ArticlePDF Available

Desperate lives: urban refugee women in Malaysia and Egypt

Authors:

Abstract

While the international community is still working out howto identify and best serve them, refugees and IDPs in urbansettings are making their own way – often placing themselvesat considerable risk.
20 URBAN DISPLACEMENT
FMR 34
The future of displacement is clearly
urban – and clearly fraught with
challenges. The Women’s Refugee
Commission (WRC) has recently
undertaken research into the
risks and challenges confronting
refugee women in urban areas –
as well as the opportunities they
gain – as they seek to provide
for themselves and their families
in seings where international
assistance is minimal. The research
included urban eld assessments
covering the plight of Burmese
refugee women in Kuala Lumpur,
Malaysia, and of Iraqi, Somali,
Sudanese, Eritrean and Ethiopian
refugee women in Cairo, Egypt.
Unsafe at home or at work
in Kuala Lumpur
Malaysia is host to a large number of
migrant workers and an estimated
100,000 refugees and asylum
seekers, most of whom are from
persecuted Burmese ethnic groups.
Forty thousand are registered
as refugees with UNHCR.1
As Malaysia has not signed the
1951 Refugee Convention, refugees
have no legal status and no
right to work or legal residency.
In the eyes of the government,
there is no dierence between
an undocumented worker and a
refugee. The Malaysian government
initiated a widespread campaign
to crack down on undocumented
migrants in 2004 and has since
reported an “intention to deport more
than one million undocumented
migrants”2 through mass arrests.
This initiative has led, on average,
to the arrest of 700-800 UNHCR-
recognised refugees each month.3
The safety of Burmese
refugee women living
in Kuala Lumpur is
greatly compromised
by their aempts
to make a living.
Whereas in many
contexts access to
livelihoods brings
greater protection
against sexual
harassment, abuse
and exploitation, for
a refugee woman
in Kuala Lumpur
having a job increases
her vulnerability
to gender-based
violence, arrest,
detention and
extortion.4
Without status and
the right to work in
Malaysia, there are
few viable economic
opportunities open
to refugees. However, because they
desperately need work, refugee
women oen nd employment in the
informal and less regulated sectors of
the economy, such as in restaurants
as waitresses and dishwashers.
Without the protection that legal
status and documentation provide,
refugee women are at the mercy
of their employers, who frequently
withhold pay or sexually harass and
exploit them. If the women were to
report the crimes, they would risk
arrest and deportation. The Women’s
Refugee Commission, in fact, found
that the women risk arrest every
time they leave the house. This
impedes their movement, further
narrows their work choices, and
limits their social and economic
interactions. Burmese refugee
women report a cycle of repeated
arrests, frequent deportations and
the recurring payment of bribes
to be either released from custody
or to re-enter the country.
“We are afraid. Women are getting
attacked and arrested coming
home late from work. We have
problems not getting paid at work.
We are afraid of the police. We are
constantly hiding. Our children go
hungry when we are not paid.”
(Focus group with refugee
women, 21 May 2008)
Because of the risks they face
leaving their apartments, some
refugee women stay home and
work cooking and cleaning for
male household members, who are
generally not related to them but
come from the same ethnic group.
As many as 25 workers reside in a
single apartment and collectively
cover the rent for a refugee woman
who agrees to tend to their domestic
needs. While this protects the
women from the potential arrest
and deportation she might face
while going out, it puts her at risk of
sexual exploitation from unrelated
male household members who share
overcrowded living quarters.
While the international community is still working out how
to identify and best serve them, refugees and IDPs in urban
settings are making their own way – often placing themselves
at considerable risk.
Desperate lives: urban refugee
women in Malaysia and Egypt
Dale Buscher and Lauren Heller
Burmese re fugee in Malay sia who was sexually haras sed at
work and lef t her job and who is now afraid to seek further
employment for fear of sexual harrassment and/or arrest.
