ArticlePDF Available

Extremes of human heat tolerance: Life at the precipice of thermoregulatory failure

Authors:
  • Martin Army Community Hospital

Abstract and Figures

1. Human life is sustainable only below an internal temperature of roughly 42–44°C. Yet our ability to survive at severe environmental extremes is testimony to the marvels of integrative human physiology.2. One approach to understanding human thermoregulatory capacity is to examine the upper limits of thermal balance between man and the air environment, i.e. the maximal environmental conditions under which humans can maintain a steady-state core temperature. Heat acclimation expands the zone of thermal balance.3. Human beings can and do, often willingly, tolerate extreme heat stresses well above these thermal balance limits. Survival in all such cases is limited to abbreviated exposure times, which in turn are limited by the robustness of the thermoregulatory response.4. Figures are provided that relate tolerance time and the rate of change in core temperature to environmental characteristics based on data compiled from the literature.
Content may be subject to copyright.
Journal of Thermal Biology 29 (2004) 479–485
Extremes of human heat tolerance: life at the
precipice of thermoregulatory failure
W. Larry Kenney
, David W. DeGroot, Lacy Alexander Holowatz
102 Noll Laboratory, Department of Kinesiology, Penn State University, University Park, PA 16802-6900, USA
Abstract
1. Human life is sustainable only below an internal temperature of roughly 42–44 1C. Yet our ability to survive at
severe environmental extremes is testimony to the marvels of integrative human physiology.
2. One approach to understanding human thermoregulatory capacity is to examine the upper limits of thermal
balance between man and the air environment, i.e. the maximal environmental conditions under which humans can
maintain a steady-state core temperature. Heat acclimation expands the zone of thermal balance.
3. Human beings can and do, often willingly, tolerate extreme heat stresses well above these thermal balance limits.
Survival in all such cases is limited to abbreviated exposure times, which in turn are limited by the robustness of the
thermoregulatory response.
4. Figures are provided that relate tolerance time and the rate of change in core temperature to environmental
characteristics based on data compiled from the literature.
r2004 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.
Keywords: Thermoregulation; Heat balance; Sweating; Prescriptive zone; Hyperthermia; Heat stroke
1. Introduction
The topic of ‘‘environmental extremes’’ for humans
seems relatively straightforward on the surface, yet
researching such a topic proves more difficult. ‘‘Ex-
treme’’ thermal environments have different connota-
tions to different people, even the thermal physiologists
who conduct research on the topic of human thermo-
regulation. Certainly there are extremes at either end of
the environmental temperature spectrum, and cold
tolerance is equally important to heat tolerance from a
teleological perspective. For brevity sake, the present
paper deals only with extremes of heat. One may
characterize a thermal extreme as the upper limit of
humans’ ability to maintain thermal balance, as defined
by a steady state core temperature. This approach has
been used in laboratory studies and a discussion of the
topic begins the present treatise.
While defining the upper limit of thermal balance is
instructive, human beings can and do tolerate extreme
heat stresses well above these equilibration limits, albeit
for short periods of time. A popularly retold story goes
as follows:
One morning toward the end of the eighteenth
century, the Secretary of the Royal Society of London,
one Mr. Blagden, ventured into a room heated to
1051C, taking with him some eggs, a piece of raw steak
and a dog. A quarter of an hour later, the eggs were
baked hard and the steak cooked to a crisp but
Blagden and his dog walked out unharmedy
(Ashcroft, 2000)
ARTICLE IN PRESS
www.elsevier.com/locate/jtherbio
0306-4565/$ - see front matter r2004 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.
doi:10.1016/j.jtherbio.2004.08.017
Corresponding author. Tel.: +1-814-863-1672; fax: +1-
425-799-1476.
E-mail address: w7k@psu.edu (W.L. Kenney).
Mr. Blagden’s experiment vividly points out how
tolerant humans truly are to dry heat—provided that
free evaporation of sweat can occur, hot surface
temperatures are avoided (Blagden’s dog was kept in a
basket to keep it from burning its feet), the circulatory
system can compensate, and the exposure time is limited.
While the above story is astonishing, situations in
which human beings tolerate such extremes form the
basis for the second part of this paper. The highest
recorded temperature on earth is apparently 58 1C in the
Sahara and many deserts routinely reach 45 1C(Ash-
croft, 2000). Sauna temperatures typically range from 80
to 100 1C with relative humidity (rh) as low as 5%, and
bathers commonly spend 15–30 min or more in these
extreme temperatures. The primary physiological com-
pensatory mechanism during these exposures is eva-
porative heat loss from sustainable sweating. This
results in progressive dehydration and cardiovascular
strain, especially in the absence of fluid and electrolyte
replacement. Where the preceding conditions rely on
evaporative heat loss, other environments rely almost
exclusively on integrated cardiovascular responses to
compensate for the heat load (such as hot water
immersion). The hottest Japanese onsen (spa baths) are
46–47 1C, yet experienced bathers routinely tolerate
these temperatures for 3 min. In summary, humans
can tolerate considerable extremes of thermal stress,
relying on different compensatory mechanisms depend-
ing on the characteristics of the environment.
2. Limits to human heat balance
Over a wide range of environments, body core
temperature (T
c
) equilibrates at temperatures propor-
tional to metabolic rate, independent of ambient
conditions (Saltin and Hermansen, 1966). Thermal
environments above this designated ‘‘prescriptive zone’’
(Lind, 1963) do not allow thermal balance either because
of excessive dry heat gain or limited evaporative heat
loss, and the result is a continuous rise in T
c
. Conditions
which define the upper limit of the prescriptive zone or
‘‘psychrometric limit’’ for a given metabolic heat
production represent one type of environmental ‘‘ex-
treme’’ and such balance points have been determined
experimentally for heat-acclimated men (Belding and
ARTICLE IN PRESS
10
15
20
25
30
35
32 34 36 38 40 42 44 46 48 50 52 54
ambient dry-bulb temperature, ˚C
30% rh
50% rh
70% rh90% rh
10% rh
heat-acclimated
women
M = 152 W/m2
v = 0 m/s
unacclimated women
M = 143 W/m2
v = 0.5 m/s
heat-acclimated women
M = 152 W/m2
v = 1.0 m/s
ambient water vapor pressure, torr
Fig. 1. Psychrometric representation of upper limits of thermal balance determined from Penn State experiments. Each line represents
such an upper limit, analogous to Lind’s ‘‘upper limit of the prescriptive zone’’. The filled circles and lighter line are from unacclimated
subjects (Kenney and Zeman, 2002), while the open circles and squares are for heat-acclimated women (Kamon and Avellini, 1976).
