ArticlePDF Available

Effectiveness of L-theanine and behavioral therapy in the treatment of noise phobias in dogs

Authors:
  • Università degli Studi di Milano

Abstract and Figures

Aim of the study - The treatment of noise phobias in dogs consists of behavioural therapy and, sometimes, of pharmacologic support. Aim of this study is to determine the efficacy of L-Theanine, a natural substance derived from the tea plant, used in conjunction with behavioural therapy in the treatment of such disorders and to assess any consequent change in blood cortisol levels. Materials and methods - Twenty subjects with a specific noise phobia were selected through a behavioural examination and thereafter divided into two groups (“ANX“ and “NOANX”). For 63 days, the “ANX” group received behavioural therapy in conjunction with L-Theanine, while the “NOANX” group received only behavioural therapy. All subjects underwent blood sampling, before and after treatment, for the evaluation of blood cortisol. Twice a week owners were asked to fill in a questionnaire containing a list of symptoms related to the phobic state. Two telephone interviews were made to assess adherence to therapy. Statistical analysis of the data collected was carried out. Results and discussion - A statistically significant reduction in the intensity of phobic symptoms was observed in both groups; a decrease in certain specific behaviours (panting, drooling, lip licking, yawning, drawing the attention of the owner, vocalizing, exhibiting compulsive behaviours) was observed only in the “ANX” group. This is suggestive of the fact that L-Theanine may be useful in the treatment of sound phobias in the dog. No difference was detected in the concentration of blood cortisol.
Content may be subject to copyright.
Vol 29, Issue 2, April 2015
1
Efficacy of L-Theanine in the
treatment of noise phobias
in dogs: preliminary results
Aim of the study - The treatment of noise phobias in dogs
consists of behavioural therapy and, sometimes, of pharma-
cologic support. Aim of this study is to determine the efficacy
of L-Theanine, a natural substance derived from the tea plant,
used in conjunction with behavioural therapy in the treatment
of such disorders and to assess any consequent change in
blood cortisol levels.
Materials and methods - Twenty subjects with a specific
noise phobia were selected through a behavioural examination
and thereafter divided into two groups (“ANX“ and “NOANX”).
For 63 days, the “ANX” group received behavioural therapy in
conjunction with L-Theanine, while the “NOANX” group re-
ceived only behavioural therapy. All subjects underwent blood
sampling, before and after treatment, for the evaluation of
blood cortisol. Twice a week owners were asked to fill in a
questionnaire containing a list of symptoms related to the pho-
bic state. Two telephone interviews were made to assess ad-
herence to therapy. Statistical analysis of the data collected
was carried out.
Results and discussion - A statistically significant reduction in
the intensity of phobic symptoms was observed in both
groups; a decrease in certain specific behaviours (panting,
drooling, lip licking, yawning, drawing the attention of the
owner, vocalizing, exhibiting compulsive behaviours) was ob-
served only in the “ANX” group. This is suggestive of the fact
that L-Theanine may be useful in the treatment of sound pho-
bias in the dog. No difference was detected in the concentra-
tion of blood cortisol.
Keywords - dog, noise phobia, L-Theanine, cortisol.
Dipartimento di Scienze Veterinarie e Sanità Pubblica (DIVET) -
Università degli Studi di Milano
* Corresponding author (zita.talamonti@hotmail.it)
Received: 20/08/2014 - Accepted: 19/01/2015
Manuela Michelazzi, Med Vet, PhD
Greta Veronica Berteselli, Med Vet, PhD
Zita Talamonti*, Med Vet
Simona Cannas, Med Vet, PhD, Dipl ECAWBM
Elisabetta Scaglia, Med Vet
Michela Minero, Med Vet, PhD, Dipl ECAWBM
Clara Palestrini, Med Vet, PhD, Dipl ECAWBM
INTRODUCTION
Noise fear and phobias are among the most common
behavioural problems in the dog. However, these dis-
orders are frequently overlooked or poorly managed
by the owners, who may not perceive them as prob-
lems until the behaviours manifested by the fearful or
phobic animal do not become exaggerated and so-
cially intollerable.1Fear is an emotional response to a
stimulus that the animal perceives as potentially dan-
gerous; this is an adaptive response, as it allows the
animal to avoid potentially dangerous situations and
thus increases its chances of survival.2Fear can be
triggered by different causes and is often the result of
various factors.
For example, specific aversive experiences may be as-
sociated with the development of intense fears. In
other cases, inadequate exposure to specific stimuli dur-
ing the behavioural development of the subject, such as
Michelazzi imp.:Layout 1 26-03-2015 14:21 Pagina 1
Vol 29, Issue 2, April 2015
2
to places, objects, or persons, may trigger the onset of
a fear response in later stages of the animal’s life.2,4,5,6,7
Genetics may also play a role in the development of
certain fears; studies have shown that puppies born to
parents with fear of noises are more likely to incur in
the same problem compared to puppies born to fear-
less parents.8However, studies on the genetic predis-
position to develop certain phobias often resulted in
conflicting results. For some Authors,9,10,11 shepherd
dogs, Golden Retrievers and Labradors are more
prone to various types of phobia, while other studies
have not confirmed it.12 Dogs coming from animal
shelters are apparently more prone to such behavioural
disorders.12,13,14,15,16,17 In a study on noise fear and pho-
bias,18 the analyzed data indicate a greater manifesta-
tion of thunderstorm phobia in mongrels than in
purebred dogs; however, this observation may in fact
be related to the fact that many mongrels come from
animal shelters.