Women’s Refugee Commission/Lauren Heller
URBAN DISPLACEMENT 21
FMR 34
While some small NGO projects
support home-based handicra
production as a means of reducing
vulnerability, the projects oer
limited skills training, are not
market-driven and hence provide
lile opportunity for sustainable
income. Quality and market access
are major impediments to scaling
up this projects. At present, most
buyers are from the NGO and
expatriate volunteer community.
Working risks in Cairo
Cairo hosts a highly diverse
refugee population that is
struggling to survive in a very
dicult urban environment with
limited assistance. High national
unemployment rates and a huge
population of unemployed youth
plague the local labour market
and impede refugee access.
WRC’s eld assessment trip to
Cairo found many of the same
challenges and risks that confront
refugee women in Kuala Lumpur.
While Egypt allows refugees to
obtain work permits, securing
a work permit is an expensive,
lengthy and complicated process
that requires an employer sponsor
and no competition from a similarly
qualied Egyptian candidate. As
a result, refugees are forced into
unregulated work sectors and
occupations with few protections.
The majority of refugee women who
work do so as domestic workers
in Egyptian households. As this
sector is not regulated by Egyptian
labour law, a work permit is not
required and there is a constant
market demand for such labour.
However, the lack of regulation
creates a risky work environment.
Inside the connes of these private
homes, refugee women face potential
harassment, physical abuse, sexual
exploitation and the non-payment
of wages. Of the refugee women
who cannot nd domestic work,
some reportedly turn to commercial
sex work.5 Despite frequent reports
of gender-based violence, WRC
found few established support
services for survivors in Cairo.
Protective elements
The eld assessments conducted by
WRC did, however, nd examples
of how refugee women’s protection
can be enhanced – even in urban
areas where there is no legal right
to work. Protective elements can be
built into economic programmes –
elements such as accompaniment,
requiring codes of conduct for
employers, sensitisation campaigns,
creating linkages with local
women’s leadership and political
groups, and engaging men – both
from the refugee community and
also from the host community.
One organisation in Cairo, for
example, that trains and places
refugee women in Egyptian homes
as domestic workers accompanies
them on their rst day. The NGO
records the name and contact details
of the employer as well as the agreed
payment rate, thereby leing the
employer know that the woman has a
backup support system and the NGO
knows how and where to nd the
employer should there be problems.
Other successful models includes
a private sector initiative, the
Malaika Linen Factory, that hires
both Egyptian and refugee women
to do highly skilled embroidery.
The factory oers a 40-day
training programme that includes
transportation and meal costs for
women participants and is one
of the only examples of a private
sector company actively recruiting
refugee women and integrating them
with Egyptian female employees.
Building in these protective elements,
though, requires thoughtful
planning, understanding the
risks faced, assessing the means
of reducing risks, and integrating
components into the livelihoods
intervention to reduce vulnerability.
Advocating for and securing
legal status for refugees in these
environments and their legal right to
work would oer the most protection.
Dale Buscher (DaleB@wrcommission.
org) is Director of Protection
and Lauren Heller (LaurenH@
wrcommission.org) is Program
Ofcer with the Women’s Refugee
Commission (http://www.
womensrefugeecommission.org).
1. Interview with UNHCR, 26 May 2008.
2. Joint NGO Memorandum concerning the crackdown
on undocumented migrants, 29 January 2005.
3. See article Nah pp31-3.
4. ‘Desperate Lives: Burmese Women Struggle to Make a
Living in Malaysia’, Women’s Refugee Commission, May
2008: hp://www.womensrefugeecommission.org/docs/
mys_rep.pdf
5. Interview with Refugee Egypt medical sta, 24 July
2008.
Refugee women working in the Malaika Linen Factory, Cairo.
Women’s Refugee Commission/Lauren Heller
... Although the Malaysian government allows UNHCR to operate in the country, refugees have limited legal rights, few social and health supports, and experience widespread economic insecurity (Buscher & Heller, 2010;Shaw et al., 2019). Like most countries in the region, Malaysia is not a signatory to the 1951 Refugee Convention and its 1967 Protocol, which provides refugees recognition and certain rights in their country of asylum (UNHCR, 2024b). ...
