ArticlePDF Available

Säure-Basen-Haushalt: Latente Azidose als Ursache chronischer Erkrankungen

Authors:
  • Institute for Prevention and Nutrition, Ismaning/Munich, Germany
  • European Medicines Agency (EMA)

Abstract and Figures

Hintergrund: Die Regulation des pH-Wertes innerhalb und auβerhalb der Zellen ist eine wesentliche Vorraussetzung für die Funktionsfähigkeit der enzymatisch gesteuerten Stoffwechselvorgänge unseres Organismus. Das Verhältnis von Säuren zu Basen ist nicht nur für einen gesunden Stoffwechsel von Bedeutung, sondern entscheidet auch über die Struktur und Funktion von Proteinen, die Permeabilität von Zellmembranen, die Verteilung von Elektrolyten sowie die Funktion des Bindegewebes. Langfristige Störungen des natürlichen Säure-Basen-Gleichgewichtes finden aufgrund des gegenwärtigen wissenschaftlichen Erkenntnisstandes als Risikofaktor für chronische Erkrankungen zunehmend Beachtung. Fragestellung: Lassen sich die pathobiochemischen Auswirkungen einer geringgradigen chronischen metabolischen (latenten) Azidose und die positiven gesundheitlichen Aspekte eines ausgeglichenen Säure-Basen-Haushalts kausal belegen? Methoden: Systematische Auswertung der wissenschaftlichen Literatur in der MEDLINE Datenbank ab dem Jahr 1990 über die latente Azidose und deren Einfluss auf die Gesundheit. Ergebnisse: Eine latente Azidose als Folge einer schleichenden Verminderung der Pufferreserven, überwiegend bedingt durch Ernährungseinflüsse, ruft aufgrund der Kompensation durch die Säureausscheidung über die Nieren keine wesentlichen Veränderungen des Blut-pH hervor. Allerdings führt diese Kompensation auf lange Sicht unausweichlich zu einem Verlust von Knochensubstanz und beeinträchtigt die Struktur und Funktion des Bindegewebes. Schlussfolgerung: In der Vergangenheit wurde die pH-Regulation bei Personen, die nicht ernsthaft erkrankt sind, als Selbstverständlichkeit aufgefasst und die hierzu erforderliche Pufferkapazität des Organismus als beinahe unerschöpflich erachtet. Heute wird zunehmend erkannt, dass die latente Azidose als Folge einer allmählichen Abnahme der Pufferreserven für die Entstehung und den Verlauf chronischer Erkrankungen wie z.B. Osteoporose und Rheuma von Bedeutung ist.
Content may be subject to copyright.
Acid-Base Homeostasis:
Latent Acidosis as a Cause of Chronic Diseases
Jürgen Vormann, Thomas Goedecke
Institut für Prävention und Ernährung, DE-Ismaning
I
n the healthy human being, the blood
has a pH value of 7.4. Even slight
deviations from this value may lead to
s e v e r e disturbances in metabolism
which may even be life-threatening. It
is for this reason that the body`s exten-
sive buffer systems ensure that the
blood pH is maintained between the
very narrow limits of 7.37 and 7.43.
These buffer systems bind and neu-
tralize the additional protons (H
+
ions)
or hydroxide ions (OH
ions) respec-
tively associated with excessive acidity
or alkalinity and thereby prevent them
f rom immediate and marked influ-
ences on metabolism. In order to
maintain the optimal metabolic func-
tioning and there f o re the buff e r i n g
capacity on a long-term basis, the
organism is also dependent on the con-
stant regeneration of the buffer sys-
tems.
Physiological regulation of
acid-base homeostasis
What has been said above presuppos-
es precise regulation of the acid-base
homeostasis which involves many fac-
tors (Fig. 1). Apart from the buffering
characteristics of the blood and the
extracellular and intracellular com-
partments, the gas exchange in the
lungs and the excretion mechanisms of
the kidneys are essential components
of this regulatory system all of which
a re in functional equilibrium with
each other. The bicarbonate system is
of primary importance for maintaining
a constant blood pH, but plasma pro-
teins as well as the hemoglobin and
the phosphate buffer also play a role
Background: A prerequisite for the proper functioning of the enzyme-controlled metabolic
processes of the human organism is the regulation of pH both inside and outside of the cells. The
ratio of acids to bases is not only important for a healthy metabolism, it also determines the struc-
ture and function of proteins, the permeability of cell membranes, the distribution of electrolytes,
and
the function of connective tissue. Currently, long-term disturbances of the natural acid-base
homeostasis are receiving increasing attention as a risk factor for chronic diseases. Objective: To
determine whether there is causal evidence for the pathobiochemical effects of a low-grade
chronic metabolic (latent) acidosis and for the beneficial disease-modifying aspects of a well-bal-
anced acid-base homeostasis. Methods: The MEDLINE data base is systematically reviewed for
scientific literature since 1990 on latent acidosis and its impact on human health. Results:
A latent acidosis resulting from a gradual reduction of the buffer re s e rves, mainly due to nutritional
influences, does not produce major changes of blood pH because of compensatory mechanisms
through urinary acid excretion. However, there is causal evidence that this compensation, in the
long term, inevitably leads to loss of bone substance and impairs the structure and function of
the connective tissue. Conclusion: In the past, pH regulation was taken for granted in persons
not being severely ill and the required buffering capacity of the organism was accepted as being
virtually inexhaustible. But today latent acidosis resulting from a gradual reduction of the buffer
reserves is increasingly the focus of interest for the development and progression of chronic dis-
eases such as osteoporosis and rheumatoid disorders.
Key Wo rd s : Acid-base homeostasis, latent acidosis, osteoporosis, rheumatoid disorders, nutrition,
e v o l u t i o n
Säure-Basen-Haushalt:
Latente Azidose als Ursache chronischer Erkrankungen
Hintergrund: Die Regulation des pH-Wertes innerhalb und außerhalb der Zellen ist eine wesent-
liche Vorraussetzung für die Funktionsfähigkeit der enzymatisch gesteuerten Stoffwechselvor-
gänge unseres Organismus. Das Verhältnis von Säuren zu Basen ist nicht nur für einen gesunden
Stoffwechsel von Bedeutung, sondern entscheidet auch über die Struktur und Funktion von Pro-
teinen, die Permeabilität von Zellmembranen, die Verteilung von Elektrolyten sowie die Funktion
des Bindegewebes. Langfristige Störungen des natürlichen Säure-Basen-Gleichgewichtes finden
aufgrund des gegenwärtigen wissenschaftlichen Erkenntnisstandes als Risikofaktor für chroni-
sche Erkrankungen zunehmend Beachtung. Fragestellung: Lassen sich die pathobiochemischen
Auswirkungen einer geringgradigen chronischen metabolischen (latenten) Azidose und die positi-
ven gesundheitlichen Aspekte eines ausgeglichenen Säure-Basen-Haushalts kausal belegen?
Methoden: Systematische Auswertung der wissenschaftlichen Literatur in der MEDLINE Daten-
bank ab dem Jahr 1990 über die latente Azidose und deren Einfluss auf die Gesundheit. Er
geb-
nisse: Eine latente Azidose als Folge einer schleichenden Verminderung der Pufferreserven, über-
wiegend bedingt durch Ernährungseinflüsse, ruft aufgrund der Kompensation durch die Säu-
reausscheidung über die Nieren keine wesentlichen Veränderungen des Blut-pH hervor. Aller-
dings führt diese Kompensation auf lange Sicht unausweichlich zu einem Verlust von Knochen-
substanz und beeinträchtigt die Struktur und Funktion des Bindegewebes. Schlussfolgerung: In
der Vergangenheit wurde die pH-Regulation bei Personen, die nicht ernsthaft erkrankt sind, als
Selbstverständlichkeit aufgefasst und die hierzu erforderliche Pufferkapazität des Organismus als
beinahe unerschöpflich erachtet. Heute wird zunehmend erkannt, dass die latente Azidose als
Folge einer allmählichen Abnahme der Pufferreserven für die Entstehung und den Verlauf chroni-
scher Erkrankungen wie z.B. Osteoporose und Rheuma von Bedeutung ist.
S c h l ü s s e l w ö rt e r : S ä u re-Basen-Haushalt, latente Azidose, Osteoporose, rheumatische Erkrankun-
gen, Ern ä h run g, Evolution
Schweiz. Zschr.
G
anzheits
M
edizin Jg.18, Heft 5, September 2006
255
Schweiz. Zschr.
GanzheitsMedizin 18, 255–266 (2006). © Verlag für GanzheitsMedizin, Basel. www.ganzheitsmedizin.ch
Übersichtsarbeiten Review Articles
as H
+
or OH
scavengers. The highly
rapid responsiveness of the buffer sys-
tems produces an extremely fast and
constant regulation of the blood pH.
