ArticlePDF Available

The Lakou System: A Cultural, Ecological Analysis of Mothering in Rural Haiti

Authors:

Abstract

This descriptive exploratory study uses a cultural-ecological framework to examine mothering and the role of family support within the lakou (group living) system in the rural province of Leogane, Haiti. Historically, the lakou refers to clusters of homes in which Haitian families reside, as well as to the extended and multiple-generation family form that is prominent in Haitian culture. Initially, the members of a lakou worked cooperatively and provided for each other with financial and other forms of support.
The Lakou System: A Cultural, Ecological
Analysis of Mothering in Rural Haiti
by
Yanique M. Edmond, Suzanne M. Randolph, Guylaine L. Richard
Yanique Edmond, Ph.D., University of Maryland; M.P.A., Rockefeller College is a Research Analyst in
the Washington, DC metro area. Her interests include Pan-Africanism, Haitian traditions and culture,
immigrant families, parenting, acculturation, and adolescent development.
Suzanne Randolph, Ph.D., University of Michigan, is currently an Associate Professor in the
Department of Family Science at the University of Maryland College Park School of Public Health. Her
interests include African-American families, HIV/AIDS, community violence, and the evaluation of
maternal/child health programs. She is the author of numerous articles and chapters, publishing in such
journals as Child Development, Infant Mental Health Journal, Journal of Black Psychology, and the
Journal of School Health. She is a past National President of the Association of Black Psychologists.
Guylaine Richard, M.D. M.P.H., George Washington University School of Medicine and Public Health;
M.D., School of Medicine and Pharmacy in Haiti is a doctoral candidate in Natural and Naturopathic
Medicine from the Clayton College of Natural Health in Alabama and a former Head Start fellow. Her
interests include maternal and child health, Haitian culture and community development, and early
childhood and preventive medicine. She is the Founder and Chairperson of WISEOP, Inc., a non-profit
agency focusing on international maternal and child health,
positive youth development, educational
advocacy, parenting, and self-sufficiency.
Direct all correspondence to: Dr. Yanique Edmond, Research and Policy Analyst [301-947-3239,
ep69pun@aol.com].
Abstract
This descriptive exploratory study uses a cultural-ecological framework to examine mothering
and the role of family support within the lakou (group living) system in the rural province of
Leogane, Haiti. Historically, the lakou refers to clusters of homes in which Haitian families
reside, as well as to the extended and multiple-generation family form that is prominent in
Haitian culture. Initially, the members of a lakou worked cooperatively and provided for each
other with financial and other forms of support.
19
The Journal of Pan African Studies, vol.2, no.01, November 2007
However, the original lakou system has changed due to the pressures of increased poverty and
landholding fragmentation brought about by the globalization of capitalism. One of the
detrimental impacts of these changes in the lakou system is the disruption of parenting. This
difficult shift has fallen largely on the shoulders of Haitian mothers. The move from multiple
mothering, wherein several women in the lakou shared in the caring and supervision of young
children, to individual mothering, wherein single mothers are now the sole caretakers, constitutes
a major social change that needs to be understood within the cultural context of the Haitian
framework.
Introduction
Fam se poto mitan” (women are the center post) is a well-known Haitian proverb that highlights
the central role women play not only in Haitian commerce, but also within Haitian families. In
Haiti, 70% of rural households are headed by women, despite a history of embedded male
dominance. Against the backdrop of ongoing poverty, sociopolitical crisis, and gender
discrimination and oppression, Haitian women have been the stabilizing centers to uphold unique
African traditions of womanhood and multiple mothering within a distinctive African space
known as the lakou. Since the 19th century (1804), the lakou, referring to family members and
the cluster of houses in which Haitian families reside, has been the principal family form.
Initially, the members of a lakou worked cooperatively and provided for each other through
financial and other forms of support (LaRose 482). Moreover, the original lakou was based on
the African reality that raising children was too great a responsibility for only one or two people
to bear, and that it was healthier for children— and mothers— to have contact with a wide circle
of people and share parenting responsibilities (Ambert 530). Therefore, within this location or
bounded space, where children have multiple caregivers, Haitian mothers were able to carry out
their traditional functions according to the healthy, successful parenting models of Haitian
communities.
Although the new lakou system continues to provide a range of support that sometimes serves to
reduce family hardship and buffer daily stressors for poor parents, some research has noted that
in high-poverty communities, the support received may be compromised by highly stressed
network members (LaRose 488). Given the central role of women in families and that women in
general are more bound to the parenting role, such high stress may, in turn, adversely affect the
mental health of mothers. Since this early work, Haiti’s social conditions have worsened due to
economic instability, political unrest, and destructive hurricanes. Yet little information is
available on the sources of parenting stress, or the role of family support in the lives of Haitian
mothers within their country of origin. Research on Haitian mothers and the lakou system is
needed to assess contemporary patterns of support in this socio-cultural context. Therefore, this
pilot study explores parenting stress within the lakou in a sample of parents living in rural Haiti.
20
The Journal of Pan African Studies, vol.2, no.01, November 2007
Theoretical Framework
This study is grounded in a cultural-ecological model, which posits that child and family well-
being are influenced by the differential and interactive effects of individual, family, community,
and larger societal systems, as well as the context of the values, attitudes, and skills of particular
cultural groups (Bronfenbrenner 725; Ogbu 413). When factors within each of these levels are
stressful, families are at risk; when factors are supportive and protective, families are able to
respond positively in adverse situations. On the individual level, demographic variables, such as
age, gender, marital status, number of children, and income, influence the risk of stress related to
the daily role of mothering (Jackson 1409). At the community level, the risk of parental stress is
increased in areas marked by high poverty and low maternal support (Martsoff 294). At the
societal level, factors such as social norms, public policy, and economic opportunity may
influence the level of resources available to parents (Farmer 1483). Using Ogbu’s cultural-
ecological perspective, it is also recognized that in Haitian culture, both mothering behavior and
larger kinship networks and communities, such as the lakou, may influence child and maternal
well-being.
