ArticlePDF Available

Aerosol nucleation induced by a high energy particle beam

Wiley
Geophysical Research Letters
Authors:

Abstract and Figures

The effect of ions in aerosol nucleation is a subject where much remains to be discovered. That ions can enhance nucleation has been shown by theory, observations, and experiments. However, the exact mechanism still remains to be determined. One question is if the nature of the ionization affects the nucleation. This is an essential question since many previous experiments have been performed using radioactive sources that ionize differently than the cosmic rays which are responsible for the majority of atmospheric ionization. Here we report on an experimental study of sulphuric acid aerosol nucleation under near atmospheric conditions using a 580 MeV electron beam to ionize the volume of the reaction chamber. We find a clear and significant contribution from ion induced nucleation and consider this to be an unambiguous observation of the ion-effect on aerosol nucleation using a particle beam under conditions not far from the Earth's atmosphere. By comparison with ionization using a gamma source we further show that the nature of the ionizing particles is not important for the ion component of the nucleation.
Content may be subject to copyright.
Aerosol nucleation induced by a high energy particle beam
Martin B. Enghoff,
1
Jens Olaf Pepke Pedersen,
1
Ulrik I. Uggerhøj,
2
Sean M. Paling,
3
and Henrik Svensmark
1
Received 8 February 2011; revised 25 March 2011; accepted 31 March 2011; published 12 May 2011.
[1] We have studied sulfuric acid aerosol nucleation in an
atmosphericpressurereactionchamberusinga580MeV
electron beam to ionize the volume of the reaction chamber.
We find a clear contribution from ioninduced nucleation
and consider this to be the first unambiguous observation
of the ioneffect on aerosol nucleation using a particle beam
under conditions that resemble the Earths atmosphere. By
comparison with ionization using a gamma source we fur-
ther show that the nature of the ionizing particles is not
important for the ioninduced component of the nucleation.
This implies that inexpensive ionization sources as
opposed to exp ensive accelerator beams can be used for
investigations of ioninduced nucleation.
Citation: Enghoff,
M. B., J. O. P. Pedersen, U. I. Uggerhøj, S. M. Paling, and
H. Svensmark (2011), Aerosol nucleation induced by a high
energy particle beam, Geophys. Res. Lett., 38, L09805,
doi:10.1029/2011GL047036.
1. Introduction
[2] Aerosol and cloud research is one of the most critical
frontiers of climate science [Shindell et al., 2009; Bodenschatz
et al., 2010] and the direct radiative forcing and indirect
cloud albedo forcing from aerosols remain the dominant
uncertainty in the radiative forcing of the atmosphere.
Among the uncertainties are the mechanisms behind for-
mation of new aerosols from the gas phase and several
schemes have been suggested [Curtius, 2006] such as ternary
nucleation with amines [Kurtén et al., 2008]. Observations
show that sulfuric acid, together with water and other gas
phase molecules play an important role in atmospheric
nucleation [Lee et al., 2003; Kulmala et al., 2006] and these
systems are also the basis of many theoretical nucleation
works [Wyslouzil et al., 1991; Hanson and Lovejoy, 2006].
[
3] The importance of ioninduced nucleation for the
Earth atmosphere is a subject of intense discussions [Yu,
2010; Sloan and Wolfendale, 2008] which is being studied
both in field measurements [Kulmala et al., 2010] and in
modeling work [Pierce and Adams, 2009; Kazil, 2010].
Previous laboratory studies using gamma rays have found a
positive correlation between ionizing radiation intensity and
aerosol concentration in air [Raes and Janssens, 1985;
Svensmark et al., 2007; Enghoff et al., 2008], but systematic
laboratory experiments on aerosol nucleation with ionizing
particle radiation have so far only been performed with very
high radiation doses far above natural atmospheric levels
using a and bsources [Adachi et al., 1996] or high
intensity electron [Hakoda et al., 2003] and proton beams
[Imanaka et al., 2010]. Preliminary measurements with a
more realistic 3.5 GeV/c pion beam have been reported to
show indications of ioninduced nucleation [Duplissy et al.,
2010], but suffered from unstable conditions in the reaction
chamber. A new experimental facility dedicated to these
studies is under commissioning at the CERN Proton Syn-
chrotron (PS) [CLOUD Collaboration, 2000] and is likely to
resolve these problems.
2. Experimental Methods
[4] The experiments took place in a 1 m long, 50 L
cylindrical, electropolished stainless steel reactor, previously
used by Enghoff et al. [2008]. A mixture of pure humidified
synthetic air is continuously flowed through the vessel at a
rate of 3.1 L/min together with trace amounts of (typically
2 ppb) sulfur dioxide (SO
2
) and approximately 55 ppb
ozone (O
3
) with the relative humidity held at about 50%.
UV light was used to initiate the photochemistry in the
chamber leading to an in situ production of sulfuric acid.
The temperature was kept at 21.2 ± 0.04°C and the pressure
at 12 mbar above room pressure.
[
5] A lowintensity beam of 580 MeV electrons from the
Aarhus Storage Ring ASTRID [Myers et al., 1998] at
the University of Aarhus was used as the ionizing source. The
energy of the electron beam falls within the main part of
the natural cosmic ray spectrum and the induced ion con-
centrations cover the full range of atmospheric values.
[
6] Production of aerosols was measured using a con-
densation particle counter (CPC) with a nominal 50% cutoff
diameter of 4 nm. The chamber volume could be ionized
using the 580 MeV electrons going coaxially through the
chamber covering an elliptical area with semi axes of 4.4
and 6.1 cm (FWHM) at the front end of the chamber. The
ionization level from the beam was adjustable by changing
the amount of beam extracted and, as shown by the esti-
mated energy loss (see auxiliary material), the electrons pass
through the volume of air almost undisturbed.