Apart from water, transient carbon
dioxide the intermediate pro d u c t
from the protonation of bicarbonate
(HCO
3
) is produced by the dissocia-
tion of carbonic acid; it is expired via
the lungs and, as a result, H
+
ions are
effectively eliminated. However, since
HCO
3
is also removed at the same
time, net acid excretion does not take
place. Even though acute acidosis can
usually be avoided by carbon dioxide
expiration, the buffer systems of the
kidneys are primarily responsible for
the net excretion of the H
+
i o n s
released from the breakdown of various
acids.
This excretion is necessary because
the production of protons (e.g. via
metabolizing sulphur-containing amino
acids from protein) from a normal
mixed diet exceeds the absorption of
alkaline substances. In the modern
diet, mainly the proportionately high
consumption of protein compared with
that of base-supplying fruit and veg-
etables contributes to the daily acidifi-
cation of the body. A particular exam-
ple of acidification is that from imbib-
ing phosphoric acid-containing bever-
ages. Fasting (i.e. reducing body weight
by not eating) increases the acidifica-
tion of the body via the increased for-
mation of keto acids from the break-
down of fatty acids, and so does the
i n c reas ed production of lactic acid
under anaerobic conditions as the end
p rod uct of glycolysis during sport s
activities.
With regard to the buffering of H
+
ions, of major importance are those
alkaline vegetable substances in the
form of metabolizable organic anions
that can neutralize the acid produced
from protein metabolism. During the
dissociation of these salts, org a n i c
anions are released which can then
depending on the dissociation constant
of the acid group – accept H
+
ions. The
organic acids produced are neutrally
metabolized to water and carbon diox-
ide (CO
2
) and ensure in this way that
p rotons are eliminated from the
organism. As is shown for the example
of sodium citrate (Fig. 2), the remain-
ing cations (e.g. Na
+
) are available for
reabsorption from the primary urine
in the kidney in exchange for H
+
ions.
By this means, the charge neutrality is
maintained and acid is eliminated
from the body. It can thus be seen that
the level of intake of organic anions
represents a major factor in regulating
acid-base homeostasis.
Definition of latent acidosis
and its manifestations
Compared with the clinically rather
r a r e manifestation of re s p i r a t o ry or
m e t a bolic acidosis, which is character-
ized by a decrease in the blood pH,
latent acidosis is much more commonly
observed. In most cases, there is a
slight shift of the blood pH in the acid
direction within the normal range and
the total buffering capacity of the
blood is reduced. The term “latent”
refers to a chronic condition which is
without acute symptoms and is clini-
cally detectable only by determining
the intracellular and extracellular
buffer capacity and the renal net acid
excretion.
It is mentioned here that latent aci-
dosis affects a wide cross-section of
the population. The cause of increased
acidification is, above all, the high pro-
tein content in food which, when cou-
pled with the declining renal function
associated with increasing age, leads
to latent acidosis
[1]. With increasing
256
Schweiz. Zschr.
G
anzheits
M
edizin Jg.18, Heft 5, September 2006
Übersichtsarbeiten
Review Articles
Fig. 1. Regulation of the acid-base homeostasis.
Fig. 2. Function of organically bound minerals in the elimination of acids as shown for
the example of sodium citrate.
age, the ability of the kidneys to excre t e
acids progressively decreases [2, 3]. As
is shown in Fig. 3, the blood pH
declines within the normal range over
the years, but at the same time the
concentration of plasma bicarbonate
buffer bases also decreases.
This in turn not only results in an
i n c reas ed consumption of buff e r i n g
minerals from the bone reservoir, but
also in detrimental effects on various
metabolic functions such as the
increased muscle breakdown which is
frequently observed in senior citizens
[3]. The age-related renal functional
decline together with a constantly high
protein intake exacerbates latent aci-
dosis and its harmful influences on
health.
Compensation mechanisms
of latent acidosis
Nowadays, the pathobiochemical eff e c t s
of latent acidosis on osteoporosis, dia-
betes mellitus, hyperuricemia, gout, or
on restricted renal function are
undisputed. These links were ultimate-
ly recognized because of the very eff i-
c i e n t homeostatic counter-regulation
of the organism in maintaining the
bicarbonate and proton concentrations
and there f o r e the pH value of the blood.
The regulation mechanisms have
been partially explained in re c e n t
years [4]. The adaptation mechanisms
of the kidney play an essential role in
compensating diet-induced latent aci-
dosis. They are schematically depict-
ed in Fig. 4. There are four ba
sic mech-
a n i s m s that compensate for latent aci-
dosis.
Increased excretion of
ammonium ions (NH
4
+
)
Ammonia (NH
3
) – which is produced in
the renal tubular cells and freely dif-
fuses through membranes combines
with H
+
ions in the primary urine to
form ammonium (NH
4
+
) ions which
can hardly diffuse back and which are
therefore excreted with the urine (pro-
ton trapping). Consequently most of
the renal acid is excreted bound to
NH
3
. This latter product is formed in
the tubular cells from the breakdown
of the nitrogenous amino acid gluta-
mine. With acidosis, the activity of the
glutamine-degrading enzymes (gluta-
minase, glutamine-dehydrogenase etc.)
is increased. Accordingly, there is an
increased consumption of glutamine
and subsequently of other nitrogen-
supplying amino acids. Thus, mild
latent acidosis also leads to increased
activity of the protein-degrading sys-
tems via the production of ubiquitin
and C2/C3 proteasoms in the muscular
system with a corresponding loss of
myoprotein. By increasing the intake
of bases, the loss of nitrogen caused by
mild latent acidosis could be prevented
in postmenopausal women [5].
Increased secretion of protons
(H
+
) in the renal tubules
Even with mild acidosis, the quantity
and activity of the Na
+
/ H
+
ion exchanger
in the kidney is increased, resulting in
increased excretion of H
+
ions with
simultaneous Na
+
reabsorption.
Reduction of
urinary citrate excretion
With acidosis the relative reabsorption
of critrate
3–
(the trivalent negatively
charged anion of citric acid) from the
primary urine is increased. Compensa-
tion occurs by the following mecha-
nism: the absorption of citrate
3–
in the
tubular cells occurs mainly in the pro-
tonated form, i.e. H-citrate
2 –
. The
activity of the citrate transporter is
therefore increased with reduced pH.
Intracellularly, citrate
3–
is converted
by the acceptance of additional pro-
tons to
uncharged citric acid, which is
then pH-neutrally broken down into
carbon dioxide and water. By the
absorption of one molecule of citrate
3–
from the primary urine, 3 H
+
ions can
therefore be eliminated. As a result,
the concentration of citrate in the pri-
m a ry urine decreases (see Fig. 4) .
However, citrate is essential for com-
plexing calcium ions (Ca
2+
). The lack
of formation of soluble calcium-cit-
rate-complexes increases the urinary
concentration of free Ca
2+
ions and
therefore the availability of calcium to
257
Schweiz. Zschr.
G
anzheits
M
edizin Jg.18, Heft 5, September 2006
Übersichtsarbeiten
Review Articles
Fig. 3. Relationship between blood pH and
plasma bicarbonate concentration and age
(modified from [2, 3]).
Fig. 4. Compensation mechanisms for latent acidosis (modified from [4]).
Urine Kidney Blood Bone
1. NH
4
+
formation
2. H
+
secretion
3. citrate re a b s o r p t i o n
4. Ca
2+
reabsorption
1. [NH
4
+
]
2. [H
2
PO
4
-
]
3. [Ca
2+
]
4. [H
+
]
5. [citrate
3-
]
1. Ca
2+
/PO
4
3-
release
2. osteoblast activity
3. osteoclast activity
blood pH
[HCO
3
-
]
Protein
break down
Muscle
7.3
6
7.3
7
7.3
8
7.3
9
7.4
0
7.4
1
26
24
22
20
f o r m renal calculi, e.g. with oxalic acid.
Increased release of minerals
from the bones
On the one hand, mild acidosis leads to
the removal of minerals from the bone
matrix; on the other hand, acidosis
results in an increase in the activity of
the bone-decomposing osteoclasts and
inhibition of the activity of the bone-
forming osteoblasts (see Fig. 10). All in
all, increased renal excretion of Ca
2+
ions takes place with the consequence
of the increased risk of formation of
renal calculi, as described above.
Effects of latent acidosis
on calcium and bone
metabolism
Epidemiology and
dietary implications
With experimental acidosis, first a
reduction of the blood buffering capac-
ity occurs, then, with further increase
of acid load a reduction of the intracel-
lular buffering capacity and a strain on
the buffering capacity of bone occurs.
And finally, with increasing acid load
buffering is achieved by the release of
minerals from bone [6]. This and com-
parable investigations led already in
the Sixties to the hypothesis, that one
of the significant causes of osteoporo-
sis is a high dietary acid load [7].
