ArticlePDF Available

The Aerodynamics of Hummingbird Flight

Authors:

Abstract and Figures

(Abstract) Hummingbirds fly with their wings almost fully extended during their entire wingbeat. This pattern, associated with having proportionally short humeral bones, long distal wing elements, and assumed to be an adaptation for extended hovering flight, has lead to predictions that the aerodynamic mechanisms exploited by hummingbirds during hovering should be similar to those observed in insects. To test these predictions, we flew rufous hummingbirds (Selasphorus rufus, 3.3 g, n = 6) in a variable-speed wind tunnel (0-12 ms-1) and measured wake structure and dynamics using digital particle image velocimetry (DPIV). Unlike hovering insects, hummingbirds produced 75% of their weight support during downstroke and only 25% during upstroke, an asymmetry due to the inversion of their cambered wings during upstroke. Further, we have found no evidence of sustained, attached leading edge vorticity (LEV) during up or downstroke, as has been seen in similarly-sized insects - although a transient LEV is produced during the rapid change in angle of attack at the end of the downstroke. Finally, although an extended-wing upstroke during forward flight has long been thought to produce lift and negative thrust, we found circulation during downstroke alone to be sufficient to support body weight, and that some positive thrust was produced during upstroke, as evidenced by a vortex pair shed into the wake of all upstrokes at speeds of 4 - 12 m s-1.
Content may be subject to copyright.
American Institute of Aeronautics and Astronautics
1
The Aerodynamics of Hummingbird Flight
Douglas R. Warrick
*
and Bret W. Tobalske.
Oregon State University, Corvallis Oregon 97331 and University of Portland, Portland OR 97203
Donald R. Powers
George Fox University, Newburg, OR 97132
and
Michael H. Dickinson
§
California Institute of Technology, Pasadena, CA 91125
[Abstract] Hummingbirds fly with their wings almost fully extended during their entire
wingbeat. This pattern, associated with having proportionally short humeral bones, long
distal wing elements, and assumed to be an adaptation for extended hovering flight, has lead
to predictions that the aerodynamic mechanisms exploited by hummingbirds during
hovering should be similar to those observed in insects. To test these predictions, we flew
rufous hummingbirds (Selasphorus rufus, 3.3 g, n = 6) in a variable–speed wind tunnel (0-12
ms
-1
) and measured wake structure and dynamics using digital particle image velocimetry
(DPIV). Unlike hovering insects, hummingbirds produced 75% of their weight support
during downstroke and only 25% during upstroke, an asymmetry due to the inversion of
their cambered wings during upstroke. Further, we have found no evidence of sustained,
attached leading edge vorticity (LEV) during up or downstroke, as has been seen in
similarly-sized insects - although a transient LEV is produced during the rapid change in
angle of attack at the end of the downstroke. Finally, although an extended-wing upstroke
during forward flight has long been thought to produce lift and negative thrust, we found
circulation during downstroke alone to be sufficient to support body weight, and that some
positive thrust was produced during upstroke, as evidenced by a vortex pair shed into the
wake of all upstrokes at speeds of 4 – 12 m s
-1
.
I. Introduction
ITH a few exceptional intersections, the evolution of human-engineered flight and the study of the evolution
of animal flight have been essentially parallel. Given the results of the earliest such meetings (e.g.,
DaVinci’s ornithopter), this has probably been for the best; the disparity in scale between these lineages and
its effects on structural and fluid mechanics has necessarily cloistered these two fields and prevented further fruitless
and dangerous intercourse. However, interest in the development of micro-air-vehicles (MAVs) has thrown a
debutante ball, and it would seem that the convergence, the meeting and mixing of these lines – now working at
similar scales and Reynolds numbers (Re) – could produce useful offspring. The key to the viability of such
products will be determining which of those characteristics described for biological fliers are results of natural
selection, rather than results of ancestry. That is, the utility of our understanding of biological flight to the
engineering community rests upon our ability to determine adaptation – a question fundamental to biologists.
Certainly, some of the loveliest of biological models to walk onto the dance floor are the hummingbirds. Possessing
the right range of sizes (from 2-20 grams), unmatched aerial performance for animals of those sizes, along with
important research intangibles (i.e., tractability and warmth), hummingbirds seem likely sources of useful design
*
Assistant Professor, Department of Zoology, 3029 Cordley Hall.
Associate Professor, Department of Biology, 5000 N Willamette Blvd.
Professor and Chair, Department of Biology, 414 N. Meridian Street.
§
Esther M. and Abe M. Zarem Professor of Bioengineering, Division of Biology, 1200 E California Blvd.
W
American Institute of Aeronautics and Astronautics
2
seeds – places for engineers to start. The purpose of this paper is to describe what is currently known of the
biomechanics and aerodynamics of hummingbirds, placed in an evolutionary context that will allow those who
might use these animals as models to assess those mechanisms as worthy of emulation.