Review of Related Research: Poverty and Parenting Stress in Haiti
Today, Haiti ranks 153 out of the 177 countries in the Human Development ranking. The most
recent Haitian census indicates that 65 percent of the population lives in rural regions, 20 percent
in the metropolitan area of Port-au-Prince, and 15 percent in other urban areas (Institut Haitien
de Statistique et d'Informatique: Division d'Analyse et de Recherche Demographique 60). In
addition, more than 67 percent of the total population lives below the poverty line, 80 percent of
rural Haitians live in poverty, 32 percent of households have more than seven members, and 46
percent of families have only one room in which to sleep. According to the Pan American Health
Organization’s Haiti Profile, inflation was estimated at 15 percent and food prices increased to
10.4 percent from 1999 to 2000. Moreover, Haiti’s per capita income is less than $400 (in U.S.
dollars) per year, the average life expectancy is 57, and half of the children under the age of five
are malnourished (World Bank 8). Hence, Haitian mothers and children are more likely to
experience chronic poverty.
A number of researchers have shown that living in chronic poverty has a harmful effect on
maternal behavior. Specifically, poor parents experience more chronic stress over family
economic pressures, such as difficulty paying bills, substandard housing, and poor-quality
medical care, as well as the stress associated with the daily tasks of childrearing (Hashima and
Amato 394; World Health Organization 10). Because parenting can influence children’s social,
emotional, and cognitive adjustment, efforts have been made to determine the variables that
affect parenting behavior, and one such variable is parenting stress. Parenting stress has been
conceptualized as a condition in which the different aspects of parenthood result in a perceived
discrepancy between situational demands and personal resources (Abidin 407).
21
The Journal of Pan African Studies, vol.2, no.01, November 2007
In other words, parents experience excess anxiety and tension specifically related to the
parenting role and parent-child interactions (Abidin 409). Parents’ perceptions of the availability
of resources to assist them in parenting and their feelings of competence regarding their
parenting are all-important elements of this definition (Deater-Deckard 317).
In Haiti, mothers must negotiate parenting responsibilities in desperate economic and worsening
social conditions (Farmer 1485). Difficulty functioning and stressful family circumstances can
lead to distress in the mothering role, which can have long-term consequences for mothers and
children. According to Abidin, many variables contribute to parenting stress and parenting
behavior (409). These variables include the problems mothers encounter daily, the characteristics
of the marital relationship, the characteristics of the environments in which people live and work,
and the occurrence of major life events. Moreover, mothers’ appraisals of themselves as parents
are essential in determining the level of parenting stress they experience. A key reason for the
importance of studying parenting stress is that stress adversely affects a mother’s ability to
respond constructively to her children’s needs. High parenting stress has been found to be
associated with a number of negative consequences for both mothers and children, such as adult
depression and child maltreatment.
Mothering in the Lakou
A key factor in the negative outcomes associated with parental stress among Haitian mothers is
the availability of support from other mothers or the tradition of multiple mothering. In Haiti,
extended family and fictive kin are usually the primary sources of support. Haitians view home
(lakay) and family as both biological and relational. Households consist of multiple generations
as well as extended and fictive kin. Home is geared toward the needs and strengths of the
extended family. Haitian communities often consist of a dozen or more lakay grouped together to
form a lakou.
Even though husbands, fathers, brothers, sons, and other male kin live in the lakou, the lakou
system of support is mainly a female creation based on the connections and interactions between
adult females in that location. For example, when the male of one household experiences some
difficulty providing food, the mother asks her lakou system to provide for her family and it will.
The mother thereby protects the pride of her partner who, when faced with financial challenges,
might abandon the family until he is able to respond to their needs. Therefore, we see how this
system—created by the women— works not only as a strong social network that protects
children, but also as a marital or conjugal tool that keeps partners together, decreases stress, and
provides stability for the entire family.
22
The Journal of Pan African Studies, vol.2, no.01, November 2007
Within the lakou, mothers work together to complete their daily tasks, such as farming, building
new houses, and caring for the children. This collective sharing focuses not only on work but
also on the social and emotional aspects of family life (Dash 45). Extended family and friends
from the lakou are always there to provide guidance and perspectives until issues are resolved,
and these relationships supply the final safety net during hard times (Desrosiers and St. Fleurose
515).
Several studies have explored the role of social support as a buffer to stressful experiences. The
results of most of these studies indicate that social support has a positive relation to optimal
parenting and familial well-being (Glazier, Elgar, Goel, and Holzapfel 247). Regarding parenting
stress, Ostberg and Hagekull found that parents ranking high in social support experienced lower
levels of parenting stress (620). Social support also seems to provide specific benefits for low-
income parents; parents reporting higher levels of social support may experience less
psychological distress in conjunction with financial strain (McLoyd 311). Other research
indicates that the presence of social support may explain why some individuals experience
higher life stresses and strains without showing a high level of distress (Bonds, Gondoli, Sturge-
Apple, and Salem 410). Dash notes that social support from extended kin and the Haitian church
facilitates maternal competence in new mothers in urban communities (153). Clearly, protective
factors that buffer the impact of stress on mothering need to be identified. Yet the nature and role
of these risk and protective factors have been only minimally examined in families living in rural
Haiti.
Method
Participants
The target population for this exploratory pilot study was made up of parents and primary
caregivers with children between the ages of three and 18 who reside in the province of Leogane,
Haiti. Leogane is a small rural community of approximately 10,000 inhabitants, located 30
kilometers west of Port-au-Prince, the capital of Haiti. A convenience sample of 31 mothers,
grandmothers, and fathers was recruited for this study through the parent associations of the
AGAPE-Leogane Christian Mission Program, which serves 3,000 poor families in the Ca-Ira,
Guerin, Masson, and Mellier sections of Leogane. The mothers and grandmothers ranged in age
from 24 to 61 years, with Mean equaling 40.33 and Standard Deviation (SD) equaling 9.99. Of
the respondents, 11 were unmarried but living with a partner (35.5%), eight were
separated/divorced from their spouse (25.8%), eight were married (25.9%), and four were
widowed or single/never married (12.9%).
Measures
23
The Journal of Pan African Studies, vol.2, no.01, November 2007
Self-report measures were chosen based on their use in previous cross-cultural research and their
designation as the least intrusive means for gathering information from this population (Reitman,
Currier, and Stickle 384). Two bilingual and bicultural consultants were used to translate the
questionnaire and measures to French and Kreyol, the two official languages of Haiti. Although
only educated Haitians speak French, all Haitians speak Kreyol. The first consultant translated
all measures and demographic questionnaires from English to French and Kreyol. The second
bilingual and bicultural consultant translated these measures from Kreyol and French to English.