Numerous epidemiological studies
are available on the obvious relation-
ship between the type of diet and the
development of osteoporosis. The
influence of a vegetarian diet on bone
mineral density is based on the signif-
icant effect of dietary content of acid
and base: a higher base content is cor-
related with a higher bone mineral
density [8]. A comparative study on
omnivorous and vegetarian women [9]
showed that a high proportion of base
generating foodstuffs leads to a clearly
improved calcium balance in vegetari-
ans. In spite of equal calcium intake in
both groups, the women who consumed
a mixed diet showed not only a signifi-
cantly higher excretion of acid but also
a significantly higher excretion of cal-
cium. For premenopausal women a
correlation was shown between the
intake of alkaline foods and bone min-
eral density [10]. Although the intake
of alkaline food components (especial-
ly potassium and magnesium) and the
high consumption of fruit and vegeta
-
bles were correlated with an increased
bone mineral density in a study on
elderly subjects, this was not the case
for the calcium content of the con-
sumed food [11]. No associations with
other food components, e.g. the cal-
cium intake or the total caloric intake,
were found in this study.
Recent epidemiological studies on
the nutritional effects on bone loss
during menopausal transition demon-
strated that with decreasing endoge-
nous acid production femoral bone
mineral density of pre- and perimeno-
pausal women significantly increased
[12], see Fig. 5.
Another epidemiological study
showed the beneficial effect of cal-
cium, alcohol, and fruit and vegetable
intake and the detrimental effect of
fatty acids. The authors conclude that
although menopausal status and hor-
mone replacement therapy dominate
women's bone health, diet may influ-
ence early postmenopausal bone loss
with fruit and vegetable intake pro-
tecting against premenopausal bone
loss [13]. These findings are confirmed
by the results of a study which investi-
gated the relationship between dietary
potassium and protein intake, net
endogenous acid production and
potential renal acid load and markers
of bone health. Low dietary potassium
intakes and high dietary estimates of
net endogenous acid production were
found to be associated with low bone
mineral density at the femoral neck
and lumbar spine in premenopausal
women (Fig. 6) and increased markers
of bone resorption in post-menopausal
women [14].
On the whole, the epidemiological
data indicate a correlation of the
intake of alkaline acting-substances
from fruits and vegetables and the cor-
responding dietary acid load over the
years and their effects on calcium and
bone metabolism from the viewpoint of
osteoporosis.
258
Schweiz. Zschr.
G
anzheits
M
edizin Jg.18, Heft 5, September 2006
Übersichtsarbeiten
Review Articles
Fig. 5. Mean SEM) bone mineral density of pre- and perimenopausal women by
quartile of net endogenous non-carbonic acid production (NEAP). *Significantly different
from quartile 4, p<0.04. Modified from [12].
Confirmation
by intervention studies
I n t e rvent ion studies largely confirm
the physiological effects of latent aci-
dosis. In animal experiments it was
shown that due solely to a high-protein
diet, the bone formation in young rats
was impaired [15]. Another study (see
Fig. 7) shows that an excess acid load
was artificially caused by an increase
of the protein intake [16]. As expected,
increased renal net acid excretion (as
the sum of ammonium and titratable
acids) and calcium excretion were first
o b s e rved. However, because of the
concomitant intake of sodium bicar-
bonate as a base supplier, a negative
calcium balance could be prevented
and the protein-induced over-acidifi-
cation of the organism was neutral-
ized. The positive effects of a high
intake of base-forming substances
could also be proved in intervention
studies with postmenopausal women:
i n c reased alkaline intake bro u g h t
about both a reduction in the break-
down of bone and an increase in bone
formation [17]. Thanks to a reduction
of the protein intake, the calcium
excretion and therefore the risk of
renal calculi could be reduced in
h y p e rcalciuric patients [18]. In a
p l a c e b o - c o n t r olled study comparing
treatment with alkaline minerals to a
placebo group for almost all syn-
dromes involving the gastrointestinal
tract, musculoskeletal system, cardio-
vascular system, skin, and a tendency
to become easily exhausted, a consid-
erable improvement of the symptoms
was shown [19]. Moreover, laboratory
parameters (e.g. acid excretion, serum
c h o l e s t e r ol) were significantly impro v e d
by means of the
alkaline therapy.
Treatment with alkaline salts such
as potassium citrate is even able to
reduce bone resorption. This effect of
potassium citrate supplementation on
bone metabolism was investigated in
46 postmenopausal women with low
bone density. One group received a
3-month course of potassium citrate
supplementation (0.08 0.1 g/kg body
weight daily), another group served as
control. Evaluation of electrolyte and
acid-base homeostasis-related para-
meters, and markers of bone turnover
and of renal function showed a signifi-
cant decrease in net acid excretion
only upon citrate supplementation.
Moreover, urinary excretion of bone
resorption markers decreased thus
indicating that citrate ingestion posi-
tively affects bone health [20]. The
equimolar replacement of dietary sodi-
um chloride and potassium chloride
with alkaline sodium and potassium
bicarbonate under metabolic homeosta-
sis conditions, thus neutralising dietary
acid load, not only resulted in signifi-
cant calcium retention and reduced
renal excretion of bone markers but
also decreased mean daily plasma cor-
tisol and urinary excretion of tetra-
h y d ro c o r tisol [21]. Other endocrine
factors relevant to bone such as para-
thyroid hormone or vitamin D were
not affected. There f o re, mild metabolic
acidosis may be associated with a state
of cortisol excess. These acidosis-
induced increases in cortisol secretion
and plasma concentration may play a
role in mild acidosis-induced alter-
ations in bone metabolism as well.
Dieting and Fasting
Dieting and fasting are critical to
changes of acid-base homeostasis. For
example,
solely because of the intake
of sodium bicarbonate, the calcium
release from bone in young women
who had developed ketoacidosis as a
result of fasting could be prevented
[22]. Generally speaking, modern diets
contribute to an increase in metabolic
acidosis and to greater bone loss as
demonstrated for low-carbohydrate,
h i g h - p r otein diets (Atkins). Consumption
of such a diet for six weeks may in fact
help an individual to lose weight, but it
considerably increases acid load and
results in latent acidosis with
increased risk of kidney stone forma-
tion, negative calcium balance, and
increased risk of bone loss, as demon-
strated in Fig. 8 [23]. Table 1 illus-
trates the dietary scheme applied for
three different phases.
Is animal or vegetable protein
detrimental to bone health?
Judging from the most recent studies,
259
Schweiz. Zschr.
G
anzheits
M
edizin Jg.18, Heft 5, September 2006
Übersichtsarbeiten
Review Articles
Fig. 6. Mean (± SEM) bone mineral density at the femoral neck and lumbar spine with
increasing quartiles of energy-adjusted potassium intake for premenopausal women
(n=336). *Significantly different from quartile 1, p<0.01. Modified from [14].
food protein from different sources
seems to have different effects on bone
metabolism. Elderly women who have
a high proportion of animal protein in
their diet showed a more rapid loss of
bone density and a higher risk of hip
fractures than women with a low pro-
portion [24]. In the latter group (low
proportion of animal protein), it was
found that fewer women sustained a
hip fracture during the observation
period of 7 years. Animal foods contain
p r edominantly acid-forming substances
whereas protein in vegetable foods is
accompanied by base-forming sub-
stances.
The protective function that an
increased consumption of vegetables
as opposed to animal protein may have
has also been confirmed in interna-
tional studies. The incidence of hip
fractures differs in the populations of
different countries, and it is directly
correlated with the level of consump-
tion of animal protein of the different
cultures. Analysis of the data on the
incidence of hip factures in 33 coun-
tries in relation to the respective coun-
try-specific characteristics of the per
capita consumption of animal and veg-
etable foods (Fig. 9) showed that the
incidence of hip fractures is the lowest
in countries with a low intake of ani-
mal protein [25].
H o w e v e r, latest studies with childre n
indicate that protein consumption is
not generally detrimental to bone
health because in children long-term
dietary protein intake appears to act
anabolically on diaphyseal bone
260
Schweiz. Zschr.
G
anzheits
M
edizin Jg.18, Heft 5, September 2006
Übersichtsarbeiten
Review Articles
Tab. 1. Composition of normal diet, severely carbohydrate-restricted induction diet and
moderately carbohydrate-restricted maintenance diet. Modified from [23].
(g/day) Duration Carbo- Protein Fat Body weight
(weeks) hydrates (kg, n=10)
Normal 2 285 81 90 81.3
Induction 2 19 164 133 78.4
Maintenance 4 33 170 136 77.2
Fig. 7. Renal acid and calcium excretion with different protein intakes [g/day] with and
without sodium bicarbonate substitution [70 mEq/day] (modified from [16]).
Fig. 8. Effect of low-carbohydrate, high-protein diet (Atkins diet) on renal net acid excretion, renal calcium excretion and serum osteocal-
cin. Patients had been on a normal non-weight-reducing diet, then a severely carbohydrate-restricted induction diet for 2 weeks, after which
they followed a moderately carbohydrate-restricted maintenance diet for 4 weeks as depicted above (n=10). Modified from [23].
strength during growth. This may at
least partly be negated if the dietary
potential renal acid load is high, i.e. if
the intake of base-forming minerals,
as provided by a high consumption of
fruit and vegetables, is low. Children
with higher dietary potential re n a l
acid load (PRAL), however, had signifi-
cantly lower bone mineral content and
l o n g - t e r m calcium intake was not
associated with any bone variable.
Protein and alkalinising minerals are
thus increasingly described as playing
a major role in influencing bone status
in children and adolescents [26].