A sudden, extreme and intense fear is classified as a
phobia. The manifestations of phobias are always ex-
cessively intense, symptoms persist even after the dis-
appearance of the triggering stimulus and, sometimes,
the phobic reaction can be triggered in the absence of
a specific stimulating factor.1,19,20,21,22
The symptoms exhibited by phobic dogs consist of a
sudden, non- gradual, exaggerated response to a stim-
ulus, with a strong impulse to flee or escape from the
source of the stimulus by seeking to hide, wit anxious
behaviours such as panting, vocalizing, urination or
defecation, increased vigilance, trembling and exhibi-
tion of destructive behaviours. Sometimes the inten-
sity of these symptoms is such that phobic states may
be compared to panic attacks in humans.23,24,25 Unlike
fear, which may be adaptive, phobia is considered “mal-
adaptive“, as it interferes with the normal functioning
of the living organism.4It has been hypothesized that
once a phobic event has been experienced, every sub-
sequent event associated with the same experience or
with its memory is sufficient to trigger the response.4,7
One of the most common dog phobias is the one spe-
cific to sounds, meaning an intense and extreme fear
response to an unexpected, loud and non-gradual
noise; this phobia consists of an intense and active at-
tempt of avoidance, with anxious behaviours associ-
ated with the activation of the sympathetic component
of the autonomous nervous system.4The noises that
most frequently cause phobic reactions in the dog are
those caused by thunderstorms, fireworks, gunshots
and traffic.1,22
The treatment of this behavioural disorder should in-
clude a specific behavioural therapy, based on a pro-
gramme of desensitization and counterconditioning.
Systematic desensitization requires a gradual and con-
trolled exposure to noise stimuli in order to eradicate
the manifestation of fear-related behaviours. The
counterconditioning phase consists in reinforcing a
calm and controlled behaviour in response to the trig-
Table 1 - Phobic manifestations in the dog
Panting Open mouth breathing
Pacing Walking to and fro aimlessly
Trembling Involuntary movements characterized by rhythmic oscillations
of body segments
Yawning Accessory respiratory act characterized by rapid chest expansion,
forced mouth opening and, in most cases, palpebral constriction
Remaining close to the owner Remain in the proximity of the owner
Seeking attention Search for interaction with the owner
Hiding Withdrawing from eyesight, go into hiding
Escaping Fleeing from a specific situation
Drooling Excessive salivation
Lip licking Passing the tongue over the lips
Vocalizing Barking, whining or howling
Destructive behaviour To break or damage objects
Inappropriate elimination Vomiting, defecation, urination
Presence of compulsive behaviours Repetitive or stereotypic behaviours (such as licking parts
of the body, circling)
Aggressiveness Growling, biting or trying to bite
Michelazzi imp.:Layout 1 26-03-2015 14:21 Pagina 2
Vol 29, Issue 2, April 2015
3
gering noise stimulus, by means of a positive emo-
tional stimulus. In this way the animal is conditioned
to experience a positive feeling in direct competition
with the previous state of fear.1,2
Behavioural therapy may also be performed in con-
junction with a pharmacologic intervention, typically
with substances in the pharmacologic class of tricyclic
antidepressants, benzodiazepines, monoamine oxidase
inhibitors or of selective serotonin reuptake in-
hibitors.4,20,22 To support behavioural therapy, some
Authors consider useful the use of non-conventional
medications, such as pheromones,26,27 while for others,
to date, the number of studies available is not suffi-
cient to confirm the beneficial effect of synthetic
pheromones on canine phobias.28,29
L-Theanine (N-ethyl-L-glutamine), the left-handed
isomer of theanine, is a natural substance obtained in
2001 the approval for use in the treatment of certain
behavioural disorders in companion animals. This
molecule is a nutraceutical, used to reduce and allevi-
ate stress conditions and certain anxiety-related dis-
orders in small animals.30,31 L-Theanine inhibits the
reuptake of glutamate and increases GABA levels,
generating an anti-stress effect and a sense of well-
being, and has neuroprotective effects in the hip-
pocampus by blocking the multiple receptor subtypes
of glutamate.30,32,33,34 Furthermore, it has been shown
that in the rat, L-Theanine is able to increase sero-
tonin levels in the striatum, hippocampus and hypo-
thalamus, and dopamine levels in the striatum. In
humans and in the rat, L-Theanine is able to regulate
blood pressure, improve memory and learning skills
(closely related to the action of dopamine and sero-
tonin).30,35,36,37,38 Anxitane®tablets (Virbac Animal
MATERIALS AND METHODS
Recruitment of subjects
Dogs with noise phobias were recruited following a be-
havioural examination carried out at the Clinic for be-
havioural problems in dogs and cats of the University of
Milan (Università degli Studi di Milano).
In total, 20 subjects were taken into consideration, het-
erogeneous in terms of breed, age and gender, and suf-
fering from specific phobias against thunderstorms or
fireworks; dogs with concomitant physical disorders,
over 10 years of age or with the presence of other be-
havioural disorders were excluded from the study.
PROTOCOL GUIDELINES
Prior to the study, all the dog owners received infor-
mation on the research methodology used and were
trained to recognize phobia symptoms in the dog23
(Table 1); in the early stages of the protocol they were
also assisted by an expert. The 20 owners received the
same behavioural instructions (ignore demands of at-
tention and inappropriate phobic behaviours, reward
relaxed behaviours). Using a randomized block de-
sign,39 two age- and gender-balanced groups were cre-
ated, “ANX” and “NOANX”, of 10 dogs each. The
ANX” group consisted of six spayed females and four
intact males, mean age of 5.3 ± 1.88 years; the
“NOANX” group consisted of six spayed females and
four intact males, mean age of 5.7 ± 2:00 years. Both
groups underwent a desensitization and countercondi-
tioning protocol, using an audio simulation reproduc-
ing the sounds responsible for the phobic response in
dogs (“Sound CD for behaviour therapy“ - The Company of
Animals):4,19 owners were asked to play the audio simu-
lation to their dogs at the minimum volume capable of
triggering a phobic response in the animal; while lis-
tening to the sound CD, owners had to entertain the
dog with a pleasant activity, such as playing together or
allowing the dog to eat, depending on the character of
each subject.19 In our study, within the “ANX” group 3
owners associated a recreational activity to the listening
of the CD, while the remaining owners used food; in
the “NOANX” group, while listening to the audio file
4 dogs were involved in recreational activities and 6 re-
ceived food. Owners repeated such protocol twice a
week for a total of 18 times (63 days). In addition to the
standard behavioural therapy (desensitization using the
audio CD and counterconditioning), subjects belonging
to the “ANX” group received an oral therapy with L-
Theanine (Anxitane®), twice daily at the dose recom-
mended by the manufacturer (dogs weighing less than
10 kg: Anxitane®S, ½ tablet twice daily; dogs weighing
between 10 and 25 kg: Anxitane®M/L, ½ tablet twice
daily; dogs weighing more than 25 kg: Anxitane®M/L,
1 tablet twice daily) for the entire duration of the study.
