Article

Sensemaking and sojourner adjustment among Korean entrepreneurs in London (UK)

Authors:
To read the full-text of this research, you can request a copy directly from the authors.

Abstract

This paper takes a new look at the role of narrative construction in sojourner adjustment through a case study of two female Korean entrepreneurs (selected from interviews with 10 Korean sojourners) to best differentiate their cultural adjustment from ‘culture shock’ in the UK. We review the literature on culture shock, beginning with Oberg’s classic modernist/foundational ‘transformational’ model. The limitations of this model are shown in terms of the restricted focus upon individualistic, universal cognitive stages of change experienced by the sojourner. Then the benefits afforded by applying Goffman’s dramaturgy and Weick’s sensemaking approach are discussed. These approaches, informed by relationalist metatheory and metamethods, focus upon persons and interaction. They provide more collective, particularistic, social constructivist lenses that incorporate emotional, symbolic, communicative and linguistic viewpoints to complement cognitive explanations. The narrative methodology employed is that of Barbara Czarniawska whose work is heavily influenced by Goffman and Weick.

No full-text available

Request Full-text Paper PDF

To read the full-text of this research,
you can request a copy directly from the authors.

... Researchers on international management focused predominantly on expatriation Fisher and Hartel, 2003;Graf, 2004;Hartl, 2004;Jun et al., 2001;Tung, 1987), repatriation (Eschbach et al., 2001;Gregerson and Stroh, 1997;Harvey, 1982;Larson, 2006;Lazarova and Caliguiri, 2002), culture shock (Baty and Dold, 1977;Feldman and Tompson, 1992;Friedman et al., 2009;Gullahorn and Gullahorn, 1963;Li, 2012;Lowe et al., 2011;Oberg, 1960;Rajasekar and Franck, 2013;Robertson et al., 2007;Sims and Schraeder, 2004;Winn, 2013;Winkelman, 1994) and reverse culture shock (Christofi and Thompson, 2007;Howard, 1974;Murray, 1973;Rohrlich and Martin, 1991;Uehara, 1986). However, research on comparing culture shock and reverse culture shock is indeed given less importance. ...
... Another study shows that the training the expatriate receives, the demographic characteristics of expatriates, the dispositional and personality characteristic of the expatriate, the level of organisational support and the level of technical competence of the expatriate are some of the key factors that affect expatriate culture shock (Sims and Schraeder, 2004). It is a broader discourse that involves identity, self-expression and defensive mechanisms through which international assignees deal with changes in identity due to their shift in environment (Lowe et al., 2011). Though research on culture shock is well documented Eschbach et al., 2001;Friedman et al., 2009;Lowe et al., 2011;Nicolescu and Galalae, 2013;Oberg, 1960;Rajasekar and Franck, 2013;Sims and Schraeder, 2004;Smith, 2008;Winkelman, 1994), there is scarcity of studies that understand the adjustment patterns of expatriated employees on his return to the home country. ...
... It is a broader discourse that involves identity, self-expression and defensive mechanisms through which international assignees deal with changes in identity due to their shift in environment (Lowe et al., 2011). Though research on culture shock is well documented Eschbach et al., 2001;Friedman et al., 2009;Lowe et al., 2011;Nicolescu and Galalae, 2013;Oberg, 1960;Rajasekar and Franck, 2013;Sims and Schraeder, 2004;Smith, 2008;Winkelman, 1994), there is scarcity of studies that understand the adjustment patterns of expatriated employees on his return to the home country. ...
Article
Full-text available
Adaptability of individuals to different cultures and countries is a challenge to be dealt with in the growing years. This study focuses on the ability to manage culture shock and reverse culture shock of employees travelling on international assignments and returning to India. Factors such as age, income, educational qualification, overall industry experience and previous international experience were tested for managing culture shock and reverse culture shock. Data were collected from 204 employees working in the IT sector who had travelled on international assignments. Z test and chi-square test was done to analyse the collected data. The findings revealed that unlike other studies culture shock is more severe than reverse culture shock for Indian expatriates and repatriates. The study also found that though all factors are important for international employees' acculturation, income, overall work experience and previous international experience facilitated in managing diverse cultures. Managerial implications of research are presented in the end.
