ArticlePDF Available

Individualism-CollectivismA Study of Cross-Cultural Researchers

June 1986
Journal of Cross-Cultural Psychology 17(2):225-248

DOI:10.1177/0022002186017002006

Authors:

C. Harry Hui

The University of Hong Kong

Harry Triandis

University of Illinois, Urbana-Champaign

Individualism and collectivism are terms used by both social scientists and the public, but there are few systematic studies of this dimension. A sample of psychologists and anthropologists from all parts of the world was asked to respond to a questionnaire the way they believe an individualist and a collectivist would respond. The questionnaire described 10 target persons in seven situations. The responses converged, suggesting that there is consensus about the meaning of the dimension. Accordingly, collectivism can be defined as (1) concern by a person about the effects of actions or decisions on others, (2) sharing of material benefits, (3) sharing of nonmaterial resources, (4) willingness of the person to accept the opinions and views of others, (5) concern about self-presentation and loss of face, (6) belief in the correspondence of own outcomes with the outcomes of others, and (7) feeling of involvement in and contribution to the lives of others. Individualists show less concern, sharing, and so on than collectivists. The approach can be used with other relatively unstudied constructs to establish whether there is consensus among researchers about the meaning of a construct.

Content uploaded by C. Harry Hui

Content may be subject to copyright.

http://jcc.sagepub.com/

Psychology

Journal of Cross-Cultural

http://jcc.sagepub.com/content/17/2/225

The online version of this article can be found at:

DOI: 10.1177/0022002186017002006

1986 17: 225Journal of Cross-Cultural Psychology

C. Harry Hui and Harry C. Triandis

Individualism-Collectivism : A Study of Cross-Cultural Researchers

Published by:

http://www.sagepublications.com

On behalf of:

International Association for Cross-Cultural Psychology

at:

can be foundJournal of Cross-Cultural PsychologyAdditional services and information for

http://jcc.sagepub.com/cgi/alertsEmail Alerts:

http://jcc.sagepub.com/subscriptionsSubscriptions:

http://www.sagepub.com/journalsReprints.navReprints:

http://www.sagepub.com/journalsPermissions.navPermissions:

http://jcc.sagepub.com/content/17/2/225.refs.htmlCitations:

What is This?

- Jun 1, 1986Version of Record >>

at University of Hong Kong Libraries on November 15, 2011jcc.sagepub.comDownloaded from

Thai EFL teachers' self-reported levels of intercultural communicative competence and intercultural sensitivity

Article

Full-text available

Mar 2023

Pariwat Imsa-ard

Individuals must be interculturally competent and sensitive in today's globalised society to interact effectively with members of other societies. EFL teachers, as critical stakeholders in language education, must be interculturally competent and sensitive to enhance their students' intercultural communicative competence (ICC) and intercultural sensitivity (IS). The purpose of this research was to ascertain Thai EFL secondary school teachers' views regarding ICC, levels of ICC and IS, and the relationship between their IS and ICC. 395 Thai EFL teachers completed the ICC questionnaire and the IS scale. Additionally, six of them took part in follow-up interviews. Descriptive statistics indicated that Thai EFL teachers had good ICC and IS levels. A correlational study indicated significant correlations between the different components of ICC and IS, with the exception of the relationship between the knowledge dimension of ICC and the respect for other cultures and interaction enjoyment dimensions of IS. Finally, the implications and future research recommendations are presented to complement the results and assist the development of English language textbooks that foster a knowledge of language and cultural diversity.

The impact of pandemic mental cognition on cultural values: an empirical study based on social media

Article

Full-text available

Jun 2023
BMC PUBLIC HEALTH

Background COVID-19 has triggered a global public health crisis, and had an impact on economies, societies, and politics around the world. Based on the pathogen prevalence hypothesis suggested that residents of areas with higher infection rates are more likely to be collectivists as compared with those of areas with lower infection rates. Many researchers had studied the direct link between infectious diseases and individualism/collectivism (infectious diseases→ cultural values), but no one has focused on the specific psychological factors between them: (infectious diseases→ cognition of the pandemic→ cultural values). To test and develop the pathogen prevalence hypothesis, we introduced pandemic mental cognition and conducted an empirical study on social media (Chinese Sina Weibo), hoping to explore the psychological reasons behind in cultural value changes in the context of a pandemic. Methods We downloaded all posts from active Sina Weibo users in Dalian during the pandemic period (January 2020 to May 2022) and used dictionary-based approaches to calculate frequency of words from two domains (pandemic mental cognition and collectivism/individualism), respectively. Then we used the multiple log-linear regression analysis method to establish the relationship between pandemic mental cognition and collectivism/individualism. Results Among three dimensions of pandemic mental cognition, only the sense of uncertainty had a significant positive relationship with collectivism, and also had a marginal significant positive relationship with individualism. There was a significant positive correlation between the first-order lag term AR(1) and individualism, which means the individualism tendency was mainly affected by its previous level. Conclusions The study found that more collectivist regions are associated with a higher pathogen burden, and recognized the sense of uncertainty as its underlying cause. Results of this study validated and further developed the pathogen stress hypothesis in the context of the COVID-19 pandemic.

