In this work we studied the trophodynamics of five potentially toxic trace elements, chromium (Cr), cobalt (Co), silver (Ag), arsenic (As) and selenium (Se), in the biota of 3 lakes belonging to Nahuel Huapi and Los Alerces National Parks (NHNP and LNP respectively), as well as some aspects of the toxicological risk for humans and biota. From the trace elements quoted above, Ag, Cr, and Co were associated in previous work with anthropogenic contamination, with concentrations of Ag in fish livers among the highest reported globally.
This study was focused at 2 levels, a) the whole biota of Lake Moreno (NHNP) and b) the top predator fish from the same lake and from Lakes Futalaufquen (LNP) and Nahuel Huapi (NHNP). Samples from plankton, benthos and nekton communities were taken between 2004 and 2009 through conventional methods. Elements concentrations were measured by using Instrumental Neutron Activation Analysis in Centro Atómico Bariloche. The trophodynamics of elements was studied through the C and N stable isotopes ratios technique, en “Queen´s Facility for Isotope Research, at The Stable Isotope and ICP/MS Laboratory at Queen‟s University, Canada.
Concerning the trophodynamics of Ag, As and Co, the C source (benthic- littoral or pelagic) analysis in the diet of organisms from Lake Moreno, showed no differences between its 2 basins. On the opposite, between-basins differences arose concerning Cr and probably Se. Based on supporting evidence, the present work hypothesizes, for the first time, that the morphology of a lake (lake Moreno) influences the trophodynamics of Cr, and probably Se.
In the biota of Lake Moreno, a general pattern of biodilution of Ag was observed between primary producers and the forage fish G. maculatus when whole body [Ag] was analyzed. Nevertheless when considering the whole food web trend, and hepatic [Ag] of top predator fish, a biomagnification pattern was observed. The present work evaluates the trophodynamics and reports tissue-specific biomagnification of Ag in a whole fresh water ecosystem for the first time.
Chromium, Co and As showed biodilution patterns in the 2 basins of Lake Moreno whereas Se did not present any pattern. Furthermore, fish from the western basin had higher [Cr] that those from the eastern one, probably due to a higher proportion of benthic-littoral preys in their diets.
Some trophodynamic trends observed in the whole food web of Lake Moreno were reflected in top predator fish from the same lake and from the lakes Futalaufquen and Nahuel Huapi considered together. Both in the whole biota from Lake Moreno, and in top predator fish from the 3 lakes, the C source was important for Cr trophodynamics but not for Co, As and Ag. On the opposite, the biodilution pattern observed in the whole food web of Lake Moreno for Co and As, was not reflected in top predator fish from the 3 lakes.
Relative to risk, trace element concentrations measured in muscle tissue of top predator fish from different lakes (exposure source for humans) enable us to state that, with the possible exceptions of Cr (minimal risk levels are not set for total Cr) and chronic exposures to As, there is no risk evidence for human health. In the case of Ag,
VI
experimental studies including fish eating vertebrates like the Kelp Gull and the endangered Southern River Otter, could be of interest.