Fears and phobias of loud noises are very
common in the dog, but are often over-
looked by the owner.
Health), used in this study, is a nutraceutical contain-
ing 99.95% of L-Theanine.38 The tablets are palatable
and have no side effects even when administered at
five times the recommended dose (http://vir-
bacvet.com/images/resources/other/anxitane_firsti-
nention.pdf).
The aims of this study were to assess the potential effe-
cacy of L-Theanine (Anxitane®) in conjunction with
behavioural therapy in the treatment of noise phobias
in the dog, to evaluate any difference in cortisol levels
in the blood of dogs with noise phobia compared to
non-phobic subjects, and to highlight the possible im-
pact of L-Theanine on these hormone levels.
Michelazzi imp.:Layout 1 26-03-2015 14:21 Pagina 3
Vol 29, Issue 2, April 2015
4
Subjects belonging to the “NOANX” group received
only the standard behavioural therapy (desensitization
using the audio CD and counterconditioning). At the
end of each session, all the owners (both those of
group ANX” and those of group “NOANX”) com-
pleted a questionnaire designed to provide information
on the specific reactions of the dogs to the audio sim-
ulation, based on a score system ranging between 1 and
5 and related the frequency and intensity of symptoms,
with 1 representing the absence of symptoms and 5 the
maximum possible severity of phobic manifestations.
The owners’ compliance was assessed by means of two
telephone interviews, the first halfway through the
study and the second at the end of it.
During these interviews an investigation was made on
the owners’ opinion on the initial explanation given for
the treatment, on the difficulties encountered in im-
plementing it, on the presence of side effects and on
problems related to the administration of Anxitane®
tablets.
Two blood samples were collected in all the dogs (at
the Clinic for behavioural problems in dogs and cats and in the
time slot between 14:00 and 16:00 hrs), the first at the
time of the first behavioural examination, before initi-
ation of therapy, and the second at the end of treat-
ment (day 63), with the aim of assessing the clinical
status of the animals and to assay blood cortisol levels
with RIA methodology (Radio Immune Assay).24,40 As
for the assessment of cortisol levels, a control group
was included in the study in addition to groups ANX”
and “NOANX”, consisting of 10 dogs (6 spayed fe-
males and 4 intact males, mean age of 5.6 ± 2:00 years)
with no behavioural disorders. Blood samples were col-
lected in the same location and within the same time
slot as for the dogs belonging to groups ANX” and
“NOANX”.
The study period was divided into three time intervals:
time 1 (T1), corresponding to the time interval between
day 1 and day 21; time 2 (T2), corresponding to the
time interval between day 22 and day 42; time 3 (T3),
corresponding to the time interval between day 43 and
day 63.
STATISTICAL ANALYSIS
All data were entered into an Excel file and statistically
analyzed with SPSS 16.0 software (SPSS, 2007). De-
scriptive measures were used to calculate the mean and
the standard deviation of the scores assigned to indi-
vidual phobic behaviours and to cortisol levels. Mann-
Whitney and Friedman tests were performed to
compare the behaviour scores of groups ANX” and
“NOANX”. The differences in the concentration of
cortisol before and after treatment were analyzed using
the Wilcoxon test (SPSS, 2007).
RESULTS
The dogs’ phobic-response variation over time in both
groups was evaluated by comparing the mean scores
resulting from the questions proposed in the question-
naires administered to the dog owners at times 1, 2 and
3. This comparison revealed a statistically significant
decrease in phobic manifestations at both T2 and T3
(Fig. 1).
The change over time of specific phobic signs (in pe-
riods T1, T2, and T3) was then assessed: trembling
(Fig. 2), seeking contact with the owner, hiding, pacing
(Fig. 3) and escape behaviour (Fig. 4) were significantly
The relaxing effects of L-Theanine may help to
reduce stress and anxiety in the dog.
The dogs in the study were divided into two
groups: the first received behavioural therapy in
conjunction with the administration of L-Thea-
nine, the second only behavioural therapy.
Figura 1 - Mean total scores of phobic symptoms in the three time
intervals.
Figura 2 - Trembling behaviour in the two dog groups in the three
time intervals.
Michelazzi imp.:Layout 1 26-03-2015 14:21 Pagina 4
Vol 29, Issue 2, April 2015
5
decreased in both groups (“ANX” and “NOANX”);
destructive behaviours, inappropriate elimination and
aggressive behaviours did not instead shown any sig-
nificant decrease in either the ANX or the NOANX
groups. The comparison between the variation of in-
dividual phobic behaviours over time revealed that
only dogs in the ANX group showed a significant re-
duction in the score of the following behaviours: pant-
ing (Fig. 5), yawning (Fig. 6), drooling, drawing the
owner’s attention, vocalizing, exhibition of compul-
sive behaviours.