Mechanisms of the effects of acid
on bone cell function
The homeostasis for the maintenance
of a stable physiological pH environ-
ment often functions only at the
expense of the bone mineral content
because latent acidosis causes the
release of calcium from bone, thereby
b u f fering the additional pro t o n s .
Metabolic acidosis first stimulates the
physicochemical release of minerals
(decrease of the sodium, potassium,
carbonate, and phosphate content of
bones) and subsequently the cell-
mediated absorption of bone, as is
schematically depicted in F i g . 1 0 .
Acidosis results in an increase in the
activity of bone-decomposing or re s p e c-
tively bone-resorbing cells (osteoclasts)
and inhibition of the bone-form i n g
cells (osteoblasts).
Genes that regulate the
early “imme-
diate reaction” of the osteoblasts are
inhibited as are genes that control the
formation of bone matrix; gene inhibi-
tion leads to an overall reduction of
bone remodelling and form a t i o n .
Several in vitro studies with artificially
cultured bone cells confirmed their
characteristics as potent acid buffers
[27].
Figure 11 shows the dependence of
the net calcium flux of cultured bone
cells on the pH value of the surround-
ing medium. With a physiologically
acidic pH value below 7.4, calcium
flows out of the bone cells into the
medium, whereas a net absorption of
calcium was only detectable with a pH
value above 7.4.
G r owth and maturation of the osteo-
clasts is dependent on the interplay of
261
Schweiz. Zschr.
G
anzheits
M
edizin Jg.18, Heft 5, September 2006
Übersichtsarbeiten
Review Articles
Fig. 9. Worldwide incidence of hip factures (modified from [25]).
Fig. 10. Schematic diagram of the effects of latent acidosis on bone (modified from [27]).
a number of factors. One of the expla-
nations of the mechanisms of latent
acidosis on bone cell function is the
induction of osteoblastic prostaglandin
synthesis, which is activated by meta-
bolic acidosis and is followed by the
induction of a receptor activated
NFκB ligand” (RANKL). This increase
in RANKL is expected to augment osteo-
clastic bone resorption by interaction
with the osteoclastic cell-surf a c e
receptor RANK as shown in Fig. 12.
The RANKL/RANK interaction not only
initiates a differentiation cascade of
pre-osteoclasts to osteoclasts, that cul-
minates in mature bone-re s o r b i n g
osteoclasts, but also increases the
resorptive capacity and survival of
osteoclasts [28]. This acidosis-induced
increase in RANKL is expected to aug-
ment osteoclastic bone resorption and
offers an appropriate explanation for
the increase in cell-mediated net cal-
cium efflux as described above.
Finally, thanks to the mechanisms
of compensation dietary-induced latent
acidosis does not provoke any signifi-
cant changes of blood pH but the com-
pensation inevitably consumes the
b o d y ’s re s e r voir of buffering sub-
stances. When excess intake of animal
protein and deficient dietary base sup-
ply persists for a longer time this will
have a negative impact on bone mass.
The undoubted positive influence of a
diet rich
in fruit and vegetables can be
explained not only by a high intake of
micronutrients and secondary herbal
ingredients but also by the positive
effects of an adequate base supply.
Effects of latent acidosis on
connective tissue function
Connective tissue is an important tran-
sit pathway for metabolic pro d u c t s
such as oxygen, carbon dioxide, nutri-
ents, electrolytes, water, acids and
bases. Even slight changes of the blood
pH lead to a change in the physico-
chemical characteristics of the proteo-
glycans, the branched protein-saccha-
ride constituents of connective tissue.
These proteoglycans directly exchange
with the extracellular fluid.
Proteoglycans are composed of a
p r otein component and a glucosamino-
glycan component, which contains a
multitude of negatively charged func-
tional groups (e.g. sulphate residues
R ~ O - S O
3
). This negative charge enables
the binding of water molecules which
contribute to the elasticity and flexibil-
ity of the connective tissue. In latent
acidosis the negative charge of the sul-
phate residues is diminished and the
water binding capacity is decreasing
t h e reby reducing the elasticity and
flexibility of the connective tissue.
In cartilage as well, proteoglycans
with the hyaluronic acid molecules
that are bound to them represent a
h i g h - m o l e c u l a r-weight polyanionic
complex that forms the import a n t
compressible component of cartilage
because of the high water- b i n d i n g
capacity [29]. The water-binding capac-
ity of the extracellular matrix proteins
is very much determined by the degree
of dissociation of the functional acid
residues whose dissociation is again
highly pH-dependent. Acidosis of the
synovial fluid therefore decreases car-
tilage elasticity due to reduced water
binding. Effects
of latent acidosis on
the function of cartilage can be
explained in this way. At present, how-
e v e r, the complex stru c t u re of the
extracellular matrix does not allow
direct measurement of the function of
c a r tilaginous tissue with diff e r e n t
d e g ree s of dissociation. In patients
with rheumatoid arthritis the pH of the
knee joint’s synovial fluid is signifi-
cantly more acidic compared to the
normal range (pH 7.4 – 7.8), as shown
in Fig. 13 [30]. Consequently, acidosis
encourages joint cartilage abrasion by
mechanical stress that promotes the
vicious circle of deformation and
262
Schweiz. Zschr.
G
anzheits
M
edizin Jg.18, Heft 5, September 2006
Übersichtsarbeiten
Review Articles
Fig. 11. Effect of medium pH on the net cal-
cium flux in cultured bone cells. A positive
value shows a net calcium flow out of the
bone cells into the surrounding medium, nega-
tive values indicate net calcium influx (modi-
fied from [27]).
Fig. 12. Scheme of acidosis induced activation of RANKL/RANK interaction initiating the
differentiation cascade of pre-osteoclasts and increasing bone resorptive capacity and
survival of osteoclasts (modified from [28]).
Net calcium flux
(nmol/bone/3h)
Initial medium pH
inflammation. Acidosis might also
impair the filtration effect of the con-
nective tissue which may, in turn ,
additionally contribute to a deteriora-
tion in the nutrient supply of this poor-
ly perfused tissue. Finally the whole
locomotor system is involved because
of acidosis-induced impairment of the
ligaments and tendons.
Patients with chronic low back pain
without radicular involvement benefit-
ed from a 4-week supplementary diet
therapy by taking alkaline minerals:
both the pain as well as the physical
mobility improved significantly (see
Fig. 14), and the consumption of non-
s t e roidal, anti-inflammatory dru g s
(NSAID), which may cause severe side
effects when applied chronically, could
be clearly reduced [31]. Indeed, long
term balancing of acids and bases is
required for a complete regeneration
of the connective tissue and to notice-
ably relieve the chronic pain.
In a recent study, patients with
rheumatoid arthritis of at least two
years’ duration were shown to have
benefited from alkaline mineral sup-
plementation (see Fig. 15). At the end
of a 12-weeks study there was a signif-
icant decrease in disease activity score
(DAS-28) and in pain level measured
on a visual analogue scale (VAS) only
in the group supplemented with 30 g/
day of an alkaline food supplement
(Basica Vital
®
) compared to the control
group. Moreover, the steroid or NSAID
medication could be reduced with
alkaline supplementation whereas no
reduction of medication was consid-
ered to be possible for the control
group [32].
Another important impact on acid-
base homeostasis with long-term eff e c t s
on the functions of the connective tis-
sue occurs with chronic intake of pro-
ton pump inhibitors for the treatment
of gastroesophagea
l reflux. After meals
the parietal cells produce hydrochloric
acid to enable the digestion of foods.
At the same time bicarbonate is gener-
ated and transferred into the blood
stream from where it afterwards is
transported via the bile ducts into the
intestine to neutralize or alkalize the
gastric mash. This closed system does
not exert any net effect on acid-base
homeostasis, but acts as a kind of tem-
poral effect reflected by the “alkaline
floods” after each meal. These alkaline
floods provide an important physiolog-
ical process for removing the acids
bound to sulphated residues of con-
nective tissue proteoglycanes. Chronic
intake of proton pump inhibitors such
as omeprazol interfere with this sys-
tem and may suppress the essential
“purification process”.
263
Schweiz. Zschr.
G
anzheits
M
edizin Jg.18, Heft 5, September 2006
Übersichtsarbeiten
Review Articles
Fig. 13. Mean H
+
concentration in the synovial fluid from the knee joints of patients with
different forms of arthritis (modified from [30]).
Fig. 14. Effects of alkaline mineral supplementation on patients with chronic low back
pain. Arhus low back pain rating scale before and after supplementation with Basica
®
(n=82). Modified from [31].