1
Alternatively
a 33.5 MBq Na22 gamma source could be used. For some
of the runs a 5 cm thick scintillator was placed in the beam,
7.5 m upstream of the chamber, dispersing the beam by an
additional 6 cm at the front of the chamber.
[
7] The procedure for each experiment involved turning
the UV lamps on for 10 minutes giving a burst of sulfuric
acid and then recording the resulting particle number. The
time between UV bursts was 60 minutes, in order to allow
1
National Space Institute, Technical University of Denmark,
Copenhagen, Denmark.
2
Department of Physics and Astronomy, University of Aarhus,
Aarhus, Denmark.
3
Department of Physics and Astronomy, University of Sheffield,
Sheffield, UK.
Copyright 2011 by the American Geophysical Union.
00948276/11/2011GL047036
1
Auxiliary materials are available in the HMTL. doi:10.1029/
2011GL047036.
GEOPHYSICAL RESEARCH LETTERS, VOL. 38, L09805, doi:10.1029/2011GL047036, 2011
L09805 1of4
the aerosol concentration (as measured by the CPC) to reach
zero by the end of each burst, with the aerosols being lost to
walls and by dilution.
3. Results and Discussion
[8] The measurement program consisted of varying the
ionization levels by adjusting the electron beam, investi-
gating the effect of dispersing the electron beam, and
comparing the aerosol formation (observed at 4 nm) induced
by, respectively, the gamma source and the electron beam.
A range of ionization levels from background levels to
700 cm
3
s
1
were tested and the results can be seen in
Figure 1, where the formation rate measured by the CPC is
shown as a function of ion concentration. The runs have
been divided into 3 groups and it is seen that an increase in
ion concentration causes an increase in the aerosol formation
rate for all three groups of runs. Also shown for each group
is the best linear fit to the data. Runs 15 were made using
air from the same cylinders. Between run 5 and 6 the air
supply was changed, causing a large shift in the number of
aerosols produced in a burst and between runs 9 and 10 a
shift occurred again. This shift is seen on Figure 1 as a
vertical displacement of the 3 groups of measurements, and
we speculate that the shift is due to varying amounts of trace
impurities in the purified air cylinders. The impurities are
able to pass the filters and influence the neutral component
of the nucleation process. There is also a smaller variation of
the slopes of the linear fits in Figure 1 between the 3 groups
of measurements, but they do not seem to vary in a sys-
tematic way with the vertical shift. While we cannot exclude
that the ioninduced component of the nucleations are also
affected by the impurities, the effect thus seem to be smaller
on this component, and does not change the main obser-
vation that there is a clear effect of the ion concentration on
the formation rate.
[
9] During run 6 the effect of dispersing the beam was
tested. The formation rate at 4 nm changed from 0.095 ±
0.003 cm
3
s
1
to 0.094 ± 0.009 cm
3
s
1
, showing that
there was no significant difference between the two settings.
This also shows that the gases in the chamber were well
mixed.
[
10] The sulfuric acid concentrations are found to be
7·10
8
cm
3
(+100/50)% for runs 15 and 6·10
8
cm
3
for runs 610, with run 10 having a slightly higher con-
centration than runs 69 (see auxiliary material). This could
explain the changes in aerosol production rates observed
during the experiments.
[
11] In all runs the effect of the ions is to produce addi-
tional aerosol formation over a wide range of ion con-
centrations from background levels to 19,000 cm
3
. Model
results [Kazil and Lovejoy, 2004] indicate that the nucle-
ation rate should peak at high ionization levels, but appar-
ently this range is not reached at the present experimental
conditions, which may be a result of our rather high
[H
2
SO
4
] values. The error bars shown are statistical
uncertainties and the absolute uncertainties are much larger,
but since our purpose is to investigate the relative variation
of the nucleation rate with ion density, we find the statistical
uncertainties to be most relevant. A linear relationship
(which has been observed before in a smaller range of ion
densities by Svensmark et al. [2007]) would show that the
nucleation rate depends on ion concentration, but we cannot
for example exclude a square relationship, which would
indicate that nucleation depends on the ion production rate
and any conclusions would also be complicated by linear
wall losses. An extrapolation of the curves to zero ion
density would give the nucleation rate due to processes not
involving ions, but further experimental work at low ioni-
zation values is needed to resolve this.
[
12] We caution that the combination of a finite residence
time in the reaction chamber and a detector cutoff larger
than the diameter of the critical cluster has the effect that
Figure 1. Formation rate (at 4 nm) versus ion concentration as measured by the CPC (see text for details). Error bars show
statistical uncertainties.
ENGHOFF ET AL.: NUCLEATION INDUCED BY A PARTICLE BEAM L09805L09805
2of4
only a fraction of the nucleated particles will grow to
detectable sizes as recently shown by Sipilä et al. [2010]. In
our experiment the possibility of a faster growth rate of the
ions may artificially enhance the measured particle con-
centrations when using the ionizing sources compared to no
sources. From an estimated residence halflife of 200 s, and
with [H
2
SO
4
] concentrations in the range 67·10
8
cm
3
we
conclude from Sipilä et al. [2010, Figure 3] that we reach
mean particle diameters above 3 nm, which is close to the
detector cutoff around 4 nm, but may still leave the majority
of the aerosols undetected. Since our measurements were
made under stable conditions where only the ion density
was varied, our observation that ions enhance the formation
rate at 4 nm remains solid in spite of the large absolute
uncertainties; however, the measured relative enhancement
should be considered an upper limit. Sipilä et al. [2010] also
found that the rate of homogenous nucleation measured with
an instrument similar to ours should vary with the 6th power
of [H
2
SO
4
]. If the difference between our runs 15 and 69
is due to a change in [H
2
SO
4
] by about a factor of 1.2, this
should result in a homogeneous nucleation rate difference
by a factor of 3 which is close to the values found by
extrapolating the rates shown in Figure 1 to zero ion
concentration.