CHALLENGE STRESS, HINDRANCE STRESS AND WORK RELATED OUTCOMES: A CROSS CULTURAL STUDY

Thesis

Full-text available

Mar 2009

Shima Husen

This study examined the relationship between challenge-related stress and hindrance-related stress with motivation, work satisfaction, and burnout among healthcare professionals in Canada (N=84) and the Middle East (N=245). A model was proposed where two cultural dimensions (Individualism and Uncertainty Avoidance) and social support were proposed as moderators. A structured questionnaire was used to collect data from Canadian healthcare professionals working in hospitals in Montreal and their Arab counterparts working in hospitals in three Middle Eastern countries (Egypt, Jordan, and the United Arab Emirates). Standardized scales with proven psychometric properties were used for all the variables in the study. To analyze the data, Pearson correlation and moderated multiple regression were used. Challenge stress and hindrance stress were both significantly positively related to burnout in the Canadian and Middle Eastern samples. Some differential effects were found in terms of the relationship between the two types of stress and work satisfaction and motivation. The proposed moderator effects were generally supported by the data. Relationships were compared in both samples. Potential implications and directions for future research were highlighted.

Disability in South Asia: Historical understanding through family, religion, and support structure

Article

Full-text available

Apr 2023

This conceptual paper explores some aspects of social and cultural diversity of South Asia with particular attention given to traditions related to family, society, religions and disability. Families’ attitudes towards disabilities are associated with families’ cultural meanings of disability, preparation for dealing with disability and coping strategies. And religious understanding of disability as causal factor of karma, punishment or god’s anger in text and practice inl uences attitudes towards people with disabilities and interventions. h ese dichotomized dif erences between disability policy initiatives and actual practices need to be revised and to reclaim regional disability history for better understating disability culturally same as socially. Key words: South Asia, disability, religion, family, culture, support, disability history, Hinduism, Islam, Buddhism.

Family First: Evidence of Consistency and Variation in the Value of Family Versus Personal Happiness Across 49 Different Cultures

Article

Mar 2023
J CROSS CULT PSYCHOL

People care about their own well-being and about the well-being of their families. It is currently, however, unknown how much people tend to value their own versus their family’s well-being. A recent study documented that people value family happiness over personal happiness across four cultures. In this study, we sought to replicate this finding across a larger sample size ( N = 12,819) and a greater number of countries ( N = 49). We found that the strength of the idealization of family over personal happiness preference was small (average Cohen’s ds = .20, range −.02 to.48), but present in 98% of the studied countries, with statistical significance in 73% to 75%, and variance across countries <2%. We also found that the size of this effect did vary somewhat across cultural contexts. In Latin American cultures highest on relational mobility, the idealization of family over personal happiness was very small (average Cohen’s ds for Latin America = .15 and .18), while in Confucian Asia cultures lowest on relational mobility, this effect was closer to medium ( ds > .40 and .30). Importantly, we did not find strong support for traditional theories in cross-cultural psychology that associate collectivism with greater prioritization of the family versus the individual; country-level individualism–collectivism was not associated with variation in the idealization of family versus individual happiness. Our findings indicate that no matter how much various populists abuse the argument of “protecting family life” to disrupt emancipation, family happiness seems to be a pan-culturally phenomenon. Family well-being is a key ingredient of social fabric across the world, and should be acknowledged by psychology and well-being researchers and by progressive movements too.

Three reasons why parental burnout is more prevalent in individualistic countries: a mediation study in 36 countries

Article

Full-text available

May 2023
SOC PSYCH PSYCH EPID

Purpose The prevalence of parental burnout, a condition that has severe consequences for both parents and children, varies dramatically across countries and is highest in Western countries characterized by high individualism. Method In this study, we examined the mediators of the relationship between individualism measured at the country level and parental burnout measured at the individual level in 36 countries (16,059 parents). Results The results revealed three mediating mechanisms, that is, self-discrepancies between socially prescribed and actual parental selves, high agency and self-directed socialization goals, and low parental task sharing, by which individualism leads to an increased risk of burnout among parents. Conclusion The results confirm that the three mediators under consideration are all involved, and that mediation was higher for self-discrepancies between socially prescribed and actual parental selves, then parental task sharing, and lastly self-directed socialization goals. The results provide some important indications of how to prevent parental burnout at the societal level in Western countries.

