decrease of approximately
60% in the number of female-headed households, especially
of those who were African American and had children under
age 18. She further finds that the main reasons due to which
many of them could not return were affordability of housing
and health care, and lack of employment opportunities.
Thus, climate change-induced migration can potentially push
women into a poverty trap or permanently displace them from
their homes.
Drawing upon the broader literature on gender and
international or cross-border migration, it can be said that
overcoming cultural barriers while maintaining their identities
will be a significant problem for women climate migrants.
Ramachandran (2005, p 9) finds that many women who
migrated to India from Bangladesh had to or were forced to
assume Hindu religious markers, such as vermillion on their
forehead, to evade detection and deportation. The increasing
threat of climate change in Bangladesh and tightening of
the immigration policy in India will only intensify these
problems. Concerns regarding loss of culture and identity
were also observed among women in Kiribati, where
inhabitants are increasingly facing the risk of resettlement due
to sea-level rise (UNFPA 2009, p 30).
Thus, migration outcomes of climate change are also
gendered. On one hand they may seem to be empowering
5
Environ. Res. Lett. 7(2012) 025601 N Chindarkar
Figure 2. Analytical framework to examine gender and climate change-induced migration decisions.
women, while on the other they may actually exacerbate
their socio-economic status and make them worse off.
Gender distinctions in vulnerabilities not only determine who
migrates, but also, for who is it easier to return and restore
their lives.
The framework in figure 2links vulnerabilities with
migration outcomes and serves as a guide to examine
gender and climate change-induced migration decisions. For
instance, women facing high exposure but having very
low adaptive capacities are likely to be forced to migrate
permanently such as the women affected by Hurricane
Katrina, who were not able to return due to lack of housing,
relief aid, and employment opportunities. Most migration
decisions are likely to be internal or within country because
of the lack of resources to undertake international migration
following a climate change disaster, and social and economic
ties (Bohra-Mishra and Massey 2010).
5. Conclusion
In conclusion it can be said that the experiences, needs,
and priorities of climate migrants will vary by gender and
these differences need to be accounted for if policies are
to be inclusive. Governments, donor organizations, and the
civil society should shoulder the responsibility to initiate
efforts that promote women’s education, health, agricultural
knowledge and rights that will reduce the impact of
climate change on women. In thinking about vulnerability
to climate change-induced migration in developing countries,
researchers should focus on women as being one of the
most vulnerable groups. Inter-disciplinary studies on climate
migrants explicitly delineating the experiences of and effects
on men and women are required for a more nuanced
understanding of the gender dimensions. The frameworks
proposed in this paper are intended to provide a way forward.
Acknowledgments
I would like to thank the Regional and Sustainable
Development Department at the Asian Development Bank for
their support in conducting this research and their valuable
feedback.
References
Adger W N 1999 Social vulnerability to climate change and
extreme events in coastal Vietnam World Dev. 27 249–69
Adger W N 2006 Vulnerability Glob. Environ. Change 16 268–81
Aguilar L et al 2009 Training Manual on Gender and Climate
Change
Bateman J M and Edwards B 2002 Gender and evacuation: a closer
look at why women are more likely to evacuate for hurricanes
Natural Hazards Rev. 3107–17
Bohra-Mishra P and Massey D S 2010 Environmental Degradation
and Out-Migration: New Evidence from Nepal (Princeton, NJ:
Office of Population Research, Princeton University)
Brenkert A L and Malone E L 2005 Modeling vulnerability and
resilience to climate change: a case study of India and Indian
states Clim. Change 72 57–102
Brody A, Demetriades J and Esplen E 2008 Gender and Climate
Change: Mapping the Linkages—A Scoping Study on
Knowledge and Gaps (Brighton: BRIDGE, Institute of
Development Studies (IDS), University of Sussex)
Brooks N, Adger W N and Kelly P M 2005 The determinants of
vulnerability and adaptive capacity at the national level and the
implications for adaptation Glob. Environ. Change 15 151–63
Brown O 2008 Climate change and forced migration: observations,
projections and implications Background Paper for the 2007
Human Development Report (Geneva: United Nations
Development Programme)
Buechler S 2009 Gender, water, and climate change in Sonora,
Mexico: implications for policies and programmes on
agricultural income-generation Gender Dev. 17 51–66
Cannon T 2002 Gender and climate hazards in Bangladesh Gender
Dev. 10 45–50
Chambers R 2006 Vulnerability, coping and policy IDS Bull.