... Yusuf (2011) described the capacity of entrepreneurs to employ charisma in the performance of pitches to investors to achieve funding in a dramaturgical analysis. And Lowe et al. (2011) used Goffman's (1959b framework to understand Korean entrepreneurs' dramaturgical performative choices as an aspect of wayfinding adjustments made to work successfully in the United Kingdom. The work of Anderson (2005) delved more deeply into the theoretical as well as methodological use of Goffman in an entrepreneurial context. ...
Thesis
Full-text available
Research into the inner-workings of high-tech startups in the field of leadership within the United States is needed. The accelerating impact of technology on society is clear. The Internet of Things (IoT) is a primary technology of an emergent era, the Fourth Industrial Revolution (Industry 4.0). Silicon Valley startups germinate many of these Industry 4.0 IoT technologies. The current understanding of leadership in IoT startups is often based on media reports. recounting villains and heroes. This is not that. This is a qualitative, normative case study based on the researcher’s insider status at an IoT startup. Insider case study research into leadership of this type is sparse. Based on a review of the literature, multiple one-on-one interviews were conducted with leaders in an IoT startup. An additional 12 interviews were conducted with leaders in the IoT startup field. This study asks: What does it take to lead an IoT startup in Silicon Valley? The data supported the use of Goffman’s (1959b) dramaturgy as an analytical tool for leadership. The leadership at IoT Inc. took on prescribed roles in formal and informal settings. Bourdieu’s (2020) social capital, habitus, and field concepts are also supported for analyzing IoT startups. The individuals at IoT Inc. used social capital and exhibited habitus based on experiences and expertise while interacting with the IoT field. Chia’s (2013) process orientation and application of knowledge types like techne, metis, and phronesis is supported. Leaders in the case study exhibited complexity-based leadership when pursuing opportunities in an environment of constrained resources. The data demonstrated that entrepreneurial leaders with accumulated social capital and habitus, who understand the dramaturgical context of an emergent technology field, applied forms of knowledge - techne, episteme, metis, phronesis, and arete - and expertise pragmatically to navigate the complexity in pursuit of a vision.
... Cultural differences in emotion rules and how power is performed through those rules may affect ethnic relations at work (Shenoy-Packer 2014). Emotions, as a form of power within a culturally diverse group, may cause cultural shocks and challenges in interpersonal communication and strengthen inequality and exclusion (Lowe, Hwang, and Moore 2011). ...
Article
Full-text available
This paper examines how emotion rules are socially constructed and how and why they are enacted and challenged through specific modes of embodiment in face-to-face interactions. The paper broadens the understanding of emotion rules by connecting them to aesthetics to explore face-to-face interactions. This paper is based on ethnographic data gathered from a two-year study of a micro-sized service company. It explores the structure, function, and meaning of three emotion rules: (1) the emotionality rule, (2) the enthusiasm rule, and (3) the nice way rule as enacted by the company's chief executive officer (CEO) and employees. This paper enhances the understanding of the role of emotion rules in establishing an innovative and democratic organisation. It offers insight into how emotion rules were enacted, challenged, and broken in an unexpected situation when the CEO announces her non-consultative decision that affected the company's employees. ARTICLE HISTORY
... This may be particularly beneficial for small entrepreneurial firms, in which an entrepreneur is the core representative of the firm. For instance, the multicultural identity of migrant entrepreneurs may result in them having better skills at developing and maintaining business relationships with partners across cultures (see Lowe et al., 2011). Therefore, the increasing amount of migrant entrepreneurs creates the need to consider multiculturality and its consequences for the current and future international business environments. ...
... Mainly, open display of emotions is less common in Finland (Vuori 2011), but at the same time, the long cultural history of appreciating honesty and openness (Ekwall and Karlsson 1999;Valtonen 2007) in face-to-face interaction has laid the ground for culturally-specific emotional expressions between Finns. Cultural differences in emotion rules and embedded power relations may have a potential impact on ethnic relations at work and the use of emotions as a form of power within a diverse group of employees may cause culture shocks and lead to ineffectiveness in interpersonal communication (Lowe, Hwang and Moore 2011). Shenoy-Packer (2014), for instance, described the potential for misunderstanding emotional displays in culturally diverse workplaces. ...
