ArticlePDF Available

‘Cleanliness is next to godliness’Religious change, hygiene and the renewal of Heraka villages in Assam

Authors:

Abstract and Figures

This article investigates the link between religious change and perceptions of and attitudes towards ‘hygiene’ and ‘order’ amongst adherents of Heraka, a religious reform movement among the Zeme Naga of Assam. It examines the problematic role of sacrifice, its relation-ship to the economy, and the consequent theological shift towards a monotheistic god, Tingwang, by focusing on the ritual of a Heraka village renewal. Not only does this ritual validate the abandonment of sacrifice, but also greatly diminishes disease-creating conditions—with blood equalling dirt—that traditional sacrifices had allegedly involved. Thus, while it can be said that ‘secular’ factors such as economic and health benefits explain the ‘conversion’ to Heraka, the article argues that theological beliefs, in particular Christian notions of ‘cleanliness is next to godliness’, also had an impact on the Heraka.
Content may be subject to copyright.
http://cis.sagepub.com/
Sociology
Contributions to Indian
http://cis.sagepub.com/content/45/2/189
The online version of this article can be found at:
DOI: 10.1177/006996671104500202
2011 45: 189Contributions to Indian Sociology
Arkotong Longkumer
renewal of Heraka villages in Assam
'Cleanliness is next to godliness': Religious change, hygiene and the
Published by:
http://www.sagepublications.com
can be found at:Contributions to Indian SociologyAdditional services and information for
http://cis.sagepub.com/cgi/alertsEmail Alerts:
http://cis.sagepub.com/subscriptionsSubscriptions:
http://www.sagepub.com/journalsReprints.navReprints:
http://www.sagepub.com/journalsPermissions.navPermissions:
http://cis.sagepub.com/content/45/2/189.refs.htmlCitations:
What is This?
- Sep 30, 2011Version of Record >>
at The University of Edinburgh on May 16, 2014cis.sagepub.comDownloaded from at The University of Edinburgh on May 16, 2014cis.sagepub.comDownloaded from
‘Cleanliness is next to godliness’:
Religious change, hygiene and the
renewal of Heraka villages in Assam
Arkotong Longkumer
This article investigates the link between religious change and perceptions of and attitudes
towards ‘hygiene’ and ‘order’ amongst adherents of Heraka, a religious reform movement
among the Zeme Naga of Assam. It examines the problematic role of sacrifice, its relation-
ship to the economy, and the consequent theological shift towards a monotheistic god,
Tingwang, by focusing on the ritual of a Heraka village renewal. Not only does this ritual
validate the abandonment of sacrifice, but also greatly diminishes disease-creating
conditions—with blood equalling dirt—that traditional sacrifices had allegedly involved.
Thus, while it can be said that ‘secular’ factors such as economic and health benefits
explain the ‘conversion’ to Heraka, the article argues that theological beliefs, in particular
Christian notions of ‘cleanliness is next to godliness’, also had an impact on the Heraka.
Keywords: religious change, sacrifice, hygiene, Heraka, Zeme Nagas.
I
Introduction
A widespread, if not always explicit, view of modernisation associates it
with the abandonment of traditional religious and cultural practices in
favour of economic and scientific notions rooted in post-Enlightenment
European thought. If such a clear-cut and comprehensive abandonment
ever happened, it was certainly not typical. In most cases, the change
described as ‘modernising’ arises in contexts in which there are iden-
tifiable, and crucial, continuities between past and future, and where
Contributions to Indian Sociology 45, 2 (2011): 189216
SAGE Publications Los Angeles/London/New Delhi/Singapore/Washington DC
DOI: 10.1177/006996671104500202
Arkotong Longkumer is a lecturer in Religious Studies, University of Edinburgh.
Email: A.longkumar@ed.ac.uk
at The University of Edinburgh on May 16, 2014cis.sagepub.comDownloaded from
Contributions to Indian Sociology 45, 2 (2011): 189–216
190 / ARKOTONG LONGKUMER
religious, economic, educational, medical and domestic beliefs and
practices are deeply intertwined. With the advent of modernisation, there
is a fragmentation of ‘traditional society’ into differentiated and dispersed
practices. ‘Old practices’ are reassessed in a new light that transforms
how they are understood, while ‘new practices’, under the aegis of
‘reform’, are formulated so as to maintain continuities with the past. The
case of the Heraka, a religious reform movement, popular among the
Zeme Naga of North Cachar Hills, Assam, India (see Figure 1), illustrates
this with especial clarity. In particular, the movement brought to bear
new ideas of ‘advancement’ and ‘order’ that resulted in a reworking of
the perception of ‘hygiene’ and ‘health’ among the Zeme.
Although, there is a large number of studies that analyse the relation-
ship between modernisation, illness and its diagnosis within cultural
frameworks (Garro and Mattingly 2000; Kleinman 1988), and the tensions
between indigenous healing systems and Western medical science (Pigg
1995; Wing 1998),1 there is a paucity of research that explicitly examines
the link between hygienic practices and religious change. This article
aims to address this lacuna by examining how religious change has been
influential in reworking the practical connection between illness and
better hygiene for the Heraka. Not only does this connection provide a
basis and explanation for religious change, but also points to how these
ideas developed in conjunction and competition with Christianity. The
article is organised to highlight several interrelated themes that underpin
this central point.
First, the article examines the genesis of the Heraka movement in the
North Cachar Hills. The central tenet of the Heraka posits it as a departure
from Paupaise2 (ancestral practice), especially with regard to the adoption
1 Modernisation’s focus on hygiene was an important aspect of the colonial and post-
colonial discourse on sanitation and public health. Some scholars (Anderson 2006;
Bashford 2004; Burke 1996) have shown how ideas of hygiene in colonial/post-colonial
situations centred around controlling disease and disciplining the body, and have analysed
the role of science and medicine in mediating the organisation of good governance. Since
there is scant evidence to suggest that there was any such link between hygiene and gov-
ernance amongst the Zeme in North Cachar Hills, I do not find the above analysis pertinent
to my study. Rather, most of the discourse on hygiene is connected to the language of
cleanliness, informed through the process of reform and proximity to Christian ideas.
2 ‘Paupaise’ literally means grandfather–grandmother practice (Pau-pai-se), and is a
20th century construction by the Heraka and Christians to separate their own ‘practices’
from those of their ancestors. Paupaise traditionally encompassed the entirety of a Zeme
at The University of Edinburgh on May 16, 2014cis.sagepub.comDownloaded from
‘Cleanliness is next to godliness’ / 191
Contributions to Indian Sociology 45, 2 (2011): 189–216
Figure 1
Note: Map not to scale and does not depict authentic boundaries.
at The University of Edinburgh on May 16, 2014cis.sagepub.comDownloaded from
Contributions to Indian Sociology 45, 2 (2011): 189–216
192 / ARKOTONG LONGKUMER
of a sky god, Tingwang. For the Heraka, the significance of Tingwang as
the principal deity is two-fold: (a) he was seen as mobile as his overarch-
ing presence delimited any territorial reach; and (b) because traditionally
his status was that of a minor (and distant god), he required fewer sacri-
fices. Therefore, this cosmological shift was associated with the economic
ease that the reduction (and eventual abolishment) of sacrifices brought
about. Not only did this shift characterise the importance of cosmological
change, but it also helped explain the abandonment of the many smaller
gods, and the subsequent reconfiguration of Heraka society. This process
is explained below in important rituals such as village renewals.
Second, the article examines the reconfiguration of the role of sacrifice
within the Heraka movement. It further demonstrates how the under-
standing of illness was connected with the practice of sacrificing.3 It dis-
cusses the manner in which Heraka cosmology negotiated and interacted
with concurrent social changes, such as the move away from using sacri-
fices and the Heraka’s relationship with Christianity. Third, to demon-
strate how cosmological change, the role of sacrifices, illness and hygiene
interacted; the article examines the renewal of a Heraka village. Import-
antly, I draw on the connection between metaphor and the management
of hygiene, especially as it articulates and reflects the process of religious
change for the Heraka. Although ideas of purification, healing and illness
can be associated with the intrinsic process of becoming ‘converted’ from
Paupaise/Heraka to Christianity, I, however, discuss the difficulty of
strictly applying a conversion model between the Paupaise and Heraka.
I, therefore, argue that the use of metaphors articulated by Ricoeur (1978)
is better framed to address the developments between the Paupaise and
Heraka, particularly as it pertains to religious change.4 Finally, the article
person’s life and made him/her a human (zemena). Gods, rituals, sacrifices, agriculture,
household customs, taboos, kin relations, were all intertwined and governed by Paupaise
hingde (rules governing everyday life). Although the Heraka initially continued in the
tradition of Paupaise by reforming only selected practices, both groups now see themselves
as different religious communities.