37 33–40
6
Environ. Res. Lett. 7(2012) 025601 N Chindarkar
CIDA 2002 Gender Equality and Climate Change: Why Consider
Gender Equality when Taking Action on Climate Change?
(Quebec: Canadian International Development Agency)
Demetriades J and Esplen E 2010 The gender dimensions of poverty
and climate change adaptation Social Dimensions of Climate
Change: Equity and Vulnerability in a Warming World
ed R Mearns and A Norton (Washington DC: The World Bank)
Denton F 2002 Climate change vulnerability, impacts, and
adaptation: why does gender matter? Gender Dev. 10 10–20
Enarson E 1999 Women and housing issues in two US disasters:
case studies from Hurricane Andrew and the Red River Valley
flood Int. J. Mass Emerg. Disasters 17 39–63
Enarson E 2006 Women and Girls Last?: Averting the Second
Post-Katrina Disaster (New York: Social Science Research
Council) (http://understandingkatrina.ssrc.org/Enarson/,
accessed 27 June 2010)
Enarson E and Morrow B H 1997 The Gendered Terrain of
Disaster: Through Women’s Eyes (Westport, CT: Greenwood)
Fothergill A 1996 Gender, risk and disaster Int. J. Mass Emerg.
Disasters 14 33–56
Gururaja S 2000 Gender dimensions of displacement Forced
Migration Rev. 913–6
Hanh M B, Riederer A M and Foster S O 2009 The livelihood
vulnerability index: a pragmatic approach to assessing risks
from climate variability and change—a case study in
Mozambique Glob. Environ. Change 19 74–88
Hunter L M and David E 2009 Climate Change and Migration:
Considering the Gender Dimensions (Boulder, CO: Institute of
Behavioral Science, University of Colorado) Working Paper,
Population Program
Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC) 2001 Climate
Change 2001: Impacts, Adaptation and Vulnerability.
Contribution of Working Group II to the Third Assessment
Report of the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change
(Cambridge: Cambridge University Press)
Kakissis J 2010 Environmental refugees unable to return home New
York Times (www.nytimes.com/2010/01/04/world/asia/
04migrants.html, accessed 18 June 2010)
Kolmannskog V 2009 Climate change, disaster, displacement and
migration: initial evidence from Africa New Issues in Refugee
Research No. 180 (United Nations High Commissioner for
Refugees)
Lambrou Y and Piana G 2006 Gender: The Missing Component of
the Response to Climate Change (New York: Gender and
Population Division, Sustainable Development Department,
Food and Agriculture Organization of the United States)
Masika R 2002 Editorial Gender Dev. 10 2–9
Massey D, Axinn W and Ghimire D 2007 Environmental Change
and Out-Migration: Evidence from Nepal (Ann Arbor, MI:
Population Studies Center, University of Michigan Institute for
Social Research)
Mitchell T, Tanner T and Lussier K 2007 We Know What We Need:
South Asian Women Speak Out on Climate Change Adaptation
(Brighton: ActionAid and Institute of Development Studies
(IDS) at the University of Sussex)
National Intelligence Council 2009 India: Impact of Climate
Change to 2030—Geopolitical Implications (prepared jointly
by CENTRA Technology Inc. and Scitor Corporation)
(Washington, DC: National Intelligence Council)
Nelson V et al 2002 Uncertain predictions, invisible impacts, and
the need to mainstream gender in climate change adaptations
Gender Dev. 10 51–9
O’Brien K et al 2008 Disaster Risk Reduction, Climate Change
Adaptation and Human Security Global Environmental Change
and Human Security Report No.3 (Oslo: University of Oslo)
Ospina A and Heeks R 2010 Unveiling the Links between ICTs &
Climate Change in Developing Countries: A Scoping Study
(Manchester: Centre for Development Informatics Institute for
Development Policy and Management, SED, University of
Manchester)
Parry M L et al (ed) 2007 Contribution of Working Group II to the
Fourth Assessment Report of the Intergovernmental Panel on
Climate Change (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press)
Ramachandran S 2005 Indifference, impotence, and intolerance:
transnational Bangladeshis in India Global Migration
Perspectives (Geneva: Global Commission on International
Migration) no. 42
Reyes R 2002 Gendering responses to El Ni˜
no in rural Peru Gender
Dev. 10 60–9
Shrestha S S and Bhandari P 2007 Environmental security and labor
migration in Nepal Popul. Environ. 29 25–38
Spring U O 2008 Gender and disasters human, gender and
environmental security: a HUGE challenge Studies of the
University: Research, Counsel, Education (Bonn: UNU
Institute for Environment and Human Security (UNU-EHS))
no. 8
Stavropoulou M 2008 Drowned in definitions Forced Migration Rev.
