ArticlePDF Available

A General Theory of Scientific/Intellectual Movements

DOI:10.1177/000312240507000202
Authors:
Scott Frickel at Brown University
Scott Frickel
Neil Gross
Neil Gross
Neil Gross
  • This person is not on ResearchGate, or hasn't claimed this research yet.
Download full-text PDF
Read full-text
Download citation

Abstract

The histories of all modern scientific and intellectual fields are marked by dynamism. Yet, despite a welter of case study data, sociologists of ideas have been slow to develop general theories for explaining why and how disciplines, subfields, theory groups, bandwagons, actor networks, and other kindred formations arise to alter the intellectual landscape. To fill this lacuna, this article presents a general theory of scientific/intellectual movements (SIMs). The theory synthesizes work in the sociology of ideas, social studies of science, and the literature on social movements to explain the dynamics of SIMs, which the authors take to be central mechanisms for change in the world of knowledge and ideas. Illustrating their arguments with a diverse sampling of positive and negative cases, they define SIMs, identify a set of theoretical presuppositions, and offer four general propositions for explaining the social conditions under which SIMs are most likely to emerge, gain prestige, and achieve some level of institutional stability.
Content uploaded by Scott Frickel
Author content
All content in this area was uploaded by Scott Frickel on May 20, 2014
Content may be subject to copyright.
Reproduced with permission of the copyright owner. Further reproduction prohibited without permission.
A General Theory of Scientific/Intellectual Movements
Scott Frickel; Neil Gross
American Sociological Review; Apr 2005; 70, 2; ABI/INFORM Global
pg. 204
Reproduced with permission of the copyright owner. Further reproduction prohibited without permission.
Reproduced with permission of the copyright owner. Further reproduction prohibited without permission.
Reproduced with permission of the copyright owner. Further reproduction prohibited without permission.
Reproduced with permission of the copyright owner. Further reproduction prohibited without permission.
Reproduced with permission of the copyright owner. Further reproduction prohibited without permission.
Reproduced with permission of the copyright owner. Further reproduction prohibited without permission.
Reproduced with permission of the copyright owner. Further reproduction prohibited without permission.
Reproduced with permission of the copyright owner. Further reproduction prohibited without permission.
Reproduced with permission of the copyright owner. Further reproduction prohibited without permission.
Reproduced with permission of the copyright owner. Further reproduction prohibited without permission.
Reproduced with permission of the copyright owner. Further reproduction prohibited without permission.
Reproduced with permission of the copyright owner. Further reproduction prohibited without permission.
Reproduced with permission of the copyright owner. Further reproduction prohibited without permission.
Reproduced with permission of the copyright owner. Further reproduction prohibited without permission.
Reproduced with permission of the copyright owner. Further reproduction prohibited without permission.
Reproduced with permission of the copyright owner. Further reproduction prohibited without permission.
Reproduced with permission of the copyright owner. Further reproduction prohibited without permission.
Reproduced with permission of the copyright owner. Further reproduction prohibited without permission.
Reproduced with permission of the copyright owner. Further reproduction prohibited without permission.
Reproduced with permission of the copyright owner. Further reproduction prohibited without permission.
Reproduced with permission of the copyright owner. Further reproduction prohibited without permission.
Reproduced with permission of the copyright owner. Further reproduction prohibited without permission.
Reproduced with permission of the copyright owner. Further reproduction prohibited without permission.
Reproduced with permission of the copyright owner. Further reproduction prohibited without permission.
Reproduced with permission of the copyright owner. Further reproduction prohibited without permission.
Reproduced with permission of the copyright owner. Further reproduction prohibited without permission.
Reproduced with permission of the copyright owner. Further reproduction prohibited without permission.
Reproduced with permission of the copyright owner. Further reproduction prohibited without permission.
... Quantifying the dynamics of scientific fields can help us understand the past and design the future of scientific knowledge production. Several studies have investigated the emergence and evolution of scientific fields, from the discovery of new concepts to their adaptation and modification by the scientific community [1][2][3][4][5][6], to the slow-down in their growth due to the ever rising number of publications [7]. In particular, methods ranging from bibliometric studies [8,9] to network analyses [6,10,11] and natural language processing [12][13][14] implemented on large publication corpora to monitor the propagation of concepts across articles [15][16][17] and the social interactions between researchers that are producing them [11,[18][19][20]. ...