[
13] Using an analytical model (see auxiliary material) we
have calculated the unobserved nucleation rate J1 from the
observed formation rates J4. This has large inherent uncer-
tainties and gives absolute 1 nm nulceation rates in the
order of 1 s
1
cm
3
, which is about two orders of magnitude
lower than previous laboratory measurements under similar
conditions and with only background ionization [see Sipilä
et al., 2010, and references therein]. Some explanations
for this discrepancy could be that our sulfuric acid con-
centrations and our counting efficiency are lower than
estimated. A possible remedy would be to normalize our
nucleation rates to the literature values, but we have chosen to
give our estimated absolute values with the added note that
only the relative variations should be considered accurate.
4. Conclusions
[14] An important result from this work is (as seen from
Figure 1) that nucleation induced with the ionization from the
gamma source experiments are indistinguishable from those
using the electron beam. Compared to the 580 MeV elec-
trons the gamma rays have rather low energies and the
electrons emitted through Compton scattering will ionize
very locally, whereas the 580 MeV electrons have a mean
energy loss rate close to the minimum (minimum ionizing)
and will ionize along their path. The gammas may however
ionize more than one atom due to secondary gammas
emitted in the Compton process. Nevertheless our data show
that the fraction of nucleation events due to the electron
beam or the gamma rays is an effect of the produced ions
and that the nature of the ionizing particles is not important.
This demonstrates that while a particle beam can be used for
studies of the ioneffect on aerosol nucleation future labo-
ratory studies of atmospheric aerosol nucleation can be
greatly facilitated, since they can more easily be done with
gamma radiation sources instead of using complicated and
expensive accelerator beams.
[
15] Further we conclude that under the present experi-
mental conditions (P = 1 atmosphere, T = 21.2°C, [SO
2
]=
2 ppb) there is a clear evidence of ioninduced nucleation as
a source of aerosol production, which corroborates earlier
measurements using only gamma radiation as the ionizing
source [Svensmark et al., 2007; Enghoff et al., 2008].
However we also stress that this is a qualitative result and
that further work at lower values of P, T,[H
2
SO
4
], and
[SO
2
] is required to perform an extrapolation to real atmo-
spheric conditions, in particular since our [H
2
SO
4
] con-
centrations of 6 7·10
8
cm
3
are at least an order of
magnitude above typical cleanair concentrations of about
10
7
cm
3
. Using the lower estimated [H
2
SO
4
] concentration
of 6 · 10
8
cm
3
in runs 69 we find that the effect of
changing the ion density from 700 to a typical atmospheric
value of 1,500 cm
3
results in a relative increase in for-
mation rate at 4 nm of approximately 7%, but modelling
results [Kazil and Lovejoy, 2004] show that lowering the
values of the present experimental parameters will influence
both the critical cluster size and the particle production and
may both correlate and anticorrelate with the ionization
level.
[
16] Acknowledgments. We thank Michel Avngaard for help with
setting up the experiment and the ASTRID staff for delivering the electron
beam. MBE acknowledges support from the Carlsberg Foundation and
SMP thanks the Engineering and Physical Sciences Researc h Counc il
(EPSRC) and the Science and Technology Facilities Council (STFC) for
support.
[17] The Editor thanks two anonymous reviewers for their assistance in
evaluating this paper.
References
Adachi, M., et al. (1996), Exp erimental evaluation of ioninduced nucle-
ation in nanometeraerosol formation by aray radiolysis of SO
2
/H
2
O/
N
2
mixtures, Coll. Surf., 109,3948.
Bodensch atz, E., et al. (2010), Can we understand clouds witho ut turbu-
lence, Science, 327, 970971.
CLOUD Collaboration (2000), A study of the link between cosmic rays and
clouds with a cloud chamber at the CERN PS, Rep. CERN/SPSC 2000
021, SPSC/P317, Eur. Organ . f or Nucl. Res., Geneva, Switzerland.
[Available at http://cloud.web.cern.ch/cloud.]
Curtius, J. (2006), Nucleation of atmospheric aerosol particles, C. R. Phys. ,
7, 10271045.
Duplissy, J., et al. (2010), Results from the CE RN pilot CLOUD experi-
ment, Atmos. Chem. Phys., 10, 16351647.
Enghoff, M. B., et al. (2008), Evidence for the role of ions in aerosol nucle-
ation, J. Phys. Chem. A, 112, 10,30510,309.
Hakoda, T., et al. (2003), Charged nanoparticle formation from humidified
gases with and without dilute benzene under electron beam irradiation,
J. Aerosol Sci., 34, 977991.
Hanson, D., and E. Lovejoy (2006), Measurement of the thermodynamics
of the hydrated dimer and trimer of sulfuric acid, J. Phys. Chem. A, 110,
95259528.
Imanaka, M., et al. (2010), Nanoparticle formation in H
2
O/N
2
and H
2
O/Ar
mixtures under irradiation by 20 MeV protons an dpositive corona dis-
charge, J. Aerosol Sci., 41, 468474.