31 11–2
The Government Office for Science 2011 Foresight: Migration and
Global Environmental Change Final Project Report (London:
Department for Business Innovation and Skills)
UNFPA 2009 State of World Population 2009—Facing a Changing
World: Women, Population, and Climate (New York: United
Nations Population Fund)
Willinger B (ed) 2008 Katrina and the Women of New Orleans
(New Orleans, LA: Newcomb College Center for Research on
Women)
Yohe G and Tol R S J 2002 Indicators for social and economic
coping capacity moving toward a working definition of
adaptive capacity Glob. Environ. Change 12 25–40
7
... Al mismo tiempo, debemos recordar que los efectos del cambio climático no son neutros en cuestiones de género (Banque Mondiale, 2022; Chávez-Rodríguez, 2016), no impactando en la misma medida a hombres y mujeres. Como bien afirma Chindarkar (2012), este puede afectar directamente a las mujeres y hacerles más vulnerables debido a su interacción con factores socioculturales. ...
... 4) Houzir (2017) sostiene que el descenso de la producción en los oasis puede llegar a un 16% de la misma, aunque Tangerman y Traore (2016) estiman que esta reducción puede situarse entre un 17 y un 32%; y, si se trata de la producción de dátiles, este descenso llegaría hasta un 34% (Houzir, 2017). Este significativo descenso podría hacer peligrar la seguridad alimentaria de la población, con consecuencias que podrían acabar siendo desiguales entre hombres y mujeres, dada la mayor vulnerabilidad de estas últimas (Chindarkar, 2012). ...
Article
Full-text available
Resumen En este artículo abordamos la interrelación entre el turismo, la emigración y el cambio climático, a partir del caso de una comunidad oasiana en Marruecos. La localidad de Merzouga, situada al sureste de Marruecos, es una zona afectada gravemente por la sequía y la subida de temperaturas y, consecuentemente, por la falta de agua. Dicha situación ha implicado graves pérdidas en la rentabilidad agrícola. Y ha llevado a su población -antes nómada- a abandonar la ganadería y a refugiarse, por un lado, en el turismo como alternativa económica; y, por otro, en la emigración. Todo ello en una sociedad con fuertes desigualdades de género. En este artículo, tratamos de demostrar cómo el turismo, la emigración y el cambio climático se retroalimentan entre sí. Para ello, hemos empleado una metodología cualitativa con trabajo de campo, adoptando una perspectiva de género.
... In this vein, given the highly unique climate vulnerabilities, risks, and impacts among women and girls, Chindarkar (2012) and others have proposed frameworks for climate change and migration that make explicit gender-specific climate exposures, sensitivities, and adaptative capacities. Others have approached climate change and migration from a distinctively health and wellbeing lens anchored in, for example, the United Nations' Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs) and international development more broadly (Bastia 2014;Tulloch, Machingura and Melamed 2016;Wilkinson et al. 2016). ...
... Since then, research on gender and migration has come out of the shadows, leading to the awareness that migration is a highly "gendered phenomenon that requires sophisticated theoretical and analytic tools" (Donato et al. 2006, 3). As a result, an impressive array of studies have emerged to significantly expand theoretical, methodological, and empirical work in this area (e.g., see Piper 2006;Nawyn 2010;Hondagneu-Sotelo 2011;Chindarkar 2012;Donato and Gabaccia 2015;Abel and Cohen 2019;Singh et al. 2019;Boyd 2021;Anastasiadou et al. 2023;Bircan and Yilmaz 2023). Some studies have traced how gender has emerged within specific [sub]disciplines and [sub]areas of migration research that include migrant care work, transnational families, and gendered analyses of migration policies (Herrera 2013). ...