Heat acclimation shifts the lines upward and to the right, increasing the range of environments in which heat balance is possible for a
given metabolic rate (M) and air velocity (v). Similarly, increasing vshifts the curve further to the right. Each data point represents the
mean results from a cohort of subjects.
W.L. Kenney et al. / Journal of Thermal Biology 29 (2004) 479–485480
Kamon, 1973) and women (Kamon and Avellini, 1976),
as well as for unacclimated men and women (Kenney
and Zeman, 2002).
Experiments are conducted in a programmable
environmental chamber. The experimental protocol
involves the determination of either (1) the critical water
vapor pressure (P
crit
) for the upward inflection of T
c
at
several distinct dry-bulb temperatures (T
db
), or (2) the
critical dry-bulb temperature (T
crit
) at several distinct
ambient water vapor pressures (P
a
). The methods used
to determine P
crit
and T
crit
have been previously
described in detail (Belding and Kamon, 1973;Kamon
and Avellini, 1976;Kenney, 1988). During the T
crit
experiments, P
a
is held constant and T
db
is system-
atically increased approximately 1 1C every 5 min after a
30-min equilibration period. In the P
crit
experiments,
T
db
is held constant while P
a
is increased approximately
1 Torr every 5 min after a similar equilibration period.
During each test, the subjects walked continuously on a
motor-driven treadmill for up to 3 h at a pre-determined
exercise intensity. Air velocity (v) was also varied in
some experiments. Typically, T
c
begins to plateau by
about 40 min and remains at an elevated steady state as
P
a
or T
db
is increased. The critical environment is
defined as that immediately before the upward T
c
inflection, i.e. the combination of conditions below
which thermal balance can be maintained, but above
which a steady rise in T
c
occurs.
Fig. 1 presents a portion of a psychrometric chart
showing data compiled from two sets of experiments
performed in our laboratory some 25 years apart
(Kamon and Avellini, 1976;Kenney and Zeman,
2002). Each point shown is the mean from several
subjects and each line represents the extreme critical
environments below which T
c
can achieve a biophysical
steady state, but above which T
c
rises continuously. The
effect of heat acclimation is to shift the line rightward,
encompassing more environmental conditions below the
psychrometric limit. Increased velocity of air movement
around the subject is another factor that shifts the
psychrometric limit rightward and upward.
3. Environmental extremes
3.1. Dry heat
Extreme dry heat presents a severe challenge to
homeostasis. Yet human beings have demonstrated a
remarkable capacity to withstand, and adapt to, the
extreme physiological stresses desert conditions demand.
To dissipate heat gained in a desert environment, the
free evaporation of sweat is coupled with an elevation in
skin blood flow. Tolerance time in dry heat depends on
the sustainable sweating rate and the ability to withstand
the resultant dehydration. The following is an anecdotal
account of extended desert exposure.
In 1994, Mauro Prosperi became lost in a sandstorm
during the 160-mile Marathon des Sables in the
Moroccan desert (Kamler, 2004). On day 4 of the event,
scheduled as a 50-mile leg of the race in an ambient
temperature of 46 1C (115 1F), Prosperi lost his way in a
sandstorm and wandered off course. With less that one
full canteen of water, he survived for 9 days. During his
ordeal, he drank his own urine and sought shelter in an
empty Muslin shrine, where he ate bats he was able to
catch in the shrine. He restricted his movement to the
cooler parts of the day and night. The following is a
description of Prosperi after he was rescued and brought
to an Algerian hospital:
ydoctors reported that the desert wanderer had lost
33 pounds and that 16 liters of intravenous fluids
were needed to replace his water loss. His kidneys
were barely functioning, his liver was damaged, and
he was unable to digest food. His eyes had sunk back
inside their sockets, and his skin was dry and
wrinkled. He looked like a tortoise. But he would
survive.
Assuming that this amazing tale is true, it may be the
most extreme documented case of survivable dehydra-
tion.
Physiology of dry heat exposure: The ability to
withstand extreme heat exposure depends on the aerobic
fitness, hydration status, and heat acclimation status of
the subject. In the ensuing discussions of the physiolo-
gical adaptations that make it possible for subjects to
tolerate exposure to extreme temperatures, such assump-
tions are necessary for tolerance to, and survival in, true
extremes of environment.
The primary physiological compensatory mechanism
during exposure to dry heat is evaporative cooling.
Unofficially, the highest sweating rate recorded is 5.6 L/
h, a rate based on the43 kg body weight loss of a
professional tennis player in a laboratory setting over a
50-min period of exercise (Dr. Robert Murray, Ph.D.,
personal communication). Exercise consisted of cycling
at 75–95% of maximum heart rate and voluntary fluid
consumption was 1.6 L. The environmental chamber
was 35 1C and 63% rh, with minimal air movement. In
the published literature the highest reported sweating
rate may be that of Olympic distance runner Alberto
Salazar. Based on body weight change during the 1984
Olympic Marathon, and compensating for estimated
fluid consumption, Salazar had a reported sweating rate
of 3.7 L/h. During testing in an environmental chamber
earlier that year, his measured sweating rate was 2.8 L/h
(Armstrong et al., 1986).
Hypohydration caused by high sweating rates in the
absence of adequate fluid replacement leads to eleva-
ARTICLE IN PRESS
W.L. Kenney et al. / Journal of Thermal Biology 29 (2004) 479–485 481
tions in T
c
, relative to a euhydrated state, and an
increased rate of heat storage, thereby decreasing
tolerance time. Hypohydration leads to cardiovascular
strain by reducing cardiac filling pressure, reducing
stroke volume and causing a compensatory increase in
heart rate (Sawka and Pandolf, 1990). Sawka (Sawka et
al., 1985) investigated the influence of heat stress and
graded hypohydration (0, 3, 5, 7% body weight) during
exercise at 49 1C, 20% rh. Higher levels of hypohydra-
tion resulted in a greater incidence of exhaustion
(exercise termination) at a given T
c
, such that a 7%
reduction in body weight decreased time to exhaustion
from 140 min (at 0 and 3% dehydration) to 64 min.