Thesis
Full-text available
Tutkimus tarkastelee tunteita, valtaa ja toimijuutta pienen organisaation uudistamisessa. Metaforinen käsite tunnevalta kiinnittää huomion tunne-esityksiin ja valtaan toisiinsa kietoutuneina ilmiöinä. Aineisto koostuu kokousten videotallenteista, ja sitä täydennettiin työpaja-aineistolla, haastatteluilla ja havainnoinnilla. Tutkimus antaa uutta tietoa siitä, miten tunnevalta on systeemistä matalaa valtaa, joka mahdollistaa ja rajoittaa toimijuutta merkitysten alati muuttuvilla näyttämöillä.
... Weickin (1988;1995, 20) (Weick 1985). Kun yksilö kohtaa uutta, hän joutuu määrittelemään uudelleen omaa itseään, sosiaalista verkostoaan ja toimintaansa sen osana (Lowe, Hwang & Moore 2011;Hilde & Mills 2017). Se, millaiseksi näkee itsensä, muokkaa sitä, millaiseksi ymmärtää ympäröivän maailman. ...
... Yet, in a globalised world, being a cultural sojourner – someone who temporarily spends time in another country (Sussmann, 2002a) – is an increasingly common feature. One should note that sojourning differs from migration because (1) it does not imply the stabilisation in a different country/culture and (2) it implies a double process of adaptation: first to the new space and later during repatriation (Leong & Ward, 2000; Lowe, Hwang, & Moore, 2011; Sussmann, 2002a, 2002b). ...
Article
Full-text available
This special commentary section proposes new directions in researching the nexus of ethnicity and well-being under three themes of (1) mobility and shifting identities in relation to place, (2) empowerment and identity performance in relation to the virtual space, and (3) religious conflicts in relation to markets and spaces of consumption. The three short essays in this collection are geared towards accelerating research on ethnicity in marketing and consumer behaviour. They problematize the very nature of ethnicity in relation to space and how ethnicity is performed in different spaces by looking at the issues of social relations, transformations and conflict. They suggest potential areas of enquiry, particularly for new (doctor of philosophy) research projects, policy-focused research grant applications, conferences/seminars/workshops and also classroom activities and teaching purposes.
... Korean culture plays a major part in how female-owned businesses are looked at. To also plays a major part in adjusting to other cultures, as evident in a study of Korean entrepreneurs in London (Lowe et al., 2011). Korea is known to be conservative at heart and being an entrepreneur is looked upon as being deviant or rebellious. ...
Article
Full-text available
Less than one-fifth of all entrepreneurs are women in Korea (Xavier et al., 2012). We investigate the determinants of Korean women entrepreneurs' firm performance. Specifically, we examine the impact of personal problems and family support and their interaction effects on firm performance. We find empirical support for the negative effects of personal problems on firm performance and positive moderation effects of family support on this link. Implications and future studies are discussed.
... Yet, in a globalised world, being a cultural sojournersomeone who temporarily spends time in another country (Sussmann, 2002a)is an increasingly common feature. One should note that sojourning differs from migration because (1) it does not imply the stabilisation in a different country/culture and (2) it implies a double process of adaptation: first to the new space and later during repatriation (Leong & Ward, 2000;Lowe, Hwang, & Moore, 2011;Sussmann, 2002aSussmann, , 2002b. ...
Article
Full-text available
Research into consumer ethnicity is a vital discipline that has substantially evolved in the past three decades. This conceptual article critically reviews its immense literature and examines the extent to which it has provided extensive contributions not only for the understanding of ethnicity in the marketplace but also for personal/collective well-being. We identify two gaps accounting for scant transformative contributions. First, today social transformations and conceptual sophistications require a revised vocabulary to provide adequate interpretive lenses. Second, extant work has mostly addressed the subjective level of ethnic identity projects but left untended the meso/macro forces affecting ethnicity (de)construction and personal/collective well-being. Our contribution stems from filling both gaps and providing a theory of ethnicity (de)construction that includes migrants as well as non-migrants.