Article
For this special issue of the International Migration Review, we develop and provide a comprehensive organizing framework, the Migration Intersections Grid (MIG), to inform and guide migration research in and through the remainder of the twenty-first century. We motivate our work by conducting a high-level scoping review of summaries and syntheses of different directions of travel in migration research over time. Informed by these results, we then identify and describe 12 components that constitute the MIG, which, as we later discuss, is an interactive intersectional organizing framework. Finally, we illustrate the MIG's interactive intersectional nature by applying it to several areas of migration research where a comprehensive organizing framework of this sort is needed to address existing and emerging issues and questions now and in the coming decades.
... By integrating Vulnerability Theory, we can better understand how these dynamics exacerbate the challenges faced by women in the context of climate-induced migration (Chindarkar, 2012). Vulnerability Theory provides a lens to explore how socioeconomic disadvantages and environmental risks disproportionately affect women, particularly those from marginalized communities. ...
... The majority of earlier climate or environmental migration debates took place as if migration were a gender-neutral phenomenon, or as if gender were the exclusive property of women (Detraz and Windsor, 2014;Gioli and Milan, 2018). Several scholars have reviewed the gender-mobility-environment triad, offering valuable conceptual insights and examining available empirical evidence (Lama et al., 2021;Hummel, 2021;Gioli & Milan, 2018;Chindarkar, 2012;Hunter & David, 2009). ...
... The loss of productive labor due to out-migration can reduce agricultural productivity and food availability in rural areas, while the influx of migrants into urban centers can strain food supply chains and increase competition for resources [130]. Moreover, climate-induced displacement can exacerbate existing vulnerabilities and inequalities, particularly for women, children, and marginalized groups [131]. ...
Chapter
Full-text available
Climate change poses significant challenges to global food security and agricultural sustainability in the 21st century. Rising temperatures, altered precipitation patterns, and more frequent extreme weather events are impacting crop yields, nutrient content, and the geographic range of cultivation. This chapter examines the multifaceted effects of climate change on food systems, including impacts on crop physiology, water availability, pests and diseases, and socioeconomic factors influencing food access. Adaptation and mitigation strategies are explored, such as developing climate-resilient crops, improving water management, diversifying cropping systems, and reducing greenhouse gas emissions from agriculture. The chapter emphasizes the need for an integrated, multidisciplinary approach to address the complex interplay between climate change and food security. Collaborative efforts among researchers, policymakers, and stakeholders are essential to develop sustainable solutions that enhance the resilience
... Can Tho City was selected as the research site due to its prominence as the largest city in the Mekong Delta, with a gender, and mobility. 1 This heightened attention reflects the recognition that these factors are not isolated but are deeply intertwined, influencing one another in multifaceted ways. Scholars have focused on understanding how climate change impacts mobility patterns and how these impacts are experienced differently based on gender dynamics. ...
Chapter
Full-text available
Viet Nam’s response to its vulnerability to climate change impacts is marked by the integration of climate change concerns into sectoral laws. The Government of Viet Nam has also acknowledged the interlinkages of climate change, gender equality, and mobility within its climate regulatory framework. However, the focus on climate-related mobility has predominantly centred on macro-level mobility, which refers to the broad categorisation of migration, displacement, and planned relocation, with limited attention given to micro-level mobility. This chapter understands micro-level mobility as the smaller-scale and day-to-day movements which involve individual decisions regarding daily activities, destinations, and modes of travel. Furthermore, challenges remain in translating national commitments into local action, as evidenced by urban flooding in Can Tho City. Complex interactions between political, economic, social, and environmental elements contribute to recurring floods, with a disconnection between central Government commitments and local implementation, resulting in gendered impacts. Women in Can Tho City bear disproportionate impacts during recurring flood events, restricting their micro-level mobility in the household and public sphere. Women’s decision to remain during floods results from a complex interplay between risk perception, socio-economic elements which contribute to vulnerability, and limited macro-level mobility options. However, at the same time, these women also actively employ strategies to cope with their restricted mobility, which signifies their agency in negotiating the associated risks and adapting to recurring floods. These insights into women’s mobility behaviour during flooding offer a valuable starting point for policymakers to integrate gender and mobility, both at the macro and micro-level dynamics, into concrete climate actions. The findings also underscore the need to pay more attention to micro-level mobility within the climate-related mobility discourse.
