Article

Lifetime Prediction of Tires with Regard to Oxidative Aging

Authors:
To read the full-text of this research, you can request a copy directly from the authors.

Abstract

It is a challenging task in the design of automobile tires to predict lifetime and performance on the basis of numerical simulations. Several factors have to be taken into account to correctly estimate the aging behavior. This paper focuses on oxygen reaction processes which, apart from mechanical and thermal aspects, effect the tire durability. The material parameters needed to describe the temperature-dependent oxygen diffusion and reaction processes are derived by means of the time–temperature–superposition principle from modulus profiling tests. These experiments are designed to examine the diffusion-limited oxidation (DLO) effect which occurs when accelerated aging tests are performed. For the cord-reinforced rubber composites, homogenization techniques are adopted to obtain effective material parameters (diffusivities and reaction constants). The selection and arrangement of rubber components influence the temperature distribution and the oxygen penetration depth which impact tire durability. The goal of this paper is to establish a finite element analysis based criterion to predict lifetime with respect to oxidative aging. The finite element analysis is carried out in three stages. First the heat generation rate distribution is calculated using a viscoelastic material model. Then the temperature distribution can be determined. In the third step we evaluate the oxygen distribution or rather the oxygen consumption rate, which is a measure for the tire lifetime. Thus, the aging behavior of different kinds of tires can be compared. Numerical examples show how diffusivities, reaction coefficients, and temperature influence the durability of different tire parts. It is found that due to the DLO effect, some interior parts may age slower even if the temperature is increased.

No full-text available

Request Full-text Paper PDF

To read the full-text of this research,
you can request a copy directly from the authors.