... According to (Flanagan 1954), method of critical incidents emphasizes objective truth, not the subjective interpretation. (Lowe et al. 2011), however, used the analysis of critical incidents as heuristics that focuses researchers to analyze events and actions. From research view, focusing on extremities may be easier than focusing on usual or average behavior. ...
Conference Paper
Full-text available
In this case study, we analyzed teacher and peer influence on how student makes sense of recorded lectures. 14 students were asked to watch recorded lectures and complete related statistical assignments in pairs. On-screen activity and collaboration was recorded and eye tracking was used to indicate the most used features and regions of the user interface. From these data, we identified critical incidents for sensemaking. According to our findings, a teacher may help students focus on certain issues by verbal or visual cues. Challenging questions that are related to teaching resources and peers’ feedback also help students to discover unclear issues. Especially, when the weaker student challenges the more talented one to rationalize and verbalize his thoughts, both students may create deeper understanding that materializes in better grades. Instead, imitating and copying teacher’s actions while solving statistical problems was not seen as effective learning strategy.
Article
Full-text available
This is a conceptual study that suggests the importance of “entrepreneurial symbolic management” in enhancing the business growth potential of ventures. Symbolic management is a means of effectively communicating the significance of a venture’s new business in a complex market environment by increasing its identifiability, while inducing stakeholders to associate symbols with their own meanings while appealing to their imagination. To date, studies have pointed out the importance of symbolic management, but there is little evidence that it is an effective strategy for venture business growth. In addition, the concept of symbolic management is complicated by similar arguments that exist in proximity, such as the identity argument and the brand argument, and researchers have not reached a consensus on a unified view of the concept. This study conceptually suggests that ventures can survive the fierce market environment and raise their own viability by appropriately practicing symbolic management.
Article
Full-text available
This paper aims to problematize cross-cultural management (CCM) discourse that naturalizes and depoliticizes similarities as a power-neutral or even power-neutralizing mechanism for creating a positive sense of familiarity, closeness, trust, and intimacy between partners. Employing a postcolonial perspective, the paper deals with the ambiguity and partiality embedded in similarity through Homi Bhabha’s theoretical concept of mimicry – when similarities conceal and therefore tacitly reproduce and reinforce cultural differences, thus enhancing power asymmetries. Through the systematic content analysis of 151 accounts of similarity in Israel-Korean business alliances – asking who is similar to whom (direction), to what extent (degree), and under what circumstances (context) – this paper reveals similarities construction as a sophisticated othering. Rather than being an effective tool for distance management, similarities-as-mimicry, imposed or desired, determine the hierarchical relations between the compared parties through symbolic projection of being or becoming similar from a superior model to its imitation.
Book
Full-text available
This open access book brings together narratives of inbound and outbound expatriate entrepreneurship in Japan to provide a comprehensive overview of international entrepreneurship in the region. Through in-depth interviews with expatriate entrepreneurs, policymakers, and additional stakeholders it provides the reader with a solid understanding of the current landscape of international entrepreneurship as it relates to Japan and the challenges for policymakers. The topics addressed in this book include definitions of expatriate entrepreneurship, entrepreneurship policy development and implementation, concepts of mindset, cultural brokerage, community, and identity as they relate to Japanese self-initiated expatriate entrepreneurs working in South East Asia and to non-Japanese self-initiated expatriate entrepreneurs working in Japan. Additionally, the book provides an overview of issues connected to regional development and economic growth in Asia. Illustrated through carefully chosen cases from Japan, Myanmar, Thailand, Cambodia, Vietnam, and Indonesia and developed by connecting these cases to policy and interdisciplinary studies, this book is highly recommended to scholars, policymakers and practitioners who seek an in-depth and up-to-date integrated overview of the field of expatriate entrepreneurship in Asia.
Chapter
Full-text available
Article
Full-text available
One of the central tenets of Karl Weick's work and one of his original contributions to organization theory is his insistence that organizational scholars should study structures of events rather than people, objects, or pseudo-objects, important as they all are. Through the operation of sensemaking, events may be portrayed as meaningful actions or random occurrences, but it is the connections among them that are central to organizing. This paper connects Karl Weick's work to that of Floyd H. Allport and Erving Goffman, two among several writers who inspired Weick. These three authors shared an interest in what Allport called structuring, Goffman called ordering, and Weick called organizing of the events and experiences of everyday life. This genealogical presentation of their work attempts to situate their thoughts within contemporary debates in social sciences, including those determined by the spirit of the times.