Additionally, hypohydration led to a predictable in-
crease in heart rate and T
c
for each exercise bout.
Interestingly, two of the subjects terminated the exercise
due to the appearance of premature ventricular con-
tractions, suggesting that this level of 7% hypohydra-
tion may be near the tolerable safe limit. We are
unaware of experimentally induced hypohydration
exceeding 8% of body weight.
3.2. Non-evaporative environments
A distinctly different hot environment in comparison
to the desert is one in which both ambient heat and
ambient water vapor pressure are high. The robustness
of the cardiovascular response and the ability to tolerate
profound elevations in T
c
determine tolerance time in
this situation. The most extreme example of a non-
evaporative environment is hot water immersion. In this
environment most avenues of heat loss are unavailable,
as skin temperature quickly equilibrates with water
temperature and evaporative cooling is limited to any
skin surface not immersed in water. Immersed skin
cannot dissipate heat through evaporation, and radia-
tion and conduction become avenues of heat gain. One
extreme example of hot water immersion is the Japanese
onsen, ancient stone communal baths where the hottest
water temperatures are reported to be 46–47 1C. Most
bathers can only withstand these extreme temperatures
for 3 min (Ashcroft, 2000). However, Japanese people
customarily bathe in 40 1C water for periods of up to
60 min. The following is an account of a Westerner’s first
experience with the Japanese onsen.
I stepped boldly into the pool—and leapt straight out
again. It was scalding hot. At least 45 1C. I thought I
must have first-degree burns. yWhen I emerged
from my pool five minutes later I was a bright cherry
red, like a boiled lobster. All of my blood had been
directed to my skin as my body tried desperately to
cool down — to no avail, for not only could I not get
rid of the heat I generated myself, but I was rapidly
accumulating that of the bath. I sat on the edge of the
pool, my skin pouring sweat. But I felt marvellous
yfor although a short dip is marvellously invigorat-
ing, to remain there too long would, quite literally, be
fatal.
Warm water SCUBA diving is a unique example of
thermoregulatory stress that adds metabolic heat
production in addition to hot water immersion. Rescue
divers working in warm water wear vulcanized rubber
suits and carry equipment that can weigh up to 45 kg.
These divers can experience increases in T
c
as high as
31C during a 1-h rescue mission (White et al., 1998).
Rescue operations are carried out with dive pair teams
with one diver remaining on the surface, where
evaporative cooling is still limited by the wet suit. White
(White et al., 1998) measured T
c
changes during both
warm and cold water rescue training sessions; the
ambient temperature for the warm water training rescue
situation was 23 1C and the water temperature was
21 1C. These investigators found that the mean increase
in T
c
in all divers was 1.2 1C, however 2 divers had an
increase in T
c
greater than 2 1C in 30–50 min. T
c
continued to climb even after exiting the water at the
conclusion of the training session. This situation
represents another example of extreme heat stress
because evaporative cooling is severely limited while
metabolic heat is being generated causing core tempera-
ture to climb rapidly.
Physiological responses to extreme non-evaporative
heat: In the laboratory, a standard method to test
subjects’ upper limits of thermal tolerance is the water-
perfused suit. In numerous experiments (Minson et al.,
1998;Rowell et al., 1970;Rowell, 1974, 1983, 1986)
investigators raised skin temperature to 40 1C by the use
of these tube-filled suits to examine the cardiovascular
adjustments to severe hyperthermia. This experimental
paradigm maximizes skin blood flow and allows for
investigation of integrated cardiovascular adjustments
when the T
c
T
sk
thermal gradient is reversed (as occurs
in hot water immersion as well).
When subjects are heated to thermal tolerance using
water-perfused suits, an integrated cardiovascular re-
sponse ensues. During severe hyperthermia, skin blood
flow can increase to as much as 7–8 L/min. To support
this increase in skin blood flow, cardiac output is raised
by 3L/min/ 1C rise in right atrial blood temperature
(Rowell, 1986). This increase is primarily mediated
through an increase in heart rate although small
increases in stroke volume do occur, despite the falling
right atrial filling pressure. Additionally, approximately
0.6 L/min of blood is redistributed to the skin from the
splanchnic circulation, and 0.4 L/min of blood from the
renal circulation. Muscle blood flow may also be
reduced during passive heat stress and redirected toward
the cutaneous circulation. Due to the volume of blood in
the cutaneous circulation and the lack of muscle pump
activity, right atrial pressure declines.
ARTICLE IN PRESS
W.L. Kenney et al. / Journal of Thermal Biology 29 (2004) 479–485482
3.3. Heat tolerance: duration of exposure
While anecdotal accounts of extreme heat exposure
provide some qualitative insight into the limits of human
heat tolerance, laboratory experiments over the decades
provided ample data relating tolerance time to a given
set of environmental characteristics. Numerous investi-
gators have measured the ‘‘maximal’’ tolerance time in a
given environment, and have used that information to
determine ‘‘safe’’ exposure limits. Figs. 2 and 3 are
drawn using data compiled from the literature in an
attempt to examine the nature of the relation between
environment, rate of rise in T
c
, and tolerance time. To be
included in this analysis, experiments had to satisfy
several critical criteria. These studies needed to report
the time to exhaustion for the group, the change in T
c
(or provide enough data to calculate this variable), and a
description of the subject’s activity level. Additionally,
chamber T
db
and either T
wb
or rh were necessary. As few
laboratory studies over the years have included globe
temperature data (a measure of radiant heat load),
calculation of wet-bulb globe temperature (WBGT)
across the studies was not possible. Alternatively, the
modified discomfort index (MDI) proposed by Moran
and Pandolf (1999) was calculated. Briefly, the MDI is
calculated as (0.75T
wb
)+(0.30T
db
) and correlates well
with WBGT (r40.95). Fig. 2 presents data for the rate
of change in T
c
/h as a function of MDI, compiled from
several studies meeting the aforementioned criteria
(Avellini et al., 1980;Goldman et al., 1965;Iampietro
and Goldman, 1965;Nag et al., 1999, 1997;Pandolf et
al., 1988;Randle and Legg, 1985;Sawka et al., 1983,
1992;Shapiro et al., 1980;Shvartz and Benor, 1972).