... Future development of the model will address leveraging its critical plane analysis framework in combination with a microsphere-based model of energy dissipation [60][61][62], and toward incorporating aging effects into the material model [63][64][65]. ...
Article
Full-text available
Tire developers are responsible for designing against the possibility of crack development in each of the various components of a tire. The task requires knowledge of the fatigue behavior of each compound in the tire, as well as adequate accounting for the multiaxial stresses carried by tire materials. The analysis is illustrated here using the Endurica CL fatigue solver for the case of a 1200R20 TBR tire operating at 837 kPa under loads ranging from 66 to 170% of rated load. The fatigue behavior of the tire’s materials is described from a fracture mechanical viewpoint, with care taken to specify each of the several phenomena (crack growth rate, crack precursor size, strain crystallization, fatigue threshold) that govern. The analysis of crack development is made by considering how many cycles are required to grow cracks of various potential orientations at each element of the model. The most critical plane is then identified as the plane with the shortest fatigue life. We consider each component of the tire and show that where cracks develop from precursors intrinsic to the rubber compound (sidewall, tread grooves, innerliner) the critical plane analysis provides a comprehensive view of the failure mechanics. For cases where a crack develops near a stress singularity (i.e., belt-edge separation), the critical plane analysis remains advantageous for design guidance, particularly relative to analysis approaches based upon scalar invariant theories (i.e., strain energy density) that neglect to account for crack closure effects.
Article
The functions of the tire can be fully performed only under the appropriate inflation pressure. Tire inflation pressure loss rate (IPLR) is an important indicator used to evaluate tire inflation pressure retention performance. When the tire is under a rolling state, the temperature will increase leading to an accelerated oxidation process. Standard tire IPLR test is costly and time-consuming. In order to simulate the tire IPLR under the steady rolling state, the permeability parameters of rubbers and rubber-cord components (belts & carcass) are tested. Moreover, the oxidation reaction is coupling with the IPLR model based on the basic autoxidation scheme (BAS). The simulation results show that the IPLR of the tire under rolling state increases obviously. A novel calculation method of rubber oxygen consumption is proposed and applied to the oxygen consumption of different parts of the tire. Two approaches are adopted to reduce tire IPLR based on the innerliner structure design. This simulation method can predict tire IPLR not only under steady rolling state but also under static state and even under tire aging condition in oven. It also provides an important model basis for tire aging and life prediction research in the future.
Chapter
While different subtopics of degradation of rubber under strain, temperature, wear, tire-road abrasion or fatigue are discussed in detail from an experimental and numerical point of view in other chapters, this chapter mainly aims at the numerical aspects of the model setup from the material to the structural scale. The objective of this chapter is to establish the link between experimental testing on the material scale and predictive simulation on the structural scale. To demonstrate the general procedure in the context of the finite element method (FEM), thermal damage or thermal aging as one phenomenon of material alteration over time is addressed by developing a corresponding continuum mechanical model. The phenomenological model is derived at the material scale and integrated at the structural scale by solving the thermo-mechanically coupled problem for the example of a rubber-cord structure in the form of an automobile tire. With the structural model at hand, simulations of the entire lifetime become feasible. Future trends in this context are introduced by focusing on the further extension of the pure simulative approach to cyber-physical systems (CPS), e.g. for the holistic assessment of the impact of tire wear particles (TWP) on the environment (definition of system boundaries, material flows, and interactions).
Chapter
Numerical modeling of particle-reinforced or filled elastomers is a challenging task and includes the adequate representation of finite deformations, nonlinear elasticity, local damage as well as rate-dependent and rate-independent dissipative properties. On the structural scale, the permanent alteration of the material is visible as formation and propagation of discrete cracks, especially in the case of catastrophic crack growth and fatigue crack propagation. In this chapter, macromechanically formulated material models for finite viscoelasticity and endochronic elasto-plasticity of filled elastomers are presented in order to describe the material response of the undamaged continuum. On the FE-discretized structural scale, crack sensitivity of the material is assessed by the material force method. Material forces are used for the computational determination of fracture mechanical parameters of dissipative rubber material. Finally, arbitrary crack growth on the structural level is addressed by an adaptive implementation of cohesive elements. In a first application, crack propagation starting from an initial side notch in a tensile rubber specimen under mixed-mode loading is numerically predicted and compared to experimental observations. In a second example, averaged stress and energy based criteria are studied and compared with respect to their crack path predictability. In a third example, the durability of a tire design is numerically assessed by using the material force method.
Article