The first author then compared the Kreyol-to-English translation with the original English.
Translators were fluent in both written and spoken English and Kreyol, and Kreyol was the first
language of all of the translators. In addition, the 10 local interviewers reviewed each item in the
proposed questionnaire and the measures, focusing on cultural appropriateness and ease of
translation. They were asked to indicate any terms that were difficult to understand,
grammatically incorrect, or culturally insensitive. Some aspects of the measures and the
questionnaire were altered, and phrases that presented some degree of discrepancy were
modified accordingly.
Parenting Stress
The Parenting Distress Subscale of the Parenting Stress Index-Short Form (PSI-SF) was used to
determine the level of stress parents felt in association with parenting (Abidin 19). This subscale
is a direct derivative of the Parenting Stress Index (PSI), and items for the short form, which
contains three subscales, were identified by factor analysis of the original PSI. Parents rated 12
items on a five-point scale from 1 (strongly disagree) to 5 (strongly agree). The Parenting
Distress Subscale has previously been shown to measure distress experienced by parents as a
function of personal factors that are directly related to parenting. Items measure a parent’s
perception of childrearing competence, stresses associated with restrictions on activities due to
parenting, and social support (e.g., “I feel limited by my responsibilities as a parent”). The
Parenting Distress Subscale scores range from 12 to 60. Higher scores on the subscale indicate a
greater level of stress. According to Reitman, Currier, and Stickle, the PSI-SF Parenting Distress
Subscale has good internal consistency with low-income African American families, with a
Cronbach alpha coefficient reported of .88 (392). In the current study, the Cronbach alpha
coefficient was .83 for the translated subscale.
Lakou Support
The Family Support Scale was used to measure lakou parenting support and parents’ satisfaction
with the support they receive in raising a child (Dunst, Jenkins, and Trivette 47). The scale
consists of 18 items, covering sources of support such as the immediate family, relatives, friends,
and others in the family’s social network, social organizations, and specialized and generic
professional services.
24
The Journal of Pan African Studies, vol.2, no.01, November 2007
The measure consists of 18 items that are rated on a five-point Likert scale ranging from 0 (not at
all helpful) to 4 (extremely helpful). Parents were instructed to indicate the response that best
described how helpful the source was to the family in the last three to six months. If the source
was not applicable, they could indicate “does not apply” (“NA”). Cronbach’s alpha coefficient
for this study was .82 for the translated scale.
Demographic and Background Variables
The first and last sections of the questionnaire included items measuring the respondent’s gender,
age, marital status, age of children, number of children, number of household members, years of
residence within a lakou, number of families within the lakou, employment, and family income
history.
Procedure
In keeping with the culturally suitable mode of associative communication in Haiti, regional
community coordinators conducted face-to-face home visits to solicit participation and to explain
the goals and purpose of the study (Glenn and Glenn 20;
Devieux et al. 112). In addition, several
days before initiating the fieldwork, the first author trained 10 regional community coordinators
from various sections of the province in how to complete the interview protocol, protect
participant confidentiality and rights, ask questions respectfully, and show sensitivity to
respondent distress. The first author and local interviewers also conducted group sessions to
orally explain the content of the forms in both French and Kreyol, with the content consisting of
the purpose, procedures, confidentiality, risks, and benefits of the study. They also explained the
respondents’ freedom to withdraw and their right to ask questions. Informed written consent was
obtained from each parent participant, and signed copies were provided for their records.
According to the most recent report from PAHO, the illiteracy rate in Haiti is approximately 75
percent (3). Therefore, due to the sensitive nature of the questions, interviewers took parents to a
private area, where they read the instruments and recorded their responses. Interviewers did not
interview parents with whom they had personal relationships—for example, friends, kin, or
speaking acquaintances.
25
The Journal of Pan African Studies, vol.2, no.01, November 2007
Results
Description of Lakou Parents
Sociodemographic data were summarized using descriptive statistics as appropriate (range,
frequency distribution, mean, and percentage). The mean number of children in each household
was 4.19, and the SD was 2.24 (range: 1–11 children). Fifty-two percent of the children were
boys, and the mean age of the children was six years, with SD equaling 4.05. More than three-
fourths of the parents (77%) indicated that they were not currently working. The mean family
income was $4.39 (in U.S. dollars) per year. The majority of mothers (81%) had resided for more
than 10 years in their lakou, and nearly two-thirds (65%) had both kin and blood relatives who
resided in the same lakou. On average, mothers had a total of 14 families within their lakou.
Descriptive Analysis
In this study, raw PSI-SF Parental Distress Subscale scores were converted into percentiles.
Based on clinically validated cutoff values established by the author of the PSI, parents are
considered to be at high levels of stress if their total parenting stress score is above the 85th
percentile (Radloff 385). In this sample, 52% of parents indicated moderate levels of parenting
stress (33rd percentile range), while responses of more than one-fourth of the parents (29%)
indicated high levels of parenting stress ( 85th percentile). Overall, the results indicated that
81% of parents scored in the moderate and high levels of stress based on the values established
by the author of the PSI. In addition, parents indicated less availability of parenting support (“not
at all helpful” to “sometimes helpful”).
Statistical analyses were also conducted to evaluate whether demographic variables were
associated with stress. The demographic variables of age, marital status, child age, number of
children, income, and number of people in the lakou were correlated with family support and
parenting stress. The prevalence of parenting stress and parenting support for the total sample is
shown in Table 1. As expected, scores indicate a significant positive correlation between number
of children and parenting stress (r = .37, p < .05). Age was significantly correlated with the
number of people in the lakou (r = .40, p < .05). Family support was negatively and significantly
correlated with marital status (r = 44, p < .05) and positively correlated with the age of children
(r = .37, p < .05) and family income (r = .46, p < .01).