Life stories of graduate students in Chile and the United States: influences on becoming a scientist from childhood to adulthood

Article

Apr 2023
INT J SCI EDUC

The ways in which children and adolescents become interested in science have been well studied. However, little is known from a lifespan perspective about how this process continues from childhood through adulthood. This cross-national study builds an understanding of doctoral students in the sciences in the Chile and the United States and how they choose to pursue careers in the life sciences from childhood to adulthood. Fifteen Chilean and 15 U.S. doctoral students were interviewed using the life story approach. The qualitative analysis indicates that the main difference between the two groups when pursuing science across their lifespans was their valuation of and experience with different learning approaches, with ‘collectivist’ approaches being more typical for the Chilean students and ‘individualist’ approaches for the U.S. students. On the other hand, the principal similarities between the two groups were related to participants’ experiences and perceptions of science at each life stage: ‘playing science’ as children, ‘studying science’ as adolescents, ‘doing science’ as young adults and undergrads, and ‘labouring in science’ and ‘practising science’ as professionals and doctoral students. Implications for pedagogical practice and planning for science teaching and teacher training are addressed.

Administrative Efficiency of Old Age Homes in Geriatric Care and the Level of Satisfaction of Inmates: A Study in Kottayam District

Article

Full-text available

Feb 2023

Purpose: By reviewing the available literature this paper made a solid foundation to the current scenario of old age homes in geriatric care as a social necessity and the satisfaction of the inmates is a factor which measures the administrative efficiency of the old age homes. Administrative inefficiency and inadequacy of governance may contribute to poor treatment and poor treatment of members in old age homes. Medical care provided to the inmates in the old age homes is a major factor which contributes to the satisfaction level of the inmates along with several other factors. This study was taken place to examine the level of satisfaction of the inmates on the infrastructural factors such as atmosphere, facilities, environment, and behavior of staff toward the elderly inmates. Objective: The study tries to examine the administrative efficiency of old age homes for the elderly and the inmate’s level of satisfaction. Design/Methodology/Approach: The codes are taken from the literature and used in the review of literature. This research was explanatory research that was conducted through an exploratory approach. On the internet's platform, desktop research was carried out. Almost 100 research articles were reviewed in depth and studied to identify the research gap. Findings/Result: The review of the articles indicates elderly are quite satisfied with the efficiency of old age homes and they are happy to be there in the old age homes other than being isolated at home and also, they are comfortable with their embers in the caretaking homes. In this study it can be found that the level of satisfaction of old age home inmates is different from each other as there are different types of paid and non-paid old age homes. Originality/Value: This review presents key findings from studies that show the level of satisfaction of the inmates in the old age home. This article was unique in its way of being a review article and compiling a satisfactory report of elderly inmates of old age home in the past 15 years. In all these studies the researcher can find that the efficiency and satisfaction of the old age home are different from each other. Paper Type: It was a review-based study which is also known as an integrative review where many articles from the past 15 years were selected from different search engines such as Google scholar, Research gate, and others.

The Concept of Privacy in the Context of Chinese Law and Culture

Article

Feb 2023

DAI Yihan

Body Dissatisfaction and Social Anxiety among Adolescents: A Moderated Mediation Model of Feeling of Inferiority, Family Cohesion and Friendship Quality

Article

Mar 2023

Previous research has documented that body dissatisfaction is positively related to social anxiety. However, little is known about the mediating and moderating mechanisms underlying this relation. Based on person-environment interaction theory, this study aimed to examine the chain mediation effect of feeling of inferiority and family cohesion in the relationship between body dissatisfaction and social anxiety among adolescents and whether this mediating process was moderated by friendship quality. A total of 972 students (M = 15.77, SD = 0.856) were enrolled in this study. All participants completed questionnaires regarding adolescent body dissatisfaction, feeling of inferiority, family cohesion, friendship quality and social anxiety. Our study found that body dissatisfaction was positively associated with social anxiety. Feeling of inferiority and family cohesion were found to play a chain-mediated role in the relation between body dissatisfaction and social anxiety. In addition, friendship quality plays a moderating role in the relationship between body dissatisfaction and social anxiety. According to the person-environment interaction theory, this study not only confirms the effect of body dissatisfaction on social anxiety in a collectivist culture, but also reveals the mechanism of the role of individual characteristics (feeling of inferiority) and external environmental factors (family cohesion) in the relationship between body dissatisfaction and social anxiety, and the moderating effect of friendship quality on the whole mechanism. These findings show lights on how body dissatisfaction is associated with social anxiety in adolescents.