II. Hovering Flight: Lessons from Convergence?
Thirty-three years after the first rigorous treatment of
hummingbird flight by Stolpe and Zimmer in 1939
1
, describing
the kinematics of hovering, Weis-Fogh (1972)
2
developed an
aerodynamic model of hummingbird flight, noting its
similarities to insect flight. Although the fruit flies operated at
Re considerably lower than those of the hummingbirds, their
kinematic similarities led to the assumption
2,3,4,
that the
aerodynamic mechanisms were also similar – most notably in
that the two halves of the wingbeat cycle were roughly similar
in aerodynamic force production. More recently, flow
visualization and dynamically-scaled robotic simulations of
insect flight
5,6
demonstrated that the half-strokes of insects
similar in size to hummingbirds, were indeed aerodynamically
active and equal, and that lift was generated through leading-
edge vorticity (LEV) attached to the dorsal surface of the
translating wing. Hummingbird wings, modeled as flat plates
and flown in a dynamically-scaled robot, produced similar
LEVs and symmetrical force when flown at kinematic angles of
attack observed in hovering hummingbirds (Fig.1). The
inferences it made to hummingbird flight were clear and
compelling; the demonstration of convergence, from two such
long-diverged evolutionary lines, on the same locomotor
mechanism would make a profound statement to MAV
engineers: there’s only one way to hover a small, flapping
vehicle.
We tested the assumptions of half-stroke symmetry using 2-D
digital particle image velocimetry (DPIV), sampling the wake
of hummingbirds in both the frontal and parasagittal plane (see
Appendix) allowing us to capture tip and starting/ending
vorticity respectively. We found that hummingbirds exhibit
marked asymmetry in lift force production, with 75% of the
body weight lift support being generated during the downstroke
– in essence, about half-way from the typical bird condition
(100% of lift during the downstroke) and the typical insect
7
(Fig.2). Given the respective wing speeds and areas of the two
half-strokes, we concluded that this asymmetry was at least in
part due to the positive camber of the hummingbird wing,
which does not completely reverse during upstroke. However,
the far-field wake, remarkably similar to that produced by
hawkmoths
6
(Fig. 3) did suggest that LEVs were present during
at least the downstroke, and that hummingbirds might be true
hovering chimeras. While it seemed certain that leading-edge
vorticity was formed at some point during the downstroke, the
question of the intent and purpose of such flow remained.
Preliminary examination of the near-field flow around
hummingbird wings during both half-strokes reveals that no
attached, stable leading-edge vorticity is developed during the
Figure 2. Frontal plane vorticity (Rot Z [dx/dy]) field
of a hovering hummingbird. Upper vortex pair (a) are
tip vortices from upstroke; lower pair were produced
by the previous downstroke.
Figure 3. Parasagittal plane vorticity. (Rot Z
[dx/dy]) field of a hovering hummingbird. Upper
vortex (a) is the starting vortex of upstroke; (b) putative
LEV, produced by the rapid pitch up of the wing; (c)
ending vortex of downstroke.
Figure 1. DPIV vector field. Flow around a
dynamically-scaled robotic simulation of hummingbird
wings. Wings were modeled as flat plates; angle of
incidence = 15
o
. Note clockwise attached LEV above
wing.
b. 8282300 s
-1
a. 2827130 s
-1
8718780 s
-1
1005040 s
-1
b. 8282300 s
-1
a. 2827130 s
-1
8718780 s
-1
1005040 s
-1
a.
b.
c.
a.
b.
c.
American Institute of Aeronautics and Astronautics
3
majority of the wing translation (Fig. 4); that is, the flow is essentially laminar, and typical lifting line aerodynamics
probably explain the majority of lift production. The vorticity seen in the far-field wake would seem to be a result
of a transient LEV produced by the rapidly-pitching airfoil at the end of the downstroke – an effect typical of a
dynamically-stalling airfoil. However, the flow at the leading edge of the wing is not entirely typical; in particular,
the stagnation point of the airflow is deep – several millimeters back from the leading edge on the ventral side of the
wing. The movement of air from this ventral point, around the leading edge to the dorsal surface of the wing
ostensibly creates a vortex with a center at the anatomical leading edge of the wing. In outward appearance, this
flow is similar to that around the leading edge of fixed (i.e, gliding) swift wings
8
, but due to the differences in wing
presentation (strongly swept in the swift versus straight in the hummingbird) the equivalence of these structures
cannot be determined.
The observed difference in flow between the robotic model and
real hummingbird wing (Figs. 1, 4) may have several origins;
the two most immediately recognizable are both a result of the
effects of camber. As previously suggested, the greater lift
coefficients generated by cambered wing of the real bird
generated greater downwash during downstroke, forming the
basis of half-stroke disparity. This greater downwash also
lowers the effective angle of attack; the 25
o
-30
o
angle of
incidence in early downstroke is reduced to 9
o
-15
o
when a near-
field downwash of 3 ms
-1
is incorporated into the calculation of
angle of incidence. The flow around a flat plate at this angle
may be more similar to the observed flow around hummingbird
wings.