... While fields rise and fall on different temporal and population scales, they are generally argued to pass through a common set of evolutionary stages [1,3], a process driven by consensus building within the scientific community and the discovery of new research fronts and the development of corresponding technologies [2,28]. Different stages are typified by micro-level changes in membership and behavior proposed to drive macro-level dynamics from birth to death. ...
Quantifying the rise and fall of scientific fields
Article
Full-text available
Science advances by pushing the boundaries of the adjacent possible. While the global scientific enterprise grows at an exponential pace, at the mesoscopic level the exploration and exploitation of research ideas are reflected through the rise and fall of research fields. The empirical literature has largely studied such dynamics on a case-by-case basis, with a focus on explaining how and why communities of knowledge production evolve. Although fields rise and fall on different temporal and population scales, they are generally argued to pass through a common set of evolutionary stages. To understand the social processes that drive these stages beyond case studies, we need a way to quantify and compare different fields on the same terms. In this paper we develop techniques for identifying common patterns in the evolution of scientific fields and demonstrate their usefulness using 1.5 million preprints from the arXiv repository covering 175 research fields spanning Physics, Mathematics, Computer Science, Quantitative Biology and Quantitative Finance. We show that fields consistently follow a rise and fall pattern captured by a two parameters right-tailed Gumbel temporal distribution. We introduce a field-specific re-scaled time and explore the generic properties shared by articles and authors at the creation, adoption, peak, and decay evolutionary phases. We find that the early phase of a field is characterized by disruptive works mixing of cognitively distant fields written by small teams of interdisciplinary authors, while late phases exhibit the role of specialized, large teams building on the previous works in the field. This method provides foundations to quantitatively explore the generic patterns underlying the evolution of research fields in science, with general implications in innovation studies.
... Although it is difficult to break out of standard ways of thinking, paradigms can shift. New paradigms emerge when there are doubts about prevailing approaches or grievances with dominant intellectual practices (Frickel and Gross 2005;Kuhn 1962). Moreover, "stories that are capable of countering the hegemonic are those which bridge, without denying, the particularities of experience and subjectivities and those which bear witness to what is unimagined and unexpressed" (Ewick and Silbey 1995:220). ...
Reducing the Joy Deficit in Sociology: A Study of Transgender Joy
Article
  • Jun 2022
Joy is a crucial element of people’s everyday lives that has been understudied by sociologists. This is particularly true for scholarship about transgender people. To address what we term a joy deficit in sociology, we analyze 40 in-depth interviews with trans people in which they were asked what they find joyful about being trans. Their responses demonstrate the methodological and theoretical importance of asking about joy. Four main themes emerged from the interviews. First, interviewees easily answered the question about joy. Second, contrary to common assumptions, we found that transgender people expressed joy in being members of a marginalized group and said that they preferred being transgender. Third, embracing a marginalized identity caused the quality of their lives to improve, increasing self-confidence, body positivity, and sense of peace. Finally, being from a marginalized group facilitated meaningful connections with other people. Our findings demonstrate a vital need to address the joy deficit that exists in the sociological scholarship on transgender people specifically, and marginalized groups more generally. Bridging the sociology of knowledge and narratives, we show how accentuating joy offers nuance to understandings of the lived experiences of marginalized people that has been absent from much of sociological scholarship.
... Les mouvements scientifiques et intellectuels dépendent de leaderships individuels de premier plan, dont la reconnaissance professionnelle facilite l'affirmation d'une posture hétérodoxe (Frickel et Gross, 2005). Le MAB-France n'échappe pas à cette logique de personnalisation qui repose sur la capacité fédératrice de quelques individus. ...