Individualism and interdependence

Article

Full-text available

Jul 1981

Alan S. Waterman

The value system of individualism underlying many contemporary psychological theories has been criticized on grounds that it is antithetical to social interdependence. The critics have developed a philosophical analysis that links individualism to unscrupulous competition, atomistic self-containment, and alienation. In contrast, the principles espoused by the proponents of individualism in psychology are derived from a philosophical orientation defined by eudaimonism, freedom of choice, personal responsibility, and ethical universality. Within this framework, the holding of individualistic values is hypothesized by the present author to facilitate, not inhibit, helping, cooperation, and other prosocial behaviors. A review of the literature provides extensive support for this hypothesis. (83 ref) (PsycINFO Database Record (c) 2012 APA, all rights reserved)

Individual models of social behavior.

Article

Full-text available

Jun 1984

Presents a technique that extracts individual models of social behavior. Such models reflect each individual's ideas about what social behaviors are interrelated, and what aspects of social situations are linked to different levels of probability that particular patterns of social behavior will occur. The method was used in 2 studies, one with bicultural Ss (1 American, 6 Latin Americans, 2 Hong Kong Chinese, and 1 Greek) and the other with 22 monocultural Mexican and Chinese Ss and 8 of the bilinguals from the 1st study. For each S, factor analysis of the judgments concerning the probability of occurrence of specific social behaviors in specific social situations provided information of how the S linked social behaviors. ANOVA on the factor scores provided information about the S's beliefs concerning how attributes of social situations are linked to social behaviors. Inspection of the individual models of social behavior indicated that some common elements across models are probably linked to culture. The technique has wide applicability for social and personality psychology because it permits idiographic comparison of models of social behavior across individuals who share some attribute. (39 ref) (PsycINFO Database Record (c) 2012 APA, all rights reserved)

Comparative Need Patterns of Five Ancestry Groups in Hawaii

Article

Oct 1962

This study compared need patterns of male and female high school students of Caucasian, Chinese, Filipino, Hawaiian, and Japanese descent as measured by the Edwards Personal Preference Schedule. The Caucasian profile proved to be singular—for many of the needs there seemed to be a Caucasian and a non-Caucasian level of expression. The profiles of the several female groups were more similar than those for the male groups. There was some suggestion of an acculturational process among the students of Japanese ancestry. (PsycINFO Database Record (c) 2012 APA, all rights reserved)

Adler's concept of Social Interest: Theory, measurement, and implications for adjustment

Article

Sep 1980

James E. Crandall

After summarizing the meaning of A. Adler's (1938) concept of social interest and his theorizing concerning its influence on adjustment, the author describes the development of a new, short measure of social interest (Social Interest Scale). Data concerning reliability and validity are presented. The results of a number of studies relating this measure to both self-report and more indirect measures of adjustment support Adler's and other contemporary theorists' beliefs that a concern for others contributes to the adjustment of the individual. Results also indicate that sex, age, and stress may be important moderators of the relation of social interest to adjustment. (67 ref) (PsycINFO Database Record (c) 2012 APA, all rights reserved)

Perspectives on selfhood

Article

Dec 1978

M. Brewster Smith

Examines selfhood as the criterial features of the human condition from 3 perspectives: evolutionary or phylogenetic, cross-cultural and transhistorical, and developmental or ontogenetic. It is argued that to deal with the phenomena of selfhood, psychology has to be a historical and cultural science, as well as a biological one. The reflexiveness of selfhood makes theories about it important in partly constituting the selves that we are—an insight of the currently popular "attributional" approach. Yet the cognitive emphasis of the attributional approach requires balance from Jung's vision of dynamic archetypes. Indeed, if psychology is to begin to grasp the phenomena of selfhood, it needs to work in both the causal and the interpretative traditions, taken as complementary. (73 ref) (PsycINFO Database Record (c) 2012 APA, all rights reserved)