Analysis of the answers given by the owners during the
two telephone interviews provided information re-
garding the owners’ adhesion to the protocol: all 20
owners followed the study protocol accurately, consid-
ered it of easy execution and appreciated the clarity of
the instructions given on the use of the CD. No owner
reported the presence of side effects or problems in
administering Anxitane®tablets. Blood tests did not
identify any clinical problems in the subjects of the
study. Cortisol levels were within physiologic limits in
both groups and comparable to those of the dogs in
the control group (10-60 ng/ml). No significant varia-
tions os such levels were detected after treatment.
DISCUSSION
The study detected an improvement in phobic symp-
toms in the dogs of both the ANX” and the “NOANX”
treated groups. As shown in the literature, the results
obtained confirm that behavioural therapy (desensiti-
zation and counterconditioning), in accordance with
the methodology used by the Authors of the article, is
to be considered essential for the treatment of noise
phobias. In order to achieve optimal results, it is im-
portant for the veterinarian to teach the owner how to
recognize the signs of stress, fear and phobia exhibited
by the dog. In fact, during the standard desensitization
and counterconditioning protocol the dog should be
exposed to the sound stimuli in a gradual and con-
trolled way, in order to allow desensitization to the
stimulus, conditioning to elicit a positive response and
extinguishment of fear-related behaviours.1.22
The use of a score assigned to each phobic behaviour
allows to make the owner’s interpretation as objective
as possible.22 The owner’s compliance is also impor-
tant, in order to ensure that the treatment protocol is
followed regularly and for the entire period necessary
for the healing of the animal. The treatment protocol
must therefore be explained clearly, it must be of easy
Figura 3 - Pacing behaviour in the two dog groups in the three time
intervals.
Figura 4 - Escaping behaviour in the two dog groups in the three
time intervals.
Figura 5 - Panting behaviour in the two dog groups in the three
time intervals.
Figura 6 - Yawning behaviour in the two dog groups in the three
time intervals.
Michelazzi imp.:Layout 1 26-03-2015 14:21 Pagina 5
Vol 29, Issue 2, April 2015
6
execution and the owner must be aware of the time in-
terval necessary for clinical improvements.22
The ANX group presented a significant improvement
in some phobic signs (panting, drooling, lip licking,
yawning, drawing attention, vocalizing and compulsive
behaviours), a result not found in the NOANX group.
This improvement may be related to the reduction or
alleviation of conditions of anxiety and stress induced
by L-Theanine. Our study confirms the usefulness of
Anxitane®in the treatment of dogs with anxiety- and
fear-relateted behaviours, as reported in the litera-
ture.30,32,41,42 Anxitane®can therefore be considered a
valid support in conjunction with behavioural therapy
in dogs with phobia of loud noises. Furthermore, the
palatability of the tablets makes the product easy to ad-
minister and the absence of contraindications and side
effects in all the subjects of the study allows for its safe
administration.
Our study did not show any difference in blood corti-
sol values between dogs with noise phobias and sub-
jects in the control group, neither differences between
the values found in the first and second sampling. Al-
though some studies have shown that the rise in corti-
sol levels is correlated with the body’s response to
stress, and that it can hence be considered as a valid pa-
rameter for the assessment of conditions of stress,40,43
other studies report that in the dog such variations nev-
ertheless fall within the range of normal values.2In ad-
dition, the level of plasma cortisol may be affected by
multiple factors, such as the circadian rhythm, gender
and age; a considerable individual variation in its pro-
duction is also present.2
In addition to a general improvement in both
groups, subjects who took L-Theanine presented
a significant decrease of some phobic signs.
KEY POINTS
Phobias of loud noises are a common behavioural problem in the dog; the treatment of
choice consists of a specific behavioural therapy.
With regard to this disorder, the pilot study compared a desensitization and countercondi-
tioning protocol used in conjunction with the administration of L-Theanine versus behav-
ioural therapy alone.
The results showed that L-Theanine may be considered a valid support for behavioural ther-
apy in the presence of noise phobias.
REFERENCES
1. Overall KL. Noise phobias in dogs. In: Horwitz DF, Mills DS, Heath S.
(Eds) BSAVA Manual of Canine and Feline Behavioural Medicine,
BSAVA, Gloucester, 2002, pp.164-172.
2. Casey R. Fear and stress. In: Horwitz DF, Mills DS, Health S. (Eds)
BSAVA Manual of Canine and Feline Behavioural Medicine, BSAVA,
Gloucester, 2002, pp.144-153.
3. Estelles G, Mills D, Coleshaw PH et al. A retrospective analysis of rela-
tionships with severity of signs of fear of fireworks and treatment out-
come in 99 cases. In Mills D. et al (Eds) Current issues and research in
Veterinary Behavioural Medicine. 2005, pp. 161-164.
4. Overall KL. La clinica comportamentale del cane e del gatto. CG Edi-
zioni medico scientifiche. 2001, pp. 306-309.
5. Poulton R, Davies S, Menzies RG. Evidence of a non associative model
of the acquisition of fear of heights. Behaviour Research and Therapy
36:537-544, 1998.
6. McCune S. The impact of paternity and early socialisation on the de-
velopment of cats’ behaviour to people and novel objects. Applied An-
imal Behaviour Science 45:109-124, 1995.
7. Palestrini C. Situational sensitivities. In: Horwitz DF, Mills DS (Eds) Ca-
nine and feline behavioural medicine (second edition). BSAVA, Glouces-
ter, 2009, pp. 169-181.
8. Sheppard G, Mills D. The development and psychometric scale for the
evaluation of the emotional predispositions of pet dogs. International
Journal of Comparative Psychology. 2002, pp. 201-222.
9. Landsberg GM. The distribution of canine behaviour cases at three be-
havior referral practices. Veterinary Medicine 86:1011-1018, 1991.