Article
Full-text available
Recent hires (n = 149) in 12 electronics manufacturing firms were asked to relate their experiences of formative events and the messages derived from them. Newcomers also described the behavioral norms characterizing their organization, one facet of its culture. Critical incidents newcomers reported were significantly related to their perceptions of behavioral norms. The messages newcomers interpreted from these incidents were coded in terms of positive or negative frame (emphasizing desirable or undesirable outcomes). Positively framed events were related to experiencing the organization's culture as team-oriented. Negatively framed events were related to describing the culture as more control-oriented. Analyses indicate that the critical incidents impact beliefs regarding cultural norms through their effect on the frame of the message newcomers derive from the events. Moreover, team norms were negatively related to role conflict and positively related to role clarity. Findings are interpreted with respect to proactive and reactive roles played by newcomers in their own socialization.
Article
Full-text available
A review of empirical studies that directly investigated the overseas adjustment of expatriate managers revealed four dimensions that were related to successful expatriate acculturation: (1) the "self-oriented" dimension; (2) the "others-oriented" dimension; (3) the "perceptual" dimension; and (4) the "cultural-toughness" dimension. The study's implications for expatriate selection and training procedures in multinational corporations are discussed.
Article
Full-text available
This paper examines the socialization of graduate recruits into a knowledge intensive labour process and organizational culture. Theoretically the paper draws upon the idea of ‘preparing for work’ to position this early socialization as a crucial moment in the production of subjectivities suited (and booted) for the labour process of management consulting. Empirically the paper reports on a two‐day induction session for new graduate recruits joining a global management consultancy and their responses to this training. Particular attention is given to the use of role‐play and a dramaturgical workshop used in part of the training process. The paper argues that the utilization of dramaturgy in training is consistent with the overall approach to control developed in the firm in response to the fact that the labour process of consulting is often conducted on client sites, away from any direct supervisory gaze. As such, the consultants were subjected to a form of cultural control that was designed to function independently of direct supervision. This control did not operate directly upon the new employees professed values, however, but at one step removed so that a ‘cynical distance’ from the content of the organization’s culture was accepted so long as a professional ‘ethic of behaviour’ was established. By focusing on an ‘ethic of behaviour’ these young professionals were encouraged to internalize a self‐control akin to that of an actor, rather than internalizing the corporate values entirely.
Article
Full-text available
Considers the general description of intercultural adjustment by means of a w-curve function of culture shock. Very little apparent integration exists among the various approaches for explaining or understanding the sojourner's adjustment. Social patterns of behavior and personality traits have not been very successful in explaining intercultural adjustment, while social interaction and background and situational factors have been of somewhat greater value. These divergent approaches can be more meaningfully understood in relation to adjustment to the degree that they facilitate or impede intercultural communication. Thus, intercultural communication appears to be both an integrating and crucial factor for understanding the adjustment of the sojourner. (2 P. Ref.) (PsycINFO Database Record (c) 2012 APA, all rights reserved)
Article
Culture shock tends to be an occupational disease of people who have been suddenly transplanted abroad. Like most ailments, it has its own symptoms, cause, and cure. Many missionaries have suffered from it. Some never recovered, and left their field. Some live in a constant state of such shock. Many recover beautifully. As will be clear from the implications of Dr. Oberg's article, the state of culture shock in which a Christian lives will have great bearing on his temperament and witness.
Article
The paper seeks to address the ways in which organizations are selective in the aspects of employees which they want and value, and those which are implicitly rejected by the organization. As such, the paper considers Diderot's famous comparison between acting and whoring in order to give emphasis to what might be termed 'performed synedoche' in the employee role. The paper draws on a range of examples from service occupations in order to explore what 'performed synedoche' might mean in practice. It concludes with a discussion of the necessary hypocrisy of certain aspects of the service role and examines the psychological costs which attach to this type of performance.