Psychology and the American Ideal

Article

Nov 1977

Edward E. Sampson

Applies 3 recent criticisms of personality and social psychology—the historical, the dialectical, and the interdependence theses—to a critical examination of existing trends in theory and practice, in particular to concepts of androgyny, mental health, and moral development. The position is developed that existing conceptions in these and other areas emphasize a cultural and historical thesis of self-contained individualism; syntheses of opposing or desirable characteristics are located within the person rather than within an interdependent collectivity. By viewing these and other psychological concepts against this background, it can be better understood that (a) these (e.g., androgyny) are not fundamental psychological principles; (b) alternative conceptualizations are both possible and perhaps even more desirable; and (c) in an era in which collective problem solving is necessary, the perpetuation of self-contained, individualistic conceptions can stifle psychology's effort to contribute to resolving contemporary social issues. (48 ref) (PsycINFO Database Record (c) 2012 APA, all rights reserved)

A Comparative Study of Selected Attitudes, Values, and Personality Characteristics of American, Chinese, and Indian Students

Article

Jun 1962

37 American, 37 Chinese, and 37 Indian students attending an American university responded to the following questionnaires: the Allport-Vernon-Lindzey, Morris' Ways to Live, Sanford and Older's AE Scale, and Edwards' Personal Preference Schedule. The following differences were found: (a) American students were more self-centered while both Chinese and Indian students were more society-centered; (b) American students were more theoretical than the other groups; (c) Indian students were more politically and economically oriented than the other groups; (d) Indian and Chinese students were more authoritarian than American students; (e) American students were more religious than the other groups; and (f) Indian and Chinese students showed a greater preference for enjoying life through group participation, while American students preferred the many-sided, flexible approach to the good life. (PsycINFO Database Record (c) 2012 APA, all rights reserved)

Measurement of interpersonal orientation

Article

Jan 1983

The construct of interpersonal orientation (IO) is proposed as useful for understanding behavior in certain social situations. High IOs are interested in and reactive to other people; low IOs are less interested and responsive to others and more concerned with economic features of relationships. A self-report measure of IO was constructed; questionnaire and interview data generally supported the hypothesized parameters of the construct, with females scoring higher than males and high scorers (regardless of sex) indicating greater interest in and responsiveness to interpersonal features of their environments. Two experiments were conducted to assess the utility of IO in social situations. In Exp I (82 Ss), a factorial combination of sex and IO eliminated a previously demonstrated sex difference in favor of an IO difference: High IOs expressed greater liking than did low IOs for a partner who had self-disclosed to them. In Exp II (56 Ss), males and low IOs whose performance was either superior or inferior to a partner allocated rewards in accordance with equity theory; females and high IOs seemed more concerned with equality than with equity. (40 ref) (PsycINFO Database Record (c) 2012 APA, all rights reserved)

Cultural Determinants of Achievement, Aggression, and Psychological Distress

Article

May 1980
ARCH GEN PSYCHIAT

We present a cross-cultural exploration of the interrelationships among six concepts: achievement (ie, cultural attainment), aggression, psychological distress, competition, interpersonal intensity (strength of passionate attachments), and social synergy (patterned behavior that simultaneously benefits both individual and society). Of interest is the proposition that levels of achievement, aggression, and psychological distress are partly determined by corresponding levels of competition and interpersonal intensity; however, in the presence of high levels of social synergy, aggression and psychological distress are lowered without affecting the level of achievement. We have tested the implied linear relationships, using blind ratings (of five variables assessed from ethnographic extracts) obtained from ten cross-cultural scholars, and a Social Development Index (from Tatje and Naroll) to indicate achievement. A sample of 58 societies was employed in correlation and multivariate analysis of variance.

A Study of Normative and Informational Social Influences Upon Individual Judgment

Article

Dec 1955

Several modifications of the Asch experiment in which the S judges the length of lines in the company of a group of "stooges" who carry out the experimenter's instructions are described. These include a face-to-face situation, an anonymous situation, and a group situation, with self-commitment, public commitment and Magic Pad commitment variations. The results indicate that, even when normative social influence in the direction of an incorrect judgment is largely removed (as in the anonymous situation), more errors are made by Ss in experimental groups than by Ss making their judgments when alone.

Individualism-CollectivismA Study of Cross-Cultural Researchers

Abstract

Recommendations

The Second Demographic Transition : From Local to Global.

IGI Global International Student Mobility and Opportunities for Growth in the Global Marketplace

Managing Water Resources under Climate Uncertainty: Examples from Asia, Europe, Latin America, and A...

L'Europe, l'Amérique latine et les problèmes de sécurité

Seeking international consensus in the use of icons for medication instructions