3 It must be noted that illness is understood here as a patho-physiological process, and
a culturally shaped understanding. Disease, on the other hand, is the problem from the
medical practitioner’s perspective that shows how illness is recast utilising theories of
disorder (Kleinman 1988: 4–5).
4 Change from Paupaise to Heraka historically has been associated with ‘conversion’
by the Paupaise and Christians in the region. Although I argue that the Heraka are a reform
at The University of Edinburgh on May 16, 2014cis.sagepub.comDownloaded from
‘Cleanliness is next to godliness’ / 193
Contributions to Indian Sociology 45, 2 (2011): 189–216
investigates how the relationship between health and wealth is valued as
a result of these changes, and how ultimately ‘advancement’ resonates
with the formation of a modern religious community. First, however, let
us begin with the geography and context.
II
Geography and context
The Zeme are a Naga tribe,5 who were separately classified for admin-
istrative purposes by the British between 1834 and 1947, and have re-
mained fragmented even after Indian independence, in the contiguous
areas of three north-eastern states: Assam, Nagaland and Manipur. Their
desire for a unified administrative area within the Indian Union was
championed in the 1960s and 1970s by the leader of the Heraka move-
ment, Rani Gaidinliu (also Gaidinliu, Ranima [queen mother]), under
the pan-tribal union known as the Zeliangrong movement which is a
combination of the three prefixes of the ‘Naga tribes’: Zeme, Liangmai
and Rongmei (Ze-liang-rong) (Kabui 1982: 53). Although Zeliangrong
was composed of both Christians and non-Christians, Rani Gaidinliu
hoped that the Heraka movement would be the emblem of a unified
Zeliangrong people, which has not transpired.
The history of the Heraka movement has evolved through various
stages.6 It was principally organised under their second prophet Rani
Gaidinliu, who took over the remnants of the movement from Jadonang
movement, ‘reform/conversion’ is a blurred and historically dynamic phenomenon because
of evolving Paupaise/Heraka/Christian relations, and the Heraka’s tendency to borrow
Christian ideas.
5 Nanga (naked in Hindi), a young man (in Kachari), ‘Nag’ (snake in Hindi) are all
considered as translations of the word ‘Naga’ (Hutton 1965: 17). Due to the ambiguity of
‘Naga’, there are now 68 Naga tribes recorded both in India and Myanmar (Nuh 2006:
24–26), compared to only 9 recorded in the 1891 Assam Census. The use of the problematic
word ‘tribe’ here is solely for uniformity as it corresponds with the list of ‘Scheduled
Tribes’ drawn up for protective discrimination under Article 342 of the Indian Constitution.
6 From early descriptions of events in 1929 and over the next 45 years, Heraka has
been known by various names, for example, the Kacha Naga movement, the Gaidinliu
movement, Periese (old practice), Kelumse (prayer practice) and Ranise (‘practice of the
queen’, a reference to Gaidinliu as the people’s queen), all representing the different
developments of the movement which finally came to be known as Heraka in 1974. In
this article, I have generally used ‘Heraka’ as shorthand to indicate all these stages.
at The University of Edinburgh on May 16, 2014cis.sagepub.comDownloaded from
Contributions to Indian Sociology 45, 2 (2011): 189–216
194 / ARKOTONG LONGKUMER
after he was executed by the British on charges of human sacrifice in the
early 1930s.7 Although some scholars hold the view that Jadonang was
the first prophet and the principal founder of the Heraka movement
(Yonuo 1982), most Heraka adherents look to Rani Gaidinliu as the ini-
tiator of the reforms because the Heraka movement developed separately
in North Cachar Hills and in the Peren district of Nagaland after
Jadonang’s death (Longkumer 2010: 14–16). Therefore, the reforms from
Paupaise initiated by Rani Gaidinliu made the Heraka highly popular in
the North Cachar Hills; it is now the dominant religious group amongst
the Zeme, followed by the Christians, and the Paupaise.
Although it is beyond the scope of this article to provide a detailed
examination of Christianity, its spread or reaction to Paupaise and the
Heraka, a brief historical summary is useful to help understand its wider
relevance to this article. Christianity was first introduced by J. Garlan
Williams, a missionary of the Calvinistic Methodist Church of Wales
(later known as the Presbyterian Church of Wales), in the North Cachar
Hills in 1904.8 The first Zeme convert was Dituing Zeme of Kenareram
village, six years later in 1910. Unlike the other Naga-inhabited areas of
Nagaland and Manipur, Christian conversion among the Zeme of North
Cachar Hills was very slow primarily because Christian progress was
actively opposed by the competitive other, the Heraka. The Heraka
prophet Rani Gaidinliu allegedly said that ‘Christians will be the greatest
hindrance to the Heraka, but when the Heraka receives [sic] their freedom,
Christians will be our slaves’ (Pame 1996: 211). However, two revivals
in 1948 and 1978 significantly strengthened the growth of Presbyterian
Christianity in the North Cachar Hills. Furthermore, the first Baptist
mission penetrated Hsongle and other Zeme villages from Manipur,
7 Jadonang was accused of murdering two traders as sacrifices to the gods of his ‘new
religion’. He was found guilty and hanged by the British. For an account of his trial see
Political and Secret Department: L/PS/13/1002: 441–46. However, it is unlikely that
Jadonang was actually involved in murder and human sacrifice. It could have been possible
the British feared that Jadonang, who was a popular reformer and leader in Manipur,
could initiate a revolt against British rule. Some scholars have suggested that the British
in fact engineered these charges to prevent any further problems (see Kamei 2002; Yonuo
1982).
8 The Welsh Presbyterians were primarily operating from the Lushai Hills (the present
state of Mizoram in India) in 1891 (Dena 1988: 41–46).
at The University of Edinburgh on May 16, 2014cis.sagepub.comDownloaded from
‘Cleanliness is next to godliness’ / 195
Contributions to Indian Sociology 45, 2 (2011): 189–216
around 1975–76, while the Roman Catholics have entered Zeme villages
in the last 20 years through the Salesians of Don Bosco and the Holy
Cross missions.
Moreover, it is important to note that Christians have traditionally
converted from Paupaise and some recently from the Heraka. The
Paupaise, on the other hand, have decreased in numbers dramatically
over the years.9 Therefore, the manner in which Paupaise is viewed both
by the Heraka and Christians is noteworthy. The Heraka adherents still
look to Paupaise as an important basis of Zeme tradition and indeed
some older Heraka may say that, aside from eliminating sacrifices and
the adoption of Tingwang, they continue in the ‘tradition’ of Paupaise
by observing agricultural practices, kin relations, customs, festivals, and
so on, a point I return to later. Similarly, the Christians also attempt to
‘preserve’ aspects of Paupaise tradition. However, they acknowledge a
clearer break from Paupaise in terms of their religious practices. The
Paupaise adherents, however, declare the Heraka and the Christians’
piecemeal attempts at preserving ‘tradition’ as a sham. These complex
relationships have developed over the years through the following chrono-
logy of events.
III
Negotiating religious change
Reform and colonialism
In the 1930s, the first Heraka reformers started preaching against the
‘old way of life’ (i.e., Paupaise), and attacking specific institutions that
crippled the Zeme economy. Although, it is difficult to ascertain precisely
who these early reformers were, oral sources indicate that they were
mostly Zeme people whose aim was to spread the message of reform ex-
pounded by Jadonang and Rani Gaidinliu. However, their message of
reform was sometimes uneven. Some, for example, argued that to par-
take in the modern world, eradicating sacrifices was necessary, leading
to changes in cosmology, and making the Heraka more flexible. Others
9 In the North Cachar Hills, the Paupaise are numerically negligible. There is only
one Paupaise village (Lozeihe) comprising around 12 households (with a population of
around 60).
at The University of Edinburgh on May 16, 2014cis.sagepub.comDownloaded from
Contributions to Indian Sociology 45, 2 (2011): 189–216
196 / ARKOTONG LONGKUMER
preached against working in the fields because grains would fall from
the sky or said that the Zeme need not attend school, as knowledge could
be acquired by using a book as a pillow. Sometimes, I was told, these
reformers were vehement about the impending ‘end of the world’. These
millenarian ideas formed the core of their disillusionment with the eco-
nomic and social situation.
Part of the reason for their unhappiness could be attributed to the
British colonial policy of parcelling land out to new immigrants, par-
ticularly the Kuki people.10 This created a land shortage for the Zeme,
leading in turn to a serious shortage of food during the 1930s. Ursula
Graham Bower, working in the North Cachar Hills at that time, observed
that under these circumstances, ‘progressive over-cultivation followed,
with endless encroachments, land disputes, tribal friction, and steady
deforestation and degeneration of what jhum-land there was’ (Bower
1946: 52).