Arhus low back pain rating scale (ARS)
before and after supplementation with Basica
®
Evolutionary aspects of
acid-base homeostasis
There is a growing awareness that the
profound changes in the environment
including diet and other life-style con-
ditions that began with the introduc-
tion of agriculture and animal hus-
b a n d r y approximately 10,000 years
ago, occurred too recently on an evo-
lutionary time scale for the human
genome to adjust. In conjunction with
this discordance between our ancient,
genetically determined biology and the
nutritional, cultural, and activity pat-
terns of contemporary Western popu-
lations, many of the so-called diseases
of civilization have emerged. In partic-
ular, agriculture and food-processing
p ro c e d u r es introduced during the
Neolithic Period and during the
Industrial Period fundamentally altere d
crucial nutritional characteristics of
the diets of our ancestors: in addition
to changes in the glycemic load, fatty
acid composition, macronutrient com-
position, micronutrient density, sodi-
um-potassium ratio, and fibre content,
considerable changes have taken place
in the acid-base homeostasis. Comparison
of the estimated net endogenous acid
production (NEAP) from 159 retro-
spective ancestral preagricultural diets
with contemporary diets clearly demon-
strates that 87% were net base-pro-
ducing with a mean NEAP of –88 ± 82
meq/day [33].
The average contemporary American
diet provides an acid surplus of 48
meq/day and is characterized by an
imbalance of nutrient precursors of
hydrogen and bicarbonate ions there-
by
inducing a lifelong, low-grade
pathogenically significant systemic
metabolic acidosis. The historical shift
from negative to positive NEAP was
a c c o u n t ed for by the displacement of
highly alkalising plant foods in the
ancestral diet by cereal grains and
energy-dense, nutrient-poor foods in
the contemporary diet neither of
which are net base-pro d u c i n g .
Therefore the evolutionary collision of
our ancient genome with the nutrition-
al qualities of recently intro d u c e d
foods may underlie many of the chro n i c
diseases of Western civilization [34].
Further research fields
related to acid-base
homeostasis
In sportsmen and sportswomen, fre-
quent lactate acidosis increases the
susceptibility to physical injury. In con-
trast, it is suggested that an adequate
base supply may have a beneficial
impact on performance by delaying
the onset of lactate acidosis but also by
avoiding physical impairment. Muscle
activity during sports performance is
in fact known to be associated with an
increase in both intra- and extracellu-
lar proton concentration. It is known
that alkaline sodium citrate ingestion
could reduce plasma proton concen-
tration and improve physical perfor-
mance [35, 36, 37].
Extracellular pH affects mineral
cation flux through cell membranes as
well. It seems that there is a strong
correlation between interstitial proton
concentration and the potassium
release from muscle cells during exer-
cise since potassium efflux is regulated
by voltage-dependent K channels and
pH-dependent K
ATP
channels. Potas-
sium efflux and accumulation in the
264
Schweiz. Zschr.
G
anzheits
M
edizin Jg.18, Heft 5, September 2006
Übersichtsarbeiten
Review Articles
Fig. 15. Percent change of disease activity score DAS-28 (left) and percent change of VAS pain index (right) of rheumatoid arthritis patients
(*p<0.05, **p<0.01). Modified from [32].
interstitium is not only important for
muscle function but also for the develop-
ment of fatigue resulting from exer-
cise. Microdialysis measurements have
recently demonstrated that sodium
citrate ingestion (300 mg/kg body
weight) reduces the exercise-induced
interstitial acidosis in human skeletal
muscle (Fig. 16) [38].
It was also shown by the latter
authors that this reduction of H
+
ion
concentration was associated with a
reduced interstitial accumulation of
potassium during muscle activity.
These results accordingly suggest a
delayed onset of muscle fatigue and
sustained muscle perf o r mance by
alkaline sodium citrate ingestion prior
to exercise in sports.
Of considerable interest was the
finding, in a study on 42 boys [39], of a
significant positive correlation between
the pH in the brain and the intelligence
quotient (IQ), i.e. the lower the actual
acid concentration in the brain, the
higher the IQ.
Conditions representing physiologi-
cal acidosis in vitro induced the aggre-
gation of human Ab amyloid proteins
( A b ) [40]. Metal ions such as copper,
zinc and iron are enriched in the amy-
loid plaques in Alzheimer's disease
and unlike other biometals tested at
maximal biological concentrations,
marked copper-induced aggregation of
Ab emerged as the pH of the sur-
rounding solution was lowered from
7.4 to 6.8. The reaction was completely
re v e r s i b l e with eit
her chelation or
alkalinization. Since a mildly acidic
environment together with increased
copper and zinc concentrations are
common features of inflammation, it is
suggested that Ab aggregation by
these factors may be a response to
local injury and that metabolic acido-
sis may also play a role in the develop-
ment of Alzheimers disease.
The acid-base homeostasis depen-
dent modulation of cortisol output may
influence the risk of insulin resistance
syndrome. This hypothesis appears to
be consistent with previous epidemio-
logical reports correlating high potas-
sium consumption, or a high intake of
fruits and vegetables, with a reduced
risk for diabetes and coronary disease.
Metabolic acidosis is known to pro-
mote renal acid excretion by the
induction of ammonia-generating glut-
aminase and other enzymes in the
renal tubules (see earlier: Compensation
mechanisms of latent acidosis). This
process is also strongly correlated with
i n c reased cortisol and aldostero n e
p r oduction. Since cortisol promotes the
development of visceral obesity, and
has a direct negative impact on insulin
function throughout the body, even a
modest sustained up-regulation of cor-
tisol production may have the potential
to increase the risk of insulin resis-
tance syndrome and type 2 diabetes
[41]. Future prospective epidemiology
should assess whether the estimated
acid-base homeostasis of habitual
diets correlates with the risk of insulin
resistance syndrome and diabetes.
Conclusion
To what extent the diet can affect the
acid–base homeostasis has been the
subject of controversy for many years.
Acute acidosis or alkalosis cannot be
produced by the consumption of cer-
tain foods. Howeve
r, the pathobio-
chemical effects of latent acidosis on
impaired renal function, diabetes mel-
litus, hyperuricemia, or gout are
undisputed. Based on new scientific
findings, causal evidence has also now
been furnished for the positive effects
of a well-balanced acid-base equilibri-
um empirically established in natur-
opathy. Although diet-induced latent
acidosis does not produce major
changes in the blood pH because of the
compensation mechanisms of the kid-
ney, this compensation inevitably leads
to the consumption of endogenous
buffer reserves and, therefore, pre-
dominantly to a loss of bone substance
if the increased acidification caused by
a surplus of animal protein and a
shortage of alkaline substances in the
diet exists for a long period of time. A
disturbance of the muscle pro t e i n
metabolism as well as the structure
and function of cartilage are other
negative consequences of the endoge-
nous compensation, which can also
aggravate degenerative diseases such
as arthrosis or rheumatism.
Our Stone Age ancestors preferred
a more or less mixed diet which in
spite of containing a high proportion of
animal protein was also characterized
by a surplus of base-forming sub-
stances. In contrast, the diet in today’s
Western industrial nations is charac-
265
Schweiz. Zschr.
G
anzheits
M
edizin Jg.18, Heft 5, September 2006
Fig. 16. Mean (± SEM) interstitial proton concentration during ingestion, exercise period
(solid line: citrate ingestion; dotted line: placebo) and recovery from exercise (n=7). *Sig-
nificant difference between citrate ingestion (CIT) and placebo (PLA). Modified from [38].
0.0 0.5 1.0 1.5 2.0 0 5 10 15 20 25
Übersichtsarbeiten Review Articles
terized by a large quantity of acid-
forming nutrients, above all due to the
surplus of animal protein. On the other
hand, a high proportion of fresh fruit
and vegetables in the diet contributes
to the formation of the surplus of bases
in the body.
References
1. Frassetto L, Todd, KM, Morris RC, Sebastian
A: Estimation of net endogenous non-carbon-
ic acid production in humans from diet potas-
sium and protein content. Am J Clin Nutr
1998;68:576–583.
2. Frassetto L, Morris RC, Sebastian A: Effect of
age on blood acid-base composition in adult
humans: role of age-related renal functional
decline. Am J Physiol 1996;271:F1114–
F1122.
3. Frassetto L, Sebastian A: Age and systemic
acid-base equilibrium: analysis of published
data. J Gerontol 1996;51A:B91–B99.
4. Alpern RJ, Sakhaee K: The clinical spectrum
of chronic metabolic acidosis. Homeostatic
mechanisms produce significant morbidity.
Am J Kidney Disease 1997;29:291–302.
5. Frassetto L, Morris RC, Sebastian A: Potassi-
um bicarbonate reduces urinary nitro g e n
excretion in postmenopausal women. J Clin
Endocrin Metab 1997;82:254–259.
6. Lemann, J Jr, Litzow JR, Lennon EJ: The
effects of chronic acid loads in normal man:
Further evidence for the participation of bone
mineral in the defense against chronic meta-
bolic acidosis. J Clin Invest 1966;45:1608–
1614.
7. Wachman A, Bernstein DS: Diet and Osteo-
porosis. Lancet 1968;958–959.
8. Marsh AG, Sanchez, TV, Michelsen O, Chaf-
fee FL, Fagal, SM: Vegetarian lifestyle and
bone mineral density. Am J Clin Nutr 1988;
48:837–841.
9. Ball D, Maughan RJ: Blood and urine acid-
base status of premenopausal omnivorous
and vegetarian women. Br J Nutr 1997;
78:683–693.