The aerodynamic properties of feathers cannot be discounted as
a source of the unique flow around hummingbird wings, and
studies of the effects of the microstructure of feathers on
boundary-layer interactions – either through surface ‘tripping’
or airfoil transmissivity, are probably warranted.
III. Forward flight
While the advantages of leaving the wing
extended during the upstroke during
hovering are clear, there are good
theoretical reasons
4,9
, and some
experimental evidence
10,11
to suggest it
may be a liability at low forward flight
speeds and during acceleration. During
upstroke, the supinated wing should
produce a lift force with a rearward vector
component, producing negative thrust,
adding to the profile drag already produced
by the wing. Thus, most small birds flex
their wings during the upstroke, completely
ceasing lift production and avoiding these
aerodynamic penalties
12
– which, for small
birds, with relatively low inertia, may be
severe. Perhaps owning to the anatomical
commitment to hovering flight,
hummingbirds leave their wings extended
during upstroke at all flight speeds. The
far-field wake of hummingbirds indicates
that lift production indeed continues
-20 0 0
2000
Vort icit y (s
-1
)
5cm
Downstroke
Down
a
b
c
d
Figure 5. Wake of a hummingbird. Forward flight, (6 ms
-1
). Note the
downstroke starting (a) and ending vortices (b), and the vortex pair,
hypothetically a result of a secondary ‘post-ending’ vortex at mid-
upstroke (c )and a ‘pre-starting’ vortex (d) produced in quick
succession. The interaction of this vortex pair suggests thrust
production.
Figure 4. Flow around a hummingbird wing.
DPIV vector field of flow around a hummingbird
mid-wing at mid-downstroke. Red line indicates the
position of the chord x-section, moving left to right.
Note the absence of dynamic stall vorticity, present
in the robotic simulation (Fig. 1), above the wing.
American Institute of Aeronautics and Astronautics
4
throughout the upstroke; however, there is little to suggest that negative thrust is produced during this type of
upstroke. Indeed, the shedding of a vortex pair at mid-to-late upstroke, coinciding with the point in the upstroke
where the speed of the upward translation of the wing has reduced angle of incidence to zero (Fig. 5), suggests that
some thrust may be generated during this portion of the wingbeat cycle. The strength and utility – and ubiquity
among other birds with aerodynamically active upstrokes - of this mechanism to hummingbirds have yet to be
determined, but it is probably insufficient to overcome the aerodynamic costs of active upstrokes in birds (or MAVs)
with larger wings. Evidence from the anatomy and performance of swifts
10
suggests that unusually large pectoral
muscles (and, hence, particularly strong downstrokes for thrust production) are required to overcome the costs
incurred by stiff wings and active upstrokes.
IV. Conclusion
DPIV analysis of live birds and robotic simulations suggests that for thin wings at low Re, cambered airfoils
generate greater lift coefficients than flat plates (or other such symmetrical sections), and it seems likely that the
asymmetry in the half-strokes of hovering hummingbirds is clearly an artifact of its avian ancestry – ancestors for
which the downstroke (or just a wing extended in glide) was the only lift generating portion of the wingbeat cycle.
Given that symmetry in lift production offers some advantages (e.g., more continuous availability of lift force for
needs of maneuvering; smaller vertical oscillations in body movement between the half-strokes), there would be
little use in incorporating this particular aspect of hummingbird flight into a MAV. However, emulating the rigid
and kinematically simple wing of hummingbirds may be extremely useful, given its performance over a range of
speeds.
Appendix
A. Circulation and Weight Support
To compute vorticity (ω, s
-1
), we post-processed
vector fields using a median filter, and then computed
rot z[dy/dx]. We measured circulation (Γ, m
2
s
-1
) in the
trailing tip vortices by integrating ω with respect to area
(m
2
). We limited our analysis to views where vortex
cores were normal to the sampling plane (parasagittal:
centered at midwing; frontal: centered at wing root). We
tested whether observed Γ was sufficient to support
body weight by comparing Γ with circulation required
(Γ
ο
) = WT / ρS where W is body weight (N), T is time
per wingbeat (s), and S is the projected horizontal area
swept by the two wings (m
2
)
13
.
B. Kinematics
Separate flight trials (n = 4 birds) were
recorded using two synchronized high speed digital
video cameras operating at 500 Hz sampling and shutter
speed of 1/1000 s. We merged two-dimensional
coordinates from each camera into a single 3-d
coordinate space using the direct linear transformation
(DLT) coefficients derived from a 16-point calibration
frame
14
. Using these data, we calculated angular
velocity of the wing (rad s
-1
) and angle of attack of the
mid-wing (degrees) relative to incurrent air flow.
Incurrent air velocity was the sum of translational
Figure 6. Position of Hummingbirds hovering. DPIV
laser light sheet illustrating the frontal (a,b) and
parasagittal (c,d) sampling planes and revealed wake
structures.
