A preview of this full-text is provided by The Royal Society.
Content available from Proceedings of the Royal Society B
This content is subject to copyright.
rspb.royalsocietypublishing.org
Review
Cite this article: Gerkema MP, Davies WIL,
Foster RG, Menaker M, Hut RA. 2013 The
nocturnal bottleneck and the evolution of
activity patterns in mammals. Proc R Soc B
280: 20130508.
http://dx.doi.org/10.1098/rspb.2013.0508
Received: 25 February 2013
Accepted: 3 June 2013
Subject Areas:
behaviour, neuroscience, palaeontology
Keywords:
eutherian, bottleneck, activity, vision,
photolyases, endothermia
Author for correspondence:
Menno P. Gerkema
e-mail: m.p.gerkema@rug.nl
One contribution to a Special Feature ‘Animal
clocks: when science meets nature’.
The nocturnal bottleneck and the
evolution of activity patterns in mammals
Menno P. Gerkema1, Wayne I. L. Davies2,3, Russell G. Foster2,
Michael Menaker4and Roelof A. Hut1
1
Centre for Behaviour and Neuroscience, Department of Chronobiology, University of Groningen, Groningen,
The Netherlands
2
Nuffield Laboratory of Ophthalmology, University of Oxford, Oxford OX3 9DU, UK
3
School of Animal Biology, University of Western Australia, Perth, Western Australia 6009, Australia
4
Department of Biology, University of Virginia, Charlottesville, VA 22904 4328, USA
In 1942, Walls described the concept of a ‘nocturnal bottleneck’ in placental
mammals, where these species could survive only by avoiding daytime
activity during times in which dinosaurs were the dominant taxon. Walls
based this concept of a longer episode of nocturnality in early eutherian
mammals by comparing the visual systems of reptiles, birds and all three
extant taxa of the mammalian lineage, namely the monotremes, marsupials
(now included in the metatherians) and placentals (included in the euther-
ians). This review describes the status of what has become known as the
nocturnal bottleneck hypothesis, giving an overview of the chronobiological
patterns of activity. We review the ecological plausibility that the activity
patterns of (early) eutherian mammals were restricted to the night, based
on arguments relating to endothermia, energy balance, foraging and preda-
tion, taking into account recent palaeontological information. We also assess
genes, relating to light detection (visual and non-visual systems) and the
photolyase DNA protection system that were lost in the eutherian mamma-
lian lineage. Our conclusion presently is that arguments in favour of the
nocturnal bottleneck hypothesis in eutherians prevail.
A more likely view is that the placental mammals had an early history of strict
nocturnality.
...what was the retina like in these strictly nocturnal ‘bottle-neck’insectivores? [1, p. 687]
1. Introduction
A general view that early mammals were small insectivores, living on trees and
being only night active, has become commonplace in textbooks, with some
articles devoted specifically to vision [1,2], whereas others are more general
in nature [3,4]. Menaker and co-workers formulated a specific ‘nocturnal bottle-
neck hypothesis’ [5– 7], although some researchers have suggested the
involvement of a period of mesopia (medium-light levels) in the evolution of
eyes in response to light-restricted habitats [8], as observed in other species
(e.g. birds; [9]). The main focus of this review is the ‘nocturnal bottleneck’ con-
jecture that was inspired by the fact that mammals have only one (retinal)
photic input pathway to their circadian pacemaker system, whereas non-
mammalian species have several parallel retinal and extra-retinal circadian
photic input systems (e.g. hypothalamus, pineal gland, parietal eye). Further
evidence to support the hypothesis arose from consistent findings in mamma-
lian evolution, including the evolution of endothermia [3,10] and the adaptation
of photosensory systems (e.g. the loss of photoreceptor pigments: [7,8]).
The nocturnal bottleneck hypothesis suggests that early eutherian mammals
faced competition with diurnal reptiles (e.g. dinosaurs) during the Mesozoic
era: [1,6,11,12]. Thought to be mainly ectothermic, these reptiles would have
had to restrict their activity to the daytime because solar radiation was essential
to increase their body temperature to operational levels [13]. Predation pressure
and inter-species competition are thought to have stimulated the development
of endothermia, a major adaptive change that enabled early mammals to
&2013 The Author(s) Published by the Royal Society. All rights reserved.