10. New SA, Bolton-Smith C, Grubb DA, Reid
DM: Nutritional influences on bone mineral
density: A cross-sectional study in pre-
menopausal women. Am J Clin Nutr 1997;
65:1831–1839.
11. Tucker KL, Hannan MT, Chen H, Cupples LA,
Wilson PW, Kiel DP: Potassium, magnesium,
and fruit and vegetable intakes are associated
with greater bone mineral density in elderly
men and women. Am J Clin Nutr 1999;69:
727–736.
12. New SA, Macdonald HM, Campbell MK, Mar-
tin JC, Garton MJ, Robins SP, Reid DM:
Lower estimates of net endogenous non-car-
bonic acid production are positively associat-
ed with indexes of bone health in pre-
menopausal and perimenopausal women.
Am J Clin Nutr 2004;79:131–138.
13. Macdonald HM, New SA, Golden MH, Camp-
bell MK, Reid DM: Nutritional associations
with bone loss during the menopausal transi-
tion: evidence of a beneficial effect of calci-
um, alcohol, and fruit and vegetable nutrients
and of a detrimental effect of fatty acids. Am
J Clin Nutr 2004;79:155–165.
14. Macdonald HM, New SA, Fraser WD, Camp-
bell MK, Reid DM: Low dietary potassium
intakes and high dietary estimates of net
endogenous acid production are associated
with low bone mineral density in pre-
menopausal women and increased markers
of bone resorption in postmenopausal
women. Am J Clin Nutr 2005;81:923–933.
15. Weiss RE, Gorn A, Dux S, Nimni ME: Influ-
ence of high protein diets in cartilage and
bone formation in rats. J Nutr 1981;111:
804–816.
16. Lutz J: Calcium balance and acid-base status
of women as affected by increased protein
intake and by sodium bicarbonate ingestion.
Am J Clin Nutr 1984;39:281–288.
17. Sebastian A, Harris ST, Ottaway JH, Todd
KM, Morris RC Jr: Improved mineral balance
and skeletal metabolism in postmenopausal
women treated with potassium bicarbonate.
N Engl J Med 1994;330:1776–1781.
18. Giannini S, Nobile M, Sartori L, Dalle Car-
bonare L, Ciuffreda M, Corro P, D´Angelo A,
Calo L, Crepaldi G: Acute effects of moderate
dietary protein restriction in patients with
idiopathic hypercalciuria and calcium
nephrolithiasis. Am J Clin Nutr 1999;69:267–
271.
19. Witasek A, Traweger C, Gritsch P, Kogelnig R,
Trötscher G: Einflüsse von basischen Miner-
alsalzen auf den menschlichen Organismus
unter standardisierten Ernährungsbedingun-
gen. Erfahrungsheilkunde 1996;45:477–488.
20. Mar
angella M, Di Stefano M, Casalis S,
Berutti S, D'Amelio P, Isaia GC: Effects of
potassium citrate supplementation on bone
metabolism. Calcif Tissue Int 2004;74:330–
335.
21. Maurer M, Riesen W, Muser J, Hulter HN,
Krapf R: Neutralization of We s t e rn diet
inhibits bone resorption independently of K
intake and reduces cortisol secretion in
humans. Am J Physiol Renal Physiol 2003;
284:F32–F40.
22. Grinspoon SK, Baum HBA, Kim V, Coggins C,
Klibanski A: Decreased bone formation and
increased mineral dissolution during acute
fasting in young women. J Clin Endocrin
Metab 1995;80:3628–3633.
23. Reddy ST, Wang CY, Sakhaee K, Brinkley L,
Pak CY: Effect of low-carbohydrate high-pro-
tein diets on acid-base balance, stone-form-
ing propensity, and calcium metabolism. Am
J Kidney Dis 2002;40:265–274.
24. Sellmeyer DE, Stone KL, Sebastian A, Cum-
mings SR: A high ratio of dietary animal to
vegetable protein increases the rate of bone
loss and the risk of fracture in post-
menopausal women. Am J Clin Nutr 2001;
73:118–122.
25. Frassetto LA, Todd KM, Morris RC Jr., Sebas-
tian A: Worldwide incidence of hip fracture in
elderly women: relation to comsumption of
animal and vegetable foods. J Gerontol 2000;
55A:M585–M592.
26. Alexy U, Remer T, Manz F, Neu CM, Schoe-
nau E: Long-term protein intake and dietary
potential renal acid load are associated with
bone modeling and remodeling at the proxi-
mal radius in healthy children. Am J Clin Nutr
2005;82:1107–1114.
27. Bushinsky DA, Frick KK: The effects of acid
on bone. Curr Opin Nephrol Hypertens 2000;
9:369–379.
28. Frick KK, Bushinsky DA: Metabolic acidosis
stimulates RANKL RNA expression in bone
through a cyclo-oxygenase-dependent m e c h-
anism. J Bone Miner Res 2003;18:1317–1325.
29. Garret RH, Grisham CM: Biochemistry. Saun-
ders College Publishi
ng, Orlando, Florida
1995;345–350.
30. Farr M, Garvey K, Bold AM, Kendall MJ,
Bacon PA: Significance of the hydrogen ion
concentration in synovial fluid in rheumatoid
arthritis. Clin Exp Rheumatol 1985;3:99–104.
31. Vormann J, Worlitschek M, Goedecke T, Sil-
ver B: Supplementation with alkaline miner-
als reduces symptoms in patients with chron-
ic low back pain. J Trace Elem Med Biol 2001;
15:179–183.
32. Cseuz RM, Bender T, Vormann J: Alkaline
mineral supplementation for patients with
rheumatoid arthritis. Rheumatology 2005;44
(Supplement 1):i79.
33. Sebastian A, Frassetto LA, Sellmeyer DE,
Merriam RL, Morris RC Jr.: Estimation of the
net acid load of the diet of ancestral preagri-
cultural Homo sapiens and their hominid
ancestors. Am J Clin Nutr. 2002;76:1308–
1316.
34. Cordain L, Eaton SB, Sebastian A, Mann N,
Lindeberg S, Watkins BA, O'Keefe JH, Brand-
Miller J: Origins and evolution of the Western
diet: health implications for the 21st century.
Am J Clin Nutr 2005;81:341–354.
35. Greenleaf JE, Looft-Wilson R, Wisherd JL,
McKenzie MA, Jensen CD, Whittam JH: Pre-
exercise hypervolemia and cycle ergometer
endurance in men. Biol Sport 1997;14:103–
114.
36. Oopik V, Saaremets I, Medijainen L, Karelson
K, Janson T, Timpmann S: Effects of sodium
citrate ingestion before exercise on
endurance performance in well trained col-
lege runners. Br J Sports Med 2003;37:485–
489.
37. Shave R, Whyte G, Siemann A, Doggart L:
The effects of sodium citrate ingestion on
3,000-meter time-trial perf o rmance. J Stre n g t h
Cond Res 2001;15:230–234.
38. Street D, Nielsen JJ, Bangsbo J, Juel C:
Metabolic alkalosis reduces exercise-induced
acidosis and potassium accumulation in
human skeletal muscle interstitium. J Physiol
2005;566:481–489.
39. Rae C, Scott RB, Thompson CH, Kemp GJ,
Dumughn I, Styles P, Tracey I, Radda G.: Is
pH a biochmical market of IQ? Proc. R. Soc.
Lond. B 1996;263:1061–1064.
40. Atwood CS, Moir RD, Huang X, Scarpa RC,
Bacarra NM, Romano DM, Hartshorn MA,
Tanzi RE, Bush AI: Dramatic aggregation of
Alzheimer abeta by Cu(II) is induced by con-
ditions representing physiological acidosis. J
Biol Chem 1998;273:12817–12826.
41. McCarty MF: Acid-base balance may influ-
ence risk for insulin resistance syndrome by
modulating cortisol output. Med Hypotheses
2005;64:380–384.
Address for correspondence:
Prof. Dr. rer. nat. Jürgen Vormann
Institut für Prävention und Ernährung
Adalperostrasse 37, DE-85737 Ismaning
vormann@ipev.de
266
Schweiz. Zschr.
G
anzheits
M
edizin Jg.18, Heft 5, September 2006
Übersichtsarbeiten
Review Articles
Article
Objective The objective of this study was to study how acid accumulation (lower plasma bicarbonate and higher anion gap [AG] and corrected anion gap [CAG]) correlates with metabolic parameters, food intake, and 24‐h energy expenditure (EE). Methods Acid accumulation was measured in 286 healthy adults with estimated glomerular filtration rate > 60 mL/min/1.73 m ² . Measurements included body composition by dual‐energy x‐ray absorptiometry scan, ad libitum energy intake by a vending machine paradigm over 3 days, and 24‐h EE in a whole‐room indirect calorimeter. Results Lower bicarbonate, higher AG, and higher CAG were correlated with higher waist and thigh circumferences, body fat (percentage), fat mass, triglycerides, and lower high‐density lipoprotein cholesterol. Acid accumulation markers were correlated with higher total energy (CAG partial r = 0.17; p = 0.02), fat (CAG partial r = 0.17; p = 0.02), protein intake (CAG partial r = 0.20; p = 0.006), and 24‐h EE (CAG partial r = 0.24; p = 0.0007). A mediation analysis of CAG and total energy intake found that 24‐h EE was a partial mediator (40%), but the association remained significant (β = 0.15; p < 0.0001). Conclusions In healthy individuals, acid accumulation was associated with an unfavorable metabolic phenotype; higher 24‐h EE; and increased total energy, fat, and protein intake. Acid accumulation markers, as putative markers of higher dietary acid load (e.g., from protein), may affect energy balance physiology promoting weight gain.