Kazil, J. (2010), Aerosol nucleation and its role for clouds and Earths radi-
ative forcing in the aerosolclimate model ECHAM5HAM, Atmos.
Chem. Phys., 10, 10,73310,752.
Kazil, J., and E. R. Lovejoy (2004), Tropospheric ionization and aerosol
production: A model study, J. Geophys. Res., 109, D19206,
doi:10.1029/2004JD004852.
Kulmala, M., K. E. J. Lehtinen, and A. Laaksonen (2006), Cluster activa-
tion theory as an explanation of the linear dependence between formation
rate of 3 nm particles a nd sulphuric acid concentration, Atmos. Chem.
Phys., 6, 787793.
Kulmala, M., et al. (2010), Atmospheric data over a solar cycle: No connec-
tion between galactic cosmic rays and new particle formation, Atmos.
Chem. Phys., 10, 18851898.
Kurtén, T., V. Loukonen, H. Vehkamäki, and M. Kulmala (2008), Amines
are likely to enhance neutral and ioninduced sulfuric acidwater nucle-
ation in the atmosphere more effectively than ammonia, Atmos. Chem.
Phys., 8, 40954103.
ENGHOFF ET AL.: NUCLEATION INDUCED BY A PARTICLE BEAM L09805L09805
3of4
Lee, S.H., et al. (2003), Particle formation by ion nucleation in the upper
troposphere and lower stratosphere, Science, 301, 18861889.
Myers, S., L. Liljeby, C. PetitJeanGenaz, J. Poole, and K. Rensfelt (Eds.)
(1998), Proceedings of the Sixth European Particle Accelerator Confer-
ence, Inst. of Phys., Philadelphia, Pa.
Pierce, J. R., and P. J. Adams (2009), Can cosmic rays affect cloud conden-
sation nuclei by altering new particle formation rates?, Geophys. Res.
Lett., 36, L09820, doi:10.1029/2009GL037946.
Raes, F., and A. Janssens (1985), Ioninduced aerosol formation in a H
2
O
H
2
SO
4
system1. extension of the classical theory and search for exper-
imental evidence, J. Aerosol Sci., 16, 217227.
Shindell, D. T., et al. (2009), Improved attribution of climate forcing to
emissions, Science, 326, 716718.
Sipilä, M., et al. (2010), The role of sulfuric acid in atmospheric nucleation,
Science, 327, 12431246.
Sloan, T., and A. W. Wolfendale (2008), Testing the proposed causal link
between cosmic rays and cloud cover, Environ. Res. Lett., 3, 024001.
Svensmark, H., et al. (2007), Experimental evidence for the role of ions in
particle nucleation under atmospheric conditions, Proc. R. Soc. A, 463,
385396.
Wyslouzil, B., J. Seinfeld, R. Flagan, and K. Okuyama (1991), Binary
nucleation in acidwater systems. I. Methanesulfonic acidwater, J. Chem.
Phys., 94, 68276841.
Yu, F. (2010), Ionmediated nucleation in the atmosphere: Key controlling
parameters, implica tions, and lookup table, J. Geophys. Res., 155,
D03206, doi:10.1029/2009JD012630.
M. B. Enghoff, J. O. P. Pedersen, a nd H. Svensmark, National Space
Institute, Technical Universi ty of Denmark, Juliane Maries Vej 30,
DK2100 Copenhagen, Denmark. (jopp@space.dtu.dk)
S. M. Paling, Department of Physics and Astronomy, Univ ersity of
Sheffield, Sheffield S3 7RH, UK.
U. I. Ug gerhøj, Department of Physics and Astron omy, University of
Aarhus, Ny Munkegade 120, DK8000 Aarhus, Denmark.
ENGHOFF ET AL.: NUCLEATION INDUCED BY A PARTICLE BEAM L09805L09805
4of4
... Aurorae are clearly solar and astronomical induced phenomena (Komitov, 2009) and are an index of the electrification of the ionosphere. The atmospheric global electric circuit has been proposed to regulate the microphysics of cloud formation (Tinsley, 2008;Enghoff et al., 2011), which can then regulate the global climate through albedo oscillations. Because the albedo oscillations would share the same frequencies of the mid-latitude aurora records, the albedo too would present ~60-year oscillations. ...
... Moreover, the two major tidal cycles at 9.3 years (Jupiter and Saturn alignment) and 11.86 years (Jupiter period) beat at about 61 years. Thus, a possibility is that the solar activity and/or the heliosphere may synchronize to a natural solar system ~60-year cycle and, through a nuclear amplification mechanism, may make this signal sufficiently macroscopic to influence the Earth's climate too probably through a modulation of cosmic ray which would modulate the cloud cover (Enghoff et al., 2011). Indeed, a mechanism in which the planets of the solar system can affect the sun has been recently proposed (Wolff and Patrone, 2010). ...
Preprint
The North Atlantic Oscillation (NAO) obtained using instrumental and documentary proxy predictors from Eurasia is found to be characterized by a quasi 60-year dominant oscillation since 1650. This pattern emerges clearly once the NAO record is time integrated to stress its comparison with the temperature record. The integrated NAO (INAO) is found to well correlate with the length of the day (since 1650) and the global surface sea temperature record HadSST2 and HadSST3 (since 1850). These findings suggest that INAO can be used as a good proxy for global climate change, and that a 60-year cycle exists in the global climate since at least 1700. Finally, the INAO ~60-year oscillation well correlates with the ~60- year oscillations found in the historical European aurora record since 1700, which suggests that this 60-year dominant climatic cycle has a solar-astronomical origin.