As a response to these activities, the early reforms incorporated myths
of a ‘golden age’ that sought to attract people who were experiencing
famine and loss of land ownership. It claimed that signs of this ‘golden
age’ would appear when the taxes paid to the British government were
paid instead to Gaidinliu, and when the Kukis were driven away from
Zeme land, and promised that prosperity could be attained through prayers
to the Zeme sky god, Tingwang (see Burridge 1969; Worsley 1970).11
Due to these economic pressures, the early reformers reasoned that
the economic viability of numerous sacrifices to the many gods was dif-
ficult to maintain and therefore had to be curtailed. The Heraka reformers
started addressing this problem by arguing for two significant processes:
eradicating sacrifices because they were costly, and reconfiguration of
the cosmology.
Sacrifices and illness
Certain traditional institutions (animal sacrifices) were thought to hinder
Zeme development in relation to the modern world. Paupaise involved
innumerable sacrifices to the gods and spirits of the village. These were
10 The Kuki are an ethnic group related to the Chins of Mizoram (in India) and Myanmar.
11 One such song expressing these sentiments was entitled ‘Kedeirei Se Keli Wang
Jeu’ (The World has Changed). It celebrated the changes taking place and foretold a future
of joy, freedom and abundance (Longkumer 2007: 505).
at The University of Edinburgh on May 16, 2014cis.sagepub.comDownloaded from
‘Cleanliness is next to godliness’ / 197
Contributions to Indian Sociology 45, 2 (2011): 189–216
prescribed for illnesses and to ensure good harvests, rain and so on. A
sacrifice is a ‘purchase’ from gods, who set the price on animals (Mauss
1990: 16), through a shaman or priest. This can involve a chicken, cow,
or mithun (Indian Bison), depending on the occasion or the gravity of
the illness: the rule is that the greater the need, the bigger the sacrifice.
These sacrifices were an attempt to appease the gods, and a failure to
carry them out or to do them correctly could have dire consequences for
the village.
The association of sacrifice with illness was widespread during the
early 1930s in the region. In a British Administrative Report, it was
recorded that a certain Naga sadhu (holy man) was popular because of
his healing powers, and it was said that villagers in the North Cachar
Hills were bringing him mithuns for sacrifice to enquire about their chil-
dren’s illnesses, as disease and death were rampant.12 Sacrifices were
common in divining illnesses during the 1930s, but they demanded a
huge investment, which people could not afford. Therefore, Gaidinliu’s
reform banning sacrifices of larger animals, while strategically allowing
the continued performance of those involving fowls, was an important
intermediate step. An outright ban would have been too dramatic a change.
In fact, according to Pautanzen Newme, the act of sacrificial obligations
gradually decreased from the first stage (roughly around the 1960s) where
small animal sacrifices were permitted, to the fourth stage (in 1990),
which advocated an ‘official’ and complete ban of sacrifices. This is
how the event was narrated:
...the preceptress (Ranima) vigorously declared and confessed before
the general public that we have fully done the requirement of sacri-
ficial oblation in puja [reverence or worship]. Now, influential
sacrifices of animals in any puja are to be totally abolished. And we
are free to perform puja with a clean mind and body at any specific
time and day. (Newme 2002: 4)
Cosmology
One important effect of eradicating sacrifices was the alteration of the
cosmology for the Heraka movement. Since minor gods required numer-
ous sacrifices, they were abandoned and a universal god, Tingwang was
12 Proceedings series: P/11892, No. 50.
at The University of Edinburgh on May 16, 2014cis.sagepub.comDownloaded from
Contributions to Indian Sociology 45, 2 (2011): 189–216
198 / ARKOTONG LONGKUMER
adopted. The adoption of a cosmology that was well organised and
espoused a high level of integration was paramount in the establishment
of a new religious system. It took on a relatively monotheistic and hier-
archical structure. Nine smaller gods (who are ineffectual) were at the
same time, retained in the cosmology as a way of securing legitimacy
based on the Zeme tradition.13 This image also conveys an idea that the
Heraka god Tingwang is positioned over, and to an extent encompasses,
the smaller gods of Paupaise. For instance, the very meaning behind
Heraka envisages a state where various smaller gods (hera) are fenced
out (ka) to accommodate one god, the sky god Tingwang.
Lévi-Strauss reminds us that myth undergoes transformation due to
‘romantic elaboration’, or ‘historical legitimation’. Such history, he says,
is of two types: ‘retrospective—to base a traditional order on a distant
past; or prospective—to treat this past as the beginning of a future that is
in the process of taking shape’ (Lévi-Strauss and Moore 1974: 280–81).
It is most likely that the Heraka cosmology is a combination of the ‘retro-
spective’ and the ‘prospective’, legitimising a new order framed on the
past, and using the past to recreate something for the present and the
future.
Therefore, the manner in which the inclusion and exclusion of gods
is understood here is important. In the first instance, ‘encompassment’ is
an activity of hierarchical inclusion, which means that the ‘smaller gods’
are incorporated and maintained for traditional legitimacy. There is
evidence to suggest that during the early Heraka reforms in the 1930s,
the nine smaller gods were also efficacious and relevant. Even today,
amongst the smaller gods, Chuprai (the god of grain), Hechawang (the
python king) are still evoked by some Heraka who are anxious of letting
go, because of the unanticipated ways in which they could make their
presence felt. This view is particularly visceral in some villages whose
residents reasoned to me that since Chuprai was traditionally the king of
the gods (Herawang), to abandon him so suddenly could have dire con-
sequences on their crops, and hence their livelihoods.
In the second instance, ‘fencing out’ suggests a more radical approach
by the majority of the Heraka. Gods like Chuprai required innumerable
sacrifices and to eradicate the need for constant appeasement, these gods
13 The nine are: Banglawang, Gechingpeu, Heransia, Lhu, Nrak, Mekang, Munseniu,
Chuprai, and Hechawang.
at The University of Edinburgh on May 16, 2014cis.sagepub.comDownloaded from
‘Cleanliness is next to godliness’ / 199
Contributions to Indian Sociology 45, 2 (2011): 189–216
had to be ‘fenced out’. The Heraka believe that the way this is done is by
praying to one God, Tingwang, and singing songs that the prophets com-
posed, especially during important rituals such as Jalua (full moon day).
In these songs, there are special prayers to protect the people and exorcise
the gods who are portrayed as ‘evil’ and ‘bloodthirsty’ (see Longkumer
2010: 180–97).
These points unravel in two significant ways regarding the cosmology.
First, it could be simply that the gods have been reconceptualised and
altered to mirror the changes in the sacrificial structure. Second, it mimics
a certain cosmological framework, perhaps incorporated from their
Christian neighbours. In this respect, while it is important to bear in
mind that the Heraka gods are autochthonous, it is of equal significance
to analyse how cosmological views travel. Let us examine this point.
Heraka and Christianity
In instituting new practices, especially in relation to the reorganisation
of the place of gods in their cosmology, the Heraka are strongly influenced
by the ideas of monotheism within Christianity. Tingwang, who in trad-
itional Paupaise cosmology is a minor god, was and is called upon only
when a new settlement or a village is established; a god that establishes
community irrespective of the new locale. It was possibly the Christians
who first started using Tingwang during the early 20th century, as a way
of addressing the Christian high god. In the case of the Heraka, it is only
from around the 1960s that the importance of Tingwang starts featuring
regularly in their narratives and writings. The Christian influence can
also be found in recent literature on the theology of the Heraka. It looks
upon Tingwang as the ‘root of all creation’, and the belief in the ‘worship
of one Supreme Being, as practised by the Heraka, is the introduction of
the concept of monotheism or belief in one God in the Zeliangrong reli-
gion’, which was traditionally polytheistic (Zeliang 1980: 7).
Cosmology and social relations
Since the Paupaise gods and spirits were relatively fixed to their localities,
the new cosmology allowed the Heraka to become more mobile, a feature
which ties in with developments such as education, employment and
trade, integrating the Heraka more effectively in relation to (colonial)
at The University of Edinburgh on May 16, 2014cis.sagepub.comDownloaded from
Contributions to Indian Sociology 45, 2 (2011): 189–216
200 / ARKOTONG LONGKUMER
governance and labour. By privileging Tingwang, the ensuing reforms
encouraged abolishing ties with the smaller gods through sacrifices and
the agricultural cycle, making the new movement both simplified and
economically viable, in contrast to the complex and ‘burdensome’ prac-
tices of Paupaise. This idea points to a larger theoretical point made by
Horton (1975), in which he contends that cosmologies reflect the func-
tioning of social relations. In connection to a two-tier cosmology com-
prising a microcosm (lesser gods) and macrocosm (supreme god), Horton
examines how these relations affect those bounded within a certain
locality, on the one hand, and those with access to the wider world, on
the other. What Horton concludes is that eventually due to ‘modernity’
and the dissolution of microcosmic boundaries; people gravitate towards
more macrocosmic realities. However, Horton has been criticised for
focusing on the monolatrous (single-divinity-focused) aspect, as the sole
criterion of religious change (see Hefner 1993).
