Uranium in the Earth's core

Article · January 1984with 60 Reads
Abstract
That there is no radioactivity in the earth's core is a concept that has long been held. The reason is that the major radioactive elements, potassium and uranium, exist as siderophobic compounds, such as silicates and oxides, in the earth's mantle and thus were thought to be immiscible with the metal core. An experimental measurement of the binary system of steel and UO2, however, shows that above 3120 K the system is a two-phase liquid, the one rich in UO2 and the other poor in UO2. The phase diagram predicts that there must be a temperature above which there is total miscibility between UO2 and steel. This temperature may be above the boiling point of UO2, estimated as 3750 K. The temperature at the core-mantle interface of the earth's interior is estimated most recently as 3130 K. Thus there is a strong likelihood that uranium exists in the earth's metal core. Hence the natural alpha radioactivity of uranium offers a power source for the earth's magnetic dynamo.
Ad

Do you want to read the rest of this article?

Request full-text
Request Full-text Paper PDF
  • Article
    Measurable uranium (U) is found in metal sulfide liquids in equilibrium with molten silicate at conditions appropriate for a planetary magma ocean: 1–10 GPa, 1750–2100 °C, 0–28 wt% S, and fO2 2 log units below IW. However, the transfer of U from metal sulfide to silicate under our experimental conditions is so complete that insufficient U would remain so as to be of any importance to the core’s heat budget. U content in the sulfide phase increases strongly with S content but shows no significant variability with either pressure or temperature. Maximum is 0.001 while most values are considerably lower.
  • Article
    Investigations of necessary conditions for a self-sustained chain reaction in the Earth inner regions hypothetically containing uranium is presented for the time interval from Earth formation to present time. It is determined that criticality was theoretically possible up to 2.5 Ga before present if uranium concentrated in pure form. In the early geological history (4 Ga before present) the self-sustained criticality could occur even if uranium was diluted up to 1:20 by the average core material or 1:60 by the average mantle material. If other metallic materials of similar density as uranium (e. g., Au, W) or similar atomic weight (e.g., Th) concentrated from the primordial mixture in equal proportion as uranium, criticality was not possible for any period in Earth history provided that the basic material contained no light nuclides (H, C). Criticality in the Earth inner regions could have established only if uranium concentrated from the basic material more effectively than elements of similar density or atomic number.
  • Article
    Many astrophysical bodies possess magnetic fields. The Earth has one, the geomagnetic field, and it is apparently as old as the Earth. Since the temperature throughout most of the Earth is above the Curie points of all known materials, the Earth is not a permanent magnet. The geomagnetic field must be produced by electric currents flowing mainly within its core, which is a good electrical conductor. Lacking sources, such currents would die out in about 10,000 years. It is now believed that the currents are maintained by electromagnetic induction, as in a commercial dynamo, the moving parts of the geodynamo being motions in the outer core, which is fluid. The first question in dynamo theory is whether self-excitation is possible in a body having such a low degree of symmetry as the Earth’s core. This well-studied “kinematic dynamo problem” defines a nontrivial non-self adjoint eigenvalue problem, which will be discussed after the basic electrodynamic theory has been summarized. The second question is whether motions of sufficient vigor, and which have the “helicity” required for field generation, would arise naturally in the Earth’s outer core. This nonlinear “magnetohydrodynamic dynamo problem” raises some interesting questions in rotating magnetoconvection. The third question is whether the required energy source is available to power the dynamo. For bodies such as the solar convection zone, energy is available in abundance, but the geodynamo’s needs are less easily met. Other topics will be touched on, including fast dynamos, auto-reversing dynamos, and chaotic dynamos.
  • Article
    In order to quantify possible fractionation of U and Pb into a metallic core, we have performed piston cylinder and multi-anvil press experiments at high pressure (up to 20 GPa) and high temperature (up to 2400 °C) and obtained the distribution coefficient Dmetal–silicate and the exchange partition coefficient Kmetal–silicate for these elements between metal and silicates (mineral or liquid). and depend strongly on the S content of the metallic phase, and also on the oxygen fugacity, in agreement with an effective valence state of 4 for U in silicates and 2 for Pb in silicates. and show no discernable pressure and temperature trend. U remains lithophile even at high pressure and high temperature but its lithophile nature decreases at very low oxygen fugacity. From our experimental data, it was possible to calculate the U and Pb contents of the cores of Mars and Earth under core-mantle equilibrium conditions at high pressure and high temperature. From the Dmetal–silicate of the present study, we obtained that: 0.008 ppm < Pbin the core <4.4 ppm, and 0.0003 ppb < Uin the core < 0.63 ppb, depending on whether the metal is S-free or S-saturated respectively, and if the mantle was molten or solid during the segregation process of the Earth’s core around ΔIW-2. For Mars, based on a core segregation process around ΔIW-1, we obtained that: 0.005 ppm < Pbin the core < 3 ppm, and 0.00002 ppb < Uin the core < 0.05 ppb, depending on the metallic composition: S-free or S-saturated respectively.