Book
Cross-cultural management is a crucial challenge for the successful development of international business, yet it is often badly understood and poorly implemented. Misunderstandings arise as culture affects both individuals and organizations, yet attempts to understand, explain and interpret these differences have often been hidden between a welter of conflicting theories and paradigms. This book is a much-needed guide to the theory and practice of cross-cultural management. It focuses on four key areas: The language connection. The global connection. The management connection. The multimedia connection. Using an innovative approach combining theory, tool-kits and applications, it takes a fresh look at this complex topic, investigating the recognition of cross-cultural differences, accounting for them in managerial communications, and bridging them in a variety of negotiations, interactions and collaborative projects.
Article
This paper examines the theoretical backgrounds on knowledge management and cross-cultural management in international project settings. The purpose of this paper is to clarify explored and unexplored areas in current research. Propositions of a concept, project knowledge management from a cross-cultural perspective, is presented, establishing an expanded role of knowledge management. The literature review is made up of three parts: "Models and Theories on Knowledge Management", "Knowledge Management Theories Focusing on Projects" and "Knowledge Management Theories Focusing on Cross Cultural Settings". The research situated on the boundary among them are introduced, in addition to the relationships. © Common Ground, Miwa Nishinaka, Katsuhiro Umemoto, All Rights Reserved.
Article
Recent work in cognitive psychology and social cognition bears heavily on concerns of sociologists of culture. Cognitive research confirms views of culture as fragmented; clarifies the roles of institutions and agency; and illuminates supra-individual aspects of culture. Individuals experience culture as disparate bits of information and as schematic structures that organize that information. Culture carried by institutions, networks, and social movements diffuses, activates, and selects among available schemata. Implications for the study of identity, collective memory, social classification, and logics of action are developed.
Book
Scitation is the online home of leading journals and conference proceedings from AIP Publishing and AIP Member Societies
Article
Currently working on the Chinese mainland, Western expatriate business managers, mainly from the USA, France, Germany, Australia and Great Britain, participated in a mail survey regarding their degree of adjustment which was then mapped over time. The results showed that while the three dimensions of sociocultural adjustment; work adjustment, interaction adjustment and general adjustment, all showed a clear U-curve pattern indicating a typical culture shock experience, no such pattern was displayed in the case of psychological adjustment as measured by their subjective well-being. Implications for Western expatriate business managers on the Chinese mainland and for companies assigning Western expatriates there are discussed.
Article
Currently working on the Chinese mainland, Western expatriate business managers, mainly from the USA, France, Germany, Australia and Great Britain, participated in a mail survey regarding their degree of adjustment which was then mapped over time. The results showed that while the three dimensions of sociocultural adjustment; work adjustment, interaction adjustment and general adjustment, all showed a clear U-curve pattern indicating a typical culture shock experience, no such pattern was displayed in the case of psychological adjustment as measured by their subjective well-being. Implications for Western expatriate business managers on the Chinese mainland and for companies assigning Western expatriates there are discussed.
Article
A critical incident study examined the factors perceived by employees to cause high and low productivity. One hundred and fifty-two employees from one firm, working in managerial, clerical, and professional jobs were interviewed. The interview responses were coded into factors within each of three broad categories: external events, agents, and personal traits. Generally, goals, deadlines or schedules, workload, and task interest were the most frequently mentioned events. The self, the organization, and the immediate supervisor were most often cited as agents. The most frequently mentioned personal traits were: satisfaction, pride, frustration, and desire for recognition. The implications of these findings for various schools of management thought are discussed.
Article
This article outlines a training activity that can enable both business and governmental professionals to translate the principles in a code of ethics to a specific list of company-related behaviors ranging from highly ethical to highly unethical. It also explores how this list can become a concrete model to follow in making ethical decisions. The article begins with a discussion as to what will improve ethical decision making in business and government. This leads us to explore the factors that can most easily lead to improvement, namely a comprehensive code of conduct and employee training. From there we look at the Critical Incident Technique as a training strategy that has the potential for identifying those behaviors that distinguish really outstanding behaviors from those that go “by the book”, and can be used to encourage more independent thinking and to set expectations for future decisions. If employees are given the skills and examples that will enable them to make better decisions, they can apply them to any situation.