American Institute of Aeronautics and Astronautics
5
velocity of the wing and average 3-d air velocity computed using DPIV data from frontal and sagittal planes, which
is dominated by a mean downward velocity of 1.1 ms
-1
.
Acknowledgments
We thank Dr. Andrew Johnson, AHPCRC, Dr. Steve Anderson, LaVision Inc., Dr. Ty Hedrick, UNC Chapel
Hill, Beth Klopfenstein, George Fox University, Gabe Hyder and John Ranola, University of Portland, Will
Dickson, California Institute of Technology, and Doug Altshuler, UC Riverside. Supported by NSF IBN 0327380
and IOB 0615648.
References
1
Stolpe, V. M. & Zimmer, K. “Der schwirrflug des kolibri im zeitlupenfilm,” J. feur Ornith. Vol. 87, 1939, pp. 136-155
2
Weis-Fogh, T. “Energetics of hovering flight in hummingbirds and in Drosophila,” J. Exp. Biol. Vol. 56, 1972, pp. 79–104
3
Greenwalt, C. H. “The wings of insects and birds as mechanical oscillators,” Proc. Amer. Phil. Soc. Vol. 104, 1960, pp.
605-611
4
Norberg, U. M. Vertebrate Flight: Mechanics, Physiology, Morphology, Ecology, And Evolution. Springer-Verlag, Berlin
1990
5
Wilmott, A. P. & Ellington, C. P. “The mechanics of flight in the hawkmoth Manduca sexta II. Aerodynamic consequences of
kinematic and morphological variation,” J. Exp. Biol. Vol. 200, 1997,
pp. 2723-2745
6
van den Berg, C., & Ellington, C. P. “The vortex wake of a ‘hovering’ model hawkmoth,” Phil. Trans. R. Soc. Lond. B Vol.
352, 1997,
pp. 329–340
6
Ellington, C. P. “The aerodynamics of hovering insect flight. V. A vortex theory,” Phil. Trans. R. Soc. Lond. B Vol. 305,
1984,
pp. 79-113
7
Warrick, D. R., , Tobalske, B. W., and Powers, D. R. “Aerodynamics of the hovering hummingbird,” Nature, Vol. 435, 2005,
pp.1094-1097.
8
Videler, J. J., Stamhuis, E. J., and Povel, G. D. E. “Leading-edge vortex lifts swifts,” Science, Vol. 306, 2004, pp. 1960-1962.
9
Spedding, G. R., “The wake of a kestrel (Falco tinnunculus) in flapping flight,” J. Exp. Biol., Vol. 127, 1987, pp. 69-78.
10
Warrick, D. R. “The turning and linear maneuvering performance of birds: the cost of efficiency for coursing insectivores.
Can. J. Zool. Vol. 76, 1998, pp. 1063-1079.
11
Hedrick, T. L., Usherwood, J. R., and Biewener, A. A. “Wing inertia and whole-body acceleration: an analysis of
instantaneous dynamic force production in cockatiels (Nymphicus hollandicus) flying across a range of speeds.J. Exp. Biol.
Vol. 207, 2002, pp. 1689-1702.
12
Tobalske, B. W., Hedrick, T. L. & Biewener, A. A. “Wing kinematics of avian flight across speeds.,” J. Avian Biol. Vol. 34,
2003,
pp. 177-184
13
Spedding, G. R., Hendenstrom, A. & Rosen, M. “Quantitative studies of the wakes of freely flying birds in a low-turbulence
wind tunnel,” Exp. Fluids Vol. 34, 2003,
pp. 291-303
14
Hedrick, T. L., Tobalske, B. W. & Biewener, A. A. “Estimates of gait change based on a three-dimensional analysis of flight in
cockatiels (Nymphicus hollandicus) and ringed turtle doves (Stretopelia risoria).,” J. Exp. Biol. Vol. 205, 2002,
pp. 1389-1409
... Substantial research has been carried out on understanding the flight mechanism of flying creatures as well as FWAVs. In order to understand the flight mechanism of flying birds and bats, computational fluid dynamic (CFD) simulations and wind tunnel tests have been performed [1][2][3][4]. Mulijres et al. [1] measured the flapping motion of a small nectar-feeding bat with the digital particle image velocimetry (DPIV) technic. Strong leading-edge vortices (LEV) can be observed at the front of the wing which contributes more than 40% of the total lift. ...
... Strong leading-edge vortices (LEV) can be observed at the front of the wing which contributes more than 40% of the total lift. Warrick and Tobalske [2] also equipped the DPIV technic to investigate the wake structure and dynamics of hummingbirds at different flight speeds. Riskin et al. [3] made a comparison of flight kinematics of 27 bats in six pteropodid species. ...