Article
Full-text available
Climate change impacts are gendered. This is also true for climate-induced migration, which affects men and women differently. On account of this difference, legal instruments and policies seeking to address and support climate-induced migration need to be gender-focused to address differentiated needs and outcomes. This paper looks at existing policies and legal instruments for the inclusion of gender aspects of climate-related migration. We focus on Ethiopia, India, and Peru, all of them with developed instruments to address the human mobility-climate change nexus. We investigate the scope of provisions concerning gender in relevant instruments in the three country contexts, their likely impact to tackle gender-specific vulnerabilities arising with climate-induced migration and suggest strategies and priorities for enhancing gender-inclusion in policy development and application broadly.
Article
Full-text available
We conducted a systematic review of the available peer-reviewed literature that specifically focuses on the combination of sustainability and gender. We analyzed the existing peer-reviewed research regarding the extent to which gender plays a role in the empirical literature, how this is methodologically collected and what understanding of gender is applied in those articles. Our aim is to provide an overview of the current most common fields of research and thus show in which areas gender is already being included in the sustainability sciences and to what extent and in which areas this inclusion has not yet taken place or has only taken place to a limited extent. We identified 1054 papers that matched our criteria and conducted research on at least one sustainable development goal and gender research. Within these papers (i), the overall number of countries where lead authors were located was very high (91 countries). While the majority of lead authors were located in the Global North, less than a third of the articles were led by authors located in the Global South. Furthermore, gender is often just used as a category of empirical analysis rather than a research focus. We were able to identify (ii) a lack in coherent framing of relevant terms. Often no definition of sustainability was given, and only the sustainability goals (SDGs or MDGs) were used as a framework to refer to sustainability. Both gender and sustainability were often used as key words without being specifically addressed. Concerning the knowledge types of sustainability, our expectation that system knowledge dominates the literature was confirmed. While a problem orientation dominates much of the discourse, only a few papers focus on normative or transformative knowledge. (iii) Furthermore, the investigated literature was mainly contributing to few SDGs, with SDG 5 ‘Gender Equality’ accounting for 83% of all contributions, followed by SDG 8 ‘Decent Work and Economic Growth’ (21%), SDG 3 ‘Good Health and Well-being’ (15%) and SDG 4 ‘Quality Education’ (12%). We were additionally able to identify seven research clusters in the landscape of gender in sustainability science. (iv) A broad range of diverse methods was utilized that allow us to approximate different forms of knowledge. Yet within different research clusters, the spectrum of methodologies is rather homogeneous. (v) Overall, in most papers gender is conceptualized in binary terms. In most cases, the research is explicitly about women, running the risk that gender research in sustainability sciences grows into a synonym for women's studies.
Article
Full-text available
Focusing on gender differences, this article synthesizes the literature on gender, risk, and disasters, and presents a comprehensive view of what is known in this area. Data are limited, yet, by using a nine-stage typology to delineate disaster preparedness, impact, and recovery, noteworthy findings are documented and discussed. The literature reveals a pattern of gender differentiation throughout the disaster process. The differences are largely attributed to childcare responsibilities, poverty, social networks, traditional roles, discrimination, and other issues of gender stratification. The emergent patterns have important implications and recommendations for future directions are offered.
Article
Full-text available
The abstract for this document is available on CSA Illumina.To view the Abstract, click the Abstract button above the document title.
Article
Full-text available
Overview In the face of extreme weather events, desertification, and a rise in sea levels, governments and communities around the world increasingly recognise that the need to adapt to and mitigate the effects of climate change is urgent. The global agenda and negotiations focus on what governments, corporations, and institutions can do in the search for large-scale technological solutions. Yet women, men, and local communities all have roles, responsibilities, and interests that hold the potential either to harm or to benefit their environment.
Chapter
Why do more than 24,000 people—basically children—die each day from hunger and why only in Sub-Saharan Africa has the number of undernourished children grown from 29 to 37 million during the last decade (UNICEF in The state of the world’s children 2015: reimagine the future: innovation for every child. UNICEF, New York, 2015a)?