Article
Full-text available
Foods contain substances impacting the acid-base balance. The Western diet is often viewed as being overly acid due to its high-level of animal-based protein and low-level of vegetable intake. Meanwhile, with ageing the ability to excrete acid compounds is reduced as kidney function declines and so there is a risk of acid retention and subsequent interstitial acidosis. Two systems used for calculating the Dietary Acid Load (DAL): the potential acid load of foods (PRAL) and the net endogenous acid production (NEAP). This report outlines weaknesses in these formulas and concludes that dietitians and nutritionists lack the necessary tools to research the acid-base hypothesis. Additionally, the report emphasizes the importance of food selection in the ageing population. Background: Foods contain substances impacting the acid-base balance. The Western diet is often viewed as being overly acid due to its high-level of animal-based protein and low-level of vegetable intake. There are concerns that the disproportionate acid intake promotes low-grade metabolic acidosis in the interstitial fluid, interstitial acidosis, and may lead to chronic disease. Two formulas are used for calculating the DAL: the PRAL and the NEAP. Both PRAL and NEAP are based on levels of protein and minerals. Aim: To identify additional food constituents that impact DAL. Methods: Review of the literature concerning the acid-forming and alkaline-forming constituents of foods. Results: Five additional food constituents were identified as potentially having a meaningful impact on DAL. The oxidation of taurine and the metabolism of fructose and purines increase acidity, whereas organic acids increase alkalinity. Additionally, polyphenols affect the microbiota which break down uric acid excreted in the intestinal tract. Conclusions: Neither PRAL nor NEAP provides complete assessments of the impact of foods on DAL. These formulas could be improved by the inclusion of dietary amino acids rather than protein, taurine, purines, fructose, organic acids and polyphenols. Currently, dietitians and nutritionists lack the necessary tools both to research the acid-base hypothesis and recommend managed diets. Managed diets are of particular importance for the elderly because of their reduced kidney function which increases the risk of acid retention and subsequent interstitial acidosis.
Article
With the advantages of miniaturization, simple device structure, and fast response, the organic electrochemical transistor (OECT) has become an emerging platform for developing wearable pH sensors for real-time human health...
Article
Full-text available
Metabolic acidosis and metabolic bone disease are frequent complications in patients on parenteral nutrition (PN). A common contributor to these complications could be a daily high renal acid load. This study aims to find a method for predicting the potential total acid load (PTAL) and the pH of the compounded parenteral nutrition mixtures. The pH and titratable acidity (TA) of fifty compounded mixtures were measured. The potential metabolic acid load (PMAL) was calculated by considering the amount of nutrients that are acid producers and consumers. The PTAL of the TPN mixtures was calculated by adding TA to PMAL. Multiple linear regression analyses were used to develop a predictive model for the TA and pH of the compounded mixtures. The predicted TA and pH values of the analyzed mixtures agreed with those measured (Passing-Bablok analysis). The PTAL was >50 mmol/day for 82% of the mixtures, >75 mmol/day for 40% of the mixtures, and >100 mmol/day for 22% of the mixtures. The prediction of the renal acid load in patients on long-term PN could allow more appropriate acid-base balancing. Moreover, predicting the pH of such mixtures could be useful to pharmacists to assess the stability and compatibility of the components in the compounded mixtures.
Article
Es gibt eine Vielzahl vegetarischer Ernährungsformen, zwischen denen bei der Bewertung ihrer Tauglichkeit als Naturheilverfahren gewissenhaft unterschieden werden muss. Eine Fülle wissenschaftlicher Studien zeigt, dass der Lakto-Ovo-Vegetarismus als Dauerkostform sowie für die Prävention und Therapie verschiedener Krankheiten geeignet ist. Im vorliegenden Kapitel wird dargestellt, wie die verschiedenen Varianten vegetarischer Ernährungsformen in der Praxis erfolgreich durchgeführt werden können.
Article
Full-text available
The nutritional acid load hypothesis of osteoporosis is reviewed from its historical origin to most recent studies with particular attention to the essential but overlooked role of the kidney in acid-base homeostasis. This hypothesis posits that foods associated with an increased urinary acid excretion are deleterious for the skeleton, leading to osteoporosis and enhanced fragility fracture risk. Conversely, foods generating neutral or alkaline urine would favour bone growth and Ca balance, prevent bone loss and reduce osteoporotic fracture risk. This theory currently influences nutrition research, dietary recommendations and the marketing of alkaline salt products or medications meant to optimise bone health and prevent osteoporosis. It stemmed from classic investigations in patients suffering from chronic kidney diseases (CKD) conducted in the 1960s. Accordingly, in CKD, bone mineral mobilisation would serve as a buffer system to acid accumulation. This interpretation was later questioned on both theoretical and experimental grounds. Notwithstanding this questionable role of bone mineral in systemic acid-base equilibrium, not only in CKD but even more in the absence of renal impairment, it is postulated that, in healthy individuals, foods, particularly those containing animal protein, would induce 'latent' acidosis and result, in the long run, in osteoporosis. Thus, a questionable interpretation of data from patients with CKD and the subsequent extrapolation to healthy subjects converted a hypothesis into nutritional recommendations for the prevention of osteoporosis. In a historical perspective, the present review dissects out speculation from experimental facts and emphasises the essential role of the renal tubule in systemic acid-base and Ca homeostasis.
Article
Full-text available
Abstract Background Acid–base balance refers to the equilibrium between acids and bases in the human body. Nutrition may affect acid–base balance and further physical performance. With the help of PRAL (potential renal acid load), a low-protein vegetarian diet (LPVD) was designed to enhance the production of bases in body. The aim of this study was to investigate if LPVD has an effect on blood acid–base status and performance during submaximal and maximal aerobic cycling. Methods Nine healthy, recreationally active men (age 23.5 ± 3.4 yr) participated in the study and were randomly divided into two groups in a cross-over study design. Group 1 followed LPVD for 4 days and group 2 ate normally (ND) before performing a cycle ergometer test. The test included three 10-min stages at 40, 60 and 80% of VO2max. The fourth stage was performed at 100% of VO2max until exhaustion. After 10–16 days, the groups started a second 4-day diet, and at the end performed the similar ergometer test. Venous blood samples were collected at the beginning and at the end of both diet periods and after every stage cycled. Results Diet caused no significant difference in venous blood pH, strong ion difference (SID), total concentration of weak acids (Atot), partial pressure of CO2 (pCO2) or HCO3- at rest or during cycling between LPVD and ND. In the LPVD group, at rest SID significantly increased over the diet period (38.6 ± 1.8 vs. 39.8 ± 0.9, p=0.009). Diet had no significant effect on exercise time to exhaustion, but VO2 was significantly higher at 40, 60 and 80% of VO2max after LPVD compared to ND (2.03 ± 0.25 vs. 1.82 ± 0.21 l/min, p=0.035; 2.86 ± 0.36 vs. 2.52 ± 0.33 l/min, p
Article
Full-text available
The menopausal transition is characterized by rapid bone loss. Few data exist on the role of nutrition. The objective of the study was to ascertain which dietary factors influence perimenopausal skeletal loss. A longitudinal study was conducted of 891 women aged 45-55 y at baseline and 50-59 y at follow-up 5-7 y later. Bone mineral density (BMD) was measured by using dual-energy X-ray absorptiometry at the lumbar spine and femoral neck (FN). Nutrient intakes were assessed after the baseline visit and 5 y later, by using the same food-frequency questionnaire. After adjustment for energy intake and other confounders, higher intakes of calcium were correlated with change in FN BMD (ie, reduced loss) (r = 0.073, P < 0.05), and the intake of modest amounts of alcohol was associated with less lumbar spine bone loss (P < 0.01 for quartile of alcohol intake). Greater FN BMD loss was associated with increased intake of polyunsaturated fatty acids (r = -0.110, P < 0.01), monounsaturated fatty acids (r = -0.069, P < 0.05), retinol (r = -0.067; P < 0.05), and vitamin E (r = -0.110; P < 0.01). The latter 2 nutrients were highly correlated with polyunsaturated fatty acids. For premenopausal women, calcium and nutrients found in fruit and vegetables (vitamin C, magnesium, and potassium) were associated with FN BMD, and calcium, vitamin C, and magnesium were associated with change in FN BMD. Although menopausal status and hormone replacement therapy use dominate women's bone health, diet may influence early postmenopausal bone loss. Fruit and vegetable intake may protect against premenopausal bone loss.