... [14,15] Indeed, experiments show that ion-induced nucleation, taking place in the presence of charged molecular clusters, is significantly enhanced. [16][17][18] In a recent work, we extended the Thomson model to describe nucleation around charged particles in fluids containing dissolved ions, considering only the electrostatic forces. [19] In such fluids, dissociated ions lead to screening of the potential characterized by the Debye length. ...
Preprint
Full-text available
We present a model for ion-induced nucleation, focusing on the effect of dissociated ions embedded in the fluid surrounding a charged core or colloid. The model includes the ions' direct electrostatic energy and preferential solvation. The integrated ions' free energy has two terms: The first can be short- or long-range, depending on their density. The second is proportional to the nucleus' volume and can shift the state from undersaturation to supersaturation at high ion concentration. The inclusion of the Gibbs transfer energies of ions in the free energy leads to a modified Poisson-Boltzmann equation for the potential around the core. The integrated ions' free energy is added to the fluids' interfacial and bulk terms to establish a generalized Thomson model. In the Debye-Huckel limit, the model is solved analytically, while in the nonlinear regime, it is solved numerically. The state diagram in the plane of saturation and core charge includes regions with a homogeneous phase, electro-prewetting, metastable vapor, metastable nucleus, and spontaneous nucleation states. The lines separating these regions depend sensitively on the preferential solvation. Our model shows nucleation asymmetry to the sign of the nucleus' charge. This sign asymmetry is due to the Gibbs transfer energies of ions.
... 14,15 Indeed, experiments show that ion-induced nucleation, taking place in the presence of charged molecular clusters, is significantly enhanced. [16][17][18] In a recent work, we extended the Thomson model to describe nucleation around charged particles in fluids containing dissolved ions, considering only the electrostatic forces. 19 In such fluids, dissociated ions lead to screening of the potential characterized by the Debye length. ...
Article
Full-text available
We present a model for ion-induced nucleation, focusing on the effect of dissociated ions embedded in the fluid surrounding a charged core or colloid. The model includes the ions' direct electrostatic energy and preferential solvation. The integrated ions' free energy has two terms: The first can be short- or long-range, depending on their density. The second is proportional to the nucleus' volume and can shift the state from undersaturation to supersaturation at high ion concentration. The inclusion of the Gibbs transfer energies of ions in the free energy leads to a modified Poisson-Boltzmann equation for the potential around the core. The integrated ions' free energy is added to the fluids' interfacial and bulk terms to establish a generalized Thomson model. In the Debye–Hückel limit, the model is solved analytically, while in the nonlinear regime, it is solved numerically. The state diagram in the plane of saturation and core charge includes regions with a homogeneous phase, electro-prewetting, metastable vapor, metastable nucleus, and spontaneous nucleation states. The lines separating these regions depend sensitively on the preferential solvation. Our model shows nucleation asymmetry to the sign of the nucleus' charge. This sign asymmetry is due to the Gibbs transfer energies of ions.
... Introduction: The physics of nucleation, where a droplet of order defining the global energy minima grows or shrinks within a metastable phase is one of the defining tenets within the study of phases and phase transitions [1][2][3]. These ideas govern a wide range of phenomena spanning condensed matter [4][5][6], nuclear physics [7][8][9][10][11][12][13] and high-energy field theories [14][15][16][17][18][19][20]. The conditions on growth and decay of any such nuclei, however, are governed by a competition between the surface tension and bulk free-energy density [21][22][23]. ...
Preprint
Full-text available
Metastable phases, in general, are unstable to nucleating droplets of the order defining the global free energy minima. However, whether such a droplet grows or shrinks relies on a competition between the surface tension and bulk energy density. We study the role of coupling a topological fermionic field to a scalar field undergoing such nucleation processes. We find that existence of non-trivial fermionic boundary modes on the nucleating droplets leads to substantial quantum corrections to the surface tension thereby modifying the size of the critical nucleus beyond which unrestricted droplet growth happens. To illustrate the phenomena we devise a minimal model of fermions in a Chern insulating system coupled to a classical Ising field in two spatial dimensions. Using a combination of analytic and numerical methods we conclusively show that topological phases can lead to characteristic quantum surface tension. Apart from material systems, our work has implications on the interplay of physics of statistical classical fields and quantum topological order.
... Firoz et al. (2022); Doyle et al. (2018); Reep & Knizhnik (2019)),while the influx of GCRs is more continuous. It should be noted that studies have found that in the case of ion-induced nucleation the nature of the ionizing radiation is not important as long as the ionizing effect is the same (Enghoff et al. 2011). ...
Article
Full-text available
It is known from Earth that ionizing high-energy radiation can lead to ion-induced nucleation of cloud condensation nuclei in the atmosphere. Since the amount of high-energy radiation can vary greatly based on the radiative environment of a host star, understanding the effect of high-energy radiation on cloud particles is critical to understand exoplanet atmospheres. This study aims to explore how high-energy radiation affects the aggregation and charging of mineral cloud particles. We present experiments conducted in an atmosphere chamber on mineral SiO 2 particles with diameters of 50 nm. The particles were exposed to gamma radiation in either low-humidity (RH ≈ 20%) or high-humidity (RH > 50%) environments. The aggregation and charging state of the particles were studied with a scanning mobility particle sizer. We find that the single SiO 2 particles (N1) cluster to form larger aggregates (N2–N4), and that this aggregation is inhibited by gamma radiation. We find that gamma radiation shifts the charging of the particles to become more negative by increasing the charging state of negatively charged particles. Through an independent t -test, we find that this increase is statistically significant within a 5% significance level for all aggregates in the high-humidity environment and all except the N1 particles in the low-humidity environment. For the positively charged particles, the changes in charging state are not within the 5% significance level. We suggest that the overall effect of gamma radiation could favor the formation of a high number of small particles over a lower number of larger particles.