Development of the laboratory-based accelerated service life testing-"tire aging test"-encountered difficulties due to the complexity of multidisciplinary processes in the tire materials and structures while trying to induce thermooxidative degradation similar to that taking place in the "worst case" in-service. Preliminary experience with the oven aging at elevated temperatures showed that in some light truck tires damaging conditions occur in the form of sidewall blisters/detachments and casing separations due to inflation gas built up in interior tire layers during oven aging, even prior the roadwheel endurance testing (DOT HS 810 799, Research Report to Congress on Tire Aging, National Highway Traffic Safety Administration (NHTSA), Washington, D.C., 2007, http://www.cbsatlanta.com/download/2010/0512/ 23529107.pdf). Analysis and comprehensive modeling techniques are developed for gas diffusion and oxidation in the tire structure, with focus on the intracarcass pressure (ICP) build-up predictions. In finite element models, the temperature dependent diffusion properties are used with account for their high heterogeneity in different tire components. Results of transient simulations predict higher oxidation/degradation rate in the sidewall and a detrimental effect of ICP build-up for Load Range E tires-mainly due to excessive nitrogen permeation. Influence of the butyl liner barrier permeability and gauge is evaluated, as well as impact of other tire construction variations. Predicted trends agree with the available observations and measurements. ICP levels in simulations of the long-term gas diffusion under regular service conditions are significantly lower than in the oven aging test modeling. Mechanical aspects of the ICP-induced sidewall separation are also discussed. Modified aging test conditions are proposed that will greatly reduce the deleterious side-effect of the ICP buildup, as assessed in simulations.
Article
The accelerated thermal aging was performed for NBR composite sheet in aviation kerosene. It was observed by XPS and ATR-FTIR that some obvious changes related to silicon were caused by thermal aging. Based on careful analysis of ATR-FTIR spectra of various NBR samples, a probable aging mechanism for NBR composite sheet in aviation kerosene was proposed. With the help of nonlinear curve fitting of ATR-FTIR spectra and Arrhenius plot, the lifetime prediction equation of NBR composite sheet in aviation kerosene was obtained. The lifetime of NBR composite sheet in aviation kerosene at room temperature (25 °C) was 6467 days.
Article
In this contribution, a numerical framework for the efficient thermo-mechanical analysis of fully 3D tire structures (axisymmetric geometry) in steady state motion is presented. The modular simulation approach consists of a sequentially coupled mechanical and thermal simulation module. In the mechanical module, the Arbitrary Lagrangian Eulerian (ALE) framework is used together with a 3D finite element model of the tire structure to represent its temperature-dependent viscoelastic behavior at steady state rolling and finite deformations. Physically computed heat source terms (energy dissipation from the material and friction in the tire-road contact zone) are used as input quantities for the thermal module. In the thermal module, a representative cross-sectional part of the tire is employed to evaluate the temperature evolution due to internal and external heat sources in a transient thermal simulation. Special emphasis is given to an adequate material test program to identify the model parameters. The parameter identification is discussed in detail. Numerical results for three different types of special performance tires at free rolling conditions are compared to experimental measurements from the test rig, focusing especially on rolling resistance and surface temperature distribution.
Chapter
Full-text available
In a series of studies we consider the breakage of a polymer chain of segments, coupled by anharmonic bonds under applied tensional force or subject to rise in temperature. The chain dynamics at the onset of fracture is studied by means of Molecular Dynamics simulation and also using analytic considerations. A deeper insight into the changes in polymer relaxation dynamics when bonding anharmonicity is taken into account, that is, beyond the limits of the conventional Rouse model description, is gained by comparing analytic results from the Gaussian Self-Consistent approach to data derived from Monte Carlo and Molecular Dynamics simulations. Simulation results on polymer chain rupture are confronted with the predictions of Kramers-Langer theory. Two cases are investigated: a) thermally induced fracture of unstrained chain, and b) rupture of a chain under tensile stress. Cases of both under- and overdamped dynamics are explored. The recently experimentally observed and intensively studied case of covalent bond scission in ``bottle-brush'' macromolecules adsorbed on a hard surface is modeled and comprehensively investigated with regard to tension accumulation and breakdown kinetics. Eventually we report on our latest studies of the force-induced rupture and thermal degradation of 2D (graphene-like) networks, focusing on the creation and proliferation of cracks during failure.
Article
Full-text available
With the development of tire mechanics and computer technology, tire deformation, rolling resistance, and temperature distribution under rolling conditions may be predicted accurately through finite element analysis (FEA). Deep knowledge of tire fracture and failure behavior may also be obtained by FEA. During the past years, an in-house finite element program has been developed in our research laboratory which can analyze the tire deformation, stress, and strain under the static inflation and footprint load conditions and can predict the tire rolling resistance and temperature distribution as well. This paper gives a brief description of the mathematical and mechanical foundations of the developed FEA code and the computing procedures, emphasizing the tire material loss model and the calculation procedure of strain energy release rate in tire fracture analysis. Two characteristics of the presented model compared with the published literature are the three-dimensional anisotropic properties included in the loss model of cord-rubber materials and a new VCCT (Virtual Crack Closure Technique), which is simple and physically direct, saves on the amount of computation, and is developed to compute the fields of strain energy release rates (Serrs) in the crack front to analyze tire fracture behavior.
Article