Article
Full-text available
The aim of this pilot study was to investigate the efficacy of an alkaline mineral supplement as a means of suppressing disease activity in rheumatoid arthritis (RA) patients, and to check whether any change occurs in the circulating beta-endorphin concentration. Thirty-seven patients with moderately active RA of at least two years duration, who were receiving stable pharmacological treatment, participated in a 12-week study. All patients were randomly allocated to a supplemented group (30g of an alkaline mineral supplement daily) or to an unsupplemented group. Their usual diet and medication was maintained. Disease activity, pain, and health-associated status were recorded (DAS 28-Disease Activity Score 28, VAS-visual analogue scale for pain, HAQ-Health Assessment Questionnaire). Plasma immunoreactive en-dorphin (ir-EP) was measured in the study groups and also in healthy subjects. DAS 28 and VAS decreased in the supplemented group, whereas there was no change in these parameters during the trial in the control group. The functions (HAQ) of the supplemented patients improved. The ir-EP levels increased in both groups but to a higher degree in the supplemented group. During the trial, medication (NSAIDs and steroids) could be reduced in the supplemented group only. Conclusion: This study suggests that an alkaline supplement may improve function and pain in rheumatoid arthritis and may represent an easy and safe addition to the usual treatment of RA patients.
Article
Full-text available
The amount and type of dietary protein affect bone mineral loss after the menopause. This observation was substantiated in 10 y of studies by direct photon absorptiometry, four results of which follow. 1) Studies of 1600 women in southwestern Michigan revealed that those who had followed the lactoovovegetarian diet for at least 20 y had only 18% less bone mineral by age 80 whereas closely paired omnivores had 35% less bone mineral. 2) A study of self-selected weighed food intake showed no statistical difference in nutrient intakes but a difference in Ca:P ratio and acid-base formation of diet, each significant to p less than 0.001. 3) When sulfur intake of a fixed diet was increased, the titratable acidity of the urine increased proportionately. 4) Bone mineral densities of 304 older women from the continental United States closely paralleled those from earlier Michigan studies.
Article
Full-text available
In normal subjects, a low level of metabolic acidosis and positive acid balance (the production of more acid than is excreted) are typically present and correlate in degree with the amount of endogenous acid produced by the metabolism of foods in ordinary diets abundant in protein. Over a lifetime, the counteraction of retained endogenous acid by base mobilized from the skeleton may contribute to the decrease in bone mass that occurs normally with aging. To test that possibility, we administered potassium bicarbonate to 18 postmenopausal women who were given a constant diet (652 mg [16 mmol] of calcium and 96 g of protein per 60 kg of body weight). The potassium bicarbonate was given orally for 18 days in doses (60 to 120 mmol per day) that nearly completely neutralized the endogenous acid. During the administration of potassium bicarbonate, the calcium and phosphorus balance became less negative or more positive--that is, less was excreted in comparison with the amount ingested (mean [+/- SD] change in calcium balance, +56 +/- 76 mg [1.4 +/- 1.9 mmol] per day per 60 kg; P = 0.009; change in phosphorus balance, +47 +/- 64 mg [1.5 +/- 2.1 mmol] per day per 60 kg; P = 0.007) because of reductions in urinary calcium and phosphorus excretion. The changes in calcium and phosphorus balance were positively correlated (P < 0.001). Serum osteocalcin concentrations increased from 5.5 +/- 2.8 to 6.1 +/- 2.8 ng per milliliter (P < 0.001), and urinary hydroxyproline excretion decreased from 28.9 +/- 12.3 to 26.7 +/- 10.8 mg per day (220 +/- 94 to 204 +/- 82 mumol per day; P = 0.05). Net renal acid excretion decreased from 70.9 +/- 10.1 to 12.8 +/- 21.8 mmol per day, indicating nearly complete neutralization of endogenous acid. In postmenopausal women, the oral administration of potassium bicarbonate at a dose sufficient to neutralize endogenous acid improves calcium and phosphorus balance, reduces bone resorption, and increases the rate of bone formation.
Article
Background: Different sources of dietary protein may have different effects on bone metabolism. Animal foods provide predominantly acid precursors, whereas protein in vegetable foods is accompanied by base precursors not found in animal foods. Imbalance between dietary acid and base precursors leads to a chronic net dietary acid load that may have adverse consequences on bone. Objective: We wanted to test the hypothesis that a high dietary ratio of animal to vegetable foods, quantified by protein content, increases bone loss and the risk of fracture. Design: This was a prospective cohort study with a mean (±SD) of 7.0 ± 1.5 y of follow-up of 1035 community-dwelling white women aged >65 y. Protein intake was measured by using a food-frequency questionnaire and bone mineral density was measured by dual-energy X-ray absorptiometry. Results: Bone mineral density was not significantly associated with the ratio of animal to vegetable protein intake. Women with a high ratio had a higher rate of bone loss at the femoral neck than did those with a low ratio (P = 0.02) and a greater risk of hip fracture (relative risk = 3.7, P = 0.04). These associations were unaffected by adjustment for age, weight, estrogen use, tobacco use, exercise, total calcium intake, and total protein intake. Conclusions: Elderly women with a high dietary ratio of animal to vegetable protein intake have more rapid femoral neck bone loss and a greater risk of hip fracture than do those with a low ratio. This suggests that an increase in vegetable protein intake and a decrease in animal protein intake may decrease bone loss and the risk of hip fracture. This possibility should be confirmed in other prospective studies and tested in a randomized trial.
Article
Phylogenetic and experimental data on the inorganic content of bone have led to a postulate which delineates the functioning of bone mineral as a buffer base. Bone dissolution is considered as a possible mechanism to buffer the fixed acid load imposed by the ingestion of an "acid ash" diet in man.
Article
The hydrogen ion (H+) concentration and pCO2 were measured in the synovial fluid (SF) from the knee joints of 130 patients with arthritis by an acid-base analyser (ABL2 Acid-Base Laboratory), using a simple technique which prevented contact with air. H+ concentration was significantly higher in SF from 60 RA patients (mean 64.4 n mol/l; range 38-142 n mol/l) compared with patients with OA (mean 44 n mol/l; range 29-56 n mol/l), and 40 with other arthritides (mean 52 n mol/l). The H+ concentration in the SF showed a significant association with other variables of local inflammation-platelet, total leucocyte and polymorph counts, 5-nucleotidase, acid phosphatase and IgA levels in the SF and the clinical knee score, but not with the volume of the effusion. A similar relationship between these variables of inflammatory activity and SF pCO2 was also established. A higher SF H+ concentration was also found in systemically active disease, but no difference in SF pH between seropositive and seronegative patients. Whilst the pH of SF approximated to that of the blood in OA, it was significantly lower in the SF in RA. SF pH is a useful marker of local inflammatory activity, and its measurement is simple, reliable and rapid. It is relevant because changes in pH influence many of the processes involved in inflammation and the pH difference between SF and blood influences the transfer of drugs into the joint.
Article
Six women, aged 38 to 62 yr, participated in a 40-day metabolic study to investigate the effect of level of protein intake and of sodium bicarbonate ingestion on urinary calcium, net calcium balance, net renal acid excretion, and arterialized venous blood pH and bicarbonate ion concentration. The diet contained 44 g protein during the first 16 days and 102 g during the remaining 24 days. During the last 10 days of the study, 5.85 g of sodium bicarbonate was ingested concomitantly with the higher protein intake. Calcium, phosphorus, and magnesium intakes were held constant at 500, 900, and 300 mg, respectively. The increase in protein intake significantly increased urinary calcium and net renal acid excretion and the mean net calcium balance became negative. The ingestion of sodium bicarbonate alkalinized the urine and reversed the increase in urinary calcium associated with the higher protein intake; the mean net calcium balance became positive. The arterialized venous blood pH and bicarbonate ion concentrations were not significantly affected by dietary treatments. The results suggest that the ingestion of a small amount of sodium bicarbonate may be an effective way to increase calcium retention in women with protein-induced hypercalciuria.
Article
The influence of diets containing combinations of high protein and low calcium on discrete stages of bone formation was investigated in 28-day-old rats. A bone matrix-induced bone forming system was utilized to determine the stages of endochondral ossification that were being affected. Mesenchymal cell proliferation as assessed by [3H]-thymidine incorporation and ornithine decarboxylase activity were unchanged in animals fed a high protein (80% casein)/normal calcium (0.61% Ca; 0.40% P) diet. However, osteogenesis was reduced by 78% in the rats fed high protein/normal calcium as measured by 45Ca incorporation. Alkaline and acid phosphatase activities in bone were increased 2.5 and 2.3 times, respectively, reflecting increased matrix turnover induced by the high protein availability. Bone that did form was not remodeled nor was there evidence of marrow formation. The animals were normocalcemic and normophosphatemic and showed no evidence of acidosis. A combination diet of high protein and low calcium resulted in a 62% reduction of cell proliferation and chondrogenesis and a 98% inhibition of bone formation. High dietary protein-induced osteoporosis in animals is due to a failure of osteogenesis of the stage of ossification possibly a result of restricted availability of calcium at the site of mineralization.