... Given the known role of ions in pure biogenic NPF (2), in this study, we focus on experiments with ions formed naturally in the chamber by galactic cosmic rays, referred to as "galactic cosmic ray" (GCR) runs. Runs at increased ion concentrations were performed using an adjustable π+ beam from the CERN Proton Synchrotron (45). The π+ beam is defocused to a transverse size of about 1.5 m by 1.5 m when it passes through the CLOUD chamber. ...
Article
Full-text available
Biogenic vapors form new particles in the atmosphere, affecting global climate. The contributions of monoterpenes and isoprene to new particle formation (NPF) have been extensively studied. However, sesquiterpenes have received little attention despite a potentially important role due to their high molecular weight. Via chamber experiments performed under atmospheric conditions, we report biogenic NPF resulting from the oxidation of pure mixtures of β-caryophyllene, α-pinene, and isoprene, which produces oxygenated compounds over a wide range of volatilities. We find that a class of vapors termed ultralow-volatility organic compounds (ULVOCs) are highly efficient nucleators and quantitatively determine NPF efficiency. When compared with a mixture of isoprene and monoterpene alone, adding only 2% sesquiterpene increases the ULVOC yield and doubles the formation rate. Thus, sesquiterpene emissions need to be included in assessments of global aerosol concentrations in pristine climates where biogenic NPF is expected to be a major source of cloud condensation nuclei.
... Numerical field observations, 11,12 laboratory simulations, 13,14 and modeling studies 15,16 have confirmed the importance of IIN in the atmosphere. For example, Kirkby et al. 17 found that ions increase the nucleation rate in terrestrial environments with low sulfuric acid pollution, and the dominant core ions in the clusters are identified as NH 4 + and NO 3 − . ...
Article
Full-text available
Atmospheric new particle formation (NPF), which exerts comprehensive implications for climate, air quality and human health, has received extensive attention. From molecule to cluster is the initial and most important stage of the nucleation process of atmospheric new particles. However, due to the complexity of the nucleation process and limitations of experimental characterization techniques, there is still a great uncertainty in understanding the nucleation mechanism at the molecular level. Laboratory‐based molecular beam methods can experimentally implement the generation and growth of typical atmospheric gas‐phase nucleation precursors to nanoscale clusters, characterize the key physical and chemical properties of clusters such as structure and composition, and obtain a series of their physicochemical parameters, including association rate coefficients, electron binding energy, pickup cross section and pickup probability and so on. These parameters can quantitatively illustrate the physicochemical properties of the cluster, and evaluate the effect of different gas phase nucleation precursors on the formation and growth of atmospheric new particles. We review the present literatures on atmospheric cluster formation and reaction employing the experimental method of laboratory molecular beam. The experimental apparatuses were classified and summarized from three aspects of cluster generation, growth and detection processes. Focus of this review is on the properties of nucleation clusters involving different precursor molecules of water, sulfuric acid, nitric acid and NxOy, respectively. We hope this review will provide a deep insight for effects of cluster physicochemical properties on nucleation, and reveal the formation and growth mechanism of atmospheric new particle at the molecular level.
Chapter
The analysis of power atmospheric processes depending on its parameters and external conditions allows one to describe the thermal state of the Earth. For simplicity, one parameter is used usually for this goal—the global temperature that is the temperature of the Earth’s surface averaged over the globe and time. An important factor of a change of the global temperature in time is the intensity of solar radiation that penetrates in the Earth’s atmosphere. Its variation due to a change of the Earth’s position with respect to the Sun causes the periodicity in the global temperature with the period of the order of hundred thousand years. Two regimes exist for evolution of the global temperature, with and without glaciers, because of different values of the Earth’s albedo for these regimes. The local temperature in past resulted from the isotope analysis of sediments allows one to restore evolution of the Earth’s temperature. In particular, the difference between the maximal and minimal temperatures in the course of Earth’s evolution is almost 20 ^{\circ }C that by one order of magnitude exceeds the corresponding value that is the basis of the Paris agreement 2015 on climate. The influence of the human activity is stronger for a megapolis with a heightened density of population. It is shown that artificial cooling of the megapolis temperature may be resulted from injection in the atmosphere the water microdroplets with a dissolved absorbed additivity. This technology is analogous to aerial firefighting. In addition, it is shown that the power of hydroelectric plants and wind turbine is compared with that of greenhouse radiation due to water evaporated from the ground under the action of these systems. As it follows from our experience, the start of the Earth’s warming begins from eighties of twentieth century, as well as the anthropogenic change of the climate.