In her study of African cosmologies, Emefie Ikenga-Metuh observes
that indigenous forms of worship are incorporated into an already existing
pantheon, by circumventing monolatry or monotheism (cited in Hefner
1993: 23). Others, such as David Jordan’s (1993) study of conversion in
Taiwan, demonstrate that rather than a replacement, traditional Chinese
religion has long been characterised by its inclusive ‘additive’ quality,
or what he calls ‘pantheon interchangeability’, in contrast to Christian
exclusivism. Is this the reason, he asks, why Christianity has not been
well received by the Chinese (Jordan 1993: 286)? This is an interesting
theoretical point. With regard to the Heraka cosmology, although there
is a strong monotheistic influence, monolatry has been a defining feature.
It privileges a single god, Tingwang, without excluding the smaller gods,
even if they are less efficacious. Not only have the Heraka moved towards
a macrocosmic reality, but simultaneously maintained autochthonous
deities that provide legitimacy of tradition. It is for this reason that the
Heraka were historically more successful numerically when compared
to the Zeme Christians, who had an exclusive cosmology: the Heraka
allowed more fluidity and flexibility with their cosmology.14 This notion
14 Similarly, Eaton’s (2000) interesting conversion theory amongst the Sema, Ao and
Angami Nagas, throws light on some of these issues.
at The University of Edinburgh on May 16, 2014cis.sagepub.comDownloaded from
‘Cleanliness is next to godliness’ / 201
Contributions to Indian Sociology 45, 2 (2011): 189–216
not only reflects Lévi-Strauss’ ‘retrospective’ and ‘prospective’ views
but is connected to the larger process of conversion in the region (see
also Robinson and Clarke 2003).
Certain limitations inhibit the application of a strict ‘conversion’ model
to the Heraka. First, when the Heraka message was spreading, it appears
that the reformers were conscious of maintaining the status quo prevalent
in the Zeme villages. Therefore, becoming Heraka was seen as a fluid
transition from one system to another and not as ‘conversion’ in the sense
of exclusivism.15 In fact, what we see is incremental replacement of
the traditional cosmology with one which, I was told, ‘was more effective
and attuned with present conditions’. Second, it is difficult to suggest
that the reformers were exclusivist in the sense that one is either Heraka
or Paupaise. This exclusivist attitude is regarded as the hallmark of
Christianity, which saw itself as the true religion. Becoming Heraka did
not require its adherents to profess their faith or announce certain doc-
trines. It was seen simply as changing with the times.16 All these reasons—
flexibility, lack of exclusiveness, and reform—made the Heraka more
popular than Christianity in the North Cachar Hills, when compared to
other Naga inhabited areas of Nagaland and Manipur, where Christianity
became the major religion. However, for both the Heraka reformers and
the Christians, Paupaise was seen as expensive, outmoded and too
cumbersome.
Due to these exigencies, religious change in the Heraka context occur-
red on various levels. The change in agricultural practices and the different
rituals associated with the reforms also required a certain psychological
shift. The need to ‘renew’ villages meant not only changing certain aspects
of Paupaise life, it meant that literally, physically they had to ‘scrub the
village exteriors’ to draw the connection between ‘religious change’ and
‘hygienic practices’.
15 Of course, I am not arguing that all conversion is exclusivist, sudden, or radical—it
can involve prolonged periods, and in some cases dramatic changes can be difficult to pin
point (see Buckster and Glazier 2003).
16 According to the Heraka, each generation supposedly receives a new Hingde (rules
governing everyday life), through the regeneration of time. Following this schema, the
Heraka believe that it is now the turn of their generation to follow its ascribed religious
practices, through a reinterpretation of an outmoded Paupaise (ancestral) practice.
at The University of Edinburgh on May 16, 2014cis.sagepub.comDownloaded from
Contributions to Indian Sociology 45, 2 (2011): 189–216
202 / ARKOTONG LONGKUMER
IV
Renewal of a village: Name is everything
This representation of the present and the past in the village renewals
was narrated to me by Kuame, a Heraka preacher (hingde pame) in
Nchubonglo village,17 in the western part of the North Cachar Hills. He
said:
During Paupaise most of the people were sick and eventually died.
Wild animals also plagued us and ate our livestock and grains. So we
realised that it was time to change our practice and follow what our
prophets Rani Gaidinliu and Jadonang taught. So after we became
pure Heraka, 25 years or so ago, all these things, which happened
during the Paupaise, have not reoccurred. We have our livestock and
have no trouble at all. And, the population also increased after we
became Heraka. This is because we renewed our village according to
Heraka Hingde.
On the day of renewal, we washed all the things in each house
with water. We also changed the stone of the hearth and made bamboo
jars to carry the water. All the firewood was gathered and, along with
the bamboo jars, we put it on the hezoa.18 We changed the altar stone
of the hezoa as well and plastered the floor of the houses. Before
sunset we went outside the village boundary and constructed temporary
huts to sleep in for the night. We cooked outside the village and slept
in the temporary houses.
As soon as the sun rose (the day of the ritual), from the North side
of the village, we sang a song ‘Ndi Pumkuna Wangra Chimak Keheu
Kum’. The meaning of the song is ‘before we did not know about
Tingwang, but now we know about the creator’. So, on this day we
asked for blessings on our present generation, our livestock, and
agriculture. We sang this song and marched to the hezoa; and then we
stopped the song and put the new altar stone in the hezoa. The priest
(tingkopau) was standing behind the stone and praying. In his prayer
17 The names of the villages in this section have not been altered for the purposes of
the narrative and the argument.
18 Hezoa is a mound of earth which is the ritual centre of the village. It is placed
equidistant from the upper and lower gates of the village. All major rituals including the
ritual for the foundation of the village are performed here (Betts [also Bower] 1950: 28).
at The University of Edinburgh on May 16, 2014cis.sagepub.comDownloaded from
‘Cleanliness is next to godliness’ / 203
Contributions to Indian Sociology 45, 2 (2011): 189–216
he asked Tingwang to bless this generation, livestock, agriculture,
wood, trees, water, to bring wealth, care for the needy and also to
keep the wild animals away. After the prayer was over, each and every
family of the household gathered near the stone of the hezoa and lit
a fire using the wood already there, carrying the bamboo jugs and
fire to their houses because man cannot live without water and fire.
The women carried the water and men carried the fire (fire and water
are the signs of renewal). Once the fire was lit in every household, we
cooked, ate and drank. After this renewal ritual, I saw that the prayers
had come true—the village had improved.
When the village was originally established, we settled here from
the village Ramchiram. No ritual had been performed, but we con-
tinued with our jhum [swidden cultivation]. At that time it was
Paupaise, and the village had ill health, was very poor, and had no
paddy. Priests also had a short life. We thought that these problems
could have arisen because no proper ritual was conducted when the
village was established, so different Heraka preachers advised a
renewal ritual.
So I decided to ask Ranima if we could renew the village in this
way. I went to Ranima at Lsong and asked her. The villagers contri-
buted 10 Rupees to give to Ranima. This renewal was around 1987.
Ranima blessed the 10 rupees and she told me to remind her again in
the morning. Next morning, I went to her and asked for the ritual and
she said to me, ‘The founders of the village did not have the ritual for
foundation. That is why you are having these problems’. I also asked
her, ‘Should we follow what the preachers have said?’ So she said,
‘Yes, you can follow as the preachers have suggested’. She said the
same thing as the preachers had said but she said when you pray for
the village say ‘Nchubonglo’ [a new name given to the village] and
not ‘Bolosan’ [the previous name]. The renewal was necessary because
the village had been made dirty by the Paupaise practice and we might
have displeased Tingwang somehow. Also, we hadn’t prayed to
Tingwang [sky god] but to Tingchura [god of stone] and evil spirits.