Article
Full-text available
In this work, we use a three-dimensional computational fluid dynamics (CFD) simulation to comprehend how the two wing arrangement variables, i.e., inner/outer wing proportion and mid-stroke dihedral, affect the lift characteristic of a bat-inspired span foldable flapping wing. The employed flapping mechanism is based on previous work. In this study, the structure parameters of the flapping mechanism remain unchanged across all simulations. Based on the CFD results, the tendency and work point regarding maximum lift generation can be found by changing both of the variables. As a result, when modifying the inner/outer wing proportion without changing the total wing shape and area, the maximum time-averaged lift appears in the case of the inner wing occupying half of the semi-span. In addition, when changing the dihedral, the maximum time-averaged lift was obtained when the inner wing dihedral was equal to zero. To discuss the lift variation of the foldable flapping wing, pressure distribution and vorticity of the flow field at certain time points were provided corresponding to the instantaneous lift curves. The conclusions of this research are able to help understand the wing arrangement of birds and bats issued from natural selection, and also support the future design of flapping wing micro-aerial-vehicles.
... The positive camber exhibited by the bird was primarily the reason behind this asymmetrical distribution in lift generation and also its inability to reverse during the up-stroke. The airfoil of a hummingbird also acts as a dynamic stalling airfoil [26] [1]. For the purpose of extraction of the involved wing kinematics, anatomical landmarks are located in the form of proximal plane and the distal planes on the primary feathers as well as the secondary ones. ...
Article
Full-text available
This review tends to shed light on the eagle's aerodynamic attributes along with its inbuilt structural control surfaces that facilitate its high maneuverability. Apart from this, few aspects of the eagle's wing morphing techniques, its aerofoil, and its aerodynamic stability are also being highlighted. The aim is to highlight the bio-mimicable traits of an eagle which can be incorporated into bionic UAVs. This work acts as a base for current and future works involving slotted wingtips and bionic control surfaces. The traits discussed are being used to design mechanical control surfaces and wingtips that resemble the eagle's slotted wings and control surfaces. These works when combined with compliant mechanisms can help improve roll and yaw control of a UAV along with drag reduction. This review also highlights the aerodynamics of flapping; specifically of the hummingbird. From the hummingbird's aerodynamics to its hovering techniques; all of its main features are being highlighted. These birds have demonstrated a wide range of aerodynamic traits which if mimicked to near perfection could pave the way for new-age drones. Maneuverability and enhanced aerodynamic optimality could be the outset of extreme sustainability measures with these birds paving the way with their evolutionary flight measures. Apart from their aerodynamic traits, a few aspects of their wing morphing techniques and their evolutionary hereditary traits are also being highlighted.
... 7(b) that the attached vortex of the turbine under fluctuating wind is closer to the blade surface, which indicates that the turbine under fluctuating wind has better delay stall mechanism. According to the study on the bird flight by LIANG and DONG[18]and also WARRICK[19], the delay stall is the reason why the birds produce larger aerodynamic force(the Reynolds number Re of the bird flight is similar to the VAWT considered in this work), which indicates that the unsteady working mechanic of VAWT is similar to the birds flight. This conclusion is consist with the opinion proposed by WORASINCHAI et al[20]. ...
Article
The present work deals with an investigation of the self-starting aerodynamic characteristics of VAWT under fluctuating wind. In contrast to the previous studies, the rotational speed of the turbine is not fixed, the rotation of the turbine is determined by the dynamic interaction between the fluctuating wind and turbine. A weak coupling method is developed to simulate the dynamic interaction between the fluctuating wind and passive rotation turbine, and the results show that if the fluctuating wind with appropriate fluctuation amplitude and frequency, the self-starting aerodynamic characteristics of VAWT will be enhanced. It is also found that compared with the fluctuation amplitude, the fluctuation frequency of the variation in wind velocity is shown to have a minor effect on the performance of the turbine. The analysis will provide straightforward physical insight into the self-starting aerodynamic characteristics of VAWT under fluctuating wind. © 2016, Central South University Press and Springer-Verlag Berlin Heidelberg.
... It is also found in Fig. 7(b) that the attached vortex of the turbine under fluctuating wind is closer to the blade surface, which indicates that the turbine under fluctuating wind has better delay stall mechanism. According to the study on the bird flight by LIANG and DONG [18] and also WARRICK [19], the delay stall is the reason why the birds produce larger aerodynamic force(the Reynolds number Re of the bird flight is similar to the VAWT considered in this work), which indicates that the unsteady working mechanic of VAWT is similar to the birds flight. This conclusion is consist with the opinion proposed by WORASINCHAI et al [20]. ...
Article
The solid state transformer (SST) can be viewed as an energy router in energy internet. This work presents sliding mode control (SMC) to improve dynamic state and steady state performance of a three-stage (rectifier stage, isolated stage and inverter stage) SST for energy internet. SMC with three-level hysteresis sliding functions is presented to control the input current of rectifier stage and output voltage of inverter stage to improve the robustness under external disturbance and parametric uncertainties and reduce the switching frequency. A modified feedback linearization technique using isolated stage simplified model is presented to achieve satisfactory regulation of output voltage of the isolated stage. The system is tested for steady state operation, reactive power control, dynamic load change and voltage sag simulations, respectively. The switching model of SST is implemented in Matlab/ Simulink to verify the SST control algorithms.