Article
An approach is presented here for analyzing the relationship between cultural and social action in bureaucracy. Symbols and power are shown as the primary variables of sociocultural study, where symbolic forms and techniques are manipulated by asymmetrical groups in the articulation of basic interests. Through their interrelationship the organizational conditions of production are reproduced or transformed. Social drama is the processual unit through which power relations, symbolic action, and their interaction are played out, and through which social structure is made evident. This perspective is applied to data from an ethnographic study of an advertising agency.
Article
This study examines the method of scenario analysis as a means of exposing hidden assumptions which cause misattributions that lead to multicultural conflict and as a way of assessing cross-cultural understanding. Results from thirty-five critical incident interviews of technical professionals and semi-structured scenario questionnaires from graduate business and engineering students are presented. The results provide support for the use of scenarios as a method of exposing hidden assumptions leading to multicultural conflict and as a process which helps participants deal with the conflict. Implications for organizational research and practice are discussed, including the use of scenario analysis as an evaluation and measurement tool for culturally-related conflict in organizations.
Article
Recent work in cognitive psychology and social cognition bears heavily on concerns of sociologists of culture. Cognitive research confirms views of culture as fragmented; clarifies the roles of institutions and agency; and illuminates supra-individual aspects of culture. Individuals experience culture as disparate bits of information and as schematic structures that organize that information. Culture carried by institutions, networks, and social movements diffuses, activates, and selects among available schemata. Implications for the study of identity, collective memory, social classification, and logics of action are developed.
Article
Bolman and Deal (1984, 1991) have developed four perspectives, or frames, for understanding organizations and leadership: structural, human resource, political, and symbolic. This paper reports two studies that operationalize that model. The first study uses critical incidents written by managers to assess how many and which frames they use. Most incidents show the use of one or two frames; very few contain all four. In every population, the structural frame was used frequently while the symbolic frame was rarely evident. Across different populations, the use of the human resource and political frames varied substantially. The second study used survey instruments to assess managers' frame orientations. Regression analyses show that their orientations, as perceived by colleagues, are differentially related to perceived effectiveness as manager and leader. Managerial effectiveness is related to an emphasis on rationality and organizational structure. Leadership effectiveness is linked to symbols and culture. For men and women in comparable positions, gender is unrelated to leadership orientations or to their effectiveness as managers or leaders.
Article
This paper focuses on identity and identification on a network level of analysis. Perceptions of competition and cooperation in relationships arising from such an approach are explored, and the concept of network identification is introduced, with an explicit focus on boundaries that are activated, questioned and moved. At a network level of analysis it is less obvious who are competitors and who are not. In general the approach encourages an enhanced awareness of interdependence and embeddedness, which in turn promotes a more comprehensive sense of belonging and a new perception of goal compatibility. It is suggested that the focus on competition in the terminology of the contemporary business discourse need to be paired with a perception of relations as involving a sense of shared destiny.
Article
The paper seeks to address the ways in which organizations are selective in the aspects of employees which they want and value, and those which are implicitly rejected by the organization. As such, the paper considers Diderot's famous comparison between acting and whoring in order to give emphasis to what might be termed "performed synedoche" in the employee role. The paper draws on a range of examples from service occupations in order to explore what "performed synedoche" might mean in practice. It concludes with a discussion of the necessary hypocrisy of certain aspects of the service role and examines the psychological costs which attach to this type of performance.
Article
This article reports part of a two stage study of intercultural communication between first generation immigrants from India and Euro-Americans. In-depth interviews were used in the first stage to develop intercultural “critical incidents” for use as stimulus material in a survey. The survey was used in the second stage to explore participant perceptions of the influence of national culture as well as rules for managing intercultural interactions. It was determined that while participants did not agree in their perceptions of the influence of culture, they generally agreed on the dominant culture rules for competent intercultural communication in each of the critical incidents. In addition, support was found for the tacit influence of cultural differences on perceptions of competent communication between Asian Indians and Euro-Americans in one critical incident involving the proper amount of supervision.
Article
This study reviews the considerations involved in employing an expatriate industrial sales force and then explores the nature of culture shock and sojourner adjustment in terms of their impact on expatriate sales performance and turnover. Managerial actions for enhancing expatriate performance and reducing turnover are suggested.