So, the ritual was performed to ask Tingwang to forgive us for our
mistakes because this ritual symbolises what Heraka is: to overcome
evil spirits and to erase the memory of sacrifices and evil spirits
(emphasis added).
at The University of Edinburgh on May 16, 2014cis.sagepub.comDownloaded from
Contributions to Indian Sociology 45, 2 (2011): 189–216
204 / ARKOTONG LONGKUMER
Renewal, narrative, memory
As Kuame narrated the renewal of the village, sitting inside the spaci-
ous hut in Nchubonglo and warmed by the constant flickering of the
flame from the hearth, it became strangely apparent that I was inhabiting
two worlds as my host talked about Bolosan (the old name) in the past
and Nchubonglo (the new name) in the present. What occurred to me as
merely a linguistic preference of Nchubonglo over Bolosan was, for the
speaker, a significant change in which the latter with its reference to
Tingchura and evil spirits was seen as pejorative. The time shift is a de-
bate that persists: Christians refer to their village as Bolosan, because
that was the name associated with ancestry, and also to exasperate the
Heraka. On the other hand, the Heraka prefer Nchubonglo because they
are trying to erase the memory of sacrifices and evil spirits associated
with the Paupaise and hence Bolosan. The naming of terrain is thus not
only linguistic but ideological in its form. With the change in names, the
village has also changed.
It is important to note that the use of the concept of hygiene and its
relation to advancement and progress comes primarily from Christian
attitudes focused on the interdependency of religious change with chang-
ing attitudes towards dirt and cleanliness. The epidemiology of these
ideas finds its root, as explained below, in the Christian Protestant notion
of ‘cleanliness as next to godliness’. In order to differentiate themselves
from the Paupaise past, the Heraka have borrowed the language and
concepts employed by the Christians to indicate that the Paupaise past
was ‘heathen’ and disease ridden. The eradication of ‘dirt’ is also strat-
egically linked with the eradication of sacrifice, and how this abandon-
ment of sacrifice reflects on the perception of progress and advancement
the Heraka are making alongside their competitive ‘other’, the Zeme
Christians.
Metaphor and hygienic practices
Through the renewal ritual the Heraka people dissociate themselves from
the Paupaise past. In a crude way—to borrow a Heraka metaphor—it
washes them clean of a ghostly exterior by scrubbing the interior of the
village. If Paul Ricoeur is right in pointing out that the rule of metaphor,
at The University of Edinburgh on May 16, 2014cis.sagepub.comDownloaded from
‘Cleanliness is next to godliness’ / 205
Contributions to Indian Sociology 45, 2 (2011): 189–216
like language, enables differentiation and varied meanings, then the meta-
phorical ‘is’ at once signifies both ‘is not’ and ‘is like’ (Ricoeur 1978:
6–7). It is in this tension that the route to metaphorical truth is attainable
because it confronts not only the verbal and non-verbal, it also produces
a new meaning by challenging two domains of thought we do not
habitually bring together: the literal and the figurative (Ricoeur 1978:
213–14). Metaphor, importantly for Ricoeur, has the ability to transform
abstract language into something concrete until it becomes the ‘language
of action’ (Simms 2003: 65). In his own words,
Metaphor is living not only to the extent that it vivifies a constituted
language. Metaphor is living by virtue of the fact that it introduces
the spark of imagination into a ‘thinking more’ at the conceptual level.
This struggle to ‘think more’, guided by the ‘vivifying principle’, is
the ‘soul’ of interpretation. (Ricoeur 1978: 303)
Similarly, the Heraka metaphor of scrubbing the village clean operates
on two levels of the literal and the figurative. In this manner, metaphor
confers an ‘insight’ (Ricoeur 1978: 87). Therefore, the metaphor here is
used to elicit a way of thinking about the past–present–future that con-
solidates two different perspectives: the internal and external.
The internal metaphor in this case, I think, could indicate possible
Christian resonances, of cleaning the heart, or washing oneself of sins,
and the external metaphor could indicate a Heraka motif of cleansing
the past (in this case blood sacrifices), through the altering of the hezoa
stone and cleaning of the village. It is useful to recall the way in which
Mircea Eliade points to the importance of consecrating a territory by
making it ‘our world’ through recreating and renewing it. For example,
when Spanish conquistadores took possession of a territory by claiming
it for Jesus Christ they raised a Cross, which was equivalent to consecrat-
ing a country to ‘a new birth’ (Eliade 1959: 32). The replacement of the
hezoa stone similarly invokes the consecration of place to effect a renewal,
even a new birth.
Belongings such as pots and pans are washed, floors scrubbed, and
the ritual cleaning of the village begins at its heart, the hezoa. A com-
bination of the internal and external metaphor of cleaning the heart and
at The University of Edinburgh on May 16, 2014cis.sagepub.comDownloaded from
Contributions to Indian Sociology 45, 2 (2011): 189–216
206 / ARKOTONG LONGKUMER
the past also surfaces in Kuame’s narrative: to erase the memory of
sacrifices and evil spirits. This double metaphor—internal/external;
present/past—resonates with the Paupaise Hgangi (new year) ritual that
propitiates and asks the major spirits to leave the village so that it is
healthy and free of illness (Betts [also Bower] 1950: 151–52). However,
although the double metaphors appear similar, the key difference is the
derogatory reference to Tingchura (god of stone) who is contrasted with
God Tingwang, and how this negative view of Tingchura has enabled
the Heraka to banish all past references of spirits (read evil spirits). In a
double cause and effect, since the evil spirits are now expunged from
the village, no blood sacrifices are required for them. Therefore, the vil-
lage now is figuratively cleansed from the dirt that blood sacrifice
represented.19
The renewal of Nchubonglo village is also tied in with the role of
hygiene, and illnesses associated with its lack. Part of the problem is the
habitual patterns of Paupaise life that, as a Heraka elder said, kept the
village dirty. Removal of dirt, as I was told, functioned within the vil-
lage like any other daily routine, informed largely by the priest. For ex-
ample, it was prohibited (neube) to sweep the floor on certain days, or it
was neube to use water on certain days to clean the plates. So most people
would lick the plate clean with their saliva and prop it by the wall.
Animals, children, people, would come and go and the ‘dirt’ and ‘bacteria’
would naturally collect until it caused disease and illness, which people
then attributed to an evil spirit troubling them. Through reinterpretation
of these processes—the adoption of Tingwang, the abandoning of sacri-
fices, and the renewal of villages—the Heraka have managed to preach
hygiene as a crucial tenet in upgrading or ‘advancing’ their lives in a
sustainable and healthier way.
Considering the classification of purity and danger in society, Mary
Douglas examines them in relation to ideas of cleanliness and dirt. The
former gives society a sense of order in contrast to the disorder repre-
sented by the latter. In cleaning dirt, an attempt is being made to control
the environment positively (Douglas 2003: 2). The disorder that is dirt is
also, in this case, ‘backward’, while cleanliness is order and ‘advance-
ment’. In this sense, the notion that dirt was present in Paupaise life
19 Heraka adherents say that blood represents ‘danger’ because of the way it elicits an
important connection with sacrifice; it evokes a connection with Paupaise gods. The absence
of blood sacrifice mirrors the ‘spiritual’ cleanliness of the village.
at The University of Edinburgh on May 16, 2014cis.sagepub.comDownloaded from
‘Cleanliness is next to godliness’ / 207
Contributions to Indian Sociology 45, 2 (2011): 189–216
clearly represents a system where dirt was ‘matter out of place’ (Douglas
2003: 36). Since the Heraka have reclassified the role of sacrifice, it
resonates with Douglas’ classification of cleanliness and dirt: cleanliness
(equals renewal and reform) and dirt (equals blood and Paupaise pro-
hibitions).20 This symbolic understanding is also expressed literally by
the Heraka adherents who say that their system distinguishes itself by
removing dirt from the village and homes. For example, by sweeping
the floors and using water to clean the village or the plates, the new sys-
tem is seen as orderly, an elevation of personal and collective hygiene
and therefore ‘advancement’ from the previous life of disease and dis-
order. In the Heraka context, by using water to wash the dirt, a renewal
takes place. Writing about the religious symbolism of water, Mircea
Eliade discusses a common South Asian phenomenon:
Breaking up all forms, doing away with the past, water possesses this
power of purifying, of regenerating, of giving new birth...Water
purifies and regenerates because it nullifies the past, and restores—
even if only for a moment—the integrity of the dawn of things. (Eliade
1958: 194; quoted in Douglas 2003: 162)
There is, however, an important interplay between the past and the
present, and how the Heraka negotiate aspects of the Paupaise past with
the reform. This is illustrated in the way symbols like water and fire are
used in the village renewal. Not only do water and fire symbolise purity
(and the act of catharsis), but equally they demonstrate a metonymic
connection as they are based on contiguity and association rather than
separation from Paupaise ideas—the assertion in the renewal narrative
that ‘man cannot live without fire and water’. Even the notion of changing
the name of the village suggests a connection with the object (the trad-
itional land) prior to connecting ideas (the name of the village) (Ricoeur
1978: 56). On the other hand, the greater span of meaning accorded to
metaphors unleashes a certain capacity for interpretation on the concep-
tual level that correlates with the message of the reform.