Article
Full-text available
In order to evaluate how much Total Solar Irradiance (TSI) has influenced Northern Hemisphere surface air temperature trends, it is important to have reliable estimates of both quantities. Sixteen different estimates of the changes in Total Solar Irradiance (TSI) since at least the 19th century were compiled from the literature. Half of these estimates are “low variability” and half are “high variability”. Meanwhile, five largely-independent methods for estimating Northern Hemisphere temperature trends were evaluated using: 1) only rural weather stations; 2) all available stations whether urban or rural (the standard approach); 3) only sea surface temperatures; 4) tree-ring widths as temperature proxies; 5) glacier length records as temperature proxies. The standard estimates which use urban as well as rural stations were somewhat anomalous as they implied a much greater warming in recent decades than the other estimates, suggesting that urbanization bias might still be a problem in current global temperature datasets - despite the conclusions of some earlier studies. Nonetheless, all five estimates confirm that it is currently warmer than the late 19th century, i.e., there has been some “global warming” since the 19th century. For each of the five estimates of Northern Hemisphere temperatures, the contribution from direct solar forcing for all sixteen estimates of TSI was evaluated using simple linear least-squares fitting. The role of human activity on recent warming was then calculated by fitting the residuals to the UN IPCC’s recommended “anthropogenic forcings” time series. For all five Northern Hemisphere temperature series, different TSI estimates suggest everything from no role for the Sun in recent decades (implying that recent global warming is mostly human-caused) to most of the recent global warming being due to changes in solar activity (that is, that recent global warming is mostly natural). It appears that previous studies (including the most recent IPCC reports) which had prematurely concluded the former, had done so because they failed to adequately consider all the relevant estimates of TSI and/or to satisfactorily address the uncertainties still associated with Northern Hemisphere temperature trend estimates. Therefore, several recommendations on how the scientific community can more satisfactorily resolve these issues are provided.
Article
Full-text available
Just over 50 years ago, Henry Houghton published an essay in Science entitled “Cloud physics: Not all questions about nucleation, growth, and precipitation of water particles are yet answered” (1). Since then, understanding of cloud processes has advanced enormously, yet we still face some of the basic questions Houghton drew attention to. The interest in finding the answers, however, has steadily increased, largely because clouds are a primary source of uncertainty in projections of future climate (2). Why is our understanding of cloud processes still so inadequate, and what are the prospects for the future?
Article
Full-text available
Experimental studies of aerosol nucleation in air, containing trace amounts of ozone, sulphur dioxide and water vapour a concentrations relevant for the Earth's atmosphere, are reported. The production of new aerosol particles is found to be proportiona to the negative ion density and yields nucleation rates of the order of 0.1–1 cm−3 s−1. This suggests that the ions are active in generating an atmospheric reservoir of small thermodynamically stable clusters which are important for nucleation processes in the atmosphere and ultimately for cloud formation.
Article
Full-text available
A decrease in the globally averaged low level cloud cover, deduced from the ISCCP infra red data, as the cosmic ray intensity decreased during the solar cycle 22 was observed by two groups. The groups went on to hypothesise that the decrease in ionization due to cosmic rays causes the decrease in cloud cover, thereby explaining a large part of the presently observed global warming. We have examined this hypothesis to look for evidence to corroborate it. None has been found and so our conclusions are to doubt it. From the absence of corroborative evidence, we estimate that less than 23%, at the 95% confidence level, of the 11-year cycle change in the globally averaged cloud cover observed in solar cycle 22 is due to the change in the rate of ionization from the solar modulation of cosmic rays.
Article
Full-text available
Although controversial, many observations have suggested that low-level cloud cover correlates with the cosmic ray flux. Because galactic cosmic rays have likely decreased in intensity over the last century, this hypothesis, if true, could partly explain 20th century warming, thereby upsetting the consensus view that greenhouse-gas forcing has caused most of the warming. The “ion-aerosol clear-air” hypothesis suggests that increased cosmic rays cause increases in new-particle formation, cloud condensation nuclei concentrations (CCN), and cloud cover. In this paper, we present the first calculations of the magnitude of the ion-aerosol clear-air mechanism using a general circulation model with online aerosol microphysics. In our simulations, changes in CCN from changes in cosmic rays during a solar cycle are two orders of magnitude too small to account for the observed changes in cloud properties; consequently, we conclude that the hypothesized effect is too small to play a significant role in current climate change.
Article
Full-text available
Nucleation from the gas phase is an important source of aerosol particles in the Earth's atmosphere, contributing to the number of cloud condensation nuclei, which form cloud droplets. We have implemented in the aerosol-climate model ECHAM5-HAM a new scheme for neutral and charged nucleation of sulfuric acid and water based on laboratory data, and nucleation of an organic compound and sulfuric acid using a parametrization of cluster activation based on field measurements. We give details of the implementation, compare results with observations, and investigate the role of the individual aerosol nucleation mechanisms for clouds and the Earth's radiative forcing. The results of our simulations are most consistent with observations when neutral and charged nucleation of sulfuric acid proceed throughout the troposphere and nucleation due to cluster activation is limited to the forested boundary layer. The globally averaged annual mean contributions of the individual nucleation processes to total absorbed solar short-wave radiation via the direct, semi-direct, indirect cloud-albedo and cloud-lifetime effects in our simulations are −1.15 W/m2 for charged H2SO4/H2O nucleation, −0.235 W/m2 for cluster activation, and −0.05 W/m2 for neutral H2SO4/H2O nucleation. The overall effect of nucleation is −2.55 W/m2, which exceeds the sum of the individual terms due to feedbacks and interactions in the model. Aerosol nucleation contributes over the oceans with −2.18 W/m2 to total absorbed solar short-wave radiation, compared to −0.37 W/m2 over land. We explain the higher effect of aerosol nucleation on Earth's radiative forcing over the oceans with the larger area covered by ocean clouds, due to the larger contrast in albedo between clouds and the ocean surface compared to continents, and the larger susceptibility of pristine clouds owing to the saturation of effects. The large effect of charged nucleation in our simulations is not in contradiction with small effects seen in local measurements: over southern Finland, where cluster activation proceeds efficiently, we find that charged nucleation of sulfuric acid and water contributes on average less than 10% to ultrafine aerosol concentrations, in good agreement with observations.