Compared to resting exposure, exercise is associated
with a larger rate of change in T
c
/h in a given
environment, in part because of the additional cardio-
vascular strain superimposed on the thermoregulatory
strain. The highest absolute change in T
c
recorded was
2.6 1C (several studies only reported the per hour value,
and the absolute T
c
change was not reported). Fig. 3
shows the relationship between tolerance time (time to
exhaustion or test termination) and MDI. During either
resting or exercising conditions, an increase in MDI
reduced tolerance time in a relatively predictable
fashion. However, exercise data are again shifted to
the left.
4. Thermoregulatory failure
Heat stroke is traditionally defined as a rectal
temperature greater than 40.6 1C, with untoward neu-
rological involvement. This condition is the consequence
of severe cardiovascular strain accompanied by thermo-
regulatory failure. In heat stroke, the internal heat load
overwhelms the capacity of the system, and the
ARTICLE IN PRESS
0
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
25 30 35 40 45 50
MDI, ˚
rate of rise in core temperature, ˚C/h
C
Fig. 2. Rate of rise in core temperature plotted against the mean discomfort index (MDI, a measure of the combined non-radiant
thermal environment similar to WBGT). These data points were derived from a series of published studies meeting finite criteria (see
text). Open circles are from resting exposures while filled circles come from exercise trials. Above an MDI of about 32 1C, both
responses are linear (resting: y=7.4x2.8, R
2
=0.92; exercise: y=4.3x1.4, R
2
=0.84).
W.L. Kenney et al. / Journal of Thermal Biology 29 (2004) 479–485 483
maintenance of core temperature is sacrificed so that
arterial pressure and blood flow to vital organs may be
better maintained (Rowell, 1986). The ensuing cardio-
vascular strain due to heat and progressive dehydration
causes a reduction in skin blood flow and sweating and a
rapid increase in core temperature. Heat stroke is often
associated with multiple organ system damage including
cognitive impairment, acute renal failure, rhabdomyo-
lysis, liver dysfunction with hepatic enzyme elevation,
disseminated intravascular coagulation, and acid base
disturbances (Sutton, 1990).
While a T
c
in excess of 42 1C is usually considered
fatal, T
c
correlates poorly with the severity of organ
dysfunction (Gardner and Kark, 2001). The highest T
c
survived without lasting complications was 46.5 1C
(Slovis et al., 1982). On that day, the ambient high T
db
was 38 1C, with 44% rh. The 52-year-old male victim
reported that he had been cooking indoors all day in a
poorly ventilated room. Emergency medical services
were summoned when the victim failed to answer his
door. Medical personnel recorded a rectal temperature
at the scene of 42 1C, which represented the upper limit
of their thermometer. Upon arriving at the hospital, and
25 min after aggressive cooling had been initiated,
doctors recorded a rectal temperature of 46.5 1C.
Calibration of the thermometer was validated later that
day. In spite of the severe hyperthermia, liver and renal
complications, and disseminated intravascular coagula-
tion, the patient survived and was discharged after 24
days of hospitalization.
5. Summary
This paper has attempted to present anecdotes,
clinical cases, and results of laboratory experiments
related to extremes of heat stress. The purpose has been
two fold: to examine environmental ‘‘extremes’’ in their
many facets, and to highlight the exquisite precision and
adaptability of human thermoregulation.
References
Armstrong, L.E., Hubbard, R., Jones, B., Daniels, J., 1986.
Preparing Alberto Salazar for the heat of the 1984 Olympic
Marathon. Physician and Sportsmedicine 14, 73–81.
Ashcroft, F., 2000. Life at the Extremes: The Science of
Survival. University of California Press, Berkeley.
Avellini, B.A., Shapiro, Y., Pandolf, K.B., Pimental, N.A.,
Goldman, R.F., 1980. Physiological responses of men and
women to prolonged dry heat exposure. Aviation, Space,
Environ. Med. 51, 1081–1085.
ARTICLE IN PRESS
Fig. 3. ‘‘Tolerance’’ time (time to exhaustion or physiological cessation of experimental session) plotted against the modified
discomfort index (MDI). These data points were derived from a series of published studies meeting finite criteria (see text). Open circles
are from resting exposures while filled circles come from exercise trials. Each relationship is well represented by an exponential
function, with the exercise relationship shifted to the left relative to resting data.
W.L. Kenney et al. / Journal of Thermal Biology 29 (2004) 479–485484
Belding, H.S., Kamon, E., 1973. Evaporative coefficients for
prediction of safe limits in prolonged exposures to work
under hot conditions. Federation Proc. 32, 1598–1601.
Gardner, J., Kark, J., 2001. Clinical diagnosis, management,
and surveillance of exertional heat illness. In: Pandolf, K.B.,
Burr, R. (Eds.), Medical Aspects of Harsh Environments.
Office of the Surgeon General, US Army, Falls Church, VA,
pp. 231–279.
Goldman, R., Green, E., Iampietro, P.F., 1965. Tolerance of
hot, wet environments by resting men. J. Appl. Physiol. 20,
271–277.
Iampietro, P.F., Goldman, R.F., 1965. Tolerance of man
working in hot, humid environments. J. Appl. Physiol. 20,
73–76.
Kamler, K., 2004. Surviving the Extremes: A Doctor’s Journal
to the Limits of Human Endurance. St. Martin’s Press, New
York, NY.
Kamon, E., Avellini, B., 1976. Physiologic limits to work in the
heat and evaporative coefficient for women. J. Appl.
Physiol. 41, 71–76.
Kenney, W.L., 1988. Control of heat-induced cutaneous
vasodilation in relation to age. Eur. J. Appl. Physiol. 57,
120–125.