In this regard the ‘hygiene’ metaphor departs from the traditional
Paupaise past and shows how cleanliness signifies ‘advancement’ to the
20 The connection between the spilling of animal blood and dirt is context-dependent:
for non-sacrificial purposes, it is not seen as impure and dirty.
at The University of Edinburgh on May 16, 2014cis.sagepub.comDownloaded from
Contributions to Indian Sociology 45, 2 (2011): 189–216
208 / ARKOTONG LONGKUMER
Heraka. The Heraka preacher, Kuame, told me these hygiene practices,
which in hindsight were common sense, were credited to Rani Gaidinliu
and her teachings to legitimise the changes. Of course, what worked so
effectively is that the reform, side by side with safety and hygienic rituals,
safeguarded the community from further illnesses. This in turn eradicated
the need for sacrifices, for not only was disease less, but it was believed
that these changes happened because their religious lifestyles had been
altered for the better.
The emphasis on lifestyle is evident in meetings such as the Telung
Ndui (cultural meetings; see Figure 2), where mostly women and children
are taught how to cook, clean, and minimise the use of water while achiev-
ing maximum cleanliness. The idea of maintaining the home as the inner
sanctum is positively reinforced by the Heraka, albeit only recently.
Figure 2 illustrates the way women are often instructed by an elder of
the village (in this case a male) about the role of women in maintain-ing
the homestead and providing a sanctuary for the overall development of
the family. This attitude towards domesticity as a virtue came about when
less attention was placed on agriculture and more on the education of
children. Previously, the agricultural fields were the primary place of
Figure 2
Telung Ndui meeting in Hsongle village, 2005
at The University of Edinburgh on May 16, 2014cis.sagepub.comDownloaded from
‘Cleanliness is next to godliness’ / 209
Contributions to Indian Sociology 45, 2 (2011): 189–216
work that involved the participation of the entire family, but now with
the economy recast according to present realities, the home is seen as
the sanctum around which life revolves. The role of women within the
house is thus further validated with these developments. In light of this,
the idea of home as the centre of virtue and the woman as the guardian of
this sanctum is pivotal to the Heraka notion of domesticity.
The encouragement of these ideals amongst the Heraka is also a
reaction against the widespread perceptions of the superiority of Zeme
Christian women, who are seen as better equipped and more effective in
managing a healthy home—a perception centred on the brewing and use
of zao (rice beer) in Heraka homes. Christian women contend that
domestic brewing of zao by Heraka women destabilises the home, due
to excessive consumption by the husband and other male family members.
The effects are drunkenness and disruption of order in the home, which
allegedly, in turn, restricts the educational advancement of the children.
The Heraka leaders take this seriously and routine instructions are com-
municated to Heraka preachers who entreat the public to desist from
brewing zao at home.
These conceptions of cleanliness and its relation to ‘health’ and ‘advan-
cement’ connect with notions surrounding one’s superiority over the
‘other’. This attitude is reflected in a hierarchy envisaged between the
Christian, Heraka and Paupaise. The first is seen as being the most
‘advanced’ due to its extreme Puritanism, while the last is viewed as the
most ‘backward’ due to its ‘primitivism’. In the Heraka context, therefore,
it is most likely that it is with reference to their Christian neighbours
that a new set of imperatives has arisen and that the language of clean-
liness as well as bodily practices are reformed in this competitive scene.21
This also reflects the functioning of a collective in its pursuit of health
and wealth.
V
The world has changed: The body of practice
Healing narratives abound in Zeme villages that are not only about alter-
ing one’s religious practices (and by extension a new belonging), but
21 I am using the term ‘body’ in this context as both a physical and symbolic article,
natural and culturally shaped, situated in historical instances (Kirmayer 1992).
at The University of Edinburgh on May 16, 2014cis.sagepub.comDownloaded from
Contributions to Indian Sociology 45, 2 (2011): 189–216
210 / ARKOTONG LONGKUMER
also about affirming a better ‘self’ incorporated into a Christian theology
of grace and salvation. In one such instance, a convert, now a Baptist
preacher, narrated his journey towards Christianity from Heraka, which
was connected to a long history of illness in his family.
We were sick with fever and one of my sons also died. The houses
where I prayed [when I was Heraka] were all cured, except my house.
Later when the Christians came to our house to pray, I refused to con-
vert, until eventually when my wife was really sick, I relented. After
that, my entire household was cured.
The relationship between religious attitude, health and illness illu-
strates the intrinsic connection between conversion and purification. It
further demonstrates how a Christian narrative privileges its beliefs over
the Heraka’s, just as the Heraka overrides the Paupaise practice, thus
reinforcing the Puritanism–primitivism hierarchy. The discipline instilled
amongst Puritan adherents is characteristic of the way both the Christian
and Heraka compete over the management of hygiene and domesticity.
It reflects a healthy social body and therefore mirrors a better ‘self’ in
relation to God’s providence. Reflecting on similar attitudes regarding
cleanliness in America, Suellen Hoy comments that John Wesley’s adage,
cleanliness as a virtue next to godliness, was adopted by the Calvinists
not to suggest that one was ungodly if unclean, but that those who were
seen as ‘neat’ and ‘tidy’ were also seen to be polite, responsible and
orderly and, in a very generalised way, to be associated with godliness
(Hoy 1995: 3–4).
By becoming Heraka, a religious community is affirmed and in the
process new memories that evoke a religious history are envisioned. In
other words, the renewal of the village is an act of remembrance that
creates meaning and symbolises a new beginning, which is also ideo-
logically linked to other changes such as mobility, education and employ-
ment. This point is particularly pertinent to the way religious memory is
distinctive for communities of faith because it can be wrested from the
past anytime due to the historical foundation that pervades it (Hervieu-
Léger 2000: 124). The conception of religious memory becomes nor-
mative, according to Daniéle Hervieu-Léger, when it is reinforced and
centred on a lineage of belief that ‘...is affirmed and manifested in the
at The University of Edinburgh on May 16, 2014cis.sagepub.comDownloaded from
‘Cleanliness is next to godliness’ / 211
Contributions to Indian Sociology 45, 2 (2011): 189–216
essentially religious act of recalling a past which gives meaning to the
present and contains the future’ (Hervieu-Léger 2000: 125). Thus when
the Heraka recall an event such as the village renewal, it affirms a line-
age that allows them to positively reinforce the reforms that legitimise it
for the present.
To help draw together the various narrative threads of this article con-
cerning illness, religious attitude, and the notion of change, I quote an
anecdote from one of Ursula Graham Bower’s accounts (in the mid-
1940s) while working with the Zeme (i.e. Paupaise). Bower’s narrative
recounts her crippling pain caused by a dislocated knee cap as she weeded
spinach with one of her Zeme assistants, Hozekiemba. He suggested
calling a skilled Zeme to manipulate it, as there were no doctors for
miles. She refused and instead strapped on an elastic plaster to hold it
still.
After this failed to give her relief, she said, ‘The only thing left, then,
was an appropriate sacrifice’. An old man was called and the words of
the ancient Zeme prophet Herakandingpeu were uttered as he used ginger
to ‘divine the trouble’. After ‘trial and error’, ‘black magic’ was elim-
inated and it was concluded that one of the evil spirits had seized her
and, in return for a cockerel, would release its hold. A suitable cockerel
was found and offered to the ‘offending spirit’. After this, a blessing was
pronounced by the old man who told Bower that ‘the ceremony...had
been correctly done’ and that ‘she should most certainly be cured’. ‘They
left me’, she said, ‘feeling not one jot worse or better’. Then, in a wistful
manner, she concluded,
As I turned painfully over in the small hours of the morning, my knee
gave a click and went back. I could limp about next day. It may, of
course, have been the elastic plaster. But I never tried to tell the Zemi
that (Bower 1952: 125–26).
What was her reason for not telling the Zeme? Did she think that by
showing her scepticism of the efficacy of their healing practices, she
might offend them? Or was it too sensitive a subject to broach when
divine intervention was sought? Bower’s account elaborates the import-
ance of sacrifice for the Paupaise, and her own attitude towards it: she
saw the Paupaise’s appeal to sacrifice as ineffectual/irrational, when her
‘modern’ or ‘Western’ approach indicated that the elastic plaster had
at The University of Edinburgh on May 16, 2014cis.sagepub.comDownloaded from
Contributions to Indian Sociology 45, 2 (2011): 189–216
212 / ARKOTONG LONGKUMER
solved the problem. While Bower’s ethnography represents a clear dis-
junct of the ‘rational’/‘irrational’, the Heraka have had to negotiate the
difficulty of reform which maintains continuity with the past. It is the
past that legitimises their reform, which although exorcising certain prac-
tices like sacrifices, nevertheless is grounded in the reality of the everyday
life of their adherents. In this way renewal, management of order through
hygienic practices, banning of sacrifices, and the alteration of the cos-
mology contribute to a society that is seen as healthy, secure, and
‘developed’ in stark contrast to the memory of the past.