10. Tuber DS, Hothersall D, Peters MF. Treatment of fears and phobias in
dogs. Veterinary Clinics of North America (animal behavior) 12:607-
623, 1982.
11. Rapoport J, Ryland DH, Kriete M. Drug treatment of canine acral lick
- an animal model of obsessive-compulsive disorder. Archives General
Psychiatry 49:517-521, 1992.
12. Mengoli M, Tancini V, MaritiC, Sighieri C, Osella MC, Gazzano A.
Indagine sui fattori predisponenti all’insorgenza della fobia dei tempo-
rali nel cane Veterinaria 26(4):27-33, 2012.
13. McCobb EC, Brown EA, Damiani K, Dodman NH. Thunderstorm
phobia in dogs: an internet survey of 69 cases. Journal of the American
Animal Hospital Association 37(4):319-24, 2001.
14. Borchelt PL, Voith VL. Diagnosis and treatment of separation-related
behavior problems in dogs. Veterinary Clinics of North America: Small
Animal Practice 12(4):625-35, 1992.
15. McBride EA, Bradshaw JWS, Christians A et al. Factors predisposing
dogs to separation problems. In: Rutter SM, Rushen J, Randle HD, Ed-
dison JC. Proceedings of the 29th International Congress of the Inter-
national Society for Applied Ethology, 1995, pp. 103-104.
16. Wells DL, Hepper PG. Prevalence of behaviour problems reported by
owners of dogs purchased from an animal rescue shelter. Applied Ani-
mal Behavior Science 69(1):55-65, 2000.
17. Bollen KS, Horowitz J. Behavioral evaluation and demographic infor-
mation in the assessment of aggressiveness in shelter dogs. Applied An-
imal Behavior Science 112(1-2):120-135, 2008.
Michelazzi imp.:Layout 1 26-03-2015 14:21 Pagina 6
Vol 29, Issue 2, April 2015
7
18. Blackwell E, Casey R, Bradshaw J. Firework fears and phobias in the do-
mestic dog. RSPCA, University of Bristol, 2005, pp. 2-13.
19. Shull-Selcer EA, Stagg W. Advance in the understanding and treatment
of noise phobias. Veterinary Clinics North America: Small Animal Prac-
tice 21:353-367, 1991.
20. Horwitz DF, Neilson JC. Canine & feline behavior. Blackwell Publish-
ing, Ames, Iowa, USA, 2007.
21. Imura K. The nature of noise fears of domestic dogs. MPhil thesis, Uni-
versity of Lincoln, 2007.
22. Levine ED. Sound sensitivities. In: Horwitz DF, Mills DS (Eds) Canine
and feline behavioural medicine (second edition). BSAVA, Gloucester,
2009, pp. 159-168.
23. Neilson JC. Paura di luoghi o cose. In: Horwitz DF, Mills DS, Heath S.
Terapia comportamentale del cane e del gatto. UTET, 2004, cap. 18.
24. Dreschel NA, Granger DA. Physiological and behavioural reactivity to
stress in thunderstorm-phobic dogs and their caregivers. Applied Ani-
mal Behavour Science 95:153-168, 2005.
25. Beaver BV. Canine Behavior. Insights and Answers. Saunders Elsevier,
St.Louis, Missouri, 2009, 88-94.
26. Sheppard G, Mills D. Evaluation of dog-appeasing pheromone as a po-
tential treatment for dogs fearful of fireworks. Veterinary Record
152:432-436, 2003.
27. Levine ED, Ramos D, Mills D, A prospective study of two self-help CD
based desensitization and counter-conditioning programmes with the
use of Dog Appeasing Pheromone for the treatment of firework fears
in dogs (Canis familiaris). Applied Animal Behaviour Science, 105:311-
329, 2007.
28. Frank D, Beauchamp G, Palestrini C. Systematic review of the use of
pheromones for treatment of undesirable behavior in cats and dogs.
Journal of the American Veterinary Medical Association 236:1308-1316,
2010.
29. Overall KL. Manual of clinical behavioural medicine for dogs and cats.
Elsevier, 2013, pp. 501-5012.
30. Kimura K, Ozeki M, Juneja LR et al. L-theanine reduces psychological
and physiological stress responses. Biological Psychology 74:39-45, 2007.
31. Araujo JA, De Rivera C, Either JL et al. Anxitane®tablets reduce fear of
human being in a laboratory model of anxiety-related behavior. Journal
of Veterinary Behavior: Clinical Applications and Research 5:268-275,
2010.
32. Sadzuka Y, Sugiyama T, Suzuki T, Sonobe T. Enhancement of the ac-
tivity of doxorubicin by inhibition of glutamate transporter. Toxicol-
ogy Letters 123:159-167, 2001.
33. Kimura R, Murata T. Influence of alkylamides of glutamic acid and re-
lated compounds on the central nervous system I. Central depressant ef-
fect of theanine. Chemical and Pharmaceutical Bulletin 19:1257-1261,
1971.
34. Lu K, Gray MA, Oliver C, Liley DT et al. The acute effects of L-thea-
nine in comparison with alprazolam on anticipatory anxiety in humans.
Human Psychopharmacology 19:457-465, 2004.
35. Yokogoshi H, Kobayashi M, Mochizuki M, et al. Effect of theanine, r-
glutamylethylamide, on brain monoamines and striatal dopamine release
in conscious rats. Neurochemical Research 23:667-673, 1998.
36. Juneja LR, Chu DC, Okubo T, et al. L-theanine a unique amino acid of
green tea and its relaxion effect in humans. Trends Food Science Tech-
nology 10:199-204,1999.
37. Yokogoshi H, Terashima T. Effect of theanine, g-glutamylethylamide, on
brain monoamines, striatal dopamine release and some kinds of behav-
ior in rats. Nutrition 16:776-777, 2000.