Kenney, W.L., Zeman, M.J., 2002. Psychrometric limits and
critical evaporative coefficients for unacclimated men and
women. J. Appl. Physiol. 92, 2256–2263.
Lind, A.R., 1963. A physiological criterion for setting thermal
environmental limits for everyday work. J. Appl. Physiol.
18, 51–56.
Minson, C.T., Wladkowski, S.L., Cardell, A.F., Pawelczyk,
J.A., Kenney, W.L., 1998. Age alters the cardiovascular
response to direct passive heating. J. Appl. Physiol. 84,
1323–1332.
Moran, D.S., Pandolf, K.B., 1999. Wet bulb globe temperature
(WBGT)—to what extent is GT essential? Aviat. Space
Environ. Med. 70, 480–484.
Nag, P.K., Ashtekar, S.P., Nag, A., Kothari, D., Bandyopad-
hyay, P., Desai, H., 1997. Human heat tolerance in
simulated environment. Indian J. Med. Res. 105, 226–234.
Nag, A., Kothari, D., Desai, H., 1999. Exposure limits of
women in hot environment. Indian J. Med. Res. 110,
138–144.
Pandolf, K.B., Cadarette, B., Sawka, M.N., Young, A.J.,
Fransesconi, R., Gonzalez, R.R., 1988. Thermoregulatory
responses of middle-aged and young men during dry-heat
acclimation. J. Appl. Physiol. 65, 65–71.
Randle, I.P., Legg, S.J., 1985. A comparison of the effects of
mixed static and dynamic work with mainly dynamic work
in hot conditions. Eur. J. Appl. Physiol. Occup. Physiol. 54,
201–206.
Rowell, L.B., 1974. Human cardiovascular adjustments to
exercise and thermal stress. Physiol. Rev. 54, 75–159.
Rowell, L.B., 1983. Cardiovascular aspects of human thermo-
regulation. Circ. Res. 52, 367–379.
Rowell, L.B., 1986. Human Circulation: Regulation During
Physical Stress. Oxford University Press, New York.
Rowell, L.B., Brengelmann, G.L., Blackmon, J.R., Murray,
J.A., 1970. Redistribution of blood flow during sustained
high skin temperature in resting man. J. Appl. Physiol. 28,
415–420.
Saltin, B., Hermansen, L., 1966. Esophageal, rectal, and muscle
temperature during exercise. J. Appl. Physiol. 21,
1757–1762.
Sawka, M.N., Pandolf, K.B., 1990. Effects of body water loss
on physiological function and exercise performance. In:
Gisolfi, C., Lamb, D. (Eds.), Fluid Homeostasis During
Exercise. Cooper Publishing Group, Traverse City, MI, pp.
1–38.
Sawka, M.N., Toner, M.M., Francesconi, R.P., Pandolf, K.B.,
1983. Hypohydration and exercise: effects of heat acclima-
tion, gender, and environment. J. Appl. Physiol. 55,
1147–1153.
Sawka, M.N., Young, A.J., Francesconi, R.P., Muza, S.R.,
Pandolf, K.B., 1985. Thermoregulatory and blood re-
sponses during exercise at graded hypohydration levels. J.
Appl. Physiol. 59, 1394–1401.
Sawka, M.N., Young, A.J., Latzka, W.A., Neufer, P.D.,
Quigley, M.D., Pandolf, K.B., 1992. Human tolerance to
heat strain during exercise: influence of hydration. J. Appl.
Physiol. 73, 368–375.
Shapiro, Y., Pandolf, K.B., Avellini, B.A., Pimental, N.A.,
Goldman, R.F., 1980. Physiological responses of men and
women to humid and dry heat. J. Appl. Physiol. 49, 1–8.
Shvartz, E., Benor, D., 1972. Heat strain in hot and humid
environments. Aerospace Med. 43, 852–855.
Slovis, C.M., Anderson, G.F., Casolaro, A., 1982. Survival in a
heat stroke victim with a core temperature in excess of 46.5
C. Ann. Emerg. Med. 11, 269–271.
Sutton, J., 1990. Clinical Implications of Fluid Imbalance. In:
Gisolfi, C., Lamb, D. (Eds.), Fluid Homeostasis During
Exercise. Cooper Publishing Group, Traverse City, MI, pp.
425–448.
White, L.J., Jackson, F., McMullen, M.J., Lystad, J., Jones,
J.S., Hubers, R.H., 1998. Continuous core temperature
monitoring of search and rescue divers during extreme
conditions. Prehospital Emerg. Care 2, 280–284.
ARTICLE IN PRESS
W.L. Kenney et al. / Journal of Thermal Biology 29 (2004) 479–485 485
... Through repeated exposure to heightened ambient and metabolic 14 temperatures, these physiological processes become increasingly efficient at removing 15 excessive heat, known as heat acclimation (Périard & Racinais, 2019). 16 With excessive heat stress, heat strain occurs (Kenney, Degroot, & Holowatz, 2004). ...
... Arguably, the only truly significant differences in cognitive function would occur at the 3 extreme ends of human tolerance and so would be essentially testing performance at a state 4 precariously close to death (Kenney et al., 2004). The risks of conducting such research are 5 ethically questionable. ...
... Humans involved in certain sporting, military, and occupational settings frequently face the challenge of sustaining prolonged bouts of physical exertion while simultaneously maintaining a high level of cognitive functioning (1)(2)(3)(4)(5)(6)(7)(8)(9)(10). Traditional investigations into the influence of thermal strain on human performance have focused predominantly on physiological responses, including body temperature, perspiration, heart rate, and hydration statuses (11)(12)(13)(14)(15)(16)(17)(18)(19)(20). While comparatively less attention has been given to investigating how the same stressors may impact cognitive functions, this topic has garnered increased interest in recent years (10,(21)(22)(23)(24). ...
... Several physiological characteristics influence the ability to maintain core temperature within a compensable zone. Responses to thermal gain and dissipation primarily rely on heat acclimatisation status, total body adiposity, body mass, surface area, and body mass to surface area ratios (20,80). Typically, women have higher total body adiposity, higher surface area to mass ratio (i.e., are smaller in size), and lower maximal oxygen consumption (V O2max) compared to men (80,127). ...