Article
This paper reviews research traditions of vulnerability to environmental change and the challenges for present vulnerability research in integrating with the domains of resilience and adaptation. Vulnerability is the state of susceptibility to harm from exposure to stresses associated with environmental and social change and from the absence of capacity to adapt. Antecedent traditions include theories of vulnerability as entitlement failure and theories of hazard. Each of these areas has contributed to present formulations of vulnerability to environmental change as a characteristic of social-ecological systems linked to resilience. Research on vulnerability to the impacts of climate change spans all the antecedent and successor traditions. The challenges for vulnerability research are to develop robust and credible measures, to incorporate diverse methods that include perceptions of risk and vulnerability, and to incorporate governance research on the mechanisms that mediate vulnerability and promote adaptive action and resilience. These challenges are common to the domains of vulnerability, adaptation and resilience and form common ground for consilience and integration.
Article
A retrospective assessment of 100 consecutive accepted referrals to a crisis intervention centre was undertaken. Successful outcome and a good level of previous coping were most likely amongst those not exposed to any of the Brown and Harris vulnerability factors, although there was no evidence for an additive effect for those experiencing more than one vulnerability factor. A significantly greater number of clients without a confidante showed a poor level of previous coping but none of the other vulnerability factors individually had a major influence on coping or outcome. The implications of the findings are discussed.
Book
Preface Gender? Why Women?: An Introduction to Women and Disaster by Elaine Enarson and Betty Hearn Morrow Perspectives on Gender and Disaster The Neglect of Gender in Disaster Work: An Overview of the Literature by Alice Fothergill Gender Inequality, Vulnerability, and Disaster: Issues in Theory and Research by Robert Bolin, Martina Jackson, and Allison Crist The Perspective of Gender: A Missing Element in Disaster Response by Joe Scanlon Social Construction of Gendered Vulnerability Eve and Adam among the Embers: Gender Pattern after the Oakland Berkeley Firestorm by Susanna M. Hoffman A Comparative Perspective on Household, Gender, and Kinship in Relation to Disaster by Raymond Wiest "Men Must Work and Women Must Weep": Examining Gender Stereotypes in Disasters by Maureen Fordham and Anne-Michelle Ketteridge Women and Post-Disaster Stress by Jane C. Ollenburger and Graham A. Tobin Balancing Vulnerability and Capacity: Women and Children during Philippine Disasters by Zenaida G. Delica Domestic Violence after Disaster by Jennifer Wilson, Brenda D. Phillips, and David M. Neal Case Studies of Women Responding to Disaster Gender, Disaster, and Empowerment: A Case Study from Pakistan by Farzana Bari Women in Bushfire Country by Helen Cox "Floods, They're a Damned Nuisance": Women's Flood Experiences in Rural Australia by C. Christine Finlay Disaster Prone: Reflections of a Female Permanent Disaster Volunteer by Carrie Barnecut Women's Disaster Vulnerability and Response to the Colima Earthquake by Carolina Serrat Vinas Gender Differentiation and Aftershock Warning Response by Paul W. O'Brien and Patricia Atchison Reflections from a Teacher and Survivor by Diane Gail Colina Women Will Rebuild Miami: A Case Study of Feminist Response to Disaster by Elaine Enarson and Betty Hearn Morrow Women in Emergency Management: An Australian Perspective by Doone Robertson Women's Roles in Natural Disaster Preparation and Aid: A Central American View by Letizia Toscani The Role of Women in Health-Related Aspects of Emergency Management: A Caribbean Perspective by Gloria E. Noel Conclusion: New Directions Toward a Gendered Disaster Science--Policy, Practice, and Research by Elaine Enarson and Betty Hearn Morrow References Index
Article
DHAKA, BANGLADESH — Mahe Noor left her village in southern Bangladesh after Cyclone Sidr flattened her family's home and small market in 2007. Jobless and homeless, she and her husband, Nizam Hawladar, moved to this crowded megalopolis, hoping that they might soon return home. Two years later, they are still here. Ms. Noor, 25, and Mr. Hawladar, 35, work long hours at low-paying jobs — she at a garment factory and he at a roadside tea stall. They are unable to save money after paying for food and rent on their dark shanty in Korail, one of the largest slums in Dhaka. And in their village, more people are leaving because of river erosion and dwindling job opportunities. "We're trapped," Ms. Noor said. Natural calamities have plagued humanity for generations. But with the prospect of worsening climate conditions over the next few decades, experts on migration say tens of millions more people in the developing world could be on the move because of disasters.