38. Nathan PJ, Lu K, Gray M et al. The neuropharmacology of L-theanine
(N-ethyl-L-glutamine): a possible neuroprotective and cognitive en-
hancing agent. Journal Herbal Pharmacotherapy 6:21-30, 2006.
39. Petrie A, Watson P. Statistics for Veterinary and Animal Science. Black-
well Science, Oxford, UK, 1999.
40. Berteselli GV, Servida F, Dall’Ara P, et al. Valutazione di alcuni parametri
dello stress, immunitari e comportamentali in cani con disturbi correlati
all’ansia. Uno studio pilota – Parte II. Summa 1:37-42, 2007.
41. Berteselli GV, Michelazzi M. Use of L-theanine tablets (AnxitaneTM) and
behaviour modification on treatment of phobias in dog. A preliminary
study. Journal of Veterinary Behavior: Clinical Applications and Re-
search 2-101, 2007.
42. Michelazzi M, Berteselli GV, Minero M et al. Effectiveness of L-theanine
and behavioral therapy in the treatment of noise phobias in dogs. Jour-
nal of Veterinary Behavior: Clinical Applications and Research 5:34-35,
2009.
43. Beerda B, Schilder MBH, Janssen NSCR et al. The use of saliva cortisol,
urinary cortisol, and catecholamine measurements for a non invasive as-
sessment of stress responses in dog. Hormones and Behavior 30:272-
279, 1996.
Michelazzi imp.:Layout 1 26-03-2015 14:21 Pagina 7
... However, some effort was made to blind the outcome assessors by Stellato et al. (2019). In contrast, Michelazzi et al. (2010) had the owners, who had implemented the intervention, self-report the outcome measures. Furthermore, Herron et al. (2014) and Orihel & Fraser (2008) reported some attrition of participants but did not include details on the attrition per group or reasons for attrition. ...
... In one study, this technique was found to reduce separation-related behaviours (SRB) for only one out of four dogs, and the inappropriate behaviours had returned two weeks after the intervention concluded (Babington, 2019). In contrast, Michelazzi et al. (2010) found that reinforcement-stimulus pairing regardless of the dog's behaviour significantly reduced noise-phobic behaviours. Similarly, two kennel-behaviour studies found that providing treats to dogs as people approached or passed their kennels was effective at reducing barking J o u r n a l P r e -p r o o f (Protopopova & Wynne, 2015;Zurlinden et al., 2022) and general undesirable behaviour (Protopopova & Wynne, 2015). ...
... Agents considered by the owners as more natural, such as homeopathic or herbal products, aromas, Bach Flowers, nutraceuticals such as l-theanine and alpha casozepine, or even cannabidiol (CBD), are broadly available in the pet market. However, there is not sufficient efficacy evidence for all of them, with some rigorous studies presenting positive results of the agents, e.g., [18][19][20][21][22][23], but others failing in different aspects (e.g., uncontrolled studies, few participants, lack of effect, lack of behavioural responses analysis), e.g., [24][25][26][27][28][29][30], or demonstrating a placebo effect, e.g., [31]. ...
Article
Full-text available
Canine fear of fireworks is a common problem worldwide, with serious implications for the welfare of both dogs and their owners. Therapies for the problem are available, and herbal and nutraceutical agents are increasingly suggested by professionals; nonetheless, studies on their real efficacy in reducing firework fear are lacking. In a randomised, double-blinded, placebo-controlled study, 44 dogs (25 in the “supplement” group and 19 in the “placebo” group) completed a long-term continuous treatment with either a supplement made of tryptophan, valerian, and passiflora or a placebo, including two real exposures to fireworks (on 2020 Christmas and 2021 New Years’ Eve, after 42 and 48 days of treatment, respectively). Owners of both groups received the same general environmental management and food/toy offering recommendations for trying with their dogs on those nights. Behavioural (measured by LSSS—Lincoln Sound Sensitivity Scale and PANAS—Positive and Negative Activation scale, as rated by the owners) and stress (measured via salivary cortisol measures) reactions were evaluated. Significantly greater fear decrease (LSSS) was recorded in the “supplement” dogs, as compared to the “placebo” group. Cortisol dosages on New Year’s Eve (“noisy” night) were in line with behavioural results; “supplement” dogs showed a smaller increase in the stress response from 22:30 to 00:30 h on New Year’s Eve and a greater decrease in their stress response from 02:30 h to 10:30 h on New Year’s Day compared to “placebo” dogs. Smaller cortisol levels were also shown by “supplement” dogs than “placebo” dogs on a controlled “quiet night” (27th December). Owners’ rates on PANAS remained stable during the whole period of therapy for both groups. The evaluated supplement, a combination of tryptophan, valerian, and passiflora, showed satisfactory results and rare side effects when treating dogs fearful of fireworks.
... Solliquin (Nutramax Laboratories Veterinary Science, Inc., Lancaster, SC, USA), a nutraceutical, contains Magnolia officinalis , Phellodendron amurense and L-theanine. L-theanine has been examined for its potential ability to decrease fear to unfamiliar people ( Araujo et al., 2010 ), noise phobia ( Michelazzi et al., 2010 ), and storm anxiety in dogs ( Pike et al., 2015 ). Magnolia officinalis and Phellodendron amurense decreased storm anxiety in dogs ( DePorter et al., 2012 ). ...
Article
Animal shelters are often associated with high levels of stressors that can compromise welfare. Mitigating stressors or the associated distress is a priority for shelters. Given restricted time and financial resources it's important that shelters use evidence-based interventions. This study evaluated the efficacy of Solliquin (Nutramax Laboratories Veterinary Science, Inc., Lancaster, SC, USA), a behavioral nutraceutical, to mitigate stress responses of dogs entering a shelter. Stress responses were quantified using fecal cortisol and activity tracking with triaxial accelerometers. For all the conditions analyzed, the Solliquin treated group had an increase in only the light rest category (p=0.050) compared to control dogs. There were no effects on other parameters measured including deep rest.