... Corrupted data refers to information that was unprocessable due to equipment malfunctions or transmission issues. Implausible data, such as heart rate below 40 bpm or above the maximum predicted by the Tanaka formula 45 and CBT readings outside the range of 35°C-42°C, were treated as outliers 46,47 . Data availability was defined as the proportion of participants (n = 48) from whom at least one usable data recording was retrieved. ...
... During exercise the increase in T c normally plateaus after about 30 minutes (33). The continued rise in T c that we observed after that must have been due to the inability of the participants to achieve heat balance (34). While the monitoring of T c can provide information on whether a given exposure is compensable for a majority of people, it may not predict the development of symptoms, at least in untrained individuals (35). ...
... Humans are thought to be highly efficient thermoregulators when exposed to heat stress (Bligh, 1967;McKechnie and Wolf, 2019). They are able to survive Ta exposures exceeding 110˚C (Blagden, 1775;Murray, 1966) and exploit EWL rates upwards of 3.5 L hr -1 (Armstrong et al., 1986;Eichna et al., 1945), with unofficial reporting's of rates of EWL as high as 5.6 L hr -1 (Kenney et al., 2004), making them anomalous to the majority of other mammals. Small mammals, in contrast, are known to have limited capacities to counter high heat stress through evaporative cooling as a result of limitations imposed by their fur and size (Hoole et al., 2019;Schmidt-Nielsen, 1975), resulting in a much reduced capacity to counter thermal stress by comparison. ...
Thesis
Full-text available
As the Anthropocene continues to be characterised by ever rising temperature highs, increasingly sporadic and extreme climatic events, and their accompanying mass mortality events, climate scientists now warn that the continued climate destabilisation may for the first time in recorded history prevent terrestrial homeothermic endotherms from being able to thermoregulate. Having evolved to maintain body temperatures (Tbs) well above their ambient (Ta) conditions, these endotherms have evolved a suite of adaptations to a colder environment to allow for homeothermic thermoregulation to occur. However, by the same vein, having evolved in a colder climate to stay warm also has led to a reduced capacity to prevent heat stress when temperature conditions are elevated. In absence of behavioural counter measures, the only physiological means available to thermoregulation to prevent such heat stress is that of evaporative water loss (EWL). If still inefficient, the endotherm will risk becoming hyperthermic. Literature has established that excessive heat exposure or reduced evaporative cooling capacities strain or retard thermoregulatory processes. If an endotherm experiences severe heat exposure, the rate at which passive heating is experienced will increase. Should an endotherm be in a humid environment, evaporative cooling efficiency is reduced. As a result, these two abiotic factors are therefore known to contribute towards heat storage, and therefore thermal stress. However, should both factors occur in the same environment, the heat stress effects are compounded, creating an environment dangerous for thermoregulating endotherms. For this reason, authors have emphasised that future wet-bulb (Tw) conditions may pose a penultimate threat to thermoregulating endotherms. Being a measure of coldest temperature attainable as a result of evaporative cooling, Tw has been proposed to represent a lower temperature thermal limit to endothermic thermoregulation. Once reaching a 2°C differential below an endotherms Tb (Tb – Tw = 2˚C), Tw is believed to impede the evaporative cooling process and, consequentially, commit endotherms to becoming hyperthermic. Considering that most mammals defend constant Tbs within the range of predicted Tw maxima increases that future Tw conditions may pose a significant threat to mammalian thermoregulation. However, to date, despite being well supported in the literature, empirical investigations into how extreme Tw conditions will affect endothermic thermoregulation are scant. Therefore, understanding of the proposed inhibitory nature of extreme Tw conditions is lacking. Considering that such conditions are to have a profound effect of endothermic survival, this dearth in understanding could prove fatal. As such, this thesis sought to provide evidence on how extreme Tw conditions may affect thermoregulatory processes in homeothermic endotherms. By measuring the rates of heat storage in a small obligate homeothermic mammal, the Four-striped grass mouse (Rhabdomys pumilio, n = 21), an investigation into how extreme Tw conditions approaching an endotherms Tb may affect its thermoregulatory responses, was conducted. Using a combination of the push open-flow respirometry design and intraperitoneally injected, temperature sensitive passively integrated transponder tags, a fine scale resolution dataset was generated by measuring the shifts in Tb, metabolic rate, and EWL in response to prolonged static Tw heat stress. In doing so, an understanding of how the rates of heat storage differed between Tw conditions at Tws approaching the endothermic Tb was attained. Consequentially, an understanding of how Tw heat stress will affect thermoregulatory processes while approaching the proposed Tw limit was drawn. Wet-bulb temperature was found to enforce a lower limit on thermoregulatory processes. However, this occurred at a significantly lower Tb – Tw differential than the 2˚C reported in literature. In the grass mice, thermoregulatory inhibition occurred at 33˚C (Tb – Tw  4˚C) rather than at the predicted Tw of 35˚C (Tb – Tw = 2˚C). At this point, 50% of the mice needed to be removed from the experiment within the first 110 minutes of the trial to avoid lethal hyperthermia. By contrast, at the lower Tws used (Tw = 30˚C – 32˚C), mice were largely able to be tolerate the level of heat exposure for the trial duration of 220 minutes, with insignificant differences being detected in all measured indicators of hyperthermic stress between these condition (p > 0.05 for all treatment metrics). While exposed to the 33˚C Tw, not only were the rates of heat storage significantly higher than in other treatments (p < 0.01), but also the rates of EWL used despite the reliance on facultative hyperthermia (p = 0.01). These findings indicated not only that Tws can enforce a lower limit on thermoregulatory processes, but also that the threat these conditions may pose is likely underestimated. However, as Tw is comprised of both heat and humidity components, of which both occur heterogeneously in the natural world, it was also key to understand how the interplay between heat and humidity conditions may differ the effect of Tw on thermoregulatory processes. Literature currently champions humidity as the key driver to thermoregulatory inhibition in terrestrial endotherms owing to its inverse relationship with evaporative cooling. However, it was found that the primary driver towards Tw induced hyperthermia was not the inhibition of evaporative cooling, but rather the extreme Tas associated with high T¬w exposure. When exposing the mice to identical Tws while using different humidities, the Tbs that mice defended were significantly different (p = 0.001). Individuals defended Tbs ~1˚C higher when exposed to a lower humidity and higher Ta (Tb = 38.11 ± 0.455˚C) than when exposed to a higher humidity and lower Ta (Tb = 37.02 ± 0.870˚C). Similarly, the treatment combination of low humidity and high Ta resulted in significantly higher rates of EWL (p = 0.002). As such, the results suggest that the primary risk factor to homeothermic mammal thermoregulation regarding elevated wet-bulb temperatures is less likely to be the inhibition of heat as a result of increased humidity limiting evaporative cooling, but rather high Tas driving heat storage beyond the capacities of evaporative cooling to prevent hyperthermia. Collectively, this thesis found that Tw conditions do certainly pose a threat to thermoregulatory processes in homeothermic endotherms, however this threat is mainly driven by the Ta conditions associated with Tw heat stress. As such, considering the comparatively slower elevations in extreme Tw conditions versus the extreme and sporadic Ta elevations predicted to occur as a result of global warming, Tw as a threat is merely secondary to Ta conditions and the increasing extremes that future Tas are predicted to bring about
Article
We developed a hydrogel controlled by near-infrared light. The NIR light excites nanoparticles to produce upconversion luminescence and polymerizes gelatin monomers into the long-chain compound GelMa in the presence of the photoinitiator LAP.