26
The Journal of Pan African Studies, vol.2, no.01, November 2007
Discussion
Parenting Stress in the Leogane Lakou
Haitian mothers reported higher levels of stress in their parenting role than generally found in the
U.S. sample, which would be expected given the political and economic situations in Haiti
(Abidin 150). Furthermore, mothers reported feeling less competent as parents and more
restricted in pursuing their own activities and interests. However, family income does not show a
strong relation to parents’ reports of parenting stress. One explanation for the lack of a
significant relationship between family income and parenting stress is that all of the mothers in
this sample were living in poverty; therefore, small variations in family income may not
significantly affect parenting stress levels.
In contrast to income, the number of children in the family was a strong predictor of parenting
stress. Use of the cultural-ecological model helps explain the relationship between number of
children and parenting stress within the Haitian context (Ogbu 425). According to the model,
social norms vary among cultural groups and influence the role of parents and child well-being
in a given society. In Haiti, large families are the norm. In the city, families may have three to
four children. In rural provinces, the average is seven children (PAHO 2). Traditionally, the
responsibility for rearing children has been shared with extended kin within the lakou network.
This network enabled mothers to work while adult female friends, family, and kin provided
oversight and care of the children. This mutual interdependence allowed mothers to meet the
demands of caring for large families. However, current rural mothers are not only expected to
fulfill the daily tasks of caring for all their children, but they must also do so within an overall
trend of deteriorating child health and education services and with decreasing support from the
network (Coreil, Augustin, Halsey, and Holt 236). Specifically, the availability of resources and
characteristics of the community, such as the lack of access to clean water sources, vaccination,
electricity, and schools in the Leogane province, are environmental and external variables that
can lead to a decreased sense of parenting competence and anxiety for these rural Haitian
mothers. The results also reveal that within this lakou network, mothers with younger children
receive lower levels of family support. These findings add to the sparse literature on stress,
which reports higher levels of parenting stress among mothers of younger children and among
families in which more siblings are present (Mash and Johnston 335).
Conversely, Haitian mothers also are aware of the shame and risk related to not being good
providers for their children. According to Devieux, Haitian culture is “other” focused (20). It is a
collective culture in which the emphasis is on what a person can do for his or her family or
community. For example, parents may have had several of their children die from malnutrition
and diarrhoeal diseases or may have had to send one or two of their older children to a nearby
city as a restavek (child domestic). In addition, some mothers may not have the resources to
reciprocate in caring for other children in their lakou. This situation may cause them to be
labeled as incompetent or selfish mothers.
27
The Journal of Pan African Studies, vol.2, no.01, November 2007
These shameful experiences and their inability to reciprocate with support can lead to negative
feelings and tensions directly attributable to the demands of parenthood (Deater-Deckard 330).
Therefore, future research should attempt to expand knowledge of the potential interaction
between poverty and other psychological and cultural factors that relate to parenting stress with
this population.
Summary and Implications
Overall, mothering is stressful, which—combined with other ecological stressors—can lead to
parental distress (Willinger, Diendorfer-Radner, Willnauer, Jorgl, and Hager 63). A number of
researchers have long suggested that children increase financial pressure on the family and often
create secondary problems, which then can lead to chronic role strains among certain groups of
mothers. In the African Diaspora, multiple mothering and support is the cornerstone of many
agrarian communities (Sault 12). Not only do many children experience and benefit from
multiple caregivers, mothers also receive support in the care and supervision of children.
However, this support or tradition of support does not exist in a vacuum. It is influenced by the
other political and social systems within Haitian culture and society. Sociohistorical and
environmental changes, such as political coups, U.S. occupations, and lack of basic human
services may influence the ability of lakou members to fulfill their responsibilities to each other
in the area of parenting. Some findings in this study are consistent with research showing that
parental distress can have adverse consequences for the psychological, physical, and emotional
health and well-being of Haitian families (Martsolf 296). Other findings in this study support
earlier research, which proposes that when exposed to stressors, mothers in positive supportive
environments demonstrate lower levels of strain compared with those in less supportive
environments (Bliese and Britt 434). Within the Haitian context, the lakou system appears to be a
protective factor for some mothers, but a source of stress for other mothers.
In summary, this study examined the interaction between individual and family factors, the
larger socioeconomic context, and parental stress to better understand the conditions likely to
influence mothering in a rural Haitian province. The findings from this pilot study suggest the
need for further research on mothering within collectivistic cultures. This study has implications
for family programs and public health interventions aimed at addressing the health and
psychological consequences of poverty and violence in Haiti. Poor rural Haitian mothers and
children would benefit from services that build on the strength of the lakou system.
28
The Journal of Pan African Studies, vol.2, no.01, November 2007
Limitations
This exploratory pilot study has several limitations. The first limitation is the size of the sample
(n=31), which precludes generalizability beyond the sample. Restriction to one rural community
in Haiti also limits generalizing to other rural and urban families or Haitian families in general.
Future studies should include larger samples of parents from a wider array of localities and
lakou. Finally, current levels of stress were obtained by self-report of symptoms rather than
diagnosis by a mental health professional. Over- or underestimation of symptoms and their
severity may have occurred. Due to the aforementioned limitations, caution should be exercised
in generalizing the results of this study beyond this sample. As indicated in the ecological
model, multiple factors affect the occurrence and results of stress. Longitudinal multivariate
studies may better clarify how stress and lakou support interact over time.
Works Cited
Abidin, R. R. Parenting Stress Index (PSI) Manual. 3d Ed. Charlottesville, VA.: Pediatric
Psychology Press, 1995.
Abidin, R. R. “The Determinants of Parenting Behavior.” Journal of Clinical Child Psychology
21 (1992): 407–412.
Ambert, A. “An International Perspective on Parenting: Social Change and Social Constructs.”
Journal of Marriage and the Family 56 (1994): 529–543.
Bonds, D. D., D.M. Gondoli, M.L. Sturge-Apple, and L.N. Salem. “Parenting Stress as Mediator
of the Relation between Parenting Support and Optimal Parenting.” Parenting Science
and Practice 2.4 (2002): 409–435.
Bliese, P.D., and T.W. Britt. “Social Support, Group Consensus and Stressor-Strain
Relationships: Social Context Matters.” Journal of Organizational Behavior 22 (2001):
425–436.
Bronfenbrenner, U. “Ecology of the Family as Context for Human Development: Research
Perspectives.” Developmental Psychology 22 (1986): 723–742.