... Several studies have been performed on 1 particular veterinary nutraceutical product whose only functional ingredient is L-theanine. The most notable findings have been demonstrated in dogs, including a reduced fear of unfamiliar people, 15 reduced noise phobia, [11][12][13][14] and decreased storm-related anxiety. 16 One study on cats demonstrated a decrease in anxiety after 30 days of treatment. ...
Article
Behavioral problems of companion animals are becoming more widely recognized. As a result, there are a growing number of behavioral nutraceuticals and diets on the market. These products may be useful for the treatment of mild conditions, for clients who are hesitant to give their pet a psychopharmacologic agent, or sometimes in conjunction with psychopharmacologic agents. Veterinarians should critically review the research associated with nutraceuticals and diets, and have an understanding of the functional ingredients and their mechanisms of action before prescribing treatment. This article provides an overview of nutraceuticals, their mechanisms of action, and relevant research regarding their use.
Article
Canine stress-related behavioural issues are common welfare problems that can have negative implications on the quality of life of both the dog and owner. The effective management of canine stress is multifaceted, with emphasis on appropriate training, addressing environmental factors and the provision of supporting therapies such as nutraceuticals. In this randomised, double-blind, placebo-controlled study in 52 pet dogs with a history of stress behaviour, the nutraceutical CALMEX® was shown to significantly improve stress-related behavioural responses in dogs after 14 days of supplementation as determined by an owner-assessed questionnaire, with no significant change seen in the placebo group. Specifically, there was a significant difference found between placebo and CALMEX® in response to loud noise, with CALMEX® reducing owner-assessed stress scores by over a third in the 14 day study period. The results of this study suggest that CALMEX® is an effective product in the management of stress in pet dogs.
Chapter
Behavior can change as a result of medical issues or physiological changes. It is well understood that dogs and cats continue to express many of the behavioral patterns expressed by their wild ancestors. The behaviors typical of sick animals represent a highly adaptive behavioral strategy, so it is not surprising that many of these behaviors have been retained in spite of domestication. A variety of different studies have suggested that monitoring of sickness behaviors in the cat may be an excellent additional means of evaluating feline welfare and that the cats' behavior is a more reliable indicator of their level of stress than their physiological responses. Urine-marking behavior is more common in intact dogs and is considered a normal form of communication. When neutered animals mark, it is often due to situations involving conflict, frustration or anxiety.
Article
Full-text available
l Sistema dello Stress (SS) è un meccanismo altamente adattativo che permette all’organismo di ripristinare l’omeostasi alterata da un agente stessante (fisico o psichico) mettendo in atto risposte di natura endocrina, immunitaria e comportamentale [14]. Esiste quindi una stretta comunicazione e relazione tra SNC, SS e Sistema Immunitario (SI) [6, 9]. Tale risposta può diventare problematica quando lo stress diventa cronico e l’animale non è più in grado di risolvere la situazione e di ripristinare l’equilibrio omeostatico. In questo caso si può osservare una disregolazione della funzionalità immunitaria, dovuta all’aumento del cortisolo circolante, e la manifestazione di comportamenti anomali e inappropriati da parte dell’animale, allo scopo di ridurre tale risposta endocrina. I problemi comportamentali che ne derivano possono rientrare nei disturbi correlati all’ansia (ansia, paura, fobia, disturbi compulsivi) [1, 2, 6]. Gli scopi di questo lavoro sono stati quelli di approfondire la relazione tra stress, comportamento e immunità e di valutare come la presenza di problemi comportamentali nel cane sia una evidente manifestazione di uno stato di stress. Infatti, si è voluto cercaree validare anche per il cane dei parametri oggettivi dello stress, sia fisiologici (cortisolo) sia immunitari (IgA, lisozima, fagocitosi) sia comportamentali, che permettano di quantificare scientificamente la condizione di stress. Inoltre, si è valutato come l’applicazione di una corretta terapia comportamentale influenzi questi parametri e porti a un miglioramento del benessere animale.