Preprint
Full-text available
Sub-Saharan Africa is experiencing increased heat events due to climate change, affecting health and productivity. Wearable technology, though promising for monitoring these impacts, is underexplored in this region. This pilot study assessed the feasibility and acceptability of research-grade wearables in Kenyan subsistence farmers. In Siaya, Kenya, 48 farmers (50% women) were monitored for 14 days using wearable sensors for physiological (heart rate and core temperature), sleep, activity and geo-location data, and data loggers for environmental factors, including wet bulb globe temperature. Participants rated their experiences with wearables using a 5-point Likert scale. Acceptability was high, with over 95% reporting likability and minimal disruption to daily routines. Data availability ranged from 88% (actigraphy) to 100% (core temperature), with median completeness at 100% for most wearables. Women experienced higher heat strain than men. Overall, the study demonstrates that research-grade wearables are both highly acceptable and feasible for monitoring environmental impacts on work capacity and wellbeing in rural Africa. Authors Sandra Barteit and Martina Anna Maggioni share the senior authorship.
Article
The purpose of this research is to discuss the effect of human physiological factors on thermal comfort indoors. In the natural ventilation environment in summer, the effectiveness of human physiology adjustment on alleviating thermal discomfort was discussed through indoor thermal environment measurement, physiological experiment test, questionnaire, and other methods. The influence of skin temperature and sweat on human thermal sensation was analyzed. The results showed that the influence of skin temperature and sweat on human thermal sensation in summer could not be ignored. A modified predicted mean vote (mPMV) based on predicted mean vote (PMV) is proposed, and the accuracy of the model is evaluated. The results show that the mPMV meets the accuracy requirements at the application level and can be used for thermal sensation prediction in partially hot summer environments. A comparative analysis of thermoneutral temperature differences (TDE) calculated from mPMV and PMV revealed that the human body extends the range of acceptable temperature differences by 0.9 scales at one end through physiological. With the largely improved prediction quality, the research contributes to the development of energy-efficient thermal comfort buildings that benefit human health.
Article
The disparity between the postoperative outcomes of rhinoplasty and the expected results frequently necessitates secondary or multiple surgeries as a compensatory measure, greatly diminishing patient satisfaction. However, there is renewed optimism for addressing these challenges through the innovative realm of Four-Dimensional (4D) printing. This groundbreaking technology enables three-dimensional objects with shape-memory properties to undergo predictable transformations under specific external stimuli. Consequently, implants crafted using 4D printing offer significant potential for dynamic adjustments. Inspired by worms in our research, we harnessed 4D printing to fabricate a Shape-Memory Polyurethane (SMPU) for use as a nasal augmentation prosthesis. The choice of SMPU was guided by its Glass Transition Temperature (Tg), which falls within the acceptable temperature range for the human body. This attribute allowed for temperature-responsive intraoperative self-deformation and postoperative remodeling. Our chosen animal model for experimentation was rabbits. Taking into account the anatomical structure of the rabbit nose, we designed and produced nasal augmentation prostheses with superior biocompatibility. These prostheses were then surgically implanted in a minimally invasive manner into the rabbit noses. Remarkably, they exhibited successful temperature-controlled in-surgery self-deformation according to the predetermined shape and non-invasive remodeling within a mere 9 days post-surgery. Subsequent histological evaluations confirmed the practical viability of these prostheses in a living organism. Our research findings posit that worm-inspired 4D-printed SMPU nasal prostheses hold significant promise for achieving dynamic aesthetic adjustments.
Article
Full-text available
This study determined whether 1) exhaustion from heat strain occurs at the same body temperatures during exercise in the heat when subjects are euhydrated as when they are hypohydrated, 2) aerobic fitness influences the body temperature at which exhaustion from heat strain occurs, and 3) curves could be developed to estimate exhaustion rates at a given level of physiological strain. Seventeen heat-acclimated men [maximal oxygen uptake (VO2max) from 45 to 65 ml.kg-1.min-1] attempted two heat stress tests (HSTs): one when euhydrated and one when hypohydrated by 8% of total body water. The HSTs consisted of 180 min of rest and treadmill walking (45% VO2max) in a hot-dry (ambient temperature 49 degrees C, relative humidity 20%) environment. The required evaporative cooling (Ereq) exceeded the maximal evaporative cooling capacity of the environment (Emax); thus thermal equilibrium could not be achieved and 27 of 34 HSTs ended by exhaustion from heat strain. Our findings concerning exhaustion from heat strain are 1) hypohydration reduced the core temperature that could be tolerated; 2) aerobic fitness, per se, did not influence the magnitude of heat strain that could be tolerated; 3) curves can be developed to estimate exhaustion rates for a given level of physiological strain; and 4) exhaustion was rarely associated with a core temperature up to 38 degrees C, and it always occurred before a temperature of 40 degrees C was achieved. These findings are applicable to heat-acclimated individuals performing moderate-intensity exercise under conditions where Ereq approximates or exceeds Emax and who have high skin temperatures.