... However, mental health service utilization among different ethnic groups have been minimally examined partially due to studies with small sample sizes. Furthermore, refugees residing in host countries that are not signatories to the UN Refugee Convention are particularly vulnerable and may be less likely to utilize mental health services (Buscher & Heller, 2010;Shaw et al., 2019). Lastly, length of stay is also associated with health service utilization, as new immigrants and refugees have to adapt to the culture, society, and health care system of the new country (Yang & Hwang, 2016). ...
Article
Full-text available
This paper examines the frequency of post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD) and factors associated with mental health counseling utilization among adult refugees and asylum-seekers in Malaysia. Participants (n = 286) were recruited using venue-based random sampling from three health clinics in 2018. Framed by Andersen’s model of health care utilization, we used a multilevel logistic regression and hypothesized that predisposing factors (female, older age, not married, higher education, lived longer in Malaysia, registered refugee), greater enabling factors (easy access to healthcare, larger household income, not needing interpreter, health literacy, larger household), and greater need factors (higher PTSD symptoms) would be associated with counseling attendance. We found one-third (34.3%) of participants screened positive for PTSD and most (71.9%) never attended counseling services. Our hypothesis was partially supported. Older age was associated with counseling attendance [OR:1.03 (95% CI:1.00,1.06)]. Enabling factors associated with counseling attendance include easy access to a health facility [OR:9.82 (95% CI:3.15,30.59)] and not needing interpreter services [OR:4.43 (95% CI:1.34,14.63)]. Greater need factor/PC-PTSD score [OR:0.69 (95% CI:0.52,0.91)]; however, was associated with lower counseling attendance. Other predisposing/enabling/need factors did not show significant associations. Understanding factors associated to care can benefit health clinics address gaps in counseling utilization for refugees and asylum-seekers in Malaysia.
... This is justified by the cordial relations that IDPs have with their hosts. This assertion of IDPs is refuted by authors such as [9,10,11,12,13,5,1,2,14] who claim that displaced persons are generally segregated from the host population in camps or slums located on the outskirts of urban centres, lacking basic socioeconomic infrastructure. Their freedom of movement is restricted by inappropriate regulations and laws put in place by the authorities of the host areas. ...
... They are finding it increasingly difficult to find work compared to men. According to Buscher and Heller [12] the types of jobs available to them are those of waitresses or dishwashers in restaurants and domestic servants. In shelters, displaced women often face all kinds of ill-treatment, sexual exploitation and abuse by their employers, and non-payment of their wages. ...
Article
Burkina Faso, previously spared from destabilization of all kinds, suffered its first terrorist acts in April 2015 in Samorogouan. These first terrorist acts were followed by several others that led to the forced internal displacement of nearly 2,000,000 people. These IDPs have chosen 301 municipalities spread across the 13 regions of the country as destinations for refuge. The main objective of this study is to analyse the living conditions and socio-territorial integration of IDPs and durable solutions to address the crisis of forced internal displacement in the commune of Kaya. The research methodology consisted of conducting a literature review on the study topic, collecting primary data through field surveys, interviews and direct observations in the study area. The results of this study show that IDPs in Kaya commune face precarious living conditions. On the other hand, their conditions for socio-territorial integration are good in view of the cordial relations that the IDPs maintain with the host populations of the commune. In addition, durable solutions to address the forced internal displacement crisis include the resettlement of IDPs in other parts of the country, return to areas of origin and integration in IDP-hosting areas. These solutions could address forced internal displacement and address those affected. This would facilitate the reintegration or socio-territorial integration of IDPs either in their areas of origin or in their reception areas.