Article
Full-text available
Many pet dogs exhibit problem behaviours which can be corrected through the judicious use of posi- tive and negative reinforcers in training. However, animals often vary in their sensitivity and re- sponse to these. It is hypothesised that this variation may offer a biological basis for discriminating between animals that develop certain types of problems (eg fears and phobias) and their response to treatment. The development of a clinical tool that uses owner report to measure individual differences in positive and negative activation in pet dogs is described. The activation scales each measured a single homogeneous construct and effectively differentiated between individuals, demonstrating variation on two dimensions. Test-retest reliability was good and the study provided evidence of va- lidity. Normative data were calculated and may be used in future research that could provide further evidence of validity and in investigations of the underlying structure of canine behaviour disorders. The final scales comprised of 21 items, and so can be administered with little difficulty. Veterinary behavioural medicine is the diagnosis and treatment of behav- iour disorders in animals under the auspices of the veterinary profession. In 1997, the first global conference was held for this emerging field of veterinary science (Mills et al., 1997) and a disparity between alternative approaches to the conceptu- alisation of behaviour problems was highlighted. It is apparent that in many ways, the discipline has developed along similar lines to the human psychiatric field, but it has the potential to learn from the experiences of this related discipline and re- cent advances in psychobiology (Sheppard & Mills, 2003). Thus, in contrast to many other streams of comparative psychology, this field is developing through the use of methods and concepts developed in the human field to explore the mind of other animals, more than the reverse. An area of growing importance, in both the veterinary and human medical fields, is the need for comprehensive theories that link behaviour, affect, motiva- tion and neurobiology (Panksepp, 1998). For example, Depue and Collins (1999) reviewed evidence that links individual differences in positive incentive motivation with variation in dopamine activity and personality. This model also implies that individuals at the extremes of the dimension are more likely to exhibit behaviour, which is inappropriate and problematic in a range of circumstances and so are more likely to present with signs of "clinical mental illness". Psychometric inter- views may be developed to quantify such traits, but must be based on an under- standing of the underlying psychobiology of the construct to be measured. This has The authors would like to thank Ceva Santé Animale for funding this work including Gill Sheppard's position at the university. We would also like to thank two anonymous referees and Melissa Burns, for their insightful and constructive comments on an earlier draft of this work. Corre- spondence concerning this article may be addressed to Daniel S. Mills, Animal Behaviour, Cognition
Article
Full-text available
Behavioral evaluations of 2017 shelter dogs were used for identifying dogs with aggressive tendencies and for predicting post-adoption behavior problems. Associations between failure of the behavioral evaluation and demographic factors (age, breed, and sex) and the dog's behavioral history, evaluated by logistic regression, were highly significant (P72 months). Dogs that failed the behavior evaluation were not placed for adoption; therefore it was not possible to study prospectively the capability of behavioral evaluation to predict future aggressiveness in these dogs. Instead we developed tests for classifying dogs as aggressive or not aggressive based on their demographic factors and behavior evaluation outcomes. The results were compared retrospectively to the dogs’ known behavioral histories, which were obtained at intake to the shelter. This allowed estimation of the sensitivity, specificity, and accuracy of the classification tests. The most significant postdictor (i.e., “retrospective predictor”) of aggressiveness was failure of the behavioral evaluation (odds ratio 11.83, P
Article
Full-text available
A developmental study in domestic cats (Felis silvestris catus) examined the interaction of their early socialisation and the friendliness of their father and its consequences on their later friendliness to people. Kittens were either handled between 2 and 12 weeks of age (socialised) or received no handling (unsocialised) during this period. These kittens were the offspring of either a ‘friendly’ father or an ‘unfriendly’ father. When 1 year old, these cats went through a series of three experiments: (1) response to a familiar person; (2) response to a stranger; and (3) response to a novel object. Cats socialised or from the friendly father were quicker to approach, touch and rub a test person, were more vocal and spent a greater total time within 1 m of them. Differences in the cats' response to a novel object could not be accounted for by differences in early socialisation. However, cats from the friendly father were quicker to approach, touch, explore and remain in close contact with the novel object than were cats from the unfriendly father. The genetic contribution to friendliness towards people in cats was reinterpreted as boldness; a general response to unfamiliar or novel objects irrespective of whether or not the objects are people. The socialisation effect was specific to the cats' response to people. Socialised cats and friendly-fathered cats were not only friendlier to unfamiliar people but less distressed when approached and handled by them.
Article
Canine Behavior: Insights and Answers, 2nd Edition offers cutting-edge information on the latest advances in the field of clinical canine behavior. It is intended to meet the needs of veterinarians, veterinary students and technicians as well as pet owners dealing with problem pets, pet care personnel who handle dogs in the course of their work, and dog lovers who are seeking understanding of the natural and aberrant behaviors of their canine companions. This new edition establishes a solid foundation for understanding innate, dog-to-dog social interactions, communication, and sensory awareness, so that we humans can learn how to meaningfully and effectively communicate with our âbest friends.â The authorâs goals are to provide a clear understanding of normal behaviors and to provide the necessary tools to identify problem behaviors and their origins. Only then is it possible to successfully â and humanely â prevent, eradicate, or minimize unacceptable behaviors and build successful, lifelong relationships with our dogs. © 2009, 1999 by Saunders, an imprint of Elsevier Inc. All rights reserved.
Article
The aims of this study were to evaluate the efficacy of two self-help CD based desensitization and counter-conditioning programmes with the use of Dog Appeasing Pheromone (DAP) for the treatment of firework fears in dogs and to evaluate the training progress and owner compliance. Fifty-four individuals were recruited for an 8-week period of training between August and October 2004. The dogs were separated into two treatment groups, each using a different CD based programme. After implementing the CD programme for the 8-week period without any personalized instruction, two telephone follow-up interviews were completed after periods during which fireworks are commonly used (November and January). Forty-two individuals completed the first 4 weeks of training and 38 completed the 8-week training period. Thirty-six individuals completed the first follow-up interview with 29 completing the second follow-up interview. Assessment of efficacy was measured using both owner reports of its natural response (i.e. the dog's behaviour in the home) and video footage of behaviour in response to a novel recording of the problem sound (i.e. the dog's behaviour in the behaviour clinic) pre- and post-treatment.
Article
This study addresses interactions between hypothalamic–pituitary–adrenal (HPA) axis activation in response to stress, relationship quality, and behavior in thunderstorm-anxious dogs and their owners. Using a controlled repeated-measures design, we experimentally manipulated exposure of individuals to a stressor they were highly fearful of, and assessed both their own and their caregivers’ physiological and behavioral responsiveness. Saliva samples were collected from 19 dog–owner dyads before, 20 and 40min after exposure to a simulated thunderstorm and were later assayed for cortisol. In response to the challenge, the dogs exhibited classic signs of fear (i.e., pacing, whining, hiding), their cortisol levels increased 207%, and these levels did not return to baseline within 40min. There were no effects of the owners’ behavior or the quality of the dog–owner relationship on the dogs’ HPA or behavioral reactivity. However, the presence of other dogs in the household was linked to less pronounced reactivity and more rapid recovery of the dog's HPA response. On average, the cortisol levels of the caregivers did not increase. Owners’ mood (e.g. depression, anger) affected their behavioral response towards their dogs. These findings are among the first to study the HPA responsiveness of anxious canines in response to stress in a home setting, and the physiological and behavioral effects of problem canine behavior on their caregivers.