Article
Full-text available
Aerosol particles affect the Earth's radiative balance by directly scattering and absorbing solar radiation and, indirectly, through their activation into cloud droplets. Both effects are known with considerable uncertainty only, and translate into even bigger uncertainties in future climate predictions. More than a decade ago, variations in galactic cosmic rays were suggested to closely correlate with variations in atmospheric cloud cover and therefore constitute a driving force behind aerosol-cloud-climate interactions. Later, the enhancement of atmospheric aerosol particle formation by ions generated from cosmic rays was proposed as a physical mechanism explaining this correlation. Here, we report unique observations on atmospheric aerosol formation based on measurements at the SMEAR II station, Finland, over a solar cycle (years 1996-2008) that shed new light on these presumed relationships. Our analysis shows that none of the quantities related to aerosol formation correlates with the cosmic ray-induced ionisation intensity (CRII). We also examined the contribution of ions to new particle formation on the basis of novel ground-based and airborne observations. A consistent result is that ion-induced formation contributes typically significantly less than 10% to the number of new particles, which would explain the missing correlation between CRII and aerosol formation. Our main conclusion is that galactic cosmic rays appear to play a minor role for atmospheric aerosol formation events, and so for the connected aerosol-climate effects as well.
Article
Full-text available
Aerosol particles affect the Earth’s radiative balance by directly scattering and absorbing solar radiation and, indirectly, through their activation into cloud droplets. Both effects are known with considerable uncertainty only, and translate into even bigger uncertainties in future climate predictions. More than a decade ago, variations in galactic cosmic rays were suggested to closely correlate with variations in atmospheric cloud cover and therefore constitute a driving force behind aerosol-cloud-climate interactions. Later, the enhancement of atmospheric aerosol particle formation by ions generated from cosmic rays was proposed as a physical mechanism explaining this correlation. Here, we report unique observations on atmospheric aerosol formation based on measurements at the SMEAR II station, Finland, over a solar cycle (years 1996–2008) that shed new light on these presumed relationships. Our analysis shows that none of the quantities related to aerosol formation correlates with the cosmic ray-induced ionisation intensity (CRII). We also examined the contribution of ions to new particle formation on the basis of novel ground-based and airborne observations. A consistent result is that ion-induced formation contributes typically less than 10% to the number of new particles, which would explain the missing correlation between CRII and aerosol formation. Our main conclusion is that galactic cosmic rays appear to play a minor role for atmospheric aerosol formation, and so for the connected aerosol-climate effects as well.
Article
Evaluating multi-component climate change mitigation strategies requires knowledge of the diverse direct and indirect effects of emissions. Methane, ozone and aerosols are linked through atmospheric chemistry so that emissions of a single pollutant can affect several species. I will show new calculations of atmospheric composition changes, radiative forcing, and the global warming potential (GWP) for increased emissions of tropospheric ozone and aerosol precursors in a coupled composition-climate model. The results demonstrate that gas-aerosol interactions substantially alter the relative importance of the various emissions, suggesting revisions to the GWPs used in international carbon trading. Additionally, I will present results showing how the net climate impact of particular activities depends strongly upon non-CO2 forcing agents for some sectors. These results will be highlighted by discussing the interplay between air quality emissions controls and climate for the case of emissions from coal-fired power plants. The changing balance between CO2 and air quality pollutants from coal plants may have contributed to the 20th century spatial and temporal patterns of climate change, and is likely to continue to do so as more and more plants are constructed in Asia.
Article
Nucleation is an important source of atmospheric particles and ubiquitous ions in the atmosphere have long been known to promote nucleation. An ion-mediated nucleation (IMN) mechanism based on a kinetic model is supported by recent measurements of the excess charge on freshly nucleated particles and ion cluster evolution during nucleation events. Here we investigate the dependence of steady state IMN rate (JIMN) on key controlling parameters. We find that sulfuric acid vapor concentration, temperature, relative humidity, ionization rate, and surface area of preexisting particles have profound and nonlinear impacts on JIMN. The sensitivities of JIMN to the changes in these key parameters may imply important physical feedback mechanisms involving climate and emission changes, solar variations, nucleation, aerosol number abundance, and aerosol indirect radiative forcing. We also describe a five-dimensional JIMN look-up table derived from the most recent version of the IMN model, with the key parameters covering a wide range of atmospheric conditions. With the look-up table and a multiple-variable interpolation subroutine, JIMN and the properties of critical clusters can be determined efficiently and accurately under given atmospheric conditions. The look-up table reduces the computational costs of the IMN rate calculations significantly (by a factor of around 8000) and can be readily incorporated into multidimensional models to study the secondary particle formation via IMN and associated climatic and health effects.
Article
Recent observations of ultrafine aerosol production in the atmosphere support the hypothesis of ions acting as nucleation agents. We use a numerical model of ion-induced aerosol formation based on experimental cluster ion thermodynamics to study the production of ultrafine aerosol in the troposphere and its response to variations in background ionization. An analytical model is used to explain the findings. Our results show a considerable ultrafine particle and surface area production due to ion-induced nucleation. Both particle and surface area production readily respond to variations in ionization, such as resulting from the modulation of the galactic cosmic ray intensity by the 11 year solar cycle. However, this response may be positive or negative, depending on ambient conditions. We explain the mechanism responsible for this behavior. The large particle production seen in our simulations suggests that ion-induced nucleation is an important atmospheric process, which may promote the solar cycle signal to the troposphere.