... Similar to other countries in the Southeast Asian region, Malaysia has not ratified the 1951 Refugee Convention or the 1967 Protocol (Stange et al., 2019), meaning refugees in Malaysia are not legally recognized and have limited and restricted access to public resources such as public healthcare and education (Lego, 2018). Since there is no formal legal framework, refugees are denied the legal rights to work, and often resort to participation in numerous dirty, dangerous, and demeaning jobs in order to support themselves and their family (Buscher and Heller, 2010;Salim, 2019;Ghazali et al., 2020;Nungsari et al., 2020). Despite them having no legal rights, it is important to note that they are often tolerated and spared prosecution by Malaysian law enforcement on their discretion (Yesmin, 2016). ...
Article
Full-text available
The Rohingya ethnic group is one of the most persecuted minorities, whose specific circumstances pose unique and interesting challenges. The digital revolution is transforming the world and is leaving refugees behind (UNHCR). In this paper, we present a multiphase user centred approach we used to explore how Rohingya refugees could access assistance by utilizing technology they already have or share; both early on and long after they arrived in a new country. The findings we present from phase 1, which was an early participatory design phase, were confirmed and endorsed by the Rohingya community, UNHCR and local charities during phase 3. These findings, suggest that concepts aiming to assist Rohingya refugees should primarily focus on: safety, social capital, upskilling, and language translation. Finally, we present the iterative user centred design, implementation, and evaluation of one of these concepts focusing on safety, before being deployed within the Rohingya community in Malaysia.
... They also suffer restricted or unaffordable access to public resources and services (Lego, 2018;Nungsari et al., 2020) such as healthcare, education, housing, banking and public transportation. It is important to note that refugees are granted a degree of mobility and that there are no encampments (Nah, 2010), so most of them can be found in urban areas, living in close contact with the local community and resorting to the informal job market for their livelihoods (Buscher and Heller, 2010;Ghazali et al., 2020;Salim, 2019;Sullivan, 2016). Given the absence of formal legal frameworks and governance mechanisms, the responsibility of providing assistance and protection to refugees tends to fall largely under the local UNHCR office or with civil society organizations (CSOs). ...
Article
Full-text available
Purpose This paper aims to provide an in-depth conceptualization of service exclusion by drawing on our exploratory research as well as thick and rich insights from the authors’ qualitative data. Design/methodology/approach Qualitative research was used to explore service exclusion practices against customers experiencing vulnerabilities. A total of 28 semi-structured in-depth interviews were conducted with refugees residing within Malaysia. The Gioia methodology was used for the authors’ data analysis and the findings were validated by an independent moderator. Findings The authors’ empirical findings challenge how service exclusion is currently understood, by adding substantial depth and complexity beyond simply describing “the lack of access to services”. The authors also offer rich empirical findings describing 29 forms of exclusion, which were further reduced to seven types of service exclusion practices: discrimination, restriction, cost barriers, language and technology barriers, poor servicing, non-accountability and non-inclusivity. Originality/value This study conceptualizes service exclusion from a process perspective, that is, “how” customers experiencing vulnerabilities are being excluded, rather than “what” is excluded.
... They cannot legally work and are constrained in the type and nature of jobs that they can hold in the country, regardless of the amount of education and training that they have (Lego, 2018;Nungsari et al., 2020a). To make money to sustain themselves and their families, refugees generally either work informally for local companies and organizations in industries such as construction, cleaning, or landscaping, complete ad hoc jobs for small amounts of money, or operate as small-time entrepreneurs by running their own business (Buscher & Heller, 2010;Salim, 2019;Sullivan, 2016). Given that all of these lines of work involve interfacing with members of the host country, it is crucial that refugees searching for work have at least a basic grasp of the local language (Alba & Nee, 1997;Chiswick & Miller, 2001;Remennick, 2003). ...
Article
Full-text available
Does exposure to an unfamiliar migrant community change implicit biases? We conducted an experimental study by exposing Malaysians them to a few hours of volunteering with Rohingya refugees, and we examined the effect of this treatment on their attitudes through a textual analysis. We measured changes in attitude through pure valence and multiple measures of implicit bias, including linguistic intergroup bias. We found that the volunteers became markedly more positive, and this change was statistically significant. Our results suggest that brief exposure to refugees may be a cost-effective policy lever for changing local perceptions of refugees. © 2021 The Author(s). Published with license by Taylor & Francis Group, LLC.