Coreil, J., A. Augustin, N.A. Halsey, and E. Holt. “Social and Psychological Costs of Preventive
Child Health Services in Haiti.” Social Science and Medicine 38.2 (1994): 231–238.
29
The Journal of Pan African Studies, vol.2, no.01, November 2007
Dash, J. M. Culture and Customs of Haiti. Westport, CT: Greenwood Press, 2001.
Deater-Deckard, K. Parenting Stress. New Haven, CT: Yale University Press, 2004.
Deater-Deckard, K. “Parenting Stress and Child Adjustment: Some Old Hypotheses and New
Questions.” Clinical Psychology: Science and Practice 5.3 (1998): 314–332.
Desrosier, A., and S. St. Fleurose. “Treating Haitian Patients: Key Cultural Aspects.” American
Journal of Psychotherapy 56.4 (2002): 508–522.
Devieux, J. G., R.M. Malow, M.M. Jean-Gilles, D.M. Samuels, M. Deschamps, M. Ascencio Jr.,
L. Jean-Baptiste, and J.W. Pape. “Reducing Health Disparities through Culturally
Sensitive Treatment of HIV+ Adults in Haiti.” ABNF Journal 15.6 (2004): 109–115.
Dunst, C. J., V. Jenkins, and C.M. Trivette. “The Family Support Scale: Reliability and
Validity.” Journal of Individual, Family, and Community Wellness 1 (1984): 45–52.
Farmer, P. “Political Violence and Public Health in Haiti.” New England Journal of Medicine
350 (2004): 1483–1486.
Glazier, R.H., F.J. Elgar, V. Goel, and S. Holzapfel. “Stress, Social Support, and Emotional
Distress in a Community Sample of Pregnant Women.” Journal of Psychosomatic
Obstetrics and Gynecology
25 (2004): 247–255.
Glenn, E. S., and C.G. Glenn. Man and Mankind: Conflict and Communication between
Cultures. Norwood, NJ: Ablex, 1981.
Hashima, P. Y., and P.R. Amato. “Poverty, Social Support, and Parental Behavior.” Child
Development 65 (1994): 394–403.
Institut Haitien de Statistique et d'Informatique: Division d'Analyse et de Recherche
Demographique. A Study of the Relationship between Population and Regional
Development in Haiti. Port-au-Prince, Haiti: Institut Haitien de Statistique et
d'Informatique, 1989.
Jackson, A. “Maternal Self-Efficacy and Children’s Influence on Stress and Parenting among
Single Black Mothers in Poverty.” Journal of Family Issues 21(2000): 3–16.
LaRose, S. “The Haitian Lacou, Land, Family and Ritual.” Family and Kinship in Middle
America and the Caribbean. Eds. A. Marks and R. Romer. Willemstadt/Curacao,
Institute of Higher Studies in Curacao: 1975. 482–501.
30
The Journal of Pan African Studies, vol.2, no.01, November 2007
Luthar, S. Poverty and Children’s Adjustment. Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage Publications, 1999.
Martsoff, D. S. “Childhood Maltreatment and Mental and Physical Health in Haitian Adults.”
Journal of Nursing Scholarship 36.4 (2004): 293–299.
Mash, E.J. and C. Johnston. “Determinants of Parenting Stress: Illustrations from Families of
Hyperactive Children and Families of Physically Abused Children.” Journal of Clinical
Child Psychology 19 (1990): 313–338.
McLoyd, V. C. “The Impact of Economic Hardship on Black Families and Children:
Psychological Distress, Parenting, and Socio-Emotional Development.” Child
Development 61.2 (1990): 311–346.
Ogbu, J. U. “Origins of Human Competence: A Cultural Ecological Perspective.” Child
Development 52 (1981): 413–429.
Ostberg, M., and B. Hagekull. “A Structural Modeling Approach to the Understanding of
Parenting Stress.” Journal of Clinical Child Psychology 29.4 (2000): 615–625.
Pan American Health Organization. Haiti Profile. 2004. 23 December 2005
<
http://www.paho.org/English/sha/prflhai.htm>.
Reitman, D., R.O. Currier, and T.R. Stickle. “A Critical Evaluation of the Parenting Stress
Index-Short Form (PSI-SF) in a Head Start Population.” Journal of Clinical Child and
Adolescent Psychology 31.3 (2002): 384–392.
Willinger, U., G. Diendorfer-Radner, R. Willnauer, G. Jorgl, and V. Hager. “Parenting Stress and
Parental Bonding.” Behavioral Medicine 31.2 (2005): 63–69.
Willner, P., and R. Goldstein. “Mediation of Depression by Perceptions of Defeat and
Entrapment in High Stress Mothers.” British Journal of Medical Psychology 74 (2001):
473–485.
World Bank. Haiti Country Brie. 23 December 2005 <
http://go.worldbank.org/55NM6X1VQ0>.
World Health Organization. “Women’s Mental Health: An Evidence-Based Review.” Mental
Health Determinants and Populations, Department of Mental Health and Substance
Dependence. World Health Organization: Geneva, 2000.
World Health Organization. Haiti. December 23, 2005
<http://
www.who.int/entity/hac/crises/hti/background/2004/Haiti_Nov04.pdf>.
31
The Journal of Pan African Studies, vol.2, no.01, November 2007
Table 1: Means, Standard Deviations, and Correlations between Variables
Variable M SD 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8
1. Age 40.33 9.9 --
2. Marital Status ------ ------ -.09 --
3. Child Age 6.13 4.0 .36 -.06 --
4. Family Income $4.39 $12.59 .03 -.22 -.90 --
5. Number of People in Lakou 13.81 17.84 .40* -.05 -.11 -.15 --
6. Number of Children 4.19 2.2 .22 .09 -.29 .23 -.15 --
7. Parenting Stress 43.80 9.5 .30 .12 .03 -.13 .03 .37* --
8. Family Support 6.8 7.2 .14 -.44* .37* .60** .11 .03 -.23 --
Note.* p .05, **p .01
32
The Journal of Pan African Studies, vol.2, no.01, November 2007
... In slum communities in Haiti, a neighborhood is often composed of multiple smaller units called lakou, a common courtyard shared between households, where most of the cooking, cleaning, communal raising of kids, and toileting occurs between multiple families. These lakou promote strong social bonds and support systems for their residents [19]. Inclusion criteria were age � 18 years, and primary residence in Port-au-Prince. ...