Article
Studies were conducted on 10-man groups exposed at rest to 51 different hot, wet environmental conditions."Tolerance times" of unacclimatized volunteers established objectively, as the time of occurrence of a rectal temperature of 102.5 F and/or a heart rate of 180 beat/min, were similar to reported values established on a subjective basis. The wet and dry bulb index (WD) of environment was the best predictor of tolerance time. Prior acclimatization to work in hot, dry conditions did not result in prolonged tolerance for resting men exposed to hot, wet environments; neither did it alter the rates of sweat production, the final skin temperatures, or the rates of increase in heart rate or rectal temperature during these resting, hot, wet environmental exposures. Finally, "passive" resting in hot, wet environments (up to 3 hr/day) did not prolong tolerance times or induce other manifestations of heat acclimatization during subsequent resting exposures to hot, wet environments for either unacclimatized or prior, hot, dry, acclimatized subjects. heat tolerance; acclimatization; sweat rates; heart rates; body temperatures; environmental indices Submitted on June 17, 1964
Article
Observations were made on American marathon record holder Alberto Salazar during a climatic chamber trial, heat acclimatization training, and the 1984 Olympic Marathon. Blood samples and rectal temperature data showed that hormonal and thermoregulatory mechanisms were normal. However, measurements of a very high sweat rate (2.79 liter/hr and 3.06 liter/hr) indicated that dehydration was a potentially serious problem. In fact, Salazar lost 5.43 kg (-8.1 percent) during the Olympic marathon, in 134.3 minutes of running. Although Salazar's decreased rectal temperature was desireable, his increased sweat rate was an unnecessary physiological adaptation to training in the heat. Keywords include: Exercise, physical training, gastric emptying, body weight, and iron deficiency.
Article
During direct passive heating in young men, a dramatic increase in skin blood flow is achieved by a rise in cardiac output (Q(c)) and redistribution of flow from the splanchnic and renal vascular beds. To examine the effect of age on these responses, seven young (Y; 23 ± 1 yr) and seven older (O; 70 ± 3 yr) men were passively heated with water-perfused suits to their individual limit of thermal tolerance. Measurements included heart rate (HR), Q(c) (by acetylene rebreathing), central venous pressure (via peripherally inserted central catheter), blood pressures (by brachial auscultation), skin blood flow (from increases in forearm blood flow by venous occlusion plethysmography), splanchnic blood flow (by indocyanine green clearance), renal blood flow (by p-aminohippurate clearance), and esophageal and mean skin temperatures. Q(c) was significantly lower in the older than in the young men (11.1 ± 0.7 and 7.4 ± 0.21/min in Y and O, respectively, at the limit of thermal tolerance; P < 0.05), despite similar increases in esophageal and mean skin temperatures and time to reach the limit of thermal tolerance. A lower stroke volume (99 ± 7 and 68 ± 4 ml/beat in Y and O, respectively, P < 0.05), most likely due to an attenuated increase in inotropic function during heating, was the primary factor for the lower Q(c) observed in the older men. Increases in HR were similar in the young and older men; however, when expressed as a percentage of maximal HR, the older men relied on a greater proportion of their chronotropic reserve to obtain the same HR response (62 ± 3 and 75 ± 4% maximal HR in Y and O, respectively, P < 0.05). Furthermore, the older men redistributed less blood flow from the combined splanchnic and renal circulations at the limit of thermal tolerance (960 ± 80 and 720 ± 100 ml/min in Y and O, respectively, P < 0.05). As a result of these combined attenuated responses, the older men had a significantly lower increase in total blood flow directed to the skin.
Article
Ten heat-acclimated females exercised seminude on a treadmill at 30% Vo2 max (M=152 W-m-2) under eight air temperatures (Ta) ranging from 30 degrees C to 52 degrees C. Each experiment involved 1 h of fixed and a 2nd h of progressively increasing water vapor pressure (Pw) with either air movement of 1 m-s-1 or still air. The equilibrium values of rectal temperature (Tre), mean skin temperature (Tsk),and heart rate (HR) reached in the 1st h were forced upwards in the 2nd h by the rising Pw. The critical Pw was defined by the Tre inflection point for each Ta. The loci of the critical Pw were used to delineate the thermal limits on the psychrometric chart and were used to derive the effective evaporative coefficient (Ke') applicable to the ambient capacity for evaporative cooling (Emax). The derived Ke' was 17.6 +/- 4.2 W-m-2 (mean +/- SD) for v0.6m-s-1. Isotherms constructed on the basis of the obtained Ké, Tsk, and sweating capacity were higher than the physiologically based Pw limits.
Article
Well matched unacclimatised older (age 55–68, 4 women, 2 men) and younger (age 19–30, 4 women, 2 men) subjects performed 75 min cycle exercise (∼40%V˙O2max\dot V_{{\text{O}}_{{\text{2max}}} } ) in a hot environment (37°C, 60% rh). Rectal temperature (T re), mean skin temperature (¯T sk), arm blood flow (ABF, strain gauge plethysmography), and cardiac output (Q, CO2 rebreathing) were measured to examine age-related differences in heat-induced vasodilatation.T re and¯T sk rose to the same extent in each group during the exposure. There was no significant intergroup difference in sweat rate (older: 332±43 ml · m−2 · h−1, younger: 435±49 ml · m−2 · h−1; mean±SEM). However, the older subjects responded to exercise in the heat with a lower ABF response which could be attributed to a lowerQ˙\dot Q for the same exercise intensity. The slope of the ABF-T re relationship was attenuated in the older subjects (9.3±1.3 vs 17.9±3.3 ml · 100 ml−1 · min−1 · °C−1,p <0.05), but theT re threshold for vasodilatation was about 37.0°C for both groups. These results suggest an altered control of skin vasodilatation during exercise in the heat in older individuals. This attenuated ABF response appears to be unrelated toV˙O2max\dot V_{{\text{O}}_{{\text{2max}}} } , and may reflect an age-related change in thermoregulatory cardiovascular function.