Article
Full-text available
Rohingya women are doubly marginalized owing to their ethnicity and gender. Therefore, this study aims to describe the unique experiences of violence faced by Rohingya women who fled Myanmar and Bangladesh to seek asylum in Malaysia before, during, and after their transit. Primary data were collected from 33 participants comprising Rohingya women refugees and asylum seekers, medical social workers, medical officials, volunteer workers/activists, refugee organization officers, and a mental health care provider. Thematic analysis was used to identify the patterns in and relationships between the concepts in the collected data. Rohingya women were exposed to various forms of violence and trauma by various groups of men, including those from their own community, throughout their journey to and in Malaysia. The lack of recognition of refugees and asylum seekers in Malaysia prevents them from having mainstream or legal access to jobs, education, and healthcare, and this predicament compounds their suffering from violence, especially for women and girls. Rohingya women and girls in Malaysia need better access to healthcare, resources, and support to identify and address violence, which has a significant impact on their health.
Article
Full-text available
Background Among refugees residing in countries of first asylum, such as Malaysia, high rates of psychological distress call for creative intervention responses. Aims This study examines implementation of a Screening, Brief Intervention, and Referral to Treatment (SBIRT) model promoting emotional well-being and access to services. Method The one-session intervention was implemented in community settings by refugee facilitators during 2017 to 2020. 140 Participants including Afghan (n = 43), Rohingya (n = 41), and Somali (n = 56) refugees were randomized to receive either the intervention at baseline, or to a waitlist control group. At 30 days post-intervention, all participants completed a post-assessment. Additionally, after completing the intervention, participants provided feedback on SBIRT content and process. Results Findings indicate the intervention was feasible to implement. Among the full sample, Refugee Health Screening-15 emotional distress scores reduced significantly among participants in the intervention group when compared to those in the waitlist control group. Examining findings by nationality, only Afghan and Rohingya participants in the intervention condition experienced significant reductions in distress scores compared to their counterparts in the control condition. Examining intervention effects on service access outcomes, only Somali participants in the intervention condition experienced significant increases in service access compared to the control condition. Conclusions Findings indicate the potential value of this SBIRT intervention, warranting further research.
Article
In developing countries with limited resources available for aid distribution, community-based organizations have been pivotal in providing emergency relief to marginalized groups during the COVID-19 pandemic and its subsequent lockdown(s). Using the theory of power–dependence relations and resource dependency theory, this paper explores the realities of refugee-led community-based organizations (RLOs) in Malaysia and their relationships with internal and external agents. Utilizing qualitative data from 38 leaders and followers, we conducted a thematic analysis to understand the experiences of RLOs since March 2020, finding that during the pandemic: (1) a significant burden fell on a few leaders to distribute aid from external parties; (2) leaders and followers experienced the pandemic very differently; and (3) leaders became disseminators of public health information. Given the power structures, dependencies and findings identified in this paper, we propose a more cohesive aid distribution strategy for different actors to engage with RLOs, allowing them to maximize the reach of disbursed funds.
Chapter
This chapter focuses on the experience of volunteers and frontline workers who serve in marginalized communities across Southeast Asia. More frontline workers and volunteers are taking the initiative to support marginalized communities in the region. With the rise of human rights violations towards marginalized communities in the past decade, frontline workers and volunteers face unique experiences in working with these communities, ranging from stigma and discrimination to unaddressed levels of burnout. Based on the authors' experiences working with these communities and the summary of the interviews with fellow frontline workers, the experience of working with marginalized communities, particularly those affected by HIV/AIDS and refugees, are elaborated in this chapter. Current challenges as well as recommendations are highlighted to ensure that the frontline workers and volunteers are supported throughout their vital work towards society.
ResearchGate has not been able to resolve any references for this publication.