  • Article
    Experimental partitioning studies are reported of K, U, and Th between silicate and FeFeS liquids designed to test the proposal that actinide partitioning into sulfide liquids is more important then K partitioning in the radioactive heating of planetary cores. For a basaltic liquid at 1450 C and 1.5 GPa, U partitioning into FeFeS liquids is five times greater than K partitioning. A typical value for the liquid partition coefficient for U from a granitic silicate liquid at one atmosphere at 1150 C and low fO2 is about 0.02; the coefficient for Th is similar. At low fO2 and higher temperature, experiments with basaltic liquids produce strong Ca and U partitioning into the sulfide liquid with U coefficient greater than one. The Th coefficient is less strongly affected.
  • The Earth's Core, Academic
    • Jacobs
  • Constraints on the composition of the earth's core
    • Sommerville
  • Article
    A knowledge of the chemical constitution of a molten oxide fast reactor core is of great importance in the assessment of heat transfer from a cooling molten pool of debris and in the selection of materials for the construction of sacrificial beds for core containment. This paper describes some thermodynamic assessments of the likely chemical constitution of a molten oxide core, and shows that the chemical state of the molten core may well influence the way in which heat is removed.
  • Article
    Only a small percentage of the mantle's total content of radioactive elements can be in the lower mantle if this region convects steadily and separately from the upper mantle. Recent geochemical models of a depleted upper mantle and an undepleted lower mantle are thus inconsistent with a steady thermal model involving distinct upper and lower mantle convection cells. Steady two-layer mantle convection requires a depleted lower mantle and an undepleted upper mantle to match the observations of surface heat flow and mantle viscosity. The constraint on the abundance of radioactive elements in the lower mantle depends on the existence of at least one thermal boundary layer at the upper mantle-lower mantle interface with thickness comparable to that of the surface thermal boundary layer. Since the temperature drop across an interface boundary layer is limited by the relatively small differences between the solidus temperature and the upper mantle temperature, the amount of heat which can be transferred across this layer is small compared with the surface heat flow. The upper limit on the concentration of radioactive elements in the lower mantle can be relaxed only if both the lower boundary layer of the upper mantle cell and the upper boundary layer of the lower mantle cell are extremely thin or absent altogether, which we consider, however, highly unlikely.
  • Article
    A series of dynamic compression experiments on potassium thioferrite is presented and results are discussed in relation to the possible partition of potassium into the earth's core. The Hugoniot equation of state of KFeS2 was determined for polycrystalline samples at shock pressures up to 110 GPa. A transition to a higher density form is observed at a pressure of 13 GPa, and comparison with the compression curves of Fe, FeS, FeS2 and K reveals the atomic volume of potassium in KFeS2 to be approximately twice that of iron at 75 GPa. Thermochemical calculations of potassium partitioning indicate that pressure does not have a pronounced effect on the relative stability of solid KFeS2 or potassium aluminosilicate high-pressure phases, and that the high-pressure KFeS2 phase would not be stable in relation to kalsilite in the upper mantle or hollandite in the lower mantle. The results are interpreted as not supporting the hypothesis that a large fraction of the terrestrial potassium budget has dissolved into a molten iron sulfide-bearing core.
  • Shock wave data for Fe, C, iron sulfides, Fe2O3, Fe3O4 and FeO can be used to place constraints on the maximum abundances of the light elements Si, C, S, and O in the earth's core, yielding mass percentage ranges of from 14-20% for Si to 7-8% O. Recent high pressure equilibrium data indicate a marked decrease in Fe-O-S system oxygen solubility with pressure, making the solution of oxygen in the core appear unlikely. The hypothesis that S, at 8-12% by mass, is the light constituent of the earth's core is consistent with shock wave data for iron sulfides and implies that the earth accreted its entire cosmic component of S. Because of the low eutectic melting point in the Fe-FeS system at about 100 GPa and 2100 K, compared with 400 K for Fe at this pressure, the inclusion of S in the core provides a mechanism for producing a molten core early in the earth's history and retaining its volatile complement. The depletion of such major volatiles as K and Na remains unexplained.
  • Article
    This volume, together with its companion, Selected Values of Thermodynamic Properties of the Elements, represents a complete revision of the work, Selected Values of Thermodynamic Properties of Metals and Alloys, by Hultgren, Orr, Anderson, and Kelley, published in 1963 by John Wiley and Sons, New York. The work should cover pertinent data available at the date printed on the first page of each system. Inspection will show that many or most of the selected values differ from the 1963 edition; many of the differences are substantial. This shows progress in measurement and, at the same time, hints of uncertainties still present.