VI
Conclusion
This article has illustrated how economic pressures brought the Heraka
to question traditional religious practices that involved expensive sacri-
fices. In turn this led to altered practices, including, crucially, the abandon-
ment of sacrifice, and the reconfiguration of the cosmology. The effects
of these reforms can be exemplified in the renewal of a Heraka village.
In order to demonstrate the connection between religious change, hygiene
and ‘advancement’, the renewal substantiates an important theological
point for the Heraka. Basing their perception on the view that the Paupaise
made the village ‘dirty’, causing illness and frequent mortality, the re-
newal explains the important symbolic connections between past practices
such as appeasing Tingchura (god of stone), ‘evil spirits’ and sacrifices.
The Heraka’s reliance on Tingwang supposedly puts an end to (or greatly
diminished) the illness created by Paupaise and brings about prosperity
to the village. This is a rationale that has been retrospectively invoked
by the Heraka to the extent that it is the ‘efficacy’ of sacrifice that the
Heraka now question and not simply the cost. In other words, the focus
on cleanliness has called into question the efficacy of sacrifices. It is in
fact that ‘cleanliness’ brings one closer to godliness, and not sacrifices.
What could be viewed largely as a matter of making sense of the changes
in relation to the situation—that eradication of sacrifices was cost-
effective and practical—the Heraka have retrospectively managed to lend
theological validity to the reasons for these changes. Furthermore, the
demotion of sacrifice was both made possible by, and reflected in, a
change in beliefs and conceptions (from worship of Tingchura to worship
of Tingwang) that make the substitution of one set of beliefs and practices
at The University of Edinburgh on May 16, 2014cis.sagepub.comDownloaded from
‘Cleanliness is next to godliness’ / 213
Contributions to Indian Sociology 45, 2 (2011): 189–216
with another, ‘rational’. These attitudes are also influenced by the Zeme
Christians, whose own religious and social conversion and subsequent
transformation has meant that they are now powerful competitors to
Heraka adherents both numerically and ideologically.
In a way it would perhaps be apt to argue in a Marxist vein that the
‘real’ explanatory factors in all this are the economic pressures and
the beneficial effects of better hygiene. But the Heraka would argue that
the improvement in hygiene, with the consequent improvement in health
was not valued merely in itself, but evidence of the greater efficacy of
the worship of Tingwang and its theological viability, and hence con-
firmation of the wisdom of religious change. However, it would also be
a misinterpretation simply to argue that change is brought about only
because such things as cleanliness are understood to have symbolic mean-
ing and hence spiritual value.
In a sense, the Heraka enable us to understand the processes by which
the changing conditions relating to the practical business of everyday
life finds an equal relationship with theological beliefs, validating the
experience of illness and its relation to sacrifices to many gods. This
religious attitude is exemplified in the way the body is conceived phy-
sically, socially and symbolically, and extends the metaphor of God’s
providence expressed in the adage, ‘cleanliness is next to godliness’, as
crucial to perceptions concerning advancement, progress and even purity.
The various changes of practice and belief were consolidated into
one ‘historic’ change by religious procedures of renewal. Its historic char-
acter was marked by the change of name for the village, not simply a
new name for the same village but rather the name of a new village
emerging out of its acknowledged past, from Bolosan to Nchubonglo:
the former is pejoratively associated with illness, sacrifices and ‘evil
spirits’, while the latter is the symbol of prosperity, renewal, and reform.
It is precisely the purpose and function of collective narrative thus to
fashion past and future, memory and aspiration into a unity. Through the
use of memory, the space between the past and the present is cleared so
that a new genealogical succession can be invoked that symbolises what
the Heraka is: ‘to overcome evil spirits and to erase the memory of sacri-
fices and evil spirits’. This enables the Heraka to posit a new religious
lineage that Hervieu-Léger says ‘gives meaning to the present and con-
tains the future’ (Hervieu-Léger 2000: 125).
at The University of Edinburgh on May 16, 2014cis.sagepub.comDownloaded from
Contributions to Indian Sociology 45, 2 (2011): 189–216
214 / ARKOTONG LONGKUMER
Acknowledgements
Apart from Bolosan/Nchubonglo village, all proper and village names have been changed
to maintain anonymity. All the quotes from the fieldwork have been translated from
Zeme into English with the help of my co-workers, Tahulung and Adeule, during the
summer of 2005. My thanks to Gordon, Elspeth, and Lindsay for reading various versions
of this article and to the two anonymous referees and editors whose suggestions vastly
improved it.
REFERENCES
Anderson, Warwick. 2006. Colonial Pathologies: American Tropical Medicine, Race, and
Hygiene in the Philippines. Durham, NC: Duke University Press.
Bashford, Alison. 2004. Imperial Hygiene: A Critical History of Colonialism, Nationalism
and Public Health. Basingstoke: Palgrave Macmillan.
Betts, U.V.G. 1950. Village Organisation among the Central Nzemi Nagas. Diploma in
Anthropology Thesis. London: University College.
Bower, Ursula Graham (formerly Betts). 1952. Naga Path. London: Readers Union, John
Murray.
Buckster, Andrew and Stephen D. Glazier (eds). 2003. The Anthropology of Religious
Conversion. Lanham, MD: Rowman & Littlefield Publishers.
Burke, Timothy. 1996. Lifebuoy Men, Lux Women: Commodification, Consumption, and
Cleanliness in Modern Zimbabwe. Durham, NC: Duke University Press.
Burridge, Kenelm. 1969. New Heaven, New Earth: A Study of Millenarian Activities.
New York: Schocken Books.
Dena, Lal. 1988. Christian Missions and Colonialism: A Study of Missionary Move-
ment in Northeast India with Particular Reference to Manipur and Lushai Hills
1894–1947. Shillong: Vendrame Institute.
Douglas, Mary. 2003. Purity and Danger: An Analysis of Concepts of Pollution and Taboo.
London: Routledge.
Eaton, Richard M. 2000. Essays on Islam and Indian History. New Delhi: Oxford
University Press.
Eliade, Mircea. 1958. Patterns in Comparative Religion. London: Sheed and Ward.
———. 1959. The Sacred and the Profane: The Nature of Religion. New York: Harcourt,
Brace.
Garro, Linda C. and Cheryl Mattingly. 2000. Narrative as Construct and Construction. In
Linda C. Garro and Cheryl Mattingly (eds) Narrative and the Cultural Construction
of Illness and Healing, pp. 1–49. Berkeley: University of California Press.
Hefner, Robert W. 1993. World Building and the Rationality of Conversion. In Robert W.
Hefner (ed.) Conversion to Christianity: Historical and Anthropological Perspectives
on a Great Transformation, pp. 3–44. Berkeley: University of California Press.
Hervieu-Léger, Daniéle. 2000. Religion as a Chain of Memory. Cambridge: Polity Press.
at The University of Edinburgh on May 16, 2014cis.sagepub.comDownloaded from
‘Cleanliness is next to godliness’ / 215
Contributions to Indian Sociology 45, 2 (2011): 189–216
Horton, Robin. 1975. On the Rationality of Conversion Part I. Journal of the International
African Institute. 45 (3): 219–35.
Hoy, Suellen. 1995. Chasing Dirt: The American Pursuit of Cleanliness. New York: Oxford
University Press.
Hutton, J.H. 1965. The Mixed Culture of the Naga Tribes. The Journal of the Royal
Anthropological Institute of Great Britain and Ireland. 95 (1): 16–43.
Jordon, David K. 1993. The Glyphomancy Factor: Observations on Chinese Conversion.
In Robert Hefner (ed.) Conversion to Christianity: History and Anthropological
Perspectives on a Great Transformation, pp. 285–303. Berkeley: University of
California Press.
Kabui, Gangmumei. 1982. The Zeliangrong Movement: An Historical Study. In K.S. Singh
(ed.) Tribal Movements in India. 1: 53–66. Delhi: Manohar.
Kamei, Gangmumei (formerly Kabui). 2002. Jadonang: A Mystic Naga Rebel. Imphal:
Lamyanba Printers.
Kirmayer, Laurence J. 1992. The Body’s Insistence on Meaning: Metaphor as Presentation
and Representation in Illness Experience. Medical Anthropology Quarterly (New
Series). 6 (4): 323–46.
Kleinman, Arthur. 1988. The Illness Narratives: Suffering, Healing and the Human
Condition. New York: Basic Books.