Article
Full-text available
Neighborhood factors have been associated with health outcomes, but this relationship is underexplored in low-income countries like Haiti. We describe perceived neighborhood cohesion and perceived violence using the Neighborhood Collective Efficacy and the City Stress Inventory scores. We hypothesized lower cohesion and higher violence were associated with higher stress, depression, and hypertension. We collected data from a population-based cohort of adults in Port-au-Prince, Haiti between March 2019 to August 2021, including stress (Perceived Stress Scale), depression (PHQ-9), and blood pressure (BP). Hypertension was defined as systolic BP ≥ 140 mmHg, diastolic BP ≥ 90 mmHg, or on antihypertensive medications. Covariates that were adjusted for included age, sex, body mass index, smoking, alcohol, physical activity, diet, income, and education, multivariable linear and Poisson regressions assessed the relationship between exposures and outcomes. Among 2,961 adults, 58.0% were female and median age was 40 years (IQR:28–55). Participants reported high cohesion (median 15/25, IQR:14–17) and moderate violence (9/20, IQR:7–11). Stress was moderate (8/16) and 12.6% had at least moderate depression (PHQ-9 ≥11). Median systolic BP was 118 mmHg, median diastolic BP 72 mmHg, and 29.2% had hypertension. In regressions, higher violence was associated with higher prevalence ratios of moderate-to-severe depression (Tertile3 vs Tertile1: PR 1.12, 95%CI:1.09 to 1.16) and stress (+0.3 score, 95%CI:0.01 to 0.6) but not hypertension. Cohesion was associated with lower stress (Tertile3 vs Tertile1: -0.4 score, 95%CI: -0.7 to -0.2) but not depression or hypertension. In summary, urban Haitians reported high perceived cohesion and moderate violence, with higher violence associated with higher stress and depression.
... However, in doing so they miss that the associated outcomes are not merely economic or political problems in which women are marginalized, but a social problem centered in gender relations. Other literature speaks of the Haitian female in their gendered role of poto mitan-the center post of family relations and commerce activities (N'Zengou-Tayo 1998;Edmond et al., 2007;Renée and Schuller, 2009;Vansteenkiste, 2017;Moore, 2020), but fail to attribute the historical successes of local food security to the same gendered role and responsibility; a necessary step to understand the impact of integration into the world food economy. The 1994 RFSA team found female-headed households more vulnerable than male-headed ones, yet in times of scarcity social networks ensured vulnerable people-children under age of five, pregnant and lactating women, the elderly and chronically ill-were given priority in feeding, marking the critical importance of social relations in maintaining food security (Baro et al., 1994:23;Baro, 2002). ...
Article
Full-text available
Over the past five decades, agricultural trade liberalization and integration into the global food system have undermined gender equality, women’s empowerment, and food security in Haiti. International actors who design agricultural policies are aware of gendered contributions to Haitian food security, yet ignore this knowledge to privilege an ideological belief that trade liberalization and structural adjustment programs will advance gender equality. I argue that agriculture and food policies must treat gender roles and responsibilities as constitutive to the solution by recognizing their critical contribution to the structure of Haitian agrarian society and accordingly food security. I advance this claim by analyzing scholarly literature, institutional documents, and interviews with interlocutors ( n = 292) from rural, peri-urban, and urban settings across Haiti to document how: 1) dominant narratives support an ideological belief that trade liberalization will advance gender equality; 2) integration of Haiti’s local food economy into the world food economy demands the reorientation of gendered labour; 3) women must participate in a system that while purporting to improve food security, ultimately diminishes their nutrition and social, economic and political wellbeing. This research documents that policies designed to globalize Haiti’s food economy on the premise of improving food security actually force women to abandon agricultural production and intensify their labour in less lucrative distribution and consumption roles of imported goods. This analysis documents that the transition ultimately reifies gender inequalities, heighten food insecurity, and contributes to feminist food scholarship.
... We considered the relationship between peacekeeping bases located in urban, semiurban, and rural regions and narratives about sexual misconduct. Women and girls in rural Haiti face greater socioeconomic disparities compared to their urban or semi-urban counterparts, on account of fewer opportunities for education, employment, reduced access to health and social services, greater reliance on remittances from emigrated relatives, and increased employment in the informal sector (Verner 2008;Orozco 2006;Edmond et al. 2007;Padgett and Warnecke 2011;Fawzi et al. 2005). We propose that rural, urban, and semi-urban geographical locations are associated with differential participation in the gendered peacekeeping economies of transactional sex, domestic work, and sex work, thereby resulting in a greater sharing of narratives about SEA. ...
Article
Full-text available
During the United Nations Stabilization Mission in Haiti (MINUSTAH), reports of sexual abuse and exploitation and children fathered by peacekeepers were brought forward to the UN. In 2017, a cross-sectional mixed-methods survey was administered by Haitian research assistants using SenseMaker® (Cognitive Edge, Singapore), a rapid data collection tool that allows participants to share a narrative on a topic of interest. In total, 2541 self-interpreted narratives in relation to the experiences of Haitian women and girls vis-à-vis peacekeepers were collected from a convenience sample of Haitian males and females across Haiti. This exploratory secondary data analysis analyzes whether narratives about sexual misconduct perpetrated by MINUSTAH peacekeepers were associated with rural, semi-urban, or urban locations and investigates the relationship between sharing narratives about sexual misconduct and the desire to engage with the UN/MINUSTAH. After adjustment, narratives addressing sexual misconduct were more likely to be shared in rural locations, compared to urban locations (RRrural: 1.19; 95% CI: 1.03, 1.38). Personal experiences of sexual misconduct were more likely (RRsex: 4.52; 95% CI: 3.34, 6.12) to be associated with rejection of the UN/MINUSTAH, compared to personal narratives of positive/neutral experiences. This research is an empirical steppingstone to understanding the distribution and consequences of peacekeeper-perpetrated sexual abuse and exploitation in Haiti.