Quand la recherche transdisciplinaire en environnement promet/promeut un mode de gouvernement: genèse du programme "éco-acteurs" dans les Réserves de biosphère françaises
Article
Full-text available
  • Jan 2022
Cet article examine la façon dont un groupe de chercheurs français a importé les idées d'Elinor Ostrom, jusqu'à inspirer la naissance d'un programme de gestion dans les réserves de biosphère françaises. Promoteurs d'une philosophie participative visant à dépasser le dilemme État-marché, ces chercheurs ont proposé un modèle de gestion fondé sur l'engagement volontaire des communautés locales. La genèse du programme "éco-acteurs" permet d'analyser les opérations de traduction entre la phase d'exploration par les chercheurs et celle d'opérationnalisation par les gestionnaires, ainsi que les dynamiques de "co-production" entre science et politique. En effet, cet article démontre que la recherche transdisciplinaire en environnement promeut et promet de nouvelles formes de gouvernement qui, tout en cherchant des voies alternatives, s'insèrent dans un ordre néolibéral. À l'heure du "faire mieux avec moins", ces scientifiques ont défendu un type de gouvernement rendu théoriquement efficace et peu coûteux par les mécanismes de "contrôle social." Le programme "éco-acteurs" offre ainsi l'opportunité de confronter les principes théoriques d'Ostrom aux réalités de leur mise en œuvre locale, dans un contexte marqué par un manque généralisé de financements publics.
... Les mouvements scientifiques et intellectuels dépendent de leaderships individuels de premier plan, dont la reconnaissance professionnelle facilite l'affirmation d'une posture hétérodoxe (Frickel et Gross, 2005). Le MAB-France n'échappe pas à cette logique de personnalisation qui repose sur la capacité fédératrice de quelques individus. ...
When transdisciplinary environmental research promotes/promises a new mode of government. Genesis of the "eco-actors" programme in the French Biosphere Reserves.
Article
Full-text available
  • Apr 2022
This article examines how a group of Frenchresearchers imported Elinor Ostrom's ideas and inspired the birth of amanagement program in French biosphere reserves. Promoters of a participatoryphilosophy aimed at overcoming the State-market dilemma, these researchersproposed a management model based on the voluntary commitment of localcommunities. The genesis of the "eco-actors" program allows us toanalyze the translation operations between the exploration phase by researchersand the operationalization phase by managers, as well as the dynamics of"co-production" between science and politics. Indeed, this articledemonstrates that transdisciplinary environmental research promotes andpromises new forms of government that, while seeking alternative paths, areinserted into a neoliberal order. In an era of "doing better withless," these scientists have defended a type of government made theoreticallyefficient and low-cost by "social control" mechanisms. The"eco-actors" program thus offers the opportunity to confront Ostrom'stheoretical principles with the realities of their local implementation, in acontext marked by the generalized lack of public funding.
... Also, methodologically social and scientific movements can be addressed in a single manner, as both are constituted through collective action beyond borders. 16 We therefore do not investigate social reformers and experts in local or national isolation, but we consider them as actors in a global field of discourse and practice. Such an actororiented approach reveals the ways in which experts set in motion global processes of knowledge exchange and transformation, which ultimately fuelled processes of scientific discipline formation based on relationships of mutual recognition, support and mobility across boundaries. ...
Public health, hygiene and social activism
Chapter
  • Jan 2021
... Most courses included Marx-Weber-Durkheim plus a small handful of others, usually a subset of Simmel, Mead, Martineau, Du Bois, Gilman, or Comte. 1 Research has also emphasized the Eurocentric character of the canon, most notably Connell's (1997) seminal study of over 100 English-language textbooks from 1896-1996. 2 Others have considered national traditions and general characteristics in organization and contents in British and French textbooks (Schrecker, 2008). Survey research has sought to reveal "the subjective canon" and 1 The process by which a new author enters into this extended canon involves a form of intellectual activism (Frickel & Gross, 2005) worthy of additional study. For the case of Simmel, see Broćić and Silver (2021). 2 See also Alway (1995) for a more recent examination of the gendered character of approximately 10 English-language theory textbooks, and a recent 2019 study by McDonald. ...
The Rhetoric of the Canon: Functional, Historicist, and Humanist Justifications
Article
Full-text available
  • Feb 2022
This paper seeks to uncover the modes of justification by which sociological theo-rists legitimize the "canon" of sociological theory in practice, through the stories they tell to students in sociological theory textbooks. Specifically, we ask: how do textbook authors rationalize their decisions to include and exclude some theorists? Further, what are the modes or "rules of the conceptual game" underlying these jus-tifications? To address these questions, we undertake a rhetorical examination of a corpus of 250 English-language editions of sociological theory textbooks. Focusing on their Introductions and Conclusions, we highlight texts that presume the canon is a social fact and investigate the justifications they provide for assenting to this fact. We articulate and illustrate three forms of legitimation: functionalist, historicist, and humanist. Functionalist justifications legitimate the canon by appealing to its capacity to generate disciplinary unity and integrity. Historicist justifications legitimate the canon by appealing to its members' foundational and influential role in defining the direction of the field. Humanist justifications legitimate the canon through appealing to the intrinsic qualities of its texts and authors. Identifying these pathways is the primary empirical contribution of this paper, which in turn contributes to the collective project of disciplinary self-reflection.