Lévi-Strauss, Claude and F.C.T. Moore. 1974. How Myths Die. New Literary History.
5 (2): 269–81.
Longkumer, Arkotong. 2007. Religious and Economic Reform: The Gaidinliu Move-
ment and the Heraka in North Cachar Hills. Journal of South Asian Studies. 30 (3):
499–515.
———. 2010. Reform, Identity and Narratives of Belonging: The Heraka Movement of
Northeast India. London: Continuum.
Mauss, Marcel. 1990. The Gift: The Form and Reason for Exchange in Archaic Societies.
London: Routledge.
Newme, Pautanzan. 2002. The Origin and Reformation of Heraka Religion. Regional
Zeliangrong Heraka Association, Assam: Silver Jubilee Celebrations 1977–2002
Souvenir. Haflong: R.Z.H. Association.
Nuh, V.K. 2006. 165 Years History of Naga Baptist Churches. Kohima: Council of Naga
Baptist Churches.
Pame, Rabi. 1996. The Zeme Naga Baptist Church, North Cachar Hills, Assam: A Study
of Culture and the Church. Doctor of Missiology Thesis. Bangalore: South Asia
Institute of Advanced Christian Studies.
Pigg, Stacy Leigh. 1995. The Social Symbolism of Healing in Nepal. Ethnology. 34 (1):
17–36.
Ricoeur, Paul. 1978. The Rule of Metaphor: Multi-disciplinary Studies in the Creation of
Meaning in Language (trans. by Robert Czerny, with Kathleen McLaughlin and
John Costello). London: Routledge and Kegan Paul.
Robinson, Rowena and Sathianathan Clarke (eds). 2003. Religious Conversion in India:
Modes, Motivations, and Meanings. New Delhi: Oxford University Press.
Simms, Karl. 2003. Paul Ricoeur. London: Routledge.
at The University of Edinburgh on May 16, 2014cis.sagepub.comDownloaded from
Contributions to Indian Sociology 45, 2 (2011): 189–216
216 / ARKOTONG LONGKUMER
Wing, Donna Marie. 1998. A Comparison of Traditional Folk Healing Concepts with
Contemporary Healing Concepts. Journal of Community Health Nursing. 15 (3):
143–52.
Worsley, Peter. 1970. The Trumpet shall Sound: A Study of ‘Cargo’ Cults in Melanesia.
London: Paladin.
Yonuo, Asoso. 1982. Nagas Struggle Against the British Rule Under Jadonang and Rani
Gaidinliu 1925–1947. Kohima, Nagaland: Leno Printing Press.
Zeliang, N.C. 1980. The Word of God (Tingwang Hingde). Dimapur: Anonymous.
at The University of Edinburgh on May 16, 2014cis.sagepub.comDownloaded from
... As a little girl, I vividly remember having mixed feelings of awe and mystification. While growing up, we often heard stories of her bravery-but were sceptical of her socio-religious movement known as Heraka, meaning the pure, immured from other impurities (Longkumer, 2011) propounded by her cousin, the spiritual leader Haipou Jadonang (Kamei, 2004a). ...
... Her staunch opponents labelled her as a magician, mystic, witch, demon-possessed, sorcerer (J. P. Mills, 1932, in Longkumer, 2018 and even a cannibal. While Arkatong Longkumer (ibid.) ...
Article
Full-text available
This article attempts to analyse why Rani Gaidinliu, who was a freedom fighter and social and religious reformer, was keen to preserve the identity and culture of her cognate tribe¹—the Zeme, Liangmai, Rongmai/Kabui and Npui. Does Heraka—a socio-religious movement started by Haipou Jadonang and later developed by the Rani—become a tool of ‘cultural revivalism’ and act as a means to unite cognate tribes? Why do we juxtapose Heraka with the Hindutva ideologues such as the Vishwa Hindu Parishad (VHP) and Rashtriya Swayamsevak Sangh (RSS) that position Rani Gaidinliu in a new spirit of nationalism and identity as the lone woman spiritual and political protagonist of Northeast India? She used Heraka with politics to fulfil her goals in fighting the British. Using the interview method, I spoke to selected respondents, particularly elders and community leaders, about Rani Gaidinliu. Her story illustrates a rationality that could encourage marginalised and invisible women to become sociopolitical and spiritual leaders, questioning patriarchy and bringing about empowerment and social inclusion.
Article
Full-text available
Marriage is one of the oldest social institutions in human society. During this occasion, some marriage payments are made in the form of bride price, dower, and dowry. In the Lotha community, a marriage payment, "Hanlam" is practiced. Hanlam is different from any of the marriage payments mentioned above. Thus the study's main objective is to find out the relevance of the Hanlam practiced among the Lotha community and its impact on women's rights. The paper is descriptive, where the respondents were selected based on purposive sampling. Altogether 50 couples from Wokha town were interviewed. The study found that Hanlam still holds relevance among the Lotha couples as it indirectly benefits the newly married couple not only in terms of monetary help but through Hanlam the couples are recognised and accepted by their kin, especially the groom is regarded as one of the kin members by the brides' paternal kins. Furthermore, it is the only traditional practice left in Lotha marriage ceremony. Finally, the continuation of the practice of Hanlam has not led to the curtailment of women's rights.
Chapter
In Indian history one of the crucial dimensions of tribal relations with the British reflects in resentment and protest against the former. The protest is recorded primarily as armed struggle which is evident from such dictions as tribal revolt, insurrection, insurgency, uprising, etc. The petition mode of protest which the Bhils and Santals, if we see the history, had adopted did not get prominence. Similarly, reform mode of protest launched by Bhagirath Manjhi, Birsa Munda, Jatra Oraon, Govind Giri (Guru). Haikou Jadonang and Rani Gaidinliu did not get due place in the history of tribal resistance to colonial rule. Instead, protests through reform have been presented as revival or socio-religious movements. In the beginning of these movements socio-religious reforms appeared prominent which attracted huge followers. But subsequently, leaders of the movement directed the course to resist all types of exploitation in the colonial rule which they also justified through religious teachings. They exhorted their followers not to pay tax, supply forced labour, etc. This not only changed the form of the movement but linked it with the then ongoing struggle for Independence. Tribal freedom fighters joined various phases of the freedom struggle of the nation and played crucial role therein. It is therefore argued that resistance with socio-religious reform was a tribal strategy of freedom from colonial rule and claims an understanding in totality and in pan-Indian context. In view of this, five reform movements under the messianic leadership of Bhagirath Manjhi, Birsa Munda, Jatra Oraon, Govind Giri (Guru) Jadonang and Rani Gaidinliu have been examined in this paper.KeywordsForeign ruleTribal resistanceMass resistanceCapital punishmentSocio-religious movementsEast India companyPolitical disturbanceFreedom movementBritish GovernmentPolitical agitationChristian missionariesMoneylenders
Article
This article examines the Swedish-American Baptist Minnie Johnson Hanson, who worked among the Kachins of Northern Burma from 1890 to 1928. Through a biographical reconstruction and analysis of Hanson’s contexts, it argues that Hanson was a figure of some significance in literary work, education and medical work among the Kachins. In contrast to the agenda of the mission to ‘civilize’, development needs to be indigenized through the analysis of indigenous researchers. The writer pleads for translocal developmental analysis – the comparison of ethnic groups in adjacent spaces.
Article
In the 1920s and 30s, the Naga areas comprising Naga Hills and the adjoining Naga inhabited hill tracts of Manipur witnessed two important initiatives which were to become integral to the imagining and making of a Naga nation: the movement among the Rongmeis, Liangmeis and Zemes under the leadership of Jadonang and later Gaidinliu—popularly known as the Zeliangrong movement—and the programmes and activities of the Naga Club. Both the Zeliangrong movement and the Naga Club had a history and trajectory of their own but at the same time, faced with situations that seemed to threaten their way of life, they envisioned and anticipated a moment when Nagas would be united as a single political entity independent from the kingdoms of the plains and other external political authorities. This article looks closely at these initiatives, their shared and particular histories, how they made sense of and negotiated with their existing reality, and finally the visions they had of their anticipated Naga nation. The article concludes by briefly looking at how and why the Naga national movement, in the later decades of twentieth century, came to privilege one initiative over the other.
Chapter
This introductory chapter discusses narrative as a theoretical construct and within the context of anthropology and medicine. It then examines the succeeding chapters and situates them within broader trends. These trends are not limited to medical anthropology or to cultural anthropology, but extend into various disciplines. It examines the centrality of narrative to some forms of therapeutic practice and discusses the definition of the term “story” and the different uses of the narrative form. The chapter also studies some important terms related to the narrative construct and views the narrative as a form of communication, representation, and construction of self.