To understand the mode of tire failure caused by the shoulder separation in bias truck tires, tires were subjected to laboratory wheel test conditions leading to failure similar to that encountered in service. The results show that: (1) crack formation occurs in the rubber at the shoulder region where the tire temperature rises to 130-150 degree C; (2) rate of the crack propagation is sensitively affected by the temperature; (3) the rubber has an anisotropy in fatigue resistance; (4) contribution of the cord to the tire temperature rise is significant and it varies with different cords; (5) cord contribution to the temperature rise comes from the viscoelastic nature of the cord. The results indicate that the improvement of tire endurance against the shoulder separation type failure requires (1) lower tire temperature, (2) cord generating less heat, (3) rubber with reduced anisotropy and with improved resistance to crack formation and propagation.
Article
A finite element program called Femoxi was developed to forecast the long term effects of penetration of oxygen toward critical rubber components of tires and moisture toward steel reinforcement. It is capable of solving transient, plane, two-dimensional and two-dimensional axisymmetric problems of diffusion with reaction in tires. Additional software was developed to permit the use of a digitizer and a commercial finite element model builder and post processor program. The entire system operates on a personal computer.
Article
Over the past ten years the Finite Element Analysis (FEA) has been increasingly integrated into the tire design process. The FEA has been used to study the general tire behavior, to perform parameter studies, and to do comparative analyses. To decrease the tire development cycle, the FEA is now being used as a replacement for certain tire tests. This requires the accuracy of the FEA results to be within those test limits. This paper investigates some of the known modeling techniques and their impact on accuracy. Some of the issues are the use of shell elements, assumptions for boundary conditions, and global/local analysis approaches. Finally, the use of new generation supercomputers, massively parallel processing systems (MPP), is discussed.
Article
The thermomechanical behavior of pneumatic tires is a highly complex transient phenomenon that, in general, requires the solution of a dynamic nonlinear coupled thermoviscoelasticity problem with heat sources resulting from internal dissipation and contact and friction. This highly complex and nonlinear system requires in-depth knowledge of the geometry, material properties, friction coefficients, dissipation mechanisms, convective heat transfer coefficients, and many other aspects of tire design that are not fully understood at the present time. In this paper, a simplified approach to modeling this system that couples all of these phenomena in a straight forward manner is presented in order to predict temperature distributions in static and rolling tires. The model is based on a one-way coupling approach, wherein the solution of mechanical rolling contact problem (with friction and viscoelastic material properties) provides heat source terms for the solution of a thermal problem. The thermal solution is based on the thermodynamics of irreversible processes and is performed on the deformed tire configuration. Several numerical examples are provided to illustrate the performance of the method.
Article
Mathematical modelling of the oxidation of a polymer, based on Fick's Law for diffusion of oxygen with reaction, with suitable boundary conditions produced an equation which combines the diffusion-free kinetics of the surface layers of the oxidising sample with the diffusion-controlled kinetics which predominate at greater depth. Comparison of the final, simplified, equation with literature results for oxidation rates versus film thickness showed excellent agreement with experiment. Attempts to fit to the experimental results an equation which assumes diffusion control from the film surface failed, indicating that the splitting of the film into two domains for the purpose of kinetic investigation was correct.
Article
The WLF approach is appropriate for lifetime predictions when polymer ageing is controlled by a viscoelastic process (relaxation, creep). This methodology using time/temperature shift will be illustrated by the creep of SBR/NR. When physico-chemical mechanisms are dominant, the Arrhenius approach is the most widely used for evaluating accelerated test results involving the effect of temperature. Service lifetimes have been estimated for the thermal ageing of NBR/PVC and for the ageing of HNBR in gaseous fluids. Predictions using the Arrhenius model usually do not take into account oxygen-diffusion-controlled oxidations. In the case of the thermal ageing of EPDM, extrapolations are determined by the heterogeneity of the oxidative ageing of bulk polymer samples.
Conference Paper
For elastomers that will be used in applications involving long lifetimes, it is often necessary to first carry out and model accelerated aging experiments at higher than ambient temperatures, and then extrapolate the results in order to make lifetime predictions at the use temperature. Continuing goals in such endeavors are to better understand potential problems with such modeling approaches and to find ways of improving confidence in the predictions when the data are extrapolated. In this paper we will address several important issues involved in these procedures for elastomers exposed to air (oxygen), and discuss some potentially useful techniques and approaches which can increase confidence in lifetime predictions.
Article
Aging of tire rubber compounds in real service is affected by multiple factors. This process cannot be accurately represented by conventional single-factor tests. A novel cyclic aging test is proposed as a multiple factor, service simulating, accelerated aging test method. It includes four sub-tests of oxygen bomb, dynamic ozone, ultraviolet light, and water solution attack. The proposed cyclic test is compared against thermal, dynamic ozone, and dynamic outdoor aging by characterizing material property degradation as a function of aging time. Four formulations of exterior tire rubber compounds are used as experimental materials. The experimental results show that the proposed cyclic aging test is closer to dynamic outdoor aging than the conventional dynamic ozone and thermal aging tests. The static modulus increases with thermal aging, and decreases with dynamic ozone aging time. For dynamic outdoor and cyclic aging, the modulus initially increases, but then later decreases, showing traces of both of the previously mentioned results. It is also found that the size of the specimen has a significant affect on aging. Such effect can be utilized to accelerate the artificial aging without elevating the temperature.