... The only available information about these turns comes from other species like gliding or flapping birds, and hovering insects [5,13,3,2,10,6]. These animals are very different since hummingbird is entailed with simple wings that operate over a larger range of speeds [11]. ...
Article
Full-text available
We propose a new method to analyse and charac-terise the hummingbird wing dynamics using statistical measures from an optical flow field. The method starts by computing a dense optical flow, using a multi-scale spatial representation. First the pixels with larger velocities are retained as the support of the flow field, formed by the wings motion. Then, the global angular velocity is calculated as a function of the time during the hummingbird stroke. Additionally, each wing is segmented and the spatial variance of the velocity orientation is computed, providing the instants of principal stroke deformation. Finally a local measure of orientation deviation allows to localise the region of maximal torsion. Preliminary results show a compact and coherent description of the hovering flight dynamics of the hummingbird.
... In many cases however, the only available information about these turns comes from other species like the gliding or flight patterns observed in insects [5], [6], [7], [8], [10], [11]. However these animals are actually very different since they are entailed with simple wings that operate over a larger range of speeds [9] and are supported by an outer skeleton. In addition, while birds roll their body to orient the wing forces, insects can easily turn by asymmetric left-right wingbeats [4], [45], [34], [35] . ...
Article
Full-text available
A new method for automatic analysis and characterization of recorded hummingbird wing motion is proposed. The method starts by computing a multiscale dense optical flow field, which is used to segment the wings, i.e., pixels with larger velocities. Then, the kinematic and deformation of the wings were characterized as a temporal set of global and local measures: a global angular acceleration as a time function of each wing and a local acceleration profile that approximates the dynamics of the different wing segments. Additionally, the variance of the apparent velocity orientation estimates those wing foci with larger deformation. Finally a local measure of the orientation highlights those regions with maximal deformation. The approach was evaluated in a total of 91 flight cycles, captured using three different setups. The proposed measures follow the yaw turn hummingbird flight dynamics, with a strong correlation of all computed paths, reporting a standard deviation of 0.31 rad / frame 2 > and 1.9 ( rad / frame ) 2 > for the global angular acceleration and the global wing deformation respectively.
Article
Full-text available
In this paper, the interpretation of hovering flight for hummingbirds is firstly presented and discussed from a hummingbird morphology perspective (muscle and skeleton) including weight distribution, followed by a discussion of hovering aerodynamics. Next, by studying the scale laws, geometry similarity, and statistical analysis on wing parameters, the parametric relation between wing performances and weight is achieved before applying in wing design of flapping wing micro autonomous drones (FWMADs). The efficiency of designed wing based on the scaling law is verified by flying test. Designed wings based on different materials and methods are summarized. Last, the morphology of bird’s tails is presented, and then the designed tails inspired by hummingbirds are introduced before tail performances are also discussed simply. The results show that the tail could be predicted to apply to the stability of hovering twin-wing FWMADs. The current studies provide a simple but powerful guideline for biologists and engineers who study the morphology of hummingbirds and design FWMADs.
Article
The flight dynamics of flapping-wing micro air vehicles result from a complicated relationship between aerodynamics and structural dynamics. This relationship has both frequency-domain aspects and time-domain aspects that are each critical. As such, analyzing data from a flapping wing requires techniques that can process information related to both of these domains. This paper introduces wavelet analysis as a tool that determine the frequency content of time-varying deflections. The resulting wavelet map presents a time-frequency domain representation that relates both the time-domain aspects and frequency-domain aspects. Data is analyzed using wavelet processing from a set of wings with different structural dynamics and different flapping parameters whose responses in the vertical and span-wise directions are recorded using digital image correlation. The resulting wavelet maps demonstrate the variations in energy content and temporal distribution associated with the deflections.
Article
Full-text available
Variable camber deformation is observed during the flight of some insects and bird species; however, the effect of this special airfoil shape motion on the aerodynamic characteristics of the airfoil is not well understood, especially for the airfoil under gust wind. We did a numerical study to investigate the aerodynamic characteristics of a variable camber plunge airfoil under wind gusts. A weak coupling program was developed to simulate the interaction between the variable camber plunge airfoil and fluid, and the flow field, aerodynamic force and energy efficiency of different camber airfoils under different wind gust conditions are investigated. It was found that camber deformation influences the aerodynamic characteristics of the airfoil greatly. If the airfoil has an appropriate camber deformation, the deformation can increase the mean thrust and the propulsive efficiency of the airfoil. Moreover, the aerodynamic characteristics of the appropriate camber airfoils are not significantly affected by the gust frequency, and there exists a range of gust amplitude where the aerodynamic characteristics of the airfoils are also not significantly affected by the gust amplitude, which may be beneficial for aerodynamic stability of the airfoil. The results also show that appropriate camber deformation can suppress leading edge vortex separation, which improves the aerodynamic characteristics of the airfoil. © 2015, The Korean Society of Mechanical Engineers and Springer-Verlag Berlin Heidelberg.