... There is rather long and checkered history of utilizing magnetism for medical applications, 400 including the magnetically guided tethered devices for vascular exploration and treatment. 256,401−408 Unfortunately, most of them have "faded into oblivion" 409,410 with no successful adoption. Fueled by Chemical Reviews pubs.acs.org/CR ...
Magnetic Soft Materials and Robots
Article
... In addition to power, disciplinary norms and practices contribute to socially produced gaps in scientific knowledge through both deliberate actions as well as unintentional, influential institutional logics (Hess 2009;Frickel et al. 2010;Kempler et al. 2011;Kleinman and Suryanarayanan 2012). Funding priorities are often set by federal agencies or the military and thus reflect elite priorities (Moore 2008), disciplines compete for intellectual territory and scarce grant dollars (Frickel and Gross 2005), and the research questions of interest to the government or industry often receive greater attention than those of interest to communities and non-elites (Hess 2009;Frickel et al. 2010). ...
Science, citizens, and air pollution : constructing environmental (in)justice
Chapter
  • Jan 2020
This book examines the relationship between environmental justice and citizen science, focusing on enduring issues and new challenges in a post-truth age. Debates over science, facts, and values have always been pivotal within environmental justice struggles. For decades, environmental justice activists have campaigned against the misuses of science, while at the same time engaging in community-led citizen science. However, post-truth politics has threatened science itself. This book makes the case for the importance of science, knowledge, and data that are produced by and for ordinary people living with environmental risks and hazards. The international, interdisciplinary contributions range from grassroots environmental justice struggles in American hog country and contaminated indigenous communities, to local environmental controversies in Spain and China, to questions about “knowledge justice,” citizenship, participation, and data in citizen science surrounding toxicity. The book features inspiring studies of community-based participatory environmental health and justice research; different ways of sensing, witnessing, and interpreting environmental injustice; political strategies for seeking environmental justice; and ways of expanding the concepts and forms of engagement of citizen science around the world. While the book will be of critical interest to specialists in social and environmental sciences, it will also be accessible to graduate and postgraduate audiences. More broadly, the book will appeal to members of the public interested in social justice issues, as well as community members who are thinking about participating in citizen science and activism. Toxic Truths includes distinguished contributing authors in the field of environmental justice, alongside cutting-edge research from emerging scholars and community activists.
A Responsible Approach to Higher Education Curriculum Design
Article
  • Jun 2022
The changing global scenario throws a big responsibility to higher education institutes to prepare future ready students. The curriculum is the most important input, which can play a vital role in the overall development of students. Present work identifies the need for curriculum change in the 21st century and presents a responsible approach to curriculum development at the Bachelor’s level. The dynamics of curriculum design have been discussed from an international perspective with a more integrated and collaborative approach. Different dimensions of the curriculum have been identified and mapped to the needs of various stakeholders from both the academia and industry perspective. An integrated process framework has been presented for the development of the curriculum taking care of the major stakeholders. The proposed framework will support the academic institutions and their stakeholders to identify the gaps and offer a curriculum-based solution towards student development, in a more responsible manner.
The Institutionalization of Kübler-Ross's Five-Stage Model of Death and Dying
Article
Kübler-Ross's five-stage model of death and dying-denial, anger, bargaining, depression, and acceptance-is one of the most popular theoretical models to come out of the 20th century. How did an obscure theory of the dying process come to dominate our understanding of emotional processes altogether? Building on previous work in the sociology of knowledge, I analyze the diffusion and institutionalization of Kübler-Ross's five-stage model in scientific and journalistic fields. Specifically, I analyze all 3216 citations of Kübler-Ross in the New York Times and the Web of Science database using qualitative and quantitative text analysis. I demonstrate how early scientific interest and commercial promotion led to adoption in popular culture, and document how the five-stage model expanded to cover everything from rent prices to COVID-19. I also argue that renewed interest in Kübler-Ross's work may signal contemporary attempts to mine the tradition for meaningful understandings of death and dying.