Chapter
From nineteenth-century antislavery pamphleteering to accounts of ecological catastrophe in twenty-first-century fiction, Haitian literature has resounded across the globe since the nation's revolutionaries declared independence in 1804. Starting with pre-revolutionary writing, including the emergence of Haitian Creole letters, extending to the long, largely francophone nineteenth century, and concluding with present-day Haitian writing in the English language, A History of Haitian Literature presents the political, cultural, and historical frameworks necessary to comprehend Haiti's vast literary output. Whether writing in Haiti or its wide-ranging diasporas, Haitian authors have boldly contributed to pressing conversations in global letters while reflecting Haiti's unique cultural and historical experiences. Considering an expansive array of poets, playwrights, and novelists – such as Baron de Vastey, Juste Chanlatte, Demesvar Delorme, Edwidge Danticat, René Depestre, Kettly Mars, Dany Laferrière, and Évelyne Trouillot – the contributors to this volume offer a fresh examination of a richly polyglot, transnational literary tradition that spans more than two centuries.
Article
Importance Higher social vulnerability is associated with premature cardiovascular disease (CVD) and mortality but is understudied in low-income countries that have both the highest magnitude of social vulnerability and a growing CVD epidemic. Objective To evaluate the association between social vulnerability and hypertension, CVD, and CVD subtypes in Haiti as a model for similar low-income countries. Design, Setting, and Participants This population-based cohort study used enrollment data from adults participating in the Haiti Cardiovascular Disease Cohort Study. Recruitment occurred via multistage random sampling throughout slum and urban neighborhoods in Port-au-Prince, Haiti, from March 2019 to August 2021. Data were analyzed from May 2022 to December 2023. Exposures A modified Haitian Social Vulnerability Index (SVI-H) was created following the US Centers for Disease Control and Prevention Social Vulnerability Index method. Twelve variables across the domains of socioeconomic status, household characteristics, and social and community context were included. The SVI-H was calculated for each study neighborhood block and then stratified into SVI-H quartiles (quartile 1 was the least vulnerable; quartile 4, the most vulnerable). Main Outcomes and Measures Prevalent hypertension and total CVD, defined as heart failure (HF), stroke, transient ischemic attack (TIA), angina, or myocardial infarction (MI). Age-adjusted Poisson regression analysis yielded prevalence ratios (PRs) comparing the prevalence of hypertension, total CVD, and CVD subtypes across SVI-H quartiles. Results Among 2925 adults (1704 [58.3%] female; mean [SD] age, 41.9 [15.9] years), the prevalence of hypertension was 32.8% (95% CI, 31.1%-34.5%) and the prevalence of CVD was 14.7% (95% CI, 13.5%-16.0%). Hypertension prevalence ranged from 26.2% (95% CI, 23.1%-29.3%) to 38.4% (95% CI, 34.8%-42.0%) between quartiles 1 and 4, while CVD prevalence ranged from 11.1% (95% CI, 8.8%-13.3%) to 19.7% (95% CI, 16.8%-22.6%). SVI-H quartile 4 vs 1 was associated with a greater prevalence of hypertension (PR, 1.17; 95% CI, 1.02-1.34) and CVD (PR, 1.48; 95% CI, 1.16-1.89). Among CVD subtypes, SVI-H was significantly associated with HF (PR, 1.64; 95% CI, 1.23-2.18) but not with combined stroke and TIA or combined angina and MI. Conclusions and Relevance In urban Haiti, individuals living in neighborhoods with the highest social vulnerability had greater prevalence of hypertension and HF. Understanding CVD disparities in low-income countries is essential for targeting prevention and treatment interventions toward populations at highest risk globally.
Chapter
Childcare decisions made by biological parents and extended families in Haiti must be understood in the context of Haiti’s uniquely complicated and tumultuous history and modern-day conditions of extreme deprivation. Haitian parenting and child care choices are fundamentally shaped by the culturally and historically conditioned norm of fluid family structures and the use of harsher approaches in normative parenting practices. These are separate from cases of abuse in childcare as necessary adaptations to harsh living conditions. We argue that Haitian parenting, although qualitatively different from accepted normative parenting approaches in Western industrialized democracies, has in many ways evolved in ingenious and exceptional ways to protect children in a climate that is harshly unfavorable to positive outcomes for children, regardless of the parenting approaches employed. Our argument and analysis of parenting excludes extreme abusive parenting and mistreatment that is often promoted by alcoholism or mental health problems. Rather, our focus is on normative and typical Haitian parenting. For those concerned with improving outcomes for Haitian children and families, we hope to provide a deeper and more nuanced understanding of how and why Haitian parenting and childcare practices are as they are. This culturally and historically grounded knowledge should advance two goals for those desiring to support Haitian parents and caregivers. The first highlights unique assets in extended and fluid family structures in Haiti that can be leveraged and the second clarifies ways in which understanding the context and environment in which caregivers make decisions about discipline is needed to diminish violence against Haitian children.KeywordsHaitianParentingChildcareFluid familiesViolence
Article
Full-text available
Dunst, C. J. Systematic review and meta-analysis of the relationships between family social support and parenting stress, burden, beliefs and practices. ABSTRACT: This paper includes the results of a systematic review and meta-analysis of the relationships between perceived family social support and parenting stress, caregiving burden, parent engagement practices, and parent-child interaction practices among caregivers raising a child with and without identified disabilities or health-related conditions birth to 18 years of age. The study included 82 independent samples of caregivers (N = 7,675 study participants) conducted in 12 countries between 1985 and 2020. The Family Support Scale total scale score was the independent variable in each study. The dependent measures included seven different parenting stress scales, eight different caregiving burden scales, seven different parenting belief scales, and nine different parenting behavior and practices scales. The correlations between the independent and dependent measures were the sizes of effect between the perceived family social support and the different parenting measures. Results showed that perceived family social support was related to attenuated parenting stress, less caregiving burden, and more positive parenting beliefs, behavior, and practices. The sizes of effect ranged between r =-.14, 95% CI =-.17,-.11, p = .000, for caregiving burden and r = .22, 95% CI = .16, .28, p = .000, for parenting beliefs. The sizes of effect for the relationships between measures did not differ as a function of child condition (developmental disabilities, autism spectrum disorders, health-related conditions, at-risk status, or no disability or at-risk status) or caregiver gender (mothers or fathers). Child age moderated the relationships between family social support and parenting stress and caregiving burden and caregiver age and marital status moderated the relationships between family social support and parenting stress. The pattern of results provided support for the hypothesized relationships between the independent and dependent measures based on the conceptual frameworks that guided the conduct of the study and showed that perceived family social support was related to attenuated parenting stress, less caregiving burden, and more positive parenting beliefs and practices.