Conference Paper
Full-text available
The state of the art of flapping wing ornithopter MAV is reviewed to provide a comprehensive insight into the geometrical, ki nematic and aerodynamic characteristics of flapping biosystems. Then a generic approach is carried out to model the kinematics and aerodynamics of ornithopter to mimic flapping wing to produce lift and thrust for hovering and forward flight, by considering the motion of a three-dimensional rigid thin wing in flapping and pitching motion, using simple approach, applied to a two-and quad-wing flapping ornithopter, which are modeled and analyzed to mimic flapping wing biosystem to produce lift and thrust for forward flight. Considering bird's scale ornithopter, basic unsteady aerodynamic approach incorporating salient features of viscous effect and leading-edge suction are utilized. Parametric study is carried out to reveal the aerodynamic characteristics of flapping quad-wing ornithopter flight characteristics and for comparative analysis with various selected simple models in the literature, in an effort to de velop a flapping wing ornithopter model. Further, numerical and flow visualization studies are carried out to simulate the aerodynamics of generic rigid and flexible flapping ornithopter wings. Two different solvers are utilized; FLUENT for fluid flow analysis and ABAQUS for structural analysis. The resulting coupled procedure retains second order temporal accuracy. The simulation of phenomena of aeroelasticity is performed with a FSI method.
Article
Full-text available
Recent flow visualization experiments with the hawkmoth, Manduca sexta, revealed a small but clear leading-edge vortex and a pronounced three-dimensional flow. Details of this flow pattern were studied with a scaled-up, robotic insect ('the flapper') that accurately mimicked the wing movements of a hovering hawkmoth. Smoke released from the leading edge of the flapper wing confirmed the existence of a small, strong and stable leading-edge vortex, increasing in size from wingbase to wingtip. Between 25 and 75% of the wing length, its diameter increased approximately from 10 to 50% of the wing chord. The leading-edge vortex had a strong axial flow velocity, which stabilized it and reduced its diameter. The vortex separated from the wing at approximately 75% of the wing length and thus fed vorticity into a large, tangled tip vortex. If the circulation of the leading-edge vortex were fully used for lift generation, it could support up to two-thirds of the hawkmoth's weight during the downstroke. The growth of this circulation with time and spanwise position clearly identify dynamic stall as the unsteady aerodynamic mechanism responsible for high lift production by hovering hawkmoths and possibly also by many other insect species.
Article
Full-text available
Visualization experiments with Manduca sexta have revealed the presence of a leading-edge vortex and a highly three-dimensional flow pattern. To further investigate this important discovery, a scaled-up robotic insect was built (the 'flapper') which could mimic the complex movements of the wings of a hovering hawkmoth. Smoke released from the leading edge of the flapper wing revealed a small but strong leading-edge vortex on the downstroke. This vortex had a high axial flow velocity and was stable, separating from the wing at approximately 75% of the wing length. It connected to a large, tangled tip vortex, extending back to a combined stopping and starting vortex from pronation. At the end of the downstroke, the wake could be approximated as one vortex ring per wing. Based on the size and velocity of the vortex rings, the mean lift force during the downstroke was estimated to be about 1.5 times the body weight of a hawkmoth, confirming that the downstroke is the main provider of lift force.
Article
Full-text available
The structure of the wake behind a kestrel in medium-speed flight down a 36 m length of corridor was analysed qualitatively and quantitatively by stereophoto-grammetry of multiple flash photographs of the motion of small soap-covered helium bubbles. The wake consists of a pair of continuous, undulating trailing vortices. The upstroke is therefore aerodynamically active and the circulation appears to remain constant along the wing whose geometry is altered during the course of the wing-stroke. It is argued that the flight kinematics, and so the wake structure, of the kestrel may be typical of flapping flight at medium speeds and a flight model based on this wake geometry is presented. Rough estimates of the rate of momentum generated in the wake balance the weight almost exactly and a direct estimate of the induced power requirement from the wake measurements is obtained. The significance of these results for the various alternative aerodynamic descriptions and energetic predictions of models of flapping animal flight is briefly assessed.
Article
To examine the performance compromises necessitated by adaptations for high efficiency in flight, such as high aspect ratio wings, the flight morphology and acceleration performance of a guild of coursing aerial insectivores (swifts and swallows) were compared with those of a guild of avian generalists. Though phylogenetic non-independence made inference of adaptation difficult, biologically significant differences in aspect ratio and acceleration performance probably exist between the two groups of birds. A model of aerial insectivory is presented to illustrate the performance demands of this foraging method and the impacts of the compromises between high efficiency in sustained flight and turning- and linear-maneuvering performance.