Article
In light of recent global debates over the dangers of institutionalised orphan care, a new model of family care premised on the trope of family reunification has emerged among Haitian and US faith‐based actors as the best alternative for ensuring vulnerable children's well‐being. This article offers a critical cultural reading of narratives on family reunification in Haiti in social media and advocacy discourse, revealing how this approach privileges Northern assumptions about proper parenting and family life. Not only are these ideas a mismatch with realities in Haiti, they evoke deficit constructions of family and childhood that facilitate the nation's further positioning as a subject of transnational neoliberal governmentality.
Article
Full-text available
I write this essay from a place of thirst, discontent, dream; from being housed in the United States but not at home there; from thinking through this writing in English, a language that is not home; and from wanting to continue making a place that is not home. I think through this inquiry from a place of cohabitation with Western ways of knowing that have purposefully demonized peoples of African descent as less than human; from the tradition of Haitian thinkers and resurgents who emphasize spirituality as crucial to recreating themselves endlessly; and from imagining the unseen, unfelt, and invisible powers that illuminate the process. In this place of feverishness, I sit with Haitian writer and singer Mimerose Beaubrun's monograph Nan Dòmi in order to consider the possibilities and impossibilities that might be realized through a practice of decolonial labor that bridges the known and the unknown, the seen and the unseen, the metaphysical and the material. Taking inspiration from María Lugones's phenomenological approach of decoloniality and Beaubrun's theory of nan dòmi (dream/ing), this essay asks: what in Beaubrun's Nan Dòmi opens decoloniality as a radical onto-epistemological terrain from which to rethink subjectivities, politics, and worlds in uneven and unjust geographies?
Book
Culture and Customs of Haitibegins with an overview of the mountainous island that seemed forbidding to European colonizers. Historical periods, including French colonization, U.S. occupation in the early 20th century, Independence and the Duvaliers' reigns, until today, are reviewed and provide the framework for the volume. A chapter on the people and society details the pride of the black state that managed the only successful slave revolution in history. The extremes of society from the elite to the peasantry and slum dwellers are depicted, along with Haitians in diaspora. Religion in Haiti, with the strong amalgamation of Roman Catholicism and vaudou, a West African import, is then explained. A Social Customs chapter notes the joy that is found in such an economically depressed culture. The media and literature and language chapters necessarily unfold in the context of Haiti's political history. A section on writing in Creole is especially intriguing. Finally, chapters on the performing arts and visual arts evoke the energy and color of the people in such forms as vaudou jazz and dance, contemporary rara rock, and the folkloric influence on Haitian painting. A chronology and glossary supplement the text.
Article
Three general areas of research and social concern pertaining to parenting are discussed within an international perspective focusing on recent social changes as well as on constructs of parenting. First, I critique ideological biases arising out of a particular Western definition of parenting—in this case, mothering—that affect research paradigms. This critique is then expanded by linking it to current international social changes in order to offer a glimpse into areas of parenting that could be addressed empirically. And, third, consideration of socioeconomic changes and upheavals leads to the suggestion that the experience of parenting may become more difficult in the near future in most countries of the world. This discussion is informed by a critical analysis based on perspectives that view childhood, and hence parenting, as social constructs evolving with sociohistorical changes.
Article
This study explores the relations among perceived self-efficacy, social support, children's behaviors, and maternal parenting in a sample of 188 single Black mothers of a preschoolage child, employed and nonemployed, who also were current and former welfare recipients in New York City. Using multiple regression techniques, a positive relationship was found between child behavior problems and parenting stress; being nonemployed, lower self-efficacy, and less social support from friends were marginally significant predictors. Fewer child behavior problems and higher maternal educational attainment were significant predictors of more supportive, involved parenting. A marginally significant positive interaction between self-efficacy and child behavior problems indicated that self-efficacy buffered the effect of behavior problems on maternal parenting behavior.
Article
Examines the relative contributions of environmental, child, and Parental characteristics to parent-child interactive stress for families of hyperactive children and those of physically abused children. In families of hyperactive children, difficult child characteristics represent a probable source of parent-child interactive stress, whereas in abusive families such stress more likely arises from parental characteristics and adverse environments. The role of maternal cognitions as a mediator of stress in the two types of families is considered and relevant research into maternal perceptions, maternal attributions, and maternal self-efficacy is reviewed. Recommendations for the study of maternal cognitions in the context of interactive stress include: studying the interface between cognition and affect; assessing cognitions as ongoing processes; examining the role of cognitions in mediating situational influences; adopting a systems framework; and establishing the modifiability of specific types of parental cognitions.
Article
Objective. This study assessed the direct and indirect relations between 2 types of social support - parenting support and general social support - and optimal parenting. Design. Self-report data were gathered from 165 married mothers of firstborn 4th-graders between the ages of 9 and 11 years. Widely accepted measures of warmth, monitoring, general psychological distress, parenting stress, and general social support were used. A measure of parenting support from family and friends was developed for this study. Results. Path analysis indicated that the relation between specific parenting support and optimal parenting was completely mediated by parenting stress and not by general psychological distress. The relation between general social support and optimal parenting was not completely mediated by either parenting stress or general psychological distress. Conclusions. This study integrated essential components from the social support, stress and coping, and parenting research. The authors identify parenting stress as a mediator of the relation between parenting support and optimal parenting by focusing on the specificity of social support and stress in the domain of parenting.
Article
Explored factors that influence parenting behavior through examination of previously reported and more recently developed models for predicting parenting behavior. Patterson's behavioral model, Abidin's initial model of parenting stress, and Belsky's process model of determinants of parenting are reviewed. A proposed model is presented to improve on previous models by integrating sociological, environmental, and behavioral factors, as well as personality characteristics of the parent, in predicting parenting behavior. Finally, description is provided on a new self-report measure (i.e., the Parenting Alliance Inventory) developed to focus on those aspects of the marital relationship that bear directly on parenting. Implications for future research are presented.