Article
Theoretical considerations and available experimental studies are combined for a discussion on the aerodynamic mechanisms of lift generation in hovering animal flight. A comparison of steady-state thin-aerofoil theory with measured lift coefficients reveals that leading edge separation bubbles are likely to be a prominent feature in insect flight. Insect wings show a gradual stall that is characteristic for thin profiles at Reynolds numbers (Re) less than about 105. In this type of stall, flow separates at the sharp leading edge and then re-attaches downstream to the upper wing surface, producing a region of limited separation enclosing a recirculating flow. The resulting leading edge bubble enhances the camber and thickness of the thin profile, improving lift at low Re. Some of the results for bird wing profiles indicate that the complications of leading edge bubbles might even be found in the fast forward flight of birds.
Article
A full derivation is presented for the vortex theory of hovering flight outlined in preliminary reports. The theory relates the lift produced by flapping wings to the induced velocity and power of the wake. Suitable forms of the momentum theory are combined with the vortex approach to reduce the mathematical complexity as much as possible. Vorticity is continuously shed from the wings in sympathy with changes in wing circulation. The vortex sheet shed during a half-stroke convects downwards with the induced velocity field, and should be approximately planar at the end of a half-stroke. Vorticity within the sheet will roll up into complicated vortex rings, but the rate of this process is unknown. The exact state of the sheet is not crucial to the theory, however, since the impulse and energy of the vortex sheet do not change as it rolls up, and the theory is derived on the assumption that the extent of roll-up is negligible. The force impulse required to generate the sheet is derived from the vorticity of the sheet, and the mean wing lift is equal to that impulse divided by the period of generation. This method of calculating the mean lift is suitable for unsteady aerodynamic lift mechanisms as well as the quasi-steady mechanism. The relation between the mean lift and the impulse of the resulting vortex sheet is used to develop a conceptual artifice - a pulsed actuator disc - that approximates closely the net effect of the complicated lift forces produced in hovering. T he disc periodically applies a pressure impulse over some defined area, and is a generalized form of the Froude actuator disc from propeller theory. The pulsed disc provides a convenient link between circulatory lift and the powerful momentum and vortex analyses of the wake. The induced velocity and power of the wake are derived in stages, starting with the simple Rankine-Froude theory for the wake produced by a Froude disc applying a uniform, continuous pressure to the air. The wake model is then improved by considering a ‘modified’ Froude disc exerting a continuous, but non-uniform pressure. This step provides a spatial correction factor for the Rankine-Froude theory, by taking into account variations in pressure and circulation over the disc area. Finally, the wake produced by a pulsed Froude disc is analysed, and a temporal correction factor is derived for the periodic application of spatially uniform pressures. Both correction factors are generally small, and can be treated as independent perturbations of the Rankine-Froude model. Thus the corrections can be added linearly to obtain the total correction for the general case of a pulsed actuator disc with spatial and temporal pressure variations. The theory is compared with Rayner’s vortex theory for hovering flight. Under identical test conditions, numerical results from the two theories agree to within 3%. Rayner presented approximations from his results to be used when applying his theory to hovering animals. These approximations are not consistent with my theory or with classical propeller theory, and reasons for the discrepancy are suggested.
Article
Expressions have been derived for an estimate of the average coefficient of lift, for the variation in bending moment or torque caused by wind forces and by inertia forces, and for the power output during hovering flight on one spot when the wings move according to a horizontal figure-of-eight. In both hummingbirds and Drosophila the flight is consistent with steady-state aerodynamics, the average lift coefficient being 1·8 in the hummingbird and o-8 in Drosophila. The aerodynamic or hydraulic efficiency is 0·5 in the hummingbird and 0·3 in Drosophila, and in both types the aerodynamic power output is 22–24 cal/g body weight/h. The total mechanical power output is 39 cal g−1 h−1 in the hummingbird because of the extra energy needed to accelerate the wing-mass. It is 24 cal g−1 h−1 in Drosophila in which the inertia term is negligible because the wing-stroke frequency is reduced to the lowest possible value for sustained flight. In both animals the mechanical efficiency of the flight muscles is 0·2. It is argued that the tilt of the stroke plane relative to the horizontal is an adaptation to the geometrically unfavourable induced wind and to the relatively large lift/drag ratio seen in many insects. The vertical movements at the extreme ends may serve to reduce the interaction between the shed ‘stopping’ vortex and the new bound vortex of opposite sense which has to be built up during the early part of the return stroke. Two additional non-steady flow situations may exist at either end of the stroke, delayed stall and delayed build-up of circulation (Wagner effect), but since they have opposite effects it is probable that the resultant force is of about the same magnitude as that estimated for a steady-state situation. Most insects have an effective elastic system to counteract the adverse effect of wing-inertia, but small fast-moving vertebrates have not. It is argued that the only material available for this purpose in this group is elastin and that it is unsuited at the rates of deformation required because recent measurements have shown that the damping is relatively high, probably due to molecular factors.